Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals

MS SHREE RAM COTEX vs BANK OF BARODA on 13 March 2024

sTn.q.i. oz / zozs

xrT qq-fi 3TB6wr q-{f,gq

(q.s.sf ffirrq)

(ffi{ GTffi - qmfrq aft rrq fuqrs qed)

3TI{'q =i' - 07 / 2023

2.

M +tr{rq o\-effi 4a qdEr fl.f {sna,

funI g$tq (wt1 4s111s gxr qrdTt fr

qqq .irqd,

+fr fusq .itqf, Glrfrt"t fr {iqrqq ,irqa sq oftq- ffi 48 q{qT qrd sslT6, fudr g{.f{ (stl 4s1115, fr G,q-f, .irqf, Glrfrtat +ft ssqmrqq riqf, sq 6tq- ffi ft.en{.-4 .ifi q{ dN

fi qg$q .iud srfrru fr TnYraq 'ilTf,

sq ft-

ffi

48 qdET fl.f EslTE,

trf,T s{.ilq (Vntl 4s111s,

fi Tinrq .ilqd 3rfrrq fr fi{rf,rfl uft

.ir{d, sq otq-ffi +a qdqr qFf qsqr6,

fuf,r garf{ (gq*1 4s111s............entcorrur t frt,,q tfi du' q-.€)qr Fmdrd Trr{ frq {q- 3, Gffi wruTT ciytm nrg TflWTr Ed( (fq ft.) aszoot +ft ffiFI gqr oIrffiT fr q-dtq q gqT, fi"'m o+g7s{f,q q-slTa, fuf,r q<'flq (\'q ft.) +sr r rs........... ..... ......"sctqrftrur t

4.

5.

sTril{o se{

erfuqffir 1

d ftTq fr Tfrr sTqqlET

B-ffiqrft t6 d frN fr rft'T qCft

31fu6mrl

Page 1 of 9

cTrq.g.=i. ot / zozs

3Tr t

YT

(fu{i-qt 8.03.202+ o} dtfrd)

1. Gnfffi qer HRr ffitr u.ot.2o2g d sT1-{t 22 (z) €) eil-{.S.fr.g{e 1ee3 sdqbf, fuqq s_g, 16 g*- ffi Agrd (stfrq{) Ftr 1ee3 d skr.til q6 Wllffim{ Gil-ffi us erkowr Ern gs.q. 2ss/2022 +{# +ftffq dr}ffi w cnar frFq fo' Gf,q. es)qT t qTRil oifuq Gne?T fuir6 06.04.2023 d ff{-€ rqer fuqr .rqr t t

2. gilftro}ftE snir{ rqd o-(t t gv fftTq o} emr frtt qrt tg yer6 t er+eq {fl GilErn r{ erEd fuqr .rqr t frt Grfuq GTrtgr Hr{. 06.04.202s d frtrq t oil-im qe{ o} T6fi ily g;q fuim os.ot.2o23 ot g3rr, qq 3nilffi seT d sirk{fiT s fl-fu{ q-6rrE ot srfto-{q at ffi d Arr erfuq sntqT ftt eft B:qcreT q,Trfr r-{, orwr o1 onileo qa o) sFD + qrE4-q t sntqr et !ft qrw re g$ I ilEq{il-fl H-6 or.or.zo2s

o) sil-nffi qsT t eTDilffiT * sfur s*q. t sqd fu* w eqrDrf, sft srw m-{i tg Grrilqr frqr, d ffirfi rc.07.2023 d urw g$ r {fl o'R, sr'wr rgfl ort fr frffi Eet Eil F{qrft t r $A GilqTt qq fr-dq erqr Gil-ifi rftflr or grsrfufoq Grr-ne{ yr qtE w E-t qrt mr er$tl fuqT .rqr t r 3 rqd fut 'ri gwffi*q .nn{T mr 5uq srrEr* t ft1 gnq. zsg /zozz d Hkn rdi d dym orr'fqo-.rq ft1 strwrft +6 t vfi Tw H+ilsnq ot qI{f,r ftr r& eft, fuH tg onnffi seT t 46,oo,oool-(Mfl eru) FT$ Brrr w 1,-{. Tw srrrErn onnfi rqd or Tsr QT \q frqil Tqf d qeqrd ffi +m- d gr$ Er ftqt_o. 2s-.03.2023 d

Page 2 of 9

3IR.q.;T. 07 / 2023 qrEzrrl t Vo UK sqrqn ffi6n frrt qrt of grqr 6 .I{, ffi ei-gsx 4,s9,oo,ooo/- (qrq mtrs s{r-d aru) sq$ t sm gK Hqrqn ffiffi fuqr .rqr en w qrtqr1wx onneo qe{ of 30.06.2023 cf6 trq vrRr q*n o,,{=TT QIT I il{rgffi onn{6 qa t TIRT qrn .ft or fr tr

4. qTer fr orfuoem fuqr q-qT t a1 fur-r6 2e.03. 2o2s o\ ror"r t GTfuq rd EIr .rrrT, fuE sf,snfr to. d oTk{ffir Hnr erBo-sur ol gs aea t erq.rfl TS orrql rrql at qerorft + $q fu{rE o-t H,T]EII"T g6 Ttr srrrErr=T dq{r d crgwrc dT g+l t w fffrtr

31. os.zo2s o\ sri{t{ qa i H*IIEII"T trRT o-r 50 sfurd qqr rfr or lcqr t, etrqefl oihq orr*T qrRf, frt{r qFTI TerFId fuqr 51 ffiITTT gT, cterfl BTkfi-{q HTr frq .r} M t ftq M fuqr qT wFaT erTt

5. wr-d HTgT fr qi-qro sH Hrgr Gtfrq oil-asr t frqqm trcIfl ZE d Gril,td oTIEIR fuqr .rqr B o1 frf,r tfr .h{i{ 01 Tq funfi 30.11 .2011 e\ d qfi q{ vn-d smsrffit a'r ds fsn"s frfu ifrn fuqr urqT "TEq err t frT GTt-'dEo qeT HNI slkfiittr d eil-kT fuffi 17.12.2020 d Gi-gslr o,oo,oool-(d drsl qrd rwn) vri fffi-f, os.o1 .2021 o'I urril fuql rrrfl w otilRq ontgr $Trft sTT, frrsfi-t vf,wrft il6 d qTBqf, GTffi grr ffiiq{ fuqT.rqr G ffiff frq.q qTt + qrq-q t ff€q th1 .r$ sqfu or &t{h? qffi( frrqr rt-rlT I

6. orid{r stT grt gr{Thaton oil-nfi t rrcffid qrqgeTdi + qttz-q t oTfurfi frtqr q-qt t fu B-f,.qrft to or eil-q{ul oqd at *'ft ti enor t, fuq

Page 3 of 9

3nN.q.;T. 07 / 2023 rrrrr qrRf, eifu entyr tfrifi 06.04.2023 grtTtrden oT 3ilTrftT frrt qrt drrq t t

7. emwrft +fi d Hrrr grqTmer 3Tl-ilfi \q frdq flqr Gnilfr o-t yQro-yerfr ctelq lrqf, frrql rrq[ t t qr.r fr ffi dor Arqr fr y*ro srq rqo t t B. sf,srft tfi d argr fdf,q flqr ontfi s-t w{-q rqd or sfuqrE fuqr .rqr t *1 rrq+ffi gdd 2ooz d oto.Td gilTffian or o-Y$ ftqH TS t \rq rTHftq q. s.wr qrqrrq d iln rrrtq ftft.r dEft frsa Aq, tiGR (zoro) 3 w.ft.sd.d. t qren fr 'dtot qm+q S.em.q.fr. dt f+srhqloq uht qrRilm T€i t, trr {fl GTBfi{ur et fi 3tilTmtm.q a1 vrRrrm sIkT T€t +{r ril-;rT qr"TT ilEg t

e. qrq fr erq6 m .d t o1 ftqq s-( (z) Sem.

a. ffiw tG 1ee3 d srqqmrgsn furtRf, Trrrrl frr d otil gilTffieE oTtdfi eqd r€t fuqr t, wEfu Gtfrq oTrtqr fuIr6 06.04.2023 sTkf,{ur at Ws qq frqiq 06.04.202g ei oTrdrs d Aor en G fu{ro B.o4.2o2s o'r fr:gm sfr dqn dt T+t eft t vicrwrfr t-6 o'r fr{i-6 13.04.2023 e\ ft:gm' sft srq dr .d eft, re orififr sfl erQtrrT oTi{t6 qe{ d erftqffir o1 w{rq{rfr eft fu fr:gm sh sTBff{q a1 ffi t rrrqT ?Da *i t

10. Btnwrft sqT Er{r Gilqfu fr T$ t o1 eil-tqr qTRf, *t t 30 fu{fl + qwkT rq-fl fuqT rrqr glumol Gil-il({ ei-qB qrfuf, t \rq qmftq s@Tq " .tnrrrEt-q EnT €qsd qr& t6, f{sq r"T.vnA.fr fuftes fuffd GTftd t'qr sor 1 zozo frfttr{fg'1 d GrgHR grrTme=T otTilfi fr fdf,q erril ori a1

Page 4 of 9

3Tl{.9.=i. oT / 2023 eTRoTRilr rS t r gfr oilEr{ q{ frHEq eFil onffi ftrK frd qri or ergtq fttqr .nn t t

11. B-f,r-qrft to grr gilTffieE oil-nfr o-r Yerfr t w{-q rtrf, erfr gq eil-qfu m .r{ t at moft qa HRI fuim 27.02.2023 o'r go g{f, Hqrqrq rwrq to d sqer rqf, frt-qr ril, ffi fqw t erf,r qrft eftt etco: fuIr6 zg.oa.zo2g et 4,s9,00,0 oo / -(qTr, mts s*rd aro) $Tn & trkTTtl TftfiN frtqr rrq[, ftmEi fto-q FrU-qe d qrurq t sIH nRr HFryfua rS[ efr, ffi frTq fr +n qrEft-de sncqTfr Eqro z d qm q f{qr qT Tol Qr I HIeI fr erkoem t fu gs.q. zse / 2ozo fr oifrq ild gt qrt + qqqrn eir.fr.gn. ffi wt fuirfr 2s.os.zozs qtt $il Qr I [fl Q-Rur vf,{qTfr t{ d oTBilqilr d srTef ffiD d +tr{ Bm oea t GTRoisr ot er+tro o-{t-i mr dr$ GFNN r$t QT, qfrm d]qn +fl fuIrf, 2s.o3.zo2s et Yrd Eqifr r d Grgsrr eTkfiwr or etfrq sTtvr eilElSf, en t

12. B-f,.{rft qa at oft t qa ,fr sfuqrc frrqrrqr t a1 GTfufi-{q Hnr gs.q. \q oif,Rq orfffi oI x"r dlq qr furf,-{q fuqT rrrlT t, Tq sil-ilffi geT o' gr{Tffiroq ortifi d qIEzlrI t v€ ffgstf q{ g{: Wrr{ srgfu T€i t, foE eIl-il{6 qs i qrE fr rilq srrflirq q6 g-flTmEFq olrtqq rq-a fr,-qr t, dI ffifr.qr€ti'r

13. Bd.qrft sH o-t sfo{rE t of {s erBosq ENT qTRfl Gifrq sil-tqr fuil?F o6.o4.2ozs q eH ts rselEff 1fr T€f t, Uil 5T(Tffieq o-r sIIEIr{ q-{ft d r gq sft elTEnrf q{ rq( STqThdftn 3rrnfi fuK frro qfi or eqtlq frtqrrqr t t

Page 5 of 9

3Trr.g.i. 07 / 2023

14. ffi ff,r Bd.{rft oqio z d Hrgr yQro Gm-q s-qd o.{t gq g-flrhfroq GIiffr or frtteT frtqr rr-rrT t r frtltr or Wq oilEn-{ t of w Tw srTIEIl"I nrTrtr frqd qa ft{ro 2s.os.2o2s et qrd + Gftrrfi{ ffifin fuqr .rqr t ri s'qtq qa t Gtfrq ontqr frqi-o 06.04.2023 engf, frt-qr t t qrRo entvr Rilfr oo.o4.2o2s qaNrerc{qqff@rStt 1s. s+FI qs d ild d *DIqT tf ftq sr{ ffiq s.tr.- (r),- qil ori{ffi s&I gM rEf, fdffi flrlr GTrilfi ffifin or grrTffifiq oil-ffr g"r dq w gt qfiqt"qt?

(z) ,- ?rqt sfl oTEfi-rq HRI w.g.2se / zozo fr qrRf, Gifrq qTeqr fr{rfi o6.o4.zo2s gwrmaE qa GTTTTFT frd qri q}.q t ?

16. ua $enfuo frft t qfr frnft fi ffiq rDwI fi qR frdq $T IrFT ffiq t, ni eq-rrfl: ftaq mqr o1-ilfi or ft{rftT"r Gil-ry{o +f,r t t {fl oTkf,wr t on-ilffi qa Hr{r fra*o erqr sniEq lqf, frril t, o-rsrr a1 {s sTBffir"r gr{r vfl.q. zsg / zo2o t qrRf, sTfuq Gniyr fur'rfr 06.04.202s d |fitr f+rrfr M.o7.zozs et grqTmal sil-nco wgf, fuqr q-il t, qi so gqs o1 Gn-qB d qrqrf, rqf, Ecrr t, wqfu ftqq 5-q (2) tqu ffi fa{Fa (trtrw) se 1ee3 d smrmrgsn fiG--d EqRfl dr mq qq-ft sTkfi-{rr HNr qrRf, GTrkT d ftt-€ 30 fffH d si-{r :fvrffior nq-d ovt or eirr-{N trEr"T fuqr qqr t t ?rqfr silc{rft s&r e1 q6 silqfu t e1 vffi r're zooz d sir.f( g-{qTffior or qf,$ fdqn Tff *i t Grrtno se{ grr rqr y$mnq ffiq rS t, fuE {s sqi{ t qs +o

Page 6 of 9

3[R.9.=i. ot / zozt o-t rf, t of qmr fi (?) s{Sffi vffi 2ooz d eTotrr+rgwrc Turiq-fr oTfuf,wr o) TrrSffi yqe 2oo2 d ffd nqd m Tn Gnilfi 61 ftqrfiwr ern.S.S. fr. Sqe 1ee3 t oplo yrqETrq} W ffi d ergo-q ffi qri of q|.ffi rqr{ qft.d tl gs EMlur t ftd o-t mI t fu qq qxr fi s{Sqft yqu 2oo2 d Gi-il'fd u-qn *t qrA orr'dfi or furrowr eq-S oTkw"r d arsr fuqr uilror t, rq qlRf, GThq sTrtqr d f*w em. s.fr. gdd 1ee3 at qxr 22 (z) (0 d srqETnrgrrl qrRf, sidfrq Gretq eifrq sTrtyr d fut-q gflrffimr ol-ilfr qr fr-trn mri of erffior srq t, fug fu( fi fifrd qk o\ mqq s-q (z) S. enq.O. (ffiqq) if,c^H 19e3 d srqqmrgffi 30 R-{fl + oiw gilTffior snffr r*g-d oFTT ermqrd t r

17. {fl xrtrT fr siltno qa t T€q w fr q6 orrErn filqr t at oil-f{o-wr a'r offu oil-evr of ft:gm sfr fqi# sFF HRr iRil T€f ftt .r$ I {n or{q frdq effir frrS qfi qt.q t r gs ild d inqefq fr qmftq 0. erng.fr. {f,rflqrE ENI oTfrd oqio- z'ta/zo'tg * fo, ofrrr cflIft{rfl erq d nor"r t qrRfl ftufq k{o 1s.o2.zo2o qn HEffif, fuqr .rqr t t eiq {fl sqrf fr qs srffiq t fu vf,{qrfr +o. d grr rqf, frtq Tt siltt $ qput t sfuqrc frrqr rrqr t of oTfrq eil-aqr fuIr6 o6.o4.2ozs tht ft:go eft f+no B.o4.2o2s e'r dq{ dr T+t aft, E} sil.qrft il6 d aru ftlqrfi B.o4.2o2s o] srw oq fr .r$ eft, fu=g orrilEo qel d Erqt oTemr oil-i(6 qa d srfurmr aqr ft:gm vh eIkT T& fuqT q fr ffi

o) strrld evl-qT et s+ ft:gm sfr srw o{i or ft{qr r€f B't

18. qR oil-}eo sef t gilTffiaE qIilfi d HTeI ft'go eft at at{ qft €dn{ TS tht 'r$ E'rfr, Tq I 3rR.g.q. 07 / 2O2s qRRTffi ft-q aw t ergqtFd of qr sfrft eft, fuE Gil-nEo sn t (\+ffi em.g/ro) d ss q dr eifrq oil-tvr H{m 06.04.2023 et sft qif,.q fuqr t, qE GrRoqrT gM frr6 e.o4.2oz3 o'r tqn et T{ \q furr6 8s4.2023 dr ffi oqio. s77 d qnqq t Hdet a1 q-$, frgm' sfr t I 1e. gq qRRQTfuf t qa wE t e1 grfrerqoat qeT d gxr sTBorq t fuirfr 13.04.202s o'I ffi tg dqTr ft:gm' sfr srw fuqr tq y+nffiroq sil-n{q d HTgT fidr{ fi ftrqr t, f+=g frf,q t sfrfrrfr qrq ori o-r GilEn-{ FrtFT fuf,q erqr frr} qrt q-r ergtnT frrqr qT rEr t t gq qRRQTfudr fr ftd e-r qcT t of qq fum fi.04.202s oi ft:gm sfr rilq frti qrt tg t+tY d T+1 sft. ffi ftft t orTitr e77 rR H€r frri qfi tg d o1 qr T+t eft, dq qR sil-fqin qa t urr{flo{ fuf,q t ft:gm sft yrkT fuqT t, c[q qTt+o qel a\ vq ftq qRRQTffit tf n-{ftq 0.ernq. E gorgrqrs ffrr srflril oqio zro/zorg €e to' ofrq. Etrsqr frsa ffilfi{rfl qq cr=q fr drfua frutq fuirfr 1s.02.2020 g 6p+1iftn rS fuqT on soor I

20. q6r ilF grrTfrEirftE sn-ilfi fr qxr 5 rrrfEr orBfu{q o1 srdrqf,r o-r rrwr t, sf,wrft t-r Hr$ fuilq nrrr oTidfr tnr FdT yfu sFil{rq m=G gq qmftq wrilq arrnErrl HnT ftffd oTftd =iqr so't /zozo N qr& tfi ffg.q \.r.w.a.fr. fuft& .fr. ors ti effi{n qftTn d riEffiT

Page 7 of 9

ort g3 Gil-qfu cd oqqr t o1 qTil 22 (2) €) em.S. fr. g+e d eier.fd nqd dri qr& grqTmoq eirilc fr qmr 5 qqfqT sTBftm d sFxETH qrdw =r& t r {s ftufq of ops*, r+ t qr+fu sqilT qrrrrEnr d arsr fr .d qnqr d erg$T{ fu{q s-y d errETrfrrfi' yrqErrr}

e qrt.g.T. 07 / 2023 d norsr fr so fu{s t qt ryn gruffiFnl urt6 q funEq sqr frrt qfi e1 eTkilRil. r& t'r

21. sq qRRerfut q {n ftd o-r ro t qft onilffi srT HRr siqf, Wvrmoq eil-aEn Grqfu qrkf, t w w eTBnwr of mqq 5-s (2) S.em.0. (eitrw) frqq 1ee3 d edq (q sreT fr qrflftq wlcrT qrqrf,q Ergr fufra erfta oqrfr srel 2o2o qmftq $qilq arqtorl EnT frfra qfia =iq( ool /zozo €lqd En& tf, fldio-{ w.\rw.0.fr. frfre (zozo) 13 \ry.fr.fr. 618 q ar{ro-q d qrqqgiil qtrdn ot-orqtFa q..rf+s ffi fr. +rz q sffiff oTftffi erqffiq tr

23. oTidro sfl t flTftq wFT RITTIIEI-q d EnT ftfra oTftd #t qaza/ 2o2s Tt{r qn6 1ni er.q frsq rilE< frfa \rq q-q t dIRn ffiq furc 24 En-$ 2oz3 of Hqffid m-{n gY frdq trrTl GrTtfr {+flT art o-t Grj{)u fuqr t r {fl trq q WT GIrfl rrrd ori gq {fl fie or ro t ft1 qm+q sailq d.llq lc'ltl e-r wm ffiq frfi-srd RIFdf, {d =icn s\/2oo2 fr qlRf, trq forrr 01.10.2002 t sf,lET oTfrfl t sqkd t, .ilqfu Es sTBo-{q d sqe{ ua 5rgrffirol on-ilfi tINI 22 (z) €) em.S.ft. v{d sdqfrffi fufr s-\ (2) S.em.0. (efu) vffi 1ee3 t wBo drt q}fud trq fub zr \ili{ft 2o2o g sffi{n orfun d xF'RI fi qTtffi seT grtr rqf, fuffi trrlr Gn}H ffi +.q =rfr t'r

22. ue genFn frft t of funq t rqo fuqr rrqr Gil-ifi/erfra/qrq frqK mr f{qT qrhr, ,rd fr fuifi qs d Ergr iftrc or yfuqn q fuqr .rqr dt, us H-<.+ fr qm+q $qilq qrqrf,q Hrtt qlrftq sqilq

Page 8 of 9

3TR.q.t'. 07 / 2023 d tnrwr Gil-n{6 qeT o:r {s *FwT t sm qqEETdi fr+16r&ffit

24. gq qRReTfui t us fts or qo t o1 qq eil-fffi sH grrr sqf, gilTman srttr{ erqfu ilBa t \q frffi flqr eil-il{q ffi q}.q rS t, Te Gil-ilro qeT HRI trqf, frti .T$ gr{Tffial en-'fi{ of g"r dq .N qrsr rfr at qT Hfift I zs. rmrsrtrT erfffo qer gm sqd fff,q sqr enilEq frrK fuqT qror t r HTer fr qa fr'qfRf, ori gq qft grrrffio.T eTt'ffi erqfu qTfua t r trqf, crr.\.q. ot / zozs GrqE qrBa drt d oxur yr dtv w fi+qrq frrt fu{r fr fr{w frrqr qror t r onivr @ vr+ro+ fr enq fr{rfr B.os.2o2+ d q}fud fuqr I 'yv o

.0v' q-fld5r fuio:-r 3.03.2024 q-ae) fiorfr{ GTffi, S.ern.fr q.q.w uftsrrs

Page 9 of 9

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead