Telangana High Court
CRLP/13636/2018 of Sara Shiva Karna Vs The State of Telangana on 31 December 2018
FII{ST DAY OF DECEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND EIGHTEEN :PRESONT: THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE SHAMBEM AKTHER Ciiiir,llitjA.l, PIITITION NO: 13636 OF 2018 B etrveen: l. Sara Shiva Karna, S/o. Sara Bala Swamy, 2. Nama Sunil Kumar, S/o. N{allikarjuna Guptha, Petitioners/Accuscd No.1 & 2 AND The State of
i26et I
HiiiTr i-OUI{f UF Jt'i.IICA,'TURE A'I HYDERABADI'OI( THE STATT, OF TELANGANA AND THE [STATB ][OF ][ANDHRA ][PRADESH]
MONDAY, THE THIRTY FII{ST DAY OF DECEMBERTWO THOUSAND AND EIGHTEEN
:PRESONT:
THE HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE SHAMBEM AKTHER
Ciiiir,llitjA.l, PIITITION NO: 13636 OF 2018
B etrveen:
l. Sara Shiva Karna, S/o. Sara Bala Swamy,
2. Nama Sunil Kumar, S/o. N{allikarjuna Guptha, Petitioners/Accuscd No.1 & 2
AND
The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Public Prosecutor, High Court ofJudicature [at ][Hyderabad,]For the State of Telangana and the State of Andhla Pradesh.
Respondent
Petition under Section 438 of Cr.P.C, praying that in the circumstances stated in [the]petition and the grounds filed heiein, the High Court may be pleased to grant Anticipatory Bailto the Petitioners/Accused No.l and 2 in the event of their arrest by any Police Officer inCr.No.740 of 201 8 dated. 0611012018 of S.R. Nagar Police Station, [Hyderabad, registercd ][rurder]Section 420 and 406 ofLP.C; Counsel for the Petitioners SRI S.N{.RAFtrE
ADDL. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR (TS)
Counsel for the Respondent
The Court made the follorving ORDEIT:
"This [Criminal ][Petition, uuder ][Sectit-,n ][438 ][of ][thc ][Codc ][of ][Criminal ][Procedurc,]1973, is filed by the pctitioners/A.l & A.2, for grant of anticipatory bail in Crirne No.7.l0 of201.8 of Sanjeevaredrly Nagar Police Station, Hyderabad District, registercd for theoffcnces punishable undcr Scctions 420 and 406 of I.P.C.
2. Heard the learned counsel for the pctitioners/A.l & A.2, thc learned AdditionalPublic Prosecutor representing the rcspondenl-State and pcrused thc record.
.'1. lt is contended by the de-facto complaiuant (rnothcr of the victim) that hcr daughtersought admission in a medical course, rvhich is equivllcnt to MllBS, at WashingtonUniversity of Barbados School of Mcdicine. Due to dcficiency in servicc and sorneharassment alleged to have meted out to her, she could not pursuc the medical course thereand came back to India. Her admission relates to the year 2017 and an amount ofRs.16,50,000/- was paid towards college fer:s etc. Thc de-facto complainant furthercontended that her daughter lost one academir: year and she rvas cheated,
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
1. The learned counsel for thc pctitioners/A.l & A.2 rvould subnrit that therc arenumber of students rvho sought admission in the aforementioned University and arc purslling their medical course. The daughtcr of the dc-lacto complainant alone camc backto India on the ground thnt she hrs to attcnd hcr cousin's marriage, Shc applicd leavc forthe simc and came back to lndia. There arc no hchcs on the prrt of the petitioners/A.l &to India on the ground thnt she hrs to attcnd hcr cousin's marriage, Shc applicd leavc forthe simc and came back to lndia. There arc no hchcs on the prrt of the petitioners/A.l &A.2 as allcged in the report, dated 06.10.2018, lodgecl bv thc cle-lircto complainant andultimately prayed to allolv the application.ultimately prayed to allolv the application.
5. On the other hand, the lcarned z\tltlitional Public Prosccutor opposetl for grant oi'anticipatory bail to the petitioners/A.I & A.2.
6. As per thc records placed bcfore this Court, the petitioner/A.1 is the ManagingDirector of Carecr Plus abroad Educational Services India Private Limited and thepetitioner/A.2 is an employee of the said consultrncl'. The sairl consultancy is recogniscdby thc Government of India, rvhich rcnders assistance to the Indian students to pursucmedical Course abrold, particularly in the albrementioncd Universitv, Everv vear,hundreds of students are bcing sent abroad to pursue mcdical courses and everything ismadc clear to them before they are sent to pursue the medical course. The daughter of thede-facto complainant, under thc guise of cousin's marriagc, came back to India, havingpursued thc medical coursc in thc aforementiorred University for about six months.
7, It is apt to extract the first par:rgrlph ot thc !"cport. dated 06.10.2013, lodgcd by thede-facto complainant rvith the police conccrncd, * hich rc:rds ls follot's:"'l'his [is ][to ][requcst ]),ou [to ][arrest:rn(l ][get ][b:rck ][our ][rmount ][spcnt ]anddlmages if not possible lilc FIR against l\lr.Shiva Karna, MD, PhNo.[REDACTED] of Career Plus Abroad Education Services Consultancv,O/o. Flat No.202, Srvasthik Plaza, above Himalaya Book World, NiainRoad, S.R.Nagar, Hyderabad 500 038 and onc of the director ofWashington Univcrsitl' of Barbados School of Medicine, Casa Granade,llibiscus Block, OId Burv St.Phillip, Ilarb:rdos, Cnribbean lsland, SouthAmerica.'ode-facto complainant rvith the police conccrncd, * hich rc:rds ls follot's:"'l'his [is ][to ][requcst ]),ou [to ][arrest:rn(l ][get ][b:rck ][our ][rmount ][spcnt ]anddlmages if not possible lilc FIR against l\lr.Shiva Karna, MD, PhNo.[REDACTED] of Career Plus Abroad Education Services Consultancv,O/o. Flat No.202, Srvasthik Plaza, above Himalaya Book World, NiainRoad, S.R.Nagar, Hyderabad 500 038 and onc of the director ofWashington Univcrsitl' of Barbados School of Medicine, Casa Granade,llibiscus Block, OId Burv St.Phillip, Ilarb:rdos, Cnribbean lsland, SouthAmerica.'o From the above. it appears that thc dc-facto complainant intended to get her monel,back.If there arc omissions and commissions on the part of the employees of the aforementionedUniversitl, rvith regard to the students, th€ same can be placed before thc authorities of theUniversity, Under these circumstances, the petitioners/A.l & A.2 can be [granted ]bailunder Section 438 of Cr.P.C.
tl. Accortlingly, the petitioncrs/A.l .t A.2 are directcd to surrender belbre [the ][Station]House Ol'l'icer, Sanjeeva Reddy Police Station., H1'dcrabad [District, rvithin a period ][of ][I5]days fronr the date of this order. On such surrender, the saitl Station House Officer [shall]releasc thc petitioners/A.l & A.2 on bail on [each ]of them executing [a ][personal ][bond ][for ][a]sum of Rs,50.000! (Rupecs fifty thousand onty) [rvith ][t\Yo ][sureties ][in ][a ][like ][sum ][each ][to ][his]
satisfaction. On such releasc, thc p€titioners/A.l & A.2 shall report before the said StationHouse Officer on eyer), Sundal' between 09:00 ANI and l0:00 AN{, till filing of the charge-shcet. Thc petitioners/A.1 & A.2 shall also abide b1- the conditions stipulatcd in Scction.438(2) of the Codc of Crinrinll Proccdurc, 1973, :rnd shall coopcratc \vith the investigatiugofficcr in the invcstigation of thc crse.
9. Thc Criminal Petition is, aci:oi'din3l.,. allorvcd.N'lisccllaucous pctitions, if an1', pcnding in this Crinrinal Pctition, shall standcloscd."
To,
Sd/. M. [MANJULA]ASSISTANTGISTRAR
,TRL]E COPYi/
Iror ASSISTANT I{l:GlS'IRAI{
The III Addl. Chief Mctropolitan Addl. Chief Mctropolitan Chief Mctropolitan Magistratc.derabad.
IThe III Addl. Chief Mctropolitan Addl. Chief Mctropolitan Chief Mctropolitan Magistratc.derabad.2Theation House Otlicer, SR Nagarrcc Station, I Iyderabad.3CCS to Public Prosecutor, (TS), tligh Court o1'Judicature, at Hyderabad (OUT)one CC to Sri S.MRat'ee, Advocate (OPUC)2Theation House Otlicer, SR Nagarrcc Station, I Iyderabad.3CCS to Public Prosecutor, (TS), tligh Court o1'Judicature, at Hyderabad (OUT)one CC to Sri S.MRat'ee, Advocate (OPUC)
5One Spare Copy
HIGH COURT
DR.SA..I
l)A'l'Il:31-12-2018
(
OITDEIT
CRL.P. NO. [13636 ][0F ][2018]
L----."
PI.]TITIO\ ALI,OWET)
i