Kerala High Court
AS/2/1953 of DROUPATHI Vs PADMAVATHI on 26 July 1954
t 'Appeal S:;.i t no. 2 of 1~)53 • In the High Cpurt of Travancorc -Cochin. . • Before . J ·. TMf Hon I bif.e. Shr-'.. P .K. Subramania Iyer,. Judge. ·. · The Hon'ble dhri Joseph ~Vithsyathil~ Judge.. . . . . . • . . 3y ac1vocste Er.Barna Shc::.1oi. - - O
..f.[.][·]..k':i#"/X •·.._J··Ii'.I.O • .s. .s..r:o.Droroouathi,Lpa·l l • ,L1l l • ,L1 l • ,L1a • ,L1 ,L1L1lll1lll1T·l l • ,L1pa·l l • ,L1l l • ,L1 l • ,L1a • ,L1 ,L1L1lll1_if, Pf(;a, urart:o··bcani,•f,Padmii)i)admdm'11ii)Padmii)i)admdmn.biJ Villilllllage,-rrt on the IS. .,,.,_...-'"1 ._,):.'.·'·-_.- •In the High Cpurt of Travancorc -Cochin..•Before.·. TMf Hon[I]bif.e. Shr-'.. P .K. Subramania Iyer,. Judge..•Before.·. TMf Hon[I]bif.e. Shr-'.. P .K. Subramania Iyer,. Judge.·.J· The Hon'ble dhri Jose.ph ~Vith.s.ya.thil~. Judge..'Appeal S:;.i t no.2 of1~)53 •'Appeal S:;.i t no.2 of1~)53 •
--
O • .s. .s..r:o.167 of 1122 of the jikaimal District Court.
«.3
Droroouathi,daughter ofWeenakshi, residing at Thazhum-3T·l l • ,L1pa·l l • ,L1l l • ,L1 l • ,L1a • ,L1 ,L1L1lll1_if, Pf(;a, urart:o··bcani,•n:::-ta1,.,,,.-mane sayw<=:larn-nt1mu FrG.....-...adlinu}K' •al'•a•. Ai- Mppeu l:r1ia,n1':1t-atdetfanendcheanriti-·n the lower t$court.
3y ac1vocste Er.Barna Shc::.1oi.
'11ii)Padmii)i)admdmnm.b.,..,avaastthiG,...a,·tedaRg0gahdt'e, fr o--amfe Rswaa,::ra Fars ±an,..,alcddi .kne'rj.a,r. raie•s Bi. rudirni•g,_· i'i"i'na t Bt ta.anirc. h eavirr P1.a:ramba,iiJ Villilllllage, iochin anavannur alk-.Respondent-PL£f. in lower court. ±
This app-ea 1 having: oen finally: hear-d: on '26. 7.1954 thecourt on thesame day deliv':!red the following.
Judgment.
1Delivered by Subr~mania Iyer J.J.
Page 1 of 3
The only~Joint pr·~ s sedbefore us b:,.-';3ri :Rama Shenoi, lcsrned counsel for the a p1fr Jlant, is,.· as regards the .me sne profitsdecreed against his client y the court belo.. "e arguesthattheh'decree of the court belo has declared that.the possession of theippellant isthtt of aposs3ssory mortgageeentitled to.get ~.1300.by way of mortgage money· as also the value of improvements fiied bythe court below.This part of the decree has·not beenchallenged bytheplaintiff re~pondent.Therefore,it stands.The resuliis thatthe possession of the appellant is rightful and ha's been r.ightfulJtfor all the relevant per-iod.To bold- that the n~;pellant' spossessic,~1I.iswrongful which is necessary to render him liable formesne profits!awould be inconsistent with the decree which ~efinitely declareshis4possession to be thatoT a possessory mortgagee,and therefore -/._absolutely rightful~The part oftbe decree of the court. below)re8ldering the appellant L.., b-le for me sne profits fro;n 30.11.1116,Jt[½]lo[m]'CO'~~'·-c.t~L,(;~o· -f ~l.:Jx V•,the deed'.)f sale}n favour of the a_ppelJ_ant,cannotf·bes-ustained.1t is this5c,edo? sale whtcb hasgot metanaphos~d1-into a possessory mortgageon account of the decreeof the court1Jclo•N.Thntpart of the decree of the court belowwhich rEl'"ders theappellant liabl~ formesnc profitspast and future is vacated.;·....._:1 );-_, ,· ...:.
...
•
•1
app,2a-'" 1s. al1owc,d· t.::,-::::e above .lir::ited extent and. t•,..,,, decree· of thocourt bolo.zodiisd..Te remaining portionof the'decree of t':e
Page 2 of 3
2. ::-_2e:·:·2-:1:.,elm'i has not fixed a t:i..me within which theamounts iue ts ze appellant should be deposited in.court.LearreCc o±.-° - te appellan t pressed that a time :for such deposit beexec .::.-'::e t~e d~cree for reaL.sntion of the amount by sale of the -;_·,r J ~:.-:::.'ties.7.'e ,,,:.0therµfore,direct that the. rt: spondeht' IJlaintiff do!·::e;:osite aount payable to the app,e_lb:1pt.in cour.t on or befor<?3Ct~ o~ :~nuary 1955 andthatin'efault the appellant be entitledc cecuta the decree or r9covary of the amount ofs.1300 as also} v:::1·~-=- of ir:.~;rovements due to him-cy sale of the;Jro~-J:::rties compris,3c"lsta~ces of the case wu directboth parties to pay themselves theirres-pective cOsts ,in this 8!J}Jeal.26.7.1S54.Sd. l?. ::: • Subr amania Iyer, Jude •.Sd.Joseph Vithayathil, Judge.
'cop"y;
Page 3 of 3
Loading citations and judicial treatment…