Telangana High Court

WP/24516/2020 of Sri. K. Rambabu Vs The State of Telangana on 31 December 2020

THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) THURSDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEX/BER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY PRESENT THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE A . ABHISHEK REDDY WRIT PETITION NO: 245 16 oF 2020 Between: 1) Sri. K. Rambabu, S/O. Late. K. l:l::lly: Rao, as.ed uoort oJ

THURSDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEX/BER

TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY

PRESENTTHE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE A. ABHISHEK [REDDY]

WRIT PETITION NO: 245 16 oF 2020Between:1) Sri. K. Rambabu, S/O. Late. K.vuuo,uccupation: l:l::lly: [Rao, ]Business, [as.ed ][uoort ]R/o: [oJ ][, ]Fl;iNo.205, Metro Resider.V, nu;Onuu."nRoad, Hyderabad.2) Smt.. <. Girija Devi W/O. Sri. K.,1:To-l?.r, [aqed about ][sz ]J"u^,uccupation: Housewife, R,/o: ftaINo.205, Metro Residen.y, ni.1Ot'rara"nRoad, Hyderabad,3) Smt. K. lhansi Lakshmi Bai, WO,Late. K. Sadasiva nuo, ug"d ubbii93 [years, ][Occupation: ]fiour"nof J.R/o: Flat No.205, frf"tro n"i,O"r-.JlRajbhavan Road, Hyderabad [-'--"-"]PetitionersNo.2&3areRepresented by their GpA HolderSRI. K. RAMBABU S/O. LATE, K.SADASIVA RAO, aged about 63y9ars, Occupation: Business, R/o:ftu! [No.205, ][Merro ][nesiOencv.]Rajbhavan Road, Hyderabad,4) Sri. B. Hemasundara Rao, S/O. Sri.Lakshmana Rao, aged about 4;I:uIr, [Occupation: ][Business, ][R/o:]]F,3, .S,urVa [Satya ][Apart."ntr, ][frflii]Hotel Kandhari, Vi;ayawada.5) Sri. M. phanindra Kumar, S/O. Sri.M. K. Vishwanadha Rao, agecl aboutjf VeaJs, Occupation: Busiiess, R/orflat [No.205, ][Metro ][Residency,]Rajbhavan Road, Hyderabad.6) Sri. K. Sivarama Sai S/O. Late,Subrahmanyam, aged about iOyears/ Occupation: Business, Rzo;Flat No.6, MRC Regency, Behind i I

BOC,Seethammad hara,Vishakapatnam

7) Sri. V. Narayana Rao S/O. Sri. V.Ananda Rao, aged about 44 years,Occupation: Business, R/o: FIatIo.6l [MRC ][Regency, Behind ][BOC,]Seethammadhara, Visakhapatnam.(No.4 to 7 herein are representedby their Agreement of Sale cum GpAHolder, No. t herein SRI. K.RAMBABU, S/O. LATE. SADASIVAMO, aged about 63 years,Occupation: Business, R/o: FlalNo.205, Metro Residency, RajbhavanRoad, Hyderabad)

8) Smt. C. Sravani, W/O. Sri. C.Srinatha Venkateshwara Rao, ageda.bout 3S years, Occupati6n:Srinatha Venkateshwara Rao, ageda.bout 3S years, Occupati6n:Housewife, R/o; 301, Hyma SurajyaResidency, Balajinagar, Siripurjm,Visakhapatnam.Residency, Balajinagar, Siripurjm,Visakhapatnam.

Page 1 of 6

9) Sri. K. Sadasi\za Rao, S/O. Sri. K.Rambabu, aged about 33 years,Occupation; Business, R/o: flaiNo.205, Metro Residency, RajbhavanRoad, Hyderabad.Rambabu, aged about 33 years,Occupation; Business, R/o: flaiNo.205, Metro Residency, RajbhavanRoad, Hyderabad.

10)Smt. A. [padmaja ]WO. Sri. A. V. J. p.Narayana, aged about 56 years,Occupation: Housewife, R/o. NH5,Akkayyapalem, Visakhapatnam,represented by her Agreement ofSale Cum GpA Holder:SMT. C.SRAVANI WO. SRI. C. SRINATHAVENKATESHWARA RAO, aged about:l [y!!rs, ][Occupation: ][Housewife,]R/o: 301, Hyma Surajya Residency,Balaji Nagar, Siripuram,Visakhapatnam

11)Sri. A. Sivaram, S/O. Sri. A. V. J. p.Narayana, aged about 3g years,Occupation: Business, R/o: [' ]NH5,Akkayyapalem, Visakhapatnam,Represented by his Agreement oiSale cum GpA Holder:SRL K.SADASiVA MO, S/O, SRI. K.RAMBABU, aged about 33 years,Occupation: Business, R/o: 205, Metro Residency, Rajbhavan Road,Hyderabad

12)Sri.Chitturi.Srinatha VenkateshwaraRao S/O, Sri. C. Ravindra, agedabout 39 years, Occupation:Business, R/o: 301, Hyma SurajyaResidency, Balaji Nagar, Siripuram,Visakhapatnam.Rao S/O, Sri. C. Ravindra, agedabout 39 years, Occupation:Business, R/o: 301, Hyma SurajyaResidency, Balaji Nagar, Siripuram,Visakhapatnam.

13) M/S. Mrc Infrastructure privateLimited (Formerly M/s. MRCConstructions & Contractors privateLimited), a company incorporatedunder companies Act 1956, havingits office at Flat No.205, MetroResidency, Rajbhavan Road,Hyderabad-S0O 082, Represented byits Director: SRI. K. RAMBABUS/O,LATE, K. SADASIVA RAO, Agedabout 61 years, Occupation:Business, R/o; Flat No.205, MetroResidency, Rajbhavan Road,Hyderabad.Limited (Formerly M/s. MRCConstructions & Contractors privateLimited), a company incorporatedunder companies Act 1956, havingits office at Flat No.205, MetroResidency, Rajbhavan Road,Hyderabad-S0O 082, Represented byits Director: SRI. K. RAMBABUS/O,LATE, K. SADASIVA RAO, Agedabout 61 years, Occupation:Business, R/o; Flat No.205, MetroResidency, Rajbhavan Road,Hyderabad.

And

1) The State of TelanganaRep. by its Principal Secretary,Municipal AdministrationAnd Urban Development Department,Secetariat,Hydera bad-500063Rep. by its Principal Secretary,Municipal AdministrationAnd Urban Development Department,Secetariat,Hydera bad-500063

Page 2 of 6

2) Chief Commissioner of LandAdministration, Opp.Annapurna Hotel,Nampally Station Road, Hyderabad-500001.Administration, Opp.Annapurna Hotel,Nampally Station Road, Hyderabad-500001.

3) Peddamberpet MunicipalityRepresented by Its CommissionerPeddaAmberpet,Ranga Reddy District.501505Represented by Its CommissionerPeddaAmberpet,Ranga Reddy District.501505

a) M/s. S R R INFRA PROJECTS LIMiTED, Acompany Incorporated under companies Act1956, having it's Office at 5-4-L25/7, SamaComplex, Near Sushma Theatre,Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad-500070,Represented by it's Managing Director: SRLSAI\4A RANGA REDDY, S/A, LATE S.SRISAILAM REDDY, aged about 48 years,Occupation: Buslness, R/o. H.No. 4-13-262/ [263, ][HUDA ]Sainagar, Vanasthalipuram,Hyderabad - 500070.company Incorporated under companies Act1956, having it's Office at 5-4-L25/7, SamaComplex, Near Sushma Theatre,Vanasthalipuram, Hyderabad-500070,Represented by it's Managing Director: SRLSAI\4A RANGA REDDY, S/A, LATE S.SRISAILAM REDDY, aged about 48 years,Occupation: Buslness, R/o. H.No. 4-13-262/ [263, ][HUDA ]Sainagar, Vanasthalipuram,Hyderabad - 500070.

...PETITIONERS/'-

iI

b

5) M. K. Durgaprasad

S/o. Not Known, Aged about : MajorR/o. H.No. 4-1/2671268, [ptot ]No.267(p) and 268(p),Sadasiva Heavens Layout, Pedda Amberpet Village,Abdulllapurmet Mandal, Ragareddy District-50 1 505PTIN : 1176010983

...RESPONDENTS

Page 3 of 6

Petition under Article 226 0f the constitution of lndia praying that in thecircumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased torssue a writ order or direction more particurarry one in the nature of writ of \lvandamus to declare the action of the Respondent No.3 in issurng the special NoticeNo 1176004854 and assessment No.1176010983 dated 0B/1 1/2017 with regard toassessment of property tax for H.No.4- 1-267 1268 bearing prot No. 267(p) and 268(p),admeasuring 267 Sq. Yards in survey No.320,326 to 333 and 33s situated at peddaAmberpet Village and Municrparity, Hayathnagar t\,4andar, Ranga Reddy District in thename of Respondent No.5 as ilegar and Void and consequenfly to set aside theProceeding No.1176004854 and assessment No..1 .r 760.r09g3 dated o}r11r2o17issued with regard to assessment of property tax rerating to Respondent No.5 inrespect H.No.4-1-26il268 bearing prot No. 267(p) and 26B(p), admeasuring 267sq Yard in Survey No.320, 326 to 333 and 335 situated at pedda Amberpet viilageand lviunicipality, Hayathnagar tvlandal, Ranga Reddy District.lA NO; 1 OF 2020

Petition under Section i 51 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated in theaffidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be preased to suspend thespecial Notice No.1'1 76004854 and assessment No.11760.10983 dated 0811112017special Notice No.1'1 76004854 and assessment No.11760.10983 dated 0811112017issued with regard to assessment of property tax rerating to Respondent No.S inrespect H.No.4-1-2671268 bearing prot No. 267(p) and 268(p), admeasuring 267 sq.Yards in Survey No 320,326 to 333 and 335 situated at pedda Amberpet Vi age andlr/unicipality, Hayathnagar Ir,4andar, Ranga Reddy District, pending disposar of theabove writ petition.respect H.No.4-1-2671268 bearing prot No. 267(p) and 268(p), admeasuring 267 sq.Yards in Survey No 320,326 to 333 and 335 situated at pedda Amberpet Vi age andlr/unicipality, Hayathnagar Ir,4andar, Ranga Reddy District, pending disposar of theabove writ petition.

Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. SRINIVAS VELAGAPUDI

Counsel for the Respondent No.1: cp FOR MCPL ADMN URBAN DEVCounsel for the Respondent No.2: Gp FOR REVENUE

Counsel for the Respondent No. 3. SRI N. PR,AVEEN KUMAR

SC FOR MUNICIPALITIES

Page 4 of 6

Counsel for the Respondent No. 4 & 5: NONE APPEARED

The Cou( at the stage of admission made the following: ORDER

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE A.ABHISHEK REDDY

WRIT PE'TITION No.245L6 of 2O2O

ORDER:

llearc.l the 1c:rrned r:ounsol for thc petitjoners, thc lr:arne<iCovcrnmenr Irleader lor Municipal Administration ancl UrbanDevelopment, and the learned Standing Counsel lor Munrcipalitieslor the ofllcial rcspondents. With their corlsent, tl-re Writ Petition isdisposed of at the stage of admission.

'l'I.rrs u-rit pcrltion js liled qLtcstioning tllc assessmcnt ofprollcl t\ Lax rnacle bl rcspondcnt \o.3 il tltc narre oi the nnoflicialprollcl t\ Lax rnacle bl rcspondcnt \o.3 il tltc narre oi the nnoflicial:r:sporrcicnls lrc:'ciit irr rL-spcct ol' lho sLtltjec'. liinds, l.jtlrourr),rr:orrsidi:r'ltg the r-(,lllt.scnltltlr)n nt;tclc ltl. tltc lf(ttlirrlrcrs r),rr:orrsidi:r'ltg the r-(,lllt.scnltltlr)n nt;tclc ltl. tltc lf(ttlirrlrcrs 0!-l i2.2020. irs iLlcq.rl iLnrl r.irbrLi-an.

'l'ir: lc trncci cor.tnsct iil iitc pctitiolcr.s sLirLcs lhat tll(,ll(llltiorlcrs rnadc a rLpt( \r-nL.il \ l| r( spundc]ltl No.3 o1t09.12.2020 rcqucsling to canccl rho i1lcg:rl assosslr'rcnt ol propcrt)tax madc in rcspect of rhe subject lands, u,hich arc osned bl thepctitioners. Hor.l.cver, no ordcrs are passed thereon till date.llcncc, he seeks a dircr:Lron to ri:spondenr No.3 to dispose of rhcrepresenlation of the pctllioners, :1t llle earliest.

Page 5 of 6

'I'ho Iearncd Sr-itncltng Counse 1, on instrLrctions. starlcs th:rtLhl r-r'prcserrr:rtion rn:rr1r: lt.,- thc pc:tilioncrs ,,r.iil bc r:onsiclrrccl tutcllr'i lsr-,i:I1'\ or-dr:r:s l ill ltit ltussc,ri. :tir'tattl\ il lri.(.or-aiain(.(, 1 iLh iarl Iri vicl ol'thr: a'oor,c mackr subrnissiot'ts. tltc \\ir.ii Pctitio;-t isrlrspi.,scrl o1'clilcr:tir-rg thir 3 [rl ]rcsp,-ridont ['l'l-r ]c Cont rnissiolicr. PccldiL\r.nir:rpct \Iur.ricipiLlit.r'. Lo ciisposr, oi Lhc lcltrcser.:l:,rrior'r submrLteciI'rv iher 1rctitionels on 09.1,1.20:20 anil p:rss ncc:cssan orders thereon, stricliy [in ][accordance ][wrth ][la$r, ][as ][expeditiousll' ][as]possible, preferably $'ithin [a period of ][four ][u'eeks ][from the ][date ][ol]recerpt of a copy of [this ][order. ][Il ][rs ][needless ][to mention ][that ][belorc]passing an1' orders, the [petitior-rers ][as u'ell ][as ][thr: ][unollicial]respondents sh:rll [be ][put ][on notice ][ancl ][affordcd an opportl-rnitJ ol]hcziring. A copl' ol [lhe ][ordcr ][passed ][bv ][rcsponclt:nt ][No'3 shall ][be], olnmLlni..l'( d ',, tll. pntiti66, 1t Thc tnisr:cllancous ltcLlliorls llctlclil'tg. [il ][:Ltlr. ][sl'ral1 ][st:rrlcl]c:loscd. Thr:re shall be no ordcr [as ][to ][costs]

SD/.N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAOASSISTANT REGISTRAR//TRUE COPY//€oSEGTION OFFICER

To,

1The Commissioner, Peddamberpet tVunicipality, Ranga Reddy [District.501 ]5052One CC to Sri Srinivas Velagapudi, Advocate IOPUCI3Two CCs to GP for lVlunicipal Administration and Urban Department, High Courtfor the State of Telangana. [OUT]for the State of Telangana. [OUT]4One CC to Sri N. Praveen Kumar, SC for l\/lun icipalities IOPUC]5Two CD Copies5Two CD Copies CD CopiesV

CHR

HIGH COURT

DATED:31 [11212020]

ORDERWP.No.24516 [of ][2020]

DISPOSING [OF ][THE WP]AT THE STAGE [OF ][ADMISSION]WITHOUT COSTS

'I tl[E ][SIa]IgoiJ1t JAN 2021'!.i!'.'1r*

ULl)mr/l

Page 6 of 6

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead