Telangana High Court
WP/22180/2020 of Smt. Barla Anjamma Vs State of Telangana and Another on 30 December 2020
THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) WEDNESDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF DECEMBER TWO.THOUSAND AND TWENTY Between: Smt, Barla Nagayapalli Tela nga na. Anjamma, W/o (V), lMarriPalli J. Suresh Kumar, Aged about Post. Vemulavada (lt/). Rajanna 35 years, R/o Sircilla
HIGH COURT FOR THE [STATE ][OF ][TELANGANA]AT HYDERABAD(Special Original Jurisdiction)
WEDNESDAY, THE THIRTIETH [DAY ][OF ][DECEMBER]TWO.THOUSAND AND [TWENTY]
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE [ABHINAND ][KUMAR SHAVILI]
WRIT PETITION NO: [22180 ][OF 2020]
Between:
Smt, BarlaAnjamma, W/oJ. Suresh Kumar, [Aged ][about]35 years, R/oNagayapalli(V), lMarriPalliPost. Vemulavada [(lt/). ][Rajanna]Sircilla District.Tela nga na.PETITIONER
AND
1StateofTelangana,RepresentedbyitsChiefSecretary,GAD,SecretariatBuildinqs, Saifbbad, [Hyderabad.]2i"i"isZ"', Strt"i..joti6 [Service Commission, Nampally, Hyderabad, Rep ][by ][its]secretary' ...RE'P.NDENTS
...RE'P.NDENTS
Petition under Article [226 ][of ][lhe ][constitution ][of ][lndia ][praying ][that ][in ][the]circumstances stated [in ][the ][affidavit filed therewith, ][the ][High Court may ][be ][pleased]to issue an appropriate [Writ ][more in ][the ][nature ][of ][a ][Writ ][of ][lt/andamus declaring of]the action of the [Respondent ][No ][2 ][in not issuing ][Appointment orders ][to ][the Petitioner]for the [post ]of Librarian [(Junior ][college) ][in ][terms ][of ][her performance ][in ][both written]and oral examination [under ][Notification ][No. ][2812017 ][with ][Hall Ticket ][No']1728000093 as being [arbitrary, illegal, violating Articles ][14' ][16 ][and ][21 ][of ][the]constitution of lndia [and consequently direct ][the 2nd ][Respondent ][to ][forth with ][issue]Appointment orders [to ][the ][Petitioner ][for the ][post ][of Librarian ][(Junior ][colleges) ][as per]the selected list [published ][by ][the ][Commission ][and ][issue]
A NO: 1 OF 2020
Petition under Section [151][ CPC ][praying ][that ][in ][the ][circumstances ][stated ][in]the affidavit filed in support [of the ][petition, ][the ][High ][court ][may be pleased ][to ][direct]the 2nd Respondent [to ][forth ][with ][issue ][appointment orders ][to ][the ][Petitioner ][as]Librarian [(Junior ][college) ][in ][terms ][of ][her ][performance ][in the written ][test/interviews]under Notifica lton of 2Bt2O17 [vide ][Hall ][Ticket No. ][1728000093 ][for the ][Post ][of]Lib ra ria n Counsel for the [Petitioner: ][SRI CH ][SAMSON BABU]
Counsel for Respondent [No' ][1: GP ][FOR ][GENERAL ADMINISTRATION]
Counsel for Respondent [No. ][2: ][SRI ][D. ][BALAKISHAN ][RAO, SC ][FOR ][TSPSC]
The Court made the [following: ][ORDER]
THE HON'BtE SRI JUSTICE ABHINAND KUMAR SHAVILI
WRIT PETITION No.22180 of 2020
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
ORDER:
This writ petition is being disposed of ol the odmission stoge with the consenl of both porties.
This writ pelition is filed seeking the following relief:
"......to issue an appropriate Writ, more in the nature of aWrit of Mandamus dectaring of the action of theRespondent No.2 in not issuing Appointment orders to thepetitioner for the post of Librarian (Junior Cottege) interms of her performance in both written and oralexamination Under Notification No.28/2017 with HatITicket No.1728000093 as being arbitrary, ittegat, viotatingArticles 14, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of lndia andconsequentty direct the 2"d Respondent to forthwith issueappointment orders to the petitioner for the post ofLibrarian (Junior Cotleges) as per the setected [istpubtished by the Commission Heord Sri Ch.Somson Bobu, leorned counsel oppeoring forthe pelilioner ond Sri D.Bolokishon Roo, leorned Stonding Counseloppeoring for the Telongono Stote Public Service Commission.
It hos been confended by the petitioner lhol she is fullyeligible ond quolified lo be oppointed os o Librorion ond pursuontlo the Notificotion doted 02,06.2017 issued by the respondenls, shebeing o member belonging to scheduled coste community,responded lo the soid Notificotion ond she hos fored decently wellin the selection process ond secured decent morkslo the Notificotion doted 02,06.2017 issued by the respondenls, shebeing o member belonging to scheduled coste community,responded lo the soid Notificotion ond she hos fored decently wellin the selection process ond secured decent morks The grievonce of the petitioner is thot though she wosprovisionolly selecled follhe posl of Librorion, the respondenls orenot considering her cose for oppoinlmenl 1o lhe post of Librorion on lhe ground thol W.P:No.46010 of 20lB [filed ][by ][one ][Ms'B.Momothq ][is]pending before this Court.
Leorned counsel oppeoring for the [petitioner hod ][conlended]thol insofor os W.P.No.460l0 of 2018 [is ][concerned, ][the ][petitioner]lherein hos ocquired ihe requisite [quolificotion ][ofier ][issuonce ][of]Notificotion ond, iherefore, she [is ][not ]eligible. [Bul, ][however, ][this]Court wos [pleosed ]to [gront interim order ][on ][I ][8.1 ][2.201 ][8 ][direcling lhe]petitioner therein lo otlend for lhe interview. [l'lowever, ][in ][the]present cose, only on the [ground ]thot the obove [wril ][petition ][is]pending, the cose of lhe [pelitioner ]hereln [is ][not ][being considered']Therefore, oppropriole orders [be ][possed ][in ][the ][writ ][petition]directing the respondents [lo ][consider ][the cose ][of ][lhe ][pelilioner ][for]oppointment to the [posl ]of [Librorion ][in ][Junior Colleges wilhout]reference to the [pendency of ][W.P.No.460l0 ][of ][2018, ][os ][there ][is ][no]direction in the soid [writ ][petition with regord ][to ][filling ][up ][the ][post ][of]Librorion in the Junior Colleges.
Leorned Stonding Counsel [oppeoring for ][the ][Public ][Service]Commission hod conlended [thot ][the ][petilioner ][herein ][is ][eligible to]be considered [for ]oppointment [1o ][the ][post ][of ][Librorion in ][ihe ][Junior]Colleges ond [jusi ]becouse, [W.P.No.46010 ][of ][2018 ][is ][pending, ][lhe]respondenls ore not in o [position 1o consider ][lhe ][cose ][of ][the]petilioner herein for oppointment 1o the [post ]of [Librorion ][in ][Junior]Colleges.
This Court, hoving considered [lhe ][rivol ][submissions ][mode ][by]the [porties, ]is of the [considered view ][thoi ][this ][wril peiilion ][con ][be]disposed of directing [lhe ][respondenls ][to ][consider ][ihe ][cose ][of ][ihe]petiiioner for epgointment to the [posi ]of [Librorion ][in ][the ][Junior]
Colleges without reference to the pendency of W.p.No.460 j0 of201B before lhis Court ond poss oppropriote orders in occordoncewilh low, within o reosonoble period, preferobly within o period ofeight weeks from the dote of receipt of o copy of this order.wilh low, within o reosonoble period, preferobly within o period ofeight weeks from the dote of receipt of o copy of this order.
With the obove observotions, lhis writ pelition is disposed of.No costs.
Pending miscelloneous petilions, if ony, sholl stond closed.SD/-K.AMMAJIASSISTANT REGISTR,TRUE COPY//SEGTION OFFICERTo,1.The Chief Secretary, GAD, State of Telangana Secretariat Buildings, Saifabad,Hyderabad.2.The Secretary, Telangana State Public Service Commission, Nampally,Hyderabad.3.One CC to Sri Ch Samson Babu Advocate IOPUC]4.Two CCs to GP For General Administration, High Court for the State ofTelangana. [OUT]One CC to Sri D. Bala Kishan Rao, SC for TSPSC (OPUC)6.Two CD CopiesIVBC\ J,=- DATED: 3011212020
.- e.1HETA 14:i/\c2 0 JAN 2021za5*cr\(-:QORDER
WP.No.22180 ot 2020
DISPOSING OF THE WRIT PETITION
WITHOUT COSTS
{ul2-\