Karnataka High Court
CRL.A/2334/2025 of MURALI Vs STATE OF KARNATAKA on 13 March 2026
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF MARCH, 2026 BEFORE THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G. BASAVARAJA CRIMINAL APPEAL NO.2334 OF 2025 BETWEEN: MURALI S/O NARAYANAPPA AGED ABOUT 32 YEARS R/AT MOTHI NAGAR IN FRONT OF MALBAR SQUARE NEAR MARKET BENGALURU 560 032
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
! "" !
#
$ %"" & '
""" "" "
($ %" & "'
)*&'
"& ! *$&'
' "
+* " **+!) ""
"! !)&'*$$,-
".
"
/"
0
12 344255367 138 492:2992; 71<8 344235 3=3<687 712 >?;=@267A:BA6C<B7<A636;A9;29A6826726B2;372;9;?=?87 * 43882; <6 A**+ A: ) -D 712 ;;<7<A635 <7D <C<5E288<A68?;=226=35?9?&:A981A97/71279<35A?970'
A9 712 83F2 A: BA6C26<26B2 712 4397<28 1292<6 392 92:2992;7A38429712<9936F36;8737?8-2:A9271279<35A?97 9<2: :3B78 523;<6= 7A 71<8 344235 392 7137 712 "A5<B2 6842B7A9 "39344363 =931393 "A5<B2 737<A6 8?-@<772; 712 B139=2812273=3<6877123BB?82;A836;:A9BA@@<88<A6A: A::26B28?6;292B7<A68*$*G))$,36;) A:7126;<36"2635A;2 * 7<83552=2;-D71249A82B?7<A67137712BA@453<6367H38 928<;<6=<69<26F373C226A@26"H1<B1H38-2<6=9?6 -D71282BA6;3BB?82;36;8<7?372;376;73=252B79A6<B<7D
:355<6= H<71<6 712 >?9<8;<B7<A6 A: "39344363 =931393 "A5<B2 737<A612BA@453<6367H1AH38HA9F<6=<6H38928<;<6= <671283<;":9A@+71?=?87 6$71?=?8737 3@712BA@453<6367927?962;7A712"3:729129HA9F8 712 9AA@,@372 A: 712 BA@453<6367 &' 13; =A62 :A9 HA9F 712 BA@453<6367 H1A 13; 123;,3B12 7AAF 43<6 F<5529 36; 85247 H<71A?7 5ABF<6= 712 ;AA9 A: 712 9AA@ 7 3@ H126 712 BA@453<6367 H38 <6 3 ;9AH8D 87372 712 3BB?82; A 267292; 712 9AA@ 12 BA@453<6367 38F2; 1<@ <6 3@<5 38 7A H1A 12 H38I 37 7137 7<@2 3BB?82; F247 3 F6<:2 A6 712 719A37 A: 712 BA@453<6367 126 712 BA@453<6367 79<2; 7A 81A?7 3BB?82; 719237262;713712HA?5;F<55129 $ BB?82; 38F2; :A9 @A62D 36; 712 BA@453<6367 7A5; 1<@ 7137 812 13; A65D 8!, 36; 7137 812 HA?5; =<C2 H1372C29 81213;238F2;:A9@A92@A62D:A9H1<B1712BA@453<6367 <6:A9@2; 1<@ <6 3@<5 7137 812 HA?5; =<C2 129 B39; BB?82; :AB?82; 7A9B1 5<=17
719A37 A:
BA@453<6367 36; 87?::2; -2; 81227 <67A 712 @A?71 A: 712 BA@453<6367 2 7126 ;93==2; 129 -D 129 13<9 36; 5ABF2; 712
* ;AA9271267AAF1296239712-3719AA@36;8H<7B12;A6712 5<=17 2 125; 712 :3B2 A: 712 BA@453<6367 ?6;29 712 5<=17 3729124?812;712BA@453<63677A712BA736;F<882;129A6 129:3B22 79<2;7A92@AC21296<=17436736;38F2; 1297A 92@AC271283@2126712BA@453<636792:?82;71283@236; 79<2;7A28B342:9A@712453B23BB?82;719237262;129H<71712 F6<:2 36; 92@AC2; 1<8 25387<B 793BF 4367 2 4?812; 712 BA@453<6367A6712-2;36;:255A612928J?22K2;712136;8 36;-A;DA:712BA@453<636736;:A9B2:?55D9342;1292A6B2 3=3<6719237262;7AF<55129H<71712F6<:2F<882;129-A;D36; A6B2 3=3<6 3772@472; 7A 9342 129 1?8 712 3BB?82; A <8 87372; 7A 13C2 BA@@<772; A::26B28 4?6<813-52 ?6;29 2B7<A68 *$*G))36;$,A:"12BB?82;A H1A<8712AH629A:712"H1292712C<B7<@H38928<;<6=;<; 6A7 <6:A9@ 712 <6B<;267 7A 712 4A5<B2 A9 36D 4?-5<B 829C367 ;284<72 13C<6= <6:A9@37<A6 3-A?7 712 83@2 1?8 712 82BA6; 3BB?82; <8 87372; 7A 13C2 BA@@<772; A::26B2 4?6<813-52 ?6;29 2B7<A6)A:"
$ :729:<5<6=712B139=281227B382H3892=<87292;<69<@2 A+ A: 12923:729 712 B382 H38 BA@@<772; 7A 712 A?97 A: 288<A68 36; H38 92=<87292; 38 A**+ A: ) <6B2 712 ;372 A: 399287 3BB?82; A <8 <6 B?87A;D 3BB?82; A H38 9252382; A6 -3<5 12 B139=28 :93@2; 3=3<687 712 3BB?82; :A9 712 3552=2; A::26B28 36; 83@2 H38 923; AC29 36; 2L453<62;7A7123BB?82;A836;BB?82;AH1A<8712 AH629 A: 712 " 3BBA@@A;37<A6 138 4523;2; =?<57D :A9 712 B139=2852C2552;3=3<6871<@36;12H38826726B2;7A43D3:<62 A: 8$!, 6 ;2:3?57 A: 43D@267 A: :<62 12 81355 ?6;29=A 8<@452 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 ;3D8 36; 12 138 43<; 712 :<62 3@A?67 BB?82; A 4523;2; 6A7 =?<57D 36; B53<@2; 7A -2 79<2; ) A49AC2712=?<57A:7123BB?82;<635571<97226H<7628828 H292 2L3@<62; 38 " 7A . * ;AB?@2678 H292 @39F2; 38 L1<-<78"7A"*36;8<L7226@3729<35A->2B78H292@39F2;38 7A + 6B5A8?92A:49A82B?7<A68<;22C<;26B287372@267A:712 3BB?82; ?6;29 2B7<A6 A: 712 A;2 A: 9<@<635 "9AB2;?92
H38 92BA9;2; 12 3BB?82; 138 7A7355D ;26<2; 712 2C<;26B2 A: 49A82B?7<A6 H<7628828 1AH2C29 12 ;<; 6A7 B1AA82 7A 523; 712 ;2:26B22C<;26B2A61<8-2135: G 3C<6=1239;71239=?@2678A6-A718<;2879<35A?97138 BA6C<B72; 712 3BB?82; :A9 712 A::26B2 ?6;29 2B7<A68 )&' *$ 36; $, A: " 36; 43882; 3 826726B2 7A ?6;29=A 9<=A9A?8<@49<8A6@267:A93429<A;A:D239836;7A43D3:<62 A: 8!, 12 3BB?82; H38 :?97129 826726B2; ?6;29=A 9<=A9A?8 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: D2398 36; 43D :<62 A: 8$!,:A9712A::26B24?6<813-52?6;2982B7<A6*$A:712 " 12 3BB?82;A <8 358A BA6C<B72; :A9 712A::26B2?6;29 2B7<A6 A: 712 " 36; 826726B2; 7A ?6;29=A 8<@452 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: @A6718 36; 7A 43D 3 :<62 A: 8!, 12 3BB?82; A <8 358A BA6C<B72; :A9 712 A::26B2 ?6;292B7<A6$,A:712"36;826726B2;7A?6;29=A8<@452 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: D239 36; 7A 43D 3 :<62 A: 8!,
?97129 712 79<35 BA?97 138 43882; 36 A9;29 7137 ?6;292B7<A6*+A:9"7123BB?82;A81355-2267<752;:A9 3 429<A; A: 827,A:: <6 92842B7 A: 712 429<A; 84267 -D 1<@ <6
) >?;<B<35 B?87A;D :9A@ $71 2472@-29 7<55 ;372 2<6= 3==9<2C2;-D712>?;=@267A:BA6C<B7<A636;A9;29A:826726B2 71234425536713;492:2992;71<8344235 9<3>371523962;BA?6825:A9712344255367HA?5;8?-@<7 7137 712 <@4?=62; A9;29 A: BA6C<B7<A6 36; 826726B2 43882; -D 712 79<35 A?97 392 3=3<687 712 53H 49AB2;?92 36; :3B78 A: 712 B382 12 523962; 288<A68 ?;=2 2992; <6 1A5;<6= 7137 712 344255367 <8 =?<57D A: 712 3552=2; BA@@<88<A6 A: A::26B28 7 <8 358A 8?-@<772; 7137 712 523962; 288<A68 ?;=2 138 2992; <6 -25<2C<6= 712 ?6BA99A-A9372; C298<A6 A: 712 49A82B?7<A6 7 <8 8?-@<772; 7137 712 B382 H38 92=<87292; 3=3<687 A62 ;3D 36; 713771292<87HA;3D8;253D<6:<5<6=712BA@453<6712B139=2 81227 <8 :<52; 3=3<687 712 3BB?82; ?935< C26 ?6;29 2B7<A6 *A:7129"712C<B7<@13887372;71263@2A:7123BB?82;
;3D36;924A97H38:<52;3:729:<5<6=712B139=281227 3:729 53482 A: @A6718 12 BA672678 A: L1<-<7 " <7825: <8 ;A?-7:?536;92BA9;<6=A:2C<;26B2138-2=?635@A873:72953482 A:AC29D2398:9A@712;372A::<5<6=712:<635924A97H1<B1-D <7825:138C<A5372;712836B7<7DA:79<35
+ "*,9?>3713 B52395D87372; 71371D@26A:712C<B7<@ H386A7<673B736;71292H386A1<87A9DA:82L?353883?57A6712 C<B7<@ 284<72 71292 <8 ;253D A: 7HA ;3D8 <6 5A;=<6= 712 BA@453<67<7 <82C<;2677137712 3552=2;3883?57 <883<;7A13C2 -226B3?82;A6712:3B2A:7122C<;26B2A:;AB7A9H1<B1=A287A 49AC2 712 BA67939D 12 BA552B7<A6 A: -5AA; 83@4528 <6 B9<@<635 B3828 <8 C35<; A65D <: <7 :A55AH8 712 4928B9<-2; 52=35 49AB2;?928 H1<B1 @3D <6B5?;2 AC298<=17 -D 3 @3=<879372 A9 92=<87292; @2;<B35493B7<7<A62967124928267B382-5AA;83@452H1<B1<8 <@42937<C2 7A 793B2 36; BA6:<9@ 712 <;267<7D A: 712 344255367 1292<6 H38 83<; 7A 13C2 -226 73F26 A6 71 AC2@-29
<635924A97<8:<52;A66;AC2@-29H1<B1HA?5;A65D ;2@A6879372 7137 267<92 49AB2;?92 A: BA552B7<6= 36; @37B1<6= -5AA; 83@4528 H38 A65D 7A <@45<B372 712 344255367 36; 6A7 7A 38B2973<6 712 79?71 12 523962; 288<A68 ?;=2 :3<52; 7A 34492B<3727122C<;26B236;@3729<358A692BA9;36;7A6A727137 712 49A82B?7<A6 138 :3<52; 7A 49AC2 712 B382 -2DA6; 355 9238A63-52;A?-7 635571282=9A?6;8128A?=17:A9355AH<6= 71<8344235
G 5729637<C25D 712 523962; BA?6825 HA?5; 8?-@<7 7137 <: 712 A?97BA@287A712BA6B5?8<A67137712A9;29A:BA6C<B7<A643882;-D 71279<35A?97<8<63BBA9;36B2H<7153H712826726B243882;-D712 79<35A?97@3D-2@A;<:<2;3871279<35A?9713843882;36A9;297A 9?6 712 826726B2 BA682B?7<C25D 36; :?97129 12 HA?5; 8?-@<7 7137 3BB?82;<86A7<634A8<7<A67A43D:<623@A?6738<@4A82;-D712 79<35A?97671279<35A?977123BB?82;H389249282672;719A?=1 2=35<;A?6825124928267344235<7825:<8:<52;3:72953482A: @A9271363D239123BB?82;<8<6>?;<B<35B?87A;D:A9@A927136G D2398 36; $ @A6718 6 355 71282 =9A?6;8 12 8A?=17 :A9 @A;<:<B37<A6A:826726B2 8 3=3<687 71<8 712 523962; <=1 A?97 AC296@267 "523;299<3F81@36HA?5;8?-@<7713771279<35A?97138 49A4295D34492B<372;712@3729<358A692BA9;<63BBA9;36B2H<71 53H36;:3B781A?=171263@2A:7123BB?82;<8;<::29267<6712
36;712B139=2,81227712C<B7<@138<;267<:<2;7123BB?82; <6 712 7287 <;267<:<B37<A6 4393;2 BBA9;<6=5D 12 8A?=17 :A9 ;<8@<8835A:712344235
* 3C<6=1239;71239=?@2678A6-A718<;2836;A6429?835 A:@3729<358453B2;-2:A9271<8A?97712:A55AH<6=4A<678HA?5; 39<82:A9@DBA68<;2937<A6 <' 12712971279<35A?97<8>?87<:<2;<6BA6C<B7<6=712 3BB?82; :A9 712 A::26B28 4?6<813-52 ?6;29 2B7<A68 *$)36;$,A:712"I <<' 127129712344255367<8267<752;:A9@A;<:<B37<A6A: 826726B2I <<<' 137A9;29I !"!"#$% $ 13C2B392:?55D2L3@<62;712@3729<358453B2;-2:A9271<8 A?97 6842B7A9 "39344363 =931393 "A5<B2 737<A6 138 53<; B139=2,81227 3=3<687 712 3BB?82; :A9 712 A::26B2 4?6<813-52 ?6;29 2B7<A68 *$ ) $, 36; ) A: 6;<36 "2635 A;21279<35A?97138BA6C<B72;7123BB?82;:A9712A::26B2 ?6;292B7<A68*$)36;$,A:6;<36"2635A;2 122628<8A:712B38239<82:9A@712BA@453<67:<52;-D "C<B7<@384292L1<-<7"<6H1<B1<7<887372;38?6;29
/
! "#$
%& '' % '' ( ! ) * % ''
*)
(% '' )*
* * ) +% ''
* %& '
) * '
' , ) *
)
) -* .
*
) *) ' )
) )
' " **
) *
)
)
) *
' * * *
** ) ) % '' ** ' *
*
*)
' /
* * **
' ' )) )
' , 0
)
)'
1*
) * ) *
*
/*' $ ) ) *
' * ) )*' * )
) ) * '0 ) 12 BA@453<67 H38 :<52; A6 )71 ?=?87 37 G 1A?98 6 712 -38<8 A: 712 BA@453<67 B382 H38 92=<87292; <6 9<@2A+A:3=3<6873BB?82; ;3D:A9BA@@<88<A6A: A::26B24?6<813-52?6;292B7<A68*$)$,36;) A: 6;<36 "2635 A;2 36;
H38 8?-@<772; 712 BA?97 A6 )71 ?=?87374@38429L1<-<7"+:72992=<87937<A6 A: 712 B382 4A5<B2 13C2 C<8<72; 712 84A7 36; BA6;?B72; 84A7 436B1363@3 A6 +71 ?=?87 38 429 L1<-<7 " <6 712 492826B2 A: "36B138 "A5<B2 13C2 358A BA673B72; 82<K?92 436B1363@3 38 429 L1<-<7 "* 12 <6C287<=37<6= A::<B29 138 A-73<62; @2;<B35 B297<:<B372 :9A@ 712 @2;<B35 A::<B29 36; 92BA9;2; 712 87372@267 A: H<7628828 36; 8?-@<772; B139=2, 81227 + A8?-87367<372712B38249A82B?7<A61382L3@<62;C<B7<@ 38"12138;24A82;<61292C<;26B238:A55AH8
/ $
"#$ #
2 /* !'
3 4 5 6*) #
' #'7'
' #'7'& ' #'7'8
)* ' ( !' !
)* ' ) '& ' 9
( ' ) * * 2 ' )* ) #'7' ) )) *)' * ) **' '& ) ) *
)'
* ) * ' "*
:' ))
) *
' * ' ) "9 ** * ' "
) ' $ ** ) *
)' * )' )
' " *) ' "** *
)' , **
&; ' , * < )*' " )
*
' ) * ) )) *
*
)' ' 2 ' " *
) )
' * 2
** )
) =
'
* * 0
' "
*
' 5 ) **
'
' " *) )** #'7'& = *) ' ( #'7' )
*
' )
* ) * + +'' !'
) *) *)' )' ,)2 *
* ) *'0 G 12BA@453<67<8@39F2;38L1<-<7"
?97129812138 ;24A82; 38 7A 712 @313K39 BA6;?B72; -D 712 "A5<B2 38 429 L1<-<78"36;"36;358A82<K?92A: 87A
?97129812 138;24A82;7137812=3C212987372@267?6;2982B7<A6*A: " 3:729 :<:7226 ;3D8 A: :<5<6= 712 BA@453<67 6; 3:729 A62 @A671 3:729 5A;=<6= 712 BA@453<67 4A5<B2 B3552; 129 7A 712 267935 3<5 26=35?9? 12 H267 71292 36; <;267<:<2; 712
$ 3BB?82; <6 7287 <;267<:<B37<A6 4393;2 A6 712 -38<8 A: BA5A?9 12<=1736;A712941D8<B35<;267<7DH1<B181292@2@-292; ",A?;13@<6<138;24A82;<61292C<;26B238:A55AH8
/ $
"#$ #
' /* !'
3 4 5 6*) #
' '7''
' #'7'& ' 9
+ )* ( ' )* ) ) (
)) * )* *)' *
) **' > !'' !
( )
'7' )
* )
'& ' ) 2 7 * ) * + 9 +' ' !' *) ? ))'0 ",9>?6 66<F9<81636 138 ;24A82; 38 7A 712 @313K39 BA673B72; -D 712 4A5<B2 38 429 L1<-<7 " 36; 358A 82<K?92 A: -536F27
",9?>3713138;24A82;7137A6)71?=?8737 4@B3@2H<717121<87A9DA:82L?353883?5736;138 ;24A82; 38 7A 712 2L3@<637<A6 A: 712 C<B7<@ 12 138 A4<62; 713771292<86A92B26782L?353883?57A6712-A;DA:712C<B7<@ 36;812138;24A82;387A@3729<35A->2B78 7A* "$,3F3443 83<; 7A -2 712 37728729 7A @313K39 L1<-<7 "*1386A78?44A972;712B382A:49A82B?7<A6 * ",9"93;224 ?@39138;24A82;<61<82C<;26B2387A 712<88?36B2A:@2;<B35B297<:<B37242973<6<6=7A7123BB?82; $ "),9 12662=A6;3443 D3@3=A6;3443 35383=AH;3 1<2:2;<B35 ::<B29138;24A82;7137A671AC2@-29 1213873F2671283@452-5AA;A:3BB?82;A36;136;2;AC29 71283@27A712"A5<B2 "+,1<C3F?@39262935363=29 H1AH38 7126318<5;39138;24A82;387A7127287<;267<:<B37<A64393;2 36;<88?36B2A:3924A9738429L1<-<7")
) ) ",3-? ?-,6842B7A9 A: "A5<B2 36; " "9381367 3-? "A5<B2 6842B7A9 13C2 ;24A82; 38 7A 712<9 92842B7<C2 <6C287<=37<A6 + ",9 2243 138 ;24A82; <6 129 2C<;26B2 38 7A <88?36B2 A:
A9268<B B<26B2 3-A937A9D 924A97 38 429 L1<-<7 " G ", "?9?81A773@ 88<87367 <92B7A9 36; 2B16<B35 363=29
A9268<BB<26B23-A937A9D36=35A92138;24A82;<6 1<8 2C<;26B2 38 7A 712 2L3@<637<A6 A: 397<B528 7A 36; <88?36B2A:B297<:<B372L1<-<7"* ", 9<8163 ?@39 138 ;24A82; 38 7A 1<8 4397 A: <6C287<=37<A6 6B392:?52L3@<637<A6A:@3729<352C<;26B2A:"87A* L1<-<7 "
924A97 L1<-<7 " 924A97 <7 <8 B5239 7137 71292<88?::<B<2672C<;26B27ABA687<7?727123552=2;BA@@<88<A6 A:A::26B2 1263@2A:3BB?82;<8?935<77127<@2A::<5<6=
1<8 63@2 <8 81AH6 38 ;3D C26 <6 712 87372@267 ?6;29
+ 2B7<A6*A:A;2A:9<@<635"9AB2B;?92@3;2-D712C<B7<@ 38429L1<-<7 "712C<B7<@ 13887372;713771263@2A:712 3BB?82;H38?935<12612H3838F2;3-A?71<863@21283<; 7137 1<8 63@2 <8 ;3D ?7 3:729 399287 A: 712 3BB?82; <7 <8 3552=2; -D 712 49A82B?7<A6 7137 712 63@2 A: 712 3BB?82; <8 ?935< 12 3BB?82; ?935< 138 -226 <;267<:<2; -D 712 C<B7<@ 1292:A92@29283DA:7123BB?82;71371<863@2<8 ;3D37712 7<@2 A: :<5<6=
;A28 6A7 @236 7137 3BB?82; ?935< 138 6A7 BA@@<772; 36D A::26B2 " 138 B52395D 87372; 7137 3:729 BA@@<77<6= 9342 712 3BB?82; H38 BA67<6?A?85D F<88<6= 712 C<B7<@ 126 812 873972; BA6C29837<A6 H<71 1<@ 2 H38 BA67<6?A?85DBA@<6=7A12936;93421293=3<636;3=3<6126 812 7A5; 1<@ 7A BA@2 62L7 ;3D 8737<6= 7137 ;AA9 H<55 6A7 -2 537B12; 126 358A 12 H38 6A7 523C<6= 126 812 38F2; 712 63@2A:7123BB?82;283<;1<863@238 ;3DBB?82;@<=17 13C2 7A5; 1<8 63@2 38 ;3D <6 A9;29 7A 3CA<; 1<8 A9<=<635 <;267<7D ?7 8?-82J?2675D 4A5<B2 13C2 3992872; 36; 7126 712 3BB?82; <;267<:<2; -D 712 C<B7<@ 1292:A92 <6 71<8 92=39; 712 39=?@26783;C36B2;A6-2135:A:7123BB?82;!344255367B366A7 -2 3BB2472; 12 79<35 BA?97 138 49A4295D 34492B<372; 712
G @3729<358A692BA9;<649A429429842B7<C236;13;BA@27A712 BA6B5?8<A671373BB?82;138BA@@<772;7123552=2;A::26B2 62L3@<637<A636;92,34492B<37<A6A:712267<922C<;26B2 A692BA9;<6;2426;2675D;A6A7:<6;36D:3B7?35A952=35299A9 <6 712 <@4?=62; >?;=@267 A: BA6C<B7<A6 43882; -D 712 79<35 BA?9726B2368H29"A<67A<67123::<9@37<C2 !"!"#% * <7192=39;7A@A;<:<B37<A6A:826726B2<8BA6B2962;712 79<35 A?97 138 43882; 712 826726B2 3=3<687 712 3BB?82; 38 ?6;29
@) ) &(AB ##2 )) 4'
)) ) * ) &+!AB > # )
'2 2 *2 *
2 ) ** )) *
'
)) 4'
)) )
* ) 8( # )
'( 2 *2 *
= ) ** )) *
'
)) 4'
)) )
* ) && * ) )
* &
' *
* ) ** )) *
'
)) 4'
)) *2
* ) ( !/ # )
*
'2 *
* 2 ) ** )) *
'
) $) 8 ##2 )) 4' ** * )
)
(C ! ** 1 A+
2 2
B'
> * Rs.2( 2 ) ' D 2 )2 5
* ) 45$E ) )' >) )
- 15$
)
* )'
9>( ))
* ' 9> 982 9! ! ) *
* '
D )
- **
* )) 4''
>) )) 2 #* 2
2 /* )'F $ 7 <8 8?-@<772; -D 712 523962; BA6B297 :A9 712 344255367 7137 7123BB?82;13<58:9A@4AA9:3@<5D36;2C26H386A7<63 4A8<7<A67A492:2936344235C263:72953482A:A62D239:9A@ 712;372A:>?;=@267<7H38A65D719A?=152=353<;BA?6B<51<8 344235H38<687<7?72;36;7123BB?82;<8<6<6;<C<;?35B?87A;D:A9 @A92 7136 6<62 D2398 8<L @A6718 12 3BB?82; <8 6A7 <6 3 4A8<7<A6 7A 43D :<62 3@A?67 38 <@4A82; -D 712 79<35 BA?97 A68<;29<6=355712825<7<=37<6=B<9B?@8736B28128A?=177A4388 3826726B2A65D:A93429<A;A:D239836;4388712A9;297A 9?6712826726B2BA6B?992675DA68<;29<6=7128?-@<88<A6A:712 <6729627BA?6B<5:A9712344255367!3BB?82;36;358A712:<636B<35 8737?8A:7123BB?82;36;429<A;A:;27267<A635923;D?6;29=A62
-D7123BB?82;<7<8>?8749A4297A@A;<:D712826726B2<@4A82; -D71279<35BA?97BBA9;<6=5D368H294A<676?@-297HA43975D <67123::<9@37<C2 !"!"# %
A97129238A683:A9287372;36;;<8B?88<A6849AB22;7A 4388712:A55AH<6= <' 44235<8355AH2;<64397. <<' ?;=@267A:BA6C<B7<A6;372;9;?=?87* 43882; <6 A**+ A: ) -D 712 ;;<7<A635 <7D <C<5 E 288<A68 ?;=2 26=35?9?<8BA6:<9@2;. <<<' 26726B2 ;372; 9; ?=?87 * 43882; <6 A**+A:)-D712;;<7<A635<7D <C<5E288<A68?;=226=35?9?<8@A;<:<2; 38?6;29
BB?82;!344255367 81355 ?6;29=A 9<=A9A?8 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: 726D239836;7A43D:<62A:8!, :A9712A::26B2?6;292B7<A6)&'A: ". - BB?82;!344255367 81355 ?6;29=A 9<=A9A?8 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: 7HAD239836;7A43D:<62A:8!, :A9
A::26B2 4?6<813-52 ?6;29 2B7<A6*$A:". B BB?82;!34425536781355?6;29=A<@452 @49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: 71922 @A6718 36; 7A 43D :<62 A: 8!, :A9 712 A::26B2 ?6;29 2B7<A6 A: ". ; BB?82;!34425536781355?6;29=A8<@452 <@49<8A6@267 :A9 3 429<A; A: A62 D239 36; 7A 43D :<62 A: 8!, :A9 A::26B2?6;292B7<A6$,".
55
826726B28 81355 9?6 BA6B?992675D.
* : BB?82;!344255367<8267<752;:A9827,A:: :A9 712 429<A; A: ;27267<A6 35923;D ?6;29=A62 <6 >?;<B<35 B?87A;D 38 429 2B7<A6*+A:9". <C' 2=<879D7A826;712BA4DA:71<8>?;=@26735A6= H<7179<35A?9792BA9;87A712BA6B2962;A?97. C' 2=<879D <8 ;<92B72; 7A 826; 712 BA4D A: 712 @A;<:<2; BA6C<B7<A6 H399367 38 429 @A;<:<B37<A6 A: 826726B2 43882; -D 71<8 A?97 7A 712 ?429<6726;267 267935 "9<8A6 "39344363 =93139326=35?9?. C<' 2=<879D <8 358A ;<92B72; 7A 826; BA4D A: 71<8 >?;=@267 :922 A: BA87 7A 712 ?429<6726;267 267935 "9<8A6 "39344363 =931393 H<71 3 ;<92B7<A67A:?96<8171283@27A7123BB?82;38 3BB?82;<8<6>?;<B<35B?87A;D. C<<' <B7<@ <8 267<752; :A9 BA@426837<A6 ?6;29 8 A@426837<A6 B12@2 38 A9;292; -D 71279<35A?972=<879D7A826;712BA4DA:71<8
$ >?;=@267 7A 712 2@-29 2B92739D <879<B7 2=35 29C<B28 ?71A9<7D 36=35A92 & 9-36' <879<B7 7A 3H39; 8?<73-52 BA@426837<A6 7A 712 <B7<@?6;29<B7<@A@426837<A6B12@2 & '( )*&+
66