AS/38/1950 of BALAKRISHNA MARAR Vs RAMA PISHARODI on 23 October 1955

o.s.l\:o.136 of 1121 on the fiJA uf thP.

i:Et l.ltlfl1 •

.-:istrict Cou-rt e;t Anji•

President, Co\filin

Deva ~v:om Dog relbenal± i' her@nllor cha.vcoy Devasor.

Ram.a Pisharodi nelJPher, of.'Na.raya.na Pi@hFro,:H,P2ilinjare Pisha-ro:t.riu,Chi ttoo:r Des;orn,,,./:Jh,3.rane.-11.o.orVi.ltr;g~e, J<annyarmur Tal.uk.

the'1:0U!'t delive:r.ec1 the f'.>ll('ftJing JUd€f:i ".3l°it •

0..20.130.£ 1121_9 ± iscieCour; ofAn,dikai- 'ihe judl!)lent Qf th~ court lae.Jow:-•·

••

\Tha document or 1099 is 3ii t G, of 1101 1s Exhil)i t K,,.·-·ratwas.trrivis}'the PEtta[;rented t•_; Naraya!1a Po.Ll.c-.LercUl,l.,Xh101 t J d.ated-ttf11-10-1099 .is the subs,:iquent patta issued in favour of•·Jj33. /'i..(;GOro.inr tc, the defendant"the suit1 property be.--~lont,s to the Cherne11ur mhaavg thi Devesinn3anandth..,;ri,h_2tso•f the p,.laint,.iff- . is thlea,, ut o., _r_cta.-k'-Ltn•-.lat-• t••Uev_±r.;r._;t.,he· ew l,l,Lar·_.l·.,:,r../l''rent1Kanam .s/.nc,e .th1 ·r. :r.·eeo.s o,e1·nc·TI4:1xn'1• '01• + usv8XLaVI r.r.t..•1= o·so .••. j1rc·.{;It is tru,e thfi tr.::. t the Settle1.:1.ent o:r 1()80 the property was~tregistered ss 8 verrn~1~x:•ttor:1 holcirt; 2nd ']xhibi ts_F and J·\3have Qeerl i ssuea · on that basis.18'-01.19;) .J50 t·hu e1· ssti.oeof' s·pattalike Fxh ibi t Fin •.':[~ny wayG'XWlud.e ,the q(testion- o:f title as15et·.veen he 1and-.1_·r••·,r·a·..etc-,r,_.;.,{.J}_;hl[0]G!""'-· ter_J.a.·•r- .i.,t•-~It.,J'"1:.~t.) c,:• V.,.,,-•'n1"r-J.:. b-9C:;)4•_,.~C:~ ,-i~l,1...i,tf.__,_t.rn._,:..,..1.o1.j -rJ.:· Vt.1'r~1·,'lr/h;\L.;.V•h.tl.. 6~1-.···1··,·.•. :~theD-revious .cases have been surveyed,SLllilr:tarises theD-os.i..;·?J-.1-.jti,.•..) ,d. o'"'. ,q.·_f' .·u.')1r.•J\·~1·s. •·~, .,,.-··~i"The· object of the Settler'aent beinr·. to fix ths asses53-rlm9,.., •]e-na._,1.rt0 lte'19,v. diga d1J:l.o) .,,e oa rniio ~9t) eurav.Ot?rau" 9keas l,),], taandesAc1, u·{...th ,.a,1,e1, ;i. S: ',,;<::\,ett• j-lL ul.er:.1 rrney•n.!....,. •t :.,,... P.1r·1r v·ou ,.-,-:(te ..\4Ci..·.fl1rl•[f] .["][h],[t][t:!],., •• r • • • • • •ev.nl:i>·• -n8,Jt~4c.·).,..1 the, ~)-,,u+,3)a$%gs3ti to-.,8IIjn,d t•h8··,·Pr6(;lo.:;1ation thffi:;f:fi(;ersrnentione.d in sec!ticm 24 hB.ve;,i}1no ritsh t to c'. eci d.e the Olfe sti op _of' title 'to land;s1J et~_-)YJeen·the Govern.ment End its suoJe(;ts end the pr1vete-~rights or artieseanrot be_affected by any order ;"essfed under section ~4 or' theSettlenent Pro~;laffat1on.-1I·>,¥.4. The only(IUestion.t..rierer"ore th.:~1t really ar1~: esfor .C?IS1. :...Cera At.0:,,1· .m,..i ' t· ,h~-i. .1€6.,...., ...p- ,%681 i:s •eh+n}er·i-sGOVere' .d., by the kanan-1 a.ncl etl1ir·aaeds; Exttibi ts· V and VI.Thed• A ,.J,;.,,;q ~,·•Y'..i '!Y)ti ().• -n· or th 8D-'.".'. 0OD-e:r t•v).. 88is:

J

"'±~;

:

J

"'±~;

:

5. Thed.escril)tion-oi'- th·e prt)perty i.n Exhibit G (it.1), in Exhibi't K (i teui '1) and in Exhibit H( ite!:i, 1) ises$aei,it"1aa1u y'th.eSuamle ±- ,·i,Ad l.ea '·dVs= t. t)he1.rr,a_, .s.:,l' a :~t·l' !.7)]a·:..,»·.... u...-.ulusioc. that- the item: or property to i:Vhich the suit re-lates is thesame·s t.rie one· C;overed byE:xhit: its V and...'''We0:an tra;0;ethewords·an/>>0o av>eJ8>ser'.-. .. .;fi" right;")-t b. k)a .. .....,ckJ;-..,. t..o )-1__ 6 ,__O(3-~ ...H...ib··-'itec._,: V\JIT..... eU-n!.l.d...... VII'I..)-~...-.,0-a.rid_the e()ns.;ancy with ·whicb that descriptio__.,nha s1Je e n refpeatod throughout the history oi the propery can±sotoutb,eba.>LJ _sed on__ a-n~• id;J t')H 1..,itJy o.•,r1. t-~he:.pJlai_At ;1.-'e-'d•.d••y• 'i.i ]ed.i. i,:;1.,_ thone demi sect under'll':xhi1Ji t V.\·6. LearnedGOU11$elt.h[A]V[ r][e][c.!]"-'l[;][;][•][·][,][.][----]• -:[,][r-]l[rl]<.;,[o]\JJ.[>]['"].l[t][-]t,::;u c t:•~reA,. -n~- HI.I!.ha.t.l-O''_paC:AJras~ of_ p.J(..kaddy la._n,..J..dh inth4e lto..r..,;,;,;,ca.-l.1-itvyc',.;,, ..o 1n... 1."""ce•.Jrn,..edl.) i..•.;rl.l__.be:about ~8 cents snd. that i"f' w,eGame- tIo the eonc:lusion thatthe sui '½ p:rbper ty and the itern den-t~sed uncl.erEXhil)it - V arethe same_, no-_f'qrther nuestion will arise eXGer;t the ques-o:f the· Se-ttlen:en t pattawhiGb we have di:Ec:usse.c anrl aealt. \vith in rx:irat;raph 3ab.:>ve.it:Z:'.7.Bxhibi t C is the jdgent or trial court in. o.s .No. (c,.92or 192, 3xhi0it 7 is ,the judQllen t in, aeal therefrom-.3.10. is or 1osa s±it 3 is n decree in ±.s.g,In thc:,.t li tiration the def'endsntsoU[z;htrecti f'i G:e:ti on ofthe p;op~yty'.Learned 0;uunsel· f.'or the respondent ri{~htlyIconceded the t the decision in ths..·t li ti2;sti on v1ill not.operate, ua Ze jucigs and that· the lower(;ourt 's deeis 5.ohon the point h:c s to1Je [:FI::~

/'

as thein whose f0vour· exhil°Ji t F'ed• ;""".t..na_t ··-he~ eth(is~ e ',,.tfi{: t-eIr:18.·,.itl silent end t.h0•t he,d.. id. u,iot.ad.van,.:.;e sny c,f ttrni;ontentions v1hid:/ :i',)rrt: the pr 9sent plaiht.

.'8. 3xhi0it R isemso:t · the8l1(JliVinc; P~-Y~el-1:\t 2110\'Vs nosuet nuver:-\vri tin:;~t o:r2.rly c:1ter2ti on v:hs tscr-ever.

Inpos si 1J1YllfJ.-,,«'"hold. ·the·_Jlo-intiffs contention on the1JF::-sis of the. ..jSettJlet:1ent R~gistry.,-t.he c,;in?enuent is·sueuf c, :.ntts,·•{"'and the desc;ri~;tion of the prOI)erty it1:i;xhibi tT ( item 2~~..~:There can1J~ no doubt that tJ1e su1tpr1)r:e.r tylSdelineated on·t,hel)JBn sxhi1Jit '\ is the iter? c,t uro:Je:rty «.::over e<f by !l:xfiibits- V and VI, s.nc1_ th 2,t th8c,ppea~ ~ s._ :),_·-to beaJJ..lowecl.1\tiewi t11cos S.i23rd:3d./K.eT~Koshi, Chief,}ustic·e.J,..tff"'lSd. /M. S.en91,Irl',4jI'.)l.J~i,-_·A;::=_•_ ,... ,., LA..-----_..:.-• r1.J~El.pj:pI:r··. 1#so~-• '·:<2.~;;,,~:::J,L(O__ -'--~~-----=-~----- ·-~c