Telangana High Court
WP/37183/2021 of Mekala Sahadev, And 13 Others Vs The State of Telangana, And 3 Others on 31 December 2021
THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) FRIDAY , THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEA/BER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE PRESENT THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI WRIT PETITI ON NO: 37183 0F 2021 Between: AND 1 ltt]elala sah-adev. S/o. Kashaiah, Aged_about 72
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANAAT HYDERABAD(Special Original Jurisdiction)
FRIDAY ,THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEA/BERTWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY ONE
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI
WRIT PETITI ON NO: 37183 0F 2021
Between:
1 ltt]elala sah-adev. S/o. Kashaiah, Aged_about 72 years, occ. Retd. sub-rnspectorof Police(PC 279), DOR 28.02.20d8, Rl/o Vinay5inagar, Nizamabld-To;;-;;dDist.of Police(PC 279), DOR 28.02.20d8, Rl/o Vinay5inagar, Nizamabld-To;;-;;dDist.2. Syed Hasham,..Slg_Qye-Q lrrloulana, Aged about 68 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-Town and lnspector.of Dist.Police(PC254), DoR 31.07.2011 , R/o Eilahma Gutta, NizamabadTown and lnspector.of Dist.Police(PC254), DoR 31.07.2011 , R/o Eilahma Gutta, Nizamabad3. Guduru Aga-mgOpa, :9lor S4gqppa, Aged about 68 years, Occ. Retd. Asst.Sub-lnspector [of ][Potice(355), ][DOR ][31.07.2011 ][R/o ][nhit Titkies ][Road, ][Bodhin,]Nizamabad Dist.lnspector [of ][Potice(355), ][DOR ][31.07.2011 ][R/o ][nhit Titkies ][Road, ][Bodhin,]Nizamabad Dist.4. Mohd lbrahim, S/o Noor lr,4ohammed, Aged about 68 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-lnspector.of. Police(PC959), DOR 30.09.2011, Rt/o Hashmi iolony, NizamabadTown and Dist.lnspector.of. Police(PC959), DOR 30.09.2011, Rt/o Hashmi iolony, NizamabadTown and Dist.5. B.Radha Kishan, S/o B.Narayana, Aged about 69 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-lnspector of Poiice(PC66B), DOR 31 .03.2010 Ri/o [- ]Lakhsmi priya Nagar,Mubaraknagar, Nizamabad Town and Dist.lnspector of Poiice(PC66B), DOR 31 .03.2010 Ri/o [- ]Lakhsmi priya Nagar,Mubaraknagar, Nizamabad Town and Dist.6. M.Balaiah, S/o. Vittobha, Aged about 68 years, Occ. Retd.Asst. Sub-lnspector ofPolice(PC653), DOR 30.04.201'l Rlio Vinayaknaoar, Nizamabad Town and Dist.Police(PC653), DOR 30.04.201'l Rlio Vinayaknaoar, Nizamabad Town and Dist.7. Chowdekari- langaiah, S/o. Ch.Veerappa,'Aged about 69 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-lnspector of Police(PC436), DOR 31 .08.2010, Rt/o Gouthamnagar, NizamabadTown and Dist.lnspector of Police(PC436), DOR 31 .08.2010, Rt/o Gouthamnagar, NizamabadTown and Dist.
8. A.Bhaskar, S/o. Venkataswamy, Aged about 70 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-lnspectorof Police(P_C828), DOR 30.06.2008, R/o Gajulapet, Boigally Dargha, NizarirabadTown and Dist.of Police(P_C828), DOR 30.06.2008, R/o Gajulapet, Boigally Dargha, NizarirabadTown and Dist.9. Gurram Galaiah, S/o. Balaiah, Aged about 70 years, Occ. Retd. Head ConstableNo. 905, DOR 31,08.2003, R/o Suryanagar, Nizamabad Town and Dist.No. 905, DOR 31,08.2003, R/o Suryanagar, Nizamabad Town and Dist.
10. P.Ramulu, S/o Lingaiah, Aged about 70 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-lnspector ofPolice(PC795), DOR 30.11.2010, R/o Sainagar Road No. 1, Nizamabad Townand Dist.Police(PC795), DOR 30.11.2010, R/o Sainagar Road No. 1, Nizamabad Townand Dist.
1 1 . l\,4d.Azmiruddin, S/o. Shanooruddin, Aged about 68 years, Occ. Retd. Asst. Sub-lnspector of Police(554), DOR 31.01.2009, R:/o Upparapally, Sirgapur, lVledakDist.lnspector of Police(554), DOR 31.01.2009, R:/o Upparapally, Sirgapur, lVledakDist.12.Mohd.Hamza, S/o. Waheeduddin, Aged about 69 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-lnspector of Police(PC 184), DOR 31.07.2009, R/o ChandrashekharColony, Nizamabad Town and Dist.lnspector of Police(PC 184), DOR 31.07.2009, R/o ChandrashekharColony, Nizamabad Town and Dist.13.B.Sayanna, S/o Chandraiah, Aged about 70 years, Occ. Retd. Sub-lnspector ofPolice(PC 268), DOR 30.04.2011, Fi"/o presently H.No. 9-3-70, Karimnagar.Police(PC 268), DOR 30.04.2011, Fi"/o presently H.No. 9-3-70, Karimnagar.
14.J.Anand Rao, S/o. Rama Rao, Aged about 66 years, Occ. Retd. Asst. Sub-lnspector of Police(PC 772), DOR 31.05.2013, Rl/o Kodurpaka Village, SircillaMandal, Karimnagar Dist. presently R/o 6-197, Gajula Ramaram, Quthbullapur,N,4edchal Dist.lnspector of Police(PC 772), DOR 31.05.2013, Rl/o Kodurpaka Village, SircillaMandal, Karimnagar Dist. presently R/o 6-197, Gajula Ramaram, Quthbullapur,N,4edchal Dist.
...PETITIONERS
AND
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by its Principal Secretary, Home PoliceDepartment, Secretariat, Hyderabad.Department, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2, The Director General, and lnspector General of Police, Telangana State,Saifabad, Hyderabad.Saifabad, Hyderabad.
3. The Deputy lnspector, General of Police, Hyderabad Range, Hyderabad.
4. The Commissioner of Police, (Then Superintendant of Police) Nizamabad, Nizamabad DiSt
...RESP.NDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of lhe Constitution of lndia [praying ][that in ][the]circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the [High Court may be ][pleased]
'to issue a [writ, order or direction ][more ln ][the ][nature ][of writ ][of ][Mandamus declaring]extending, [ihe ][benefits ][of ][GON'4S ][No. ][280]the inaction [of tne ][responi""it ][i' ]""t Home [police-o oepartmeii ][iiri)izlioti ][as ][iileoat ][and ][discriminatorv ][despite]issuing [RC No. ][258/E2l20-i ][d ][&.znnttzolg ][for ][prep"arino ][a list of the eligible ]direct [police]thepersonat without tur,ng [In| ][irihli ][u"ii"n ][as ][illegal ][u-nd ]"on.eqr"ntly iesoondents to [extend ][th;'t";;iii;'"iin.r"."nt. ][Jf ][constables appointed upto ][the];".#";b:r\ [iilti"g'ih" ][i"ri"J'i[, ][inservice ][trainino to ][declaration ][of ][the ][probation]as on-duty "no [.on."q'"'itfy ]'"uit" [the ][pension ]in the recalculation [ind ][pensionary benefits ][and ][pav ][the ][same ][of ][the][at]petitioners and srant r,;;;il;i;;r "L" ieast in their [final ][stage of lives']
IAO:1OF21
PetitionunderSection'l5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedinthe affidavit [filed in suppori of the ][petition, ][inJHigl.', ][court ][may ][be ][pleased ][to ][direct]the 2nd respondent [to ][pur, ][;;i;it;; ][the ][memo given ][ny ][the ][2nd respondent to ][the]unit officers [in ][RC ][No. ][ZSAEZtiols ][at.2ol11t2o1g ][at ][an early date as ][otheruvise ][the]p"iit.n"i. *"rld be [put ][to ][irreparable loss and grave suffering]
Counsel for [the Petitioners: ][SRI ][K' ANANTHA ][RAO]a;;;;;iiorthe [Respondents: ][SPECIAL GP ][FoR ][HoME]
The Court made [the ][following: ][ORDER]
IHE HON'BtE SRI JUSIICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVIIIKUMAR SHAVIIIWRIT PEIIIION No.37183of 2021
ORDER:
This wril petition is being disposed of ot the odmission stogewith the consenl of both the porties.with the consenl of both the porties.
This writ petition is filed seeking ihe following relief:"........ to issue a wr.it, order or direction more in thenature of writ of Mandamus dectaring the inaction ofthe respondents jn extending the benefits ofG.O.Ms. No.280 Home police-D Departmentdt.13/1217001 as ittegal and discriminatory despiteissuing Rc.No,258/E2l2019 dt. z0t11t?019 forpreparing a [ist of the etigibte police personneIwithout taking any further action as iltegaI andconsequently direct the respondents to extend thebenefits of increments of constables appointed uptothe year 1975 treating the period from inservicetraining to dectaration of the probation as on duty andconsequent[y revise the pension and pensionarybenefits of the petitioners and grant arrears that mayarise in the recalcutation and pay the same at least intheir finaI stage of Iives......".
Heord Sri K.Anontho Roo, leorned counsel oppeoring for thepetitioners ond the leorned Speciol Government Pleoder oppeoringfor lhe respondents.
li hos been contended by the [petitioners ]ihot [they ore ][oll]retlred Sub-lnspector of Police. The [grievonce ][of the ][petilioners ][is]thot lhough were oll recruited during the [yeors ][l969 ][lo ][1974' ][Ihe]respondenls ore not extending the increments [while they ][were ][on]
:
troining [ond not ][exlending the ][regulor ][poy ][scole ][oltoched ][to ][the]post [of ][Constoble' ]F^r the [petitioners ][hod]Leorned [counsel ][oPPeoring ][for ][he]contended [thot ][the ][pe.litioners ][hove ][submitted ][o ][detoiled]03 [ll'20,19 ][requesling ][to]representotion [to ][the ]'u'ponO"nt'on extend [the ][increments ][ond ][olher ][service ][benefiis ][for ][lhe ][service]rendered [during ][the troining ][period. ][The ][2nd ][respondent ][n"t ][":","^1]for [the ][remorks ][trom ][the ][Unit Officers ][vide ][proceedings ][doied]20.11.2019' [But' ][so ][for' ][no further ][oction ][hos ][been ][token ][on ][the ][soid]representotion [[hod]]
representotion I for [the ][petitioners ][[hod]]^^^6'!rino Therefore' [leorned ][counsel ][oppeorlng ][t]contended [thot ][oppropriote ][orders ][be ][possed ][in ][the ][wrlt ][petition]direciing [the ][2nd ][respondent ][to ][consider ][the ][cose ][of the ][petitioners]e orders [in ][occordonce ][with ][low']ond Poss Poss [[oPProPriot]][[for ]][the]
ond Poss Poss [[oPProPriot]]ciol [Government ][Pleoder ][oppeoring ][[for ]][the]Leorned [SPe]ontended [ihot ][the ][2nd ][respondent ][is ][exomining]resPondents [hod ][c]petitioners [ond ][he ][hos ][colled ][tor ][o ][reporl ][trom]the request [of ][the]vide [proceedings ][doted ][20'11'2019' Let ][the]the [Unit ][Officers]petitioners [submit][ o ][fresh ][representotion ][to ][the ][2nd ][respondent' ][lhe]2no [respondent ][would ][exomine ][the ][some ][ond poss ][oPProPriote]orders [in ][occordonce ][with ][low]
This [Court' hovlng ][considered ][the ][rivol ][submissions ][mode ][by]the [porties, ][is ][of the ][considered view ][thol ][this ][writ pelition ][con ][be]disposed [of ][directing the ][pelilioners ][to ][submit o ][fresh ][representotion]io lhe [2no ][respondeni ][seeking ][increments ][ond ][other service benefits]for the [troining period ][when ][they ][were ][initrolly ][oppoinled' ][within ][o]
period of two weeks from lhe dole of receipi of o copy of thisorder. Upon such o represenloiion being received, lhe 2norespondent sholl consider the some ond poss oppropriole orders inoccordonce wilh low, within o reosonoble period of time,order. Upon such o represenloiion being received, lhe 2norespondent sholl consider the some ond poss oppropriole orders inoccordonce wilh low, within o reosonoble period of time,preferobly within o period of ihree months lhereofter.
With the obove directions. the wril petition is disposed of. Nocosts.costs.
Pending miscelloneous petitions, if ony, sholl siond closed.
SD/.V.KAVITHAASSISTANT REISTRARSECTION O FICER
,TRUE COPY//
To,1. The Principal Secretary, Home [Police Department, ][State of ][Telangana,]Secretariat, Hyderabad.2. The Director General, and [lnspector General of ][Police, ][Telangana ][State,]Saifabad, Hyderabad.S ihe-Mputv'l nspector, [General of Police, Hyderabad ]fgnge' .tly!e19!3!,4. The Cohrniissioner [of Police, (Then Superintendant of Police) ][NrzamaDao,]Nizamabad Dist.S. One CC to Sri [K ][Anantha ][Rao, ][Advocate ][[OPU-C]]6. i;; ccsio [cF ][to, ][Hore''Hig. ][court ][toitne ][st6te ][of ][relangana ][at Hyderabad]tourl7. Two CD CopiesB. One SPare [CoPY]SmNPJ
q
HIGH [COURT]
DATEO:3111212021
ORDERWP.No.37183 ot [2021]
DISPOSING OF THE WPWITHOUT COSTS
w
1[$g ][SIA][ 16:].:.r'II,,J02 [Ftts ][20?2]I_.'i-k