Telangana High Court
WP/36949/2024 of M/s. Thirumala Traders Vs State of Telangana on 31 December 2024
THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (SPecial Original Jurisdiction) TUESDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI WRIT PETITION NO: 36949 OF 2024 AND 1 Between:
HIGH COURT FOR THE [STATE ][OF ][TELANGANA AT ][HYDERABAD](SPecial Original Jurisdiction)
TUESDAY, THE THIRTY [FIRST ][DAY ][OF DECEMBER]TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY [FOUR]
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT [JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI]
WRIT PETITION NO[: ][36949 ][OF 2024]
Between:
1.M/s.ThirumalaTraders,AProprietorshipFirmhavingitsofficeat-1-488'' iiriutaniilp"i- Roao,- ttirsampet, Wararigal Rural, Telangana - 506132RepresenteO by its Proprietor [Ms. Sugunamma Vutukurl]iiriutaniilp"i- Roao,- ttirsampet, Wararigal Rural, Telangana - 506132RepresenteO by its Proprietor [Ms. Sugunamma Vutukurl]
2. Sugunamma Vutukuri, [W/o. ][S-utta ][Rao,.Aged ][about ][64 ][y"*9, ]9:9 [Brsiness']R/o. H-trto. 6-32, Mandalam, [Khanapur, Warangal'.1 elangana ][- ][cuo ][lrz]. ...PETITIONERSR/o. H-trto. 6-32, Mandalam, [Khanapur, Warangal'.1 elangana ][- ][cuo ][lrz]. ...PETITIONERS
AND
1State of Telangana, [Rep. by ][its ][Principal Secretary, Department of Consumer]Aiii-'n, foodJinO [Civit'Srpptl.s, ][Secietariat Buildings, Hvderabad']Aiii-'n, foodJinO [Civit'Srpptl.s, ][Secietariat Buildings, Hvderabad']
2. Telangana State Civil [Supplies ][Corporation ][Limited' Having,its,Ig9-lt]:l1d]office Zt [_3-655/1iA, Block-B ][Civil ][Supplies ][Bhavar, ][Somajiguda, Hyqeraoao-]500082 Rep. by [its ][Vice Chairman and Managing Director]office Zt [_3-655/1iA, Block-B ][Civil ][Supplies ][Bhavar, ][Somajiguda, Hyqeraoao-]500082 Rep. by [its ][Vice Chairman and Managing Director]
3.ViceChairpersonandManagingDiro'ctolTelanganaStateCivilSu.pplies-' iorooiatiori Limited -3-055/t/4, 6lock-B Civil Supflies Bhavan, Somajiguda,Hyderabad-500082, [Telangana.]iorooiatiori Limited -3-055/t/4, 6lock-B Civil Supflies Bhavan, Somajiguda,Hyderabad-500082, [Telangana.]
4. District Collector, [Warangal ][District.]
5. Collector, CS [Warangal ][District.]
6. District Civil Supply [Officer, Warangal ][District.]
7. District Manager, [TSCSCL Warangal ][District.]
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article [226 ][of ][the constitution ][of ][lndia ][praying ][that ][in ][the]circumstances [stated ][in ][the ][affidavit ][filed ][therewith, ][the ][High ][court ][may ][be]pleased to issue an appropriate [writ, order ][or ][direction. ][more particularly ][one ][in]the nature of writ of [Mandamus]
.
declaring the actions of the Respondents in not lifting paddy allocatedto the Petitioners for Crop Year Rabi 2022-23 in furtherance of GlobalE- Tender daled 2510112024 on as is where is' basis as being ifiegal,to the Petitioners for Crop Year Rabi 2022-23 in furtherance of GlobalE- Tender daled 2510112024 on as is where is' basis as being ifiegal,arbitrary, unjust, apart from being unconstitutional and contrary todoctrine of legitimate expectation and forthwith direct the Respondentsto lift the Rabi 2022-23 season paddy from the Petitioner rice mill into lift the Rabi 2022-23 season paddy from the Petitioner rice mill infurtherance of Global E-Tender dated 2510112024 on as is where isbasis.basis.
Alternatively, n the event of non-grant of prayer (i) this Hon,ble Courtmaybe pleased to direct the Respondents to grant the petitioners thefirst right to payment to the Respondents the equivalent tender amountas quoted by the Successful Auction Purchaser i.e., gth Respondentwith respect to Petitioners CMR paddy as per. the tender conditionsstipulated under Global E- Tender daled 2SlO1t2O24.first right to payment to the Respondents the equivalent tender amountas quoted by the Successful Auction Purchaser i.e., gth Respondentwith respect to Petitioners CMR paddy as per. the tender conditionsstipulated under Global E- Tender daled 2SlO1t2O24.
lA NO: 1 OF 2024
Petition under Section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances statedin the affidavit filed in sr:pport of the petition, the High court may be pleased todirect the Respondents to forthwith commence the.lifting of paddy lying at thePetitioner Rice Mill pe(aining to crop year Rabi 2022-2023 in terms of Global E-Tender dated 2510112024 on as is where is basis, pending disposal of thepresent Writ Petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI PASHAM MOHITH
Counsel for the Respondent No.1, 4, 5 & 6: Gp FOR CtVtL SUPPLIES
Counsel for the Respondent No.2, 3 & 7: SRI T.P.ACHARYA, SC FOR TSCSCL
The Gourt made the following: ORDER
THE HONOURABLE [SMT. JUSTICE ][T. ][MADHAVI ][DEVI]II'RIT PETITION [No.3694][9 ][of2024]
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
ORDER:
Heard learned [counsel ][for the ][petitioners, ][Iearned]
Government [Pleader ][for Civil ][Supplies ][and ][Sri ][T'P'Acharya']learned Standing [Counsel ][for ][Telangana State ][Civil ][Supplies]Limited [for the ][respondents ][and ][Perused ][the ]Corporation ,lentire material [on record.]
The main grievance main grievance grievance [[of the ][petitioners ][is that ][the]][[petitioners ][is that ][the]][[is that ][the]][[the]]
2. The main grievance main grievance grievance [[of the ][petitioners ][is that ][the]][[petitioners ][is that ][the]][[is that ][the]][[the]]respondents are not [lifting the ][CMR ][paddy ][pertaining ][to ][Crop]Year Rabi 2022-23, [from the ][possession ][of ][the petitioner's ][rice]mill and the [same ][was ][kept ][in ][auction for ][Global ][E-tender for]third parties.
3. Learned Government [Pleader ][for Civil ][Supplies ][on ][oral]instructions submitted [that ][the ][respondents ][are ][ready ][to ][lift]the paddy [lying ][in ][the ][petitioners' ][rice ][mill ][and ][seeks]sufficient time.
4. In view of the [submissions ][made ][by ][learned counsels ][on]either side, the [writ ][petition ][is ][disposed ][of ][directing ][the]to [lift ][the ][CMR ][paddy ][lying on the ][petitioner's]respondents rice mill pertaining [to ][Crop ][Year Rabi ][2022-23 ]' [within ][a]
period of twerrty (20) days from today or on rtr before20.0I.2025, whichever is earlier. There shali be no order as tocosts.
5. Miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall standclosed.
/
SD/- N. CHANDRA SEKHARASSTSTANT RK;TSTRAR ./\i ,/ASSTSTANT RK;TSTRAR ./\i ,/sEcTroN oFrrceR
//TRUE COPY//
,"11. The Principal Secretary, Department of Consumer Affairs, Foods and CivilSupplies, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad, State of Telangana.1. The Principal Secretary, Department of Consumer Affairs, Foods and CivilSupplies, Secretariat Buildings, Hyderabad, State of Telangana.
2. The Vice Chairman and Managing Director, Telangana State Civil Supplies.CivilCorporation Limited, Having its registered office at -3-655/1/A, Block-B Supplies Bhavan, Somajiguda, Hyderabad-500082.Corporation Limited, Having its registered office at -3-655/1/A, Block-B Supplies Bhavan, Somajiguda, Hyderabad-500082.
3. The Vice Chairperson and fVlanaging Director, Telangana State Civil Supplies9orporation_Limiled [-3-655/1/A, ][Block-B Civit ][Supplies ][Bhavan, Somajiguda,]Hyderabad-500082, Telangana.9orporation_Limiled [-3-655/1/A, ][Block-B Civit ][Supplies ][Bhavan, Somajiguda,]Hyderabad-500082, Telangana.
4. The District Colleclor, Warangal District.
5. The Collector, CS Warangal District.
6. The District Civil Supply Officer, Warangal District.
7. The District Manager, TSCSCL Warangal District.
B. One CC to SRI PASHAM MOHITH, Advocate IOPUCI
9. One CC to SRI T.P.ACHARYA, SC FOR TSCSCL tOpUCI
10. Two CCs to GP FOR CIVIL SUPPLIES, High Court for the Stare of Telanganaat Hyderabad [OUTIat Hyderabad [OUTI
1 1 . Two CD Copies
BSR6..
I
CC TODAY
HIGH COURT
DATED: 3111212024
1t{=-=,r, r*ri'sot--)tLlz1,.0 :1 [,. ][i ]['r'i ][?n25]I.c,.n..'i-- [r ]".
ORDER
WP.No.36949 of 2024
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION,WITHOUT COSTS
oe