Armed Forces Tribunal
Judgment & Order dated 27 Apr 2022 OA-47 of 2019 on 27 April 2022
?
AF
O2
g ,=
E;
b =
xe
i F E3H
s 8 *;'
Ja=li
O
O
7a
6 g sE
a.
z,D
rcl
r
v
= fi c a
5 +
EElg { { sfF
a s "G o
E E
==li + + P'an
(J
=
=
>
;
:
EEI:
= rp or ;
tr a
rFlS
o o ;Ag
6- =
= =
j
€
mm'" P 21 1
or
e:glEaHHqs i:=
:E gEi*
L+= = F rD p = or =
=
=
q 6
fl=
I
I
6' x
q E = i
F B' + ,, - -:
= ; P
2G 6- = P e
JEde
A=r: #qg a*P
ii
9'i+ e=
= 7 d =
"= Aq 3=i ; g E= iH .+ E i
<- a q B
.--a 3 E h E : z F
*H
6 d
"' (r 6- L
q b r + d. e g =
Efi
u
6- 8 I =
;p
+e e
- --
o-
s = 6 \o
€ q ; = 1 E i g U Fg
=o".-dqss +r+S+ q31SgE=
=k=
cdgo$'=i'.ro,=iD
= + H E
I X 3 a 6 q -r
S'" FA ;fl4
tJ.)J
rD o = rF
..e,-{ L 3g
= = !
tr-sl
., q
: = s ", I
E : 3.
iF
#4.=
a^ d I E
I d A a i d 3 €*
=3 =
o
" E 1 =
===;l
:i : ^
f 6 q :
:
e q +;
=; a;+
q {
f; ? s d g
g d s u
ga i'a n
; (n
s H = s g
:o'rr
5 e
ts q E. A o_
O- ='
o
= s o
o
OJ-r=
= q d.+ iaF€$
3 3
2 o i * I
-(DJg:F.rD:r
*Sra 3€833 i=
A*
=-rI=)o;oJrD.\?r-
d 3 d u
=+I4+
q S
E
=
Page 1 of 5
=.'
g q 3 =r
-i
a
=o X E
B--dgSq
f ;
E iiig IEE 1E EEiiEg l I $i ; F iig
HIEEi igiEEi IEii i f i i i i 3E iE
Eif i i } i i FEE lii i iE?gE i+ [Ei
5e as *B i 4 * $ {csE g ; * ifi? ;H iE +
fl fl $E 3
HE f, i *$ ?ig AEi iEE
-*EE
l\)
g#f tgfl3$EEEI
$iq
q[s
lfrTg.*HxFE
4 e - 5' I ; = S + 3 ii ; E oss* !,\a." \s:N, L<,1 t fi i E i + F fl $ F $ B q i F 3 $$$$$$$;s$ilN$ i I 3
s E ; E
s
s E i $ B I E E $:$$ $$i $$$$ $$ s E $
gq-E
i
n $ I E F I i E F [ [ [ E$$$ $$$
$$$$ $
s g
B
t * i ; e g i q E $ * i $$SF $$i *ss$ u s E
g * c * iE igE 5E [,$$$ s$S ]$i N s *
(,
- .1ii,l;
z.(o+
86d
JJ
Ln
ot
oJoJ
=rD
6J
(Do
Ot
f
'+r
J
/\)
P dE
olJ
J,1
o,oJ=
tna6-
oora
)6i
oo
=o-6
oilirl
l€
Il
-r
d;3
(DoJ
ncDf
6=a
/\-.
1f;
ood_
,'3o
lrD*E s4
oJu
5t+A
J)o6(D
(,-=)
-t
.+
rJ7o(D
oEsI
(Do=
o)f=a B1
o=!i (+
tU
-A
OJ
.(O
rD
rn
(D
=)oC
(^o)
t+
f(D
_T
rD
at
r3o)o_
rD
=
-fa
f
OJ
(D
=o
=
(Do-
oJ5
()oC)(+
rD
-t
o.,
=o-
OJ
t+
Our=cIo,E='H-=:t-c]O
Egd*e:,ePdPd-
613 q = = F =;1s
=rD65=o'fi'o'"-Fr-.,
a.i\-=^r:
h'qp-6'9=o=i;ag
0ale-60?=568==
= s q + E; = P H I e il 6
2='==o,or"i'.!d;9i=;r
toY{+6.tsr-'qFed
= = =,H +';:
B 6 b = =
=(Ddtul,_r:
3;
r o j*E
s=i*
g
il * E = iil a J q €,H $
lSas*SFqkv3e
E C q d 3 E = 3;
?" f
=
-cj-d'u,u_osISoP
d".EES-slI;
: q
=
+ E rD E;
d = F o
id 5 j
*;p-
a e H- J 3
Page 2 of 5
-."Et+q96';6'=-ia
= + =. 6 3 : + E g =*,= ?
? 6.3
3 3 = o id id'*
t
o
€ I .,tr-6
il=
E s::
g?
Ed 3 6fi 6;
g P3'ci
A
-UH +.-o = = + = o ..+F t
q
5E+iBd,H'9^oi
o_-
si6
d qt
= ts + = 3E'er-
i,B s q: i i *- d: a s
3 F -x B =*,8 3 3 e X d *
E;n a = 8- i d ad-g
o, a
+ + 3 d ? i A r s aE S
d rtB d i5
aE = goi18 z
+Eq;='stil
)J
rR
firdE
=ES
6pYa=rDru
-rCLES2Ur.o-o
3s +:e fid B
a o- €' iii
-r o-
gP -333qe
1.,qqgq-'5 qg4gds6d 6 =,e D -r iD ^ e s=."==qtgg, iq3;$."+Ha oJoJiDtr,-.) ==rD
u. -a'?r) =. u)-rE=U(D E 3; qq;ts (,-r+=(-) 0'E."'7+6-=q =(D-r* .!=roy(D:(D= (-) = or A' 39(n=d6ili SR."g;96 6'=il6-==3- +
Page 3 of 5
E i q E A H fi A ? s s 4 n * e -rWJ==i-n'=OI**OA= = 4E i 3 f ;1=
4. d = a a o, + =E = -, g + dfl P g 3 i il3,H *€ ; : q $ F5 i i q + * + H E 2\= ^r 6' q = P q n- = : 3 ; ; = = H + =t i A 8,9 = 3 E = 3 + 6 = E.5 d ilf a i H [ 1E i F fr i fr = fr: 3: ..-+ d +
- : : -l a 1 p s + f = E fi a =: = B = B + a 5 a g A = 61= a .Alua * : T E il 3 E r + q E 3 E H s a H o+.4 ;-or'Q965*rDf5 5Lo F = ti = o -rr + q i5- + g 6 q
=ro 'd = t] E = + il B-A = q =- 8 6 g xq 'I ;6 s- or :;3 -P 1E = + ? n +g $ il; = g H r e r q; E a q A q5 -r E a : + t" n + g 2; I g + rrDc= +
* I fi q_ I p = + iD o s; rD g o -, € +E: =.A [3 SB d-ie H :_ oi i I
i or LJ N)TGiq..-d.E",--:lqtga OOJY 5€ A q c :E d : f ; H = 6 tr = e : + A 3 ; ;
Page 4 of 5
p =.e p e d H E q '". E X (+ rD s I ,g.a _r+ id; =,oE- 3 f S H $g A fi +-Hil;aE:-n q+=., - ",* 3 :lt=lE==Eq+$5'", = (+ tJ. ., = :+ d,E q e = q; e,e 6 I I E =(4(.n- v_oJlv h =.(o rr, (O < ==qd J ='=(D =#,:; (DEOTD ='on.a '-r-E = -a o 8_E; d- LJJo z. et /+ i9 E z. o,6-9 or=(n =fogd fo- ; q or = = g =:-Jci' 6' o-o oJ o.' = =rD o-do- 5g! J O", (Dio- U JU (D-ta;\ =C +rD= A .i; { a=: oJg -t-r. o, o= grD rD= sd (DAo.r J= -!OJo-X o'8 ^E =o_ JEd(n a(o'= =rD sd )o_f V(D (Do- (n rooo' =-r o_(Do- =-S Z.o OC . =F, (.rto = o,aq gr
5@-octc,ooJ-{ 5E?--'o--a
AgFi=B
0. :' I .., q g q5 rDo=Eil,EU.ns ooSarD= = E (o K i E = 3 \i Ed g;Ei=3s=PEd =.3o-dq(D=io ; o lP E B r- ?
o- = = H E iO G g I E- a=:l(Jio'E :.,qd=.+ogq =6''ro='=d+=.
E s 3f; f 83 fr
0d_3rDEEErD-r +rD+orgqg+8 = 3 ga*34 * o +bi-rr oq==- =. (+ :t J -,:.' J o_ 1 tr 6 '3 i q r e f fH6 -dFg_H€ I
= E: ;; P d A ; I 9d8=--E=o 'X'HrDrD4=-+, =c)X-5=aa (+rD=9rdor J5oJ--y,Lo-'r -.(Droi-d6_'. w=.rD6E(-rraB rDVESt=o.,ru = drD+o-o-r F ='6 Oe; B- F Lr m oz rcl >E E> u3 l1I 6 xt,
1v 3F 3= EII - EE A lia >N ox Ol
Page 5 of 5
Loading citations and judicial treatment…