Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals

MS PATEL TIMBER COMPANY vs STATE BANK OF INDIA on 14 October 2024

gq. q. Tq<-18 / 2024 *-Irr qEfr 3Tk6-{"r \il{mgr (q c Tq o-ffiw6 vrw) (ffir{ qffi - qmfiq afr srq ft{rfl q}d) gq. q. ;iqt - 1gt/2024 trld Eq{ oq-fr, sz rflEqfr Trrt, Et-dTqrc I q,rc ,Tr$ q-f,, ft-dr w. rrfr .Trg qld, e). q--a Es{ srq-ft, srr-n{6 o-qio r. z Em:-qrro q}6 97 qlrc .il{ q}d, G{rg 44 s$, (qfurd Fq t) ,rrm qr$ qld 3flT E{-fr ,il{ tr}a of qrs{ G{Tq' 3rdrfr des, qdr- 28 frisTrE oHfr gIeiIEIrc, qtg s'-lPT 481001 qtc zsz+sa0727, g42b4o2s6s, Pateltimberpohari ce@gmai l.com .Jl tq qo{luT fr-w tt_c ilfi 3Trq. qRqr tsfrq cra,frq-d efrfu-s l+q-q qrn, q.rflgr 6rgt- qlkqd erffi sbi. I 0008@sbi.co.in,sarc jabalpur@sbi.co.in r}c +6 on F sfu-qr e],dlEle ql-q, fudr qTarqrd,vq.fr. gRr IIrBqd eTffi sbi.003 I 8@sbi.co.in, +ft dgaffi d Aq +iq{,qili e63ooe43s1 q-fqTq qil gxr qdqn qrEed srffi, T{rd dlq qrme fu-a HrFrrs ft-ar * eictrfi 13-wsl-{, 799777 18s4, {-td rrurar*ae@yahoo.com, qrd +d-r 27 v+ffi-d Ersrr trs-srdrqrd,(\qfi) *qrq s-Ss"{ qrdTErrc, o-+fl-{ oH, qrarqE, quqqepT 481001, dmbalaght@nic.in

J.

Page 1 of 10

\rq. q. nq718/2D24

6. . 4qrq .n{s-d erffi ffiq sfqrq qi{sE qloilq-e, oT-qfdq EftuT HFIrq qrrisd qrefiElrc qt{trtcr 481001

7. ,iqq g-q-qiir{6 EIFITEITC. 6rqid-q sq-q-$-qo, qrcnqrd, qqr&T 481oo1

8. efrqn emr $il-fr 6ffi, qnr qTFTTE[e, qta-rrtYT 481001

e. fr.l-{ gfr."tl orefters', q+q-q fuor eratq[e, qqr]cr 481001 . . sorqr*qq onn{o o-qi6 r vs 2 s-d q-}d tqs o-qft o1 riifl sfrs VdT-ff d--"GT qrro qla rro: t Grcriffi ilf, d fuq sfr ft-fo grcr erfu+wr I si-fl-n{6 o-qio + ffi ddT rrqrd ftTd {r-wsn d ft\ dt crftd-o orqcnd erfuq-mr t oiftq eir&r Cfii6 14.10.2024 d qlB-d)

3il4-{o. E-rTr furm 30.03.2024 6) q6 trmrur qr{r 22 (z-fr) erx.S.ftV{d 1ee3 vracBd F-qq 11 \q 2 w$-{fr $Rl 2002 d !-rqqnJ d 3rd.f-d g-{gd o-{d Eq sfl 3rrf6-i.U.r dRr vsq. 324/2020 q qiR-d 3TrarT fuj6 24.1j.2o22 zF) tr-{sd tg ftd sri or eTStq fu-qr .rqr t r

Page 2 of 10

\rq. g. ;tw-fi/zozc

2. rrgo eirilr< or crdq gs n+x t fu ffi{ oiDif,rft gm entcr o1 znkfir +a d z16 {$-o-ri fu-qT rrqT t fu il6 i fuo.'q sTffi fr Zfu qr1 t fur fi 3il-ie6 qa o) za,u,ooo/- (ol.idrfir ars ffir+ rwx rqt) o1 t_{rA q-gi or en*er frqi.rq B q\ qrq r+rrf, r-& t u-qfu qtft-6 sr-qrq Wf 3il-ipT d qc-dn 4o,oo,ooo / - (qrft'fl aru vq|; o1 otlfr of Gil-s it 3nn{fi d qfudr-i ;61 56tnts (uw .nt-s srd) of .fi q T-qrFqT i q-qrq zh-qr 61 fu"ql t gq Xftd 3rfrq 3ir+n d oiqq fuqr {T-s{q r€il d ilo zp6q,B6 d em of .r$ .iuo, rrqfu o1 ffi M, {fuRfl flqTil{uT 3nR eidu orffi d dsT dfro or ftqr g '

3. Gil-iffi sel ol zrd fi eiftoem t fu n-6 odqtfr gs gfi'qra ffi ddT s-tr{qrft oqio + i fta os R'Tm fi.04.2024 o\ ffi frtrtfuo or z o-i_.s (d o-its sq-d) ut eqfu o) qn 6.2i Erq d ffi w rS B yq t'o offi i {frq ft-d t qa qrqfu o\ aer o-s +ft +-{ fu{i i' vq r+rilco oqro + t 3rq-i srrs Eld d o q[qffil { s-f,r frqr B t gfu-tT eisfter-o t Rrnq-a fr G, fu-d 6llcilUlc of$ 6Tffir qfr 01 qr rS t r orsoT fu qF-d sntpT d or<q gfffJ g-d t-f, o1 rtETfril rrq-g r-S t q_qfu ilf, d e--d t+Efrrd'e q .fi rg-rm fqs Tq rful$ q {d rfi urm ;rw ft-q t, q-gwffqT ftq t, as {Ertf TS o1 qr rro-ft r wq fr Grqfu d .r$ t fu s-+f,er rrr{s dd-{ e Bqfu or Xor+r fu-qr qrfl "TR\, ffi w-v-fr-o-o d am ffi

Page 3 of 10

\rq. q ffi7-18//2D24 dor rrq-r-d fti-e vrworq o) .rnr q-ilqri d s-Etrq t 3rdq Yfrrr* of .T{ t gs q.sTft d ari wr*fl o{ Tdfl r{PtT ftvq$ ts c-{ B16 sft-q fui ol XF o) frvq$ t-s ii ao 4es $-cr rerfi tr-d fuo zns rcra cfuifi frqT I

4. snneo qei t qa d) 3tfr6an fuqT t fu TE zh1 "-gwiqr yq driqrq. ol w-r-f,rfi o) fulT m-s vfur* o1 .T{ q} orilEr ++r qtqEre B, fu-g orfBq,-i"T ar{t .f,it frrd .d qF-d qTerT t crli{fi qel d qMi 6T Cfu-o 3{BoT{ firT t qqfu ffi

o) frwfl frrd qri an q-qiw ernnq B wqfu fr-fl rrq{q rsaTr d "-gqfiTr {+Tq r-& t \'q "-giifiqr d orn-q fr T@16-{ €.rq rfr t, fuE t-6 d crD-Ed 3rffi d sm dsy$ ilffi ri Ee-{frd flEITfr o-ffi of Grffi g@ d rfi o-ft or cn-${ 6) eTfr fikd o1 Ti 1 g< enurtr tr{ slfufl q-dTq-dT or et-gtq fr-qr rqr t r u-rgo ftd .ri qil-q d qrtqq 1) fr-frq 3rd<l 6T cfrqrc o-{d gq 3rrqfu Fft T{ t fr gs 3rlqil"T rr<T gug 324/2020 q 3iT+pT em.S.fr. vf,c 1ee3 d H-qtrrd d fff, qrkd c d-i d oRU.r rTrrr zz(r)(fr) em.$fr gqd 1ee3 d qr-drr-{ o{rotrd q-S *d t vnsT fr 3ilqfu A .Tg B fu Vq.q. c-qd o-{, ysq. o) g+wffuo H qrq or ot{ frqT-{ TSr i u-qfu 3nt{r f{rTo 24.11.2022 d e-5rm vsq grT ds w frirm5 ol ,r-$ t r

Page 4 of 10

gc. g. ?-q<18/2024

6. sf,{qrfr q;Tb' 1 t z d gNT ofl-qfu d G t fu rr{o Vqq qM"q r& t qfr6 ?TR Gil-iEE qeT ot-t'lpT ffi6 24.11.2022 t fti .Bd t a'r vr\ sft=f, q)-{q d rrqa Grfid rigf, o-$rT en qsfu 3{rt{r vFdo-r ft-{m 24.0s.2024 d er-grm 3Trd-c-6 i ot{ 3Tfid nrgo r& fu-fl t I

7. s-f,rqrft +-6 d il-{r oB+reTq trcnar u-gn o-ri g\ e-{gd frhq 3iln-<-q qM'q c-€l Et-i d entns w frrr< frd qd or er5tv fu-qr rrqr t r

8. sm-<_fl-fr qirq q i eiq+r 3{ErI GcttEr u-rgd 6-{i gq 3ilqfu d .r{ t fu qr}c6 cei o) emT 18 rlqffi \-€ zooz d ur+mryn erfr-a c-rgd 6-r+r en, fu-d gqmrm-{ srd6 r-t1o mri ot ot{ f+nq l-fr t I nrgo oil-}qo frtr G ooil o-lrrdcr 3rk{q-{ ovd g-s ffir fr"{ft qrE 6l-{"r d nrgd fuqT .rqr t u+fu nflq ft'-f,q or-ffi d q'Rur:mrgsq furm fi.02.2020 o) ft-6s q-{ d Fqlcq Vq ffio 1e.03.2020 C ffiqq d cTq fi fr--6q 6l-ffi Ti E) qrfr B r nrer fr 3ilqfu A r{ t f,+- 3il-d<-6 qel rrlq'gvt erzr) t 3TBo-i!T d rrqa q-fi-{o-i qrT T& frrql t n-q g-d g-{qd zrr 66 TS B E-s ild d rrqe.tc t qrf,fiq sqf,q anrnErq ERI N nRe-q dr{:c-s fdft--s fr-s-€ rtc f6 Ss Sqrzoqz r-edgn. w.fr.sqjqso t cffid fu€ro o) rr-<ffid o-{fr gq csw n sftdfud opd d 3ilrTn s{ Gtr}Ec fuflT m qd or 3r5tq fuqT 31

\rq. \. nqr18/2024 e. 3il-is-m. ceT i ts_f,r-drftTur +1 3rli i} e-{go ftrd Td u-sr+ s-{ ft-il6 22.08.2024 qr} Rwr{si u-go o-rd gq c-rgd ccn-{q Ta 3ilifi t qFf-o oed d eirqrv q{ Xq ds w friroarT *i or erffian fuqT t r r+rQr fr R-flo. ot.ol.2o24 6) ncgo fu-d Td MGr d qnqq t *A *r* 1 vq z trM c-rEd fud Tn qqrq ol cFilqrE o.-{d gq Td 3trie{ q qFh oui d 3r-Jsc s-orqrfi d-o ErT of n-g offi G ls 3rBo-i!T gt-iT qftd oil-isr 6i q$d q-ild gq 3Tv.tr sel {sT ,rqn t t

10. seFkT: zra vdqftq t fu gs 3rBft-irr d avr {rr q-m-{ur q wkd oiltpT Hro 24.0s.2024 d mqq r\ qg qtr q-m-e fu-qT TqT t fu-carq-d, ur-6 fr-E ffiq t fu gs. oiBh-inT arur qR-d eil.tyT Hm 24.i1.2022 d frw furro 30.03.2024 o) qqd q6"ffiq q-m-{"r rqT Xur ds w gi qri +s t, v+rq fr qftd 3iltpT fuflo 23.01.2024 of Grfrq o.kmT t fr cqw fu-qr rqT t fo. frEq end-6q 61 qMqnT G rrqq '{filrt d fu-g w erni.ur grr or}qr r 1i. sifrq ild d dRrc fuflo. zs.og.oz+ o) sTri<o qeT gmr lqfl: q-qd fu-A r-d dfu"o ild d qqq t 3rftoarc fr-qr rrql t fu 3r]-]@ cel gpr c-{gd \rs.y 416 / 2014, W.q. 142 / 2o1s 3rerqT 324/2ozo q qFr Wdfl yq orDq-rq qn+r o1 dtl-m o-r rri frqrm5 r& geri B r

Page 5 of 10

\rc. q. nE7-18 / 2024

12. rnq fr e-d vqr .Tqr t fu gs srko-{"r trr<r gug 324/2020 t qrfud .n-qpr ms z+.rr. zozz I s-<rEqrfr t-o' o1 ffi orffi of frts fuw qrm .rqr fu-{ fi oil-ilq-fi q-d w 2,84,so,ooo / (d ois ffi drcr q.rlql e-wr w-i) d g.rdlc 01 yrd 3ni\fr-a o'v fr .r{ r g{ o-n'rt .1 q5 ffiu 3il-a-{q r*go fu-+r .rq * q\ rrqq {tqr d or-fl t't 'r3. sm-{dTfr qel of 3n{ i} ngo frd nd dfu6 d-d d 3r-J$R 3rrqfu d Ti t fu u-qn frfuT sna-fi rffi d.q rS t r erilro ca o) g-+qr$ 6-I Em' ttq rfr t r

14. 3rri@ ca t fr{r6 30.0s.2024 6} ffrfud ad nrgo fuuT t ffi qrtqq r\ sc-r+fr tm asr rh1 .r$ oTffir oi qFd elfl rm-d ovd gq c-{g( frfrq 3nffi rfifl{ frd qri or orgtq ft-q-r rrql trrnq fr

l. ;iTi i2lo/2o1s gq-+q psR ft-s-d afi-d-flq cko. HFfs o-fr{H q crR-d srTerT ffi6 10.04.2019 of qfr !-{gd o-{ 3rqi'T qeT rel B t

15. grr erffm-{ur d rrqer qQrq 1ffiq qr{ .:\ A,- E lcp - aqr entElo. EM c-qd ftfrq sTrtfi srq frc d sr-fl *o.v gq ds ri fi$ufrq t?

16. q-6 frffif, oeq i fu 3na-{fi ceT i q..6 frfrtr q-fi-{q {s 3rtso-wT E-M g'{T.g. oqT6 324 / 2ozo M q-|d ftqs Ts 3i-q fffi-q rlc il*- dtr gET Ts erq S qR-d 3ifrq orTtqT f,firo

\rq. q nE7-18/2O24 24.11.2022 o) srqr-ro or orftq rq r\ friTef, Tfi-{sr gs.g. 324lzozo d ga: vrfr 1E +{i tr{ {arft-f, ftrd qri oi ergtu fu-qr t r

11. 3il-i<-o. qa i qrtT 22 (r-O sw.g.ff. gqe 1ee3 d crrar ftqq 11 vq 2 ErSrft vdr 2002 d ql-qqrn o-r s-de .nrd gv 3rrle{ u-*gn fu-or .rq.I Bt

Page 6 of 10

qEt frkfr fterfr w sti fr-qn Tfr t fu qq GrftsrfllT d 3ic-i dpr crft-d en-tv7B"1q 6 f+trfu-A-o-c of pTM qtvr 22 (r-fr) erx.S.fi\.f,e rggs d or-f,.fd c-fl-{ o1 ,rE trq-erDft'qq 1i gq z w${fr $Rr 2oo2 d crsqc qrr frhq enil6q 6 ft\ $TrTd =rS d r 1e. {s' 3rtsilq 6} 3rqi fr 3rrerT 6-r gcyTfu-d-oq o-{i of of-{ q-{ftF-ir yrfu crw r$t d qfu entcl +z ft{rq r fifr.{ft d cTsilr} d trT fu{fr fi qrqrErr C arc-i fi stTerT o-T grmznc o-G of u\ {ftB-a pTfril-qT c-fl-{ $t G d, sift qqfqT q {d-d gy ill orBo-irT o) .fi grtr-d-mq qfr pTkrqi Hq. t ersTfd qrR-d oil-lyr ffipT qfr 3rftq-dT o) qqqrfuo .nEi or Em-, {fl. erD6r"r o) q-& t ld fr qrR-d 3rTerT ZE Trf E) q6r ech fu qrfud 3rTerT q q-ilfl{yff Ztr qM$-f, c elr

Page 7 of 10

qmfrq B@dq -q lq lci {.1 il-{t S€i wffi ft-'s-d rfc frF 3i-al (zor+) s g{r.S.fr. zs t q'6Eq-cRqfrGtfu

gq. q. Tqt-18 / 2024 c-cset-Ecff ZB d 3rrlq q qIR-d trq oTerdr enirT fr Scv.frdo.q 61 3Ttrlr{ TS E\ rr-+TT qs qrkd o{dyr of oifrTdr 61 M rfr fuqT uil qthfl | cFq -qlqtwlcl orsT{h1 tfr fr€ ec mF 1ff. (zors) 8 wr.fr.fr. 8! q qm+q sqilq ;qrflaru or *ro t fu SilTA-ci-{-{ erffior A 3trT aa entu t efifufua M o] Td fut t qfrerq q-fr fu-qr GT stndl I ld fr tqT M eifta znr e+rqn e) vro-or elr

21. d qq gr+ srkE{q 6[<r grg 324/2020 q 3ifrc afltrT ft-{r-6 24.11.2022 q'Rd s-{d gq ft-rorgTfo ir'.fr oeid 6t qrqq.T 6{i gg 3ifrq ftq.$ qrfufr fuio or e-*JT o{ 3iftq Frq-S fusr qzn t ss ftr-d Td ffiq ftq-{ it Ecft st c-.qer<rff Ztr Grr+eo seT fiFu q-tr w rnor ffi 3Trrrn qy qrR-f, GTftq crrepT yr-{Ifu-doq of cRB n oilTr E) nq q-d fr c{r}ffi qeT {s 3rfufi-{'T d st-frq 3TIATT t ftfu-d t fu-{ fi w eik+r"r d eqeT frfrEr sfl-iel q-rgd o-r crfud 3nepT ot oTq-rd frrd qti or ergtu Sciimfi-{ rrhf,qi d ffd o-$ or Em-il{ TS t qqfu w 3rfuo-{q d rm rtiffi \rrd 2oo2 zl1 qm rz(r) vlffi \rf,c 2oo2 d fff, agfr no-wr q crkd 3{frq oilepT d frw orDfr.qq of qm ra d ffn frB-d qkr o\ erfi-a u-qo o-r| qX qffier rfl-a qi ,r{ t r

22. EE-d 3rfrftfi q6 FqBo Reft fi s-ffiq t fu qm zz (z-fr) o{T{.S.fr.vflc rggs I

sTar 1rrd-fi q-{gd q-& *i w q-qd Gna-fi fiqq Ter fuql sr qriqr I wqfu sq frfrq end-6q 6 3il-iE-fi qa i erko-rq d 3n+pT ft-fl6 zqit.zozz d fus-€ fufffi 30.03.2024 C eiqfe d..!.rTrr 16 qrd

Page 8 of 10

Vq. Y tq-ta,/ zoz+ d srir{T gwffiot GTrnfi u-igd o.ri fu ftqq 5 y(2) S.enrd (fiqfi-q-i) re+ rgss d H-qqT-fl1TiT{ ordeT qftd +i t 30 frqr{ d 3r{i wel q-, d cqsrd q6 Afrq 3rr-ne{ nqd fu-qT .rqT B of:_d fr rrgf, G{id-<-{ q 3il-iEq q fu-s o-{ frfrq 3il4-({ fuel r-qT fu-g qrv zz (z-fi) enqg -a- qTyf,c rgss d qt-qqTq) mi sds ord gv 3il-iefi qeT i eq-inT !-{gd fuqT B q) grirh-d)sq 3rT-ne{ fr qrrr qCqT nq F-oq 5 q(2) SBrRA Fhft-qr) ae{j 1993 zF msilri d norsr t e{r-ililo seT il-{r q--{gd 3rTA-q-{ 3r-qfu ErB-d e}-ov yr AE w q}E!ftq fr c-S tl ZJ qTq+q sqilq ;qiqrdq E-M shmr otffiftq Ersffiq tuft-ls ftr-q nmr g M gs.fr.S.+rzdnorvrqfiG

qflslT d 3r5flr{ or-qD ilB-d oil-ile{ frwfl fuqT qrcT qrRI rd fr f,+tEr qa i vrqq cftqr 6T q-frsrE c fu-qT d r q-qfu Err q-m-wT d smrqTdqeT i rrq-q qftql ol cfrqTE fu-q1 g

24. C mr Grrd<o qeT il-il c-{gd 3Tr}c{ sIqD eTtsd B, X"r <)s w gi "Tri q),q r-& e"r rrer S eilf,qT a7 ftqq 1 {fi.fi.rfi. d crct]]r} d c-fiTpT d qrRd 3rhq entqr g-flTfu-doT zn1 aTmi

Page 9 of 10

Vq. q. tq<-'ta,/zoz+ o1 qRD t qfr B n-q Gr-ieo qeT FRr c-rgd gfl 3ra-<-{ q sffid oeqi oi X"r dv q{ qr{Brr r-Er ot qr rro-ft r zs. rrEfwsq 3il-ilil6 qe{ trm q-{gd fr'Aq 3IdEq Gr-qB orBa Eti d Xu <)u w gt iil.i d,q Mq c di i\ Gflf, frrqr qrnr t r

26. srq qe{ 3rrFil otqql a-q q5-q 6-l't t 3rrePT gd 'q lq lc4 q t 3Trq fu6 14.10.2024

o) erm'erRo, fuim us e}fr-d fu-qr TTqT I qqdgi, ffio 14.10.2024 2h \o (qTq q--d) ffiq 3rETmrfr S.erx.0.q.qyq u-ffiq.rd

Page 10 of 10

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead