Punjab and Haryana High Court
CRA-D/1672/2024 of ANMOLPREET SINGH Vs UT CHANDIGARH on 17 July 2026
HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT Anmolpreet Singh Versus U.T. Chandigarh 1. The date when the judgment is reserved 2. The date when the judgment is pronounced 3. The date when the judgment is uploaded 4. Whether only operative part of the judgment is pronounced or whether the full pronounced 5.
IN THE
Anmolpreet S
V
U.T. Chandig
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
6
Decisions referred to
In this index
5
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
1. The date
2. The date
3. The date
4. Whether pronounc pronounc
5. The dela judgmen
CORAM: H
H
Present : M M
Fo
M M M Fo
LAPITA BAN
T passed by Sp application in 25,54,59 of th
E HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB
CHANDIGARH
CRA-D-1672-
RESERVED
DATE OF DE Singh
Versus garh
e when the judgment is reserved e when the judgment is pronounc e when the judgment is uploaded r only operative part of the jud ced or whether the full jud ced ay, if any of the pronounceme nt, and reasons thereof HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEE HON’BLE MS. JUSTICE LAPI Mr. Davinder Kumar, Advocate fo Mr. PKS Phoolka, Advocate, or the appellant. Mr. Manish Bansal, Public Prosec Mr. Ankur Bali, Additional Public Ms. Diksha Sharma, Advocate, or respondent-U.T. Chandigarh NERJI, J. he appellant has challenged the pecial Judge, NIA Court, Chan n FIR No.29 of 26.02.2024 he Arms Act, 1959, Sections 4
B AND HARYANA AT -2024 (O&M) ON: MAY 22, 2026 ECISION: JULY 17, 2026 ...Appellant ...Respondent 22.05.2026 ced 17.07.2026 d 20.07.2026 dgment is dgment is Full ent of full Not applicable EPAK SIBAL ITA BANERJI for cutor with c Prosecutor and
order dated July 16, 2024, ndigarh, whereby his bail registered under Section 19, 471, 201, 120-B of the SHALINI
Indian Penal Sections 17, 1 1967 (hereinaf 36, Chandigarh added to the FI
2. L has been alleg under the UAP Tiger, who ha terrorist Goldy Chauhan @ T incriminating Chauhan @ Ti Pindu have ha money on vari arrest of the ap record to esta terrorist which offence and mu
3. It was that the ap Umang and Ka gave them mo designated ter harbouring any
Code, 1860 (hereinafter referr 18, 18-B, 20 of The Unlawful A fter referred to as “the UAPA”) h, has been dismissed. The prov IR on March 11, 2024. earned counsel for the appellan ged that the appellant was invo PA, but except for disclosure o ad allegedly stated that the ap y Brar’s gang and had given s Tiger and some of the co-acc material against him. It is only iger alleging that the appellant a arboured the gang members of G ious occasions at the asking of G ppellant. There was also no lega ablish the involvement of appe h could even suggest that the ap uch less an offence under the UA t is further argued that the case ppellant harboured Sunny @ Sac ailash Chauhan @ Tiger at his fl oney on several occasions at th rrorist. Under Section 19 of the y purported terrorist was three ye red to as “the IPC”) and Activities (Prevention) Act, ), at Police Station Sector- visions of UAPA were later nt submits that although it olved in unlawful activities of one Kailash Chauhan @ ppellant was a member of shelter to the said Kailash cused, there was no other y the statement of Kailash and one Parwinder Singh @ Goldy Brar and given them Goldy Brar which led to the ally admissible material on ellant with any designated ppellant has committed any APA. of the prosecution, at best, chin @ Maddy Manchanda, lat in TDI City, Mohali and he asking of Goldy Brar, a UAPA, the punishment for ears upto life imprisonment SHALINI
and the appell evidence to sh of Goldy Brar appellant shou
4. H v. State of M there was no ingredients “c present in this charged by inv
5. H Court in Unio Shoma Kanti 2024 SCC On another, repor Ashfaq Ansar 2024 SCC On Maharashtra wherein it has accused being 21 of the Cons
6. T affidavit after January 15, 2
lant is in custody for more than ow that the aforesaid people wer
r. Therefore, on the basis of pro uld be released on bail. He has relied on the judgment of Maharashtra reported in (1994)4 allegation or the material to onstituting a terrorist act” as de case. When such material is abs voking provisions of UAPA. He has further placed reliance on on of India v. K.A. Najeeb, repo Sen v. State of Maharashtra nLine SC 498, Vernon v. The S rted in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 8 ri @ Javed Ansari v. State of U Line SC 1755 and Javed Gulam and another, reported in 202 s been held that long custody tried under UAPA to the grant stitution of India. he Court had directed the Stat r filing of the supplementary
026. Pursuant to the said direc n two years. There was no re harboured at the instance olonged custody alone, the f Hitendra Vishnu Thakur 4 SCC 602 to submit that o argue that the essential efined under Section 15 is sent, the accused cannot be the judgments of the Apex orted in (2021) 3 SCC 713, and another, reported in State of Maharashtra and 885, Sheikh Javed Iqbal @ Uttar Pradesh, reported in m Nabi Shaikh v. State of 24 SCC OnLine SC 1693, by itself would entitle the of bail by invoking Article te to file a comprehensive challan, vide order dated ction, the State has filed a SHALINI
comprehensive Police (Crime)
7. L with his co- prosecution’s were apprehen Stand, Sector- without helme Sachin @ Mad one pistol and Sunny’s trouse trousers. All th No.29 was in 25/54/59 of the
8. T Singh @ Pind to Chandigarh (members of G Nagar, Mohali Umang to his @ Tiger along present appella @ Tiger, the February 28, 2 being identifie e affidavit of Dhiraj Kumar, ), Chandigarh Police. earned counsel for the State su -accused is involved in ant case is that on the basis of sec nded at around 11:45 pm on Fe 43, Chandigarh. The said boys ets. Upon enquiry, they revealed ddy Manchanda and Umang. Up d a live cartridge was found ers and 03 live cartridges were he cartridges bore the mark of “ nitially registered on February e Arms Act. he prosecution’s case is that du with the intention of harbouri h Railway Station and brought Goldy Brar’s gang) to his flat in i, in his Verna car. Thereafter, friend’s i.e the present appellan g with Sunny and Umang, was ant. Upon disclosure made by co e present appellant-Anmolpree 2024 from TDI City, Sector-111 ed by Sunny.
Deputy Superintendent of ubmits that appellant along ti-national activities. The cret information, two boys ebruary 25, 2024 near Bus were riding a white Activa d their names as Sunny @ pon search being conducted from the right pocket of e recovered from Umang’s “KF 7.65” on the back. FIR 26, 2024 under Sections the co-accused Parwinder ing the terrorists, had gone t back Sunny and Umang TDI City, Sector-111, SAS he shifted said Sunny and nt’s flat. Kailash Chauhan s then given shelter by the o-accused Kailash Chauhan t Singh was arrested on 1, SAS Nagar, Mohali after SHALINI
9. T designated ter had done recc and Panchkula gangster- Bhup hearing. Co-a Goldy Brar an present appella
10. T of the appella comprehensive members of a that the appell fully examined
11. T perused the ma
12. A the UAPA. Se ready referenc “4 C
an be cl as ca to he prosecution further alleges th rrorist Goldy Brar, co-accused e at the premises of District Co a on February 12, 2024 with pinder @ Bhuppi Rana when he ccused Sunny used to commu nd Vicky Chauhan through his ph ant has harboured members of G he prosecution has also relied u ant for the relevant period to b e affidavit. Since there was a co gang belonging to a designate ant should not be enlarged on b d his Court has heard learned co aterial on record. At the outset, it is appropriate to ection 43(D) of the UAPA is e:- 43 D. Modified application of ce Code.—
Notwithstanding anything ny other law, every offence puni e deemed to be a cognizable offe lause (c) of section 2 of the Cod s defined in that clause shall be c
Section 167 of the Code s ase involving an offence punisha o the modification that in sub-sec hat upon instructions from a Sunny, Umang and Maya urts at Mohali, Chandigarh the motive of killing one e would come for his court unicate with terrorists like hone on Signal App and the Goldy Brar’s gang. upon the account statement bring home his guilt in its ommon intention to harbour ed terrorist, it is submitted ail before the witnesses are ounsel for the parties and o refer to Section 43(D) of reproduced hereinafter for ertain provisions of the contained in the Code or ishable under this Act shall fence within the meaning of de, and “cognizable case” construed accordingly. shall apply in relation to a able under this Act subject ction (2),— SHALINI
(a “s ref da
(b in
“P in m in re pe hu
Pr in in pe th an in m
(a
(i) ref G (ii as St
(b G C m to ha .
pe an a) the references to “fifteen sixty days”, wherever they occ eferences to “thirty days”, “n ays” respectively; and
b) after the proviso, the foll nserted, namely:— Provided further that if it is no nvestigation within the said perio may if it is satisfied with the repo ndicating the progress of the inv easons for the detention of the eriod of ninety days, extend th undred and eighty days: rovided also that if the po nvestigation under this Act, req nvestigation, for police custody fr erson in judicial custody, he sh he reasons for doing so and sha ny, for requesting such police cu
3) Section 268 of the Code shall nvolving an offence punishable u modification that—
a) the reference in sub-section (1) ) to “the State Government” eference to “the Central G Government.”;
i) to “order of the State Gover s a reference to “order of the C tate Government, as the case may
b) the reference in sub-section Government” shall be construe Central Government or the State may be”.
4) Nothing in section 438 of the C o any case involving the arrest aving committed an offence puni
5) Notwithstanding anything co erson accused of an offence pun nd VI of this Act shall, if in cust days”, “ninety days” and cur, shall be construed as ninety days” and “ninety lowing provisos shall be ot possible to complete the od of ninety days, the Court ort of the Public Prosecutor vestigation and the specific e accused beyond the said he said period up to one olice officer making the quests, for the purposes of from judicial custody of any hall file an affidavit stating ll also explain the delay, if ustody. apply in relation to a case under this Act subject to the ) thereof— shall be construed as a Government or the State rnment” shall be construed Central Government or the ay be”; and
(2) thereof, to “the State d as a reference to “the e Government, as the case Code shall apply in relation of any person accused of ishable under this Act ontained in the Code, no nishable under Chapters IV tody, be released on bail or SHALINI
on gi su re pe gr pe se or ba an off ci ill re
13. A an offence pun custody, be re an opportunity relief and if th Section 173 Cr believing that proved. Sectio bail specified provided unde granting of bai
14. It Dhiraj Kumar incriminating n his own bond unless the Pu iven an opportunity of being he uch release: Provided that such a eleased on bail or on his own erusal of the case diary or the 73 of the Code is of the opinion rounds for believing that the erson is prima facie true.
6) The restrictions on granting ection (5) is in addition to the r r any other law for the time bei ail.
7) Notwithstanding anything con nd (6), no bail shall be granted ffence punishable under this A itizen and has entered the c legally except in very exception easons to be recorded in writing. As per Section 43-D(5) of the UA nishable under Chapter IV and V leased on bail unless the public y of being heard on the applicat e Court, on perusing the case dia r.P.C is of the opinion that there t the accusations against such on 43-D(6) further stipulates th in Section 43-D(5) would be in er the Cr.P.C or any other law for il. t appears from the comprehensiv r, DSP (Crime), Chandigarh P material has been found agai ublic Prosecutor has been eard on the application for accused person shall not be n bond if the Court, on a report made under section n that there are reasonable accusation against such g of bail specified in sub- restrictions under the Code ing in force on granting of ntained in sub-sections (5) d to a person accused of an Act, if he is not an Indian country unauthorisedly or nal circumstances and for .” APA, no person accused of VI of the UAPA shall, if in prosecutor has been given tion made by him for such ary or the report filed under e are reasonable grounds for h persons are prima facie hat restrictions for grant of addition to the restrictions r the time being in force on ve affidavit affirmed by Shri Police, that prima-facie no inst the present appellant. SHALINI
Furthermore, n appellant to th showing his in
15. T material like m show any link and also the @Pindu. No deposited the whom it was p is obtained to Pindu paid th photographs th cannot be held act. Apart from Tiger, prima-f by the prosecu
16. Fr DSP (Crime), Kailash Chauh arrested on Fe Mohali.
17. A fundamental ri right to a spee no link evidence has also been he commission of any crime, m nvolvement under UAPA. he prosecution has not reco mobile phone etc from the pre between the terrorist Goldy Bra co-accused Sunny, Umang, M link evidence is brought on money, at whose instructions paid. In case of Parwinder Singh o show after withdrawing the he same to co-accused Uman he appellant was found together d that the appellant had the inten m disclosure statements of Sunn facie no evidence has been coll ution. The appellant is in custody rom the comprehensive affidav Chandigarh Police, it transpire han @ Tiger and identification b ebruary 28, 2024 from TDI City Article 21 of the Constitution ight to protection of life and libe edy trial. It has been held by the established to connect the more so, to a crime/offence overed any incriminating esent appellant which will ar and the present Appellant Maya and Parwinder Singh record to show who had it was withdrawn and to h @ Pindu, a CCTV footage cash, Parwinder Singh @ ng. Just because in some with Sunny and Umang, it nt of committing a terrorist ny and Kailash Chauhan @ lected against the appellant y for more than two years. vit of Shri Dhiraj Kumar, es that upon disclosure by by Sunny, the appellant was y, Sector-111, SAS Nagar, n of India enshrines the erty which also includes the Supreme Court in a catena SHALINI
of judgments t UAPA to the g India. The Co the lengthy and Reference can Najeeb’s case be an essential Constitution o incarceration w an offence pu embargo unde the Court to g relevant extrac “ re ou gr at ap rig lik an ex an pr so co xx
In po ad off th ab that long custody by itself woul grant of bail by invoking Articl nstitutional Court would like to d arduous process of trial becom n be made to the judgment of t (supra), wherein it has been he l factor while granting bail unde of India provides right to speed would be a good ground to gran unishable under UAPA. It has er Section 43-D of UAPA would give effect to Article 21 of the ct of the aforesaid judgment is as
17. It is thus clear to us that estrictions like Section 43-D(5) ust the ability of Constitutiona rounds of violation of Part III of t commencement of proceedings, ppreciate the legislative policy a gours of such provisions will m kelihood of trial being complete nd the period of incarceration xceeded a substantial part of the n approach would safeguard rovisions like Section 43-D (5) o ole metric for denial of bail o onstitutional right to speedy trial xxxxxxxxxxx
9. xxxxxx nstead, Section 43-D (5) of UAP ossible ground for the compete ddition to the well settled consid ffence, possibility of tampering he witnesses or chance of the ac bsconsion etc.”
ld entitle the accused under le 21 of the Constitution of o prevent a situation where mes the punishment in itself. the Supreme Court in K.A. eld that long custody would er UAPA. Article 21 of the dy trial and long period of nt bail to an under-trial for s also been held that the d not negate the powers of Constitution of India. The s follows: t the presence of statutory of UAPA per se does not al Courts to grant bail on f the Constitution. Whereas , the Courts are expected to against grant of bail but the melt down where there is no ed within a reasonable time n already undergone has e prescribed sentence. Such against the possibility of of UAPA being used as the r for wholesale breach of l. PA merely provides another ent Court to refuse bail, in derations like gravity of the with evidence, influencing ccused evading the trial by SHALINI
18. T that serious al deny bail to hereunder:- “4 ref Sw w of Si fa di off ar pr re th re th C co th ap A re w w th de ca
19. In has held that g is necessary to an accused fr commission o possible and period of time he Supreme Court in the case o llegations against accused by it the accused. The relevant extr
44. In the case of Zahoor Ah eference was made to the judgme wamigal v. State of Tamil Na hich, citing two earlier decision f State v. Jagjit Singh (AIR 196 ingh v. State of (UT of Delhi) actors for granting bail under n iscussed. It was held that the na ffences, the character of the evid re peculiar to the accused, a re resence of the accused not be easonable apprehension of witne he larger interest of the publi elevant factors for granting or he appellants’ case founded on Constitution of India with the onsidering the fact that almost fi hey were taken into custody, ppellants have made out a llegations against them no dou eason alone bail cannot be den ith the offences under Chapters e have referred to the materials his stage. These materials etention of the appellants, pen ase under the other provisions 967 Act.” n the case of Shoma Kanti Sen ( generally pre-conviction detentio o maintain purity in the course rom being a fugitive from jus f an offence. Once it is apparen the accused has suffered inca e, the Court would ordinarily be of Vernon (supra) has held tself cannot be a reason to ract thereof is reproduced hmad Shah Watali (supra) ent of Jayendra Saraswathi adu [(2005) 2 SCC 13) in ns of this court in the cases 62 SC 253) and Gurcharan ) [(1978) 1 SCC 118), the normal circumstances were ature and seriousness of the dence, circumstances which easonable possibility of the eing secured at the trial; esses being tampered with; ic or the State would be rejecting bail. Juxtaposing Articles 14 and 21 of the aforesaid allegations and five years have lapsed since we are satisfied that the case for granting bail. bt are serious, but for that ied to them. While dealing IV and VI of the 1967 Act, s available against them at cannot justify continued ding final outcome of the of the 1860 Code and the (supra), the Supreme Court on at the investigation stage of trial and also to prevent stice or to prevent further nt that a timely trial is not arceration for a significant e obligated to enlarge them SHALINI
on bail as any facts of the cas be made betw and establish respondent’s r relevant extrac “x
SC of C pr its w on so ju St he y form of deprival of liberty mu se and also follow a just and fair ween the prosecution’s right to l the charges beyond any doub rights guaranteed under Part-III ct is reproduced hereinafter: xxx
7. In the case of K.A. Najeeb CC 713], a three Judge Bench o f us Aniruddha Bose, J was a Constitutional Court is not strictly rovisions of grant of bail in the s constitutional jurisdiction to r ho has been incarcerated for a l n Article 21 of Constitution of ought to be distinguished by Mr. udgment of this Court in the ca tate of Punjab [2024 INSC 92]. I eld:- "32. The Appellant's couns of KA Najeeb (supra) to b appellant has been in jail contrary to law laid down argument may appear co lacks depth and substance court was confronted wit except the respondent-acc already undergone trial imprisonment of not excee this court's decision to con the anticipation of the im respondent accused might since the respondent-acc portion of the maximum im five years, this court took i assessment to grant bail. case the trial of the respo from the other co-accused and he was traced back separately tried thereafter long list of witnesses that with reference to the sa ust be proportionate to the r procedure. A balance must lead evidence of its choice bt and simultaneously, the I of the Constitution. The v. Union of India [(2021) 3 of this Court (of which one a party), has held that a ly bound by the prohibitory 1967 Act and can exercise release an accused on bail long period of time, relying f India. This decision was Nataraj on facts relying on ase of Gurwinder Singh v. In this judgment it has been sel has relied upon the case back its contention that the for last five years which is in the said case. While this mpelling at first glance, it
e. In KA Najeeb's case this th a circumstance wherein used, other co-accused had l and were sentenced to eding eight years therefore nsider bail was grounded in mpending sentence that the t face upon conviction and cused had already served mprisonment i.e., more than it as a factor influencing its . Further, in KA Najeeb's ndent accused was severed d owing to his absconding k in 2015 and was being r and the NIA had filed a t were left to be examined aid accused therefore this SHALINI
ba en en fu do ha off su w pe en pr de in an ju co gr co tr sa de C be su ca la court was of the view of of trial in near future. Ho the trial is already und including the protected examined. As already available on record indica appellant in furtherance of by members of banne involving exchange of l through different chann deciphered and therefore appellant is released on ba that he will influence the which might hamper Therefore, mere delay in offences as one involved be used as a ground t aforesaid argument on th cannot be accepted.”
8. Relying on this judgment, ail is not a fundamental right. Se nlarged on bail, an accused numerated in Chapters IV and ulfill the conditions specified in S o not accept the first part of th as already accepted right of a ffences of the 1967 Act to be e uch right on Article 21 of the C as in the case of Najeeb (supra), eriod of incarceration was held nlarge an accused on bail in s rovision of Section 43D (5) of th etention is necessary to c nvestigation stage), to maintain p nd also to prevent an accused ustice. Such detention is also ne ommission of offence by the sam ravity and seriousness of the off ommitted by an accused, deten rial at the investigation and post- anction of law broadly on these r eprival of liberty results in br Constitution of India and must be eing reasonable, following a ju uch deprival must be proportion ase. These would be the overar aw Courts would have to apply unlikelihood of completion owever, in the present case der way and 22 witnesses d witnesses have been discussed, the material ates the involvement of the of terrorist activities backed ed terrorist organization large quantum of money nels which needs to be e in such a scenario if the ail there is every likelihood e key witnesses of the case the process of justice. n trial pertaining to grave in the instant case cannot to grant bail. Hence, the he behalf of the appellant Mr. Nataraj, submits that econdly, to be entitled to be d charged with offences VI of the 1967 Act, must Section 43D (5) thereof. We his submission. This Court an accused under the said enlarged on bail founding Constitution of India. This , and in that judgment, long d to be a valid ground to spite of the bail-restricting he 1967 Act. Pre-conviction ollect evidence (at the purity in the course of trial d from being fugitive from ecessary to prevent further me accused. Depending on ffence alleged to have been ntion before conclusion of -charge sheet stage has the reasonings. But any form of reach of Article 21 of the e justified on the ground of ust and fair procedure and nate in the facts of a given rching principles which the while testing prosecution’s SHALINI
pl ch w it ca co fo re Si w rej th no en pr th rej th th co in va al ap re
20. In Supreme Cour Howsoever se trial as enshrin of bail is only is not to be w thereof is repro “ ag v.
lea of pre-trial detention, both harge sheet stage.”
9. As regards second part o hich we have noted in the prece with a qualification. The rea ase would also have to be onstitutional court which is exa or retaining in custody an ac estricting offences. He cited ingh (supra) in which the judgm as distinguished on facts and a j ejecting the prayer for bail of the his was a judgment in the given ot dislocate the axis of reasonin nunciated in the case of Najeeb rosecution, another order of a c 8-1-2024, in the case of Mazhar his order, the petitioner's praye ejection order of the High Court he 1967 Act was rejected by the he ratio of the case of Watali onsidering the case of Vernon (s n this judgment accepting the r alid and applicable and then llegations in terms of the proviso 967 Act. Thus, the prosecutio ppellant is concerned, does not g easoning forming the basis of Ma
n the case of Javed Gulam N rt has observed that criminals a rious a crime may be, an accus ned under the Constitution of In to secure the attendance of the a withheld as a form of punishm oduced hereunder:
13. The aforesaid observations gain, in several judgments, such State of Bihar reported in (19
at investigation and post- of Mr Nataraj's argument eding paragraph, we accept asoning in Najeeb (supra) examined, if it is the amining prosecution's plea ccused charged with bail- the case of Gurwinder ment of K.A. Najeeb (supra) judgment of the High Court e appellant was upheld. But n facts of that case and did ng on constitutional ground b (supra). On behalf of the oordinate Bench passed on r Khan v. NIA was cited. In er for overturning a bail- under similar provisions of coordinate Bench applying (supra) judgment and also supra). We have proceeded restrictive provisions to be dealt with the individual o to Section 43-D (5) of the on's case, so far as the gain any premium from the azhar Khan (supra).’ [emphasis supplied]. Nabi Shaikh (supra), the are not born but made out. sed has a right to a speedy ndia. Moreover, the purpose accused at the trial and bail ment. The relevant extract s have resonated, time and as Kadra Pahadiya & Ors.
981) 3 SCC 671 and Abdul SHALINI
Re tr tr re ehman Antulay v. R.S. Nayak r
25. In the latter the Court reemp rial, and further held that an a rial, has no option: “The State or complain thus, the obligation of the as the case may be, to p reasonable promptitude country, where the large from poorer and weaker s versed in the ways of law, competent legal advice, t rule is wholly inadvisable. if an accused demands sp given one, may be a releva we cannot disentitle an ac infringement of his righ ground that he did not ask trial.”
4. In Mohd Muslim @ Hussa eported in 2023 INSC 311, this C “21. Before parting, it would laws which impose stringen bail, may be necessary in p are not concluded in time, th individual is immeasurable. their living conditions, more According to the Union Ho Parliament, the National C recorded that as on 31st Dec prisoners were lodged in jai 4,25,069 lakhs in the count convicts; the rest 4,27,165 w
22. The danger of unjust imp are at risk of “prisonisation Kerala High Court in A C reported in 1993 Cri L transformation” whereby identity. He is known by a n possessions. He has no Psychological problems res status, possessions, dignity life. The inmate culture of dreadful. The prisoner bec standards. Self-perception ch
23. There is a further danger crime, “as crime not only reported in (1992) 1 SCC phasized the right to speedy accused, facing prolonged ant prosecutes him. It is, e State or the complainant, proceed with the case with . Particularly, in this majority of accused come sections of the society, not where they do not often get the application of the said Of course, in a given case, eedy trial and yet he is not ant factor in his favour. But ccused from complaining of ht to speedy trial on the k for or insist upon a speedy ain v. State (NCT of Delhi) Court observed as under: be important to reflect that nt conditions for grant of public interest; yet, if trials he injustice wrecked on the Jails are overcrowded and e often than not, appalling. ome Ministry’s response to Crime Records Bureau had cember 2021, over 5,54,034 ils against total capacity of try. Of these 122,852 were were undertrials. prisonment, is that inmates n” a term described by the Convict Prisoner v. State LJ 3242, as “a radical the prisoner loses his number. He loses personal personal relationships. sult from loss of freedom, any autonomy of personal of prison turns out to be comes hostile by ordinary hanges. r of the prisoner turning to turns admirable, but the SHALINI
po cr is ad fu re fa va st in pr
21. In Javed Ansari liberty enshrin overarching an from granting provisions in undertrial und infringed. In th way. Even in stringent it m constitutionali more professional the crime, criminal” (also see Donald Community’ published in further deleterious effects - w to the weakest economic s livelihood, and in several ca as well as loss of family b society. The courts therefor these aspects (because in the loss to the accused is irrep trials – especially in cases, stringent provisions, are speedily.” Xxxxxxx
8. Criminals are not born ou otential in everyone is good an riminal as beyond redemption. T often missed when dealing with dult. Indeed, every saint has a uture. When a crime is committ esponsible for making the offend actors may be social and econo alue erosion or parental neglec tress of circumstances, or the m n a milieu of affluence contraste rivations.” n the case of Sheikh Javed Iq (supra), it has been held that ned under Article 21 of the nd sacrosanct. A Constitutional g bail to an accused on accou a penal statute if it finds that der Article 21 of the Constit hat event, such statutory restricti the case of interpretation of a may be, a constitutional court sm and the rule of law, of which
more honour is paid to the d Clemmer’s ‘The Prison 1940). Incarceration has where the accused belongs strata: immediate loss of ases, scattering of families bonds and alienation from re, have to be sensitive to e event of an acquittal, the eparable), and ensure that where special laws enact taken up and concluded ut but made. The human nd so, never write off any This humanist fundamental h delinquents, juvenile and a past and every sinner a ted, a variety of factors is der commit the crime. Those omic, may be, the result of ct; may be, because of the manifestation of temptations ed with indigence or other qbal @ Ashfaq Ansari @ right to life and personal Constitution of India is Court cannot be restrained unt of restrictive statutory the right of the accused- tution of India has been ions would not come in the a penal statute, howsoever has to lean in favour of h liberty is an intrinsic part. SHALINI
Furthermore, (supra) render on a Two Jud relevant extra hereunder:- “3 ha th th cu th ha im tr in w G pe gr to C co to in un be w in be co in co be ca ou K. Be Xx
C xx it was held that the view tak red by a three Judge Bench of th dge Bench like Sheikh Javed I act of Sheikh Javed Iqbal’s c
31. In Gurwinder Singh’s case as been placed by the responde his Court distinguished K.A. Naj hat the appellant in K.A. Naje ustody for five years and that the hat case was severed from the ot ad concluded whereupon th mprisonment of eight years; bu rial was already underway and ncluding the protected witnesse as in that context, the two Jud Gurwinder Singh observed th ertaining to grave offences cann rant bail.
2. This Court has, time and ag o life and personal liberty enshri Constitution of India is overar onstitutional court cannot be res o an accused on account of rest n a penal statute if it finds that ndertrial under Article 21 of the een infringed. In that event, s ould not come in the way nterpretation of a penal statute, e, a constitutional court has onstitutionalism and the rule of ntrinsic part. In the given fact onstitutional court may decline e very wrong to say that under annot be granted. It would run c ur constitutional jurisprudence. K.A. Najeeb’s case (supra) being ench is binding on a Bench of tw Xxxxxx
3. xxx Continued incarceration of the app xx.”
en in K.A. Najeeb’s case he Apex Court was binding Iqbal’s case (supra). The ase (supra) is reproduced e (supra) on which reliance ent, a two Judge Bench of jeeb’s case (supra) holding eeb’s case (supra) was in e trial 25 of the appellant in ther co-accused whose trial hey were sentenced to ut in Gurwinder Singh, the that twenty two witnesses es have been examined. It dge Bench of this Court in hat mere delay in trial not be used as a ground to gain, emphasized that right ined under Article 21 of the rching and sacrosanct. A strained from granting bail trictive statutory provisions t the right of the accused- e Constitution of India has such statutory restrictions
y. Even in the case of howsoever stringent it may s to lean in favour of f law of which liberty is an ts of a particular case, a to grant bail. But it would r a particular statute, bail counter to the very grain of In any view of the matter, g rendered by a three Judge wo Judges like us. ppellant cannot be justified SHALINI
22. In SCC 574, the 18-A and 20 charge-sheet w charge-sheet re “x di Bi Ph se off ho of In “P an ke ag Ja Ab m (A an Xx
23. T in the charge committed un produced on advised or inci Succinct reaso under: “x no n Jalaluddin Khan v. Union of I appellant was, inter-alia, charg of the UAPA. He was arrested was filed on January 07, 2023 eads as follows: xxx 7.1 Bihar Police had received i isturb the proposed visit of H ihar by some suspected person hulwarisharif area. On 11.07.20 ecret information, a raid was fficers of PS Phulwarisharif ouse/premises of Athar Parvej (A f documents “India 2047 Towa nternal Document: Not for Popular Front of India 20-2-20 nd 30 copies in Urdu, 49 cloth f e liye Popular Front ke saath greement on non-judicial stamp alaluddin Khan (A-2) with tenan bdul Qayum Ansari. The recover mobile phone having SIM card o A-2) were seized in the instant c nti-India activities.” Xxx” he Hon’ble Supreme Court was e-sheet showed that the appell nlawful activities as defined in record to show that the app ited the commission of terrorist a oning leading to the grant of xxx
0. Therefore, on plain readin ot possible to record a conclusio
India reported in (2024) 10 ged under Sections 13, 18, d on July 12, 2022 and a . The relevant part of the information about a plan to Hon’ble Prime Minister to ns who had assembled in 022 at about 19:30 hrs, on carried out by the police f, Patna at the rented (A-1) and recovered 05 sets ards Rule of Islamic India, Circulation”, Pamphlets 021” – 25 copies in Hindi flags, 02 magazines “Mulk h” and one copy of rent p by Farhat Bano w/o Md. nt Athar Parvej (A-1) son of red articles and a Samsung of accused Md. Jalaluddin case. They were related to of the opinion that nothing lant had taken part in or UAPA. No material was pellant advocated, abetted, acts or preparatory activity. bail is reproduced herein ng of the charge-sheet, it is on that there are reasonable SHALINI
gr ap is st m im re th pr br no ap he co Pe th ap C al du ac ex st st th ar ou If a C xx
24. In another” SLP 30, 2024, the p 40, 22-A and was in custod witnesses had rounds for believing that the ppellant of commission of offenc prima-facie true. We have take tatement of witness Z as they mini-trial. Looking at what we mpossible to record a prima-fac easonable grounds for believing he appellant of commission of o rima-facie true. No antecedents rought on record.
1. The upshot of the above d o reason to reject the bail ppellant.
2. Before we part with the ju ere that the Special Court and onsider the material in the erhaps the focus was more on herefore, the appellant’s case ppreciated. When a case is made Courts should not have any hesit llegations of the prosecution ma uty of the Courts is to consider t ccordance with the law. “Bail xception” is a settled law.
3. Even in a case like the pre tringent conditions for the gra tatutes, the same rule holds go hat the bail can be granted if th re satisfied. The rule also mean ut for grant of bail, the Court ca f the Courts start denying bail in violation of the rights guarante Constitution. xx” the case of “Mukesh Salam v. (Criminal) No.3655 of 2024, v petitioner was charged under Sec 22-C of UAPA and directed to dy since May 06, 2020 and 4 been examined. The Apex Cou e accusation against the ces punishable under UAPA en the charge-sheet and the are without conducting a e have held earlier, it is cie finding that there were that the accusation against offences under UAPA was of the appellant have been discussion is that there was application filed by the udgment, we must mention d the High Court did not charge-sheet objectively. the activities of PFI, and e could not be properly e out for a grant of bail, the tation in granting bail. The ay be very serious. But, the the case for grant of bail in is the rule and jail is an esent case where there are ant of bail in the relevant ood with only modification he conditions in the statute s that once a case is made annot decline to grant bail. n deserving cases, it will be eed under Article 21 of our State of Chhattisgarh and vide an order dated August ctions 10, 13, 17, 38 (1) (2), o be released on bail as he 40 out of 100 prosecution urt observed that continued SHALINI
detention of th was no likelih the conditions following two bail:
st
(ii Ju pr co
25. In Chhattisgarh, dated Februar order passed b the prosecution articles which search being conscious poss “x
4. w po
(i) (ii (ii (iv
(v) Xx he petitioner would not subserve hood of early conclusion of the s that may be imposed by the o conditions were imposed as t
(i) The petitioner shall repo tation once every week and i) The petitioner shall remai udge on every date of the tria resence is dispensed with by t ooperate in the early conclusion n a recent case in Tapas K reported in 2025 SCC OnLin ry 14, 2025, the Supreme Cou by the High Court, rejecting the b n’s case, the appellant was trav h could be ordinarily related to conducted, it was alleged th session of the following articles: xxx . The search was undertaken ere recovered from the car a ossession of the appellant herein ) 95 pair of shoes i) Green black printed cloth
ii) Two bundles of electric wir v) LED lens and v) Walki talki and other article
Xxx”
the ends of justice as there trial. However, along with Special Judge (NIA Act) the conditions for grant of ort to the nearest police in present before the trial al without fail, unless his the trial Court, and shall of the trial.” Kumar Palit v. State of e SC 322, by a judgment urt set-aside the impugned bail of the appellant. As per elling in a vehicle carrying o Naxalite activities. Upon hat the appellant was in
n and the following articles lleged to be in conscious n:- re each of 100 metere es. SHALINI
26. In After filing of 42 witnesses a observed that e judicial custod regarding time evidence. Th circumstances, released on Furthermore, i charge of the examined and served if sever The relevant ex “x cl ha Ar Xx of ex is Xx w in ex de ha gu an n that case, the appellant was ar the charge-sheet, the prosecutio and intended to examine as man even after the passing of five yea dy, learned counsel appearing e that would be consumed to com he Supreme Court recorded , it was left with no other optio bail despite the seriousness it was of the view that the Publ trial, had to decide which of who were to be dropped as no ral witnesses were examined for xtract of the said judgment is rep xxx
0. However, many times we lear that howsoever serious a c as a fundamental right of spe rticle 21 of the Constitution. Xxx
2. The aforesaid results in ind f trial. It is expected of the Pu xercise his discretion insofar as concerned. Xxx
4. In this regard, the role of ould also assume importance. nquire with the Special Public Pr xamine a particular witness if epose the very same thing tha ave deposed earlier. We may uidelines, but time has come to c nd bail in its true and proper pe rrested on March 24, 2020. n was only able to examine ny as 100 witnesses. It was ars of the appellant being in for the State had no idea mplete the recording of oral that in the aforesaid on but to get the appellant s of the crime alleged. lic Prosecutor who was in- f the witnesses were to be o useful purpose would be r establishing the same fact. produced hereinafter: have made ourselves very crime may be the accused eedy trial as enshrined in definite delay in conclusion ublic Prosecutor to wisely examination of the witness of the Special Judge (NIA) The Special Judge should rosecutor why he intends to f such witness is going to t any other witness might sound as if laying some consider this issue of delay erspective. If an accused is SHALINI
to in sa th on gu fin of ac re am no st an ex cr th C en Xx
27. In were indulging to the commi accused to ad commit any te of bail especi worthwhile m this stage.
28. T relevant to be hereinafter: “1 th [e o get a final verdict after incarce n jail as an undertrial prisoner, aid that his right to have a speed he Constitution has been infringe n accused persons- who rema uilty- can also be significant. nancially compensated for what f pre-trial incarceration. They m ccommodation, experienced elationships while incarcerated, mount of money on legal fees. If ot guilty, they have likely endur tigmatized and perhaps even ost nd will have to rebuild their lives
5. We would say that delays a xtremely bad for the victims, for redibility of our justice system, w he masters of their Courtrooms a Code provides many tools for the nsure that cases proceed efficien Xxx” n the present case, even if one a g in ‘terrorist acts’ or were parti ission of terrorist acts, relevan dvocating, abetting, advising, errorist act had to be brought on ially after a long period of inc aterial has been brought on rec he definition of a “terrorist e considered at this juncture an
15. Terrorist Act- (1) whoever d hreaten or likely to threaten th economic security] or sovereignt eration of six to seven years then, definitely, it could be dy trial under Article 21 of ed. The stress of long trials ain innocent until proven Accused persons are not t might be a lengthy period may also have lost a job for damage to personal and spent a considerable f an accused person is found red many months of being tracized in their community s with their own resources. are bad for the accused and r Indian society and for the which is valued. Judges are and the Criminal Procedure e Judges to use in order to ntly. assumes that the co-accused icipating in acts preparatory nt material connecting the inciting or conspiring to n record to justify rejection carceration. However, no cord by the prosecution, at act” under Section 15 is nd the same is reproduced does any act with intent to he unity, integrity, security ty of India or with intent to SHALINI
st se
(a or w or nu m
(i) (ii
(ii lif
[( pr co m
(iv fo of G ag
(b cr pu fu
(c) ki co th in or co
[( off tr
29. T IPC, Section 2
trike terror or likely to strike te ection of the people in India or in
a) by using bombs, dynamite or r inflammable substances or eapons or poisonous or noxious r by any other substances (whet uclear or otherwise) of a hazard means of whatever nature to caus ) death of, or injuries to, any per
i) loss of, or damage to, or destr
ii) disruption of any supplies o fe of the community in India or in (iiia) damage to, the monetary s roduction or smuggling or ci ounterfeit Indian paper curren material; or]
v) damage or destruction of any oreign country used or intended f India or in connection with a Government of India, any State G gencies; or
b) overawes by means of crim riminal force or attempts to do ublic functionary or attempts to unctionary; or
c) detains, kidnaps or abducts a ill or injure such person or does ompel the Government of India, he Government of a foreign coun nter-governmental organisation r abstain from doing any act; or] ommits a terrorist act.
The terrorist act includes a ffence within the scope of, and reaties specified in the Second Sc he charge sheet under Sections 1 25/54/59 of the Arms Act and Se error in the people or any n any foreign country,- other explosive substances firearms or other lethal s gases or other chemicals ther biological radioactive, dous nature or by any other e or likely to cause - rson or persons; or ruction of, property; or or services essential to the n any foreign country; or stability of India by way of irculation of high quality ncy, coin or of any other y property in India or in a d to be used for the defence any other purposes of the Government or any of their inal force or the show of so or causes death of any o cause death of any public ny person and threatens to s any other act in order to , any State Government or ntry or [an international or or any other person to do ], an act which constitutes an d as defined in any of the chedule.] 120-B, 201, 419, 471 of the ections 17, 18, 18-B and 20 SHALINI
of UAPA was prosecution wi is also unable required for co other option bu
30. In the Supreme C two and a ha considering on allowed and th appellant is or conditions bes the trial Court/
(i) ₹1
(ii ho
(ii da
(iv w
v) th th
vi th an ag th s filed on March 10, 2026 and itnesses has been examined till d to give any reasonable estimat ompletion of the trial. Therefore ut to release the appellant on bai n view of the aforesaid discussio Court, especially when the appell alf years and the end of the nly 01 out of 56 witnesses has be he impugned order dated July rdered to be released on regula sides furnishing of requisite bail /Duty Magistrate concerned:- ) He shall furnish bond of ₹10 10 lakh each;
i) He shall surrender his passpor olding the same and is still with h
ii) He shall appear before the Tri ate, unless exempted by the Cour
v) He shall appear before the In when summoned; ) He shall not directly or indirec hreat or promise to any person a he case or who is cited as witness
i) He shall not involve in any cri he pendency of trial, he is found ny offence punishable under gency would be free to approac his order and cancellation of his b only 01 witness out of 56 date. Learned State counsel te of the time that may be e, the Court is left with no l. on and the law laid down by lant is in custody for almost trial is not in sight and een examined, the appeal is 16, 2024 is set aside. The ar bail subject to following bonds to the satisfaction of 0 lakh with two sureties of rt in the Trial Court, if he is him; ial Court on each and every rt; nvestigating Officer, as and ctly make any inducement, acquainted with the facts of s; minal activity and if during involved in commission of UAPA, the prosecuting ch this Court for recalling bail; SHALINI
vi th
vi of sh
ix SH ev
31. In conditions, or independently, the bail of the Court. Similar any of the w prosecution sh concerned app Court.
(DEEPAK SI
JUDGE
JULY 17, 202 shalini
Whether speak Whether repor ii) He shall not sell, transfer or hird party right over his immovab
iii) He shall furnish an undertaki f his absence, Trial Court may pr hall not claim re-examination of
x) At the time of release of the HO shall be informed. He shall very alternate Monday till the co n the event there is a breach of a r of the conditions to be imp , it would be open to the prosecu e defaulting appellant without an rly, if the appellant seeks to thre witnesses, whether directly or hall be at liberty to seek ca pellant by making appropriate a IBAL)
(L E
king/reasoned:
Yes/No rtable:
Yes/No in any other manner create ble property; ing to the effect that in case roceed with the trial and he any witness. e appellant, the concerned appear before the SHO on nclusion of the trial. any of the abovementioned posed by the Trial Court ution to seek cancellation of ny further reference to this aten or otherwise influence indirectly, then also the ancellation of bail of the application before the Trial LAPITA BANERJI) JUDGE SHALINI