Bombay High Court
NMW/179/2003 of CITY SPACE and ORS Vs THE STATE OF MAH. and ORS. on 5 November 2003
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY ORDINARY ORIGINAL
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYORDINARY ORIGINAL CIVIL JURISDICTION
WRIT PETITION NO. 1152 OF 2002
Ngo Alliance For Governance AndRenewal(nagar))
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.
....PETITIONER
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) LODGING NO. 290 OF 2014In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And 2 Ors.....PETITIONER
V/SState Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors.and A-1,....RESPONDENTWelfare Society(regd.) And 2 Ors(applicants/org.intervener WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 6465 OF 2022
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Shivaji Shrirang Taware....PETITIONER
V/S
City Space And 5 Others
....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 7 OF 2003
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
....PETITIONER
V/S
Nityanand Co-op.hsg. Soc.....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 8 OF 2003
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/SLokmanya Tilak Co-op.hsg. Socy.....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 30 OF 2003InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SFriends Of Society....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 253 OF 2003InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Mah. And Ors. And Vasuki Nagraj....RESPONDENTCo.op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 254 OF 2003
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Mah. And Ors. And Milan Subway....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 261 OF 2003
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Basera....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 326 OF 2003
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Mah. And Ors. And S. K. S. Enterprises....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 328 OF 2003
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space And Ors.
V/S
....PETITIONER
State Maharashtra And Ors. Bhagwan Shriram....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 337 OF 2003
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citiy Space And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Shivneri....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 338 OF 2003
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Mah. And Ors. And Borivali Eksar....RESPONDENTDongri Samata Co-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 5 OF 2005
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space An Association Of Persons And Ors.....PETITIONERV/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Dharmendra....RESPONDENTV. Kanade WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 29 OF 2005
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 30 OF 2005InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Pranchashil....RESPONDENTRahivashi Seva Sangh WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 31 OF 2005InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Mah. And Ors. And Shree Kartik....RESPONDENTSwamy Seva Mandal WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 20 OF 2006
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space And Ors
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors Nuttan Nagar
....PETITIONER
Co-op Hsg. Soc.ltd
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 130 OF 2006
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
City Space And 2 Ors.
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And Sant....RESPONDENTGyaneshwar S.r.a. Co-op Housing Society(prop.)-(applicant WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 195 OF 2006In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
M/s. Citispace And 2 Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
The State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And....RESPONDENTVishnu D. Kalgude WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 82 OF 2008InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Alex ....RESPONDENTFernandes WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 107 OF 2008....RESPONDENT
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Os. And Bhagwan R.....RESPONDENTBanerji And Ors.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 60 OF 2009
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Devraj....RESPONDENTRatanchand Pagaria And Anr.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 31 OF 2010
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Ajitnagar....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg. Soc.(proposed)
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 227 OF 2010
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
V/S
....PETITIONER
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 143 OF 2011
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
The State Of Maharashtra
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 579 OF 2010InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
The State Of Maharashtra
....RESPONDENT
WITH
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.
....PETITIONER
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 3 OF 2012
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Hubtown....RESPONDENTLimited - Applicant WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 297 OF 2012In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Shivneri....RESPONDENTNavgruh Nirman Vitbhatti Sra.co-op.soc. AndAnr WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 54 OF 2014
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s.....RESPONDENTNimesh Global Syndicate And Ors.
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 34 OF 2014In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Vaishali Sra....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg, Soc. Ltd (pro) And Anr. (applicant)
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 56 OF 2014
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Mr. Shiva P.....RESPONDENTArakari WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 194 OF 2014
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And 2 Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And M/s. Lotus Logistics....RESPONDENTAnd Developers (applicant) 2 Ors.
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 218 OF 2014
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors And M/s.Maharashtra Housing And Area Dev.board (Applicant
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 219 OF 2014InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors And....RESPONDENTM/s.rushabh Real Estate Development P. Ltd.
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 170 OF 2013InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.and Slum....RESPONDENTRehabilitation Authority (applicant)
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 2716 OF 2020
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
New Look Constructions Private Limited....PETITIONER
V/SCiti Space And 5 Ors
....RESPONDENT
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 192 OF 2017
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space And 2 Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And Savitribai....RESPONDENTPhule Nagar Sta Co-op. Hsg.soc.ltd.(prop) AndAnr.
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 66 OF 2019
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Cityspace And 2 Ors....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors And Chandhok....RESPONDENTDevelopers (applicant)
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1771 OF 2022
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Naredco West Foundation
....PETITIONER
V/S
Citispace And 6 Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 28459 OF 2021
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Pandurang D. Chalke And Anr
....PETITIONER
V/S
....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 30716 OF 2021
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Slum Redevelopers Association And 3....PETITIONEROrs(applicants)
V/S
Citispace And 6 Ors.
....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 28343 OF 2021InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Cosmic Developers (applicant/intervener)....PETITIONER
V/S
Citispace And 6 Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION LODGING NO. 19651 OF 2022
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Mundara Developers....PETITIONER
V/S
Ngo Alliance For Governance And Renewal And....RESPONDENT5 Other WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 88 OF 2014
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citi Space And Ors.
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Amity....RESPONDENTConstructions And Anr. (applicant)
WITH
INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 3043 OF 2022
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Ngo Alliance For Governance And....PETITIONERRenewal(nagar)) And 2 Ors.
V/S
WITH
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.
....PETITIONER
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 179 OF 2003
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
City Space And Ors....PETITIONER
V/SThe State Of Mah. And Ors.
....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 44 OF 2005In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Or. And Narayan....RESPONDENTBhima Tandel And Anr.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 281 OF 2005
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Cityspace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And V.p Nagar....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 282 OF 2005
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Bharatnagar....RESPONDENTCo-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 283 OF 2005
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Cityspace And Ors.
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Bhaiysaheb....RESPONDENTAmbdekar Nagar Co-op. Hsg. Soc.
WITH
CONTEMPT PETITION IN WRIT PETITION NO. 40 OF 2008
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
City Space And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SShri. Debashish Chakravarty And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER ORDER NO. 803 OF 2008
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And Anr.....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER ORDER NO. 1543 OF 2008
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 232 OF 2009
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors And Shivalik....RESPONDENTVentures Pvt Ltd WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 234 OF 2009
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 235 OF 2010InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/SState Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
The State Of Maharashtra
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 624 OF 2010
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s. Sai....RESPONDENTConstruction WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 200 OF 2011
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 294 OF 2011In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 296 OF 2011
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.
....PETITIONER
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 326 OF 2011In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
CHAMBER SUMMONS IN WRIT PETITION. NO. 223 OF 2011InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And Ors.....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 481 OF 2011
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s.
....PETITIONER
Aryaman Developers Pvt. Ltd.
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 608 OF 2011
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 159 OF 2012
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
City Space And 2 Anr.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And 2 And Mulund....RESPONDENTPanchsheetal Co. Op. Hsg. Soc. Ltd.- Applicant WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 227 OF 2012
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
M/s. Ratan Builders..applicant And Citispace....PETITIONERAnd Ors.
V/S
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 243 OF 2012
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002....RESPONDENT
Citispace And Ors.
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors.
....PETITIONER
....RESPONDENT
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 379 OF 2012
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.
....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And Jess....RESPONDENTConstruction Pvt. Ltd.
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 421 OF 2012InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Cityspace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s.....RESPONDENTDamodar Suruchi Developers WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 423 OF 2012
InWRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
Citispace And Ors.....PETITIONERV/SState Of Maharashtra And M/s. Mundara....RESPONDENTDevelopers (applicant)
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 3 OF 2013In WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
City Space And Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And Ors. And M/s.....RESPONDENTSuranjan Holding And Estate Dev. Pvt. Ltd.
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 193 OF 2013
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
M/s. D.v.builders And Developers,....PETITIONERApplicant/citispace And Ors.
V/S
WITH
NOTICE OF MOTION (WRIT PETITION) NO. 142 OF 2014
In
WRIT PETITION 1152 OF 2002
City Space And 2 Ors.....PETITIONER
V/S
State Of Maharashtra And 2 Ors. And Ratan....RESPONDENTBuilders (applicant)
Mr. Shiraj Rustomjee, Sr. Adv. with Ms. Gulnaar Mistry, Mr.Aakash Rebello, Mr. Prateek Pai, Mr. P Sasuti, Mr. ShallierJariwala i/b. Jariwala Asso. Petitioner in WP/1152/2002.Mr. Ranjeev Carvalho I/b. ABHLLP for the Applicant in IA28459/2021.
Mr. Hrushi Nargekar with Mr. Rohaan Pajnigar i/b. DSK Legal for the applicant in IAL/30716/2021.
Mr. Anand Oka Adv. For Applicant in CS/88/2014.
Mr. Mayur Khandeparkar, Mr. Vikramjit Garewal a/w Ms.
Risha Shetty, Mr. Rahul Deshpande i/b Wadia Gandhy and Co.
For Applicant in IA/1771/2022.
Mr. Prathmesh Seth i/b Joseph B Fernandes Adv. For applicant in NMW/66/2019.
Mr. Anosh Sequeira i/b P.V.Nichani Adv. For Applicant IAL/19651/2022.
Mr. Ram Apte Sr.Adv. Through VC a/w Ms. Oorja Dhond i/b Mr. S.K.Sonawane For Respondent No. 2 BMC.
Mr. A.Y.Sakhare Sr.Adv. With Mr. Abhay Patki, Addl.GP for State Respondent No.1.
Mr. Milind Sathe Sr.Adv. a/w Mr. Girish Utangale, Mr. SauravUtangale and Mr. Vedant Joshi i/b M/S Utangale and Co. Adv.For Respondent SRA.
CORAM : HON'BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE &HON'BLE JUSTICE SHRI ARIF S. DOCTOR,JJ
DATE :
23rd April, 2024
P.C. :
S. O. to 26/04/2024 ( at 2.30 pm).
( ASSOCIATE )