Telangana High Court
WP/39295/2013 of Smt. Penuganta Shanthamma, Vs Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, on 31 December 2024
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA (Special Original Jurisdiction) TUESDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW FOUR PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SMTJUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI WRIT PETITIO N NO: 39295 OF 2O13 Between: 1 . Smt. Penuganta Shanthamma, w/o. Bqla Kisthaiah, aged 42-.
HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA(Special Original Jurisdiction)TUESDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEMBERTWO THOUSAND AND TWENW FOUR
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMTJUSTICE T.MADHAVI [DEVI]WRIT PETITIO N NO: 39295 OF [2O13]
Between:
1 . Smt. Penuganta Shanthamma, w/o. Bqla [Kisthaiah, ][aged ][42-. ][y.ears']R/o. H.No.2i2, Chikkepalli Village, Pangal [Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.]R/o. H.No.2i2, Chikkepalli Village, Pangal [Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.]
2. Smt. M. Sharadamma, w/o. Ramachandra [Reddy' ][aged ][42 ][years,]R/o. Chikkepalli Village, Pangal Mardal, Matuboobnagar [District.]R/o. Chikkepalli Village, Pangal Mardal, Matuboobnagar [District.]
3. Smt. Shankaramma, w/o. [Pullagura ][Venkat ][Swamy, ][aged ][37 ][years,]R:/o. H.No.3-12211 , Govardhanagiri Village, [Veepangandla ][Mandal,]Mahaboobnagar District.R:/o. H.No.3-12211 , Govardhanagiri Village, [Veepangandla ][Mandal,]Mahaboobnagar District.
4. Smt. Devamma, Wo. Peddala Lakshmaiah, [aged ][z[6 ][years, ][Rl/o] ][H.No'3-91,]Govardhanagiri Village, Veepangandla [Mandal, ][Mahaboobnagar Dislrict.]Govardhanagiri Village, Veepangandla [Mandal, ][Mahaboobnagar Dislrict.]
5. Smt. Manemma, Wo. Y. Anjanaiah, aged [32 ][years, ][Fl/o. ][H.M.4-98' ][Sathapur]Village, Peddakothapally Ma'ndal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Village, Peddakothapally Ma'ndal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
6. Smt. S. Nilamma, Wio. Narsinrha, aged [43 years, ][R/o. ][H-No.9-14l1' ][Sathapur]Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
7. Smt. Kalavathamma, W/o. Krishnaiah, [aged ][47 ][years, ][Rl/o. ][H'No'2-20,]Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
B. Smt. Ramulamma W/o. S. [Srinivasulu, ]4ed [42 ][years, ][Rl/o' H'No'2-120/A']Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
9. Smt. Baleeshwaramma, W/o. [V. ][Balakrishna, aged ][46 ][years, ][Ryo ]' [3-4213,]Kudikilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, [Mahaboobnagar District.]Kudikilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, [Mahaboobnagar District.]
10.Smt. Nageswaramma, W/o. Shagadi [Balgpeer,.aSed ][2!. ][yqap' ][F/o ][H'No'2-]BB, Kudifilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, [Mahaboobnagar District.]BB, Kudifilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, [Mahaboobnagar District.]
PETITIONERS
AND
1Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, Consumer [Affairs, ][Food and Civil Supplies]Department, Represented by its Secretary, [Civil ][Supplies, ][Hyderabad]Department, Represented by its Secretary, [Civil ][Supplies, ][Hyderabad]
2. - ieOOy, Minister-in-charge, Departrn'ent Mahboobnagar. of Ministry fir Housing, [Govgmqent ]Secretariat' [of ][AP, Sri. ]Hyderabad'[Uttam Kumar]
3. The District Collector, [Mahboobnagar District, Mahaboobnagar']
4- Dawapu chennamma, wo: [Agguraiah, ][aged: ][55 ])'Iears' [occ: coolie' ][Fl/o:]Wddpanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Wddpanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
5. Meesala Saraslvathi, W/o: Chinna [Ramulu, ][aged ][:43 ][year, Occ: Coolie, ][Rl/o]Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.
6. Gaddameedi Aruna, Wo: Ashok, aged [28 year, ][Occ: Coolie, ][R/o:]Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
7. Gaddameedi Roshamma, [Wo: ][Narsimha, aged 40 years, ][Occ ][Coolie,]Rl/o: Mahaboob ragar DistrictRl/o: Mahaboob ragar District
8. Ram Pentamnna, W/o: Pentaiah, age: [56 years, ][Occ: ][Coolie,]
Ri/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.
9. Dattaran Neelarnma, Wo: Bichaiah, aged 38 [years, ]Occ: fuolie,Rl/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.Rl/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.
10. Dayyapu Mashamma, Wo: Kistaiah aged 60 [years, ]Occ: Coolie,Rl/o: Weepanagand la, Mahaboobnagar District.Rl/o: Weepanagand la, Mahaboobnagar District.
11. Meesala Shalmma, W/o: Vishnu, aged 39 [years, ]Occ: Coolie,Rl/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar DistrictRl/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District
l2.Meesala Chandramma, Wo: Yakub, aged about 62 [years, ]Occ: Coolie,Rl/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.Rl/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.
13.Tolu Kavitha, lrV/o: Srinivasulu, aged 32 [years, ]Occ: Coolie,Ri/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.Ri/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.
( RR 4 to 13 are impleaded as per C.O. dt: 2512114 in WPMP 2170/,141
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in thecircumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may bepleased to issue any writ, order or direction, more particularly, one in the natureof writ of Mandamus; declaring the action of the respondents in issuing theimpugned proceedings No. C57l1064/2013 dated 29.06.2013 and the approval ofthe 2nd Respondent to the letter dated 12.12.20 13 and all consequentproceedings and aclicrns taken by the authorities thus far including identifying listof beneficiaries as illegal, arbitrary and unconstitutional and set aside the sameand consequently set aside the list of beneficiaries recommended under thescheme as illegal, arbitrary and unconstitutional and direct the Respondents toidentify the beneficiar es and provide LPG connections under the scheme as perthe guidelines in a transparent manner.
l.A. NO: 1 OF 2013{WPMP. NO: 48809 OF 2013)
Petition under liection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances statedin the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to tay all further [proceedingsiactircns ][taken in ][pursuance ][of the ][proceedings dated]29.06.2013 and the approval [granted by ][the ][2nd Respondent to ][the ][letter ][dated]12.12.2013 including [allotment ][of ][LPG ][connections to the beneficiaries ][identified]in pursuance of the [impugned ][proceedings dated ][29.06.2013 and ][the ][approval ][of]the 2nd Respondent to [the ][letter ][daled ][12.12.2013 pending disposal ][of ][the]present writ Petition
l.A. NO: 'l OF 2014(WVMP. [NO: 662 ][OF][ 20141]
Between:
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
1. Davyapu Chennamma, [W/o: ][Agguraiah, ][aged: 55 years, Occ: Coolie, ][Fl/o:]Wddp6nagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Wddp6nagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
2. Meesala Saraswathi, [Wo: ][Chinna ][Ramulu, ][aged ][: ][43 year, Occ: Coolie, ][Rl/o:]Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
3. Gaddameedi Aruna, [Wo: ][Ashok, ][aged 28 year, Occ: ][Coolie, ][Ri/o:]Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar [District.]
4. Gaddameedi Roshamma, [Wo: ][Narsimha, aged 40 years, Occ: Coolie,]R/o: Mahaboobnagar [District]R/o: Mahaboobnagar [District]
5. Ram Pentamma, [Wo: ][Pentaiah, age: ][56 ][years, ][Occ: Coolie']R:/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District']R:/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District']
6. Dattaran Neelamma, [Wo: ][Bichaiah, aged 38 years, Occ: Coolie,]R/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]R/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]
7. Dawaou Mashamma, [Wo: ][Kistaiah aged 60 years, ][Occ: ][Coolie,]Fyd:'Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]Fyd:'Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]
8. Meesala Shalmma, [Wo: ][Vishnu, aged 39 years, Occ: Coolie,]Rl/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar ][District]Rl/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar ][District]
L Meesala Chandramma, [W/o: Yakub, aged ][about62 ][years, Occ: ][Coolb,]R/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]R/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]
10. Tolu Kavitha, [Wo: ][Srinivasulu' ][aged 32 years, Occ: Coolie,]R/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]R/o: Weepanagandla, [Mahaboobnagar District.]
...IMPLEADING [PETITIONER]
1. Smt. Penuganta [Shantharnma, ]ry/o. [gqla ][(i$Fghr ][a999--12^,-trflt']R/o. H.No.2i2, Chikkepalli [Village, ][Pangal ][Mandal, Mahaboobnagar ][urstnct']R/o. H.No.2i2, Chikkepalli [Village, ][Pangal ][Mandal, Mahaboobnagar ][urstnct']
2. Smt. M. Sharadamma, [w/o. ][Ramactrandra ][Reddy'-.agg! ][42 ][years']-' nyo. Ct'iif"patii vittage, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District'-' nyo. Ct'iif"patii vittage, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District'
3. Smt. Shankaramma, [w/o. ][Pullagura ][Venkat ][Swamy, ][aged. ][37..years']Fi./o. H.No.3-12211 , [Govardhanagiri ][Mllage, ][Veepanganon ][Manoar']Mahaboobna [ga ][r ][District.]Fi./o. H.No.3-12211 , [Govardhanagiri ][Mllage, ][Veepanganon ][Manoar']Mahaboobna [ga ][r ][District.]
4. " Smt. Devamma, [W/o. ][Peddala ][Lakshrnaiah, aged ][46 ][years, Rl/o'.H'No'3-91']Govardhanagiri Vi|]age, [Veepangandla ][Mandal, Mahaboobnagar ][Dlstfl ][ct']Govardhanagiri Vi|]age, [Veepangandla ][Mandal, Mahaboobnagar ][Dlstfl ][ct']
5. Smt. Manemma, Wo. Y. Anjanaiah, aged32 [years, ]Rl/o. H.No.4-98, [Sathapur]Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
6. Smt. S. Nilamnra, Wo. Narsimha, aged 43 [years, ]Rl/o. [H.No.9-14l1, Sathapur]Village, Peddalrothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Village, Peddalrothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
7. Smt. Kalavathamma, Wo. Krishnaiah, aged 47 [years, ][Rl/o. ][H.No.2-20,]Paspula Village,, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Paspula Village,, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
8. Smt. Ramulamma Wo. S. Srinivasulu, aged 42 [years, ]Fl/o. H.No.2-120lA,Paspula Village,, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Paspula Village,, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
9. Smt. Baleeshrivaramma, Wo. V. Balakrishna, aged 46 [yea$, ]No. [3-4213,]Kudikilla Villager, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Kudikilla Villager, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
10. Smt. Nageswaramma, W/o. Shagadi Balapeer, aged 29 [years, ]Rl/o. H.No.2-88, Kudikilla \/illage, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.88, Kudikilla \/illage, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
.,,.PETITIONERS
11. Govt. of Andhrzr Pradesh, Consumer Affairs, Food and Civil SuppliesDepartment, Represented by its Secretary, Civil Supplies, Hyderabad.Department, Represented by its Secretary, Civil Supplies, Hyderabad.
12. Minister-in-charge, Mahboobnagar. Government of AP, Sri. Uttam KumarReddy, Departrnent of Ministry for Housing, Secretariat, Hyderabad.Reddy, Departrnent of Ministry for Housing, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
13. The District Collector, Mahboobnagar District, Mahaboobnagar.
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS NO.1 to 3
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances statedin the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased tovacate the interim order passed in WP No.39295 of 2013, dated 21.1.2014, in theinterest of justice.
l.A. NO: 2OF 20141WVMP. NO: 789 OF 2014)
Between:
1. Govt. of Andhra Pradesh, Consumer Affairs, Food and Civil SuppliesDepartment, Rerpresented by its Secretary, Civil Supplies, Hyderabad.Department, Rerpresented by its Secretary, Civil Supplies, Hyderabad.
2. Dayyapu Chennamma, Wo: Agguraiah, aged: 55 years, Occ: Coolie,R/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.R/o: Weepanagandla, Mahaboobnagar District.
...PETITIONERS/REPONDNTS
AND
1. Qmt. Penuganta Shanthamma, w/o. Bala Kisthaiah, aged 42 years,R/o. H.No.2-02, Chikkepalli Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.R/o. H.No.2-02, Chikkepalli Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
2. Smt. M. Sharadamma, w/o. Ramachandra Reddy, aged 42 years,R/o. Chikkepalli Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Distiict.R/o. Chikkepalli Village, Pangal Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Distiict.
3. 9ft. Shankarermma, w/o. Pullagura Venkat Swamy, aged 37 years,R/o. H.No.3-12211 , Govardhanagiri Vittage, Veeiang-ndta Mindal,Mahaboobnagar District.R/o. H.No.3-12211 , Govardhanagiri Vittage, Veeiang-ndta Mindal,Mahaboobnagar District.
4. Smt. Devamma, Wo. Pedda{a Lakshmaiah, aged 46 years, Ri/o. H.No.3-91,Govardhanagiri Village, Veepangand{a Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Govardhanagiri Village, Veepangand{a Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.5. Smt. Manemma, Wo. Y. Anjanaiah, aged 32 years, Ri/o. H.No.4-98, SathapurVillage, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
6. Smt. S. Nilamma, Wo. Narsimha, aged 43 years, R:/o. H.No.9-14l1, SathapurVillage, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Village, Peddakothapally Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
7. Smt. Kalavathamma, W/o. Krishnaiah, aged 47 years, R/o. H-No.2-20,Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar District.
8. Smt. Ramulamma Wo. S. Srinivasulu, aged 42 years, R/o. H.M.2-120IA,Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Dislrict.Paspula Village, Kodair Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Dislrict.
9. Smt. Baleeshwaramma, W/o. V. Balakrishna, aged 46 years, R/o. 3-4213,Kudikilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Dstrict.Kudikilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Dstrict.
10. S{nt. Nageswaramma, Wo. Shagadi Balapeer, aSed 29 years, R/o. H.No.2-88, Kudikilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Distrbt.88, Kudikilla Village, Kollapur Mandal, Mahaboobnagar Distrbt.
...PETITIONERS/RESPONDETNS
1 1 . Minister-in-charge, Mahboobnagar. Government of AP, Sri. t-ktam KumarReddy, Department of Ministry for Housing, Secretariat, Hyderabad.Reddy, Department of Ministry for Housing, Secretariat, Hyderabad.
... RESPON DE NT/RESPO NDENT
(RespondenUrespondent no.11 is not necessary party in this petition)
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances statedin the affidavit filed in support of the [petition, ]the High Court may be pleased tovacate the interim orders granted in W.P.No.39295 o'f 2013 dt:O2-O1-2014.
Counsel for the Petitioners: SRI AVINASH DESAI
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.1,2 and 3: GP FOR CIVIL SUPPLIES
Counsel for the Respondent Nos.4 to 13: M/S N. ASHWANI KUMARThe Court made the following: ORDER
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE T. MADHAVI DEVI
WRIT PETITIOII No.39295. of 2013
ORDER:
Today, rvhen the matter is taken up for consideration, Mr. S.Sahil Reddy, learned counsel, representing Mr.AvinashDesai, learned counsel for the petitioners, has submitted that inspite of his trest efforts, he is not able to contact or getinstructions from the petitioners.
2. on the other hand, the learned Government preader for civirSupplies appearing for the respondents has submitted that thesubject matte. of this writ petition has become infructuous asthe "DEEPAM S,:heme" itself is not in existence as o[-nc,u..
In view of the above submission, view of the above submission, the above submission, above submission, submission, the present u,rit petition JIn view of the above submission, view of the above submission, the above submission, above submission, submission, is closed as infructuous. No order as to costsis closed as infructuous. No order as to costs Miscellaneous applications, if any, pending rn this writpetition, shall sternd closed.petition, shall sternd closed.
SD/-L. LAKSHMABUASSISTANT REGTRAR
//TRUE COPYII
SECTION OFFICER
To,'1 . One CC to Sri A'rinash Desai, Advocate fOptJCI'1 . One CC to Sri A'rinash Desai, Advocate fOptJCI
Sri A'rinash Desai, Advocate fOptJCIA'rinash Desai, Advocate fOptJCIDesai, Advocate fOptJCIAdvocate fOptJCIfOptJCI2. Two ccs to Gp 1br civir suppries, High cburtio-i the State of re,rangana, atHyderabad [OUTIHyderabad [OUTI
4. 3. One CC to M/s N Ashwani Kumar, Advocate [OpUC]
Two CD Copiestrttrt
TJBS
HIGH COURT'
DATED:3111212024
ORDER
WP.No.39295 ot 2013
'1 [.;t]1\.[=-:--=_.\]e Sl*ri\' [(,. ][>'.]i1, '\',\!":.il,i CLOSING THE WRIT PETTTION AS INFRUCTUOUSWITHOUT COSTS(a- ! --ts l> l>,;Jca$-c:,