Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
MS SHREE RAM COTEX vs BANK OF BARODA on 13 March 2024
sTn.q.i. oz / zozs
xrT qq-fi 3TB6wr q-{f,gq
(q.s.sf ffirrq)
(ffi{ GTffi - qmfrq aft rrq fuqrs qed)
3TI{'q =i' - 07 / 2023
2.
M +tr{rq o\-effi 4a qdEr fl.f {sna,
funI g$tq (wt1 4s111s gxr qrdTt fr
qqq .irqd,
+fr fusq .itqf, Glrfrt"t fr {iqrqq ,irqa sq oftq- ffi 48 q{qT qrd sslT6, fudr g{.f{ (stl 4s1115, fr G,q-f, .irqf, Glrfrtat +ft ssqmrqq riqf, sq 6tq- ffi ft.en{.-4 .ifi q{ dN
fi qg$q .iud srfrru fr TnYraq 'ilTf,
sq ft-
ffi
48 qdET fl.f EslTE,
trf,T s{.ilq (Vntl 4s111s,
fi Tinrq .ilqd 3rfrrq fr fi{rf,rfl uft
.ir{d, sq otq-ffi +a qdqr qFf qsqr6,
fuf,r garf{ (gq*1 4s111s............entcorrur t frt,,q tfi du' q-.€)qr Fmdrd Trr{ frq {q- 3, Gffi wruTT ciytm nrg TflWTr Ed( (fq ft.) aszoot +ft ffiFI gqr oIrffiT fr q-dtq q gqT, fi"'m o+g7s{f,q q-slTa, fuf,r q<'flq (\'q ft.) +sr r rs........... ..... ......"sctqrftrur t
4.
5.
sTril{o se{
erfuqffir 1
d ftTq fr Tfrr sTqqlET
B-ffiqrft t6 d frN fr rft'T qCft
31fu6mrl
Page 1 of 9
cTrq.g.=i. ot / zozs
3Tr t
YT
(fu{i-qt 8.03.202+ o} dtfrd)
1. Gnfffi qer HRr ffitr u.ot.2o2g d sT1-{t 22 (z) €) eil-{.S.fr.g{e 1ee3 sdqbf, fuqq s_g, 16 g*- ffi Agrd (stfrq{) Ftr 1ee3 d skr.til q6 Wllffim{ Gil-ffi us erkowr Ern gs.q. 2ss/2022 +{# +ftffq dr}ffi w cnar frFq fo' Gf,q. es)qT t qTRil oifuq Gne?T fuir6 06.04.2023 d ff{-€ rqer fuqr .rqr t t
2. gilftro}ftE snir{ rqd o-(t t gv fftTq o} emr frtt qrt tg yer6 t er+eq {fl GilErn r{ erEd fuqr .rqr t frt Grfuq GTrtgr Hr{. 06.04.202s d frtrq t oil-im qe{ o} T6fi ily g;q fuim os.ot.2o23 ot g3rr, qq 3nilffi seT d sirk{fiT s fl-fu{ q-6rrE ot srfto-{q at ffi d Arr erfuq sntqT ftt eft B:qcreT q,Trfr r-{, orwr o1 onileo qa o) sFD + qrE4-q t sntqr et !ft qrw re g$ I ilEq{il-fl H-6 or.or.zo2s
o) sil-nffi qsT t eTDilffiT * sfur s*q. t sqd fu* w eqrDrf, sft srw m-{i tg Grrilqr frqr, d ffirfi rc.07.2023 d urw g$ r {fl o'R, sr'wr rgfl ort fr frffi Eet Eil F{qrft t r $A GilqTt qq fr-dq erqr Gil-ifi rftflr or grsrfufoq Grr-ne{ yr qtE w E-t qrt mr er$tl fuqT .rqr t r 3 rqd fut 'ri gwffi*q .nn{T mr 5uq srrEr* t ft1 gnq. zsg /zozz d Hkn rdi d dym orr'fqo-.rq ft1 strwrft +6 t vfi Tw H+ilsnq ot qI{f,r ftr r& eft, fuH tg onnffi seT t 46,oo,oool-(Mfl eru) FT$ Brrr w 1,-{. Tw srrrErn onnfi rqd or Tsr QT \q frqil Tqf d qeqrd ffi +m- d gr$ Er ftqt_o. 2s-.03.2023 d
Page 2 of 9
3IR.q.;T. 07 / 2023 qrEzrrl t Vo UK sqrqn ffi6n frrt qrt of grqr 6 .I{, ffi ei-gsx 4,s9,oo,ooo/- (qrq mtrs s{r-d aru) sq$ t sm gK Hqrqn ffiffi fuqr .rqr en w qrtqr1wx onneo qe{ of 30.06.2023 cf6 trq vrRr q*n o,,{=TT QIT I il{rgffi onn{6 qa t TIRT qrn .ft or fr tr
4. qTer fr orfuoem fuqr q-qT t a1 fur-r6 2e.03. 2o2s o\ ror"r t GTfuq rd EIr .rrrT, fuE sf,snfr to. d oTk{ffir Hnr erBo-sur ol gs aea t erq.rfl TS orrql rrql at qerorft + $q fu{rE o-t H,T]EII"T g6 Ttr srrrErr=T dq{r d crgwrc dT g+l t w fffrtr
31. os.zo2s o\ sri{t{ qa i H*IIEII"T trRT o-r 50 sfurd qqr rfr or lcqr t, etrqefl oihq orr*T qrRf, frt{r qFTI TerFId fuqr 51 ffiITTT gT, cterfl BTkfi-{q HTr frq .r} M t ftq M fuqr qT wFaT erTt
5. wr-d HTgT fr qi-qro sH Hrgr Gtfrq oil-asr t frqqm trcIfl ZE d Gril,td oTIEIR fuqr .rqr B o1 frf,r tfr .h{i{ 01 Tq funfi 30.11 .2011 e\ d qfi q{ vn-d smsrffit a'r ds fsn"s frfu ifrn fuqr urqT "TEq err t frT GTt-'dEo qeT HNI slkfiittr d eil-kT fuffi 17.12.2020 d Gi-gslr o,oo,oool-(d drsl qrd rwn) vri fffi-f, os.o1 .2021 o'I urril fuql rrrfl w otilRq ontgr $Trft sTT, frrsfi-t vf,wrft il6 d qTBqf, GTffi grr ffiiq{ fuqT.rqr G ffiff frq.q qTt + qrq-q t ff€q th1 .r$ sqfu or &t{h? qffi( frrqr rt-rlT I
6. orid{r stT grt gr{Thaton oil-nfi t rrcffid qrqgeTdi + qttz-q t oTfurfi frtqr q-qt t fu B-f,.qrft to or eil-q{ul oqd at *'ft ti enor t, fuq
Page 3 of 9
3nN.q.;T. 07 / 2023 rrrrr qrRf, eifu entyr tfrifi 06.04.2023 grtTtrden oT 3ilTrftT frrt qrt drrq t t
7. emwrft +fi d Hrrr grqTmer 3Tl-ilfi \q frdq flqr Gnilfr o-t yQro-yerfr ctelq lrqf, frrql rrq[ t t qr.r fr ffi dor Arqr fr y*ro srq rqo t t B. sf,srft tfi d argr fdf,q flqr ontfi s-t w{-q rqd or sfuqrE fuqr .rqr t *1 rrq+ffi gdd 2ooz d oto.Td gilTffian or o-Y$ ftqH TS t \rq rTHftq q. s.wr qrqrrq d iln rrrtq ftft.r dEft frsa Aq, tiGR (zoro) 3 w.ft.sd.d. t qren fr 'dtot qm+q S.em.q.fr. dt f+srhqloq uht qrRilm T€i t, trr {fl GTBfi{ur et fi 3tilTmtm.q a1 vrRrrm sIkT T€t +{r ril-;rT qr"TT ilEg t
e. qrq fr erq6 m .d t o1 ftqq s-( (z) Sem.
a. ffiw tG 1ee3 d srqqmrgsn furtRf, Trrrrl frr d otil gilTffieE oTtdfi eqd r€t fuqr t, wEfu Gtfrq oTrtqr fuIr6 06.04.2023 sTkf,{ur at Ws qq frqiq 06.04.202g ei oTrdrs d Aor en G fu{ro B.o4.2o2s o'r fr:gm sfr dqn dt T+t eft t vicrwrfr t-6 o'r fr{i-6 13.04.2023 e\ ft:gm' sft srq dr .d eft, re orififr sfl erQtrrT oTi{t6 qe{ d erftqffir o1 w{rq{rfr eft fu fr:gm sh sTBff{q a1 ffi t rrrqT ?Da *i t
10. Btnwrft sqT Er{r Gilqfu fr T$ t o1 eil-tqr qTRf, *t t 30 fu{fl + qwkT rq-fl fuqT rrqr glumol Gil-il({ ei-qB qrfuf, t \rq qmftq s@Tq " .tnrrrEt-q EnT €qsd qr& t6, f{sq r"T.vnA.fr fuftes fuffd GTftd t'qr sor 1 zozo frfttr{fg'1 d GrgHR grrTme=T otTilfi fr fdf,q erril ori a1
Page 4 of 9
3Tl{.9.=i. oT / 2023 eTRoTRilr rS t r gfr oilEr{ q{ frHEq eFil onffi ftrK frd qri or ergtq fttqr .nn t t
11. B-f,r-qrft to grr gilTffieE oil-nfr o-r Yerfr t w{-q rtrf, erfr gq eil-qfu m .r{ t at moft qa HRI fuim 27.02.2023 o'r go g{f, Hqrqrq rwrq to d sqer rqf, frt-qr ril, ffi fqw t erf,r qrft eftt etco: fuIr6 zg.oa.zo2g et 4,s9,00,0 oo / -(qTr, mts s*rd aro) $Tn & trkTTtl TftfiN frtqr rrq[, ftmEi fto-q FrU-qe d qrurq t sIH nRr HFryfua rS[ efr, ffi frTq fr +n qrEft-de sncqTfr Eqro z d qm q f{qr qT Tol Qr I HIeI fr erkoem t fu gs.q. zse / 2ozo fr oifrq ild gt qrt + qqqrn eir.fr.gn. ffi wt fuirfr 2s.os.zozs qtt $il Qr I [fl Q-Rur vf,{qTfr t{ d oTBilqilr d srTef ffiD d +tr{ Bm oea t GTRoisr ot er+tro o-{t-i mr dr$ GFNN r$t QT, qfrm d]qn +fl fuIrf, 2s.o3.zo2s et Yrd Eqifr r d Grgsrr eTkfiwr or etfrq sTtvr eilElSf, en t
12. B-f,.{rft qa at oft t qa ,fr sfuqrc frrqrrqr t a1 GTfufi-{q Hnr gs.q. \q oif,Rq orfffi oI x"r dlq qr furf,-{q fuqT rrrlT t, Tq sil-ilffi geT o' gr{Tffiroq ortifi d qIEzlrI t v€ ffgstf q{ g{: Wrr{ srgfu T€i t, foE eIl-il{6 qs i qrE fr rilq srrflirq q6 g-flTmEFq olrtqq rq-a fr,-qr t, dI ffifr.qr€ti'r
13. Bd.qrft sH o-t sfo{rE t of {s erBosq ENT qTRfl Gifrq sil-tqr fuil?F o6.o4.2ozs q eH ts rselEff 1fr T€f t, Uil 5T(Tffieq o-r sIIEIr{ q-{ft d r gq sft elTEnrf q{ rq( STqThdftn 3rrnfi fuK frro qfi or eqtlq frtqrrqr t t
Page 5 of 9
3Trr.g.i. 07 / 2023
14. ffi ff,r Bd.{rft oqio z d Hrgr yQro Gm-q s-qd o.{t gq g-flrhfroq GIiffr or frtteT frtqr rr-rrT t r frtltr or Wq oilEn-{ t of w Tw srTIEIl"I nrTrtr frqd qa ft{ro 2s.os.2o2s et qrd + Gftrrfi{ ffifin fuqr .rqr t ri s'qtq qa t Gtfrq ontqr frqi-o 06.04.2023 engf, frt-qr t t qrRo entvr Rilfr oo.o4.2o2s qaNrerc{qqff@rStt 1s. s+FI qs d ild d *DIqT tf ftq sr{ ffiq s.tr.- (r),- qil ori{ffi s&I gM rEf, fdffi flrlr GTrilfi ffifin or grrTffifiq oil-ffr g"r dq w gt qfiqt"qt?
(z) ,- ?rqt sfl oTEfi-rq HRI w.g.2se / zozo fr qrRf, Gifrq qTeqr fr{rfi o6.o4.zo2s gwrmaE qa GTTTTFT frd qri q}.q t ?
16. ua $enfuo frft t qfr frnft fi ffiq rDwI fi qR frdq $T IrFT ffiq t, ni eq-rrfl: ftaq mqr o1-ilfi or ft{rftT"r Gil-ry{o +f,r t t {fl oTkf,wr t on-ilffi qa Hr{r fra*o erqr sniEq lqf, frril t, o-rsrr a1 {s sTBffir"r gr{r vfl.q. zsg / zo2o t qrRf, sTfuq Gniyr fur'rfr 06.04.202s d |fitr f+rrfr M.o7.zozs et grqTmal sil-nco wgf, fuqr q-il t, qi so gqs o1 Gn-qB d qrqrf, rqf, Ecrr t, wqfu ftqq 5-q (2) tqu ffi fa{Fa (trtrw) se 1ee3 d smrmrgsn fiG--d EqRfl dr mq qq-ft sTkfi-{rr HNr qrRf, GTrkT d ftt-€ 30 fffH d si-{r :fvrffior nq-d ovt or eirr-{N trEr"T fuqr qqr t t ?rqfr silc{rft s&r e1 q6 silqfu t e1 vffi r're zooz d sir.f( g-{qTffior or qf,$ fdqn Tff *i t Grrtno se{ grr rqr y$mnq ffiq rS t, fuE {s sqi{ t qs +o
Page 6 of 9
3[R.9.=i. ot / zozt o-t rf, t of qmr fi (?) s{Sffi vffi 2ooz d eTotrr+rgwrc Turiq-fr oTfuf,wr o) TrrSffi yqe 2oo2 d ffd nqd m Tn Gnilfi 61 ftqrfiwr ern.S.S. fr. Sqe 1ee3 t oplo yrqETrq} W ffi d ergo-q ffi qri of q|.ffi rqr{ qft.d tl gs EMlur t ftd o-t mI t fu qq qxr fi s{Sqft yqu 2oo2 d Gi-il'fd u-qn *t qrA orr'dfi or furrowr eq-S oTkw"r d arsr fuqr uilror t, rq qlRf, GThq sTrtqr d f*w em. s.fr. gdd 1ee3 at qxr 22 (z) (0 d srqETnrgrrl qrRf, sidfrq Gretq eifrq sTrtyr d fut-q gflrffimr ol-ilfr qr fr-trn mri of erffior srq t, fug fu( fi fifrd qk o\ mqq s-q (z) S. enq.O. (ffiqq) if,c^H 19e3 d srqqmrgffi 30 R-{fl + oiw gilTffior snffr r*g-d oFTT ermqrd t r
17. {fl xrtrT fr siltno qa t T€q w fr q6 orrErn filqr t at oil-f{o-wr a'r offu oil-evr of ft:gm sfr fqi# sFF HRr iRil T€f ftt .r$ I {n or{q frdq effir frrS qfi qt.q t r gs ild d inqefq fr qmftq 0. erng.fr. {f,rflqrE ENI oTfrd oqio- z'ta/zo'tg * fo, ofrrr cflIft{rfl erq d nor"r t qrRfl ftufq k{o 1s.o2.zo2o qn HEffif, fuqr .rqr t t eiq {fl sqrf fr qs srffiq t fu vf,{qrfr +o. d grr rqf, frtq Tt siltt $ qput t sfuqrc frrqr rrqr t of oTfrq eil-aqr fuIr6 o6.o4.2ozs tht ft:go eft f+no B.o4.2o2s e'r dq{ dr T+t aft, E} sil.qrft il6 d aru ftlqrfi B.o4.2o2s o] srw oq fr .r$ eft, fu=g orrilEo qel d Erqt oTemr oil-i(6 qa d srfurmr aqr ft:gm vh eIkT T& fuqT q fr ffi
o) strrld evl-qT et s+ ft:gm sfr srw o{i or ft{qr r€f B't
18. qR oil-}eo sef t gilTffiaE qIilfi d HTeI ft'go eft at at{ qft €dn{ TS tht 'r$ E'rfr, Tq I 3rR.g.q. 07 / 2O2s qRRTffi ft-q aw t ergqtFd of qr sfrft eft, fuE Gil-nEo sn t (\+ffi em.g/ro) d ss q dr eifrq oil-tvr H{m 06.04.2023 et sft qif,.q fuqr t, qE GrRoqrT gM frr6 e.o4.2oz3 o'r tqn et T{ \q furr6 8s4.2023 dr ffi oqio. s77 d qnqq t Hdet a1 q-$, frgm' sfr t I 1e. gq qRRQTfuf t qa wE t e1 grfrerqoat qeT d gxr sTBorq t fuirfr 13.04.202s o'I ffi tg dqTr ft:gm' sfr srw fuqr tq y+nffiroq sil-n{q d HTgT fidr{ fi ftrqr t, f+=g frf,q t sfrfrrfr qrq ori o-r GilEn-{ FrtFT fuf,q erqr frr} qrt q-r ergtnT frrqr qT rEr t t gq qRRQTfudr fr ftd e-r qcT t of qq fum fi.04.202s oi ft:gm sfr rilq frti qrt tg t+tY d T+1 sft. ffi ftft t orTitr e77 rR H€r frri qfi tg d o1 qr T+t eft, dq qR sil-fqin qa t urr{flo{ fuf,q t ft:gm sft yrkT fuqT t, c[q qTt+o qel a\ vq ftq qRRQTffit tf n-{ftq 0.ernq. E gorgrqrs ffrr srflril oqio zro/zorg €e to' ofrq. Etrsqr frsa ffilfi{rfl qq cr=q fr drfua frutq fuirfr 1s.02.2020 g 6p+1iftn rS fuqT on soor I
20. q6r ilF grrTfrEirftE sn-ilfi fr qxr 5 rrrfEr orBfu{q o1 srdrqf,r o-r rrwr t, sf,wrft t-r Hr$ fuilq nrrr oTidfr tnr FdT yfu sFil{rq m=G gq qmftq wrilq arrnErrl HnT ftffd oTftd =iqr so't /zozo N qr& tfi ffg.q \.r.w.a.fr. fuft& .fr. ors ti effi{n qftTn d riEffiT
Page 7 of 9
ort g3 Gil-qfu cd oqqr t o1 qTil 22 (2) €) em.S. fr. g+e d eier.fd nqd dri qr& grqTmoq eirilc fr qmr 5 qqfqT sTBftm d sFxETH qrdw =r& t r {s ftufq of ops*, r+ t qr+fu sqilT qrrrrEnr d arsr fr .d qnqr d erg$T{ fu{q s-y d errETrfrrfi' yrqErrr}
e qrt.g.T. 07 / 2023 d norsr fr so fu{s t qt ryn gruffiFnl urt6 q funEq sqr frrt qfi e1 eTkilRil. r& t'r
21. sq qRRerfut q {n ftd o-r ro t qft onilffi srT HRr siqf, Wvrmoq eil-aEn Grqfu qrkf, t w w eTBnwr of mqq 5-s (2) S.em.0. (eitrw) frqq 1ee3 d edq (q sreT fr qrflftq wlcrT qrqrf,q Ergr fufra erfta oqrfr srel 2o2o qmftq $qilq arqtorl EnT frfra qfia =iq( ool /zozo €lqd En& tf, fldio-{ w.\rw.0.fr. frfre (zozo) 13 \ry.fr.fr. 618 q ar{ro-q d qrqqgiil qtrdn ot-orqtFa q..rf+s ffi fr. +rz q sffiff oTftffi erqffiq tr
23. oTidro sfl t flTftq wFT RITTIIEI-q d EnT ftfra oTftd #t qaza/ 2o2s Tt{r qn6 1ni er.q frsq rilE< frfa \rq q-q t dIRn ffiq furc 24 En-$ 2oz3 of Hqffid m-{n gY frdq trrTl GrTtfr {+flT art o-t Grj{)u fuqr t r {fl trq q WT GIrfl rrrd ori gq {fl fie or ro t ft1 qm+q sailq d.llq lc'ltl e-r wm ffiq frfi-srd RIFdf, {d =icn s\/2oo2 fr qlRf, trq forrr 01.10.2002 t sf,lET oTfrfl t sqkd t, .ilqfu Es sTBo-{q d sqe{ ua 5rgrffirol on-ilfi tINI 22 (z) €) em.S.ft. v{d sdqfrffi fufr s-\ (2) S.em.0. (efu) vffi 1ee3 t wBo drt q}fud trq fub zr \ili{ft 2o2o g sffi{n orfun d xF'RI fi qTtffi seT grtr rqf, fuffi trrlr Gn}H ffi +.q =rfr t'r
22. ue genFn frft t of funq t rqo fuqr rrqr Gil-ifi/erfra/qrq frqK mr f{qT qrhr, ,rd fr fuifi qs d Ergr iftrc or yfuqn q fuqr .rqr dt, us H-<.+ fr qm+q $qilq qrqrf,q Hrtt qlrftq sqilq
Page 8 of 9
3TR.q.t'. 07 / 2023 d tnrwr Gil-n{6 qeT o:r {s *FwT t sm qqEETdi fr+16r&ffit
24. gq qRReTfui t us fts or qo t o1 qq eil-fffi sH grrr sqf, gilTman srttr{ erqfu ilBa t \q frffi flqr eil-il{q ffi q}.q rS t, Te Gil-ilro qeT HRI trqf, frti .T$ gr{Tffial en-'fi{ of g"r dq .N qrsr rfr at qT Hfift I zs. rmrsrtrT erfffo qer gm sqd fff,q sqr enilEq frrK fuqT qror t r HTer fr qa fr'qfRf, ori gq qft grrrffio.T eTt'ffi erqfu qTfua t r trqf, crr.\.q. ot / zozs GrqE qrBa drt d oxur yr dtv w fi+qrq frrt fu{r fr fr{w frrqr qror t r onivr @ vr+ro+ fr enq fr{rfr B.os.2o2+ d q}fud fuqr I 'yv o
.0v' q-fld5r fuio:-r 3.03.2024 q-ae) fiorfr{ GTffi, S.ern.fr q.q.w uftsrrs
Page 9 of 9
Loading citations and judicial treatment…