Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
DEEPAK BHANDARI ANOTHER vs STATE BANK OF INDIA on 5 May 2025
sTfi-d vrqft iqr -ip7 /2024
ETr rqfr 3Tfufr{ur qf,dg(
(n u. G udsrg rrw)
(ffi{ 3rffi - q-rq-fiq +fr vr,ry F-qTq q-}d)
orfif, sr+ft t+t -r,tzt /zoz+
1. Aqo qlgtt oTrfrrq fftq fu-6 q-sTt, frtq Rt-6 q!-sft (qFqr) sTrfrrq fr frt< Rt6 ,il:€rfr qtlT ftqT{ft qcrid ft-flqr t-}s r, qcr+f, ftqrs i)-s nq-q \q ft. ................ .qfr-dTrff, ftsq ec fu dE gtrsqr *{s VS.ffi ffi fr-qq s, qfltif, ft-qrs tE E<h w.fr............... ... ......8-f,rqrft / eTEfrrd-c +€{, tqd ;iq6tg qTuslt gu-s TfiI qdie ftfrys (g-q ftlf,{eqq) gnr onqtfird ftrqlsq Er$o)-i Sw vq.ft. E-di Wrft fr.osd.q F.fu.T fr.ft.or\ Htq tRqr d q6 sd-t w fr .........8-f,{qrft / srEfr,de feq,
Page 1 of 18
orfrflpff qer d frC +ft 3Terf, orq-aa 3Tfu{ffirt s-ff-4rfr t-6 d fuc fr e-ftur z-gtrfi olfu-{fiTt ffi d-ar c.s{ d frl +t frnr gaar etBrm t 3TI t qI (fttio os.os.eozs ol dR-o) r. orq-f,Pfi qel dt{I ffi;6 za.ot.zoz+ o\ qe erft-d {s 3Tko{,r A EqA 3{ffi gm O.c.{' \'ffi etrqq @ctq. 74/2ooz d qrtro *fu no* 2s.os.2o23 d fr.t-€ um so (l) ern.$.fr. vqe 1ee3 d urotrnrjsti rqn a1 .d t t ,. ffi6pft qm t erfi-a rqd o{i i gc fuffq o\ erqr ftd qd tg emr s {qr{r 3rftF=qq reos d fid-.td fr=tl-fi 24.01.2024 o\ gero erfet c-q( fuqT t, srer fr 3lfr-d ngo o-G fu um eo-g em.S.fr.v{e 1ee3 d crqqmrgqri ffirqr x'r qrRr or so sfrPm q+rt frrS qri ot ft-ffid u1 qftHrtrdr t 3rq-dTrft{"sr o\ 5m r-d qfi fu gtro urne< u-q( frqr t. qrq fr u-qo elfi-a o) gq ds w g;rs-r ft-rTfl"r frti qri d e-d{)q d qreT qlll sif,ftq crtrrt 3lr{* 4as7 / 2024 ftiro zg.oz.zo24 rqd ftr+r rqT g ,
3. Barq qeT gr{ 3TE6irI d vqa qfi-d ot MqdT 1rs {"T <)s Grtrf, sT{t iqr -'1127 /2024 d ftqq t R-flo
Page 2 of 18
oTfi-f, glqfr iqr -1127 /2024 1s.04.202s o\ frkfi n-d v-qo o-{i d v+rer fr orq-i<rqi qeT srr+{ q ftfu-ir c-d rqo ftr} t t
4. orft'dreff qeT HRr oTEo-quT d wrer u-+go frrn Ti q)fu-f, ild d ci-$Fq R=m so.o+.zozs o\ u-qo frrt Ti ftfu-f, ild d qrE?rq fr qEqr @-q of ftf#f or quh ortl gv q6 deiq vqr .rqr t o1 erft-dTeftTlT qqff 51fi{q t of .d efrt oTffi d oilqM qa t, qrq fr a-d vsr.rqr t o1 ffif,reff qeT t qrRd ontsr d frsq fuq6 zs.to.zozs d F.fi./za) d qa d qrar oTfi-d trEd o-{ frqr qT, fu-d ffiq w-Sfu,T frT<q d il6-ffi ds Efi d onq effi-a qEq qfr ot -r$ gq fum 24.01.2024 e\ 3Tfr-flQff seT o\ qTqtdq g@ qrTr rr-{t of dfu.o. q++ k} uri q{ (s.fi./zt) d uyn g@ qITr of q-$ t {s oTTEIR q{ rqf, olfi-d ft=fio 2s.10:02s o\ nqo *<r ffi o-r qeT qrsr .rqr B I
s. ffidTrff sqT o-r qE fi ild t ot qfiff?ffrm iltrft q-fi-{q d qetcFrt r€f t t 3riqM of tR-'q-a t qerctx G t Ts M ftffifdqm emRil A orfi{ 5w € offi 6 ft--s-q qrRf, S$ t gu oTfi-dTefiqur d ft-s-€ stft or foriiq oTDo-ruT grqr r€t fo-qr rrqr t, fus orqq trr{ 3o-q erx.S.ff\'f,e of qruqfll 3rq-dT'Qff ss q{ oTrf,tra T€f 6)-ft I rile{ d} trm 11 (o) trftq or-jqfi 3il-q?F'{ qftfrqq 1e61 qfr HsY-w-dr o-l sds fo-qr rrqr t r orftf,reff qer i eilqFrooi qeT grr s-qd ftti Tn 3ilic{ of ilq{dr o\ fr qrf,fiq wrcrq RIrqT[r{I -\q, *rdq
Page 3 of 18
3Tfi-m vlufr fw -r pt /2024 q{.vd.3TrjIE gu-g {F+q file (rsea 1W.fr. ) fr. rsr o) rr{ffid os ffio fu-qr rTqT t t srq fr 3rft-m d grT dq w fi GTfiflaflr-or o-r seT oF-s-fl,-(r) t o.psmT-(xxr) t dea\ or sds o-{d Eq q-{gn fuqT rrrrT * r Tfr-fiT,ri o-r g&T rqr .rqr t t rl cr3*il( 3rfi-f,
6. B-di-qrfr @-qr6 1 trRr ft-rm za.oq,.zozs d nqf, frri Tn fufu-d ild d qp?rq + oifi-d ETqq d Aq-q tt nqn q-qrs fuir6 01.11.2024 Tq fudq erqr oTr-4,-fi d qrq fr qm 30_q srr.S.fi. qfre rege d frqq tf r-qo frrt od yr* q-{rq G orEo-v'r d wqm u-qo ffi Ti hfuo. ild d crTrq oTq-dletr qel gM r-qo ft--oe erqr 3iri{q EIm s qqt+r ortsFqq gq fi-ffid t gh e-ff{ fril qfi d frw q u-qo en.d-cq or qfilfl-q yt Sv u-Ea orft-a frrw m qrt o.r ergtu fu-w rpqT g, t. BrEr seT o1 Gil-{ t orBfi-{uT d sqeT fuiT6 1s.04.202s o) q-Ed fril T-$ dfufi ild gq Bqttffi ri<trd ftfu-f, ild d qTEzrq t frrS .rt qer wqelq d s-dTvr fi r-*go olft-a qfi dqrftqm qq Tre-Tilr o.r frqfwr fu-qr qT ra t t
8. nqo effia eerr Eqql GrqE efin +t fi fr-dB erqr fud qd & yer6 on-ilfi r-qo fu-ai .rqr t, qrq fr elrtl 3o-{ om.S.ff \'{e t qTqErftf, fr-ffid ht erurflr fr orft-mTQff qa oi 5qf, rut fu gQrfi orle{ u-qo fuur qqr t rnQr fr orilRq 3rT'a-qq qew /zozq kflo 2s.01.21024 rqef fusd
Page 4 of 18
sTftd strrft iq-q -l P7 /2024 o;{ trEd 3rft-d o\ X"T qts q{ Ei qri or 3r-5tq fu-qr rrqr t t e. B-f,rqrfr t-o am erfi-a flq{ \'s oTfi-d d lsie-T q-q( fr-dE trril 3Tr-iq-{ qRr 5 qqrfl 3rBR-qq G fr-ffide t gm frtS qfi HRifud Gil-ilfi or frfuo q-qrq ftiro 07.11.2024 o\ u-qo fu-qr qr Tor t t 'lo. trfr{q E.{rd tg ftri qrt w eniro qa i e-a Xfo ot-SitT fuqT t fu u-qo orq-f, {"T Etq w gfr qrq I {s B<f q Grft-f,Teff qa i qrfl+q
0. eil-{.q.8. gdralGrrq d am ftqrqa stq-f, oqio. totz / zoz+ q qIRd BTrtsT fuiTo 04.03.202s o) rl-(ffid orit gv Gif,Rq oil-iel err$q qew /zozq fA=iE 2s.07.2024 oi ffif,ri o-{ e-qd 3Tfr-d X"T Elq w gt qri ot ergtu fu-qr .rqr t t
11. strrqrfr t-o em gs orStq or qfufl-E o<i gv qmftq q.s.@r qrqrfrq Ergr ffiEq-n fueqq q,qio, qsog/zozs on$.S.qr.fi. W trfi tutu& frvq rlqrqra {s srq { dtm mtq k{io, 11 sr-rFkt zozg o) qqfff, os snqfu fr Tg t of serrfl, fuf,q oT se=I vq oTfi-f, o1 uquot or frqlqq fu-qr qrqt onqwfi t t o,.oqgqrd fr 3rq-f, 5"I dq w gfr w q-fi-ft t I
12. Brl-q sH d E-{i d q."nf, qm+q O.em.q.
t. gararqrq 6pr orfi-a @-qio rctz/zoz+ d qrkd orrtyr fu{i-fi 04.03.202s oT 3i-q-drfi-{ o-q qrqr qror B of 3rfidteff qei qr+ftq S.ons.q.fr. A sqe{ erfi-a nqo or {s orBffilT d qqer nqo +t 'r$
Page 5 of 18
orfi-d srqft isr _,nzt /zozq gs erfta oi fr-E-d 3nts d qrtqq t ffiq w t ftirq-d frti qri or fr{q qro.rql 'r3. q'r+fiq O.GTri.\.8. Hyr {q GrEfi-iq ot fr&T ft=qr .rqr t ot pfts-dr $6 2 qrE d omr elfi-e or ft-ir6a"T fu-qr qrq I sreT ff or,cfuoaf cfr o.) {q 3TDo-iur d sqer cet-firi s-fl-i ig ,!* ,q- o-ri o1 Ed-rf,r A .r$ t cd d orDil"r o) vm ord.E-{ 3tTqyqoaT ergw nc-qo frrd qri +l e-aqor fi.d Bt 't4. qmftq dlcilr.g.A. iln fi q-g wn-e-or d c-ftrcr t +f,Fft dnT ceT t s-q orEo-iq d vqer fuiro ro.os.zozs oi entcc a-qd or eryM qer d qq qffm fr qer rqi +aetqfr qr$,r$r {s'3nif,{ 6r qqrs crfi-orltr qel t fuirfi onl u.zozs d u-qo ord Sg 3rrieq or ft-tq fu-qr qql tr 1s. qr+ftq S.ern\.fi. 6ri1. ft-i ,rd fr{pr qr T{r sqn crre o-{fr gy cQrqf,. qe s-cfrqfi_q t A "nr u-go or0-a of n-fl-dr gfrRqf, m fr-.{r vs fudq t nqo g$ oTfid q fudq erqr ffi fr-{r 3r0-d W ds q-r ETm-r ftirqZ-d of w s+f B"r
16. B-mw-fr t'o gm qrftq qsvq Tq ffd qTqfu d fr'ae. erqT cilqrq-m t qo-fr tr w+dgy d q-sfr-d trq d qrtqq t T$ t qfr sarra: orfid o1 fiqqor, cTeTfd frrd qri or sFr frqtR-f, fu--qT cFT I ilqqp-qrd fr 3rft-d gq sls cr g-ft qI qlqldq
Page 6 of 18
eTqfd glqfr qGN -l 127 / 2024
17. flTflq q.c. @I amrcrq qrsffd t am ffift+s freqn +eos / zozs cil$.s.9q,.dl. qKT t6 ttsr qrd \q erqd Fr'{q q dTft-d fofq RHio 11 crrrkT 2o2s q qr+fiq sqtrq -tllqlclq ENT T{r+frq vfrsn qrffu tufr& G qq fur€ ffi fni erq (zooz) T \TT.fr.fr.+zs ti qffi{d fu{ra o\ $<ffi-d o-G gr qq{an fr .d 1e. sff.f,-wT d of "rqr cmt-coqq qqe{ qslrl ffiq trg u-e t qq GTM6-{q d qqdr 3TEolfr t of sertrl: il-Eqf,r o-l vFI, 3TQrfu frf,q erqr fu-qr qrqx s-qf, rfi-{ur x"r ds w 5i qri qt'q t, 3Telt[ qfr, {q fus oT fuil{oT fu-qr uil=ll silt[T*F'tr gs qqE€rd A e?FI{r fr str{qrft t-fi at sil-Tfu frqIErTi c-€t t t
18. qrer fi qe rt sffiq g *1 qr+q'q S orn.q.A. grr q-qd 3Tftd o"\ qfrilf,r gdo z qre d Grfl fiqTqo frtn qd or ftfvr Rqrrqr t, tqT ot$ frteT T€t t a1 qfr-f, of uETdT, qqqr frf,q d qrq *1 s-aM fl q-qf, 3Ttrf, xoT dq qi gflfl ftW( of qrq 1 5 ort'ri t qr+ftq q'q g-@ qrqr1q ggr qffi( sqt-ffi €qfi-d qqgerd d q-6'rcr ii qamfl: srfrdTeff qeT gRI ,8" gs erfi-a a qMuar \d fudE d qcq ol f+,j., fu-qr qrqr frB qqo Vq eirqrq-o di t sqrrd: oTfi-dnff qa q,t gil-i t u-qd 3Tf,Rq qriqq qr{I 5 qqf<T qftB-qq ftFirfi 24'01'2024' Err{ 30-q sm.s.fi. \'{d tr{m 24.01'2024 d qTsl 3tffiq oTltfi qagt /zozq fotm 2so7'2024 61 ff{-s{ur frilT qr rar t t
Page 7 of 18
orfrd srqfr i'qt -tlzt /zoz+ ilT crfud ontrT fu{ifi 2s.0s.2023 d fr'q-q qm so-q Gil-{.0.ff. vte 1ee3 d qTotrmrgqn e-qd 3Tfi-m gq ds w gt qfi tg qtn'nn *uI 61 50 sfryrd qq-r frri Efi ol eF:rfrr i eT T€t" r 20 erxr 3o-\ erx.0.fr. v€ 1ee3 d srqql{tgqR q6[ sq qfu d em ffi ft't-q xrr srRr qorqT *m{ tq t, q{ff erffi ErT crRf, frffi 3rTtrT d ftEq crtrd cTrtv t ftiF-d ttot xq {qft 3rEo<"r + sq'H od-a rqo o1 qffi t, il.tr se' 3rq-dreff d ftr qe'qftild t ftt eFEErr Err or so cfrcrd x"r cgfr 3llu-6-i"T t qqr mt, 3rertd erm eo 3flr.O.ft. \'+e rgsa d era.to wgo 3rfrd Ei qri tg ilq rqq \rs Mq fift, Gq uq grron d ft\ sf,rsTfr qfu t eorqr E,r or so cftcrd fi-ffisc tu-qdr 2i. 3lfr-flpfl'q.T of frr t nqo srofu ont-6< d qrqq t qa opq vsr rF[ t o1 r-qo orfr-o 3rcfufi-df qeT grfl nqo o1 .r{ t, q\ qqfr s-flor d qer-oq r€t t, qf@ Tqfi offi d e_d ft1 .T{ qqfu d sr* t, wq fr gTFoerqfu-qr .rqr t fu' crq-f,rrftror q?Dnn uq cdri d ftr B-d-.{rfffr qfu TS }, a1q of M 6qfr d sTqW d fr-f,€ crRd *, d oq4 ftrqgcn t tt qrel fr rd r-<il.rqr t ot fus s-qfu q,16-+t srffi c-wrhd o1 ,r$, cr sgff trq cRqx'ot qqfu t r u,ft qfu o1 qmqn qqfu TS t r 5S emm w GrffmrqhT'r o\ ft-ffiTe aff erETf,r t 5w rwi or ergtu fu-qr rrqr tr
Page 8 of 18
oTftm srqfr i-'q< -tlzt /zozq
22. vtrrqrfr ito arr ftqiT oz.tt zoz+ o) gq 3Tff(r oT qqrs r*gd orfr gv qfuflE fu-qr rrqr t fu cTfi-ileffqur qqfu frqfi qrsrt, 3Tsrln frt-q fu-d lT-€Tfr d fr.B'fi B-ffirffi t, ftd-€ qTEfr+e ter @qifi + d wrn * sffftrd-e t-ec 6qio 4 (1) G a (z) d vq t ffi ql€erd-c t 3Trtcr ftqi6 to.oszozr d ergsn qerox rqlilr Tl{Ir tt
23. vf,.qrfr ilo or qe rfr oel{ t o1 q{fr qffi gM qftd 3Triqr f{qto zs.os.zozo d ergerv urtrR'd-e teq t ttzzzo+sat.zo i-S (go 3f,{q qrr6 6tIs qrf-s drq +sd rqrs frq q\ g.o-ft'e- sqn rd-s q-n) A q-qm rlq t, e-q Grft-fleftTur 6M rqf, qfif, tq mq {rRr o-I so qfrrTd fr-ffie ftrd G-rT X"r <N qr Ei qfi d.q rS trqq orMR q{ c-qf, olfi-d ol ft{ffi frri cri or ergtv fo-qr rqT I I gq sfls d ecrf{ t gcq eqqir Tq.c.om.fi. €e fu {€lt ftt< gqn qrqf sT qrqq qa sa.c fu-qr .rqi B t
24. 3Tfim d sler €d.q ffi-rnq Fi€I ff/z+) q) ffi cltrfr'd-c or ef,ca t, d 3i-s-dlol t se t of W u!ft @ci-6 a lurff'q fit< frE ft-ar q}fi-ffa ,rogrfi d fq dri w aao d ga frv-o q-srt rq fttq Rtd q'sft (qFqr) d na x"t qfu d {effi qt fr.er.rqr t, Grsrfd gs erfi-o d oIftdpff-rrur aa xrt efrn g.ffq frtq Ri6..T-srfr d ge d-o< cqq ffi d sosrffii di t u"t qfr( M t t, ots"T o1 frffi f,"ft qk d frfuo vo{rffi Xfq il{r
Page 9 of 18
orfi-f, sr{fi iN -'i127 /2024 ftrn a} *q d qeTt d ftq ffE-fi sq t s€-{fl-ft dt Br zrg q?m ugc t a1 v+ a'ft qfu t fttilfi q-qfu scrTEnR fr um g{ t, ereric' fu-s fiqr oo t zq q.eri d Erfusnftc Efi, q\ deq gor <)s qr dq or frv+ 51- g, ffi uem Eeur erfi-arefwr xnt qk a1 M q Br 2s. 3Tfi-flsfqrT a1 d qe 3rrqfu t e1 crtrd a1 .r$ M offi 6 srqW d fr-E€ crRd gi B, qqfu eftt tg lrrTfua qqfu eg.ff fr-q cfu{n +1 eqfu t | {s o'Rur eTfidTrtr.roT q{ qrtt 3o-\ om.S.ft.sqe d 3iilfd ft-ffisd q,1 orFrortrdr aq r€t etfr r gq s<.{ t edq t npqt or cftqror fl{ sr-drT qrol t of rs erkos"r d +gfr 3Tffi u* F-tffi fr7rz) o1onq edrcr\ Wcr fu{rfi 2s.i1.2021 3rq-f,IeffqlT d qlq w nfuf, 6{i gq dq{ d.-s qrr+d ftors q-eq its d qR+fi qm d qa *-awa 51800 crthte, q\ ft-6q qr ft-{io 28.03.1e6e ri sFld agr fr+r d er5$q t, o\ dql r f,q q-qfr @rffi tg e-d fuqr qrq, d frsq d ifrd @1 ,g g, 3larl-d q{dl 3rffi Ertr crfud eTdqT furio zs.os.zozs ti ffi ftsq rq on"r edrd qarr t eFto *qm t. ffi fr!-q t qs tocr t of "qq s-dffi qqfu {d so1 qk 01 qrqfu e}-oi a'r ffi orffi fr qd or fr'oq d'q sqfu e'srq EsqT tqr€i"t
26. entco qer e1 ort-i t u-go frd .ri fu6q qe fuqio zs qrd teee G'i@r ft/o) d 3i-s-dt-6{
oTfif, sr+fi iq< -t,tzt /zoz+ t qrqr qror t of ffiaT Er-6rfis q-eTRTfr ssr tfr gRr oTam-$w orcrfi fr ys.fr.q-dx rq df,r fr frtq friE qwFfr fr-dT +fi-dTd fr q!-srfr d qtq fffro. r+.ro.rsoz o) fr-@-q -:cn HII
Page 10 of 18
3r-5e-€T 3TTg{q t fr-@q tg 3r-jqRm rlrqfu o-r Grvi qlrr, oTqff, q-ffi qFr 3iqc d-s e-n ft-@-q eftq-d looooo/-(vfi' aru) rud, c\ 3TEq d w d +fr gril lffio 14.10.is67 oi y-on fu-qr qr gor w, eET s1800 qrfrhtd etfi-cr ddT +ft fti-q ftr6 fr-dT fr d-ft-fld fr q!-crt d qe{ fr fr-6-q gen t, 3Tvto ftoq qa 1q-tffi fi la) t qafi EEqI qd ci-grln o6 ftorm sil qcndT of s-m eq.fu Bgff trq qR-qR d frq oq qt .ri t, efu q{s ddT fr frtq fti-6 q"-cffi i qfurf, tfuq-a t s-m qqfu o-q fu-qr t'r gq fi+oq qe o1 dtr-ot c d ffi t q fr gs srkoqq o) gs fuo-q qa d sw d qt q@-t oN Frw{ efifufuo e-{i ot snqqqE.f,r t t
27. 3rfiflpff ser o-r d qa ild t of E=ffs frt-{ fu-6 q!-sTfr i rig-ff qR-il-i o1 enq t iIRT rrlkr o1 q.q-fu o-q fu-qr t w frEq fr fr-d o-T qf, t of orft-cnefi qer of onq t nqm qffid-q (e-ftf filt), (q-q{ fitz), (!-qqf fiti, F-q{ fr+), (q-qpt fi/s), (e-<vf fr,zo) d-s S-fr, GTerqr fturwq t qkifuf, 3rq-S-qf, qr$rTq fis d GTTtil-{ q{ qM ta fis, q\ dt-n EKffq t, of sfr€ o\ {fiTi re fu-qr qr q-+-flT, eiqto erfi-ar$ qeT @-l qa a-d ffi qY'.q i-€I t of w.ffq frtq ft+-6 gM +f, *s ft-qo za qrd rooo (ncd fr/s) srr
Page 11 of 18
sTfid gt:+fr isr -tlzt / zozq @-q at .T{ sqfu qg-ff kq qftqR ot sqfu efrt
20. orqmreff va t R--i@{ ft-rs) $ffi 3igr €Fir.r frs fr{iq 16 orrrkr 2016 d qrtzq t q-e edrcl qrfl ol um T-su-s oT qW et q-d crffi6 T-srt d o\ mw g3rT, d g-{+t qfurrd qqfu tlEq 6NUT eftt qY,q r-S t, frr{ sffiq deq {E B o1 qq.otfuo<q am d.\.t/zoot fr fort-r 18.06.2002 of trq E\E'd fu-qT rrqt. ai{ Td 7o1 ek g.ffq fttq me flERd-c ter @qio +, ffi fr-r€ 3Tril{fi t'fi d qer t vgmo: vq yero-f,, Fqrfi *'q Bot qirrql f,q 1l.Pr d frqq q qrR-d of q{ gs frfr'd qeron sRrqrfr o-r \rs erm ,u oo.g16. g{e t EtFr.rT *ur {Rr d frsq it q{fr of d qfuqr qrqtnfud t, s€-d 3iil.f-d f,rt qfu of z'a cq erqa sqfu qd or ft-6s frrsT qrcr qFqfua B, d qc ed o1 .T{ qqkr Xa zfr qfu fr fitq Rr6 qrsft ft-dT qi-ft-drd qrsrfi d il{67 ErfrE dt sqfu ,ff, d mq qg$ otffi d 3r-d-.i-d Ed oc fr6-q qtq wcfu t, ae 1a u,ft qfu @t aq d qfi A qrqro, d qqk sosrErorRqt 6) 3a-f,R-d g{, at vm*rffi ol tqfurrd sETfu cfr oS qr sofr cs orq qM ffi gsq €F-s'r Sc fu{rfi 16 or.rkt zoto d r+rcr fr s-m sqfu 6-I sFrI qffid d'-{t r& ffiorcT qr q6-fl'. orelfd qfi-dletr{ur or qg rd qTTi qlq Tfr t q,1x"r oqff qffi att iB-f, qffis +tr-s t sFtd qqfu 3Tfi-drrftTuT o1
Page 12 of 18
erftf, gl{fr i* -1121 /2024 qfurrd qqfu t, or?rqr i ffi qrffffie qt qqdr olffi d u"t q'e{ T€l t, efu qle 3flcFil6df S. fus orqq i eTM oo-A em.$.fr.Ye rsss d ercqmrgqn u-qo orft-e ft1 ffiqaT tg etrlrtt uq <TRr or so cfryrd qqr frd qri o1 erEaflrtgqfltt 2s. Bl-t-firgqR cer+I EEqr asat oT qfterq o-s orEoirr gq Frs{ qr qErflr t d Glfi-dTeriTur Xa xfr qfu d ftB-o sosTErfiIt ilot Xa 74 ek d sm fr;qrka qre o] sosEon t flK fu-ql t \d {fi'rsT zq o} sgffid: gq Yeroo, Trrdn 6-{i d ft\ sc-rsrfr tt Eq oxsr 3Tfi-dpftruT q-{fr GTffir ilqr qTtrd 3lrtqT furlo 2s.o2.2023 d fu$-d u-qo of .{ qs effi-a d X"t sls w gt qfi *.q ffiq ftqiRd cC tg e-d qq,;q1 Tq or so cfryrf, qgr 3o-q em.O.fi.Vqe rsss S coqmrjt+R ft- ffise o-{i d fuc s<Tilff Bt
30. u-Eo erfi-o rht qt-Eq-dr d s<d q qr+fiq BAtrq qrqrmq aItT il{rqur d( +s f{t-d {6f +6 Ti s[q (zorr) + Ts.fr.fr. s+e n qfrcrka fu€id er-jsi"ts |, 61-wr o1 qm so-g 3il(.6.fi. v€ ie93 d qrdqn erm re (r) qqffi vqe zo02 d E-ft'q c-{Eo d q{sq'} \ti flTfiq s-a.f,q qfqtdq ft-ffise v-qo ori qroq ftd A-qffio tt ErlI cFrqrP{d sTftrd d 3TTsli sqq of +fta clft-d &{fficrdtqsXffivdot te-<r r-qo 3Ifi-d @1 Mq-or Ttro: qq EM"r t gq fr-d or q-o t ot
t4 oTqrf, grqft t*, -ttzt /zozq oTftflpftTq HcI qDr{II Ed uq {rRT, q\ B-f,{qrfr +o grrr nqo orft-a erqc G 3if,Rq 3il-ifi d utrnq d qrtzrq t fr .d cTTdl-el d 3rgqn 11222642s1.20 tfr (1-o err< err6 ots e[f,s drs dlss aon fi-{ d E-n-fi-q t-q-} E-d-s t-fr) t, ffis6-r so eftqra qqr fr',i fr-+ u-qo o1 T$ q6 olq-n XuI drq w Ei qrt tg ffi 'r& t t
31. orq qE s$t ffi-q t of "qrlT qfimrQtrqq o\ 50 qftcrd fr-ffiq-c o-{i ot crjqfr t6i ffin yr <)s w Ei uri fu urqq of qr sfi-fr t, dr gs qErf t sstrrrT: 3rfr-d s-qf, o-rt fr gq fr-f,q o-r qe=t furfR-ir fu-qT qt=tT amlgqo' ], 6rqur q,t qmfiq sqtrq ;qrqffiq + sHR ot-orqtia ftft& f*t-q rfiq g. Asrg anr frfuo sfrftE s{ srdr (zors) o gs.fr.fr. 4',12 q qffiT oTftqd d ergux q-Ef, qrql otTa-fi/ ofid oilfr q-qB qt-B"-f, t, dq elrgt 3 TqiEr oTEfr'qq d urour+Asn F-{tf, oq fr qr}'ft t q-d fr mft qer t wqq ftqr of oilqfu q fuqr d t qqfr {s qfr-{q tt sffqrfr qeT gRI qqq frqr d srq o\ q'nft{f,r $-fi ffif, fuqr rqr t t
32. ee+kl: qe vffiq t of qm eo 3r-t.S.fr. g{e 1ee3 d ur+rr+gun u,T vEfr 3rft--6-{"T d qq-dr oTffi gril wR-d frt} .rS frtfr fi 3rTtcl d Wd qfu o\ orTtcr of qfr srw di t\ so frTs d eiqq xq q-{dr eTfuor"T d sqa erfta nqo o-ri o'r frfto EcD Irfl"I ft-qr rrqr d t qR oTfi-fletr qq{ erg qrd orsrt-d +qfr oTffir gtiT ffi
Page 13 of 18
qfid srqfr iqt 1Pt /zozq qrR-d 3rtpr ffi+ zs.ogzozs d ftq ot-s{ff (*qr) verftrr Etfl. ilq oilAvt of e-qrFTil qfr lrw 6rt fun-o' t srq frqr ryET *.q +fr, fu-d 3Tft-fleff qeT ffi qrERd-e or Xa xot ak wtrRrd-c t-ec 6qto + d smrErorfut o1 tfrq-d t +qfr s,rtrfrdz d qer-fl{ t, ffi am x-qo fun .ri sTrqfu 3rrilq-q oT ftqmqq fri w GTre\frd 3rrtyr qrfto Eqr t, e-q oilt{fi ceT d ftc er0-a c-qo ovi of qqq ftqT orTt{r crRil Eti ft{16. zs.os.zo23 fr TuHr fr.q t Cs 3ndft-f, 3nAYr tht qqrFta qfr
o) ftqrm' o+ ro zoza ol BqdeI ?E{r fr .rg t, a) {c{ EMq t rposr al qrq, d so fr{s d 3i({ sPrio fu{io
04. i1.2o23 ao srfta u-qo ori of rrflq €=qT 3rfi-dptr'rloT o\ ct f, ,fr, fu-d oTEflrr d eqer ftqio z+.ot zoza o) rra 3rfid e-qd qtl .rg t, "t csrrr Eqqr dqqrl 80 fd-{s' t erqB erEa t t
33. orq-mrrff qqT I erm 5 qqfil ffiftqq 1e63 d eid.fd u-qn ftd .rt eilnfi d qrzq t qe erft'fiem fuq t of fuu-fi 2s.10.2023 o\ 3lfia nqo o1 Tg, fuE {.S.srn.fr. +fd fr 3ffir eifi-a c-trd ori of qcnqT q +i t {fdwi d qqer (v+ffir ft 7za) a eft-er nqo frrqr rrq ea qq fr-td{ {fuET{ t Bq-d fu-qr qror {6T, dq fi qfrflpff va o\ qF+o fu-ql qqf o1ffi{ 3lfr-d u-qo oti d Aq'q fr erc ilfi 6ti cfuqr trft-f, T€t Ei B, fuE qcr R-{rfi 04'01.2024 dl orqmreftroT q{dt 3TErorft d sqeT sqRero gc, Tq sd or-{.rd o{EII rtfl 61 rfffo6 w t 3lfi-d c-qd
Page 14 of 18
orqrd grqfi iE\ -1127 /2024 t-qrfu-d otd gv *tfro w qfid c-qd zF-{i ol dt !il qo-fi B, ae ft-r'ifi 24.01-2024 o) 3rfr'd u-qo o1 .r$, aq e-o q+q frqr qfi-f, d g+t * t {soilEIN q-s fr'f,q erql frt} wi or 3[5tq fuqT .rqr t t
34. sf,rdrft llo am rqo frd 'ri q-qrq d qrtqqt 3rTqfu fr rr{ t o1 3lq-mptr qa i ftqi6 24.01.2024 o\ cTedd. q$r qEffifi gwr qlR-d do m* 2s.os.2o2s d fr-s-€ erfi-a u-qd o-{i o1 frtrd qqq fiqT ao R+s qfr-a d qri d qrqro erfto rqo o1r$ tt
35. strisrfi qer of o{rqfu t fu qR qq-f,iQft qer ol ffic eifi-a v-qo o.-{i t otg 3raFmer qr qqEfl=I sTr, dqt 3IE4{T d ffiq 3IBoRT d qqa sqRTfr 6ifl 3l-ilfi rqa. 6-r q-o-d ?i, ftrd tS 6t$ cfuqr q-fr slcqr$ ,g qq frqtPt.d q'q-q frcT go k{fl d 3is1 3lft-f, e-q( oEt ot ot{ c-qrq rfr frrqT .rqr, qer n-o ol frFo qr-.rTcrq go rfr ft{15 z+.ot.zoz+ o\ g'TtTH o1 ,r$ t'r c{ eirqnt w futrq flqI 3ilt'fi tnT qfrqrq fu-+'.rqr g,
36. sril seT oi V{i d qvsrd $-s or qo t of qR i rs'3TB6-i"r ot {ffi d {f$rqn d qqs eni-6q 6 creT Ht-frfl qfi-s arqa G 3nqy{o qr+tfiil g@ lXrdn oq c-qo fu-qT *or cs {f{qR ernsft{ cfu'qr d 3trd Grfi-mreff ceT d sil'tEq qq *ierq +mr fuq srfi-o nqo 6-ri i d € n-f,ffi ersqc o\
!7 i[{fd sr{fr #r -1n7 /2024 3rgcfr tg +e fie ffi{ e{ffi d qqeT nqo +t ttfr. re qE de.zl scrYq rlutfl d fuuT qror o1 sTfi-flrft qs i frFo so fr{s d 3i<q {qfr 3{Erf,rfr ErtI crR-d 3lrtrT ft-{rfi 2s.0s.2023 d fr-d-€ orfi-a arq{ srsfua oq frtro .qlqiOq go d qrer {*r slEolq A qqeT sffi-a rqo oq fr t, cq .lrd fr 3rff-m fr ilo-ffi 6ri"tr t 3fir-dTf-q-d orq-d rq-d i-S Ei crfr, ereror gror{ tg l-S dr.ri Etfr, fuc,ff srq frff 01q-oq $ BEAvo t slftd qfq frqr d oict v-rgo eli ot ild ffi *rq vror, fu-d 3tq-drQff qei i S-q cfu-qr o-r 3i-Tsiur rfr fu-qr, qfu lfu-Etr d ill cq gtsft-d 3il-nfi ft-{ffi 25.10.2023 (\i-@r frrzzo) ft$-c E-qtd d qqsT Tqf, os 3lsi qrfu€ q,1 Xffi w d .r{ t
37. elfi-d sTq{ d erpl qif,rq qrqg@ qqr {$-E d sr-{dYm-{ t w€ t fu eno 24.01.2024 o\ 3Tfu{ffir frq-q yio{ sriTtzp{ eN 30755/- (frs.asn qro e\ qq{r) dq$ fru-o qusft frs€ ss.ff.orr$. d 3lffiq roqq o1 qEIIerq go d w { qqr fu-qT rrqrr qqfr 3rft-d etqc d celq gE w ftdrr 23.10.202a or germ.t t, frtg ftTq-+tq offi E1qT fu-qT rqT yET-6.c 1e..fi-q t, u-{fu {fsqTi d r+qq !-f,{uT wdd r€t Esi, qqfu {fuqTi dRI csr+T 3Tricr ckf,r ftqio to.oo zozq d ftrd .d B, ffi ergvx effi-anff 3TB{ffir aft frnfi qrqr d ffir krio 24.01.2024 o\ qrqr so 3TN.S.ft.\'{e d 3i-f,'ff, 3idftc aTlil{r\ d qrpr 3rft-d tr+g-d tnEi or sdq t t gc
Page 15 of 18
orftd sl{fr iqr -1'127 /2024 qfueTfuqt t oTfi-fleff ceT o't 16 ild ffi fr'q r€t t fr gs oTD-6-rur qt {fti-S d qqer frFo rnq-q frqt so fuqs d 3tfl ft-{i6 25.10.2023 @\ 3lfi-m e-qd o{ A .rg fr I
38. sreT fr qe rfi sffiq t o1 3lff-d. enil<t, 1a orril({ oT sq ft-{ifi t qFrT qraT B, ftffi ft-{rfi oi 3rfiflPft/3Tril{6 qeT i frEd cre-q fr 3iltfi/3ffi-f, qrsE-d 6t utqYqq? -qlqlc1q qTq lc4 q g@ oT Urrflq or ffi d siTfr c{gd fi kqr e\ r gs E<$ d < tl.q ffi trg.{-d (ffiw) qffi 1ee3 or ft{q + $i z qrffiq BI 3e. {s ctr{ur q qq 3ffiflPff qer i rfuqrq d qqq fti{o cr€c i olfi-d gIq-{ G orqrco go wBo eo fr+s d otqr srerta R-{ifi 25.10.2023 TO 3IQIqT U.11.2023 e-o nqo r€t fr,qr, erqen {P"rqR 6NT {fl 9'or"r i ftId 'd s.erq 3Trtsr cB-61 fu{rfi $.06.2024 il gs oq ot €flc fuqr +dI q,t 3lfif,lpff qel i fr{io 25.10. zozz d ftFo smq t eI0-d flqq rflt ftfi-fi d qqeT u-qd or ft-qT srT, Ts 3[gcn fr'ordT sr}rl ol qrwq i oTfi-dtetr qei i qE 3Tftd fr{ifi 24.01. zozq d Grtrrirfi qrql"rl g@ or SrTdrq 6t sTR6i.T d sqm u-qo fuur t, elerid ftfr-fi Erftq 6dqt d gm erfi-a srqc d qerq Ysd c( ft-{io 2J.10.2023 d ftsq t frtqr rrqr YET-6.q frFo qq-q frcr d oi{i 3Tfr-d uqo *+ 3ricTfrf, frtd Gli 6g .6qotw$qfrqrqf1
Page 16 of 18
ql-Tfiq wm-q qIqr-dq Errr {c{ t{rrd sr0e 6qfr sfi'q, Etsqr fdft& f{sq onqtRr{rd ftrq&r (zorz) to \q.fr.fr. rez ti qffi{d oTftqf, d ergwn errql 30 srn.S.ft. v+e rggs d 3tr( qqft oTPmrft gRI qrkd oil-erT d fr-t-€ trq( Et-i otfr 3ilfrd i trr{I 5 Tqf<r 3rftfuqq d rilcrErrq drf r& di, tsr fr rrf, qrrftq wrcrrT anqTerq Am erfufiqr rq .nsFrd fffiq sfiRqrum to. dq, o,r{H Qozz\ rs gq.fr. ff. zzr d trfi-{q fr qffif, ftqr rrqr t, d qq 3rfr-dT?ff qeT gM e-qd cft-f, qarq Esqr ci-qfu
40. {s e-o-{q fr frqio. rc.o6.2024 o1 Eq oTEfi-{uT grr ftrd T$ 3TrteT qkfiT q se t o1 fr-dq fir qrq \d orq-f, A ffi'qm vcrrqrfr qer o-r qqrcr GTri d rrrqkT furfRd frtn qd ot ftE!ft d qrq srra-<o qeI Hr{I rqo erofu qi}qc dfr=d {d rri q}, oTe-rfn teT ,fi T€f * fu W q ortn{6 qeT gni trEd g< ofdRq oiltr{rT o) ffi gq rer-rrq 3il-ilfi or ftqroqq foqt rrqr qI I
41. erqto sTBfr-ilT qE furfRf, otcTT t ot orftflrtr qeT grgr qs erko-sq d sqa erfi-a flq{, frFo qrqraq go' d HIar cIrKlcI t[ ftqffi z+.0r. zoz+ d u-qo fuur rrqr, Glarfd srTn{o qeT ErtI q-qd orfr-d erqB erBd t t
42. crq q6 qrq sE.-T Etdr t fu "eqr 3lft-drrff qeT gM tr{Ed oil}fi qr{I 5 Tqffl 3rftfr'qq fro-ri oq erfi-oreff qfl gRI u-qo ufi-a g,T q)q w gi qri tg qrqq o1 qT sofr t r gs q<d fr
Page 17 of 18
qfid q-{fr tx -ttzt /zoz+ qrkd B \-s r{fr 3Tffi d olresr d frw erm go qr.S.fi. g€ 1ee3 A do.fd nqa di orfr fiqE qrEfl 3Tfi-d t frdq erqr frti qfi fu uvr s q_qf-r oT*ftqq rgos d q;qq;< drrl T€l eit, fff o1 sct-ff qugE.rd d ma.q t rtrfr-q surkFT ql-rrTcr{r d aqr ftE E{srTfu-d o1 qr got t', ac aTfi-dreff qeT gr{I ngo eril<-< qm s qqiqr effiftqq d qrrq'q t 3rfr-dretr qeT gRr nqo o1 T-$ e{0-d o) rEo o-G d gg fr.mq d erqr 6r nqo efia Xu dv qi gi qri elw urqq .rfr otwsoftt
43. qsrid qq orfimpff ERT e-Ed oTfi-d q-48 qrB-d t qs E{enfrd'l4E d ergqx erq& qrBo affi-a Xu ds w r€t gff w sm-ft, ire erff-dPtr d erm so-g orr.S.ff. \rrE 1es3 d urotnrqun gs od-a o) g"T Els qi gi qri iE ffiq qqti d s{icq t crfi-drQff cer o\ krio. gr.os.zoea 01 furfr t cflqT ge{ x-rl 11222643sr.20 tfr (go oRcr sr{6 o-t's Erg-s' aro dlsa ron fic q} E-o-fi-s tvi' E-frq t-S) or so cftyrd qqr o-ri o1 erjqfr tm{ g-s oTfi-d d g"r ds w gi qri 6T 3rq{N T€i fuqT qr s-6-f,rl
44. {fu 3lfi-drrff qer gRI u-*go erfia g"T ds w gt qrt fr.q rS f l gq onur enfrilf,di qa A.t.A.sq.$.g {tr+s ffifr}c o\ c-6{rr ff qqtirTr d vq t ffi of ot{ oreraoor ts r€t {6 qrftt qralqw emftooef cer anr u-go edrt or r<rgqR ft-irf,i"T fu-q wcn tt
2r sTfi-d srqfr #t -1121/2024 4s. eraltf, sqt-fiEsTq frB-fi ftnqcT o-{ sTFo-wr gs M w qE"-dT t of erfi-arefr qa gnr rqd o1 .r$ erfi-a qm go-A ern.S.ft.g+e rgge d ilqqmrgqn 3rfrd qqfr ft-{i-f, d T{ qorur Ed xur srPr or so qfrcra qqr frd G-cr s-qd Eit t gt qrt qt'.-q q dma qrrrrflr ffi'.f-a B, qrq fr qm so cdr.S.fr.g+e rsss d srqqrflgqri sTtrT qIRd d-i eqrfi t ftfr( srq erqE eo ft-qq A oiil qfr-d rqf, c di d orqq orftd GrqE qlB-f, fi t \d elrdro qe{ grr trqgf, fr6rq erfl 3Trilfi ffi qtq c-€t t t
46. s"rsrdrT oTfi-dTQff qeT grgr q-{gd oTl-ilfi qrt 5 TqfqT Grftfrqq teog srd erqr frtt qfi fuf,q, qrel fr nqd oililfi trt-{ 30-A orx.S.fr. v{d 1ee3 ft-ffisd t 5m s-il{ frt} ufi emq gq 3Tfi-d X"r du w gi qfi tg u-qo oioRn qT-tfi q{.q. qaw / zoz+ f{rlo 2s.07.2024 ft-qrqT{ +oq ffi frrq q fri sq frB ffid-d Eti t ft-{ffi frr} srt t t
42. +flT fu sqrt-ffi o-Fs{T t {tEtr-d ft-q rrqt B 01 qlrfrq wkl-q RII-qFFI gRT ql{Esrf, strfr o\-eTlqtEq m.r+rfl rMtuft&frr€ ffiq S. tsr{ (zors) o vs.fr.fr. +tz t qffid qftT.r d q-{Tsr fr oi-qB qTE-d siltfi7 effi-a ryt dq w fr-qn frti qfi d {d fr ft{w q,t qrfr qTBq r gs frB @tnall d e-mtqr i qa qri gq ot 3Tfi-flpff qeT 6RI trqd qd 1"7 dq q{ cr-i ., qfif, sl+fi iE\ -1127 /2024 qri +'q q-€i tr s-f,Etc nqo effi-a gS ws qq ftvw of qrfr tt
48. oldv, o1 qfi cfr s{fr sTErrrft o\ cgdr ror"r i GTFJq ol-ffi tg iltrrd iB-o ol qrqt 49 B.trt ceT Glq{T-3rttfl qq q6q ott t 3Trtcr gd qrr"rq t enq kqio 05.05.2025 da- qtB-o frrq t >9 oE. ({qfr'sTs- qld) qq.rl* (ffi{ 3rffi) ft;qio":-o5.os2ozs $.ort.E. q. c., vE uffi-$rd
Page 18 of 18
Loading citations and judicial treatment…