Karnataka High Court

CRL.A/1865/2024 of SRI RAJU @ RAJA Vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA on 24 March 2026

Cites 0, Cited by 0

THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 24TH DAY OF MARCH, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1865 OF 2024 BETWEEN: 1 SRI.RAJU @ RAJA S/O KRISHNAPPA AGED ABOUT 44 YERS R/O CHOWDAIAHNAPALYA KESARAMDU ROAD, KYATHASANDRA-572104 TUMAKURU TOWN. 2 SRI.

Citations and Judicial Treatment

No citing decisions in the index yet

Cited by

0

Decisions in the index citing it

Cites

0

Decisions referred to

In this index

0

Of the decisions it cites

Overruled / Questioned

0

No negative treatment found

Loading the citing and cited decisions…

   

   

 

  

         !

  "#    

 

 



  

  !    





 

" 



  

  !    



" 

  



  

  !    



# $%

& #  

'   



      

 

 

      (!!! #

 $&

 

   ' "$ &   

    

        

        

) !  !) !  

%  '

 

''   

" "" ( 

"

' 







%%'





!)! ! (



'

*





' +

'



,



, 

- %

  ./ 011/220345 .06/ 17/8/77/9 4.:5 011/02 0;0:354 4./ <=9;>/34?8@?36:@4:?3039?79/7?85/34/3@/1055/9AB4./ 7:3@:102:547:@4039/55:?35=9;/=>0C=7=$./7/:3084/7 7/8/77/9 4? 05 D4./ 7:02 ?=74E& :3 ?) ! 904/9 !) !   ./ 1074:/5 ./7/:3 07/ 7/8/77/9 4? 05 1/7 4./:7 703CA/8?7/4./47:02?=74 " ./A7:/880@452/09:3;4?8:2:3;?84.:5011/0207/ 4.04 B04.0503970 ?2:@/ .06/ 5=A>:44/9 4./ @.07;/ 5.//4 0;0:3544./0@@=5/98?74./?88/3@/=39/7/@4:?35" "" ( "!7 F/@4:?3"?84:5022/;/9AB4./17?5/@=4:?3 4.04 0@@=5/9 3?0<= 02:05 0<0 039 0@@=5/9 3? 0;070<0 .7=4.:039"/6033002:0506:07/

  @?=5:35.7//B/07517:?74?4./904/?8:3@:9/340@@=5/9 3?5 4? " F/7/ 7/5:9:3; :3 4./ .?=5/ @?3547=@4/9 :3 2039 A/07:3; B?  ?8 B04.0503970 %:220;/ A/2?3;/9 4?  

3 "!G ! 04!""!1> .7=4.:02?3; F:4. 7:3605 ?F90 "/60330 02:05 06: 039 03/5.0 F/34

4./ .?=5/ 5:4=04/9

.?F90:0.30102B0 039 05C/9 4./ 0@@=5/9 4? 60@04/ 4./ .?=5/'?74.040@@=5/94.7/04/3/94.04:84?9? 3?4 7/;:54/7 4./ .?=5/ :3 4./ 30>/ ?8 0@@=5/9 4./B F?=29 C:224./>?3/AB?3/039;/44./17?1/74B./7/084/7F:4. 03 :34/34:?3 4? @?>>:4 >=79/7 0@@=5/9 3? A7?=;.4 @.?11/7 87?> 4./ .?=5/ 039 @.05/9  4? C:22 .:> 039 0550=24/9 ?3 .:5 2/84 2/; 5.03C 039 4?/ ?8 2/84 8??4 039 @0=5/9 ;7:/6?=5 :3<=7:/5 4? .:> @@=5/9 3? 0550=24/9  F:4. @2=A ?3 .:5 ./09 039 @0=5/9 ;7:/6?=5 :3<=7:/5 4? .:>0390@@=5/93?"0395@704@./9 ?3./7A?9BF:4. .0395 AB >0C:3; ./7 4? 8022 ?3 4./ ;7?=39 F.? @0>/ 4? 10@:8B 4./ H=077/2 039 @0=5/9 5:>12/ :3<=7:/5 4? ./7

4. ?7?=;. :36/54:;04:?3 4./ 

 .05 5=A>:44/9 4./ @.07;/ 5.//40;0:3544./0@@=5/9

   84/78:2:3;4./@.07;/5.//4@05/F057/;:54/7/9 :3? !)( ! ./7/084/7@05/F05@?>>:44/94?4./ ?=74 ?8 /55:?35 039 7/;:54/7/9 :3 ?) !  ./ 0@@=5/9F/7//3207;/9?3A0:2  1?3 ./07:3; ?3 @.07;/5 4./ 47:02 ?=74 .05 870>/9 4./ @.07;/5 8?7 4./ 022/;/9 @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/ 0>/F/7/7/09?6/7039/I120:3/94?4./0@@=5/906:3; =39/754??94./50>/0@@=5/912/09/93?4;=:24B039@20:>/9 4?A/47:/9 ( ? 17?6/ 4./ ;=:24 ?8 4./ 0@@=5/9 :3 022  F:43/55/5 F/7/ /I0>:3/9 05  4?  F/34B 9?@=>/345 F/7/ >07C/9 05 I 4?  ! :I >04/7:02 ?A</@45F/7/>07C/905

4?(

3@2?5=7/?817?5/@=4:?3 5:9/ /6:9/3@/ 5404/>/34 =39/7 /@4:?3 "" ?8 7 F05 7/@?79/9 @@=5/9 .09 4?4022B 9/3:/9 4./ /6:9/3@/ ?8 17?5/@=4:?3F:43/55/50394./B.06/51/@:8:@022B5404/94.04 4./B.06/3?4@?>>:44/903B?88/3@/05022/;/903908025/ @?>120:34 .05 A//3 8:2/9 0;0:354 4./> ./B .06/ 8:2/9 0 @?>120:34A=41?2:@/9:93?47/@/:6/4./50>/ 

A/.028 ?8 4./ 0@@=5/9 ?3/ 0C5.>: 034.070<= 02:05  0<= :5 /I0>:3/9 05  039 ?3/

  9?@=>/34:5>07C/905I06:3;./0794./07;=>/345 ?3A?4.5:9/54./47:02?=74.050@H=:44/94./0@@=5/98?7 4./?88/3@/=39/7/@4:?3 "!7 F"?8039@?36:@4/9 4./ 0@@=5/9 8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/5 =39/7 /@4:?35 " " 039 " ( 7 F " ?8  /:3; 0;;7:/6/9 AB 4.:5 <=9;>/344./011/220345.06/17/8/77/94.:5011/02 G .//073/9@?=35/28?74./011/2203457:07:5.  F?=29 5=A>:4 4.04 4./ <=9;>/34 ?8 @?36:@4:?3 039 ?79/7?35/34/3@/1055/9AB4./47:02?=74:5.:;.2B:22/;02 A/5:9/5A/:3;/77?3/?=5./47:02?=74.053?4@?35:9/7/9 4./ @?34709:@4?7B 5404/>/345 039 :>17?6/9 6/75:?3 ?8 4./ @?>120:3034 039 ?4./7 F:43/55/5 ./ 47:02 ?=74 .05 @?35:9/7/9 ?32B 039 5?2/2B ?3 4./ A05:5 ?8 :34/7/54/9 F:43/55/5 ./ 47:02 ?=74 .05 3?4 @?35:9/7/9 4./ 9:51=4/ A/4F//34./0@@=5/90394./@?>120:34054?4./7/5:9/34:02 .?=5/ 5 1/7 4./ @?>120:34 022/;04:?3 4./ @?>120:3034 :5 4./ 7/5:9/34 ?8 090A=7= 6:220;/ ?8 ?F7:A:903=7 02=C 039 ./F05@0=;.4AB4./@?>120:3034AB.04@.:3;012034?/6:@4 4./0@@=5/987?>4./.?=5/?3?3/?74./?4./7F0B0394./ :354034 @?>120:34 :5 7/5=24 ?8 4./ 50:9 @?351:70@B ./ @?>120:3034 .05 @2/072B 5404/9 4.04 04 4./ 4:>/ ?8 022/;/9

  :3@:9/34 F.:2/ ./ F05 7=33:3; ./ 8/22 ?3 4./ ;7?=39 ./ F?=39 @/74:8:@04/IG @?=12/9 F:4. 9?@4?7-5 /6:9/3@/ @2/072B;?/54?5.?F4.04:3<=7:/55=88/7/9AB07/?6/7 .:54?/?82/848??40395.03C?82/842/;./7/8?7/:4@?=29 A/@2/072B;04./7/94.044./:3<=7:/55=88/7/9AB@?=29 A/9=/4?80220393?49=/4?0550=24AB4./0@@=5/9AB=5:3; 

 =4 4./ 47:02 ?=74 F:4.?=4 @?35:9/7:3; 4./5/ 2?;:@02 051/@45 ?8 4./ >044/7 1055/9 4./ :>1=;3/9 <=9;>/34 @?36:@4:3;4./0@@=5/98?74./?88/3@/=39/7/@4:?3" (?8 ./:3<=7B5=88/7/9AB:520@/704/9F?=39?6/7.:5 8?7/./09022/;/94?.06/5=88/7/9AB.:>9=/4?0550=24AB 0@@=5/9 3? AB =5:3; 

 =4 :3 80@4 04 3? 547/4@. ?8 :>0;:304:?320@/704/9F?=39@?=29A/@0=5/9?6/78?7/./09 AB=5:3;F??9/3@2=A2:C/

./47:02?=74025?2?54:45 5:;.4?6/74.:52?;:@02051/@4?84./>044/7F.:2/1055:3;4./ :>1=;3/9 <=9;>/34 5 4?  @7/04/9 0 8025/ 54?7B ?8 0550=24 AB 0@@=5/9 ?" AB @?3@?@4:3; 4./ >/9:@02 9?@=>/345 ?8   ./ 50:9 @?3@?@4:?3 :5 /6:9/34 AB 4./ 80@44.04:34./F?=39@/74:8:@04/I!4./7/:5>/34:?305 4?.:4AB5.071:3547=>/34039F??9/354:@C.?=;.4./7/:5 3?022/;04:?3:34./@?>120:34?7:34.//34:7/@.07;/5.//4 >04/7:02 7/;079:3; 0550=24 AB 0@@=5/9 ?" AB =5:3; 03

  :3547=>/34 ?7 F??9/3 54:@C 4./ 47:02 ?=74 ?=;.4 4? .06/ 40C/3 3?4/ ?8 4./ 08?7/50:9 051/@4 ?8 4./ >044/7 F.:2/ 1055:3;4./:>1=;3/9<=9;>/34'=74./7:4:55=A>:44/94.04 7:3:6050F.?.05A//3/I0>:3/905(.059/1?5/9 4.04 ./ .05 1=7@.05/9 4./ 17?1/74B 87?>  039 4.:5 F:43/55 011/07/9 A/8?7/ 4./ ?=74 039 ;06/ .:5 /6:9/3@/ F:4.?=403B5=>>?3587?>4./?=74F.:@.@2/072B;?/54?

5. ?F4.0417?5/@=4:?3F:43/55/5 F.?07/ 022 @20:>:3; 4?A/ 4.//B/F:43/55/5.06/@?22=9/9/0@.?4./74?:>12:@04/4./ 0@@=5/9:308025/@7:>:302@05/./51?4>0.0J075/:J=7/ >0.0J07 039 4./ F:43/55/5 07/ 022 12034/9 F:43/55/5 ./B .06/ 025? 3?4 8=22B 5=11?74/9 4./ @05/ ?8 4./ 17?5/@=4:?3  :3 ./7 /6:9/3@/ 5404/9 4.04 5./ .05 ;:6/3 @?>120:34 A/8?7/ 4./ 1?2:@/ ?3 !!G !  A=4 4./ 50:9 @?>120:34 :5 3?48?74.@?>:3;:34./@.07;/5.//44?/540A2:5.4./80@4=02 051/@4./1?2:@/.06/3?417?9=@/94./F/01?35

54? A/8?7/4./?@4?74?;:6/.:5?1:3:?3F:4.7/;0794?=50;/ ?8 4./ 50:9 F/01?35 8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/ 5 1/7 4./@05/?84./17?5/@=4:?30@@=5/93?5039 039  07/5:A2:3;5039@?5.07/75":54./.=5A039?8 039  :5 50:9 4? A/ 4./ ?F3/7 ?8 4./ 2039 :3 F.:@. .?=5/ :5 @?3547=@4/9 039 :3 F.:@. 0@@=5/9 3?5 4? " .06/ A//3

  7/5:9:3;4:54./@05/?817?5/@=4:?34.04"A7?=;.4 0399/>?2:5./94./@?F5./9F.:@. F05 @?3547=@4/9AB4./ 0@@=5/9 039 025? :4 :5 4./ 51/@:8:@ @05/ ?8 4./ 17?5/@=4:?3 4.04F.?:54./=3@2/?8"F0505C/94?@?>/87?> 090A=7=6:220;/?8?F7:A:903=702=C ) '7?> 4./ 0A?6/ 50:9 80@45 039 @:7@=>5403@/5 :4 @?=29A/@2/072B;04./7/94.044?"F/7/0;;7/55:6/ 039;?3/4?4.//I4/34?89/>?2:5.:3;4./@?F5./9AB=5:3; 039025?2?9;/908025/@?>120:34:3?79/74?17/55=7:5/ 4./ 0@@=5/9 4? 60@04/ 4./ .?=5/ 5 1/7 4./ @05/ ?8 4./ 17?5/@=4:?3 4./ 

@?22/@4/9 4./ A2??9 540:3/9 >=9

87?> 4./ 022/;/9 120@/ ?8 :3@:9/34 ?3 !G !  3 80@4 4./7/F05./06B70:3:34.//6/3:3;?3 "!G ! 4.04:5 084/7 4./ :3@:9/34 022/;/9 4? .06/ 40C/3 120@/ 04 !"!! 4? !""! 1> 39/7 4./5/ @:7@=>5403@/5 4./ @.03@/ ?8 17?5/@=4:?3;/44:3;4./A2??9540:3/9>=9?3 !G ! :5 .:;.2B :>1?55:A2/ 5 5=@. 4./ 54?7B ?8 @?22/@4:?3 ?8 A2??9 540:3/9 >=9

" :5 @7/04/9 039 @?3@?@4/9 K0B :5 3?4 17?9=@/9039709:?2?;B7/1?74:5025?3?417?9=@/9./

 .05 3?4 /I120:3/9 03B4.:3; 05 4? 3?317?9=@4:?3 ?8 K70B 7/1?745 039 K70B 8:2> ./ :3<=7/9 F05 09>:44/9 4? 4./

  .?51:402 ?32B 8?7 0 90B I5G 039 ! 07/ 4./ F?=39 @/74:8:@04/50>/?84./0@@=5/9F053?4>/34:?3/9:34./ F?=39@/74:8:@04/?@4?7.053?4F.:51/7/903B4.:3; 05 4? 4./ 30>/ 039 F/01?35 =5/9 8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/  .05 @2/072B 09>:44/9 :3 .:5 /6:9/3@/ :3 1070;701.?4.044./0@@=5/9F/7/=5/94?4:/4./@0442/ :34./@0442/5./9F.:@.A/2?3;54?4./>0394./B:38?7>/9 4./ 0@@=5/9 4? 60@04/ 4./ 50>/ =4 4./B 9:9 3?4 60@04/ ./3@/ 4./B .09 7/>?6/9 4./ 5./9 4.7?=;.  4./3 4./ F0554074/9 .05@2/072B09>:44/9:31070;701. ?G4.04./.058:2/90@:6:25=:40;0:3544./0@@=5/9A/8?7/ 4./ ?=74 04 =>0C=7 ( :5 50:9 4? A/ 4./ :39/1/39/34 F:43/55 / .05 @2/072B 09>:44/9 4.04 A/8?7/ :55=:3; 5=>>?35 AB 4./ ?=74 ./ 6?2=3407:2B 011/07/9 A/8?7/ 4./ ?=7405.05:38?7>/94./904/?6/71.?3/4?.:>./ 7:02 ?=74 .05 3?4 17?1/72B 0117/@:04/9 4./ /6:9/3@/ ?3 7/@?79 :3 0 17?1/7 1/751/@4:6/ >033/7 039 @?36:@4/9 4./ 0@@=5/9 8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/ =39/7 /@4:?35 " " 039" (7 F"?8F.:@.:53?45=540:30A2/=39/720F

34./5/;7?=395:4:55?=;.48?7022?F:3;?84./011/02? 5=A54034:04/.:507;=>/345./7/2:/9?34./<=9;>/34?84./ :6:5:?3 /3@. ?8 4.:5 ?=74 :3 4./ @05/ ?8  

    

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

  B035F/74?4./0A?6/1?:34507/, ?:34?,34.//;04:6/ ?:34? ,51/78:302?79/7  $%&'()*%+)*,+#

"  .06/ /I0>:3/9 4./ >04/7:025 120@/9 A/8?7/ 4./ ?=74 ./ 36/54:;04:3;

88:@/7 .05 5=A>:44/9 4./ @.07;/

  5.//4 8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/ =39/7 /@4:?35 " " " ( 039 "! 7 F " ?8  ./ 7:02 ?=74 .05 0@H=:44/9 4./ 0@@=5/9 ?5 4? " 8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/ =39/7 /@4:?35"!7 F"?8?F/6/7@?36:@4/94./0@@=5/98?7 4./@?>>:55:?3?8 ?88/3@/=39/7/@4:?35" "" (7 F"?8   ./ ;/3/5:5 ?8 4.:5 @05/ 07:5/ 87?> 4./ @?>120:34 8:2/9AB7:3:6050;?F90051/7I4:50117?17:04/4? >/34:?3 ./7/ 05 4? 4./ @?>120:34 04 I F.:@. 7/095 05 =39/7,  

   



  



!"

#$

%

& '

(

!)( *!+,



-.(

!, /'

.(

!0 1

2-3 4"

!(

)56. 778999

!!:2 

;3 

'

<6 

 =(

!0+  

(

'

!

>?@A

 

!

 

B

CB(



(

! !D

./ '





!E 

F 0

 

! *!(

!

 

G '

 -*!(

!

 H

I

!

 "

2 -(

!B+'J 

K -> L '

!

 BM'

!J ?'

(

0

!N



!'

>'

3H

I

!

"

2- '

!?<6

> ?@A 

!

 

O

, 

O

 

B DB,

CB '.

P"

 

!

 (

@A Q (

; R'

J(

! 

! ;H (

 

I S' 



CB I

! 

/

<6(

!

 

! I

!<6

CB I

! '.

P"

 

!

!

'

 ( T, 

( T! (



(

!  

 ='

!J. S'

!J  

K 

! I

!<6  

;(

:! - 'J L '

! BM'

J2 

K U '

! (

.;!

<6 R/



K 

! I

!

!> !V .

!

K:6 '

! 3

!B+' J( 

.

CB I

!! 



 WM 0

(

:!  %

!> 

;M'

!J

! 

!'

M+ 

XM ( T 

!0

!+



( T

>?

(



! I

!

!>?

/!V.SL '

!'?'

2

CB I

!!

> 

! I

! 

 .S L '

! ( T

!> 3

:! .='

J2 

! I

!

!>



!E

  

/ 

I S.!V (

)

V( 

I SM.V( 

I

 

K Y I

!!B+(  R5 6 L '

(UZ.[-[(

!>.5

I S



!E\M+ I

!

!>"

'

!.3

4

K0+ '

!'



( ( T L -!

! 

! I.3



*! '

 

!H

]

!> XS'

!. 

!

>

!> .5 

I 

!

K' =^SM. 

!- '

!

!

F:#'

.(

^S.='

!J.' \

 ( T!

! 

!1] '



> L

  <, L

" '

'

 Z(

 .'

! (



+ I

!"

SM'

! 

( T

!'.O>0'

!. 

!- '

!

>0

5-: = .'

!?%

V(

<6X '^S- '

(

@AQ(

;

!0

!+ 

!'

:

(

!- '

! \

 ( T, 

( T

>

!> !V ^S .'

(

!

> ?@A

 

!

 

B

CB I

!

!> ( T

 

B (



! 3

! D

 '

 3

2 

;. 

! "

(

H S'

J3 '

! .0 + I

!!N_



' 



!'

>

` I

I =0

!+

(



>

!>,

CB R-[(

!> 1a0G =  (

<6 M'

J

  \

#0 

('

!. 

! - '

!

>

!> U3

(.= I

I =' b<M1a0G.SM(

!0 +(

CB I

!

.>.(

(.= I

I =1a0G 

I SM(

!0 +( \M+ ;H (

'

<6



! !:2 

 (, 

( T, (



! (



(

! .SM(

!

K'

/ '

R

(

!

!5

.

!/0 



!D.3

4Z '

!0



!E<6 .3

!40+ c ^'

/*!' 

Xde



3 4./ A05:5 ?8 4./ @?>120:34 ?3 "!G !  B040503970 1?2:@/ .06/ 7/;:54/7/9 4./ @05/ :3 7:>/ ?) ! 0;0:3540@@=5/9?54?"8?74./@?>>:55:?3 ?8?88/3@/=39/7/@4:?35" "" (039"!7 F"?8039 5=A>:44/94./@.07;/5.//4A/8?7/4./?=74051/7I?3 "!G !  04 G"! 1> 4 4./ 4:>/ ?8 40C:3; 47/04>/34 AB  :3 .7: :990;03;0 ?51:402 =>0C=7= 4./ 1?2:@/ .06/ 7/@?79/9 4./ 5404/>/34 ?8 :3<=7/9 7:3:6050;?F90 ./ 36/54:;04:3;

88:@/7 .05 17?9=@/9 4./ @@:9/34 7/;:54/7@=> F?=39 @/74:8:@04/ :55=/9 AB .7: :990;03;0 ?51:402 039

  /5/07@. /347/ =>0C=7= >07C/9 05 IG F.:@. 7/6/025 4.04?3 "!G ! 4./:3<=7/97:3:6050;?F900;/90A?=4! B/075 09>:44/9 4? 4./ .?51:402 :3 ? !G!"! F:4. 4./ .:54?7B ?8 0550=24 039 4./ ?@4?7 .05 8?=39 4./ 8?22?F:3; :3<=7:/5, :

1/3709/ 17?I:>02.02B3I870@4=7//84 39?/$7:/6?=5:3<=7B& ::

1/3 709/ :5402 .:79 :A:0 3:@?74:@02 '70@4=7/$7:/6?=5:3<=7B& ::: 0@/704/9 F?=39 ?6/7 8?7/./09 $7:/6?=5 :3<=7B&

( ':39:3;5 ?8 4./ 1.B5:@02 /I0>:304:?3 07/ 4.04M 20@/704/9 F?=395 ?6/7 034/7:?7204/702 051/@4 ?8 2/; 039 ?6/7 4./1203407051/@4?84./ 394?/  I :5 4./ :34:>04:?3 4? 4./ 1?2:@/ 0A?=4 4./ 0@@:9/34039:3<=7:/5:3F.:@.:4:55404/94.047:3:6050;?F90 ? 04/ %/3C0405F0>0110 @0>/ F:4. 4./ .:54?7B ?8 0550=24 3/07 .?F90:0.30102B0 /5070>09= ?09 =>0C=7= 04 07?=39 ""! 1> ?3 "!G !  0550=24 AB 7/204:6/5 .:4 AB 5.071 :3547=>/34 039 F??9/3 54:@C I) :5 4./ F?=39 @/74:8:@04/?875.7=4.:F.?/I0>:3/9A/8?7/4./?=74 05".055404/94.04?3 "!G ! 5./09>:44/94?4./ .?51:402 :3

 F:4. 4./ .:54?7B ?8 0550=24

.?F90:0.30102B0 /5070>09= ?09 =>0C=7= 04 07?=39

  ""!1>?3 "!G ! 0550=24/9AB7/204:6/5.:4AB5.071 :3547=>/34039F??9/354:@C G I! :5 4./ @@:9/34 /;:54/7@=>F?=39 @/74:8:@04/F.:@.7/6/0254.0475.7=4.:.055=540:3/9 8?22?F:3;:3<=7:/5, $:& N'0@/,30A705:?3?85:I/I @>5$O&?6/7 4/>1?70207/0 $::& N '?7/07>, =24:12/ 0A705:?35 ?6/7 8?7/07> 039./09 $:::& N '??4, 3 0A705:?3 $O& ?6/7 >/9:02 051/@4 ?8 8??4

) I :5 4./ /9:@?2/;02 @05/ /;:54/7 /I470@4 :55=/9 AB .7: :990;03;0 ?51:402 039 /5/07@. /347/ =>0C=7=1=75=0344?7:3:605;?F90F./7/:3025?4./.:54?7B ?8 0550=24 5.?F3 05 AB 7/204:6/5 .:4 AB 5.071 :3547=>/34 F??9/354:@C0407?=39""!1>?3 "!G !  ! I :5 4./ /9:@?2/;02 @05/ /;:54/7 /I470@4 1/740:3:3;4?75.7=4.:025?7/6/0254.045./09>:44/9 4?4./.?51:402F:4.4./.:54?7B?80550=240407?=39""!1> 04 "!G !  04 .?F90:0.30102B0 /5070>09= ?09 =>0C=7=  7:3:6050;?F90 .05 9/1?5/9 :3 .:5 /6:9/3@/ 4.04040A?=4?3/ 039.028B/075A0@C04""!1>./@0>/

  87?>B5=7=02?3;F:4.5 0393/074./.?=5/?8 039 4./ 50:9 .?=5/ F05 /347=54/9 4? 0@@=5/9 AB  039 5 P  F/7/ @2/03:3; 4./ 60@034 2039 5:4=04/9 3/07 4./ .?=5/ AB A7:3;:3;  039 4./7/084/7 @0>/ 4? 4./ .?=5/ ?8  '=74./7./9/1?5/94.044./BF/7/7/5:9:3; :3 4./ 50:9 .?=5/5:3@/"B/075039044.044:>/ 05C/94./0@@=5/9 4? 60@04/ 4./ .?=5/ 039 0@@=5/9 4?29 4.04 4./ 50:9 .?=5/ A/2?3;54?4./>0394./B9?3?4F0344?2/06/4./.?=5/039 ./096:5/94./0@@=5/9ABH=/54:?3:3;4./0@@=5/9054?F.B 4./B07/3?4;:6:3;=14./.?=5/05:4A/2?3;54? 44.04 4:>/ 0@@=5/9 ? @0>/ ?=4 ?8 4./ .?=5/ .?29:3; .:5 .039 A/.:39 039 ./ 8?=39 4./ >0@./4/ :3 4./ 7:;.4 .039 ?8 4./ 0@@=5/9 ? ./ ;?4 87:;.4/3/9 039 703 0F0B 87?> 4./ 51?4 0398/229?F30@@=5/9?@0>/87?>.:5A0@C0390550=24/9 ?3.:52/845.03CF:4.>0@./4/039@0=5/9:3<=7:/5039./.05

5. ?F3 4./ F?=39 @/74:8:@04/ A/8?7/ 4./ ?=74 / 8=74./7 9/1?5/9 4.04 0@@=5/9 ? 0550=24/9 .:> F:4. @2=A 039 ./ A/@0>/ =3@?35@:?=5 039 ./ ;?4 09>:44/9 4? 4./ =>0C=7= ?51:402 039 1?2:@/ @0>/ 039 7/@?79/9 .:5 5404/>/34 05 1/7 I/8=74./79/1?5/94.040@@=5/9?".051=5./9 039 C:@C/9 ?3 ./7 .:5 F:43/55  .05 10742B 47/04/9 05 .?54:2/F:43/55039F05@7?55/I0>:3/9042/3;4.

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

  '=74./7 5./

4.04 ?3 "!G !  5./ 05C/9 7:3:6050;?F90 4? @?>/ 4? .?F90:0.30102B0

7:3:6050;?F904?294.045./5.?=293?4;?4./7/02?3/039./ F?=29@?>/02?3;F:4../7039?3 "!G ! 04!!!0> 4./B @0>/ 4? .?F90:0.30102B0 039 05C/9 4./ 0@@=5/9 4? 60@04/4./.?=5/?F/6/74./0@@=5/92?@C/94./9??75?8022 4./7??>5?84./.?=5/039022?F/9./74?5:4:34./7??>:3 4./;7?=3982??70394./7/F05024/7@04:?3A/4F//34./>4 4.044:>/4./BF/7/@2/03:3;4./5./9F:4.4././21?8039 F./35././7.=5A039039=3@2/05C/94./0@@=5/94?60@04/ 4./.?=5/4./0@@=5/9?4?294./>4?7/;:54/74./.?=5/:3 4./:7 30>/ ?4./7F:5/ ./ F?=29 3?4 5107/ 4./> 039 0@@=5/9 ?F/34:35:9/4./.?=5/039A7?=;.4>0@./4/

35//:3; 4./ >0@./4/ ./7 =3@2/ 703 0F0B 0@@=5/9 ? A7?=;.4 @2=A 039 022 ?8 0 5=99/3 ./7 =3@2/ 8/22 9?F3 039 0@@=5/9 ? 0550=24/9 ?3 4./ 2/84 5.03C ?8 ./7 =3@2/ F:4. >0@./4/ 039 0@@=5/9? 0550=24/9./7=3@2/?3.:5./09F:4.@2=A039AB 5@7/0>:3; 5./ 703 0F0B 039 0@@=5/9 ?" 0>B0 @0>/ 039 1=5./9 ./7 ?3 4? 4./ ;7?=39 039 5@704@./9 ./7 A?9B

5//:3; /60330 039 ./7 .=5A039 4./ 0@@=5/9 F/34 0F0B AB .?29:3;>0@./4/039@2=A./8=74./75404/94.04./7=3@2/.05 5=540:3/9:3<=7:/5039./7.=5A039A7?=;.4./7039./7=3@2/ 4? :99.0;03;0 ?51:402 =>0C=7= 8?7 47/04>/34 '=74./7

  5./ .05 9/1?5/9 05 4? 4./ 51?4 >0.0J07 @?39=@4/9 AB 4./ 1?2:@/039025?5/:J=7/?8A2??9540:3/9>=903950>12/>=9 " " /06030 06: F05 /I0>:3/9 05   / .059/1?5/9:3.:5/6:9/3@/4.040A?=4B/075A0@C4./7/F05 0 7/;:54/7/9 >077:0;/ A/4F//3  039  039 084/7 4./ >077:0;/ F057/5:9:3;04B5?7/0393?F5./:57/5:9:3; 04 >/7:@0  .05 @?3547=@4/9 0 .?=5/ 4./ 0@@=5/9 F/7/ 7/5:9:3; :3 4./ 50:9 .?=5/ 039  05C/9 4./ 0@@=5/9 4? 7/5:9/:34./50:9.?=5/039204/7 039.06/9/@:9/9 4?7/5:9/:34./50:9.?=5/039?3 "!G ! ./.09A//34? 4./50:9120@/02?3;F:4. 039039025?@0>/ 4./7/039 05C/94./0@@=5/94?60@04/4./.?=5/@@=5/9 4?29 4.04 4./B F?=29 3?4 2/06/ 4./ .?=5/ 039 05C/9  4? 7/;:54/74./50:9.?=5/:34./:730>/ 9:93?40;7//039 4./7/084/7 0@@=5/9 ? >09/  4? 8022 ?3 4./ 7?09 039 0550=24/9F:4.>0@./4/?3.:52/842/;039./09@@=5/9? 0550=24/9 F:4. @2=A ?3 .:5 ./09 @./54 039 2/; 039 @0=5/9 A2//9:3; :3<=7:/5 / .05 025? 5404/9 4.04 0@@=5/9 ?" 5@704@./94./A?9B?8084/71=5.:3;./7?34./;7?=39/ 8=74./7 9/1?5/9 4.04 ./ .09 09>:44/9  039  4? 7: :99.0;03;0 ?51:402 8?7 47/04>/34 ./ 1?2:@/ @0>/ 4? 4./ 51?4039@?39=@4/9>0.0J07039@?22/@4/9A2??9540:3/9 >=9

  039 50>12/ >=9 / .05 025? 9/1?5/9 05 4? 103@.030>0 04 I   03/5.  .05 025? 9/1?5/9 :3 .:5 /6:9/3@/054?4./022/;/9:3@:9/34039025?0@4?84./0@@=5/9  (7:3:6050 F.? @:4/9 05 /B/F:43/55 .05 9/1?5/9:3.:5/6:9/3@/054?4./0550=24>09/AB4./0@@=5/9 ?3 7:3:6050;?F90 F:4. >0@./4/ 039 ./ .05 8=74./7 9/1?5/9 4.040@@=5/9? ;06/A2?F4?F:4.@2=A?3.:5./09039 0@@=5/9?"5@704@./94./80@/039.0395?8  ( "70A.0C074./0A4/@.3:@:03.059/1?5/9 054?4./>0.0J07@?39=@4/9AB4./1?2:@/051/7I    5.F04.0 /99B .05 9/1?5/9 05 4? 4./ >0.0J07@?39=@4/9AB4./?2:@/051/7I" G 3:2 =>07  .05 9/1?5/9 F:4. 7/;079 4? 4./>0.0J07@?39=@4/9AB4./?2:@/051/7I039./.05 3?48=22B5=11?74/94./@05/?84./17?5/@=4:?3 ) (7:3:6050 .05 9/1?5/9 :3 .:5 /6:9/3@/ 4.04 0@@=5/9 ? @.05/9 7:3:6050;?F90 039 ;06/ A2?F 4? .:> F:4.>0@./4/?3.:52/842/;0392/848//4@@=5/9? ;06/ A2?F4??3.:5./090390@@=5/9?".055@704@./9

  "! :60C070 .05 9/1?5/9 05 4? 4./ >0.0J07 @?39=@4/9AB4./1?2:@/051/7I " G?.0>09 .08:=220 4./ /09 ?3540A2/ .05 9/1?5/9054?4./077/54?80@@=5/9?03917?9=@/9A/8?7/ 4./039;06/7/1?74051/7I/.05025?9/1?5/905 4?4./>0.0J07@?39=@4/9AB4./1?2:@/051/7I "  )05.:5. =>07  .05 9/1?5/9 :3 .:5 /6:9/3@/ 05 4? 4./ >0.0J07 @?39=@4/9 AB 4./ 1?2:@/ 05 1/7 I( "" !07:5.4./ 2?77B?F3/7.059/1?5/9:3 .:5 /6:9/3@/ 05 4? 4./ >0.0J07 @?39=@4/9 AB 4./ 1?2:@/ 05 1/7 I( 039 ./ .05 3?4 8=22B 5=11?74/9 4? 4./ @05/ ?8 4./ 17?5/@=4:?3 " 70.=2

74. ?1/9:@ 5=7;/?3 7//9/6: 354:4=4/?8/9:@02@:/3@/5.059/1?5/9.:5/6:9/3@/054?4./ /I0>:304:?3 ?8 4./ :3<=7/9 7:3:6050;?F90 039 75 .7=4.:  039 .05 025? 9/1?5/9 F:4. 7/;079 4? 4./ :55=03@/ ?8 F?=39@/74:8:@04/504I5G039! " 5

( :990110 4./ 

>170C05.?F904./:7@2/351/@4?7?8?2:@/.06/9/1?5/9 F:4.7/;0794?4./:77/51/@4:6/:36/54:;04:?3

  "(  03/5.  :6:2 3;:3//7 .05 9/1?5/9 :3 .:5/6:9/3@/4.047:3:6050;?F90:5.:5=3@2/ :5.:5F:8/ " :5 .:5 >?4./7 ./ 0@@=5/9 07/ @?=5:35 ?8   / >077:/9  :3 4./ B/07 !G 039 4./7/084/7 4./B F/34 4? >/7:@0 /

.:5 F:8/E5 A7?4./7 :3 4./ .?=5/ ?8 7:3:6050;?F90 :5 F:8/ .7=4.:  :5 .06:3; .?=5/ :3 .?F90:0.30102B0 ./3 4./B F/7/ 17?@//9:3; 4? >/7:@0 4./B.06/;:6/34./;7?=3982??7?84./.?=5/4?4./0@@=5/94? 2??C 084/7 4./ 50>/ 039 2/84 4./ 8:754 82??7 8?7 03<=304. 4./ B?=3;/7 A7?4./7 ?8 .:5 F:8/ ./ 0@@=5/9 .06/ 055=7/9 4./> 4.044./BF:2260@04/4./.?=5/084/74./:77/4=7387?>>/7:@0 3 4./ >?34. ?8 17:2 !) F./3 ./ 039 .7=4.: @0>/ 87?> >/7:@04./BF/3403905C/94./0@@=5/94?60@04/4./.?=5/ 05 4./ 2/05/ 1/7:?9 ?8 4./ .?=5/ F?=29 @?>12/4/ ?3 G!  ! ./34./0@@=5/94?294.044./BF:223?460@04/4./ .?=5//3@/4./B2?9;/90@?>120:344?4./ B04503970?2:@/ 039 F/34 4? B5?7/ 84/7 4F? 90B5 4./B 7/4=73/9 4? .?F90:0.30102B0 039 4./7/ F05 024/7@04:?3 A/4F//3 4./ 0@@=5/9039.:>5/28039025?7:3:6050;?F90F.?@0>/ AB4.044:>/./0@@=5/97/8=5/94?.039?6/74./1?55/55:?3 ?8 4./ .?=5/ 039 4./B F/7/ @2/03:3; 4./ 5./9 4.7?=;.  ./30@@=5/9?0<0@0>/AB.?29:3;>0@./4/AB@.05:3; .:5=3@2/./3./8/22./7/084/70@@=5/9?;06/A2?F4?

  .:> ?3 .:5 2/84 2/; 039 0@@=5/9 ? ;06/ A2?F 4? .:> F:4. @2=A./3/60330039.:>5/2847:/94?7/5@=/4./>0@@=5/9 0>B0 5@704@./9 .:5 F:8/ .7=4.: F:4. ./7 30:25 4./3 4./ 0@@=5/9 F/34 0F0B / .:5 F:8/ 039 .:5 =3@2/ F/34 4? 4./ :990;03;0 ?51:402 =>C=7 8?7 47/04>/34 4 4./ 4:>/ ?8 40C:3;47/04>/344./1?2:@/@0>/0397/@?79/94./5404/>/34 ?8  :5 F:8/ 025? 4??C 47/04>/34 :3 4./ .?51:402

3 4./ 3/I490B./.039/9?6/74./@2?4./5?8.:5=3@2/4?4./1?2:@/ ./1?2:@/.06/5/:J/94./50>/=39/7I"039./:9/34:8:/9 4./ A2??9 540:3/9 5.:745 039 @2?4./5 05 

5 039 ( / 025? :9/34:8:/9 4./ >0@./4/ 039 @2=A =5/9 8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/5 

5 039  4 4./ 4:>/ ?8 5/:J=7/ ?8 @2?4./5 4./ 1?2:@/4??C.:55:;304=7/?3@.:40391054/9?3@2?4./5 "

3@07/8=2/I0>:304:?3?84.//34:7//6:9/3@/:4:5 @7B5402 @2/07 4.04 4./7/ :5 0 9:51=4/ A/4F//3 4./ 0@@=5/9 039 54?"F:4.7/;0794?4./60@04:3;?89:51=4/9.?=5/ 5=88/7/97?I:>02.02B3I870@4=7/2/84 394?/9=/4?8022?34./ ;7?=39 039 3?4 9=/ 4? 4./ 0550=24 AB 0@@=5/9 .:5 80@4 :5 /6:9/34 AB 4./ 6/7B @?>120:3034 039 025? 4./ /6:9/3@/ ?8 17?5/@=4:?3 F:43/55/5 3 4./ @?>120:34 04 I :4 :5 5404/9 4.04*

   ”

  "G  :3 .:5 @7?55/I0>:304:?3 AB 4./ =A2:@ 7?5/@=4?7 .05 09>:44/9 4.04 04 4./ 4:>/ ?8 :3@:9/34 ./ 8/22 9?F3 ".7=4.: F.? :5 025? 022/;/9 :3<=7/9 /B/F:43/55 :3 ./7 /I0>:304:?3:3@.:/8 :45/28 5404/9 4.04  8/22 9?F3 0@@:9/34022B044./4:>/?8022/;/9:3@:9/34F.:@.:5/I470@4/905 8?22?F5,      !"  #$%   &'(  )* +

") IG 4./ F?=39 @/74:8:@04/ 7/6/025 4.04  5=540:3/9:3<=7:/54?.:5 394?/0399:54024.:794:A:0=3:@?74:02 '7?>4./304=7/?84./0A?6/:3<=7:/5?3/@03055=>/4.044./ 50:9 :3<=7:/5 F?=29 2:C/2B A/ @0=5/9 9=/ 4? 8022 8 04 022 4./ :3<=7:/5 07/ @0=5/9 AB 0@@=5/9 ? 4./ :3<=7:/5 F?=29 .06/ >?7/5/6/7/:3304=7/ ! :4. 7/;079 4? 4./ 022/;/9 0550=24 >09/ AB 4./ 0@@=5/9 ? :5 @?3@/73/9 :3 4./ @?>120:34 :4 :5 5404/9 4.04 0@@=5/9 ? 0550=24/9 .:> F:4. 4./ @2=A ?3 .:5 ./09 F:4. 8?7@/.05025?9/1?5/94./50>/:3.:5/6:9/3@/" .05 025? 9/1?5/9 4./ 50>/ :3 .:5 /6:9/3@/ ?F/6/7 :3 4./ >/9:@02@/74:8:@04/0397/;:54/74./>/9:@02?88:@/7.053?4 7/@?79/9 4./ 30>/ ?8 4./ 0@@=5/9 039 022/;/9 F/01?35 =5/9

  8?7 4./ @?>>:55:?3 ?8 ?88/3@/5 ./ :3<=7/9 .7=4.: 9:9 3?4 5=540:303B:3<=7:/5?3./7./09  ./ 022/;04:?35 >09/ :3 I@?>120:34 039 /6:9/3@/?85 "039@2/072B;?/54?5.?F4.044./B 07/0;;7/55?75F.?;?3/3/074./.?=5/:3H=/54:?3F.:@.:5 :39:51=4/A/4F//34./0@@=5/90394./17?5/@=4:?3F:43/55/5 4? ;/4 4./ 1?55/55:?3 ?8 4./ .?=5/ F:4.?=4 8?22?F:3; 9=/ 17?@/55 ?8 20F 3 I@?>120:34 :45/28 4./ @?>120:3034 .:>5/28 5404/9 4.04 ./ A7?=;.4  4.7?=;.  039 ;?4 9/>?2:5./94./@?F5./9?84./0@@=5/91/75?35:3.:5 @7?55/I0>:304:?3.05025?09>:44/905=39/7, *&+ +&,-./* ” “0$1  23 .4 56 6,' 7896  :;<-= >!=  ?6@   ?6#   ,A=B.  +

   :3 .:5 /6:9/3@/ .05 025? @2/072B 5404/9 05 8?22?F5, *3 CD&+   )*$%   8EF0,%:E  80 E8  3 . GC   H6 + 3  <CD & 86  #5IJ  @ #5I#  K  L  8 MF . N 8 <O L+

" ".05025?5404/9:3.:5/6:9/3@/058?22?F5,

  *&P   ,-. &+   6/*  H6 + Q?R  E8 /*(H6 ES!T4%++

  .05 8=74./7 09>:44/9 4.04  039 .:>5/28 .06/ 8:2/9 0 5=:4 8?7 1074:4:?3 039 1?55/55:?3 0;0:354 4./ 0@@=5/9F.:@.:51/39:3;A/8?7/4./=>C=7?=74 

31/7=502?84./08?7/50:909>:55:?3>09/AB4./ 17?5/@=4:?3F:43/55/54./@?=74@03?A5/76/4.04:87/022B4./ 0@@=5/9 ? .09 03 :34/34:?3 4? 0550=24  F:4. 

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

  0@@=5/9F.?.055@704@./975.7=4.:@@?79:3;2B4./ /6:9/3@/ ?8 75 .7=4.:  :5 3?4 5=11?74/9 F:4. >/9:@02 /6:9/3@/  4 :5 7/2/6034 4? >/34:?3 ./7/ 4.04  .05 9/1?5/9:3.:5/I0>:304:?3:3@.:/84.04084/7 90B587?>4./ 904/?809>:55:?34?=>C=7?51:4028?78=74./747/04>/34./ F05 5.:84/9 4? 1?22? ?51:402 B5?7/ F./7/:3 ./ .05 40C/3 47/04>/34 05 03 :3104:/34 8?7 ?3/ >?34. :3 4./ 50:9 .?51:402 ./7/084/7 ./ =5/9 4? 6:5:4 4./ .?51:402 /6/7B90B 8?7 40C:3; 47/04>/34 3 4.:5 7/;079 4./ 36/54:;04:3;

88:@/7 .05 3?4 17?9=@/9 03B 9?@=>/34 ./ @?39=@4 ?8 4.:5 /6:9/3@/ 4./ /I0;;/704:?30394./:>17?6/9/6:9/3@/?87/6/024.04 .:5/6:9/3@/:53?4A/2:/60A2/054./50>/:53?4@?77?A?704/9 F:4.03B>/9:@02/6:9/3@/6/34./36/54:;04:3;

88:@/7.05 3?49/1?5/903B4.:3;F:4.7/;0794?4./09>:55:?3?8:3 4./1?22??51:402B5?7/ G %:/F/9 87?> 03B 03;2/ 4./ /6:9/3@/ ?8 :3<=7/9 F:43/55/5039?4./7:34/7/54/9F:43/55/59?3?4011/074?A/ 304=7020394./:7/6:9/3@/:53?4@?35:54/34F:4./0@.?4./7039 025? 3?4 5=11?74/9 F:4. >/9:@02 /6:9/3@/ :3@/ 4./7/ :5 03 /3>:4B A/4F//3 4./ 0@@=5/9 039 @?>120:3034 F:4. 7/;079 4? 60@04:3;?89:51=4/9.?=5/:4:5H=:4/304=7024?9/1?5/0;0:354

  4./ 0@@=5/9 /I0;;/704:3; F:4. 03 :34/34:?3 4? .07055 4./ 0@@=5/9 39/74./;:6/35/4?8@:7@=>5403@/5:4:53?4508/4? A/2:/6/ 4./ /6:9/3@/ ?8 5 " 039 ?4./7 :34/7/54/9 F:43/55/5 F.?5/ /6:9/3@/ :5 3?4 5=A54034:04/9

@?77?A?704/9AB03B:39/1/39/34F:43/5587/022B.05 5=540:3/9 :3<=7:/5 F:4. >0@./4/ 039 @2=A ./ F?=29 .06/ 9:5@2?5/94./50>/A/8?7/4.//9:@02

88:@/7?F/6/7./.05 3?49:5@2?5/94./30>/?8F/01?35=5/98?74./@?>>:55:?3?8 ?88/3@/039025?30>/?80@@=5/9.?=;.4.//9:@02

88:@/7 .05>/34:?3/9:34./F?=39@/74:8:@04/4.044./:3<=7B:5@0=5/9 AB0.:4F:4.5.071:3547=>/34039F??9/354:@C4./50>/:5 3?4 :3 3?4 @?35:54/34 F:4. 

5 039  17?9=@/9 AB 4./ 17?5/@=4:?3 ) ./ F?=39 @/74:8:@04/ ?8 7:3:6050;?F90 7/6/0254.044./:3<=7:/54?"07/;7:/6?=5:3304=7/0394./7/ :5 0 870@4=7/ ?8 2/84 39 4?/ 7?I:>02 1.02B3I 870@4=7/ ? 5=A54034:04/ 4./ 50>/ 4./ 36/54:;04:3;

88:@/7 .05 3?4 17?9=@/94./709:?2?;B7/1?74F:4.7/;0794?4./870@4=7/?82/84 394?/039/6/34./K70B:5025?3?417?9=@/9 ! ./ :6:5:?3 /3@. ?8 4.:5 ?=74 :3 4./ @05/ ?8   

 $5=170& .05 ?A5/76/9 4.04 4./ 17?5/@=4:?3.0580:2/94?17?6/4./022/;04:?3?8;7:/6?=5:3<=7B

  5=540:3/9 AB  :3 6:/F ?8 3?317?9=@4:?3 ?8 K70B 8?7 @?38:7>04:?3?8870@4=7/?1:3/9AB4./9?@4?7:3@2:3:@02>/9:@02 /I0>:304:?3

3 4.:5 ;7?=39 :4 :5 3?4 1?55:A2/ 4? .?29 4.04 0@@=5/950:94?.06/@?>>:44/9?88/3@/ 

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

  $9& ./A0:2A?395?8011/220345 0@@=5/94?"5.022 54039@03@/22/9M $/& ./ 47:02 ?=74 :5 9:7/@4/9 4? 7/8=39 4./ 8:3/ 0>?=34 :8 03B :3 9/1?5:4 4? 4./ 011/220345 0@@=5/94?"M

/;:547B:59:7/@4/94?5/394./47:02?=747/@?79502?3; F:4.4./@?1B?84.:5=9;>/344?4./@?3@/73/9?=74

(-. / 0



>57

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Sign in, for free, to download the court copy. Reading the full text here stays open to everyone.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead