CCCA/177/2001 of Gulab Chand Vs Bal Ram on 30 December 2021

IN THE HIGH GOURT FOR [THE STATE ][OF ][TELANGANA]

AT HYDERABAD

THURSDAY, THE THIRTIETH [DAY ][OF DECEMBER]TWO THOUSAND AND [TWENTY ][ONE]

PRESENT

THE HONOURABLE [SRI ][JUSTICE M'LAXMAN]

ctTY CIV[L ][COURT APPEA][ L ][NO: ][17][7 ][0F ][2001]

Appeal under [Sectior] ][96 ][of ][CPC ][against ][the ][Judgment ][and ][decree ][dated]29.12.2000 in [O.S.No.96'1 ][of]1993 on the file of [the ][Court ][of the I ][Senior ][Clvil Judge']City Civil Court, HYderabad.

Between:

Gulab Chand, S/olat4 Bulchand, [aged about ][43 ][years, ][R/o ][H'No 9-1-34/12l4']Langar House, [HYd]erabad

... (Plaintiff) APPELLANT

AND

1Bal Ram, S/o [late ][Bulchand, aged ][57 ][years, ][Rl/o.H.No.1.0.3.761137., ][Vijayanagar]ffi[;;,'h;;;;;oio.liie? [pliins ][+ ][t6 ][t ][z ][vide ][c'o ][dt'05 ][1 1 ]['202'1 )]ffi[;;,'h;;;;;oio.liie? [pliins ][+ ][t6 ][t ][z ][vide ][c'o ][dt'05 ][1 1 ]['202'1 )]

2. Lal Chand, [S/o ][late Bulphand. ][aged ][52 ][years' ][Fl/-o-H ][No ][17-3-782' Yakutpura']' ao t z vide c-o dated 05 11 2021)Hy'd;;;i; aiir-]5 ' ao t z vide c-o dated 05 11 2021)Hy'd;;;i; aiir-]5

3. Suraj, S/o [late Bulchand ][R/o ][H'No ][13-5-332' ][S9b1i ][Mandi' ][Hyderabad]

R-1 : Balram [(Died ][per ]{R. [r.e,pond"nts ][4 ][to ][12)]

4. Smt. Sumitra [Bai ][W/o []ate ][Balram' ][aged 72 ][years' ][Occ: Housewife' ][Fl/o ][']H.No.10-3-761, [Vijayadagar Colony' Hyderaoao']H.No.10-3-761, [Vijayadagar Colony' Hyderaoao']

5. - Smt. Anita [W/o ][Late ][Bqlram, aged ][5Q ][years' Occ: Housewife' ][Fl'to' ][H'No ][10-3-]161 , Vijayanagar [Coloqy' Hyderabad']161 , Vijayanagar [Coloqy' Hyderabad']

6. - Smt. 7or, Vii"vanagar Sunita [W/o. ]Colody, Hyderabad'[Late ][Balram, aged.47 years' Occ: Housewife' ][R/o ][H ][No ]['10-3-]

7. ' Sri Santosh [S/o. ][Late ][Balram' aged ][40 ][years' Occ: Business' ][F/o ][H'No ][10-3-]70r, Vijrvanagar Colorly, Hyderabad'70r, Vijrvanagar Colorly, Hyderabad'

8. Sri Ganesh [S/o. Late ][eltram, ][aged ][37 ][years' Occ: Business' ][R/o ][H ][No'10-3-]- 70r, Vijrvanaoar Colorjv, Hvderabad'- 70r, Vijrvanaoar Colorjv, Hvderabad'

9. Sri Kishaore [S/o ][Late ][Ealram, ][aged ][34 ][years' ][Occ: ][Business' ][F/o' ][H'No'10-3-]761 , Vijayanagar [Colony, Hyderabad']761 , Vijayanagar [Colony, Hyderabad']

'10.Sri Mukesh S/o. Late eflram, [aged ][31 ][years' Occ: Business' ][Fl/o' ][H'No'10-3-]761 , Vijayanagar [Colorly, ][Hyderabad]761 , Vijayanagar [Colorly, ][Hyderabad]

1 1 . Sri Nandu s/o. [Late ][eairam, aged ][2g ][years, ][occ: ][Business, ][Fl/o. H.No.'l0-3-761 ][,]Vilayanagar [ColonY' HYderabad']Vilayanagar [ColonY' HYderabad']

12.Sri Babuloo [S/o. ][Late ][eptram' ][aged ][28 ][years' ][Occ: Business' ][Fl/o' H ][No'10-3-]761, Vijayanagar [Colon!, ][Hyderabao']761, Vijayanagar [Colon!, ][Hyderabao']

'..PROPOSED [PARTIES-LEGAL HEIRS ][OF ][RESPONDENT ][No"t]

{Resoondents [4 ][to ][13 ][broughton ][re.cord LR ][of ][1"t ][Resoondent as per ][Court]brder dated [os.1 ][1 ][.202i'v"iiE'ix'r'iils ]"i [2ori ][ln ][n.s.ttcj.tz7 ][of ][2001)]

R-2: G. Lalchand [(Died per LRs ][respondents ][13 ][to ][17)]

13. G. Shakuntala [W/o. ][Lat]G. Lalchand, [Aged ][60 ]Y[ears, Occ: ][Household,' ][R/o ][1- ][1-]1 68, Shrungeri [ColonY,][ N/][ohan Nagar, ][KothaPet'][ Hyderabad-500035]1 68, Shrungeri [ColonY,][ N/][ohan Nagar, ][KothaPet'][ Hyderabad-500035]

14 G. Dinesh Chand, [S/o. ][Late ][G. Lalchand, aS99^11ygars' Fvo'1-1-168' Shrungeri]Colony, Mohan [Nagar, Kothapet, Hyderabad-5uuuJ5]Colony, Mohan [Nagar, Kothapet, Hyderabad-5uuuJ5]

15.G. Satish '- Chand [S/o. ][Late ][G. ][Lalchand,age!!!^Y^ITS' R/o'l-1-168' ][Shrungeri]Ci,f".v, Hl"nin Uagar, Kothapet, Hyderabad-500035Ci,f".v, Hl"nin Uagar, Kothapet, Hyderabad-500035

'16.L. Premavati, W/o. Anil Kumar, D/o. Late G [Lalchand, aged ]11J.".":," R/;.Fi.N;.;-U -1isilln, noao t'to.s, Huda colonv' water Tank Shiv Nagar'kl Jn"nrigl,, [po.t ][otricbr, ][Bahadu ][rpura, Hyderabad-64]" R/;.Fi.N;.;-U -1isilln, noao t'to.s, Huda colonv' water Tank Shiv Nagar'kl Jn"nrigl,, [po.t ][otricbr, ][Bahadu ][rpura, Hyderabad-64]

17 " [p ]Raiini w/o. P. Kedharnath [D/o. ][Late G, Lalchand, aged ][39 ][years, H.No.12-7-]i-il.'ii^i ruo.rl+, Tulja Bhavani Towers, lr/ettugadda' Secunderabao'(Resoondents 13 lo 17 broughton record [LR ][of ][2nd ][Respondent ][as-p^qr^..]E;';{tiffi;;ridj os.ii.z-oii [,id" ][t.n.ruo'a ][ot ][2021in A'S'No'177 ][of ][2001)]...PROPOSED [PARTIES-LEGAL ][HEIRS OF RESPONDENT ][No'2]i-il.'ii^i ruo.rl+, Tulja Bhavani Towers, lr/ettugadda' Secunderabao'(Resoondents 13 lo 17 broughton record [LR ][of ][2nd ][Respondent ][as-p^qr^..]E;';{tiffi;;ridj os.ii.z-oii [,id" ][t.n.ruo'a ][ot ][2021in A'S'No'177 ][of ][2001)]...PROPOSED [PARTIES-LEGAL ][HEIRS OF RESPONDENT ][No'2]

CCCAMP. NO: [180 OF 2009]

PetitionunderSectionl5lCPCprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedinthe affidavit filed [therewith, ][the ][High Court may ][be ][pleased ][to ][grant ][ad-interim]injunction restraining [the ][respondent ][No.'l ][from alienating ][the ][item ]['1 ][of ][the ][schedule]property i.e., House Bearing [No. ][13-5-832, admeasuring ][484 ][sq ][yards' ][situated ][at]Sabji Mandi, HYderabad.

Counsel for [the ][Appellants: ][SRI DAMODAR MUNDRA]

Counsel forthe [Respondents: ][SRI M. ][VENKATA ][RAYUDU]

The Court delivered [the ][following: ][JUDGMENT]

Itrrerq-

I

THE HONURABLE SRIJUSTICE M. LAXMAN

C.C.C.A.N o.177 of 2001