Telangana High Court
WP/11655/2020 of Dande Srinivasa Rao Vs The State of Telangana and 4 Others on 30 December 2021
THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Originat Jurisdiction) THURSDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF DECEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE PRESENT THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE SHAMEEM AKTHER IT PETITIO O:116 F 2020 Between: 1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Prj. Secretarv, Department of
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD(Special Originat Jurisdiction)
THURSDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF DECEMBERTWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE DR. JUSTICE SHAMEEM AKTHER
IT PETITIOO:116F 2020
Between:
Dande. SrinivasaRao, S/o D. Rama Chander, aged about 45 years, Occ: Business,R/o H.No.3-1-9, Baghameer, Kukatpaily, Hyder;bad-500072.'
...PET|T|ONER
AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Prj. Secretarv, Department of Munjcioal-Olo Administration, Government of Telangana State, dt Secretariat office,Government of Telangana State, Telangana State, HyderabadAdministration, Government of Telangana State, dt Secretariat office,Government of Telangana State, Telangana State, Hyderabad Government of Telangana State, Telangana State, Hyderabad2 If_e. -G-re-a!-gr Hyderab6d Nrlunicipal Corporation, rep. by its commissioner, O/o atGHIt4C Office, Near Tank Bund, Hyderabad-500029GHIt4C Office, Near Tank Bund, Hyderabad-500029
3. The Greater Hyderabad Municipal-Corporation, rep. by its Zonal Commissioner,[y!g!p^ally [Zone, Olo ][at ][Janatha Nagar, IVoosapei, Kdkatpaily, Hyderabad-]500072[y!g!p^ally [Zone, Olo ][at ][Janatha Nagar, IVoosapei, Kdkatpaily, Hyderabad-]500072
4. The Greater Hyderabad [t,4unicipal Corporation, rep.by its Deputy commissioner,[y!g!p^atly [ctcle-24, ][O/o ][at ][Janatha Nagar, l\/oosapei, ][Xut<atply, ][Hyderabad-]500072[y!g!p^atly [ctcle-24, ][O/o ][at ][Janatha Nagar, l\/oosapei, ][Xut<atply, ][Hyderabad-]500072
5. Smt Danda Pramila, W/o D. Upender Reddy, aged about 58 Vears,Occ:Housewife, Rio Plot No.272A,2834, inSv.-No. 196. Addioutta co-ooerativesociety, Ku katpa lly, Ku katpa lly circte, G H Ir/C, ir/ed chal [r/a tkajg"i ri District'Occ:Housewife, Rio Plot No.272A,2834, inSv.-No. 196. Addioutta co-ooerativesociety, Ku katpa lly, Ku katpa lly circte, G H Ir/C, ir/ed chal [r/a tkajg"i ri District'
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in thecircumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased toissue writ, or writs order or orders more particularly in the nature of mandamusthereby declaring the inaction of the Respondents No.'1 to 4 herein on therepresentations , dt.O410612020 and 1510612020 made by the Petitioner, as illegal,arbitrary and against the principles of Municipalities Act and consequen y directing totake an appropriate legal action against the illegal and unlawful construction raising incellar [+ ]stilt + 5 upper floors in and over Plot No.272A, 2834 on a land admeasuringtake an appropriate legal action against the illegal and unlawful construction raising incellar [+ ]stilt + 5 upper floors in and over Plot No.272A, 2834 on a land admeasuring800 Sq.Yards approximately in Sy.No.196, situated at Addagutta co-operativesociety, Kukatpally, Kukatpally circle, GHMC, Medchal Malkajgiri District by therespondent No.5.society, Kukatpally, Kukatpally circle, GHMC, Medchal Malkajgiri District by therespondent No.5.
lA NO: 1 OF 2020
Petition under Section 151 cPc praying that in the circumstances stated in theaffidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct theRespondents No.'1 to 4 herein to stop further illegal and unlawful construction raisingin cellar + stilt + 5 upper floors in and over Plot No.272A, 283A on a land admeasuring 800 Sq.Yards approximately in Sy.No.196, situated at Addagutta co-operative society, Kukatpally, Kukatpally circle, GHMC, Medchal Malkajgiri District,making by the Respondents No.5 herein.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. PUSHADAPU SUBBA RAO
Counsel forthe Respondent No.1:GP FOR MUNICIPAL ADMINISTRATION AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to 4: SRI SAMPATH PRABHAKAR REDDY,SC FOR GHMC
Counsel for the Respondent No.s: NONE APPEARED
The Court made the following: ORDER
THE HON'BLE DT. JUSTICE [SHAMEEM ][AKTHER]
o20
WRIT PETITIoN [No.1][655 ][0F]
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
ORDER
This Writ Petition, under [Article ][226 ][of the ][Constitution ][of]India, is filed by the [petitioner, wherein ][the ][following ][prayer ][is]made:
"... to issue Writ, [or ][Writs ][Order ][or ][Orders ][more]particularly in the nature of [mandamus ][thereby ][declaring]the inaction of the Respondents [No.1 ][to ][4 ][herein on ][the]rep rese ntations, [dt.04-06-2020 and 15-06-2020 ][made ][by]the Petitioner, as [illegal, ][arbitrary ][and ][against ][the]principles of Municipalities Act [and consequently directing]to take an appropriate [legal action against ][the ][illegal ][and]unlawful construction [ralsing ][in ][cellar ][+ ][stilt ][+ ][5 ][upper]floors in and over [Plot ][No.272A, ][2834 ][on ][a ][land]admeasuring 800 Sq, [Yards ][approximately ][in ][Sy No'196,]situated at Addagutta [co-operatlve ][society, ][Kukatpally,]Kukatpally circle, [GHMC, ][Medchal ][Malkajgiri ][District ][by]the respondent [No.5, and ][to ][pass ][such ][other order ][or]orders ..."particularly in the nature of [mandamus ][thereby ][declaring]the inaction of the Respondents [No.1 ][to ][4 ][herein on ][the]rep rese ntations, [dt.04-06-2020 and 15-06-2020 ][made ][by]the Petitioner, as [illegal, ][arbitrary ][and ][against ][the]principles of Municipalities Act [and consequently directing]to take an appropriate [legal action against ][the ][illegal ][and]unlawful construction [ralsing ][in ][cellar ][+ ][stilt ][+ ][5 ][upper]floors in and over [Plot ][No.272A, ][2834 ][on ][a ][land]admeasuring 800 Sq, [Yards ][approximately ][in ][Sy No'196,]situated at Addagutta [co-operatlve ][society, ][Kukatpally,]Kukatpally circle, [GHMC, ][Medchal ][Malkajgiri ][District ][by]the respondent [No.5, and ][to ][pass ][such ][other order ][or]orders ..."
2. Heard the learned [counsel ][for ][the ][petitioner; ][Sri ][Sampath]Prabhakar ReddY, [learned Standing ][Counsel ][for ][GHMC, appearing]for respondent [Nos'2 ][to ][4 and ][perused ][the ][record']
3. Having submitted [for ][a considerable ][time, ][learned ][counsel ][for]thepetitionerintendStoWithdraWtheWritPetitionunconditionally"
4. Learned Standing [Counsel ][appearing ][for ][GHMC ][would submit]that the respondent-corporation [has verified ][the ][constructions]raised by the unofficial [respondent ][No'5' ][They ][were ][in ][tune ][with]the [permission ][granted' ][There ][are ][no ][violations ][of the ][building]
permitandproperSetbaCkSwereleft.ThepresentWritPetitionisfiled on false allegations.
5. Learned Standing Counsel [has ][drawn ][the ][attention ][of ][the]Court to [paragraph ][No.2 ][of the ][writ ][affidavit ][to ][demonstrate ][the]manner in which the [present ][Writ ][Petition ][is ][drafted.]
Paragraph No.2 of the writ affidavit [reads as ][follows:]
6
"2. I submit that I am [doing ][Business ][in ][and ][around]Kukatpally. I reliably came to [know ][that the ][respondent]No.5 is raising structures [illegally ][and unlawfully without ][any]valid permission, without leaving [any ][required setbacks ][in]and over Plot No.272A, 283A [on ]a [land ][admeasuring ][800]Sq.Yards approximately in Sy.No,196, [situated ][at ][Addagutta]co-operative society, Kukatpally, [Kukatpally ][circle, ][GHMC]which is our tocality, I am residing [same locality and also I]am travelling in front of the said construction [on my ][day to]day affairs. Immediately I brought to the [notice ][of ][the]concerned authorities. But the authorities [concerned ][simply]stated that the Respondent No.5 obtained [building]construction permit No.37651/HO/\NZICir-14/2074dt.03-11-2014 from the office of GHN4C valld [from]02-05-2016 to 02-11-2017 in respect of the [said ][property."]
7. In the instant case, the [petitioner ][has ][stated ]that [on ][reliable]information he [. ]came to know that respondent No.5 has [raised]structures in the subject [premises ]illegally, [unlawfully and without]any valid [permission. ]This mention [is ][without direct ][knowledge of]the petitioner and without verification of the facts. It [is ][contrary ][to]the material facts i.e., respondent No.5 has [permission ]to [make]construction in the subject [premises ]and the structures [raised ][are]in tune with the permission [granted ]in her favour. Under these circumstances, this [Writ ][Petition ][is ][liable ][to ][be ][dismlssed ][as]withdrawn with costs.
B. Accordingly, the Writ [Petition ][is ][dismissed ][as ][withdrawn' ][The]petitioner is directed to [pay ][costs ][of ][Rs.25,000/- ][(Rupees ][twenty]five thousand only) [to ][the ][Secretary, High ][Court ][Legal ][Services]Committee, [Telangana, ][within ][a ][period ][of ][thirty ][(30) ][days ][from ][the]date of this order. [If ][the ][said amount ][is not ][paid ][within the ][time]stipulated above, the [High Court ][Legal ][Services ][Committee']is entitled [to ][recover ][the ][same, ][in ][accordance ][with ][law']Telangana, Miscellaneous [Petitions, ][if ][any, ][pending ][in this Writ ][Petition]shall stand closed "w.P. No[.38][941][ of ][20 15]Rs. Ps.lffi *m3'"*':**iyr**4.+i;#f 25,000 [[- ][00]][[00]]
25,000 [[- ][00]][[00]]25,000 [- 00]
TOTAL
sD/-MoHus4NtHitJ+tr\tAHsEcTloN [(""'*]
//TRUE [COPY//]
" ffi [:: ][:il;]i ffi [i,*:* ][i,ri$rnux'ffrug+11',',+fu: ]
CHRNPJW,/
A
HIGH COURT
DATED:3011212021
ORDERW.P.No.11655 of [2020]
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITIONAS WITHDRAWNWITH COSTS
1t{cSIAft:kf,oo02 [tEB ][2022]e)*+