Karnataka High Court
CRL.A/907/2015 of THE STATE OF KARNATAKA Vs RAMESHA on 24 February 2026
NC: 2026:KHC:11601 CRL.A No. 907 of 2015 C/W CRL.A No. 464 of 2015 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 24TH DAY OF FEBRUARY, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 907 OF 2015 ( A ) C/W CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 464 OF 2015 IN CRL.A No. 907/2015
!
" #$ %$
#&&
'(
)*
#&&
I )
*
!
"
!
#
#
!$ $
%
#
& '$'
&
(!'"
)
!
! !$'(
Digitally signed
by RENUKA
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
)
*
!
"
!
#
*'
#
*'
!$"
+$'
, &
(!'"* #
!
! !"-*
& #
+
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE G BASAVARAJA
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
ORAL JUDGMENT
./0 %112%34 %5642 .7/ .8 /02 97:;<2=/ :%/2: '$'1%442:6= .(!'">?/02::6/6.=%3 64/56@/ %=: 2446.=4 &7:;2 7<A75 8.5 40.5/ B/02 /56%3 .75/B 02 /%/2 0%4 15282552: 53 .-'!' %;%6=4/ /02 .5:25 .8 @C76//%3 7=:25 2@/6.= $'( .8 =:6%=
2=%3 .:2 %=: /02 %11233%=/!%@@742: 0%4 15282552: 53 ."("!'%;%6=4//0297:;<2=/.8@.=D6@/6.=8.5 /02.882=@27=:252@/6.="-*.8=:6%=
2=%3.:2%=: 42=/2=@2 1%442: >? /02 /56%3 @.75/ /. 7=:25;. 46<132 6<1564.=<2=/8.5%1256.:.8.=2?2%5%=:/.1%?86=2.8
4 '''!* $ .5 /02 4%A2 .8 @.=D2=62=@2 /02 1%5/624 02526= %52 5282552:/./024%<25%=A>28.52/02/56%3.75/ " 56288%@/432%:6=;/./0242%112%34%52/0%/ /027>* =412@/.5 .8
.36@2 .5%
.36@2 /%/6.= 47><6//2: /02 @0%5;2 4022/ %;%6=4/ /02 %@@742: 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25
2@/6.=4 "-* %=: $'(
/ 64 %332;2: >? /02 15.42@7/6.= /0%/ /02 %@@742: <%5562: 79%/0% .= '$'('$02?E2525246:6=;/.;2/025%/06AA%/0.//637 D633%;2 .8 .5% .>36 8/25 /E.*%=:*0%38 <.=/04 .8 <%556%;2 %@@742: 4/%5/2: 47>92@/6=; 79%/0% >./0 /. <2=/%3 %=: 10?46@%3 0%5%44<2=/ >? %44%73/6=; 025 %=: %>746=;025E6/0%D62E/.@.25@2025%=:@%742:%=;25/. 025 3682 %=: E6/0 %= 6=/2=/6.= /. @%742 025 :2%/0 02 %>2//2: 79%/0% /. @.<<6/ 476@6:2 >? ;6D6=; <2=/%3 %=: 10?46@%3 0%5%44<2=/ 4 % 52473/ 79%/0% @.=47<2:
1.64. = .= ''$ %=: :62: 074 /02 %@@742: 0%4 @.<<6//2:/02@.<<6446.=.8%332;2:.882=@2 8/258636=;/02 @0%5;2 4022/ @%42E%452;64/252:6= .-!'$%=:/0252%8/25/02@%42E%4@.<<6//2: /. /02 .75/ .8 2446.=4 E06@0 E%4 52;64/252: 6= .(!'"02%@@742:E%4%5524/2:.=$'''$ %=:5232%42:.=>%63.=$''$ (
1. = 02%56=; .= @0%5;24 /56%3 .75/ 0%4 85%<2: @0%5;248.5/02@.<<6446.=.8%332;2:.882=@2%<2E%4
52%:*.D25 %=: 2F13%6=2: /. /02 %@@742: 6= /02 3%=;7%;2 A=.E= /. 06< %D6=; 7=:254/..: /02 4%<2 %@@742: 132%:2:=./;763/?%=:@3%6<2:/.>2/562: .15.D2/02;763/.8/02%@@742: 6=%33'E6/=24424 E252 2F%<6=2: %4
4 /. ' %=: /2= :.@7<2=/4 E252 <%5A2:%4F06>6/4
/.' = @3.4752 .8 15.42@7/6.= 46:2 2D6:2=@2 4/%/2<2=/ 7=:25 2@/6.= $$ .8 5
E%4 52@.5:2: @@742: 0%4 /./%33? :2=62: /02 2D6:2=@2 .8 15.42@7/6.= E6/=24424 .E2D25 02:6:=./@0..42/.32%:%=?:282=@22D6:2=@2 .=064>20%38 - %D6=;02%5:/02%5;7<2=/4.=>./046:24 /02/56%3 .75/ 0%4 @.=D6@/2: /02 %@@742: 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= "-* .8
%=: 42=/2=@2: /. 7=:25;. 46<132 6<1564.=<2=/ 8.5 % 1256.: .8 .=2 ?2%5 %=: 1%? 86=2 .8
4 '''!* 75/025 /02 /56%3 .75/ 0%4 %@C76//2: /02 %@@742:8.5/02.882=@27=:252@/6.=$'(.8
' 26=;%;;562D2:>?/0297:;<2=/.8%@C76//%3 /%/2 0%4 15282552: 56<6=%3 112%3 .-' .8 'G E0252%4 /02%@@742:0%415282552:56<6=%3112%3 ."(".8' %;%6=4//0297:;<2=/.8@.=D6@/6.=%=:.5:25.=42=/2=@2 1%442: >? /02 /56%3 .75/ 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= "-*.8
2%5=2:
56 %A40<%= E.73: 47><6/ /0%/ /026<17;=2:97:;<2=/%=:.5:25.8%@C76//%352@.5:2:>? /0232%5=2:2446.=4&7:;264@.=/5%5?/.3%E%=:8%@/4.8 /02@%42%=:2D6:2=@2.=52@.5:0252%4.=4%446;=2:>? /02 32%5=2: 2446.=4 &7:;2 E0632 1%446=; /02 6<17;=2: 97:;<2=/.8%@C76//%3%52255.=2.740232%5=2:2446.=4 &7:;2 0%4 =./ %1152@6%/2: %=: %=%3?H2: /02 2D6:2=@2 .8
*/02 @.<13%6=%=/ %=: /02 23:25 >5./025 .8 /02 :2@2%42: 02 /56%3 &7:;2 875/025 8%632: /. %1152@6%/2 /02 2D6:2=@2.8
/.
- E0.>26=;/02<%/256%3E6/=24424 /. /02 @%42 .8 /02 15.42@7/6.= 0%D2 @32%53? :21.42: 52;%5:6=; /02 :2<%=: .8 :.E5? 10?46@%3 %=: <2=/%3
0%5%44<2=/ <2/2: .7/ /. /02 :2@2%42: >? /02 %@@742: 0232%5=2:2446.=4&7:;2875/0258%632:/.%1152@6%/2/02 2D6:2=@2.8.886@6%3E6/=24424
*:.@/.5%=:F06>6/
*
.4/.5/2<521.5/=%33/0242;5.7=:4 6/644.7;0//. %33.E/02%112%3 $ 4%;%6=4//064 5602/%= /0232%5=2:@.7=4238.5 /02%11233%=/6=53 ."("!' E.73:47><6//0%//02 97:;<2=/ .8 @.=D6@/6.= %=: 42=/2=@2 1%442: >? /02 /56%3 .75/ 64 6332;%3 6=D%36: %=: 7=474/%6=%>32 7=:25 3%E 2 E.73: 47><6/ /0%/ /02 32%5=2: 2446.=4 &7:;2 0%4 =./ 15.1253?%1152@6%/2:/022D6:2=@2.=52@.5:%=:4%<20%4 52473/2: 6= <64@%556%;2 .8 974/6@2 02 /56%3 .75/ 0%4 15.1253?%1152@6%/2:/022D6:2=@2.=52@.5:6=52412@/.8 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= $'( .8 =:6%=
2=%3 .:2 .E2D25 /02 /56%3 .75/ 0%4 @.<<6//2: %= 255.5 6= @.=D6@/6=;/02%@@742:8.5/02.882=@27=:252@/6.="-* .8=:6%=
2=%3.:2 " 75/02502E.73:47><6//0%/ 6/6442//32:156=@6132.8 3%E /0%/ /02 15.42@7/6.= 40%33 15.D2 /02 @0%5;24 32D2332:
%;%6=4/ /02 %@@742: >2?.=: %33 52%4.=%>32 :.7>/ = /02 @%42 .= 0%=: /02 15.42@7/6.= 0%4 8%632: /. 15.D2 /02 @0%5;24 32D2332: %;%6=4/ /02 %11233%=/ %=: E02= /02 /56%3 .75/0%D6=;%@C76//2:/02%@@742:8.5/02<%9.5.882=@2 7=:252@/6.=$'(.8
@.=D6@/6=;/02%11233%=/8.5/02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= "-* 64 >%: 6= 3%E 02 %332;2: 6=@6:2=/0%:/%A2=13%@2.=3?%8/25$<.=/0485.</02:%/2 .8 <%556%;2 %=: <.52 1%5/6@73%53? /02 :2@2%42: %=: /02 %11233%=/ 0%: 36D2: /.;2/025 8.5 .=3? %>.7/ .=2*%=:*0%38 <.=/04 .7/ .8 4%6: /0522 <.=/04 02 %11233%=/ E%4 E.5A6=;6=%156D%/28%@/.5?%=:742:/.32%D2/020.742 %5.7=: ''' 6= /02 <.5=6=; %=: 52/75= %/ ''' 6= /02 =6;0/ 7@0 >26=; /02 @%42 /02 %11233%=/ 0%5%446=; /02 :2@2%42: 64 7=>2362D%>32 %=: 875/025 2D2= %4 125 /02 @.<13%6=/ %D25<2=/4 %=: <%/256%3 2D6:2=@2 /0252 64 =. 412@686@2F13%=%/6.=;6D2=6=/02@.<13%6=/%4/./02=%/752 6= E06@0 %11233%=/ 0%: 0%5%442: /02 :2@2%42: 02 /56%3 .75/ .=3?.=%447<1/6.=%=:15247<1/6.= 0%4@.=D6@/2: /02%11233%=/8.5/02%332;2:@56<26=/02%>42=@2.8%=?
@.;2=/15..8%;%6=4//02%11233%=/=%33/0242;5.7=:4 6/ 64 4.7;0/ /. %33.E /02 %112%3 .8 /02 %11233%=/ %=: /. :64<644/02%112%315282552:>?/02/%/2 %D6=; 02%5: /02 %5;7<2=/4 .= >./0 46:24 %=: .= 12574%3 .8 /02 <%/256%34 13%@2: >28.52 /064 .75/ /02
8.33. E6=;1.6=/4E.73:%56428.5<?@.=46:25%/6.=+ 6 02/025 /02 /56%3 .75/ 64 974/6862: 6= %@C76//6=; /02 %@@742: 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.=$'(.8
I 66 02/025 /02 /56%3 .75/ 64 974/6862: 6= @.=D6@/6=; /02 %@@742: 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.="-*.8
I 666 02/025 /02 %11233%=/ 64 2=/6/32: 8.5 <.:686@%/6.=.842=/2=@26<1.42:8.5/02.882=@2 7=:252@/6.="-*.8
I 6D 0%/.5:25I ( ?%=4E25/./02%>.D21.6=/4%52+
.6=/ .+6=/02%8865<%/6D2G
.6=/ .+6=/02%8865<%/6D2G
.6=/ .$+1%5/3?6=/02%8865<%/6D2G
.6=/ ."+%412586=%3.5:25 +,-./01,&012 0%D22F%<6=2:/02<%/256%3413%@2:>28.52/064.75/ 02 /56%3 .75/ 0%4 %@C76//2: /02 %@@742: 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:252@/6.=$'(.8
%=:@.=D6@/2:/02%@@742:8.5/02 .882=@27=:252@/6.="-*.8
6/052;%5:%@C76//%3.8 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= $'(
64 @.=@25=2: /02 /56%3 .75/0%4%446;=2:52%4.=4 E06@052%:%47=:25+*
! "" #$ %! # "" #$ # & # '
$ # " # # (
# " ) *# *
+
# " , -# "
+" .- # / 0 / $ 1
$/ 2 " $ $ " * $ 1 )$ $ #$ $ " 23
- #$ " #$ " " # $
"
# ' #
# " "" $ #$ " " $ "" ) " #
" #$
$ $ "" $ "" ) "" " # * * #$ " $ "" $ ##$ $ $ 445
! 5+ .6-72&89-
&:7-&8-&')729;
)-)2'06 .7,#
" .-# " / ' # " 8$ #
# " // / /
/ # " "$ " #. %%
" ! <</. 9-62
7=>6-9 ;
)-)2 '0 77-))
7:-97. ? , @ 7,#
" / .
A +/ B #
# #$
- . 6 )" # # $ C / 7 $ "
" 6$ # " / " " *
. %%
" ! D / .
-&?> ;E-
-&?-F
&:7
2&:-9 ;
)-)2 '0 6 7,#
" 3
+ $ . . " " # " / " $ " / B C "" . . #
* # " . )
) .- $ " # "/ )
$ *
$ *
* " . @$* #
#$ $ "" $ $" $ # #
* "/ " "" & #
" #$ B % B 5 B < # $ "
G #$
- " "
# $" #$ #
" "
& #" B %B 5 B < # * ""
# " " # # "
# H - $ * = 52*%1152@6%/6.= 52*@.=46:25%/6.= %=: 522F%<6=%/6.=.8/022=/6522D6:2=@2.=52@.5: :.=./86=: %=? 8%@/7%3 .5 32;%3 255.5 6= /02 6<17;=2: 97:;<2=/ .8 %@C76//%38.5/02.882=@27=:252@/6.=$'(
@@.5:6=;3? %=4E25
.6=/ .6=%8865<%/6D2 +,-./01,&0123 -1/4 - 6/052;%5:/./02@.=D6@/6.=7=:252@/6.="-*
/02 /56%3 .75/ 0%4 15.1253? %1152@6%/2: /02 2D6:2=@2 .= 52@.5: %=: @.=D6@/2: /02 %@@742: 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.="-*
%=:1%442:% 42=/2=@28.5% 1256.:.8 ?2%5%=:%34./.1%?%86=2.8 4 '''!* ' 2%5=2: @.7=423 8.5 /02 %@@742:!%11233%=/ 0%4 47><6//2: /0%/ /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= "-*
64
17=640%>32E6/06<1564.=<2=/8.5%/25<E06@0<%?2F/2=: /.$?2%54%=:40%33%34.>236%>32/.86=20232%5=2:@.7=423 E.73: 47><6/ /0%/ /02 %@@742: 0%4 %352%:? 7=:25;.=2 97:6@6%3@74/.:?8.5%1256.:.8$<.=/0402=4%<2<%?>2 42/ .88 8.5 /02 .<<6446.= .8 882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= "-*
75/02502E.73:47><6//0%/%@@742:0%4=./@.<<6//2: %=?.882=@2156.5/./064 0%D22F%<6=2:/02<%/256%346=/06452;%5:=/02/6/32 1%;2 .8 /02 97:;<2=/ 6/ 64 4/%/2: /0%/ :%/2 .8 %5524/ 64 $'''$ %=: :%/2 .8 5232%42 64 $''$ / 64 %34. @32%53?<2=/6.=2:/0%//02%@@742:E%46=97:6@6%3@74/.:?8.5 % 1256.: .8 $ <.=/04 02 %332;2: @.<<6446.= .8 .882=@2 7=:252@/6.="-*
6417=640%>32E6/06<1564.=<2=/8.5 %/25<E06@0<%?2F/2=:/.$?2%54%=:40%33%34.>236%>32/. 86=2 02 /%/2 0%4 =./ 13%@2: %=? <%/256%34 /. 40.E /0%/ %@@742:64@.=D6@/2:156.5/./064&7:;<2=/ 06326<1.46=; 42=/2=@2 /02/56%3.75/0%4.>425D2:/0%//02%@@742:0%4 /E.@063:52=%;2:(%=:"?2%54025264=.>.:?/.3..A%8/25 /0.42@063:52=@@742:64/02.=3?1254.=6=/020.742/64
06442@.=:<%556%;2%=:68026442=/2=@2:/.6<1564.=<2=/ 064@063:52=E633>2/05.E=/.4/522/4 .=46:256=;/02<6/6;%/6=;@65@7<4/%=@24 4.%4/.40.E /0232=62=@?/./02%@@742:%=:%34./021256.:.8:2/2=/6.= %352%:?7=:25;.=2>?/02%@@742: %<.8/02.16=6.=/0%/ 6/ 64974/%=:15.125/.<.:68?/0242=/2=@21%442:>?/02/56%3 .75/8.5%1256.:.8$<.=/046=4/2%:.8.=2?2%5E6/086=2.8
4 '''!* 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= "-* .8
2=@2 %=4E25
.6=/ . 6= %8865<%/6D2 %=:
.6=/ . $ 1%5/3?6=/021%5/3?%8865<%/6D2 +,-./01,&012 $ .5/02%8.524%6:52%4.=4%=::64@7446.=4 15.@22:/. 1%44/028.33.E6=;.5:25+ 6 02 56<6=%3 %112%3 .-' .8 ' 8632:>?/02/%/264 G 66 02 56<6=%3 %112%3 ."(" .8 ' 8632:>?/02%11233%=/64 ! "G
666 02 &7:;<2=/ .8 @.=D6@/6.= 8.5 /02 .882=@2 7=:25 2@/6.= "-* .8
>? /02 ::6/6.=%3 64/56@/ %=: 2446.=4 &7:;2 7<%A757 6= .(!'":%/2:'$'64@.=865<2: 6D 022=/2=@21%442:>?/02::6/6.=%3 64/56@/ %=: 2446.=4 6= .(!'" :%/2: '$'64<.:6862:%47=:25+ % @@742:64@.=D6@/2:%=:42=/2=@2: /.7=:25;.46<1326<1564.=<2=/8.5 %1256.:.8$<.=/048.5/02.882=@2 7=:252@/6.="-*.8
%=:%34. 1%?%86=2.8 4 '''!* D /6447><6//2:/0%/86=2%<.7=/%352%:? :21.46/2:>?/02%11233%=/02%@@742:642=/6/32: 8.5 42/ .88 7=:25 2@/6.= " .8 5
8.5 /02 1256.: %352%:? 7=:25;.=2 6= /02 97:6@6%3 @74/.:? 7/ .8 86=2 %<.7=/ .8 4 '''!* 4' '''!* 40%33 >2 1%6: /.
* %=97=:%6%0 >? E%? .8 @.<12=4%/6.= %4 125 .5:25 1%442: >? /02 /56%3 .75/
D6 %63 >.=: .8 /02 %@@742: 40%33 4/%=: @%=@2332:
2;64/5?64:652@/2:/.42=:%@.1?.8/06497:;<2=//. /02/56%3.75/%3.=;E6/0
/) ' %$( $
DHA,LDC List No.: 1 Sl No.: 39