WP/17816/2011 of D. Prasanna Kumari (deid) per Lrs 2to4 Vs The Collector, Ranga Reddy District, on 31 December 2024

ORDER:

THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATHWRIT PETITION No.17816 OF 2O11

Heard learned Counsel appearing for the petitionerand learned Assistant Government Pleader for Assignmentappearing for the respondents and perused the entiremateria,l on record.

Learned Counsel appearing lor the petitioner

submits that the schedule property admeasuring to anextent of Ac.3-10 guntaslnSy.No. 177 16, situated atAziznagar Village, Moinabad Mandal, Rangareddy District.For the Sy.No.l77 of Aziznagar Village, Moinabad Mandal,this Court passed orders dated i6.12.2022 in W.P.No.B327of 2OO8 by declaring the lands situated in Sy.No.177 ll to177 138 ol Aziznagx Village, Moinabad Mandal are [patta]iands and allowed the said writ petition.

2SK,Jw.P.No.17816 of 2011

3. The learned Counsel [requested ][to ][pass ][similar ][orders]in this writ [petition ][by ][following ][the ][orders ][passed ][in]W.P.No.8327 of 2008, [dated ][16.12.2022.]

4. Learned Assistant Government [Pleader ][for]Assignment not disputing [the ][submission made ][by ][the]learned colrnsel for [the ][petitioner ][and ][the ][orders ][passed ][by]this Court rn [W.P.No.8327 ][of ][2OO8, ][dated ][16.12 ]'2022'

5. The sub.iect matter of the [writ ][petition ][is ][in]Sy.No. 177,r 6 situated [in ][Aziznagar ][Village, ][Moinabad]Mandal, Rangareddy [District ][and the ][above ][said]W.P.No.8327 ol 2OO8 is [pertaining ][to ][the ][other ][sub]divisions in Sy.Nos. 177. [This Court while ][disposing ][the]writ petition, has called [for the ][records ][with ][regard ][to ][the]Sy.No.177 of Azizrraga:. [Village, ][Moinabad ][Mandal']Rangarecl<ly District and [has given ][the ][finding ][as ][follows:]

" 10. At the time of heaing, this Court directed [the]Lear necl Gouernment Pleader for [Assignments ][to]prot)uce the records pertaining to the [impugned]proceeclittqs ond directed to produce tle assignment \

pclttas issued to the landless poor persons in 9y.No.177.The Leamed Gouernment Pleader produced the record.sand the record.s reueal tttnt the Assi,stant Director ofS&rlfs, Ranga Reddg District issued a letter inRc. No.G3/ 2722/ 96, dated 22.11.1996 stated that asper the Classer Akar regi.ster the Su.Nos. j77/ 1 to 3gPotes Patta lands and Pote 39 is poramtrtoke. In theSethu-tar and Wasool BaEti copies prepared. in the gear1961, the Sg.Nos.177/ 1 to 39 shoun as patta lands.

1 1. TLe letter of the Mandal Reuenue Offtcer inLr. No.B/ 318O/ 95, dated 21.O7.1997 addressed to theDistrict Collector tLnt "I lmue udrified the pahanies fromthe Aear 1954-55 (Kllr-sras) wherein it is recorded thatthe Surueg Nos.177/8, 12, 13 and 2O are asKothakancha patto, except the suruey numbers 177/ 1& 177/39 uhich are recorded as sarkai porampoke.These details are carried upto 1981-82 pahani. Ancl allDistrict Collector tLnt "I lmue udrified the pahanies fromthe Aear 1954-55 (Kllr-sras) wherein it is recorded thatthe Surueg Nos.177/8, 12, 13 and 2O are asKothakancha patto, except the suruey numbers 177/ 1& 177/39 uhich are recorded as sarkai porampoke.These details are carried upto 1981-82 pahani. Ancl allof a sudden tn the year 1982-83 it is recorded as Loanipatta against each surueg number (The ertracts arepatta against each surueg number (The ertracts aresubmitted for perusal). The reasons for ttiting as Loanipatta are not knoutn. Tlrcre is no reutrd auailable in thispatta are not knoutn. Tlrcre is no reutrd auailable in thisofJice about assignment of this partiatlar land. to angperson, because th.e names of pattadars are appearedin Reuenue Records ight froa 1954-55". But therespondents are unable to produce th,e assignmentpattas issued to the landless poor persons.person, because th.e names of pattadars are appearedin Reuenue Records ight froa 1954-55". But therespondents are unable to produce th,e assignmentpattas issued to the landless poor persons.

12. After heaing both sides and. uerifging the original records, this Court is of the considered. uieu that as per S1(,J

sl('J

W.P.No.17816 [of ][2O11]

the tetters [of ][the ][Assistant ][Director' ][S&SLN ]' [dated]22.11 1996 [and ][the ][then ][Ta:ttsild'ar' ][Moinabad ][Mon'dal]dated- 21.07.1997 [clearlg ][slrllttts ][that ][tlere ][is ][no ][record]auailable [about ][the ][assignment ][of land to the ][landless]poor persons [in ][Sg.No'177 ][of ][Azeeznagar Village and]the concemed [authorities reported ][thnt ][the ][said land ][is]patta land."

The findings [of the ][above ][said ][writ ][petition]squarely [apply ][to ][the ][instant ][case ][as ][the ][suit ][schedule]property [pertaining ][to the ][Sy'No ]['177 ][l6 ][of ][Aziznagar ][Village']Moinabad [Mandal, ][RangareddY']

6. In view of [the ][submissions ][made ][by ][bottr ][sides' ][the]writ petition [is ][allowed ][by ][following ][the ][orders ][passed ][by]this Court in [W.P.No.S32'7 ][of ][2OO8' ][dated ][l6'L2'2O22 ][arrd]also setting [aside ][the ][impugned ][orders ][passed ][by ][the]PRCG'No'B/ [86212OO9' ][dated]respondent [No.2 in ]06.06.2011 [and ][consequently, ][the respondents ][are directed]to issue title [deeds ][and ][pass ][books ][to the petitioner ][for the]suit schedulc [land. ][There ][shall ][be ][no order ][as ][to ][costs']

It

\

{

/

,/

t'

SIT,JW.P.No.17816 of 2O1 1

7. Misceilaleous petitions, if any, pending shall stand closed.That Rule [Nisi has ][been ][absolute ][as ][above']witness [the Hon'ble ][ti;';;i;f ][J;"ii"" ][ALoK ][ARADHE' ][on ][this ]Tuesday, [the ][Thirty ][ri"t ][a""v ][Jf-o"""'u"i' ][f*t ][Thousand and Twenty ][four']

SD/. A.V.S.PRASADASSISTT REGISTRARSOFFICER

//TRUE [COPY//]

To,1. The Collector, [Ranga ][Reddy ][District' ][Khairtabad'tlyderabad']; +nI il;ili, trroliaoao [Mlndal' ][Ransa ][Reddv ][District']'r. iiii &$ CP ;oR C;#iiiiliGr'tourttoit'e [state ][orreransana ][at]Hvderabad. [OUTI1. The Collector, [Ranga ][Reddy ][District' ][Khairtabad'tlyderabad']; +nI il;ili, trroliaoao [Mlndal' ][Ransa ][Reddv ][District']'r. iiii &$ CP ;oR C;#iiiiliGr'tourttoit'e [state ][orreransana ][at]Hvderabad. [OUTI- diiL [luaesH ][BABU' Advocate ][[oPUCl]3l:"#;; 3l:"#;; l^'JIr"f,?^?:'?lo, [., ][order ][dated ][16'12'2022'in ][w'P'No'8327 ][or ][2008)]SABSR w /

HIGH COURT

DATED:31 11212024

ORDERWP.No.17816 of 2011.(\ IHE si4It\\\)i.rO1O FEB 2M.c)il'fr':. ". '.j- ALLOWING THE W.PWTHOUT COSTS.

gGddk*

OURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.SARATHPETITION No.8327 of 28

ORDER:

This writ pis filed for the following relief an Order, Dtrection or a Wit more porticularlgone irt theWit of Mandamus restraining the req)ondentsfrom [imple]the orders passed by the respondent No.2 inD;No.925/ 928.02.1999 which was anfirmed tn appealbg the reNo.l uide case No. EY 1910/1999 dated22. t 2.2007,them as illegal, uoid and consequentlg setaside the s

2. karned Standing Counsel for theIF,."oGovernment Pleader for Assessmentsior

3. for the petitioner submitted that theAc.3 -23 Guntas in Survey No. 177 /2O, 35inSAc.2.14 Cuntas in S.No.l77 /7 , Ac.l.25IIln22 Guntas in S.No.177/7, 32 Guntas [in ][S.No]

iItt,l.ttI1l

that the Sun,<i:177 was subdivided into 39 pots and alsomentioned in tcolumn in Wasul Baqui Sethwar in Urduithain between Himayatsagar and AziznagarVillages andin Aziznagar Village and that the landsLlarerned Counsel submits that respondentsarecommunication of the Mandal Revenueoflicer, Moinaotll';n"."," it has been stated that, ["there ]is noi.".o.a ,u.it.utJ iilithis olfice about assignments of this particularland to oJ"Uibecause the names of pattadars appeared in"", Revenue *..o.1 flght from 1954-55".,i'C6unset s. m" r-""rl"Jfor the petitioner further submitted thattt r""po.,a".,tJ Jh.rifailed to appreciate the ratio laid down in the" judgment repol.ili*1996 (4) ALD 572 (DB) Nimmagadda RamaDevi Vs DistricdJr"",o. which held on analysis of the provisions ofthe Act that onlvilnL,e there is a condition of non alienation whileIassigning the lJrlL,.,if the l;rnd is assigned is under the provisionsof the AP r-""aJntf";. [(Ceiting ]of Agriculture Holdings) Act 1973 [it]would be ,.",I& iind *ithi., the meaning of the Act, where theassignment ," Llh.t, any such condition as to non alienation [it]would not o. land under the Act and it has no application.""tr$iJe 6. Th" L"^.tJiCounsel ftrr the petitioner turther submitted thatthat even inhere assigned land is allotted under LaoniRules of l95Oi()n [lcnch held in 1977 [(4) ]ALD 294 that the

!i7*w l' No 1J327 ol2008SK, IjWasool Baquiprepared in the year 1961 the Sy.No.f77/l to:I39 shown as palands.1 1. 'The [le]e Mandal Revenue Officer in Lr.No.B/3180/95dated 21.07.19dressed to the District Collector that 'l haveverified thefrom the year 1954 55 {Khasras) wherein it isrecorded thaturvey y.No. 177/8, 12, 13 and 20 are asiiKothakancha,t1except the survey number 177/l & L77/39riwhich are recoessarkari porampoke. These details are carriediiupto 1981-82I And all of a sudden in the vear 1982-83 it isrecorded asf,{t," [.g.,n., ][each survey ][number ][(The ][extracts]are submittedsal)- The reasons for rvriting as Loani patta arenot known.is no record available in this office aboutassignment oficuiar iand to any person, because the namesof pattadarsred in Revenue Records right from 1954-55".IBut the respots are unable to producc the assignment pattasissued to thepoor persons72. After h,Jl n ancl vcrilying the original records, this"ro.r Court is ofidered view that as per the letters of the1Assistant DIS&SLN, datecl 22.1l.1996 and the thenTahsildar, Mandal datecl 2LO7.1997 clearly shows thatrithere is no reTiivailable aboul l hc assi(nnrent of land to thelandless poorin Sy.No.177 o[ Azeeznagar Village and theI ilconcerned aureported th.rt the s;ricl land is patta land iIIi 85K'w P Na.8321 ol 200813. In vi,:u' of the same, the authobasing on thepresumptiorrs passed impugned orders and theue records fromit1995 cannor be taken into account. This Cofie and again heldthat there shall be condition of non-alienatipnthe Assignmentpatta. The [-espondents ]failed to produce theaslni pattas andIthe question of proceedings under A.P.Assi11efids (POT) Act,1977 does not arise. not arise. arise. The [[judgement ]]relied bybyLearned Counselfor thc petitioner thc petitioner petitioner apply to the instant case. to the instant case. instant case. case. ;tiitI 3. 3. [n vrew of the same, this Writ vrew of the same, this Writ of the same, this Writ the same, this Writ same, this Writ this Writ Writ Petitignto be allowed.ili1Accordingly, allowed. There shall no order asno order asas14. Miscellaneous applications, pending if apstand closedf1ffCE: K.SARATH

1977 does not arise. not arise. arise. The [[judgement ]]relied bybyfor thc petitioner thc petitioner petitioner apply to the instant case. to the instant case. instant case. case. ;I 3. 3. [n vrew of the same, this Writ vrew of the same, this Writ of the same, this Writ the same, this Writ same, this Writ this Writ Writ PetitignAccordingly, allowed. There shall no order asno order asas Dated:16 12 2022

blt

II