Karnataka High Court
WP/32066/2014 of SRI SHAMANNA Vs STATE OF KARNATAKA on 21 April 2026
COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU Dated this the 7th day of September, 2017 PRESENT: THE HON’BLE MR SUBHRO KAMAL MUKHERJEE, CHIEF JUSTICE AND THE HON’BLE MR JUSTICE P S DINESH KUMAR Writ Petition No.32066 of 2014 and Writ Petition Nos.33584-33586 of 2014 c/w Writ Petition
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
!
"#$
% ! %
&'(!)(*
+
!
,
!"#$
%%&
!
&&
"#$
%%' %
!&
(
'
)
' %'
*
)% % & &
)
'
&
'
&
% &%+
&
& ,
))
'
&
% &%+
-&
(''%
' & )
&
. ' %
'
)
%% '
)
&
/ . ' % &)
& && .
' )
& &&
. & +)
& &&
. )
& &&
. ' %& +)
& && ! * +&
)
)
) &
)
)
! (
0 * '
, )
, )
)
!(
0 *
)
'
! !1
) %% '
&
!! ! 1
) &&
)
+
% ! %
,
% & +
% &
%
%
!
+
'+
&
'
% +
' % &
! + &
'
!&
( &
'
)
'
*
)% % &
)
1 '
& %'
&
'
&
% &%+
&$
& ,
))
%
'
&
% &%+
!
! "#$
%%(&
*
! &&
"#$
%%' %
! '
%
! !
! -&
(''%
' & )
&
. ' %
'
)
%% '
)
&
/ .
'
)
' %'
)
&
/!
*
+&
)
)
) &
+& / !
! ! " ! ' )
) +'
0 (* &
&
" ! & +&
! ! 1 !
0 (* + &
)
)
+ 2
34/4 5678 948787:/ 5464 ;<=>>4? 5783 5678 @994@</
"A !?4;7?4?:=<B @/834/=>C4;8 D@88467:834/4;@/4/@64/7D7<@68834:47:834/@7?5678 @994@</ +783 834 ;:/4:8 A 834 <4@6:4? @?E;@84/ A6 834 9@6874/834/4948787:/@6434@6?A6A7:@<?7/9/@< 4@6? 6:@:83 @:?@F7 <4@6:4? /4:76 @?E;@84 A6 834 948787:46/ 7: +678 &48787:/ A ! @:? +678&48787:/ ! A ! 6 3B@D&6@/@? <4@6:4? /4:76 @?E;@84 A6 834 948787:46/ 7: +678 &48787:/
" A ! 6'7C@B 3@:G@6 <4@6:4? /4:76 @?E;@84A6834@:F@<644E4<9D4:8=83678B 6'7E4G <<@ <4@6:4? 7F3 =68 E46:D4:8 &<4@?46 A6 834 8@84 @:?
64/94;87E4 <4@6:4? @?E;@84/ 7: /=9968 A @99<7;@87:/A67D9<4@?D4:8 ! +678 &48787:/ @:? ! A ! @64 A7<4?-5783@96@B468H=@/3834:87A7;@87:?@84?
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
4I;<=/7: @:? 4I4D987: >B 96?=;7:F ?;=D4:8/ /=>/8@:87@87:F 83476 ;:84:87:/ @:F@<64 4E4<9D4:8 =83678B J#$ A6 /368K 5464 ?764;84? 8 ;:/7?46 /=;3 64H=4/8G4497:F7:D7:?834/8@8=/A834<@:?@/:834?@84 A964<7D7:@6B:87A7;@87: 34<@:?5:46/7:834/496;44?7:F/D@?4/=;3 @ 64964/4:8@87: 34 7:787@<<B 64C4;84? 834 64964/4:8@87: 34 <@:? 5:46/ 3@E4 D@?4 B48 @:8346 64964/4:8@87: 97:87:F =8 83@8 /=;3 64C4;87: 6?46 5@/ 9@//4? 5783=8 @AA6?7:F @: 9968=:78B 8 834 <@:? 5:46/ @:?5783=83<?7:F@/987:/94;87: " 3464 3@/ >44: @ /4;:? 6?46 >B 834 94;7@< @:?;H=7/787:
AA7;4664;DD4:?7:F8?69 834<@:?/ 7: H=4/87:A6D@;H=7/787:96;44?7:F/ 34 <@:? 5:46/ 34647: @996@;34? 837/ =68 /44G7:F@?764;87:8;:/7?468347664H=4/884I;<=?483476 <@:?/A6D@;H=7/787:37/ =68>B6?46?@84?)4>6=@6B " !7:+678&48787:/ ! ! @:? A !
?764;84? 834 @:? 834 E46:D4:8 8 4I94?784 834 ;:/7?46@87: A 5783?6@5@< A 834 <@:?/ 7: H=4/87: A6D @;H=7/787: :787@<<B 534: 834 @;H=7/787:/ 5464 D@?4 834 <@:?5:46/5464946D7884?8>8@7:/784/A6D8347: <74=A834<@:?/@;H=764?34<@:?5:46/34647:984?8 >8@7:/784/7:<74=A;D94:/@87:;;6?7:F<B/784/5464 @<<884?8834D>B834 :
D4@:537<4 /=>/4H=4:8 8 834 64;DD4:?@87:>B834 @:?;H=7/787:
AA7;468?69834 <@:?/A6D@;H=7/787:834/784/@<<884?8834<@:?5:46/7: 834/496;44?7:F/5464;@:;4<<4?>B4I4;=87:A;@:;4<<@87: ?44?/?@84? @6;3 ! 3464@A846 834 8@84 E46:D4:8 3@E4 7//=4? @ :87A7;@87: ?@84? =:4 ! =:?46 => 4;87: (* A 4;87: " A 834 ;8 " ?4;<@67:F 83@8 834 <@:?/ D4:87:4?834647:537;37:;<=?4?834<@:?/>4<:F7:F8834
<@:? 5:46/ 7: 834/4 96;44?7:F/ 5464 :44?4? A6 9=><7; 9=69/4 ! 34 64/=<8@:8 9/787: 537;3 4D46F4? 7/ 834 <@:? 5:46/7:834/496;44?7:F//8??4967E4?A>83834765: <@:?/@/54<<@/834;D94:/@87:7:834A6DA/784/@<<884? 8834D>B834 3464A64 7: =6 E745 @/ 834 94;7@< @:? ;H=7/787:
AA7;46 ;@D4 8 834 ;:;<=/7: 83@8 834 <@:?/ 7: H=4/87: 5464 8 >4 4I;<=?4? A6D 834 @;H=7/787: 834 64/9:?4:8/ D=/8 4I;<=?4 834 <@:?/ 7: H=4/87: A6D @;H=7/787:G4497:F7:D7:?83@8834<@:?5:46/5=<?</4 83476<@:?/@:?@</:8F48878<4883/4/784/@<<884?7:<74= A ;D94:/@87: 3464A64 7: =6 E745 834 7D9=F:4? :87A7;@87:(::4I=64 *7/=:/=/8@7:@><47:<@5@:?<7@><48 >4H=@/34? :83464/=<854@<<58345678948787:/ A ! @:? ! A ! @:? H=@/3 834 :87A7;@87:
?@84?=:4 !>47:F::4I=64 88345678948787:/ 7:/A@6@/834948787:/;34?=<4<@:?/@64;:;46:4? +4 ?7/9/4 A 834 5678 948787:/ " " A !5783@?764;87:88348@<<8@<846:@87E4/784/8 834948787:46/ @<<8844/964A46@><B7:834/@D4@64@ :E745A834?7/9/@<A8345678948787:/@<<834 94:?7:F 7:846<;=86B @99<7;@87:/ ? :8 /=6E7E4 A6 ;:/7?46@87:@:?834B@6483464A64?7/9/4?A@;;6?7:F<B " +4D@G4:6?46@/8;/8/
$23
$23 ;9L B: