WP/4619/2020 of Durgam Shankai Vs The Union of India and 8 others on 31 December 2021

HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE

STATE(sd";; a,[i?:,:',:,t],:f]$, [Ar ][HYDERABAo]

FRIDAY, THE THIRTY

,wo rHoude,rS Xil ?fi,".ii,p5cEMBER

PRESENT

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI

WR|T PET|TTON NO: 4619 OF 2020

Between:I6$p"#f:*iifri.l##Ji*iitfn#dfi Hr*u3j...,"mir[riiANO... PETITIONER1. The Unron of India, l\,4rnistrarea, centrar sJc-r;i;;;i:,{"";B""1,l,,Tsino,"l secrerary, Ra,pathf8Jr'i""jpar 2. The^Joint Brpartite Commrnilh:#.,llo,1ll;;$$*Lf{,J,y#[3,:.J7"[iix:?.t:? [j,{u,,"*,"*"]3. The C_oal Mines provident tLrne, Dhanbad, lnarf<franO-=At4dOSrganization, [Rep, ]by [jts ]Commissioner, policeI4. The A,4eqcal Councit of IndiiDwa rra [p ]n a se -t 6";l;ii ?: 33Si3lr,ti!,ii,"il:_rBi?r??l#?ndir Road' I[*[ff!::i]lEX:ffi[r"x.il hf["ri":,-&jy [its ]chairman and r\,4anasins6. The Director (pA & W). TheKothagudem, Khammbm Limited (sccL),D,j,J[?.""'' [collieries companv ]' iH8ff f i-,Y8! iB";Jil,i::,P1,fl":'I" x a nd cS R rh e s insa ren i co r r ieriessins5renl B;;;;; [t;;;;!d;rrare ][vvrns' ][corporate ][ee.sonreioepart,.ieni,]' L[:,Sf ?33lyf t?fl:ffilftrH'r:;eg,ffi [srnsareni ][co,ieries ]company9. The Kothagudem. Kharmmam A,4edicat Board. The Sin.,arenj Drsrrrct, xep. Co ieries by the Chief Company [r/edicat Officer.Limited (SCCL),...RESPONDENTS

Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in thecircumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High court may be preased tocircumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High court may be preased toissue an order or direction, more particurarry one in the nature of writ of A,4andamus,decraring that the r\'4inutes of the A/edicar Board dated 03.12.2019, issued by the gthRespondent-ft,4ed ica I Board of the Sth Respondenlcompany, communicated videRespondent-ft,4ed ica I Board of the Sth Respondenlcompany, communicated videProceedings in Ref. No. S Rp/pER/i 8-002/8091 , dated 20.i2.201g of the BthRespondent' in so far as staring that the petitioner disabres to perform his dutiesregularly and efficienfly, having regard to the nature of disability he was suffering andcategorized under Clause No. (ii) of g.4.0 of National Coal Wage Agreement-Vl, asillegal, arbitrary, contrary to the earlier cerfl{icate under Form-REF-4 issued under thecategorized under Clause No. (ii) of g.4.0 of National Coal Wage Agreement-Vl, asillegal, arbitrary, contrary to the earlier cerfl{icate under Form-REF-4 issued under the L

Coal [Mines Provident Fund ][Scheme' 1963' ][contrary ][to the ][policy ][under ][the ][Mines]Act, [1 ][952 and ][its ][Rules' ][t ][9S5' violative ][of ][the ][National Coal Wages ][Agreement']violative [Of ][principles ][of ][natural ][iustice and ][violative ][of ][Articles ][14' ][16 and 21 of ][the]and [set aside ][the same' ][by holding ][that ][the]Act, [1 ][952 and ][its ][Rules' ][t ][9S5' violative ][of ][the ][National Coal Wages ][Agreement']violative [Of ][principles ][of ][natural ][iustice and ][violative ][of ][Articles ][14' ][16 and 21 of ][the]and [set aside ][the same' ][by holding ][that ][the]Constitution [o{ ][lndia and ]'ntonttitution'l 'ntonttitution'l petitioner [is ][medically invalidated under Clause ][(i) ][of ][NCWA-Vl ][of ][9 ][4'0 ][of the ][2nd]respondent [by ][providing employment ][to ][the ][petitioner's ][son ][in ][the ][sth ][Respondent-]Company [as per clause ][(i) ][ot ][g + ][O ][and further ][to ][pay all ][the ][statutory benefits ][under]the I\,'lines [Act, ][1952 and its ][Rules' ][1955 ][with ][all ][consequential benefits]respondent [by ][providing employment ][to ][the ][petitioner's ][son ][in ][the ][sth ][Respondent-]Company [as per clause ][(i) ][ot ][g + ][O ][and further ][to ][pay all ][the ][statutory benefits ][under]the I\,'lines [Act, ][1952 and its ][Rules' ][1955 ][with ][all ][consequential benefits]

lA NO: [1 ][OF 2020]

lA NO: [1 ][OF 2020]

Petition [under section ][151 ][cPC ][pravins ][lhli" f:-:ll';J;I3::fi ]if::il [ll:],r,a""i'iii"i [in'.i'opo,.t ][ot ][tn".n":''#.y:rlitJ;ff[H"fi ][iuniXeji"e-,orrs ][or tne]T,"^'H::;::i:#"1J?*1i:: [ol;";:;;;;i;vl':ent ][to tne ][petitioners ][son ][pend ][ns]lisposat [ot the above ][Writ ][Petition']

lA NOio200

s stated [in the]Petition [under ][Section ][1 ][51 ][CPC ][praying ][that in ][the ][circlmstance]d to [direct ][the]affidavit filed [in ][support ][ot ][tne ][peiiion.'tne ][Hlgn Court,may ][be ][please]other [terminal]Resoondents [5 ][to ][B ][to ][p'v ][u"ii"'Ji'tutory ][o"ene{its ][like graluitv ][and]der the [N,lines]k^^-ritc in.lusive of Coal [fr,lrnes ][piovlOeni Fund ][to ][the ][pelitioner ][un]-disposat or the above writ petitionllil=l'Jir ffi;t IA NO 30[ F ][2020]

PetitionunderSectlon,l5lCPCprayingthatintheclrcumstancesstatedintheaffidavit [filed ][in support ][ot ][tn" ][o"iitlJn'intj ][ilgn ][court- ][may ][be ][pleased ][to ][direct ][the]sth N,4edical RespondenLCom Board [in ][respect ][pany ][to ]'' [t""J''ff ]'in3 [' ]pliit""i-n"'Lin [in" ][Ir'feoilat Certificates of the ],to the 2nd [gth ]respondent [Respondent ][for][-]adiudicating [whether ][the ]"u'" [oi'ii" ][i"ilii"^"|. ][fatls..under ][category ][(i) or ][(i') ][of ][9 ][4'0];i'i;';i;-;I, ;e;dins [disposal ][o{ ][the ][above ][writ ][petition]

IAN10?0,|

Petition under [Section ][151 ][CPC praying ][th-at ][in ][the ][circumstances stated in the]affidavit [filed in ][support ][ot ][tn" ][p"tiion, In"'Hign ][Court may.be ][pleased ][to ][amend ][and]substitute [cause ][title ][in ][r"tp"-"i'oi ]['tne ][2n"d respondent. ][as ]["The ][Joint ][Bipartite]Committee [for ][the Coal ][rnousiry, ][kottattr, ][Rep. ][by its ][l\,4ember ][Secretary, ][Under]National Coal [Wages Agreeme'ii, ][+ ][Coar Bhavan' ][New.Town' ][Rajarhat' ][Kolkata']w?., ri""g"lzoot [50, ][insieao ][oJ ][in" ][Lolnt Bipartite Committee for ][the ][coal ][lndustry']Agreement' [# ][Coal]Kolkatta, [Rep. by ][its prt. secretaiy, ][Under ][National ]-C^o^'ly,:s"t Bhavan. New [Town. ][Rajarhat. Kolkata, West ][Bengal-/uu15b ][']

Counsel for [the Petitioner: ][SRI ][Ch ][VENKAT ][RAMAN]

Counsel for [the ][Respondent ][Nos.1 ][to ][3: SRI ][K'ARVIND ][KUMAR]

Counsel for the [Respondent No.4: ][Smt.G.POOJITHA, ][SC]

counsel for the Respondent Nos.5 to 9: ADDL.ADVOCATE GENERAL on behalf ofSRI J.SREENIVASA RAO, SC for Singareni Colleries The Court made the following: ORDER

FION'BI,E SRI JLTSTICE ABFIINAND KIJMAR SHAVILI

w.P.N o,4 6-19 of20

a&DE&

When the matter is taken up for hearing, learned counsel oncither side fairly conceded that the issue involved in this writpetidon is squarely covered by the order datetl 07.l2.2[2lpassed byup for hearing, learned counsel oncither side fairly conceded that the issue involved in this writpetidon is squarely covered by the order datetl 07.l2.2[2lpassed bythis Court in \V.p.No.5455 of 2020_

Fnllowing the order dated 07 .12.2021.in W.p.No.5455 of 2020,and for reasons alike, this Wrir pcrition is also disposed of. NoCOS tSPcnding miscellaneous petitions, if ani,, shall stand closed.

SD/.N.CHANDRA SEKHAR RAOASSISTANT REGISTRAR,TRUE COPY'C,,To,SECTION OFFICERThe Pri'rc,pa.t Secrera.y. Ulton of lnora. l\,4rnist.y of Laoour. Rajpatn Area, Cenrrarsecrelar:al, New Delhi Detlr_1 t0O0t .2Narronar lne Pr'.Sec.etarV codt waoes Jo;nt B.oartitc Commrltee Ao.ee.re"r -coa, aniuan. for lhe Coat lnduslry, Kot(arta, r,ti*"i"",n11]"n]"'jJ;,ili x"rkara, UloerweslBengal-700156. [- ]3Jharkhand-826001The Commissioner. Coal l\4ines Provideni Fund Organizallon, police Llne, Dhanbad,4 The President, Medical Council oJ lndia, Dada Dev l\,4andir Road Dwarka, phase -_ [1, ][Pocket ][14, ][Sector 8 Dwarka, New ]oritni--r tooii ['-'-" ][''""]5 The Chairman and t\,4anaoing Olrectol Singar;ni Co ieries Company Limjted, SingareniBhavan, Red H,lls, Hvoer6OjO.6 The Director {PA & W), The Srngareri Collieries Company Li4rrted (SCCL).Kothaqudem, Khammam District7 Limrted The General Manaoe. IPersonngl), Wellare and CSR, Singarenj (SCcL), w;tfaie Wrng, cciiporaie Fers6,r-"-elbJpu'rir""nt singaieni CoJlieries CompdnyBhi;;,Hyderabad.8. The General l\,4anaoer Srirampur Area, The Singarent Coflieries Company Limired(SCCL). SrirampurJlOiraOaO OrsrriCt. [-]9. Tt,e _Chief Medicat Officer, Medicat Board, The Singareni Coltieries Company Limited(SCCL), Kothaqudem, Khammam Districr10. One CC lo SRt Ch.VENKAT RAIVIAN. Advocate IOptJCt1 ['1. ]One CC to SRt K.ARV|ND KUMAR. Advocate rOpUCr12. One CC lo Smr.G.POOJ|THA. SC fOpUCt14. 13. Two C.D. One CC to SRt J.SREENIVASA RAO, Copies.So'for Sjngareni Co eries IOPUC]15. One Spare Copy.MRCrR a-'-s I

DATEOt31l1212021

ORDERWP.No.4619 [of ][2020]

DISPOSING [OF THE ][WRIT ][PETITION]WITHOUT COSTS

{[tu]

.t/i"^'I/-)1 I [APB ][?thrj]ti?,