Telangana High Court

CMA/751/2012 of MANIGALLA KISHAN , RAMAN KISHAN Vs C. BAL REDDY AND ANO on 31 December 2020

COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD THURSDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEIVBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY PRESENT THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE G SRI DEVI CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 751 OF 2012 Appeal filed under Section 30 of Workmen's Compensation Act against the Order dated 19.05.20'12

IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

THURSDAY, THE THIRTY FIRST DAY OF DECEIVBERTWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY

PRESENT

THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE G SRI DEVI

CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS APPEAL NO: 751 OF 2012

Appeal filed under Section 30 of Workmen's Compensation Act against the Orderdated 19.05.20'12 made in W.C.No.265 of 1996 NF on the file of the Commissioner forEmployee's Compensation and Deputy Commissioner of Labour, at Nizamabad.Between:

IVANIGALLA KISHAN @ RAN/AN KISHAN, S/o. Balaiah, Labour on Contract basis,R/o. Yavapur Village, Toopran lt4andal, l\,4edak District.R/o. Yavapur Village, Toopran lt4andal, l\,4edak District.

, ..APPELLANT

AND

1. C. BAL REDDY, S/o. Yadi Reddy, Owner of Lorry bearing No. ABT-3150, F/o.H.No. 3-94, Bowanpally, Secunderabad, A.P.(Appeal against Respondent No.1is Dismissed vide Court order dated 2010712016)H.No. 3-94, Bowanpally, Secunderabad, A.P.(Appeal against Respondent No.1is Dismissed vide Court order dated 2010712016)

2. National lnsurance Company Ltd., through its Divisional lvlanager, DivisionalOffice, Secunderabad, A. P.Office, Secunderabad, A. P.

...RESPONDENTS

Counsel for the Appellant :SRl M. PRAKASH REDDY

Counsel for the Respondent 2 : SMT. SUJATHA K.KUMAR

The Court made the following: ORDER

HONOURABLE JUSTICE G. SRI DEVICIVIL MISCtrLLANEOUS APPEAL NO.751 OF [2012]JUDGMENT:

Pursuant to a settlemcnt arnved at betu'cen the [parties, ][tI-rc']I-ok Ad:ilat, Hvclerabad, passecl ihe follot ing :ru-ard [ot-r ][07. ][1 ][1.2O20:]L ['l'his ]C.N4.A. arises outr. ol the order dated [19.O5.2012 itr]W.C.Nc..265 oI 1996 on the lile ol the Commissiotrer [lbr]Workmen's Compensation and Deput,v* Commissioner [of]Labour, at Nizamabad.L ['l'his ]C.N4.A. arises outr. ol the order dated [19.O5.2012 itr]W.C.Nc..265 oI 1996 on the lile ol the Commissiotrer [lbr]Workmen's Compensation and Deput,v* Commissioner [of]Labour, at Nizamabad.

2. The Commissi.oner for Workmen's compe nsation [and]Deputy Commissioner of Labour at Nizamabad [in]W.C.No.265 of 1996 has granted compensatiot-l ol'Rs.1,13,843i rncluding costs ancl Advrrcate lee. Aggner [r:c1]br- the said order, the appiicanL prei'errcd an appcal [r ][iclt:]C.M.A.No.751 ot 2Oi2.Deputy Commissioner of Labour at Nizamabad [in]W.C.No.265 of 1996 has granted compensatiot-l ol'Rs.1,13,843i rncluding costs ancl Advrrcate lee. Aggner [r:c1]br- the said order, the appiicanL prei'errcd an appcal [r ][iclt:]C.M.A.No.751 ot 2Oi2.

3. During the pendencv of appeal both the pzrrties havecompromised the malter.compromised the malter.

4. The Appeliant/ ApplicanL along u,ith his counsei SriM.Prakash Redd1,, Advocate, has represented belore thevirtual Lok Adalat through online or,er the link provrdcd bvthe High Court Legal :rtrvices Committee, High Courr lbrlhe Stale of Telangana.M.Prakash Redd1,, Advocate, has represented belore thevirtual Lok Adalat through online or,er the link provrdcd bvthe High Court Legal :rtrvices Committee, High Courr lbrlhe Stale of Telangana.

5. ['lhe ]Respondent No.2 - National Insurance Companr'Limited, Smt. Sujatha Ii. Kumar. Manager, has representedbelbre the rrirtual Lok Adalat through online over the linkprovided bv the High Court Legal Serrrices Committee, HrghCourt for the State olTelangana.Limited, Smt. Sujatha Ii. Kumar. Manager, has representedbelbre the rrirtual Lok Adalat through online over the linkprovided bv the High Court Legal Serrrices Committee, HrghCourt for the State olTelangana.

Page 1 of 5

6Both the parties stated that they resolvecl the disputeamicablv and entered into compromise. TheAppellant/ Applicant has serlt copr. of Aadhar carci in proolof his idcr-r tifica rion. The m:ttter has been sertled amicirb1r.betu'een thc. parties.amicablv and entered into compromise. TheAppellant/ Applicant has serlt copr. of Aadhar carci in proolof his idcr-r tifica rion. The m:ttter has been sertled amicirb1r.betu'een thc. parties.

The Appeilant/Appiicant has agreeci to receive an amolur rof Rs.1,63,0OO/- (Rupees One lakh sixty rhr:ee rhousandonlv) tov.ards lull and final settlement apart from theamount aq,arded b1.. the Cornmissioner lor Workmen,sCompensation and Deputr. Commissioner of Labour- atNizamabad.

8Accordtngly the au,ard is passed for an amounl o1Rs.1,63,O00/- (Rupees One lakh sixt). three thousand onlvJtor,r,ards full and final settlement apart from the amollntas,arded b1' the Commissioner for Workmcn'sCompensation and Deputv Commissioner of Labour atNrzarnabad.

The Rcspondcnt No.2,i L'rst,r.ance Companl. has to dt,ltostrrhe a\\':rrcicd .tmounL Ol i.:.. 1 ,ir3,OOOi (Rupees O]rC l:rl<hsixtl thr:ee thoLrsar-rcl on11.) tou-ar-ds full ar-rd flnal settlemcnt$'rthrn a periocl of tu'o (2) months from the date of reccipr ofcop_rr of rhis atr,ard apart from the amount au,arcled bv theCommissioner for Workmen's Compensation and Deput1,.Commissioner of Labour at Nizamabad. after giving duecredrt to the amount a1read1. deposited. In the event o1'default ol delar- in making such deposit, the arnour-rrpa1'able shali carry interest at 72.k per annum il-om thedate of default.

Page 2 of 5

10. Upon such deposit, the Appellani is ar libertl' to rvithdrau'the entire amount.the entire amount.

1 1. In terms of the compromise arrii'ed atr bet\\,ecn the p:rrLies.this case stands disposed of.this case stands disposed of.

1 2. The parties are informed that the Court fe e, if an1", paid b1, any of them before lolr,er Court shal1 be rellnded.

In vieu, of the au,ard dated 07.11.2O2O, passed b-,- the LokAdalat, Hyderabad, this Civil \,1iscellaneous Appeal is clisposed ofin terms of the ar,vard.

Miscellaneous applications, if an1', pending shall standclosed.Sd/-K.GANGADHAR RAOJOINT REGIST'.AR,TRUE COPY///f\-.'SECTION OFFICERclosed.Sd/-K.GANGADHAR RAOJOINT REGIST'.AR,TRUE COPY///f\-.'SECTION OFFICER

To,

1. The Commissioner for Workmen Compensation and DeputyCommissioner of Labour , at Nizamabad.Commissioner of Labour , at Nizamabad.

2. One CC to SRl. LAKKADI DAYAKER REDDY Advocate IOPUCI

3. One CC to SRl. . M. PRAKASH REDDY, Advocate IOPUC]

4. One CC to SRI Smt.Sujatha K.Kumar, Advocate IOPUC]

5. Two CD Copies

u$v

HIGH COURTGSDJ

DATED:31 11212020

ORDERCMA.No.751 of 2012

DISPOSING OF THE C.M.A.In terms of the lok Adalat Award \2qtdv HE STA('qr)u20J,,1iT 2021zC)1..Jr'-;l;a:?

BEFORE THE LOK ADALATHELD AT HYDERABAD(Organized by High Court Legal Services [Committee]High Court for the state [of Telangana)](Under Section 191f the Legal Services [AuthoritieqAct, ][1987 (Central]

o'

Legal (llroryh via,o Act) [Loa,[ronQ ][ndz ][)]

CMA No. 75L ot 2OLz

(Before the Hon'ble High Court)Against the order in [W.C. ][No' ][265 ][of ][1996 ][NF ][on ][the ][file ][of the]Comm'issioner for Workmen,s [Compensation ][and ][Deputy Commissioner]of Labour at [Nizamabad, ][dt' ][19th ][May 2O12)]

(No. of proceedings of the High [Court ][Legal Services ][Committee:]ORDER ROC No. [1035/HCLSC/\OZO, ][Dated ][04-11-2020']

:rPresent::

:Hon'ble Sri Justice [P.Naveen ][Rao,]Judge, High Court [for the ][State of Telangana]

:(1) Sri S.Surender [Reddy, ][Advocate,]High Court for the State [of Telangana]High Court for the State [of Telangana](2)Smt.Neindita Guha, [Advocate,]High Court for the [State ][of ][Telangana/]Social WorkerHigh Court for the [State ][of ][Telangana/]Social Worker AWARD

The a bovecase between the [parties having ][been ][referred ][for]determination to the [LoK ][ADALAT ][and ][the ][parties having ][compromised ][the]case/matter. the [following Award ][is passed in ][terms ][of ][the settlement']

l.ThisCMAarisesoutoftheorderdatedlg-05-2012inW'C'No'265of1996onthefileoftheCommissionerforWorkmen'sCompensationand Deputy Commissioner [of ][Labour, ][at ][Nizamabad']1996onthefileoftheCommissionerforWorkmen'sCompensationand Deputy Commissioner [of ][Labour, ][at ][Nizamabad']

2. The Commissioner for [Workmen;s ][Compensation ][and ][Deputy]Commissioner of Labour [at ][Nizamabad ][in ][W ][C' ][No ][265 ][of ][1996 ][NF has]grantedcompensationofRs.l,l3,S43/-includingcostsandAdvocatefee. Aggrieved by [the ][said ][order, ][the ][applicant preferred an ][appeal]vide C.M.A'No.757 of [2072.]Commissioner of Labour [at ][Nizamabad ][in ][W ][C' ][No ][265 ][of ][1996 ][NF has]grantedcompensationofRs.l,l3,S43/-includingcostsandAdvocatefee. Aggrieved by [the ][said ][order, ][the ][applicant preferred an ][appeal]vide C.M.A'No.757 of [2072.]

}{a,r;tLq/l'*

Page 3 of 5

F"c.$

the [pendancy ][of ][appeal both ][the ][parties ][have compromised the]During matter.matter.

3.

4. The Appella [nt/Applica ][nt ][along ][with ][his ][counsel ][Sri ][M'Prakash ][Reddy']Advocate, has [represented before ][the ][virtual ][Lok Adalat ][through ][on]line over the link [provided ][by ][the ][High Court ][Legal ][Services]Committee, [High Court ][for the ][State ][of ][Telangana']Advocate, has [represented before ][the ][virtual ][Lok Adalat ][through ][on]line over the link [provided ][by ][the ][High Court ][Legal ][Services]Committee, [High Court ][for the ][State ][of ][Telangana']

5The Respondent [No.2 ]- [National Insurance Company ][Limiuted,]Smt.Sujatha [K'Kumar, ][Manager, ][has ][represented ][before ][the ][virtual]LokAdalatthroughonlineoverthelinkprovidedbytheHighCourtLegal Services [Committee, ][High ][Court ][for the State ][of ][Telangana']Smt.Sujatha [K'Kumar, ][Manager, ][has ][represented ][before ][the ][virtual]LokAdalatthroughonlineoverthelinkprovidedbytheHighCourtLegal Services [Committee, ][High ][Court ][for the State ][of ][Telangana']

Both the [parties ][stated ][that ][they ][resolved ][the ][dispute amicably ][and]entered [into compromise. ][The ][Appella ][nt/Applica ][nt ][has ][sent ][copy of]Aadhar card [in proof of ][his ][identification' ][The ][matter ][has ][been ][settled]amicablY between [the ]Pa [rties ][']entered [into compromise. ][The ][Appella ][nt/Applica ][nt ][has ][sent ][copy of]Aadhar card [in proof of ][his ][identification' ][The ][matter ][has ][been ][settled]amicablY between [the ]Pa [rties ][']

Page 4 of 5

The Appellant/Applicant [has ][agreed ][to ][receive ][an ][amount ][of]Rs.1,63,000/- [(Rupees ][One ][lakh ][sixty three ][thousand ][only) ][towards]fullandfinalsettlementapartfromtheamountawardedbytheCommissioner [for ][Workmen,s Compensation ][and ][Deputy ][Commissioner]of Labour at [Nizamabad.]

iii,l,l1:')Ui''1l-CK [AL';"-'; ]B,

Accordingly [the ][award ][is ][passed ][for ][an ][amount ][of Rs' ][L'63tOoO I ][-](Rupees One lakh sixty [three ][thousand ][only) ][towards ][full ][and]final settlement [apart from ][the ][amount ][awarded by ][the ][Commissioner]for Workmen's [Compensation ][and Deputy ][Commissioner ][of ][Labour ][a't]Nizamabad.

The Respondent [No.2/Insurance Company has ][to ][deposit ][the ][awarded]amount of Rs. [1,63,000/- ][(Rupees One ][lakh ][sixty three ][thousand only)]towards full [and ][final ][settlement ][within ][a ][period ][of two ][(2) ][months]from the date of [receipt ][of ][copy ][of ][this ][award apart ][from the ][amount]awarded by the [Commissioner ][for ][Workmen's ][Compensation ][and]Commissioner [of ][Labour ][at ][Nizamabad, ][after ][giving due ][credit]Deputy to the amount [if ][any ][already ][deposited' ][in ][the ][event ][of ][default ][or]delay in making [such deposit, ][the ][amount ][payable ][shall carry ][interest]at \2o/o [per ]annum [from the ][date of ][default']

9.

10. Upon such [deposit, ][the ][Appellant ][is ][at ][liberty ][to ][withdraw ][the ][entire]a mou nta mou nt r_tIn terms bf t5e compiomise [arrived ][at ][between ][the ][parties, ][this ][case]stands disPosed [of.]stands disPosed [of.]

72. The parties are informed that the court [fee, if any, ][pald by any ][of ][them]before lower court shall be refunded.

.I-d. R.For * Slrqa[Nation]eCo. Ltd$lr&r-{sAppellant/ApplicantRespondent Norpa nyICounsel for Appell anl/antN(q):-,ottrairmanMember,Au/ta-',,,t.:Date: 07- 11-2020(:l i[Hr6l'l ][couR ][r]LOI'r ALiALliiic 011o( Seal oe Committee)

Page 5 of 5

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead