Karnataka High Court

CRL.A/824/2023 of MOHAN NAIK Vs THE STATE OF KARNATAKA on 13 March 2026

Cites 0, Cited by 0

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 13TH DAY OF MARCH 2026 PRESENT THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 824 OF 2023 BETWEEN: 1. MOHAN NAIK S/O GOVINDA NAIK, NOW AGED ABOUT 23 YEARS, R/O AMMANAPURA, AVVERAHALLI POST, KAILANCH HOBLI, RAMANAGARA

Citations and Judicial Treatment

No citing decisions in the index yet

Cited by

0

Decisions in the index citing it

Cites

0

Decisions referred to

In this index

0

Of the decisions it cites

Overruled / Questioned

0

No negative treatment found

Loading the citing and cited decisions…

 

  

  



              



   !   "   " !  "   "  "  

  #$$% &'()*+,)-)./+01',23

   !    "   " !  "   "  "  

  #$$% &'()*+,)-)./+01',23

4 5     " 6



 

        R

  



 #$$%     "  

   

#$

 !   !   !       "  

  #$$%

  %7$

4   5  "

8  "  6

    

   7956

 

   "      

     :##!##    !   "              



     7#8

           :"  

   " " 

     ;< .==<//.*10 =><?<> 1;)0 .==<./ +*,<> <-1)'* 7956 '? 1;< ',< '? >)@)*./ >'-<,+><" .AA>)<B<, C2 1;< D+,A@<*1 '? -'*B)-1)'* .*, '>,<> '* 0<*1<*-< ,.1<, :1;!01 .>-;" "

  



=.00<, )*  ' '?  C2 1;<  ,,)1)'*./ )01>)-1 .*, <00)'*0 +,A<" .@.*.A.>. -'*B)-1)*A 1;< .==<//.*10 ?'> 1;< '??<*-<+*,<>0<-1)'*07#.*,0<*1<*-<,1;<@1'+*,<>A' $2<.>0>)A'>'+0)@=>)0'*@<*1.*,1'=.2.?)*<'? 0""!# <.-; )* ,<?.+/1 '? =.2@<*1 '? ?)*<" 1' +*,<>A' 0)@=/< )@=>)0'*@<*1?'>'*<2<.>  *1;<=><0<*1D+,A@<*1"('+/,/)E<1'()1;;'/,1;<*.@< '? 1;< B)-1)@ /.,2 )* B)<( '? 1;< =>'B)0)'*0 '? <-1)'* : .*, )* =+>0+.*-< '? 1;< 'C0<>B.1)'*0 '? '*FC/< +=><@< '+>1 )*

 B    5 9  9996 ;< =>'0<-+1>)G ;<><)*.?1<> ><?<>><, 1' .0 H1;< B)-1)@I  ;< ?.-10" .0 +*?'/,<, C2 1;< =>'0<-+1)'*" )* 0;'>1 -'*0=<-1+0")01;.1'*.1.C'+1$=@"1;<.--+0<, '0.*,.><.//<A<,1';.B<B)0)1<,1;<;'+0<'?"1;< B)-1)@ 1 )0 1;< -.0< '? 1;< =>'0<-+1)'* 1;.1 1;< .--+0<, (<>< +*,<> 1;< )*?/+<*-< '? ./-';'/ .1 1;< ></<B.*1 =')*1 '? 1)@<" )@@<,).1</2 +='* <*1<>)*A 1;< ;'+0<" 1;<2 .>< 01.1<, 1' ;.B< C'/1<,1;<@.)*,''>?>'@)*0),<.*,-/'0<,1;<()*,'(0"1;<><C2

  



=><B<*1)*A .*2 ='00)C)/)12 '? '+10),< )*1<>B<*1)'* '1; 1;< .--+0<," ;.B)*A -'@@'* )*1<*1)'*" -'@@)11<, ?'>-)C/< 0<G+./ )*1<>-'+>0<+='*1;<B)-1)@'*<.?1<>1;<'1;<>"1;<><C2.11>.-1)*A 1;< '??<*-< =+*)0;.C/< +*,<> <-1)'* 7 '? 1;< *,).* <*./ ',<

+>1;<>"1;<.--+0<,.11<@=1<,1'01>.*A+/.1<1;<B)-1)@" 1;<><C2-.+0)*A )*D+>)<0.*,-'@@)11)*A.*.-1.@'+*1)*A1' .* '??<*-<=+*)0;.C/<+*,<><-1)'*7'?1;<*,).*<*./',<

+>)*A 1;< -'+>0< '? )*B<01)A.1)'*" 1;< 01.1<@<*1 '? 1;< B)-1)@ (.0 ><-'>,<, +*,<> <-1)'* 9 '? 1;< ',< '? >)@)*./ >'-<,+><C<?'><1;<D+>)0,)-1)'*./.A)01>.1<'*;< .--+0<, (<>< .==><;<*,<, .*, ><@.*,<, 1' D+,)-)./ -+01',2

='*-'@=/<1)'*'?)*B<01)A.1)'*"1;<*B<01)A.1)*A ??)-<>/.),1;< -;.>A<0;<<1C<?'><1;<'+>1'?1;<>)*-)=./<*)'>)B)/+,A< .*, ;)<? +,)-)./ .A)01>.1<" .@.*.A.>." (;)-;" .?1<> 1.E)*A -'A*)J.*-<'?1;<'??<*-<0"-'@@)11<,1;<@.11<>1'1;<'+>1'? <00)'*0 C2 '>,<> ,.1<, : ='* ><-<)=1 '? 1;< -'@@)11./><-'>,0"1;<<00)'*0'+>10<-+><,1;<=><0<*-<'?1;< .--+0<, .*," .?1<> ;<.>)*A C'1; 0),<0" ?>.@<, -;.>A<0 .A.)*01 .--+0<, '0 .*,  ?'> 1;< '??<*-<0 =+*)0;.C/< +*,<> <-1)'*0

  



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

+>1;<> 1;< .--+0<, ' ;.0 01.1<, 1;.1"     

 

 

 

     !   "#

$%   

 

 &   '( )*    ;< .--+0<, ' ;.0 01.1<, 1;.1"    

  "  +," -.

 (&"#

$%   ;<2 ,), *'1 -;''0< 1' .,,+-< .*2 ,<?<*-< <B),<*-<

  



 ;<1>)./-'+>1".?1<>;<.>)*A/<.>*<,-'+*0</?'>1;<=.>1)<0 .*, .?1<> 0->+1)*)J)*A .*, .00<00)*A 1;< <B),<*-< '* ><-'>," -'*B)-1<, .*, 0<*1<*-<, 1;< .==<//.*10 ;<><)* ?'> 1;< '??<*-< =+*)0;.C/< +*,<> <-1)'* 7#  .*, 0<*1<*-<, 1;<@ 1' +*,<>A' $ 2<.>0 >)A'>'+0 )@=>)0'*@<*1 .*, 1' =.2 . ?)*< '? 0""!# <.-;" )* ,<?.+/1 '? =.2@<*1 '? ?)*< 1' +*,<>A'

0) @=/< )@=>)0'*@<*1 ?'> '*< 2<.> .*, ;.0 .-K+)11<, ?'> 1;< '??<*-< =+*)0;.C/< +*,<> <-1)'* 7  <)*A .AA>)<B<, C2 1;<)@=+A*<,D+,A@<*1'?-'*B)-1)'*.*,'>,<>'*0<*1<*-<"1;< .==<//.*10;.B<=><?<>><,1;)0.==<./  !"#$$#%$ 

 %$&

 '(& )) $&*+,,&-%'$.

>) <<>.**.  )A.,)" /<.>*<, -'+*0</ .==<.>)*A ?'> 1;< .==<//.*10B<;<@<*1/2-'*1<*,<,1;.11;<)@=+A*<,D+,A@<*1'? -'*B)-1)'* .*, 0<*1<*-< =.00<, C2 1;< /<.>*<, >)./ '+>1 )0 -'*1>.>21'/.("?.-10.*,=>'C.C)/)1)<0'?1;<-.0<1)00+C@)11<, 1;.11;<>)./'+>1;.0?.)/<,1'=>'=<>/2.==><-).1<1;<<B),<*-< '*><-'>,)*)10=>'=<>=<>0=<-1)B<.*,;.0<>>'*<'+0/2-'*B)-1<, 1;<.==<//.*10+*,<><-1)'*7#

  



: 1)0?+>1;<>0+C@)11<,1;.11;<-'*B)-1)'*)0=>)@.>)/2C.0<, '* 1;< 0'/)1.>2 1<01)@'*2 '? 9#B)-1)@" (;'0< <B),<*-<" .--'>,)*A 1' 1;< /<.>*<, -'+*0</" )0 >),,/<, ()1; @.1<>)./ -'*1>.,)-1)'*0.*,)*-'*0)01<*-)<0;'+A;)1)0.0<11/<,=>)*-)=/< 1;.1 -'*B)-1)'* -.* C< C.0<, '* 1;< 0'/< 1<01)@'*2 '? 1;< =>'0<-+1>)G"1;<0.@<@+01C<'?01<>/)*AK+./)12.*,@+01)*0=)>< -'*?),<*-< * 1;< =><0<*1 -.0<" 1;< <B),<*-< '? #9 ,'<0 *'1 @<<11;.101.*,.>, % ;</<.>*<,-'+*0</('+/,,>.(1;<.11<*1)'*'?1;)0'+>1 1' 1;< @.1<>)./ .,@)00)'*0 </)-)1<, )* 1;< ->'00#<G.@)*.1)'* '? #9" (;<><)* B)-1)@ ;.0 01.1<, 1;.1 B)-1)@ ,'<0 *'1 E*'( 1;< .--+0<,)-1)@;.0?+>1;<>,<='0<,1;.1B)-1)@)0.A<,.C'+1$L 2<.>0"@.>>)<,";.B)*A1;><<@.>>)<,0'*0.*,A>.*,-;)/,><* '>< )@='>1.*1/2" B)-1)@ ;.0 .,@)11<, 1;.1 B)-1)@ ;., *'1 0<<* 1;<?.-<0'?1;<=<>0'*0(;'.//<A<,/2-'@@)11<,1;<'??<*-<.*, ;.0<B<*01.1<,1;.11;<=<>0'*0=><0<*1C<?'><1;<'+>1.><*'1 1;< =<>0'*0 (;' -'@@)11<, >.=< '* ;<> ;<0< .,@)00)'*0" .--'>,)*A 1' 1;< /<.>*<, -'+*0</" 01>)E< .1 1;< >''1 '? 1;< =>'0<-+1)'*-.0<.*,,<@'/)0;1;<),<*1)?)-.1)'*'?1;<.--+0<,   



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

  



1;<

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

  



,)0-;.>A< 1;.1 C+>,<* ;<><?'><" 1;< .==<//.*10 .>< <*1)1/<, 1' 1;<C<*<?)1'?,'+C1.*,-'*0<K+<*1.-K+)11./  !"#$$#%$ % !&(-



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

  



-.0<;<,<?<*-<1;<'>2'??./0<)@=/)-.1)'*'*.--'+*1 '?=>)'> <*@)12 )0 . @<>< C./, 0+AA<01)'* ()1;'+1 .*2 0+C01.*1)B< <B),<*-< ;< /<.>*<, >)./ '+>1 ;.0 >)A;1/2 ><D<-1<, 1;< 0.), ,<?<*-<.0.*.?1<>1;'+A;1  1)0./0'-'*1<*,<,1;.11;<.-K+)11./'?1;<.==<//.*10?'> 1;<'??<*-<+*,<><-1)'*7,'<0*'1)*.*2@.**<>,)/+1< 1;< =>'0<-+1)'* -.0< ()1; ><A.>, 1' 1;< '??<*-< +*,<> <-1)'* 7#.-;-;.>A<;.01'C<)*,<=<*,<*1/2.00<00<,'*1;< C.0)0 '? <B),<*-< .B.)/.C/<" .*, 1;< /<.>*<, <00)'*0 +,A< ;.0 ,'*<0')*.--'>,.*-<()1;/.( 7

)*.//2" ;< 0+C@)11<, 1;.1 1;< )@=+A*<, D+,A@<*1 ><?/<-10 =>'=<> .==><-).1)'* '? <B),<*-< .*, -'>><-1 .==/)-.1)'* '? /<A./ =>)*-)=/<0 ;< ?)*,)*A0 ><-'>,<, C2 1;< >)./ '+>1 .>< *<)1;<> =<>B<>0<*'>-'*1>.>21'1;<@.1<>)./'*><-'>,0'.01'(.>>.*1 )*1<>?<><*-< C2 1;)0 '+>1 )* .* .==<./ .A.)*01 -'*B)-1)'* --'>,)*A/2"0'+A;1?'>,)0@)00./'?1;<.==<./ :

='* ;<.>)*A 1;< >)B./ -'*1<*1)'*0 +>A<, C2 1;< /<.>*<, -'+*0</?'>1;<.==<//.*10.*,1;</<.>*<, ?'>1;<1.1<".*,   



+='* =<>+0./ '? 1;< '>./ .*, ,'-+@<*1.>2 <B),<*-< .B.)/.C/< '* ><-'>,"1;<?'//'()*A=')*10.>)0<?'>-'*0),<>.1)'*)*1;)0.==<./ 5)6 ;<1;<> .==<//.*10!.--+0<, ;.B< @.,< '+1 . -.0<1')*1<>?<><()1;1;<)@=+A*<,D+,A@<*1 -'*B)-1)'* .*, '>,<> '* 0<*1<*-< =.00<, C2 1;<1>)./'+>1N

5) )6 ;.1 >,<>N % 2.*0(<>1'1;<.C'B<=')*10)0.0+*,<>

')*1' )*.??)>@.1)B<

')*1' .0=<>?)*./'>,<> &0-*#%0 #%' 1.   ;.B< A)B<* @2 .*G)'+0 -'*0),<>.1)'* 1' 1;< .>A+@<*10 .,B.*-<,C21;</<.>*<,-'+*0</?'>1;<=.>1)<0;.B<-.><?+//2 =<>+0<, 1;< <*1)>< '>./ .*, ,'-+@<*1.>2 <B),<*-< '* ><-'>," )*-/+,)*A1;<'>)A)*./><-'>,00<-+><,?>'@1;<>)./'+>1<)*A .*.==<//.1<'+>1+*,<><-1)'*7956'?1;<>"1;)0'+>1)0

  



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

  



?'+*,1'C<1>+01('>1;2.*,-><,)C/<"-.*?'>@1;<0'/<C.0)0?'> -'*B)-1)'* ()1;'+1 1;< *<-<00)12 '? -'>>'C'>.1)'* 1 1;< 0.@<

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

  



 *   B  5

6 ><='>1<, )* 56 :  " 1;< '+>1 ?'+*, 1'1.//2 -'*?/)-1)*A B<>0)'*0 '? 1;<=>'0<-+1>)G"?>'@(;.1(.001.1<,)*1;<-'@=/.)*1.*,(;.1 (.0 ,<='0<, C<?'>< '+>1" ><0+/1)*A )* @.1<>)./ )*-'*0)01<*-)<0 <B<>0)*A1;<-'*B)-1)'*.*,;'/,)*A1;.11;<=>'0<-+1>)G-.**'1 C<;</,1'C<.P01<>/)*A()1*<00"1;<'+>1@.1=.>.A>.=;'? 1;<D+,A@<*1";.0'=)*<,1;+0

M   



         

 

         

      

      

    

       



                               

 

   



   



     

   



    

 

     

  

                 

       

        

       

 



          

  

                

  



         

 

! "       

        



    

  

  





          



          #     



 !     

   

            

    

        

 

  

 

 "      

   



              

    

  

       

        

     

  

          

  

      

     $      

  

         

     

    

    

 

     

       

        



         

        

 

 

    

         

       

   

  % 



  

        

                       

   

       

I 9 *    B

 ><='>1<, )* 567  " 1;< '*C/< +=><@< '+>1 /.), ,'(* 1;.1

  



./1;'+A;1;<B)-1)@F00'/)1.>2<B),<*-<)*@.11<>0></.1<,1'0<G+./ '??<*-<0)0A<*<>.//2,<<@<,0+??)-)<*11';'/,.*.--+0<,A+)/12" 1;<-'*B)-1)'*-.**'1C<0+01.)*<,)?1;<=>'0<-+1>)GF01<01)@'*2)0 ?'+*, +*></).C/< .*, )*0+??)-)<*1 ,+< 1' ),<*1)?)<, ?/.(0 .*, /.-+*.<1(.0;</,1;+0

M&' (

     

  

   

           

     "

  



    

 

          





       )     

  

     "         

   % 

    

      



       

   

  

       

 

& 

          

         #   '*+    #   '*'   ,-.-/01

        

      

 



 

     



    "    1   

   )  2               



     

  )  2   

   

  " 



       

  



     

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

 ><='>1 ./0' ,'<0 *'1 =>'B),< .*2 -'*-/+0)B< 0+=='>1 1' 1;< =>'0<-+1)'*B<>0)'* % *'1;<> .0=<-1 1;.1 @<>)10 .11<*1)'* )0 1;< ,)0-><=.*-2 ></.1)*A1'1;</',A)*A'?1;<-'@=/.)*1;'+A;#9;.001.1<, 1;.1 ;<> 01.1<@<*1 (.0 ><-'>,<, .1 1;< ='/)-< 01.1)'*" G# )0

  



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

  



0<<* 1;.1 1;< -'@=/.)*1 (.0 /',A<, .1 .C'+1 9$ .@ '* 7 G;)C)1  )0 1;<

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

" .@.*.A.>. G;)C)1 9 )*,)-.1<0 1;.1

 ><='>1 (.0 =<*,)*A .1 1;< ></<B.*1 1)@< G;)C)1  )0 1;<

 .-E*'(/<,A@<*10='E<*1'C27

  



9 ;<.==<//.*10(<><-;.>A<,?'>1;<'??<*-<0+*,<><-1)'*0 7 .*, 7#  <-1)'* 7  -'*1<@=/.1<0 .* .-1 ,'*< ()1; 0+-; )*1<*1)'* '> E*'(/<,A< .*, +*,<> 0+-; -)>-+@01.*-<0 1;.1")?,<.1;;.,C<<*-.+0<,"1;<.-1('+/,.@'+*11'@+>,<> <-1)'*7#><K+)><0=>''?1;.1.('@.*(.0>.=<,C2'*< '>@'><=<>0'*0-'*01)1+1)*A. A>'+= '>.-1)*A)*?+>1;<>.*-<'? -'@@'*)*1<*1)'*

;< =>)*-)=./ -'*1<*1)'* '? 1;< /<.>*<, -'+*0</ ?'> 1;< .==<//.*10)01;.11;<B<>2),<*1)12'?1;<.--+0<,)0,'+C1?+/* =.>.A>.=; '$ '? ;<> ->'00#<G.@)*.1)'* 0;< ;.0 01.1<, 1;.1 (

 /  01 2 ,3  - 45   6 1 7 , 

8

    95  :  6     :14

5 #9;.0-/<.>/201.1<,1;.1B)-1)@;.0*'1),<*1)?)<,1;< .--+0<, <)1;<> '* 1;< ,.1< '? )*-),<*1 '> C<?'>< 1;< '+>1 * =.>.A>.=; '7" B)-1)@ ;.0 01.1<, "  ; /   6< 

 "#

 :  " ;< B)-1)@ ,'<0 *'1 E*'( 1;< -'*1<*10 '? G#-'@=/.)*1 ;<0< .,@)00)'*0 .>< @.1<>)./ )* *.1+>< ,<*1)?)-.1)'* '? 1;< .--+0<, )0 . ?'+*,.1)'*./ ?.-1 .*,   



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

;< ?)*./

 '=)*)'*#G;)C)1 % )*,)-.1<0 1;.1 0<@)*./

01. )*0 (<>< ,<1<-1<, '* 1<@ ' .*, 1;.1 ='00)C)/)12 '? ><-<*1 0<G+./)*1<>-'+>0<-'+/,C<-'*-/+,<,'(<B<>"1;<=>'0<-+1)'* ;.0 *'1 <01.C/)0;<, 1;.1  0 1' : 5)*-/+,)*A +*,<>A.>@<*106

  



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

  



.+1;'>)1)<0 ;< .//<A<, .>><01 ><='>1 )0 *'1 =>',+-<, ;< *B<01)A.1)*A ??)-<> 5#:6 ;.0 *'1 <G=/.)*<, 1;<0< ,)0-><=.*-)<0 +-; )*-'*0)01<*-)<0 )* .>><01 .*, =>',+-1)'* C<?'>< '+>1 A' 1' 1;< >''1 '? 1;< )*B<01)A.1)'* *'1;<>

0) A*)?)-.*1.0=<-1)01;<,)0-><=.*-2><A.>,)*A1;<1)@<'?)*-),<*1 *G.*,G$5<-1)'*901.1<@<*16"1;<1)@<'?)*-),<*1 )0 01.1<, .0 $ =@ '(<B<>" -<>1.)* ()1*<00<0 .*, ='/)-< ><-'>,0 )*,)-.1< 1;< 1)@< .0 C<1(<<*  =@ 1'  =@ +-; @.1<>)./ -'*1>.,)-1)'* ><A.>,)*A 1;< 1)@< '? '--+>><*-< .??<-101;<-><,)C)/)12'?1;<=>'0<-+1)'*-.0<01;<G$)01;< 01.1<@<*1 ><-'>,<, +*,<> <-1)'* 9 > '*  C<?'>< 1;< /<.>*<, ,,)1)'*./ )B)/ +,A< 5> *6 Q 

" .@.*.A.>.")1)00)A*)?)-.*11'*'1)-<1;.11;<.//<A<,)*-),<*1;.0 ;.==<*<, '*  .1 .C'+1 $ =@" C2 1;< .--+0<, '0 .*,  " ;'(<B<> 1;< 9 01.1<@<*1 (.0 ><-'>,<, '* "1;<><)0.,</.2)*><-'>,)*A1;<01.1<@<*1'?B)-1)@ (;)-;)0*'1<G=/.)*<,C21;<=>'0<-+1)'* $ ;< '*C/< +=><@< '+>1" )* 1;< -.0< '? 

       B  R   

  



 ><='>1<, )*   9   ;.0 )00+<, A+),</)*<0"(;)-;.><.0?'//'(0

M4$ 

      



   

  

  

   

  "     

 5  '+  -       



   

       

    

           

   -   

, / 7           

            $   

           8  9   :

 8       

  

   

 #   '*+ -.- 5       

 #   '*+ -.- 

 

        $ 

      

             

 #   '*+ -.- 





      9 

#  ';&-.-

 

, /     $    

            <

 8  9  <

:

8  , /     $    

   

 

           

       



 

         8  9   <

 :

 8    

  



, /  

 "

+         8        $  

 

        





     8  ,/ 8

="     6#  '*+5 -.- ,  

 5  >  ??> -.- 

       $      

 

 " 

/ 5      

 

 "   



  

    8    



     

#  '*+-.- '? 5    

    

   2  @   .  # 9-

  . 8    9-

 .  7      

 

 

   

            # 97         

      

    

  

(

    

  2@.

-

   .   



   

      2@. 9-

   .    

  



  

 

    ''      

             

   2@# A -

   .         )  

     

 

   







  



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

M+!.   

       . ! "#"$ % &'( ) *+, &' -   . . /012 34 5

6  78 796.:   '.  ; 3

4  ! < ! 5 =(> 5' 06   '. (?@.7

5A()BC 0 D+ &+EB+7806 < 06  ! ! ; 1' 5F..)I

  



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

0. ?<A+.>,00+-;.01;<=>'B)0'1'<-1)'*9'?1;<B),<*-<-1" <-1)'*$'?1;<B),<*-<-1".*,<-1)'*756'?1;<',< '? >)@)*./ >'-<,+>< @.*,.1< =>'1<-1)'* '? 1;< ,)A*)12 .*, =>)B.-2 '? 1;< =>'0<-+1>)G ;< '+>1 )0 ><K+)><, 1' <*0+>< 1;.1 B)-1)@)0*'10+CD<-1<,1';+@)/).1)*A'>)>></<B.*1K+<01)'*)*A.*, 1;.1 1;< .1@'0=;<>< '? 1;< -'+>1>''@ ,'<0 *'1 C<-'@<

  



)*1)@),.1)*A*1;)0-'*1<G1"1;<+,A<)0*'1<G=<-1<,1'><@.)* . 0)/<*1 0=<-1.1'>8 >.1;<>" 1;< +,A< @.2 )*1<>B<*< 1' -/.>)?2 .@C)A+)1)<0"1'<*0+><1;.11;<1<01)@'*2)0=>'=<>/2+*,<>01''," '>1'=><B<*1-'*?+0)'*-><.1<,,+>)*A->'00#<G.@)*.1)'*

3. / G+H IH 3, H  JH 5 1H K2LH . H 3, 96 H 5'>H

- +M

H N H O.H O.H 5P1H OQR 96 :, -: H H S

TH ?@. &H

- +M

 H 5AH "$H IH 34.:H  H BU.H -BH V()H IH 34.:H  HU 06JW

4. O TH-+M

HNHB+ B'H"&HO THOQR!F.HIH3, HOQ'

!HO) H  !06JX *1;<-.0<'*;.*,1;<1>)./-'+>1;.0)*1<>?<><,)*1;<><-'>,)*A '?<B),<*-<;<>'/<'?1;<D+,A<(;)/<><-'>,)*A1;<<B),<*-<)0 1' ?.-)/)1.1< .// 1;< 01.E< ;'/,<>0 '? 1;< -.0<" 1;.1 1'' )* 1;< @.11<>0 '? '??<*-<0 .A.)*01 ('@<* ;< .,B<>0)./ 0201<@ '? ->)@)*./D+>)0=>+,<*-<<G=<-101;<0.@< $ ;< +=><@< '+>1 )* 

 B " 5%%76  " -.+1)'*<, 1;.1 D+,)-)./ )*1<>B<*1)'* @+01 *'1 .==<.>1'?)//+=/.-+*.<)*1;<=>'0<-+1)'*-.0<;<0<=>)*-)=/<0 .==/2()1;<K+./?'>-<)*>.=<1>)./0;+0"./1;'+A;.+,A<@.2 /<A.//2.0E/<.,)*AK+<01)'*01'.>.=<B)-1)@+*,<><-1)'*$"

  



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

 0' .0 1' ?'>@ 1;< 0'/< C.0)0 ?'>

  



-'*B)-1)'* ()1;'+1 -'>>'C'>.1)'*  -'@=.>)0'* '? B)-1)@0 01.1<@<*1 +*,<> <-1)'* 9 >" 1;< -'*1<*10 '? 1;<

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

  



$

='* . -'@=><;<*0)B< ><#.==><-).1)'* '? 1;< <*1)>< <B),<*-<'*><-'>,"1;)0'+>1?)*,01;.11;<=>'0<-+1)'*;.0?.)/<, 1'<01.C/)0;)10-.0<C<2'*,><.0'*.C/<,'+C1;<<B),<*-<,'<0 *'1 ,)0-/'0< -/<.> .*, -'*0)01<*1 ),<*1)?)-.1)'* '? 1;< .--+0<, C2 #98 1;< @<,)-./ <B),<*-< ,'<0 *'1 -'A<*1/2 =>'B< ?'>-)C/< 0<G+./ )*1<>-'+>0<8 1;< 0<)J+><" -+01',2 .*, =>''? '? @.1<>)./ 'CD<-100+??<>?>'@0<>)'+0)*?)>@)1)<081;<.>><01.*,=>',+-1)'*'? 1;< .--+0<, .>< -/'+,<, C2 ,)0-><=.*-)<08 .*, 1;< )*,<=<*,<*1 ()1*<00<0 ;.B< *'1 ?+>*)0;<, +*)@=<.-;.C/< -'>>'C'>.1)'* ;< -+@+/.1)B< <??<-1 '? 1;< *'*#),<*1)?)-.1)'* C2 1;< B)-1)@" -'*1>.,)-1)'*0><A.>,)*A1;<1)@<'?)*-),<*1".C0<*-<'?)*D+>)<0" ,<?<-1)B<=>''?'?@<,)-./<B),<*-<")*-'*0)01<*-)<0)*1;<.>><01 =>'-<,+><" )@=>'=<> @.>E)*A '? @.1<>)./ 'CD<-10" .*, /.-E '? ></).C/<-'>>'C'>.1)'*"-><.1<0.0+C01.*1)./.*,><.0'*.C/<,'+C1 .01'1;<A+)/1'?1;<.==<//.*10+*,<><-1)'*7#1)0. -.>,)*./ =>)*-)=/< '? ->)@)*./ D+>)0=>+,<*-< 1;.1 1;< C+>,<* /)<0 <*1)></2 '* 1;< =>'0<-+1)'* 1' =>'B< )10 -.0< C<2'*, ><.0'*.C/< ,'+C1" .*, 0+0=)-)'*" ;'(<B<> 01>'*A" -.**'1 1.E< 1;< =/.-< '? =>''? * 1;< =><0<*1 -.0<" 1;< C<*<?)1 '? 0+-; ,'+C1 @+01 *<-<00.>)/2<*+><1'1;<.==<//.*10

  



$7 --'>,)*A/2"1;)0'+>1)0'?1;<-'*0),<><,'=)*)'*1;.11;< =>'0<-+1)'*;.0?.)/<,1'=>'B<1;<A+)/1'?1;<.==<//.*10C<2'*, .// ><.0'*.C/< ,'+C1 ;< .==<//.*10 .>< 1;<><?'>< <*1)1/<, 1' .-K+)11./C2<G1<*,)*A1;<C<*<?)1'?,'+C1--'>,)*A/2".*0(<> ')*1 ' )* 1;< .??)>@.1)B<" ;'/,)*A 1;.1 1;< .==<//.*10 ;.B< @.,<'+1.-.0<?'>)*1<>?<><*-<()1;1;<)@=+A*<,D+,A@<*1'? -'*B)-1)'*.*,'>,<>'*0<*1<*-< &0-*#%0 ,#%'  .

'>1;<><.0'*0.?'><01.1<,"=>'-<<,1'=.001;<?'//'()*A      5)6 ;<.==<./)0.//'(<,8

5) )6 ;< D+,A@<*1 '? -'*B)-1)'* .*, '>,<> '* 0<*1<*-< ,.1<, :1;!01 .>-;"  =.00<, )*  ' '?  C2 1;<  ,,)1)'*./ )01>)-1 .*, <00)'*0 +,A<" .@.*.A.>." -'*B)-1)*A 1;< .==<//.*10 ?'> 1;< '??<*-< =+*)0;.C/<+*,<><-1)'*7#")0;<><C2 0<1.0),<8

  



5) ))6 ;< .==<//.*10 .>< .-K+)11<, '? 1;< '??<*-< =+*)0;.C/<+*,<><-1)'*7#8

5) B6 ;< <A)01>.>5+,)-)./60;.//-'@@+*)-.1<1;)0 '>,<>?'>1;()1;1'1;<-'*-<>*<,D.)/.+1;'>)12 1;>'+A;<#@.)/.*,1;<.==<//.*100;.//C<0<1 .1/)C<>12")?1;<2.><*'1><K+)><,)*.*2'1;<> -.0<8

<A)01>2 1' 0<*, 1;< -'=2 '? 1;< D+,A@<*1 ./'*A ()1; 1>)./ '+>1><-'>,01'1;<-'*-<>*<,'+>1 *+/ 2 34 

/**

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Sign in, for free, to download the court copy. Reading the full text here stays open to everyone.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead