Precedent

Karnataka High Court

WA/200062/2026 of DIPALI BIRADAR Vs THE UNION OF INDIA on 18 February 2026

Cites 0, Cited by 0

NC: 2026:KHC-K:1585-DB WA No. 200062 of 2026 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA KALABURAGI BENCH DATED THIS THE 18TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026 PRESENT THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE R.NATARAJ AND THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE TYAGARAJA N. INAVALLY WRIT APPEAL NO.200062 OF 2026 (EDN-AD) BETWEEN 1. DIPALI BIRADAR,

Citations and Judicial Treatment

No citing decisions in the index yet

Cited by

0

Decisions in the index citing it

Cites

0

Decisions referred to

In this index

0

Of the decisions it cites

Overruled / Questioned

0

No negative treatment found

Loading the citing and cited decisions…

   

  



 

    

 ! "#$$  "#$$% !!



&'        

        

        

     

 !  "  

#!  

 $    

        

        

     

 !  "  

#%   &  

        

     

Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

   

  



 

  

     

 !  "  

#'  '

   

        

        

     

 !  "  

#     

        

        

     

 !  "  

#!(  !        

     )  

   

))     

* ! "  

         

  %         

     

* ! 

   

  



 

"  

        +     ,      ) 

             )   

     +,   ) ) $ ) 

  )      $ *(((   )   )  +,  !*!   "    $ (( 

         

"

 )    '  "

  

 *!((

    

    '   -     

  $   

 !((

     -     .    +   

 " 

)   /   "   )  /    "   )  ',   $  )   ')    

      

    ) 

  ) )    

 "

$ ((%(%(!            

   

  



 

!((! $((%(%(!      

  "

           

       - )    

               )  

 -)      '    $    )  ((! )   

   0  - )       )"  0      

  )         "

 $        1   "   " 234 1   " 

 "  $# + 1   "   ",  5676 28869923:7 2;6 2<<;=6>64 ?@ :56 A;46; 42:64 !((! 827764 ?@ :56 962;364 =3<96 "B4<6 =3 $A((%(%(!;6CB7=3<:A<;23:23=3:6;=D A;46;  5628869923:A7!234%56;6=35248;A8A764 :A67:2?9=7523@B;>64=EA996<6=3:56@62;(#*(56 ADD=::66 288A=3:64 ?@ :56 ;678A3463: A =3786E:64 :56 A996<6 234 7B?D=::64 2 96::6; 8A=3:=3< AB: E6;:2=3 75A;:EAD=3<7 3 ;6E6=8: AC 7BE5 96::6;  28869923: A7!

   

  



 

234%28862;64?6CA;6:56ADD=::66234CB;3=7564:56=; E92;=C=E2:=A3 AF6>6;  23 A;46; 42:64 (%(# F27 827764 463@=3< 86;D=77=A3 :A :56 28869923: A7! 234 % CA; 24D=::=3< '( 346;

;24B2:6 7:B463:7 CA; :56  EAB;76 4B;=3< 2E246D=E @62; (#*( 5=7 F27 E529963<64?6CA;6:5=7AB;:=3$A(!(#56 962;364 =3<96 "B4<6 AC :5=7 AB;: =3 :6;D7 AC :56 A;46; 42:64 (%(!(  5694 :52: :56 A;46; 42:64 (%(# 75299?6:;62:6427275AFE2B763A:=E6234:5628869923: A7! 234 % F6;6 4=;6E:64 :A EAD89@ F=:5 :56 75A;:EAD=3<7 D63:=A364 :56;6=3 56;62C:6;  :56 ;6<B92:A;@ 2B:5A;=:=67 F6;6 4=;6E:64 :A ;6EA37=46; :56 2889=E2:=A3AC:5628869923:A7!234%=32EEA;423E6F=:5 92F56962;364=3<96"B4<6297A86;D=::64:567:B463:7 F5A F6;6 8B;7B=3< :56 EAB;76 :A 28862; CA; :56=; 6G2D=32:=A37 =3E6 :56 ;6HB67: AC :56 28869923: A7! 234 % F27 3A: EA37=46;64  :567:B463:7 AC:56 =37:=:B:=A3 C=964$A(%('234EA336E:6486:=:=A37766I=3< CA;24=;6E:=A3:A86;D=::56D:A28862;CA;:56B8EAD=3<

   

  



 

6G2D=32:=A37 AC :56 7:  34  ;4 234 ':5 @62; 234 :A ;6<B92;=76 :56=; 24D=77=A37 CA; :56 2E246D=E @62; ( * (# (#*( ((*56962;364=3<96"B4<6AC:5=7 AB;:=3:6;D7AC23A;46;42:64( ( 4=;6E:64:56 EA37=46;2:=A3 AC :56 ;68;6763:2:=A3 C=964 ?@ :56 7:B463:7 234 EA3:6D8A;236AB79@ 4=;6E:64 :52: :56 72D6 75299 ?6 EA37=46;64 ?@ A; ?6CA;6 ((! 3 :56 D623F5=96  :56 962;364 =3<96 "B4<6 4=;6E:64 :56 2J=>

2345= 3=>6;7=:@ AC 629:5 E=63E67 :A 233AB3E6 :56 ;67B9:7 AC :56 7:B463:7 F5A 524 :2I63 B8 :56 6G2D=32:=A37 =3 :56 DA3:57ACB<B7:23468:6D?6; (  56 28869923:7 EA3:6347 :52: :56=; ;68;6763:2:=A3=73A:@6:EA37=46;64234=3:56D623F5=96  :56 6G2D=32:=A37 52>6 EADD63E64 :A42@ 56;6CA;6  :56 28869923:7288;A2E564:5=7AB;:=3$A((%(%(! 56@ 7AB<5: CA; 2 4=;6E:=A3 :A86;D=: :56D :A 28862; CA; :56B8EAD=3<7: 34 ;4234':5@62;6G2D=32:=A356@ 297A7AB<5:CA;=3:6;=D;69=6C;6HB67:=3<CA;24=;6E:=A3:A

:A;696276:566G2DCA;D723486;D=:7:B463:7

   

  



 

:A 28862; CA; :56 B8EAD=3< 6G2D=32:=A3 AC  EAB;76 7:  34  ;4 234 ':5 @62; F5=E5 EADD63E67 C;AD ((!2C:6;EA996E:=3<:56;6HB=7=:6C66 ' :=7:56E276AC:5628869923:7:52::56962;364 =3<96"B4<6=77B643A:=E6:A:56ACC=E=29;678A3463:7?B:  4=4 3A: <;23: :56 =3:6;=D ;69=6C 6=3< 2<<;=6>64 ?@ :56 72D6 :5628869923:72;6?6CA;6:5=7AB;:  56 962;364 EAB3769 CA;

28869923:7 EA3:63464 :52: :56 28869923:7 52>6 ?663 86;D=::64 C;AD :=D6 :A :=D6 :A :2I6 B8 :56 6G2D=32:=A3 8634=3< EA37=46;2:=A3AC:562889=E2:=A3AC:5628869923:A7!234 % CA; 86;D=77=A3 6 7B?D=:7 :52: 7=3E6 :56 72=4 =77B6 =7 @6::A?6EA37=46;64 :5628869923:7E233A:?6468;=>64AC :56A88A;:B3=:@ACC2E=3<:566G2D=32:=A3756;6CA;6 56 8;2@7:52:8634=3<4=78A729AC:56F;=:86:=:=A3?6CA;6:56 962;364=3<96"B4<6 :5628869923:7?686;D=::64:A:2I6 B8:566G2D=32:=A3

   

  



 

! 56 962;364 EAB3769 CA; :56 ;678A3463: A7 234  F5A FAB94 7B?D=: =3 B3=7A3 :52: :56 HB67:=A3 F56:56;:5628869923:A7!234%2;663:=:964:A67:2?9=75 23 @B;>64=E A996<6 =7 8634=3< EA37=46;2:=A3 ?6CA;6 :56 ;678A3463: A 234 :56;6CA;6 299AF=3< :56 7:B463:7 :A EAD896:6:56=;EAB;76FAB94:23:2DAB3::A;6<B92;=7=3<23 =996<29=:@56@:56;6CA;67B?D=::52:B39677:5672=4=77B6 =7 EA37=46;64  :56 28869923:7 E233A: ?6 <;23:64 23@ 86;D=77=A3:A:2I6B8:566G2D=32:=A3 % 56 962;364 EAB3769 CA; :56 ;678A3463: A 7B?D=:7 :52: :56 6G2D=32:=A3 3A:=C=E2:=A3 F27 =77B64 =3 6E6D?6;  ( 234 :52: :56 28869923:7 52>6 F2=:64 :=99 :56927:42:623452>6288;A2E564:5=7AB;:?692:649@6 :56;6CA;67B?D=:7:52:3A=34B9<63E6E23?675AF3:A:56 28869923:7  56 962;364 EAB3769 CA; :56 ;678A3463: A' 7B?D=:7 :52: :56 ;678A3463: A' FAB94 2?=46 ?@ 23@ A;46;:52:D2@?6827764?@:5=7AB;:

   

  



 

# $6 52>6 EA37=46;64 :56 7B?D=77=A37 AC :56 962;364EAB3769CA;:5628869923:7234:56962;364EAB3769 CA;:56;678A3463:7 ( 7;=<5:9@EA3:63464?@962;364EAB3769CA;:56 28869923:7  :56 =77B6 ;6<2;4=3< <;23: AC 86;D=77=A3 :A 67:2?9=75 :56 =37:=:B:=A3 =7 8634=3< EA37=46;2:=A3 ?6CA;6 :56 ;678A3463: A =3 >=6F AC :56 A;46; 827764 ?@ 2 962;364 =3<96 "B4<6 AC :5=7 AB;: =3 $(%(' 234 EA336E:64 86:=:=A37 B;=3< 863463E@ AC 7BE5 EA37=46;2:=A3 E6;:2=37:B463:7524288;A2E564:5=7AB;: =3 $A(%(' 234 EA336E:64 86:=:=A37 F56;6 :5=7 AB;: 524 86;D=::64 :56 7:B463:7 :A :2I6 B8 :56 6G2D=32:=A3723492:6;4=;6E:64:56233AB3E6D63:AC:56 ;67B9:7 56 28869923:7 2;6 299 7:B463:7 AC :56 (#*( ?2:E5F5AF6;662;9=6;24D=::648634=3<EA37=46;2:=A3AC :562889=E2:=A3AC:5628869923:A7!234%A4AB?: :56 28869923:7 52>6 288;A2E564 :5=7 AB;: ?692:649@ 766I=3< CA; ;69=6C :A :2I6 B8 :56 6G2D=32:=A3 :52: =7 A3 <A=3< A36:569677  7=3E6 :56 28869923:7 52>6 29;624@ :2I63 B8

   

  



 

6G2D=32:=A37=3:568;6>=AB7@62;7 =:FAB943A:?6JB7::A 463@ :56D :56 ?636C=: AC :2I=3< B8 :56 6G2D=32:=A37 CA; :56B8EAD=3<7: 34 ;4234':5@62;7  3 :52: >=6F AC :56 D2::6;  F=:5AB: 6G8;677=3< 23@ A8=3=A3 A3 :56 D6;=:7 AC :56 E276 AC :56 28869923:7 F5=E5 =7 8634=3< EA37=46;2:=A3 ?6CA;6 :56 962;364 =3<96 "B4<6  F6   :5=7 288629 ?@ 86;D=::=3< :56 28869923: A7 :A  :A :2I6 B8

;6D2=3=3< 6G2D=32:=A37CA;:567: 34 ;4234':5@62;7234F6297A 4=;6E: :56 ;678A3463: A :A ;696276 :56 6G2D=32:=A3 CA;D723486;D=::5628869923:7A7:A:A28862;CA; :56 ;6D2=3=3< 6G2D=32:=A37 AC  AB;76 7:  34  ;4 234 ':5 @62;7  F5=E5 527 EADD63E64 C;AD ((! 2C:6;EA996E:=3<:56;6HB=7=:66G2D=32:=A3C66=3E9B4=3<92:6 C66 =C23@5=7=75AF6>6;7B?J6E::A:56AB:EAD6AC:56 F;=: 86:=:=A3 ?6CA;6 :56 962;364 =3<96 "B4<6 56 28869923:A7:A752993A:E92=D23@6HB=:@=3:566>63: :56 F;=: 86:=:=A3 ?6CA;6 :56 962;364 =3<96 "B4<6 =7 4=7D=7764

   

  



 

 62;364 EAB3769 CA; :56 ;678A3463: A =7 4=;6E:64 :A =3CA;D :56 ;678A3463: A 2?AB: :56 A;46; 827764?@:5=7AB;:7A27:A632?96:5628869923:A7:A :A:2I6B8:56;6D2=3=3<6G2D=32:=A37 3 >=6F AC 4=78A729 AC :56 D2=3 288629  299 8634=3< =3:6;9AEB:A;@2889=E2:=A377:2344=78A764ACC     () &$' $    () &$%' $     =7:A9A

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Sign in, for free, to download the court copy. Reading the full text here stays open to everyone.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead