Telangana High Court
MACMA/2055/2007 of THE NATIONAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED, SECUNDERABAD. Vs MEDEPUDI DHANA LAXMI AND 3 OTHERS on 31 December 2020
.ou*ll?TJE*toTffE oF TELANGANA THURSDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEMBER I,VO THOUSNND AND TWENTY Appeal filed Under Section 173 of M V' Act against the Order and Decree in M.V.O.P.No 3090 of 2005' dated 10-04-2007' on the file of the Court Chairman, Motor Accident Claims Tribunal-Cum-Chief
rN rHE [H|GH ][.ou*ll?TJE*toTffE ][oF ][TELANGANA]
THURSDAY, [THE THIRTY FIRST DAY ][OF ][DECEMBER]I,VO THOUSNND [AND ][TWENTY]
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE [SRI ][JUSTICE ][T' ][AMARNATH ][GOUD]
EOUS[AP][PEAL ][NO: 2055][ OF 2007]
MOTO RAC[CIDENT ][CIVIL][ MI][SCEL]
madeAppeal [filed ][Under ][Section ][173 of ][M ][V' ][Act ][against ][the ][Order and Decree]of thein M.V.O.P.No [3090 ][of ][2005' ][dated ][10-04-2007' ][on ][the ][file of ][the ][Court]Cou [rt,]Chairman, [Motor ][Accident Claims ][Tribunal-Cum-Chief ][Judge' ][City ][Civil]Hyderabad.
Between:
The National [lnsuran-ce ][C]i:f [d:iJf, ][:fr ][i'"x,?[x'fi ][:?i:iYsiifi?r]"['inilx'ffi ti-l-soyetaz. [2ndfloor']iG autnorized [signatory' ][Swapna'o<]O-smJngunl. [HYderabad']'l?l"t"".tld"uv c"*PrJ,, [Secuhderabad]
...APPellanUResPondent [No'2]
AND
1 tr,4edepudi [Dhana Laxmi' ][W/o ][M ][Murali ][Krishna-Occ ][House ][Wife R/o ][Flat]N o. o. [[1 ]]0 [[1, ][J ][avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[J ][avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[sh ][n ][a ]][[n ][a ]][[a ]]"p'h;"; [;[ ][:'i'i;;h' ][K ][Jm ][[a ]][I ][a n ][as ][ar' ][EC ][I ][L'][[*" ][R/o ][Frat ][no ]][[R/o ][Frat ][no ]][[Frat ][no ]][[no ]][[1 ][0 1']][[0 1']]N o. o. [[1 ]]0 [[1, ][J ][avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[J ][avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[sh ][n ][a ]][[n ][a ]][[a ]]"p'h;"; [;[ ][:'i'i;;h' ][K ][Jm ][[a ]][I ][a n ][as ][ar' ][EC ][I ][L'][[*" ][R/o ][Frat ][no ]][[R/o ][Frat ][no ]][[Frat ][no ]][[no ]][[1 ][0 1']][[0 1']]
Page 1 of 6
N o. o. [[1 ]]0 [[1, ][J ][avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[J ][avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[avakri ][sh ][n ][a ]][[sh ][n ][a ]][[n ][a ]][[a ]]"p'h;"; [[a ]]' [g;il:a:";[[3i ][*t?ii'R"',il",u,,T:s:efi ][f.:l ][[*" ][R/o ][Frat ][no ]][[R/o ][Frat ][no ]][[Frat ][no ]][[no ]][[1 ][0 1']][[0 1']][[House ][hold' ][R/o ]][[hold' ][R/o ]][[R/o ]][Flat][[House ][hold' ][R/o ]][[hold' ][R/o ]][[R/o ]][Flat]
3. M. Lakshmi [Vilasam' ][W/o M ][Venkateshwar ][l'19'^9"" ][[House ][hold' ][R/o ]][[hold' ][R/o ]][[R/o ]][Flat]r'r;ih [Kamalanagar' ][ECI ][L']r'r;ih [Kamalanagar' ][ECI ][L']No.'1 01, [Jayakrtshna ]"pltti'l;tt]t " "pltti'l;tt]t " (RR 2 and [3 ][died as ][per Lo ][Adalat Award passed ][dated ][07 ][11 ][2020)]
o3o39T,qt?""3?!R'"';,",r?1i,1#ll?".'S;llfl l'"?$iHIJ'"':1fl [:NoAP-](R4 died [for default vide Court ][Order ][dated ][l l ]['07 2016)](R4 died [for default vide Court ][Order ][dated ][l l ]['07 2016)]
.,.RESPONDENTS
Counsel [for the Appellant: ][SRI ][S' ][AGASTYA SHARMA]
Counsel [for the Respondent No'1: ][SRI ][L' ][HARISH]
Counsel [for the Respondent ][No' ][2 ][and ][3: ][----]
The Court [made the ][following: ][JUDGMENT]
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
MACMA No.2OS 5 0F 2007
JUDGMENT:
Durrng thc penrlcncl, ol Ll-re iLppc:111, Lllc nl:itt(,r u.as rclcrreclt,:) thc Lok.\<lal:.r[. a,cl tltc sarltc \\'as setrlc(l i]ulirrc Lltc L.k.,\cllilat.vidc Aryarcl clared 07, l 1 .2O 2A .t,:) thc Lok.\<lal:.r[. a,cl tltc sarltc \\'as setrlc(l i]ulirrc Lltc L.k.,\cllilat.vidc Aryarcl clared 07, l 1 .2O 2A .
Accorciilllr.., Lite N1,\CN,lA is clisposcr.l ol. lr tcl rrLS !rl Liruau,errd passcrl bl thc t,ok AclalaL. No ordcr ii:l lo cosls.
Page 2 of 6
Cr:n seclue n t11., ntiscell:rneous pi:tltions. iI anr.. penclitrg1n LlLts;rpp,;,. sl.r.l. st-no cl ,r, u SD/- I. NAGA LAKSHMIASSISTANT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER.
To,1. The Chairman, Motor Accident [Claims ][Tribunal-Cum-Chief Judge, ][City Civil]Court, Hyderabad. [(With ][Records)]2. One CC to Sri S. Agastya [Sharma, ][Advocate ]IOPUC]3. One CC to Sri L. Harish, [Advocate ]IOPUC]4. Two CD Copies (Along with a copy of Lok Adalat Award)MMKMMK
\
HIGH COURT
TAJDATED:311'1212020
JUDGMENTMACMA.No.2055 [of ][2007]
"t HE SIA14:o[s]-J3 23JAil2021z.\a)*0r.6t DISPOSING [THE ][M'A.C.M.A. ][IN ][TERMS OF ][LOK ][ADALAT AWARD']
NI
BEFORE TI.i[: i.CK [ADATAT]
HELD AT HYDERABAI)
[Orgonized [by ][High ][Courl I'egal ][Services ][Commiltee]High Courl [for ]lhe [Slote of ][Telongono](Through video Con,erence riode)
tzZ[zr ][)'!]
UrrderSeclionlgoltheLegolservicesAulhoritiesAct,l9ET(cenholAcl)]
MAC'!1A No. 2055 [at ][2AO7]
(Belore the Hon'ble High [Court)]
(Agoinsl lhe Order in OP.No. [3090 ][of ][2005 ][on ][lhe tile ol ][lhe Choilmon' ][Motor ][Accidents ][Cloims]Tribunol-cum [-Chiel Judge, City Civil Courl ][ot ][Hyderobod)]
Page 3 of 6
Appello nt/ [ResPo ][ndent ][No.z ]^.:iG Notionot [lnsuronce ][Compony ][Linriie][ cl,]Rep. by [iis ]Bronch [Moncrger, ][siluolt;'l oi]I 5-1 -5O3lB I [42, 2"d ][Fioor, ][behind holel]Rojdhoni. Ashok [morket, ][Feelkhono,]Osmongunj. [Hyderobod. ][ReP. ][bY ][its]ou thorizecl [si ][gnolory. ][Swopncrlok ][c ][orrrplex]SecunclerobodL fiespondents [(Petitioners ][&]liaedepudi Dhono [Loxmi, ][W/o. ][Muro]Krislrno. Aged [37 Yeors, ][Ot:c: ][Housewife]I Hespondent [No'l ])M.Venkoteshwor [Roo, ][S/o. ][Lo][te]M.Bhodroioh, [Aged ][85 Yeors, ][Occ: ][Nii']3M. Lokshmi [Vilosom. ][W/o. M.Venkoteshwor]L)Roo, Aged [7l ][Yeors. ][Occ: ][House ][Hold']HiGif co!.,R-!-All ore R/o. [Flot ][No. ][.t01, ][Joyokrishno]LOli AUiLr'iAporlments, [Norih ][Komolonogor, ][ECIL']Hderobod - [500 a62.]4.G.Chorrclro [Sekhor, S/o]G. Doso [rcrlho,]slAoeMojor. Occ: [Ora'ner ][of ][Vehiclc]NIO. AP-29/I-7317,R/o.C [72, ][ileor. l', ]['rrrir]Clr cken Cenlre, [Voncsllrct ][i1-rurc ][r']Fl!rr .rr-r ileclcly [Disiri'i1. ][530 ][i-r70']i _ _l .$i,i.'ij:tr'i:ilIl1'l [-:" ][u]INo of Droceedinqs [of lhe ][High ][Court ][Legol ][Services ][Conrnrillerr]bnoin noc.,ro [tb:slttcLsc/2020, ][Doted ][04-1 ][1-20201]:: Present [::]
: Hon'ble [Sri ][Juslice P.Noveen ][Roo']Judge, [High Court for ][the ][Stote ][of ][Telongono']Judge, [High Court for ][the ][Stote ][of ][Telongono']
Nome of Choirrnon
: [(1) ]Sri S. Surender [ReddY, ][Advocole']
llome of lVlernbers
t-ligh Court [for ][lhe ][Stote of ][Telongono]
(2) Smt. Nondilo [Guho, ][Advocote]'-' High Court for the Slote of Telongono/Sociol [Worker]'-' High Court for the Slote of Telongono/Sociol [Worker]
A\^/ARD
TheoboveCosebetweentheporlieshovingbeenreferredrlordeterminotion [to ][the ][LOK ADALAT ][ond ][the ][porlies ][hoving ][compromised ][lhe]cose / moller, [the ][following Aword ][is ][possed in lerms ][of the settlernenl:]
.$""\,-
Na"a, [o ][i]I
Page 4 of 6
Ia
.J'
/,'
'r [1 ]FirGH [Cfi ][!fli]j,I [,)lr. ]i.
t. The MACMA No. [2055 ][of ][2oo7 orises ][oul ][of ][lhe ][order ][dolefil]lO-4-2007 in OP.No. [3090 ][of ][2005 ][on the ][file ][of ][the ][Choirmon' ][Motor]lO-4-2007 in OP.No. [3090 ][of ][2005 ][on the ][file ][of ][the ][Choirmon' ][Motor]AccidentsCloimsTribunol-cum-ChiefJudge'CilyCivilCourt'Hyderobod.Hyderobod.
2. The Choirmon, [Molor Accidents ][Cloims Tribunol-cum-Chief ][Judge']City Civil Court, [Hyderobod, ][hos gronled ][compens][ tion ][of]Rs. 9,53,000/- [(Rupees ][Nine ][lokhs ][fifly ][three ][thousond ][o]ly) withproportionote costs ond interest [@ 6% ][per ][olnum ][from ][th]dote ofpetilion till the dote of deposii. [Aggrleved ][by ][the ][soid ][order']the lnsuronce Compony [hos ][preferred ][this oppeol ][vide]MACMA No. 2055 ol [2007.]City Civil Court, [Hyderobod, ][hos gronled ][compens][ tion ][of]Rs. 9,53,000/- [(Rupees ][Nine ][lokhs ][fifly ][three ][thousond ][o]ly) withproportionote costs ond interest [@ 6% ][per ][olnum ][from ][th]dote ofpetilion till the dote of deposii. [Aggrleved ][by ][the ][soid ][order']the lnsuronce Compony [hos ][preferred ][this oppeol ][vide]MACMA No. 2055 ol [2007.]
During the [pendoncy ]of [the oppeol ][the ][Respondents/Petilioners]No. 2 & 3 were died ond [the ][Respondent/Petilioner ][No ][l ][hos filed]deolh certificotes of the [Respondenls/Petilioners ][No.2 ][& ][3' ][The]No.l [is ][physicolly presenl ][olong ][wilh ][her]Respondent/Petilioner cou nsel.
3
Page 5 of 6
4. The Appellonl ond Respondenl/Pelilioner [No.l ][herein ][settled ][lhe]molter, os o result, lhe Appellont [No.2/lnsuronce ][compony ][inlends]to withdrow the oppeol. [The ][Appellont ]/ [2nd ][Respondenl ]- [Nolionol]lnsuronce Compony Limlted, [is ][represenled ][by ][Smt. ][Suiolho]who hos [represented ][online ][over ][the ][link]molter, os o result, lhe Appellont [No.2/lnsuronce ][compony ][inlends]to withdrow the oppeol. [The ][Appellont ]/ [2nd ][Respondenl ]- [Nolionol]lnsuronce Compony Limlted, [is ][represenled ][by ][Smt. ][Suiolho]who hos [represented ][online ][over ][the ][link]K.Kumor, Monoger, provided by the High Courl legol Services Commitlee, [High Court]for the Slole of Telongono, ond [she ][seeks ][permission ][to ][wilhdrow]the oppeol. Accordingly, ihe Appellonl [is ][permilied ][lo wilhdrow.]provided by the High Courl legol Services Commitlee, [High Court]for the Slole of Telongono, ond [she ][seeks ][permission ][to ][wilhdrow]the oppeol. Accordingly, ihe Appellonl [is ][permilied ][lo wilhdrow.]
5. ln view of the comprornise [between]the Appellont ondRespondent/Pelitioner [No.'l ], [tl-re ][oppeol]stonds dlsposed [os]withdrown.Respondent/Pelitioner [No.'l ], [tl-re ][oppeol]stonds dlsposed [os]withdrown.
6. The lnsuronce Compony [is ][reody ][to ][deposit ][the ][remoining]decreelol omount with occrued [inleresl ][ofter ][giving ][due credil ][to]the omount olreody deposited, [within ][(30) ][doys ][from ][the ][dote ][of]receipt of copy of lhis oword.decreelol omount with occrued [inleresl ][ofter ][giving ][due credil ][to]the omount olreody deposited, [within ][(30) ][doys ][from ][the ][dote ][of]receipt of copy of lhis oword.
7. The Respondenl / Pelitioner No.l [is ]ol [liberty ][to ][withdrow ][the]remoining omount deposited in the [Tribunol/Motor ][Accidents]Cloirns Tribunol-cum-Chief Judge, [City ][Civil ][Couri ][ot ][Hyderobod.]remoining omount deposited in the [Tribunol/Motor ][Accidents]Cloirns Tribunol-cum-Chief Judge, [City ][Civil ][Couri ][ot ][Hyderobod.]
8The porties ore informed lhot [the ]court [fee. if ][ony, ][poid by ][ony ][of]them sholl be ref undedthem sholl be ref unded
).[a"a" t;G'r*
-lt,9. No order os to lhe [cosls ][of ]['the ][oppeol.]O.r1afrIFor "1 [a][N][ !ra-A]C.r. [- ][f-.r ][Ltd][']- -1,t". " r'<1 U ."-r,:---1r^. .rI [D.h-o- ][]ot*L-t ]aA,ppello:21Res [po ]ndent/Pelilioner [No.l]lnsu rOeComponyCounsel for'Respondent /Peiilioner [No.1]/a:arr.92l{a"a [,t'/fi'r"]MemberChoirmon8erDote07.11.2020';i(smmIttee )
Page 6 of 6
Loading citations and judicial treatment…