Telangana High Court
CMA/1247/2011 of KANTI HARISH KUMAR Vs M.A. HAMEED AND ANOTHER on 31 December 2020
COURT FOR AT HYDTJRISBT#E OF TELANGANA THURSDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEIVBERTWO THOUSAND AND TWENT' THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE G, SRI DEVI CIV LM ISCELLANEO US APPEAL NO: 1247 0F 2011 Appeal Under Section 30 of Workmen,s Compensation Act agalnst theJudgment/Decree in w.c. No.297 0f 2003 dated
IN THE HIGH COURT FOROF TELANGANAAT HYDTJRISBT#E
THURSDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEIVBERTWO THOUSAND AND TWENT'
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE G, SRI DEVI
CIV LM ISCELLANEO US APPEAL NO: 1247 0F 2011
Appeal Under Section 30 of Workmen,s Compensation Act agalnst theWorkmen,s Compensation Act agalnst theJudgment/Decree in w.c. No.297 0f 2003 dated 03-09-2011 0n the fire of the court ofthe commissioner for wokmen's compensation and Deputy commissioner of Labour,at Nizamabadthe commissioner for wokmen's compensation and Deputy commissioner of Labour,at Nizamabad Between:
Kanti Harish Kumar, 'S/o Sailu, Occ_ Ex- Driver of Auto, R:/o. ChandrashekarColony, Nizamabad. Colony, Nizamabad.
...AppellanUAppellant
AND
1. V,A,Hameed, S/o. Hafeez, Aged; lvlajor Owner of the Auto No. Ap 25 U 3385R/o tt4alapally, Nizamabad.R/o tt4alapally, Nizamabad.
(Rl- dismissed wide Court Order dated.l 1 .07 .2016)
2. National Insurnace Compa!y Limited, represented by its Branch N,4anager,Branch Office, B. Laxmiraj Complex, Jawahar Road,'Nizamabad, NizariabadDistrict.Branch Office, B. Laxmiraj Complex, Jawahar Road,'Nizamabad, NizariabadDistrict.
... Res ponde nts/Opposite Parties
Counsel for the Appellant: SRl. LAKKADI DAYAKER REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: SMT M. BHASKARA LAKSHMI
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
HONOURABLE [JUSTICE ][G' ][SRI ][DEVI]MiSCE[LLAN EOUS][ APP][ EAL NO,12][ r+7 ][()F][ 201 ][i]
C]IVIL
{UDGMENT:
Pursuant [to ][:1 ][st--Ltlcn-Icllr ][arrived ][:It ][bet\\ ][ccll ][thel ][partics' ][l1-tc]r.,,li Ac1:rlat. Hlclerabacl, [pi'tsscd ][thc ][follorving ][aru ][ilrd ][on tl7' 11'2020:]i. This C.NI [A ][anses ][orLt ][ol ][the ][orct:r ][d:itt ][(1 ][u'l ][uu ][lu ][l l ][irl]W.C.No.297 [of ][2OO3 ][NF ][ot-r ][the ][fiLe ][ol the ][Commissioner lor]and DePutY [Commissioner ][of]Workmen's [Compensatlon]Labour, at [Nizamabad']
2The Commissioner [lor]Workmen'scompensation [and]at Nizamabad [in]at Nizamabad [in]Deputy Commissioner [of ][Labour]W.C.No.297 ol [2003 NF ][has ][granled ][compensation ][ol']Rs.2.18.7 i3i [- ][incitrdir-rg ][cosls ][:rncl ][Adt'ocale ][ir-c ][Aegriclerl]bv tlte si'LicL orcler, [lhe ][applicant ][prefcn'ed ][arL ][:'tilpciti ][I ][iclc]C.\1.A.No. 1217 ol ['2O\ ][\ ]' [Durirrg ][thc ][pcncletrcr ][ol ][trppc:'11]lrorlt 1ltc pi.rrlies halc' [compromisecl ][Ilre ul'1ltt'r']W.C.No.297 ol [2003 NF ][has ][granled ][compensation ][ol']Rs.2.18.7 i3i [- ][incitrdir-rg ][cosls ][:rncl ][Adt'ocale ][ir-c ][Aegriclerl]bv tlte si'LicL orcler, [lhe ][applicant ][prefcn'ed ][arL ][:'tilpciti ][I ][iclc]C.\1.A.No. 1217 ol ['2O\ ][\ ]' [Durirrg ][thc ][pcncletrcr ][ol ][trppc:'11]lrorlt 1ltc pi.rrlies halc' [compromisecl ][Ilre ul'1ltt'r']
3. ['ll'Le ]Appcil:,rllt,'ApplicatlI [alotlg ][l ith hrs ][t'otttlsel ][Sri]Ll.Pral<:lsl.r Rccldr. [Acllocatc, ][has ][rcpresclrtt:rl ][bclot't ][Lllr:]virtual Lok Aclalar [through ][online ][ovt:r ][the ][link ][providccl ][b1]the High Court [Legal ][Sen'ices Committee, ][High ][Courr ][for]the State of Telangana.Ll.Pral<:lsl.r Rccldr. [Acllocatc, ][has ][rcpresclrtt:rl ][bclot't ][Lllr:]virtual Lok Aclalar [through ][online ][ovt:r ][the ][link ][providccl ][b1]the High Court [Legal ][Sen'ices Committee, ][High ][Courr ][for]the State of Telangana.
Page 1 of 4
,+. The Respondent No.2 - National Insurance [Companr']Limrted, Smt' Sujatha [K.Kuntar, ][Manager, ][has ][represented]before the virtual [Lok ][Aclalat ][through ][online ][over ][lhe ][Linl<]proyiclccl b}'the [High ][Court ][Legal Services ][Comrlittee' ][Higl-r]Clourt lor the Siirte [of ][Telangana']Limrted, Smt' Sujatha [K.Kuntar, ][Manager, ][has ][represented]before the virtual [Lok ][Aclalat ][through ][online ][over ][lhe ][Linl<]proyiclccl b}'the [High ][Court ][Legal Services ][Comrlittee' ][Higl-r]Clourt lor the Siirte [of ][Telangana']
5BLrth Lhc [p:trtics]st:r1cd lhtlt tllcr [rcsoivccl ][lhe ][cltsprLlo]irilriclrltlr iLItclLjll,,rr('(L lt'.it-r cilrllllt'tlttlisc. 'l lll'irilriclrltlr iLItclLjll,,rr('(L lt'.it-r cilrllllt'tlttlisc. 'l lll'
Appeilan t/Applicant has senr cop,v of Aadhar card in prr,r.t.o1'l'ris ir:len trfica tion. The malter has been setrled amic;,1.,prr,r.t.o1'l'ris ir:len trfica tion. The malter has been setrled amic;,1.,bctrreen thc parties.
'J'he r\ppcllarrrtApplicant h:rs :rgreccl to ret:t:ir_c an :utloLrlr.ol' Rs.2.23.O00,, (Rtrpces Trvo laklts t\\_clttl thlr.t. Lltr)risl , ,onh 1 rol':r r-d s liril.utcl i-irirl scltlcnl(.n1 al)ltr_i ir-orn rir:lntoLl11t :ru-arde dbv thc Comntissionet, for- \\,or.l<rrcn.sCorlpensatiot.t :rr-rdDeput]- Cornmiss joner o1. Laltour t,,\izamabarl.
ri.
l.
.\c.o.r1i.glr llr. irri..rci i,s ,t:,Lsscd for_ :rrr ii.toLl,iRs 2 23.000r' (Rupecs Tri'o lakhs t\\'..t\ rhrec rrr.usi,,:,,onlt.) tou'ards fu11 and final settlement apart iion_r Lhc.amounl ar,r,arded by the Commissioner lor Workmen,sCompensation and Deputl. Commissioner of Labour ar rN izam abad.onlt.) tou'ards fu11 and final settlement apart iion_r Lhc.amounl ar,r,arded by the Commissioner lor Workmen,sCompensation and Deputl. Commissioner of Labour ar rN izam abad.
8. Thc llespor.rdent No.2,/lnsurance Cclnpanr, has to clepos:tLhc itri alclecl :1111t)Ltnt o1' Rs..1.23.0001 iRrrpce,s [-i-t.o ]lail\\'all\ tht ca tltousiincl onlr ) to\\:1rals 1'ull .,rnll I:r-scttlement u [jri-rin ]a peliod of t\\-o (2) n-rolrths 1l-onr thr.: rl, Io1' rt-'ccipt oi r:r-tp., of this :irr iLr-d aparl ll otn thc :uIoLtitir.rl';ilcllcl irl titc Conrmissioncr lor \\'or-knrr_,n.C)on.rpcnsation trr-irl DeltLttr Corlntissioner ol L:rltlrLtr li\izanrabacl, :rltor gir,rng clr-rc c:rcCit to t1"re :rri.roLlrl alr,-'lrrlrdepositt'd. In the etcnt ol clciar,rlt or delar ir-r r.n:rkinq sL ideposit, Lhe amount par.:lblc sha11 carn' intcrcst ztt l2t)t,.,alrnum from thc date ol delbult.
9. Upon such deposrt, the Appellant is at libertl- to \\'rlhdra.,lthe entire amount.
I1.1. Il'. [t€1-1ns ][ol lhc ][collll)rolllisc ][ilfrlvC(l ][tlt ][1)cl\\rr('ll ][lllr ][1)il1-ll!'s']
tllis cirsc [slancls ][clisilr'':'tcl ][oi']
I 1. The [p.rrlies ][are ][inlormcd ][that ][lhe Court ][1ec' ][il ][anr ][' ][paicl ][l;r']nn1' of them [before Io$'er ][Court shall ][be ][refunded']
In view of the [award ][dated ][07.1 ][l ]'2O2O, [passed ][by ][the ][Lok]Adalat, Hyderabad, this [Civil ][Misceilaneous ][Appeal ][is ][disposed ][of]in terms ol the award.
N4isceilaneous applications. if any, [pending ][shall ][stand]
;cc]
Sd/-I.NAGA LAKSHMIASSISTANT REGISTRARl^/'SECTION OFFICER
//TRUE COPY//
\To,1. The Commissioner for Wokmen's Compensation and Deputy Commissioner ofLabour, at Nizamabad.
2, One CC to Sri Lakkadi Dayaker Reddy, Advocate [OpUC]
3. One CC to Smt [t/. Bhaskara Lakshmi, Advocate tOpUC]
4. Two CD Copies
(Along with a copy of Lok Adalat Award)
h'\Y
HIGH COURTGSDJDA'IED:3111212020
Page 2 of 4
JUDGMENT1HEs14oCMA.No.'1247 of [2011]YI I J,q|J 2021P"/*I.\^,n- DISPOSING OF THE C.M,A. [IN ][TERMS ][OF THE ][AWARD]
rvtai"{v
BEFORE THE LOK ADALAT
( o r s a ni z e d ri'!i%tl.t I Hish ry Courf for the stale Srt}ltj of.Telangana)3, ". s c o m m i tte e(undersection'8fr :ff tl:;zliziin;i';i*i:iti""a"t,1e87(centrarAct)CMA No. LZ47 of ZOLLHish ry Courf for the stale Srt}ltj of.Telangana)3, ". s c o m m i tte e(undersection'8fr :ff tl:;zliziin;i';i*i:iti""a"t,1e87(centrarAct)CMA No. LZ47 of ZOLL(Befor.e the.Hon,ble High Court)Commissioner Against the order for workm.en,s in w.c. cornpens-atiilia no. zsi oi-it'ii"Nr Deputy on the Commissionerfire of theof Labour, at Nizamabad, at. SJ-S"piember, 2011)Commissioner Against the order for workm.en,s in w.c. cornpens-atiilia no. zsi oi-it'ii"Nr Deputy on the Commissionerfire of theof Labour, at Nizamabad, at. SJ-S"piember, 2011)
(No._of proceedings of the High Court Legal Services Committee:oRDER RoC No. 103S/HCLse/ZoZo, o_tua oc_ri_Jozo.
i: Present::
AWARD
The abovecase between the parties having been referred fordetermination tothe LOK ADALAT and the parties having compromised thecase/matter. the following Award is passed in terms of the settlement
1. This CMA arises out of the order dated O3-09_2011 in W.C,No.297 of2003 NF on the file of the Commissioner fcr Workmen,s Compensationand Deputy Commissioner of Labour, at Nizamabad.2003 NF on the file of the Commissioner fcr Workmen,s Compensationand Deputy Commissioner of Labour, at Nizamabad.
8.
Page 3 of 4
The Commissioner for [Workmen's Compensation ][and ][Deputy]Commissioner of Labour at Nizamabad in [W,C.No' ][297 ][of ][2003 ][NF ][has]granted compensation of Rs. 2,18,713/- including costs [and ][Advocate]fee. Aggrieved by the said order, the applicant [preferred ][an ][appeal]vide C.M.A.No. 7247 of 2011. During the [pendancy ][of ][appeal ][both ][the]parties have compromised the matter.
The Appellant/Applicant along with his counsel Sri M.Prakash Reddy,Advocate, has represented before the virtual Lok Adalat throughonline over the link provided by the High Court Legal ServicesCommittee, High Court for the State of Telangana.
The Respondent No.2 - Natlonal Insurance Company Limited,Smt.Sujatha K.Kumar, Manager, has represented before the vitualLok Adalat through online over the link provided by the High CourtLegal Services Committee, High Court for the State of Telangana.
Both the parties stated that they resolved the dispute amicably andentered into compromise. The Appellant/Applicant has sent copy ofAadhar card in proof of his identification. The matter has been settledamicably between the parties.entered into compromise. The Appellant/Applicant has sent copy ofAadhar card in proof of his identification. The matter has been settledamicably between the parties.
The Appella nt/Applica nt has agreed to receive an amount ofRs.2,23,000/- (Rupees Two lakhs twenty three thousand only) towardsfull and final settlement apart from the amount awarded by theCommissioner for Workmen's Compensation and Deputy Commissionerof Labour at Nizamabad.
Accordingly the award is passed for an amount of Rs.2,23,000/-(Rupees Two lakhs twenty three thousand only) towards full and finalsettlement apart from the amount awarded by the Commissioner forsettlement apart from the amount awarded by the Commissioner forWorkmen's Compensation and Deputy Commissioner of Labour atNizamabad.Nizamabad.
Conclusion
The Respondent No.2/Insurance Company has to deposit the awardedamount of Rs.2,23.000/- (Rupees Two lakhs twenty three thousandonly) towards full and final settlement within a period of two (2)months from the date of receipt of copy of this award apart from theamount awarded by the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensationand Deputy Commissioner of Labour at Nizamabad, after glving duecredit to the amount already deposited. In the event of default ordelay in making such deposit, the amount payable shall carry inteiestat 12o/o per annIJJTI from the date of default.
Upon such deposit, the Appellant is at liberty to withdraw the entireamount.amount.
31.0. In terms of the compromlise arrived at between stands disposed of. the parties, this case'/11.The parties are informed berore rower court shali tlree, ir anv, paid by any or them,"t::i:ffi'" 1-d*-8 der-raFor Natlalrance Co [Li]l\st<,Ho;lLFE€T€f??IiAH$ahorised Sigrrarll'Aella nAlicantRes ondent,2 Insurance ComanCou nsel for Aella nlicantP\!a^*taCha irma nMemb erMemberr1- [:i ]l [;\, ][,]a,Date: 07-11-2020lttct-i c.:t.rR.r ]LOK AC,,,Lr:.T ,,1'j,..s,iij(Sea I ofteom m ittee)
Page 4 of 4
Loading citations and judicial treatment…