AS/6/1952 of KRISHNA KAMMATHI RAMACHANDRA KAMMATHI Vs NARASIMBA PAI RAMA PAI on 25 November 1954

------; gT-¥

I

DI 'I'.H.2 HIGH C01J1T:CRAVO!-CUCL,

Present:-

.

.·. x

The Hon' ble ~bh.ri K.T. Kosn.i,

Chief.,Justice

ands

'l'hG Hon'ble Stu·i Josepb. Vithayathll, ,.Tudge •

.>.No,6 of 295%

·· lJoc-. 29 o-f-;.' ll~U. on the file of i~llf3ppey-... Dist.rict Gou.rt.

{

L...:-......:-1.lant =- Plai.nttff.

Krishna l(arrnilath.i Harnachand.ra

1Carnmathi of 1\a.klmx•ezha-t.t1.1t l1if1dom, Padinjattumlm1"'a Vadalckum Eu.ri, 'll1.u.ravoor.

By Advocate,'3hI·i

1'3•l-Ic:"1.rayc,nan Potti.

Hesoondents:-Det\:m.c1ants 1tco 7.

·h.Na.ras:1.mn»a.ras:1.mn».ras:1.mn»as:1.mn»s:1.mn»:1.mn»1.mn»mn»n»a Pei Peieiia Pei Peieii'=/.a tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!=/.a tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!a tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!B Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!ai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!i of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!f i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!n.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!1;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!elL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!lL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!L.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!aca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!ca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! oatnu a.1 u!atnu a.1 u!tnu a.1 u!nu a.1 u!u a.1 u! a.1 u!.1 u!1 u! u!, s Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i s Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- iano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- ino_.ta nr·ipa.ram- io_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i.ta nr·ipa.ram- ia nr·ipa.ram- i nr·ipa.ram- ir·ipa.ram- i·ipa.ram- iipa.ram- ipa.ram- ia.ram- i.ram- iam- im- i- i i, s Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i s Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- iano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- ino_.ta nr·ipa.ram- io_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i.ta nr·ipa.ram- ia nr·ipa.ram- i nr·ipa.ram- ir·ipa.ram- i·ipa.ram- iipa.ram- ipa.ram- ia.ram- i.ram- iam- im- i- i i »!Na.ras:1.mn»a.ras:1.mn».ras:1.mn»as:1.mn»s:1.mn»:1.mn»1.mn»mn»n»a Pei Peieii'=/.a tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!=/.a tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!a tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! tnB Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!B Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! Pai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!ai of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!i of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! of i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!f i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! i~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!~un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!un.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!n.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!.11;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!1;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!;3velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!velL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!elL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!lL.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!L.·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!·Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!Daca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!aca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!ca.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!.l'>.. oatnu a.1 u!l'>.. oatnu a.1 u! oatnu a.1 u!atnu a.1 u!tnu a.1 u!nu a.1 u!u a.1 u! a.1 u!.1 u!1 u! u!, s Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i s Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i Kano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- iano_.ta nr·ipa.ram- ino_.ta nr·ipa.ram- io_.ta nr·ipa.ram- i.ta nr·ipa.ram- ia nr·ipa.ram- i nr·ipa.ram- ir·ipa.ram- i·ipa.ram- iipa.ram- ipa.ram- ia.ram- i.ram- iam- im- i- i ipl], .resiciing at Velee!)pa.rarnbi_l, ·Kodam}l.thuruthu Liu.ri,'.l'trnravoo.r~'iTads1<:L:u Palcuthy (Died - heirsJ.)ef'endants 2 and o).)ef'endants 2 and o).f'endants 2 and o).ndants 2 and o).dants 2 and o).ants 2 and o).nts 2 and o).ts 2 and o).s 2 and o). 2 and o). and o).nd o).d o). o).)..i J.)ef'endants 2 and o).)ef'endants 2 and o).f'endants 2 and o).ndants 2 and o).dants 2 and o).ants 2 and o).nts 2 and o).ts 2 and o).s 2 and o). 2 and o). and o).nd o).d o). o).)..

r::.VernanDPai Haye:~Pai of do.c1o.3.S.r5-::1i'J2sa Pai calleci as VamaYJa Pai Vis·nanatha lai of do.

CJ.0 •-.~

:4. Jamba'Vathi Zai ife of' 2ndmeson&enofCLO.

5. Vittala Vadhia.r called as.anE:ncia Vadt1ia.r:.idappe i[adh_ x!'~·-·:,_.~i<l-ing at Thirurnalathek.1-ce -Nada,Pad injattum1:\.a.ra I VaoaK,<:u."l,Thu.ravoo.r.··i.

o.nancna Va@bier Vekappa Va@liar of do.

do.

1&aechanra a.ugthi Govin&a :a±oz8antu,dom uea1alliris:a i?lan o:1anialresicinat iramalaea1alliris:a i?lan o:1anialresicinat iramala 'ece aca, do. ruri is the guardian.

by -ttdvocate Sh.ri :Kf:X:D2!JD'i0:a:jra:xxpn~.

iespondent

N.Va.radaraja Iyengar •.

'.I'his.Apr)eal su:Lt having been finally hear·d on 5~5-11-1954, tnis cour·t on the same<Iay delivered tlle following:- The 1or-Jer· coux·t declined to pass a decree for rent for· 12 yea.rsci1a.rged on the equiy of' .redemption on ttie g.round th.at even tboug~1. theleasec1.ced p_rovided i'or a cha.rge fo.r a.r.rears ttmtViould B!)PlY only todeedthe 9e1"'iodo-.f tt1e lease fixed by the/areasand not to the ca Se of11oldinlover:.The cases followed by the lea.rned Judge in sup ~or;t o~f-/;his view have all been considered in a recent i!-·u11 Bench decision of thisco ux•t in A. S. 101/52 whe.re itwas held tbat such. a term .reallyformed po.rt of'U-w lease a.r.ra ngernent and would ensure even .for the periocof the holdlng-ovox•.In vievv of' this decision the lea1.~ne6. counsel £'01·eosttth.e .respondent had to eonecd.-that ti.le appeal has to be allowed.

Accordingly we modify the loYve.r court's decree by grant:Lng a dec.ree r .I~~~·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._~~·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._~·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._ ....~....,-'!.. _,._...~....,-'!.. _,._~....,-'!.. _,._....,-'!.. _,._-'!.. _,._'!.. _,._ _,._'!.. _,._ _,._ _,._·.-;_-, ·.-. - -~:5::::5:::;_-, -'!.. _,._'!.. _,._ _,._'!.. _,._ _,._ _,._.

~:

~~~·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._~~·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._~·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._·.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._.,. ....~....,-'!.. _,._ ....~....,-'!.. _,._...~....,-'!.. _,._~....,-'!.. _,._....,-'!.. _,._-'!.. _,._'!.. _,._ _,._'!.. _,._ _,._ _,._.. - -~:5::::5:::-,...--.~-'JA

fo.r arrears fo.r a 11 the l2-yeas as claimed in the plaint and charged on the equity of .redemption ov@.l? the plaint schedule properties.

.tr.1e· case we make no order i'o.r costs in In .the ci.tcumstances ofthe appeal, the appell{:fnt_~Yitll:r.g~_t_ nis-_•_e_nti.re costs in the f'i.rst court ••

Sd/- ~;T.--Xoshi,G.:Jt,.«t,.:-:.~f

-sd/,Joseph Vita%@ti1, J.

f

(TrueCopy).

'

.

a,s. to.6@O er 1see.

. Copy of Judgment.

•..-

(

·/I S. ·t/s'2_

. l

l