Telangana High Court
WP/5271/2014 of Shaik Rafi Vs The Admissions and Fee Regulatory Committee on 29 December 2023
THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (SPecial Original Jurisdiction) FRIDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF DE-C-Ej"IBER' '- wi,o rHousAND AND TwENTY THREE PRESENT THE HON'BLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA Between: WRIT PETITloia-No.5271 0F 20't4 Shaik Rafi 5 /o Sha ik Khajamiya, Aged 18 Years r f E
r
f
E
r'it
F
{
?s
)
HIGH COURT [FOR THE ][STATE ][OF ][TELANGANA ][AT ][HYDERABAD](SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
' '- FRIDAY, [THE TWENTY NINTH ][DAY OF ][DE-C-Ej"IBER]wi,o rHousAND AND TwENTY THREE
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE [MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDA]
WRIT PETI[Tloia-No.5][271 ][0F ][20't4]
Between:
Shaik [Rafi ][5][/o ][Sha][ik Khajamiya, ][Aged 18 ][Years]
$yea.s1)
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
1.
2. [Shaik ][Usma Begum ][D/o ][Shaik ][Subhani' ][Aged]
gl{u"
3. [Haseena Beg][um ][Shaik ][D/o Sk'lbrahim' ][Agd]
d [Jan, Aged ][19 ][Years']
4. Shaik [Ru][zma ][Begum ][D/o ][Shaik ][S]
kata [Narsaiah, Aged ][19 ][Years']
5, [Baddu][ ta ][SwaPna ][Teia][ D]
6. [ChinaPangu ][Vani ][Di ][o ][Ka][nakaiah, Aged ][19 ][Years]
7. Atta [SwaPna ][D/o ][Govinda Raju, ][Aged ][18 ][Years']8.$adala [Bindu ][Sree ][D/o ][Rambabu' ][Aged ][18 ][years']8.$adala [Bindu ][Sree ][D/o ][Rambabu' ][Aged ][18 ][years']
8.
9. [Gutti ][Y,amini ][D/o ][Eswar ][Rao' ][Aged ][19 ][years']
to. [cnatta ][Nagarani ][D/o ][Basaviah' Aged ][19 ][years']
to. ff. [CunOu ][Si'i'"nneta ][D/o ][Srinivasa Reddy' Aged ][18 ][years']ff. [CunOu ][Si'i'"nneta ][D/o ][Srinivasa Reddy' Aged ][18 ][years']
12. [lndrapatty ][Jyothsna ][D/o ][Ramarao' ][Aged 20 ][years']
l:. [o"'""'"tt' ][Nagajyothi D/o ][Ramutu' Aged ][19 ][years']
14. [Dandu Jaganmohan ][Reddy ][S/o ][Subba ][Reddy' Aged ][18 ][years']
15. [BhuPathi Mounika ][D/o ][Ramutu' ][Aged 19 ][years']
16. [Sivanguta ][Satish S/o Yagamaiah' ][Aged 22 ][years']
17. [[Patta ThiruPathi ]][Rao ][S/o Sreenu' ][Aged 20 ][years']
17. [[Patta ThiruPathi ]]18. [Devanaboyena Varaprasad ][Raiu ][5/o ][Gangaraju' ][Aged ][1E ][years']18. [Devanaboyena Varaprasad ][Raiu ][5/o ][Gangaraju' ][Aged ][1E ][years']
19. [Yamumuta ][Raiesh ][5/o ][Ganapathi Rao' ][Aged 18 ][years']
20. [K'Shyam Kumar S/o ][Vittat' ][Aged ][33 ][years']
20. 21' [Charugundta Venkateswartu ][S/o ][Buchaiah' ][Aged ][26 ][years']21' [Charugundta Venkateswartu ][S/o ][Buchaiah' ][Aged ][26 ][years']
Z?. [Gaiata ][Amin ][S/o ][Sabir ][Hawri' ][Aged 20 ][years']
Atam [5/o ][6ouse ][Atam' ][Aged 23 ][years']23.
23. ^'td'lshaque ^'td'lshaque 24-tBf [iUuttun Amin ][5/o ][Narut Amin ][Fakir' ][Aged 24 ][years']
25. Shaik Abdut 5/o Chandmiya, Aged 2'l years.
26. Shaik lmran 5/o lqbat Ahamad, Aged 21 years.
27. Nuthakki Jankiram S/o Subba Rao, Aged 18 years.
28. Baareddy Shivashankar Reddy 5/o Saidi Reddy, Aged i8 years
29. Vudari Harisha Sri 5/o Venkateshwartu, Aged 18 years.
30. Koratta Ravikiran S/o prasad, Aged 20 years.
3'l . Ganguta Harini D/o Thimma Reddy, Aged 18 years.
32. Mahesh Vantipuli 5/o Saidulu, Aged Z0 years.
33. Potisetty Mahatakhmi D/o Seetharamutu, Aged tg years.
34. Manduta Satish S/o Rama Rao, Aged 18 years.
35. Kotti Shyam Kumar S/o Prasad, Aged 21 years.
36. Potturu Karthi Choudary D/o Rangaiah, Aged 24 years.
37. Amit Raj S/o Ram Vijay Singh, Aged 19 years.
38. Gautam Kumar S/o Ramesh Prasad, Aged 21 years.
39. Ranjan Kumar lvlandal 5/o Dinesh Alandat, Aged 1g years.
40. Rohit Raj S/o Raghunath Ciaudary, Aged 23 years.
41. Shaik Basha S/o lviahaboob Subani, Aged 22 years.
42. Tenkayachetta Ativetamma S/o Suryanarayana Reddy,Aged l8 years.Aged l8 years.
43. Vetpula Prasanna D/o Ravikumar, Aged 20 years.
44. Bhukya Santhosh S/o Babu, Aged 22 years.
45. Basanti Thapa D/o Jungbahadur Thapa, Aged 21 years.
46. Sreenu Giri S/o Yettaiah, Aged 28 years.
47. Chitukuri Meerakumari D/o Venkateswar Rao, Aged ZZ years.
48. Md.Shamsuzzaman S/o l(d.eumruzaman, Aged 19 years.
49. Abu Bakar S/o Quamrul Haque, Aged 20 years.
50. Md.Shahbaz Atam S/o Sharfuddin Ansari, Aged [.19 ]years.
51 . Hamzah Bin Aatey Nabi S/o Aateya Nabi, aged 20 years.
52. Aamir Khan S/o Astam Khan, Aged Zl years.
53. Ditruba Parbin S/o Abdut Kader, Aged 19 years.
54. Md.Rakib [Akter ][Khan ][S/o ][Raza ][Khan' Aged ][22 ][years']
55. Rakibut [Hassan ][S/o Abdut Kader' Aged 72 yea(s']
56. Sami [Ahmad ][Khan ][S/o ][Guta.n ][Sarwar ][Khan' ][Aged ][21 ][years']
57. [Tastima ][Akhtar ][5/o ][Abdus ][Shahid' Aged ][26 ][years ][']
58. [Prabhakara ][Rao ][Tetturi ][S/o ][Venkaiah' ][Aged 27 ][years']
59. [Uppara ][Ravi ][S/o Venkateswartu' ][Aged ][21 ][years']
60. Mukesh [Kumar ][Yadav ][5/o ][RamJ Prasad ][Yadav' ][Aged ][18 ][years']
6'1. Fateh [Bahadur ][Rai ][S/o ][Nanda ][Rai' Aged ][ZZyeats']
62. Md.Farid [Atam S/o ][Sohrab ][Ati' ][Aged 20 ][years']
63. Amanrai [S/o ][Ramdhari Yadav' Aged ][21 ][years']
64. Md.Ashraf [S/o ][Md'Astam' ][Aged 23 ][years']
65. Binod [Kumar ][5/o ][Rajdeo Bhagat' Aged ][22 ][years']
66. Dharm [Das ][Bharti D/o ][Vishnu Prasad' ][Aged 20 ][years']
67. [Takhettambam Surajkanta ][Singh ][S/o ][Tomba Singh' Aged ][22yea$']
68. [Vivek Kumar ][5/o ][Dinbandhu Prasad' Aged ][19 ][years']
Att the oetitioners [are students ][of ][Sana ][Engineering ][CoUege']HHS, k"drO, [Natgonda ][District-508 ][206' ]
...petitioners
AND
The Admissions [and ][Fee ][Regutatory ][Committee]i;i]1oo1, lsouth [wing), ][Gagan ][vihar']M.J. [Road, ][HYderabad]Rep bY [its ][Member Secretary']i;i]1oo1, lsouth [wing), ][Gagan ][vihar']M.J. [Road, ][HYderabad]Rep bY [its ][Member Secretary']
The Government [of ][Andhra Pradesh']
z
Reo.. bv [its ][PrinciPa[ ][secretary,]o"Larti,ent [of ][rechnkat ][Education']i.Iltrrili-erituins, [saif ][abad, ][Hvderabad']o"Larti,ent [of ][rechnkat ][Education']i.Iltrrili-erituins, [saif ][abad, ][Hvderabad']
3Jawahartat "nlp-'uv i" [Nehru TechnoLogkal' ]n"il;trar, Kukatpattv' [University ]Hyderabad'[Hyderabad']
The A.P. [State ][Courcit ][for ][Higher ][Education]Siifabad, [Hyderabad ][rep ][by ][its Secretary']Siifabad, [Hyderabad ][rep ][by ][its Secretary']
sana Enqineering [Cottege,]
i-.".. u'i it. s".t"tary u'i it. s".t"tary it. s".t"tary [[ind ][Correspondent']][[Correspondent']]
i-.".. u'i it. s".t"tary u'i it. s".t"tary it. s".t"tary [[ind ][Correspondent']][[Correspondent']]il : ;, il;;; [n;isoiia ][oi't,ict'i'oo ][zoo ]"'Respondents ,1.- Petition under Articre 226 0f rhe constitution of rndia praying that in thecircumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High court may bepleased to issue a writ or order or direction more particurarry one in the nature ofwrit of Mandamus decraring the action of the 1st respondent in refusing theratification of admission of the petitioners in the I year of the B. Tech course in theSth respondent corege vide the impugned proceedings No. 12lAFRC-RA/sw. il-2013-141210 dt. 24.10.2013 as iilegar, arbitrary and viorative of Articre 14 of theConstitution of lndia and consequenfly direct theRespondents to allow thepetitioners to pursue their respective B.Tech Courses
l.A. NO:1OF 2014(WPMP. NO: 6547 OF 20141
Petition under section 1 51 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated inthe affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be preased to directthe respondents to permit the petitioners to pursue their study in B. Tech coursethe affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be preased to directthe respondents to permit the petitioners to pursue their study in B. Tech courseunder the lateral entry scheme in the sth respondent college, includingappearance in examinations, decraration of resurts, etc, pending disposar of themain writ petition.main writ petition.
Counsel for the [petitioner: ]M/s. p. SHREYAS REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent Nos. 1 & 4: SRI C. SUDESH ANAND, S.C. FOR APSCHE
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: AGp FOR TECHNTCAL EDUCATION
Counsel for the Respondent No.3: SRI K. RATHANGA pANl REDDY,- S.C FOR JNTU- S.C FOR JNTU
Counsel for the Respondent No.S: -
The Court made the fottowing: ORDER
HON,BLE MRS JUSTICE SUREPALLI NANDAWRIT PETITION No.5271 ot 2OL4
ORDER:
Heard learned counsel for the [petitioners ]and [also]heard learned Counsel appearing on behalf [of]respondents.
PERUSED T
E RECORD
The petitioners apprbached this Court seeking [the]
relief as under:
"to issue a writ or order or direction more moreparticularly one in the nature of Writ ofMandamus declaring the action of the [1't]respondent in refusing the ratification [of]admission of the [petitioners ][in ]the II [year ][of ][the]B.Tech course in the 5th respondent college [vide]the impugned [proceedings ][No.12/AFRC-]RA/SW.II-2o13-L4l2tO dt 24.t0.2013 as [illegal,]arbitrary and violative of Article 14 of [the]Constitution of India and consequently [direct ][the]Respondents to allow the [petitioners ]to [pursue]their respective B.Tech Courses and [pass ][such]other order or orders as this [Hon'ble ][Court ][may]deem fit and [proper ]in the [circumstances ][of ][the]"case.
2. It is represented by learned [Assistant ][Government]
Pleader appearing on behalf of [respondents ][that, ][the ][cause ][of]
action in [the ][present ][writ ][petition does ][not ][survive ][for]adjudication [anY ][more.]
the [[said submission on ][record' ][the ][present ]][[record' ][the ][present ]][[the ][present ]][[present ]][[writ]]Bringing the
3. Bringing the [[said submission on ][record' ][the ][present ]][[record' ][the ][present ]][[the ][present ]][[present ]][[writ]]dismissed [as infructuous' ][However' ][there shall ][be]petition is no order as [to ][costs']
pending in this [Writ]
Miscellaneous Petitions, [if ][any,]Petition, shall [stand ][closed.]Petition, shall [stand ][closed.]
s D/- [PicJl,u+fiiB ]IESFHiA>,/SECNdN [OFFICER]
,/TRUE [COPY"]
'O,,. ONU [CC ][tO ][M/S' ][P'SHREYAS REDDY' ][AdVOCAIE-IOPUCI]S'C' [for ][APSCHE ][IOPUCI]2. One [CCto ][SRI ]"''UOtt' ^*AND' PANI [REDDY' ][s ][c ][ror ][JNru ][[oPuc]]3. [one ][cc ][to ][sRl ][*' ][*;;;;^ ]Hish [court ror the ][state ][or]
3. . TH"3n$##sffiat"eoucation'
5. [Two ][CD CoPies]
MPGJP
HIGH COURT
DATED:2911212023
', :f1.i i- [ll ]lii i\t\.tc.,:\' '/ t..rl\,,(.:. \,--],'(J2 [7 ]FEB 2;24*.5 i)..\1 c.r"r-tlORDER
WP.No.5271 o12014
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITIONAS INFRUCTUOUSWITHOUT COSTS
t