Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals

DEEPAK BHANDARI ANOTHER vs STATE BANK OF INDIA on 5 May 2025

sTfi-d vrqft iqr -ip7 /2024

ETr rqfr 3Tfufr{ur qf,dg(

(n u. G udsrg rrw)

(ffi{ 3rffi - q-rq-fiq +fr vr,ry F-qTq q-}d)

orfif, sr+ft t+t -r,tzt /zoz+

1. Aqo qlgtt oTrfrrq fftq fu-6 q-sTt, frtq Rt-6 q!-sft (qFqr) sTrfrrq fr frt< Rt6 ,il:€rfr qtlT ftqT{ft qcrid ft-flqr t-}s r, qcr+f, ftqrs i)-s nq-q \q ft. ................ .qfr-dTrff, ftsq ec fu dE gtrsqr *{s VS.ffi ffi fr-qq s, qfltif, ft-qrs tE E<h w.fr............... ... ......8-f,rqrft / eTEfrrd-c +€{, tqd ;iq6tg qTuslt gu-s TfiI qdie ftfrys (g-q ftlf,{eqq) gnr onqtfird ftrqlsq Er$o)-i Sw vq.ft. E-di Wrft fr.osd.q F.fu.T fr.ft.or\ Htq tRqr d q6 sd-t w fr .........8-f,{qrft / srEfr,de feq,

Page 1 of 18

orfrflpff qer d frC +ft 3Terf, orq-aa 3Tfu{ffirt s-ff-4rfr t-6 d fuc fr e-ftur z-gtrfi olfu-{fiTt ffi d-ar c.s{ d frl +t frnr gaar etBrm t 3TI t qI (fttio os.os.eozs ol dR-o) r. orq-f,Pfi qel dt{I ffi;6 za.ot.zoz+ o\ qe erft-d {s 3Tko{,r A EqA 3{ffi gm O.c.{' \'ffi etrqq @ctq. 74/2ooz d qrtro *fu no* 2s.os.2o23 d fr.t-€ um so (l) ern.$.fr. vqe 1ee3 d urotrnrjsti rqn a1 .d t t ,. ffi6pft qm t erfi-a rqd o{i i gc fuffq o\ erqr ftd qd tg emr s {qr{r 3rftF=qq reos d fid-.td fr=tl-fi 24.01.2024 o\ gero erfet c-q( fuqT t, srer fr 3lfr-d ngo o-G fu um eo-g em.S.fr.v{e 1ee3 d crqqmrgqri ffirqr x'r qrRr or so sfrPm q+rt frrS qri ot ft-ffid u1 qftHrtrdr t 3rq-dTrft{"sr o\ 5m r-d qfi fu gtro urne< u-q( frqr t. qrq fr u-qo elfi-a o) gq ds w g;rs-r ft-rTfl"r frti qri d e-d{)q d qreT qlll sif,ftq crtrrt 3lr{* 4as7 / 2024 ftiro zg.oz.zo24 rqd ftr+r rqT g ,

3. Barq qeT gr{ 3TE6irI d vqa qfi-d ot MqdT 1rs {"T <)s Grtrf, sT{t iqr -'1127 /2024 d ftqq t R-flo

Page 2 of 18

oTfi-f, glqfr iqr -1127 /2024 1s.04.202s o\ frkfi n-d v-qo o-{i d v+rer fr orq-i<rqi qeT srr+{ q ftfu-ir c-d rqo ftr} t t

4. orft'dreff qeT HRr oTEo-quT d wrer u-+go frrn Ti q)fu-f, ild d ci-$Fq R=m so.o+.zozs o\ u-qo frrt Ti ftfu-f, ild d qrE?rq fr qEqr @-q of ftf#f or quh ortl gv q6 deiq vqr .rqr t o1 erft-dTeftTlT qqff 51fi{q t of .d efrt oTffi d oilqM qa t, qrq fr a-d vsr.rqr t o1 ffif,reff qeT t qrRd ontsr d frsq fuq6 zs.to.zozs d F.fi./za) d qa d qrar oTfi-d trEd o-{ frqr qT, fu-d ffiq w-Sfu,T frT<q d il6-ffi ds Efi d onq effi-a qEq qfr ot -r$ gq fum 24.01.2024 e\ 3Tfr-flQff seT o\ qTqtdq g@ qrTr rr-{t of dfu.o. q++ k} uri q{ (s.fi./zt) d uyn g@ qITr of q-$ t {s oTTEIR q{ rqf, olfi-d ft=fio 2s.10:02s o\ nqo *<r ffi o-r qeT qrsr .rqr B I

s. ffidTrff sqT o-r qE fi ild t ot qfiff?ffrm iltrft q-fi-{q d qetcFrt r€f t t 3riqM of tR-'q-a t qerctx G t Ts M ftffifdqm emRil A orfi{ 5w € offi 6 ft--s-q qrRf, S$ t gu oTfi-dTefiqur d ft-s-€ stft or foriiq oTDo-ruT grqr r€t fo-qr rrqr t, fus orqq trr{ 3o-q erx.S.ff\'f,e of qruqfll 3rq-dT'Qff ss q{ oTrf,tra T€f 6)-ft I rile{ d} trm 11 (o) trftq or-jqfi 3il-q?F'{ qftfrqq 1e61 qfr HsY-w-dr o-l sds fo-qr rrqr t r orftf,reff qer i eilqFrooi qeT grr s-qd ftti Tn 3ilic{ of ilq{dr o\ fr qrf,fiq wrcrq RIrqT[r{I -\q, *rdq

Page 3 of 18

3Tfi-m vlufr fw -r pt /2024 q{.vd.3TrjIE gu-g {F+q file (rsea 1W.fr. ) fr. rsr o) rr{ffid os ffio fu-qr rTqT t t srq fr 3rft-m d grT dq w fi GTfiflaflr-or o-r seT oF-s-fl,-(r) t o.psmT-(xxr) t dea\ or sds o-{d Eq q-{gn fuqT rrrrT * r Tfr-fiT,ri o-r g&T rqr .rqr t t rl cr3*il( 3rfi-f,

6. B-di-qrfr @-qr6 1 trRr ft-rm za.oq,.zozs d nqf, frri Tn fufu-d ild d qp?rq + oifi-d ETqq d Aq-q tt nqn q-qrs fuir6 01.11.2024 Tq fudq erqr oTr-4,-fi d qrq fr qm 30_q srr.S.fi. qfre rege d frqq tf r-qo frrt od yr* q-{rq G orEo-v'r d wqm u-qo ffi Ti hfuo. ild d crTrq oTq-dletr qel gM r-qo ft--oe erqr 3iri{q EIm s qqt+r ortsFqq gq fi-ffid t gh e-ff{ fril qfi d frw q u-qo en.d-cq or qfilfl-q yt Sv u-Ea orft-a frrw m qrt o.r ergtu fu-w rpqT g, t. BrEr seT o1 Gil-{ t orBfi-{uT d sqeT fuiT6 1s.04.202s o) q-Ed fril T-$ dfufi ild gq Bqttffi ri<trd ftfu-f, ild d qTEzrq t frrS .rt qer wqelq d s-dTvr fi r-*go olft-a qfi dqrftqm qq Tre-Tilr o.r frqfwr fu-qr qT ra t t

8. nqo effia eerr Eqql GrqE efin +t fi fr-dB erqr fud qd & yer6 on-ilfi r-qo fu-ai .rqr t, qrq fr elrtl 3o-{ om.S.ff \'{e t qTqErftf, fr-ffid ht erurflr fr orft-mTQff qa oi 5qf, rut fu gQrfi orle{ u-qo fuur qqr t rnQr fr orilRq 3rT'a-qq qew /zozq kflo 2s.01.21024 rqef fusd

Page 4 of 18

sTftd strrft iq-q -l P7 /2024 o;{ trEd 3rft-d o\ X"T qts q{ Ei qri or 3r-5tq fu-qr rrqr t t e. B-f,rqrfr t-o am erfi-a flq{ \'s oTfi-d d lsie-T q-q( fr-dE trril 3Tr-iq-{ qRr 5 qqrfl 3rBR-qq G fr-ffide t gm frtS qfi HRifud Gil-ilfi or frfuo q-qrq ftiro 07.11.2024 o\ u-qo fu-qr qr Tor t t 'lo. trfr{q E.{rd tg ftri qrt w eniro qa i e-a Xfo ot-SitT fuqT t fu u-qo orq-f, {"T Etq w gfr qrq I {s B<f q Grft-f,Teff qa i qrfl+q

0. eil-{.q.8. gdralGrrq d am ftqrqa stq-f, oqio. totz / zoz+ q qIRd BTrtsT fuiTo 04.03.202s o) rl-(ffid orit gv Gif,Rq oil-iel err$q qew /zozq fA=iE 2s.07.2024 oi ffif,ri o-{ e-qd 3Tfr-d X"T Elq w gt qri ot ergtu fu-qr .rqr t t

11. strrqrfr t-o em gs orStq or qfufl-E o<i gv qmftq q.s.@r qrqrfrq Ergr ffiEq-n fueqq q,qio, qsog/zozs on$.S.qr.fi. W trfi tutu& frvq rlqrqra {s srq { dtm mtq k{io, 11 sr-rFkt zozg o) qqfff, os snqfu fr Tg t of serrfl, fuf,q oT se=I vq oTfi-f, o1 uquot or frqlqq fu-qr qrqt onqwfi t t o,.oqgqrd fr 3rq-f, 5"I dq w gfr w q-fi-ft t I

12. Brl-q sH d E-{i d q."nf, qm+q O.em.q.

t. gararqrq 6pr orfi-a @-qio rctz/zoz+ d qrkd orrtyr fu{i-fi 04.03.202s oT 3i-q-drfi-{ o-q qrqr qror B of 3rfidteff qei qr+ftq S.ons.q.fr. A sqe{ erfi-a nqo or {s orBffilT d qqer nqo +t 'r$

Page 5 of 18

orfi-d srqft isr _,nzt /zozq gs erfta oi fr-E-d 3nts d qrtqq t ffiq w t ftirq-d frti qri or fr{q qro.rql 'r3. q'r+fiq O.GTri.\.8. Hyr {q GrEfi-iq ot fr&T ft=qr .rqr t ot pfts-dr $6 2 qrE d omr elfi-e or ft-ir6a"T fu-qr qrq I sreT ff or,cfuoaf cfr o.) {q 3TDo-iur d sqer cet-firi s-fl-i ig ,!* ,q- o-ri o1 Ed-rf,r A .r$ t cd d orDil"r o) vm ord.E-{ 3tTqyqoaT ergw nc-qo frrd qri +l e-aqor fi.d Bt 't4. qmftq dlcilr.g.A. iln fi q-g wn-e-or d c-ftrcr t +f,Fft dnT ceT t s-q orEo-iq d vqer fuiro ro.os.zozs oi entcc a-qd or eryM qer d qq qffm fr qer rqi +aetqfr qr$,r$r {s'3nif,{ 6r qqrs crfi-orltr qel t fuirfi onl u.zozs d u-qo ord Sg 3rrieq or ft-tq fu-qr qql tr 1s. qr+ftq S.ern\.fi. 6ri1. ft-i ,rd fr{pr qr T{r sqn crre o-{fr gy cQrqf,. qe s-cfrqfi_q t A "nr u-go or0-a of n-fl-dr gfrRqf, m fr-.{r vs fudq t nqo g$ oTfid q fudq erqr ffi fr-{r 3r0-d W ds q-r ETm-r ftirqZ-d of w s+f B"r

16. B-mw-fr t'o gm qrftq qsvq Tq ffd qTqfu d fr'ae. erqT cilqrq-m t qo-fr tr w+dgy d q-sfr-d trq d qrtqq t T$ t qfr sarra: orfid o1 fiqqor, cTeTfd frrd qri or sFr frqtR-f, fu--qT cFT I ilqqp-qrd fr 3rft-d gq sls cr g-ft qI qlqldq

Page 6 of 18

eTqfd glqfr qGN -l 127 / 2024

17. flTflq q.c. @I amrcrq qrsffd t am ffift+s freqn +eos / zozs cil$.s.9q,.dl. qKT t6 ttsr qrd \q erqd Fr'{q q dTft-d fofq RHio 11 crrrkT 2o2s q qr+fiq sqtrq -tllqlclq ENT T{r+frq vfrsn qrffu tufr& G qq fur€ ffi fni erq (zooz) T \TT.fr.fr.+zs ti qffi{d fu{ra o\ $<ffi-d o-G gr qq{an fr .d 1e. sff.f,-wT d of "rqr cmt-coqq qqe{ qslrl ffiq trg u-e t qq GTM6-{q d qqdr 3TEolfr t of sertrl: il-Eqf,r o-l vFI, 3TQrfu frf,q erqr fu-qr qrqx s-qf, rfi-{ur x"r ds w 5i qri qt'q t, 3Telt[ qfr, {q fus oT fuil{oT fu-qr uil=ll silt[T*F'tr gs qqE€rd A e?FI{r fr str{qrft t-fi at sil-Tfu frqIErTi c-€t t t

18. qrer fi qe rt sffiq g *1 qr+q'q S orn.q.A. grr q-qd 3Tftd o"\ qfrilf,r gdo z qre d Grfl fiqTqo frtn qd or ftfvr Rqrrqr t, tqT ot$ frteT T€t t a1 qfr-f, of uETdT, qqqr frf,q d qrq *1 s-aM fl q-qf, 3Ttrf, xoT dq qi gflfl ftW( of qrq 1 5 ort'ri t qr+ftq q'q g-@ qrqr1q ggr qffi( sqt-ffi €qfi-d qqgerd d q-6'rcr ii qamfl: srfrdTeff qeT gRI ,8" gs erfi-a a qMuar \d fudE d qcq ol f+,j., fu-qr qrqr frB qqo Vq eirqrq-o di t sqrrd: oTfi-dnff qa q,t gil-i t u-qd 3Tf,Rq qriqq qr{I 5 qqf<T qftB-qq ftFirfi 24'01'2024' Err{ 30-q sm.s.fi. \'{d tr{m 24.01'2024 d qTsl 3tffiq oTltfi qagt /zozq fotm 2so7'2024 61 ff{-s{ur frilT qr rar t t

Page 7 of 18

orfrd srqfr i'qt -tlzt /zoz+ ilT crfud ontrT fu{ifi 2s.0s.2023 d fr'q-q qm so-q Gil-{.0.ff. vte 1ee3 d qTotrmrgqn e-qd 3Tfi-m gq ds w gt qfi tg qtn'nn *uI 61 50 sfryrd qq-r frri Efi ol eF:rfrr i eT T€t" r 20 erxr 3o-\ erx.0.fr. v€ 1ee3 d srqql{tgqR q6[ sq qfu d em ffi ft't-q xrr srRr qorqT *m{ tq t, q{ff erffi ErT crRf, frffi 3rTtrT d ftEq crtrd cTrtv t ftiF-d ttot xq {qft 3rEo<"r + sq'H od-a rqo o1 qffi t, il.tr se' 3rq-dreff d ftr qe'qftild t ftt eFEErr Err or so cfrcrd x"r cgfr 3llu-6-i"T t qqr mt, 3rertd erm eo 3flr.O.ft. \'+e rgsa d era.to wgo 3rfrd Ei qri tg ilq rqq \rs Mq fift, Gq uq grron d ft\ sf,rsTfr qfu t eorqr E,r or so cftcrd fi-ffisc tu-qdr 2i. 3lfr-flpfl'q.T of frr t nqo srofu ont-6< d qrqq t qa opq vsr rF[ t o1 r-qo orfr-o 3rcfufi-df qeT grfl nqo o1 .r{ t, q\ qqfr s-flor d qer-oq r€t t, qf@ Tqfi offi d e_d ft1 .T{ qqfu d sr* t, wq fr gTFoerqfu-qr .rqr t fu' crq-f,rrftror q?Dnn uq cdri d ftr B-d-.{rfffr qfu TS }, a1q of M 6qfr d sTqW d fr-f,€ crRd *, d oq4 ftrqgcn t tt qrel fr rd r-<il.rqr t ot fus s-qfu q,16-+t srffi c-wrhd o1 ,r$, cr sgff trq cRqx'ot qqfu t r u,ft qfu o1 qmqn qqfu TS t r 5S emm w GrffmrqhT'r o\ ft-ffiTe aff erETf,r t 5w rwi or ergtu fu-qr rrqr tr

Page 8 of 18

oTftm srqfr i-'q< -tlzt /zozq

22. vtrrqrfr ito arr ftqiT oz.tt zoz+ o) gq 3Tff(r oT qqrs r*gd orfr gv qfuflE fu-qr rrqr t fu cTfi-ileffqur qqfu frqfi qrsrt, 3Tsrln frt-q fu-d lT-€Tfr d fr.B'fi B-ffirffi t, ftd-€ qTEfr+e ter @qifi + d wrn * sffftrd-e t-ec 6qio 4 (1) G a (z) d vq t ffi ql€erd-c t 3Trtcr ftqi6 to.oszozr d ergsn qerox rqlilr Tl{Ir tt

23. vf,.qrfr ilo or qe rfr oel{ t o1 q{fr qffi gM qftd 3Triqr f{qto zs.os.zozo d ergerv urtrR'd-e teq t ttzzzo+sat.zo i-S (go 3f,{q qrr6 6tIs qrf-s drq +sd rqrs frq q\ g.o-ft'e- sqn rd-s q-n) A q-qm rlq t, e-q Grft-fleftTur 6M rqf, qfif, tq mq {rRr o-I so qfrrTd fr-ffie ftrd G-rT X"r <N qr Ei qfi d.q rS trqq orMR q{ c-qf, olfi-d ol ft{ffi frri cri or ergtv fo-qr rqT I I gq sfls d ecrf{ t gcq eqqir Tq.c.om.fi. €e fu {€lt ftt< gqn qrqf sT qrqq qa sa.c fu-qr .rqi B t

24. 3Tfim d sler €d.q ffi-rnq Fi€I ff/z+) q) ffi cltrfr'd-c or ef,ca t, d 3i-s-dlol t se t of W u!ft @ci-6 a lurff'q fit< frE ft-ar q}fi-ffa ,rogrfi d fq dri w aao d ga frv-o q-srt rq fttq Rtd q'sft (qFqr) d na x"t qfu d {effi qt fr.er.rqr t, Grsrfd gs erfi-o d oIftdpff-rrur aa xrt efrn g.ffq frtq Ri6..T-srfr d ge d-o< cqq ffi d sosrffii di t u"t qfr( M t t, ots"T o1 frffi f,"ft qk d frfuo vo{rffi Xfq il{r

Page 9 of 18

orfi-f, sr{fi iN -'i127 /2024 ftrn a} *q d qeTt d ftq ffE-fi sq t s€-{fl-ft dt Br zrg q?m ugc t a1 v+ a'ft qfu t fttilfi q-qfu scrTEnR fr um g{ t, ereric' fu-s fiqr oo t zq q.eri d Erfusnftc Efi, q\ deq gor <)s qr dq or frv+ 51- g, ffi uem Eeur erfi-arefwr xnt qk a1 M q Br 2s. 3Tfi-flsfqrT a1 d qe 3rrqfu t e1 crtrd a1 .r$ M offi 6 srqW d fr-E€ crRd gi B, qqfu eftt tg lrrTfua qqfu eg.ff fr-q cfu{n +1 eqfu t | {s o'Rur eTfidTrtr.roT q{ qrtt 3o-\ om.S.ft.sqe d 3iilfd ft-ffisd q,1 orFrortrdr aq r€t etfr r gq s<.{ t edq t npqt or cftqror fl{ sr-drT qrol t of rs erkos"r d +gfr 3Tffi u* F-tffi fr7rz) o1onq edrcr\ Wcr fu{rfi 2s.i1.2021 3rq-f,IeffqlT d qlq w nfuf, 6{i gq dq{ d.-s qrr+d ftors q-eq its d qR+fi qm d qa *-awa 51800 crthte, q\ ft-6q qr ft-{io 28.03.1e6e ri sFld agr fr+r d er5$q t, o\ dql r f,q q-qfr @rffi tg e-d fuqr qrq, d frsq d ifrd @1 ,g g, 3larl-d q{dl 3rffi Ertr crfud eTdqT furio zs.os.zozs ti ffi ftsq rq on"r edrd qarr t eFto *qm t. ffi fr!-q t qs tocr t of "qq s-dffi qqfu {d so1 qk 01 qrqfu e}-oi a'r ffi orffi fr qd or fr'oq d'q sqfu e'srq EsqT tqr€i"t

26. entco qer e1 ort-i t u-go frd .ri fu6q qe fuqio zs qrd teee G'i@r ft/o) d 3i-s-dt-6{

oTfif, sr+fi iq< -t,tzt /zoz+ t qrqr qror t of ffiaT Er-6rfis q-eTRTfr ssr tfr gRr oTam-$w orcrfi fr ys.fr.q-dx rq df,r fr frtq friE qwFfr fr-dT +fi-dTd fr q!-srfr d qtq fffro. r+.ro.rsoz o) fr-@-q -:cn HII

Page 10 of 18

3r-5e-€T 3TTg{q t fr-@q tg 3r-jqRm rlrqfu o-r Grvi qlrr, oTqff, q-ffi qFr 3iqc d-s e-n ft-@-q eftq-d looooo/-(vfi' aru) rud, c\ 3TEq d w d +fr gril lffio 14.10.is67 oi y-on fu-qr qr gor w, eET s1800 qrfrhtd etfi-cr ddT +ft fti-q ftr6 fr-dT fr d-ft-fld fr q!-crt d qe{ fr fr-6-q gen t, 3Tvto ftoq qa 1q-tffi fi la) t qafi EEqI qd ci-grln o6 ftorm sil qcndT of s-m eq.fu Bgff trq qR-qR d frq oq qt .ri t, efu q{s ddT fr frtq fti-6 q"-cffi i qfurf, tfuq-a t s-m qqfu o-q fu-qr t'r gq fi+oq qe o1 dtr-ot c d ffi t q fr gs srkoqq o) gs fuo-q qa d sw d qt q@-t oN Frw{ efifufuo e-{i ot snqqqE.f,r t t

27. 3rfiflpff ser o-r d qa ild t of E=ffs frt-{ fu-6 q!-sTfr i rig-ff qR-il-i o1 enq t iIRT rrlkr o1 q.q-fu o-q fu-qr t w frEq fr fr-d o-T qf, t of orft-cnefi qer of onq t nqm qffid-q (e-ftf filt), (q-q{ fitz), (!-qqf fiti, F-q{ fr+), (q-qpt fi/s), (e-<vf fr,zo) d-s S-fr, GTerqr fturwq t qkifuf, 3rq-S-qf, qr$rTq fis d GTTtil-{ q{ qM ta fis, q\ dt-n EKffq t, of sfr€ o\ {fiTi re fu-qr qr q-+-flT, eiqto erfi-ar$ qeT @-l qa a-d ffi qY'.q i-€I t of w.ffq frtq ft+-6 gM +f, *s ft-qo za qrd rooo (ncd fr/s) srr

Page 11 of 18

sTfid gt:+fr isr -tlzt / zozq @-q at .T{ sqfu qg-ff kq qftqR ot sqfu efrt

20. orqmreff va t R--i@{ ft-rs) $ffi 3igr €Fir.r frs fr{iq 16 orrrkr 2016 d qrtzq t q-e edrcl qrfl ol um T-su-s oT qW et q-d crffi6 T-srt d o\ mw g3rT, d g-{+t qfurrd qqfu tlEq 6NUT eftt qY,q r-S t, frr{ sffiq deq {E B o1 qq.otfuo<q am d.\.t/zoot fr fort-r 18.06.2002 of trq E\E'd fu-qT rrqt. ai{ Td 7o1 ek g.ffq fttq me flERd-c ter @qio +, ffi fr-r€ 3Tril{fi t'fi d qer t vgmo: vq yero-f,, Fqrfi *'q Bot qirrql f,q 1l.Pr d frqq q qrR-d of q{ gs frfr'd qeron sRrqrfr o-r \rs erm ,u oo.g16. g{e t EtFr.rT *ur {Rr d frsq it q{fr of d qfuqr qrqtnfud t, s€-d 3iil.f-d f,rt qfu of z'a cq erqa sqfu qd or ft-6s frrsT qrcr qFqfua B, d qc ed o1 .T{ qqkr Xa zfr qfu fr fitq Rr6 qrsft ft-dT qi-ft-drd qrsrfi d il{67 ErfrE dt sqfu ,ff, d mq qg$ otffi d 3r-d-.i-d Ed oc fr6-q qtq wcfu t, ae 1a u,ft qfu @t aq d qfi A qrqro, d qqk sosrErorRqt 6) 3a-f,R-d g{, at vm*rffi ol tqfurrd sETfu cfr oS qr sofr cs orq qM ffi gsq €F-s'r Sc fu{rfi 16 or.rkt zoto d r+rcr fr s-m sqfu 6-I sFrI qffid d'-{t r& ffiorcT qr q6-fl'. orelfd qfi-dletr{ur or qg rd qTTi qlq Tfr t q,1x"r oqff qffi att iB-f, qffis +tr-s t sFtd qqfu 3Tfi-drrftTuT o1

Page 12 of 18

erftf, gl{fr i* -1121 /2024 qfurrd qqfu t, or?rqr i ffi qrffffie qt qqdr olffi d u"t q'e{ T€l t, efu qle 3flcFil6df S. fus orqq i eTM oo-A em.$.fr.Ye rsss d ercqmrgqn u-qo orft-e ft1 ffiqaT tg etrlrtt uq <TRr or so cfryrd qqr frd qri o1 erEaflrtgqfltt 2s. Bl-t-firgqR cer+I EEqr asat oT qfterq o-s orEoirr gq Frs{ qr qErflr t d Glfi-dTeriTur Xa xfr qfu d ftB-o sosTErfiIt ilot Xa 74 ek d sm fr;qrka qre o] sosEon t flK fu-ql t \d {fi'rsT zq o} sgffid: gq Yeroo, Trrdn 6-{i d ft\ sc-rsrfr tt Eq oxsr 3Tfi-dpftruT q-{fr GTffir ilqr qTtrd 3lrtqT furlo 2s.o2.2023 d fu$-d u-qo of .{ qs effi-a d X"t sls w gt qfi *.q ffiq ftqiRd cC tg e-d qq,;q1 Tq or so cfryrf, qgr 3o-q em.O.fi.Vqe rsss S coqmrjt+R ft- ffise o-{i d fuc s<Tilff Bt

30. u-Eo erfi-o rht qt-Eq-dr d s<d q qr+fiq BAtrq qrqrmq aItT il{rqur d( +s f{t-d {6f +6 Ti s[q (zorr) + Ts.fr.fr. s+e n qfrcrka fu€id er-jsi"ts |, 61-wr o1 qm so-g 3il(.6.fi. v€ ie93 d qrdqn erm re (r) qqffi vqe zo02 d E-ft'q c-{Eo d q{sq'} \ti flTfiq s-a.f,q qfqtdq ft-ffise v-qo ori qroq ftd A-qffio tt ErlI cFrqrP{d sTftrd d 3TTsli sqq of +fta clft-d &{fficrdtqsXffivdot te-<r r-qo 3Ifi-d @1 Mq-or Ttro: qq EM"r t gq fr-d or q-o t ot

t4 oTqrf, grqft t*, -ttzt /zozq oTftflpftTq HcI qDr{II Ed uq {rRT, q\ B-f,{qrfr +o grrr nqo orft-a erqc G 3if,Rq 3il-ifi d utrnq d qrtzrq t fr .d cTTdl-el d 3rgqn 11222642s1.20 tfr (1-o err< err6 ots e[f,s drs dlss aon fi-{ d E-n-fi-q t-q-} E-d-s t-fr) t, ffis6-r so eftqra qqr fr',i fr-+ u-qo o1 T$ q6 olq-n XuI drq w Ei qrt tg ffi 'r& t t

31. orq qE s$t ffi-q t of "qrlT qfimrQtrqq o\ 50 qftcrd fr-ffiq-c o-{i ot crjqfr t6i ffin yr <)s w Ei uri fu urqq of qr sfi-fr t, dr gs qErf t sstrrrT: 3rfr-d s-qf, o-rt fr gq fr-f,q o-r qe=t furfR-ir fu-qT qt=tT amlgqo' ], 6rqur q,t qmfiq sqtrq ;qrqffiq + sHR ot-orqtia ftft& f*t-q rfiq g. Asrg anr frfuo sfrftE s{ srdr (zors) o gs.fr.fr. 4',12 q qffiT oTftqd d ergux q-Ef, qrql otTa-fi/ ofid oilfr q-qB qt-B"-f, t, dq elrgt 3 TqiEr oTEfr'qq d urour+Asn F-{tf, oq fr qr}'ft t q-d fr mft qer t wqq ftqr of oilqfu q fuqr d t qqfr {s qfr-{q tt sffqrfr qeT gRI qqq frqr d srq o\ q'nft{f,r $-fi ffif, fuqr rqr t t

32. ee+kl: qe vffiq t of qm eo 3r-t.S.fr. g{e 1ee3 d ur+rr+gun u,T vEfr 3rft--6-{"T d qq-dr oTffi gril wR-d frt} .rS frtfr fi 3rTtcl d Wd qfu o\ orTtcr of qfr srw di t\ so frTs d eiqq xq q-{dr eTfuor"T d sqa erfta nqo o-ri o'r frfto EcD Irfl"I ft-qr rrqr d t qR oTfi-fletr qq{ erg qrd orsrt-d +qfr oTffir gtiT ffi

Page 13 of 18

qfid srqfr iqt 1Pt /zozq qrR-d 3rtpr ffi+ zs.ogzozs d ftq ot-s{ff (*qr) verftrr Etfl. ilq oilAvt of e-qrFTil qfr lrw 6rt fun-o' t srq frqr ryET *.q +fr, fu-d 3Tft-fleff qeT ffi qrERd-e or Xa xot ak wtrRrd-c t-ec 6qto + d smrErorfut o1 tfrq-d t +qfr s,rtrfrdz d qer-fl{ t, ffi am x-qo fun .ri sTrqfu 3rrilq-q oT ftqmqq fri w GTre\frd 3rrtyr qrfto Eqr t, e-q oilt{fi ceT d ftc er0-a c-qo ovi of qqq ftqT orTt{r crRil Eti ft{16. zs.os.zo23 fr TuHr fr.q t Cs 3ndft-f, 3nAYr tht qqrFta qfr

o) ftqrm' o+ ro zoza ol BqdeI ?E{r fr .rg t, a) {c{ EMq t rposr al qrq, d so fr{s d 3i({ sPrio fu{io

04. i1.2o23 ao srfta u-qo ori of rrflq €=qT 3rfi-dptr'rloT o\ ct f, ,fr, fu-d oTEflrr d eqer ftqio z+.ot zoza o) rra 3rfid e-qd qtl .rg t, "t csrrr Eqqr dqqrl 80 fd-{s' t erqB erEa t t

33. orq-mrrff qqT I erm 5 qqfil ffiftqq 1e63 d eid.fd u-qn ftd .rt eilnfi d qrzq t qe erft'fiem fuq t of fuu-fi 2s.10.2023 o\ 3lfia nqo o1 Tg, fuE {.S.srn.fr. +fd fr 3ffir eifi-a c-trd ori of qcnqT q +i t {fdwi d qqer (v+ffir ft 7za) a eft-er nqo frrqr rrq ea qq fr-td{ {fuET{ t Bq-d fu-qr qror {6T, dq fi qfrflpff va o\ qF+o fu-ql qqf o1ffi{ 3lfr-d u-qo oti d Aq'q fr erc ilfi 6ti cfuqr trft-f, T€t Ei B, fuE qcr R-{rfi 04'01.2024 dl orqmreftroT q{dt 3TErorft d sqeT sqRero gc, Tq sd or-{.rd o{EII rtfl 61 rfffo6 w t 3lfi-d c-qd

Page 14 of 18

orqrd grqfi iE\ -1127 /2024 t-qrfu-d otd gv *tfro w qfid c-qd zF-{i ol dt !il qo-fi B, ae ft-r'ifi 24.01-2024 o) 3rfr'd u-qo o1 .r$, aq e-o q+q frqr qfi-f, d g+t * t {soilEIN q-s fr'f,q erql frt} wi or 3[5tq fuqT .rqr t t

34. sf,rdrft llo am rqo frd 'ri q-qrq d qrtqqt 3rTqfu fr rr{ t o1 3lq-mptr qa i ftqi6 24.01.2024 o\ cTedd. q$r qEffifi gwr qlR-d do m* 2s.os.2o2s d fr-s-€ erfi-a u-qd o-{i o1 frtrd qqq fiqT ao R+s qfr-a d qri d qrqro erfto rqo o1r$ tt

35. strisrfi qer of o{rqfu t fu qR qq-f,iQft qer ol ffic eifi-a v-qo o.-{i t otg 3raFmer qr qqEfl=I sTr, dqt 3IE4{T d ffiq 3IBoRT d qqa sqRTfr 6ifl 3l-ilfi rqa. 6-r q-o-d ?i, ftrd tS 6t$ cfuqr q-fr slcqr$ ,g qq frqtPt.d q'q-q frcT go k{fl d 3is1 3lft-f, e-q( oEt ot ot{ c-qrq rfr frrqT .rqr, qer n-o ol frFo qr-.rTcrq go rfr ft{15 z+.ot.zoz+ o\ g'TtTH o1 ,r$ t'r c{ eirqnt w futrq flqI 3ilt'fi tnT qfrqrq fu-+'.rqr g,

36. sril seT oi V{i d qvsrd $-s or qo t of qR i rs'3TB6-i"r ot {ffi d {f$rqn d qqs eni-6q 6 creT Ht-frfl qfi-s arqa G 3nqy{o qr+tfiil g@ lXrdn oq c-qo fu-qT *or cs {f{qR ernsft{ cfu'qr d 3trd Grfi-mreff ceT d sil'tEq qq *ierq +mr fuq srfi-o nqo 6-ri i d € n-f,ffi ersqc o\

!7 i[{fd sr{fr #r -1n7 /2024 3rgcfr tg +e fie ffi{ e{ffi d qqeT nqo +t ttfr. re qE de.zl scrYq rlutfl d fuuT qror o1 sTfi-flrft qs i frFo so fr{s d 3i<q {qfr 3{Erf,rfr ErtI crR-d 3lrtrT ft-{rfi 2s.0s.2023 d fr-d-€ orfi-a arq{ srsfua oq frtro .qlqiOq go d qrer {*r slEolq A qqeT sffi-a rqo oq fr t, cq .lrd fr 3rff-m fr ilo-ffi 6ri"tr t 3fir-dTf-q-d orq-d rq-d i-S Ei crfr, ereror gror{ tg l-S dr.ri Etfr, fuc,ff srq frff 01q-oq $ BEAvo t slftd qfq frqr d oict v-rgo eli ot ild ffi *rq vror, fu-d 3tq-drQff qei i S-q cfu-qr o-r 3i-Tsiur rfr fu-qr, qfu lfu-Etr d ill cq gtsft-d 3il-nfi ft-{ffi 25.10.2023 (\i-@r frrzzo) ft$-c E-qtd d qqsT Tqf, os 3lsi qrfu€ q,1 Xffi w d .r{ t

37. elfi-d sTq{ d erpl qif,rq qrqg@ qqr {$-E d sr-{dYm-{ t w€ t fu eno 24.01.2024 o\ 3Tfu{ffir frq-q yio{ sriTtzp{ eN 30755/- (frs.asn qro e\ qq{r) dq$ fru-o qusft frs€ ss.ff.orr$. d 3lffiq roqq o1 qEIIerq go d w { qqr fu-qT rrqrr qqfr 3rft-d etqc d celq gE w ftdrr 23.10.202a or germ.t t, frtg ftTq-+tq offi E1qT fu-qT rqT yET-6.c 1e..fi-q t, u-{fu {fsqTi d r+qq !-f,{uT wdd r€t Esi, qqfu {fuqTi dRI csr+T 3Tricr ckf,r ftqio to.oo zozq d ftrd .d B, ffi ergvx effi-anff 3TB{ffir aft frnfi qrqr d ffir krio 24.01.2024 o\ qrqr so 3TN.S.ft.\'{e d 3i-f,'ff, 3idftc aTlil{r\ d qrpr 3rft-d tr+g-d tnEi or sdq t t gc

Page 15 of 18

orftd sl{fr iqr -1'127 /2024 qfueTfuqt t oTfi-fleff ceT o't 16 ild ffi fr'q r€t t fr gs oTD-6-rur qt {fti-S d qqer frFo rnq-q frqt so fuqs d 3tfl ft-{i6 25.10.2023 @\ 3lfi-m e-qd o{ A .rg fr I

38. sreT fr qe rfi sffiq t o1 3lff-d. enil<t, 1a orril({ oT sq ft-{ifi t qFrT qraT B, ftffi ft-{rfi oi 3rfiflPft/3Tril{6 qeT i frEd cre-q fr 3iltfi/3ffi-f, qrsE-d 6t utqYqq? -qlqlc1q qTq lc4 q g@ oT Urrflq or ffi d siTfr c{gd fi kqr e\ r gs E<$ d < tl.q ffi trg.{-d (ffiw) qffi 1ee3 or ft{q + $i z qrffiq BI 3e. {s ctr{ur q qq 3ffiflPff qer i rfuqrq d qqq fti{o cr€c i olfi-d gIq-{ G orqrco go wBo eo fr+s d otqr srerta R-{ifi 25.10.2023 TO 3IQIqT U.11.2023 e-o nqo r€t fr,qr, erqen {P"rqR 6NT {fl 9'or"r i ftId 'd s.erq 3Trtsr cB-61 fu{rfi $.06.2024 il gs oq ot €flc fuqr +dI q,t 3lfif,lpff qel i fr{io 25.10. zozz d ftFo smq t eI0-d flqq rflt ftfi-fi d qqeT u-qd or ft-qT srT, Ts 3[gcn fr'ordT sr}rl ol qrwq i oTfi-dtetr qei i qE 3Tftd fr{ifi 24.01. zozq d Grtrrirfi qrql"rl g@ or SrTdrq 6t sTR6i.T d sqm u-qo fuur t, elerid ftfr-fi Erftq 6dqt d gm erfi-a srqc d qerq Ysd c( ft-{io 2J.10.2023 d ftsq t frtqr rrqr YET-6.q frFo qq-q frcr d oi{i 3Tfr-d uqo *+ 3ricTfrf, frtd Gli 6g .6qotw$qfrqrqf1

Page 16 of 18

ql-Tfiq wm-q qIqr-dq Errr {c{ t{rrd sr0e 6qfr sfi'q, Etsqr fdft& f{sq onqtRr{rd ftrq&r (zorz) to \q.fr.fr. rez ti qffi{d oTftqf, d ergwn errql 30 srn.S.ft. v+e rggs d 3tr( qqft oTPmrft gRI qrkd oil-erT d fr-t-€ trq( Et-i otfr 3ilfrd i trr{I 5 Tqf<r 3rftfuqq d rilcrErrq drf r& di, tsr fr rrf, qrrftq wrcrrT anqTerq Am erfufiqr rq .nsFrd fffiq sfiRqrum to. dq, o,r{H Qozz\ rs gq.fr. ff. zzr d trfi-{q fr qffif, ftqr rrqr t, d qq 3rfr-dT?ff qeT gM e-qd cft-f, qarq Esqr ci-qfu

40. {s e-o-{q fr frqio. rc.o6.2024 o1 Eq oTEfi-{uT grr ftrd T$ 3TrteT qkfiT q se t o1 fr-dq fir qrq \d orq-f, A ffi'qm vcrrqrfr qer o-r qqrcr GTri d rrrqkT furfRd frtn qd ot ftE!ft d qrq srra-<o qeI Hr{I rqo erofu qi}qc dfr=d {d rri q}, oTe-rfn teT ,fi T€f * fu W q ortn{6 qeT gni trEd g< ofdRq oiltr{rT o) ffi gq rer-rrq 3il-ilfi or ftqroqq foqt rrqr qI I

41. erqto sTBfr-ilT qE furfRf, otcTT t ot orftflrtr qeT grgr qs erko-sq d sqa erfi-a flq{, frFo qrqraq go' d HIar cIrKlcI t[ ftqffi z+.0r. zoz+ d u-qo fuur rrqr, Glarfd srTn{o qeT ErtI q-qd orfr-d erqB erBd t t

42. crq q6 qrq sE.-T Etdr t fu "eqr 3lft-drrff qeT gM tr{Ed oil}fi qr{I 5 Tqffl 3rftfr'qq fro-ri oq erfi-oreff qfl gRI u-qo ufi-a g,T q)q w gi qri tg qrqq o1 qT sofr t r gs q<d fr

Page 17 of 18

qfid q-{fr tx -ttzt /zoz+ qrkd B \-s r{fr 3Tffi d olresr d frw erm go qr.S.fi. g€ 1ee3 A do.fd nqa di orfr fiqE qrEfl 3Tfi-d t frdq erqr frti qfi fu uvr s q_qf-r oT*ftqq rgos d q;qq;< drrl T€l eit, fff o1 sct-ff qugE.rd d ma.q t rtrfr-q surkFT ql-rrTcr{r d aqr ftE E{srTfu-d o1 qr got t', ac aTfi-dreff qeT gr{I ngo eril<-< qm s qqiqr effiftqq d qrrq'q t 3rfr-dretr qeT gRr nqo o1 T-$ e{0-d o) rEo o-G d gg fr.mq d erqr 6r nqo efia Xu dv qi gi qri elw urqq .rfr otwsoftt

43. qsrid qq orfimpff ERT e-Ed oTfi-d q-48 qrB-d t qs E{enfrd'l4E d ergqx erq& qrBo affi-a Xu ds w r€t gff w sm-ft, ire erff-dPtr d erm so-g orr.S.ff. \rrE 1es3 d urotnrqun gs od-a o) g"T Els qi gi qri iE ffiq qqti d s{icq t crfi-drQff cer o\ krio. gr.os.zoea 01 furfr t cflqT ge{ x-rl 11222643sr.20 tfr (go oRcr sr{6 o-t's Erg-s' aro dlsa ron fic q} E-o-fi-s tvi' E-frq t-S) or so cftyrd qqr o-ri o1 erjqfr tm{ g-s oTfi-d d g"r ds w gi qri 6T 3rq{N T€i fuqT qr s-6-f,rl

44. {fu 3lfi-drrff qer gRI u-*go erfia g"T ds w gt qrt fr.q rS f l gq onur enfrilf,di qa A.t.A.sq.$.g {tr+s ffifr}c o\ c-6{rr ff qqtirTr d vq t ffi of ot{ oreraoor ts r€t {6 qrftt qralqw emftooef cer anr u-go edrt or r<rgqR ft-irf,i"T fu-q wcn tt

2r sTfi-d srqfr #t -1121/2024 4s. eraltf, sqt-fiEsTq frB-fi ftnqcT o-{ sTFo-wr gs M w qE"-dT t of erfi-arefr qa gnr rqd o1 .r$ erfi-a qm go-A ern.S.ft.g+e rgge d ilqqmrgqn 3rfrd qqfr ft-{i-f, d T{ qorur Ed xur srPr or so qfrcra qqr frd G-cr s-qd Eit t gt qrt qt'.-q q dma qrrrrflr ffi'.f-a B, qrq fr qm so cdr.S.fr.g+e rsss d srqqrflgqri sTtrT qIRd d-i eqrfi t ftfr( srq erqE eo ft-qq A oiil qfr-d rqf, c di d orqq orftd GrqE qlB-f, fi t \d elrdro qe{ grr trqgf, fr6rq erfl 3Trilfi ffi qtq c-€t t t

46. s"rsrdrT oTfi-dTQff qeT grgr q-{gd oTl-ilfi qrt 5 TqfqT Grftfrqq teog srd erqr frtt qfi fuf,q, qrel fr nqd oililfi trt-{ 30-A orx.S.fr. v{d 1ee3 ft-ffisd t 5m s-il{ frt} ufi emq gq 3Tfi-d X"r du w gi qfi tg u-qo oioRn qT-tfi q{.q. qaw / zoz+ f{rlo 2s.07.2024 ft-qrqT{ +oq ffi frrq q fri sq frB ffid-d Eti t ft-{ffi frr} srt t t

42. +flT fu sqrt-ffi o-Fs{T t {tEtr-d ft-q rrqt B 01 qlrfrq wkl-q RII-qFFI gRT ql{Esrf, strfr o\-eTlqtEq m.r+rfl rMtuft&frr€ ffiq S. tsr{ (zors) o vs.fr.fr. +tz t qffid qftT.r d q-{Tsr fr oi-qB qTE-d siltfi7 effi-a ryt dq w fr-qn frti qfi d {d fr ft{w q,t qrfr qTBq r gs frB @tnall d e-mtqr i qa qri gq ot 3Tfi-flpff qeT 6RI trqd qd 1"7 dq q{ cr-i ., qfif, sl+fi iE\ -1127 /2024 qri +'q q-€i tr s-f,Etc nqo effi-a gS ws qq ftvw of qrfr tt

48. oldv, o1 qfi cfr s{fr sTErrrft o\ cgdr ror"r i GTFJq ol-ffi tg iltrrd iB-o ol qrqt 49 B.trt ceT Glq{T-3rttfl qq q6q ott t 3Trtcr gd qrr"rq t enq kqio 05.05.2025 da- qtB-o frrq t >9 oE. ({qfr'sTs- qld) qq.rl* (ffi{ 3rffi) ft;qio":-o5.os2ozs $.ort.E. q. c., vE uffi-$rd

Page 18 of 18

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead