Telangana High Court
WP/18470/2017 of D RAMU AND 18 OTHRS, Vs HOME PRL.SECY., HYD., AND ANOTHER, on 31 December 2021
THE S"] A ,T-H YD E JfJE DO F TE LA N GANA (Dpeciat Original Jurisdiction) FRIDAY, ,TH-E THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEMBERrwo THoUSAND AND rwer.rridiE,,,"*^ Between: PRESENT THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI WRIT PETITIO N NO:'t 8470 0F 2017 1 Daravath Ramu S/o paoulu l?^.1??
I
HIGH COURT FOR THE S"]F TE LA N GANA
A,T-H YD E JfJE DO
(Dpeciat Original Jurisdiction)DO
FRIDAY,
,TH-E [[THIRTY FIRST DAY ]]OF DECEMBER
,TH-E [[THIRTY FIRST DAY ]]OF DECEMBERrwo THoUSAND AND rwer.rridiE,,,"*^
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI
WRIT PETITIO N NO:'t 8470 0F 2017
Between:
1Daravath Ramu S/o paoulul?^.1?? [v^.:': ][occ.roat ][on ][Ho^re ][G.:ard]^,u [,.,\u._z_,u tnr.nmapJram ]Vtllage Chrvemra MardalSuryaper Drstrict e.srwh,re Na,gondi Drstriir2L. S rin iva s S/o GaneshAged 35 years OccuoationHome GuardR/o H. No.20-7196 SunithaRed dy Co,o'ry Narsaaou. V lageAnd lvlandal Medak District3M. Krshan S/o BhonsvamAged 29 years Occupation: Hone GuardMandai Mahaboob'Nagar .l [hummalakunta Thanda Village Talakondaoariv]Distict [- --r" ]'4K.Gopal S/o GopalAged 27 years Occupation: Home GuardGeedigunta Thanda, Gunded Viilage BalanagarMandal MhaboobNagar DistrictRathod Thukaram S/o MaruthrAged 25 y6ats Occupation: Home GuardKishan Nayak Thanda Village SirgapurMandal,wasar Post, SangaReddyDistrict,erstwhile tr/edak Dist,6. Sapavath Roopla S/o TholyaAged 32years Occupation: Home GuardR/o JodubaiThanda Village NereduGommalVanda I Nalgonda District7. Bhagawan Sabhawath S/o Pee yaAged 30 years Occupation: Home GuardR/o JodubaiThanda Vil age NeredugimmaMandal Nalgonda Dlstrict8. Devarai Nagaraju S/o EstariAged 29 years Occupation: Home GuardThadkamalla Village tt"4iryalagudaMandal Nalgonda DistrictL Laxman Nayak S/o ChanduAged 34 years Occupation: Home GuardVittu Nayak Thanda Village N4ogadampallylMandal SangaReddy Dlstrict, erstwhile Medak Dist.,'10Kethavath f,4ad havlat S/o GhasyaAged 25 years Occupation: Home GuardR/o Bachapuram Village Neredugum (Chandampet)lvlandal Nalgonda District.d(
petition under Arlicle 226 of the constituticrrcumstances stated in ,,,"0 ,i"r"*,*,on of India praying that in theto issue a writ, order otl"."rflo"r,, f direction r"r" Mandamus,, r;;;;J::f ;:T"ff:Tffi::;
a) declaring the press reledse of ISLpRBISLpRB
of ISLpRBISLpRBconsequentiat Press retease 2015 dt'22'04'2017, and the"r ot ;;"":"::t:1: TSLPRB 2015 dt.22-04-2017 rist of (provisionat setection10,113 ""n"t rx [;;rij:,.7H ][::l ][., ][,l,,,? ][::IIo,.'1,,,0J1i,,"-;*:m, ]"J:(civir/AR/sAR/rr.r,rrr,"',"u,""i;':; ror the post or scr pcprovisional ;JH:":"j thereby informing thatselection orders have been kept ,n .o"tuno'Y' orders made in wp (prL) ,, ," ;;;*, ;ffiffiJ;::iiI j::IIJ;of the Hon'ble High court which staying the appointment order of 1g8 Home Guardsselected in the open category, in spite'of representations of the petitioners whirehowever allowing 146 candidates, apparen,y in respective categories for training,several of whom secured less marks than the min.abevance or42 candidates, incruding the petitioners jru;::Jl,:ll ,:T:::J:of Art. 14 of the Constitution of tndia
b) and consequenfly direct the Respondents to alow/permit the petitroners topartlcipate in the 2nd phase of the Constable training program
c) and award costs to the petitioners
I,A, N10201WPPo2540F21
1Petition under Section '1 51 CPC prayjng that in the circumstances stated inthe affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be preased to directthe Respondents to ailow/permit the petitioners to participate iri the constaotetraining program presenfly being conducted pursuant to being serected to the postof scr PC (civir/AR/sARTrssp/spF/Firemen) in the ocHG category pur.suant toNotification Rc. No. 1s'1lRect./Admn.1lzo15 dt.31.i2.201s, pending disposat of thelVain Writ Petition lA NO: 1 OF 2019
Petition under section 151 cpc praying that in the circumstances stated inthe affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pteased to directthe affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pteased to directthe respondent to permit the petitioners to participate in the constable trainingprogram rn view of W.P (PlL) No. 43 & 79 al 2017 of both writ petitions aredismissed dated: 1 1-10-2018 as petitioners seleclions is kept in abeyance pendingPIL;program rn view of W.P (PlL) No. 43 & 79 al 2017 of both writ petitions aredismissed dated: 1 1-10-2018 as petitioners seleclions is kept in abeyance pendingPIL; Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI A. K. JAYAPRAKASH RAO
Counsel for Respondents: SPECIAL GOVERNMENT PLEADER FORGP FOR SERVICES I
The Court made the following: ORDER
HON'BLESRIJUSTICEABHINANDKUMARSHAVILI
SLP.No.184?0 [QF ][2017]
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
ORDER:
This writ [petidon ][is ][filed ][seeking ][the ][following ][relief:]
.to issu. a wri! [orde' or direclion ][more ][p!rliculorlt ][onc ][itr ][rhc]0f(') declarins [rhe ][Pre33 ]'tle'!e TSLPnB ",,,.1", [2015, ][*.,,, ][d112 ]'*o"us [04 ][2017 ]'nd the conseq(enti'l [Press ][rel€nee](provhional [selt'tion ][lhr ][of]o, ta"oo, [,0", ][dt ]'204201? 10,L3 [candidalB) ][puBusnl ][to lhe lorillcation ][iu]Rc.No l!l/Re.l/Admn [l/2015'dt ][31 ][1210t5 ][issud individ!all!]ro $< [petirionct's ][iotin ][who ][6r' ][all ][Ilome ][Cu!tli ][ind ][sclecred]fur ltc [polt ][ot ][SCT ][l'C ][(CiliUAT ][/SARTISSP/Sl'F/firr ][(n) ][in]rhc OCIIC [niltguA, ][IIcrtbv int!rning ][rhnr ][!)rorisi0 ][!l]\.leclio ord(n [hdre ][btcn ][lLepl ][i ]'b(v!nct [Pi^ ][rnt ][lo ][llLu], rerin,ohllrsmidcin\tl'lPtL)Uf [:io9l ][ul ?r)l-' ][L ][$Pilll ][)]tl of ?017, [dr ][lJ ][03 ][20tl ][of ][rh' ][llon ][hle ][lligh ][( ][ourl *hl(h]Lyr.g th( [iDDoinlmcnl ][oril$ ][0i ][l8E ][llonrc ][Cutr'ds ][\cLt(r'd ][in]rhe Opcn [Lartgurl, in ][slile ol ][rc0rtstnlxll0ns ot ][lh( ][p!tilion('r]ehil€ ho\tev.r sllorinS [116 ][czndidrlq\ ][rpp'*nll! ][in respt(livc]rat.go(is [for trninins, ][3ererdl of ][{hom securd ][lds ][ot'ls ][rh3 n]lhe nlninruft [culoff ][and ][k€eping ][i' ][rbevanct ][or ][42 ][clndidalos']lnrl!{lios tlte l,ctitioner! [rs ][illegrl, ][srbil rt' ][in ][viol'tion ][or]arti.l. l4 oI the [Constllulion ][of ][lndin (b) ][rnd ][coiscqucnllv]dirrct tIe [rtspondent! ][to ][illow/perEil ][llte ][pelitioncts ][t0]p(rticll,rlc in the [2'd ]Plrleotthe [Collst[ble ][irulnins ][proSr6|n ][(c)]!nd ,$nrd .o3t! to lh. !!li{daB [ind ][i' ][n'3t ][ord'r o' ][0rdet! ][!e]ttili Hontblc C'orfl tt.v [d.em ][fli ][6nd ]['proP" in ][t"€]ctrcu dsm nce3 [of lhe ][crla rnd ][In ][th. ][Intcrest ][of ][j ][uslice,"]0f(') declarins [rhe ][Pre33 ]'tle'!e TSLPnB ",,,.1", [2015, ][*.,,, ][d112 ]'*o"us [04 ][2017 ]'nd the conseq(enti'l [Press ][rel€nee](provhional [selt'tion ][lhr ][of]o, ta"oo, [,0", ][dt ]'204201? 10,L3 [candidalB) ][puBusnl ][to lhe lorillcation ][iu]Rc.No l!l/Re.l/Admn [l/2015'dt ][31 ][1210t5 ][issud individ!all!]ro $< [petirionct's ][iotin ][who ][6r' ][all ][Ilome ][Cu!tli ][ind ][sclecred]fur ltc [polt ][ot ][SCT ][l'C ][(CiliUAT ][/SARTISSP/Sl'F/firr ][(n) ][in]rhc OCIIC [niltguA, ][IIcrtbv int!rning ][rhnr ][!)rorisi0 ][!l]\.leclio ord(n [hdre ][btcn ][lLepl ][i ]'b(v!nct [Pi^ ][rnt ][lo ][llLu], rerin,ohllrsmidcin\tl'lPtL)Uf [:io9l ][ul ?r)l-' ][L ][$Pilll ][)]tl of ?017, [dr ][lJ ][03 ][20tl ][of ][rh' ][llon ][hle ][lligh ][( ][ourl *hl(h]Lyr.g th( [iDDoinlmcnl ][oril$ ][0i ][l8E ][llonrc ][Cutr'ds ][\cLt(r'd ][in]rhe Opcn [Lartgurl, in ][slile ol ][rc0rtstnlxll0ns ot ][lh( ][p!tilion('r]ehil€ ho\tev.r sllorinS [116 ][czndidrlq\ ][rpp'*nll! ][in respt(livc]rat.go(is [for trninins, ][3ererdl of ][{hom securd ][lds ][ot'ls ][rh3 n]lhe nlninruft [culoff ][and ][k€eping ][i' ][rbevanct ][or ][42 ][clndidalos']lnrl!{lios tlte l,ctitioner! [rs ][illegrl, ][srbil rt' ][in ][viol'tion ][or]arti.l. l4 oI the [Constllulion ][of ][lndin (b) ][rnd ][coiscqucnllv]dirrct tIe [rtspondent! ][to ][illow/perEil ][llte ][pelitioncts ][t0]p(rticll,rlc in the [2'd ]Plrleotthe [Collst[ble ][irulnins ][proSr6|n ][(c)]!nd ,$nrd .o3t! to lh. !!li{daB [ind ][i' ][n'3t ][ord'r o' ][0rdet! ][!e]ttili Hontblc C'orfl tt.v [d.em ][fli ][6nd ]['proP" in ][t"€]ctrcu dsm nce3 [of lhe ][crla rnd ][In ][th. ][Intcrest ][of ][j ][uslice,"]
02. Heard Sri A.KJ'.rya [Prakash ][f,ao, ][learned ][cou'Rse1]appearing for the [petitioners) ][and ][learned ][Special ][Government]Pleader appearing for the [,:esPondents.]
03. All the petitioners are worldng [as ]Home [Guards]and thevarefully eligible and qualified to be appointedasPolice Constables. While so, the respondents have issued arecruitmerrt notiflcation ort 37.72.2015. Pursuant thereto, thepetitioners have applied, participated in the selection processand 'nvere selected rrde proceedings dated 22.04.2017. Theirgrievance is that WP(PIL) Nos.43 and 79 of 2077 were filecl before the Division Br:nch and initially, the Division Benchgranted stay of selection on 1,3.03,2017 and consequently,though the petitioners were selected as Constables, theselection of the petitioners were kept in abeyance and finallyW.P.(PIL) Nos.43 and79 sf 2017 were dismissed by this Courtuide order dated 11.10.201g and hence, the cases of thepetitioners are liable to be considered for appointment to thepost of Police Constables.04. Learned counsel appearing for the peritionerssubmits that since WP (PIL) Nos.43 & 79 of 2017 wercdismissed by the Dir.ision Bench on 11.10.2018, appropriateorders be passed in the writ petition directing the respondentsto consider the cases of the petitioners for appointment to thepost of Police Constables pursuant to their provisionalselection.
05. T,earned Government Pleader aPpearing for therespondents contended that since [\X/P ][(PIL) ][Nos.43 and ][79 ][of]2017 were dismissed by Division [Bench wde ][order ][dated]L1.08.2018, the respondents [would ][consider ][the ][cases ][of ][the]petitioners and pass [appropriate orders ][in ][accordance ][with]law.
06. Having considered [the rival ][submissions made ][by]the learned counsel on [either ][side, ][this ][Court ][is of ][the ][view]
l that the apPointment [of ][the petitioners was kept ][in ][abeyance]just because of the iriterlocutoly [orders ][passed ][by ][the ][Division]Bench in \V? [(PIL) ][Nos,43 ][and79 ][of ][2017 ][and ][the same ][were]disrnissed uide ordet [dated ][11.10'2018, ][it ][is ][appropriate ][to]direct the respondents [to consider the ][cases ][of ][the ][petitioners']07, Accordingly, the Writ [Petition ][is ][disposed of]directing the respondents to consider [the ][cases ]of [the]petitioners for appointment to the post of Police Constables inaccordance with the Rules and pass appropriate orders inaccordance with law. No costs.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending shallstandclosed.
SD/.T.KRISHNA KUMARASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY'SECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principal Secretary, Home [Department, State of ][Telangana ][Secretariat]
Buildings Saifabad, Hyderabad '500 [022]
2. The Ch;irman, Telanlana State Level [Police ][Recruitment Board (TSLPRB)]Office of the Direclor General of Police, [(DGP) ][Lakdi-ka-pul, ][Hyderabad,]Telanoana State-sO0 0043, one iC to Sri A K Jayaprakash [Rao ][Advocate ]IOPUC]4, Two CCs to GP For Services, High Court [for ][the ][State of ][Telangana. ][OUT]5. Two CCs to Special Government Pleader, [High Court for ][the ][State of Telangana](our)6. Two CD Copies7. One Spare Copy N,lBCT$- HlGl'l [couRT]
DATED: [3111212021]
"t[g ][tiTAI6]k4.l:i.)24 "tuU2$22,,I\ ,./'_\r--.i.'//.i:"",''../,ORD ERWP,No.18470of2017
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUTCOSTS