Telangana High Court
WP(TR)/3660/2017 of K. PANDU Vs The state of Telangana on 30 December 2021
THE S AT HYDEJJiJE DO F TE LAN GANA THURSDAY, THE THIRTIE rwo rH o u i;ffi ;i3 iil f,froo.,$=. * = * PRESENT Between: fr:Il,8ii,jlf :x[df #,,[lsAns,o*?tt#j,r,J""s:;;;,,.,i:"ot] ome Guard Lingala (V), ,.PETITIONER AND 1. 2. ff
Between:
HIGH COURT FOR THE SS
THE SSF TE LAN GANAAT HYDEJJiJE DO
rwo rH o u * i;ffi ;i3 iil f,froo.,$=.
THURSDAY, THE THIRTIE
= [*]
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRIJUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI
WRIT PETITION (TR) NO. 3660 OF 2017
ome Guardfr:Il,8ii,jlf :x[df Lingala (V),#,,[lsAns,o*?tt#j,r,J""s:;;;,,.,i:"ot],.PETITIONER
AND
1.
2. ff n,,,tt4i$i[itts:x'"tiiq's:t*;",:"""::::J,.",ii"]l-\-,lne [Commissroner ]of [police, ]4rne uommandant. Home curr6i,-Hyoei;d;l Hyderabad City, Hyderabad. it;:iri;j"rabad 500029._ 500002
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Articre 226 0I the constitution of rndia praying that in thecircumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High court may be preasedto call for the records rerating to and connected with the impugned order bearingD O NO S5/201 4rNO.g75rA2rHGs.Hvd/2014, dated 9.10.2014 passed bv the 4threspondent in removing the name of appricant from the rofls of Home Guardsorganisation, Hyderabad city, Hyderabad, and set aside the same to the extent ofapplicant herein, as being ilegar, arbitrary, unreasonabre, viorative of Articres 14and 16 of the constitution of lndia and aiso against the principles of natural justiceand consequently direct the respondents herein to reinstate the applicant intoservice as Home Guard with all consequentjal benefits.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRt B. KRISHNA
Counsel for the Respondents: Gp FOR HOME (SER.)
The Court made the following: ORDER
HON'BL [SRI ][JUSTICE ][ABHINAND ][KUMAR ][SHAVILI]
\ lRl[T ][PET][llro][ N (TR][)N][o.][3660][ ol ][2][0'17]
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
ORDER:
When the [motter ][is ][token up for heorlng' ieorned ][counsel]for [petitioner ][sr ][bmiis ][thot ihe ][issue ][roised ][in ][this ][wri.t ][petition ][is]squorely [cover( ][d ][by ][the ][Division ][Bench ][ludgments of ][this ][Court ][in]W.P.No.'l 9455 [cf ][20\4 ][ond ][botch ][doted ][20'04'2018 ][ond]W.P.No.77B4cf201BondW.P.(TR)'No'3129of2c17doted2S.o2,2olgonccontendsthottheimpugnedremovolorderwospossed withou [giving ony ][opportunity ][to ][the ][petitioner ][in ][terms]of Rule 714) of [he Modros Home Guords ][Rules' ][I ][949']
Leorned counsel [for ][petitioner further ][subm ][is ][thot ][the]Division Bencl^ [of ][this ][Court in ][its ][orders ][in ][W'PNo',]9'455 ][of ][20,]4]ondbotch<loted2O.O4.2OlSdirectedtheresp'ondentstoreinstote the J [etitioners ][therein ][into ][service ][withouf ][cny ][benefiis]in relotion to ['heir post ][service ][including ][senlority' ]':ontinuity [of]seivice ond [o' ][tendont ][benefits.]
Leornec Government [Pleoder ][oppeorin'3 ][for ][the]respondents [l- ][cs ][not disputed the ][obove ][submission ][rnode ][by the]leorned coun;el [for ][petitioner ][ond contended thot the ][cose ][of]the [petitioner ][would ][be considered ][for ][reinstotemert ][into ][service]to [pl ][ysicol ][fitness ][ond ][ovoilobility ][of ][posts ][without ][ony]subject benefits in elotion [to ][his ][post ][service ][lncluding ][seniority']continuity of [: ]ervice [ond ][ottendont ][benefits']
This Co rrl, hoving [considerecl ][the ][rivol ][submis:;ions' ][ls ][of ][the]considered [r ]iew [thot the ][impugned order ][is ][possed ][without]
grvrng ony opportunity to ihe petiiioner in terms of Ruje 7(4) ofthe Nzlodros Home Guords Rules, 194g. Therefore. the orderthe Nzlodros Home Guords Rules, 194g. Therefore. the orderimpugned is set oside ond ihe respondents ore directed toreinstote the petilioner into service os o fresh Home Guordsubjeci to physicol fitness ond ovoilobility of posts wilhou.t onybenefits in relotion to his posi service including senioriiy,continuity of service ond ottendont benefiis Wiih the obove observoilons, the writ petition ls disposedof . No order os to cosis.
Pending mlscellqneous [petliions, ]if ony, sholl [stond closed.]
""' sD/- N. CHANDRA ['" ][SEKHAR ]neetsrnan [RAO ]Ii;sSiSiAni (ln //TRUE [COPY//]
SECTION [OFFICER]
Conclusion
Tor state of relangana' [secretariat]1 Tha princioal secretary, Home Department, , +Xl ruit[x:i'S.P83,ilB%'"irar [or ][porice, Home Guards, State ][of ][rerangana']a The Commandant' [I]"+*'z::r*"****qtffffi,:,*$:ffi1i1":'l't:f;:' **x"sanaa,:: *: ??y 3-$ [Hvderabad lOUTlz. two CD [CoPies']8. One [SPare ][CoPY']1 Tha princioal secretary, Home Department, , +Xl ruit[x:i'S.P83,ilB%'"irar [or ][porice, Home Guards, State ][of ][rerangana']a The Commandant' [I]"+*'z::r*"****qtffffi,:,*$:ffi1i1":'l't:f;:' **x"sanaa,:: *: ??y 3-$ [Hvderabad lOUTlz. two CD [CoPies']8. One [SPare ][CoPY']
MPq{v
HIGH [GOURT]
DATED:3011212021
ORDERWP(TR).No.3650 ot 2017
DtsPoslNG o: THE WRIT PET|T|ON (TR)WITHOUT COI;TSWITHOUT COI;TS
I; [:,-iA ][r'(-],//^f_1..]?t [JIN20fl]f,