Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
MS PATEL TIMBER COMPANY vs STATE BANK OF INDIA on 14 October 2024
gq. q. Tq<-18 / 2024 *-Irr qEfr 3Tk6-{"r \il{mgr (q c Tq o-ffiw6 vrw) (ffir{ qffi - qmfiq afr srq ft{rfl q}d) gq. q. ;iqt - 1gt/2024 trld Eq{ oq-fr, sz rflEqfr Trrt, Et-dTqrc I q,rc ,Tr$ q-f,, ft-dr w. rrfr .Trg qld, e). q--a Es{ srq-ft, srr-n{6 o-qio r. z Em:-qrro q}6 97 qlrc .il{ q}d, G{rg 44 s$, (qfurd Fq t) ,rrm qr$ qld 3flT E{-fr ,il{ tr}a of qrs{ G{Tq' 3rdrfr des, qdr- 28 frisTrE oHfr gIeiIEIrc, qtg s'-lPT 481001 qtc zsz+sa0727, g42b4o2s6s, Pateltimberpohari ce@gmai l.com .Jl tq qo{luT fr-w tt_c ilfi 3Trq. qRqr tsfrq cra,frq-d efrfu-s l+q-q qrn, q.rflgr 6rgt- qlkqd erffi sbi. I 0008@sbi.co.in,sarc jabalpur@sbi.co.in r}c +6 on F sfu-qr e],dlEle ql-q, fudr qTarqrd,vq.fr. gRr IIrBqd eTffi sbi.003 I 8@sbi.co.in, +ft dgaffi d Aq +iq{,qili e63ooe43s1 q-fqTq qil gxr qdqn qrEed srffi, T{rd dlq qrme fu-a HrFrrs ft-ar * eictrfi 13-wsl-{, 799777 18s4, {-td rrurar*ae@yahoo.com, qrd +d-r 27 v+ffi-d Ersrr trs-srdrqrd,(\qfi) *qrq s-Ss"{ qrdTErrc, o-+fl-{ oH, qrarqE, quqqepT 481001, dmbalaght@nic.in
J.
Page 1 of 10
\rq. q. nq718/2D24
6. . 4qrq .n{s-d erffi ffiq sfqrq qi{sE qloilq-e, oT-qfdq EftuT HFIrq qrrisd qrefiElrc qt{trtcr 481001
7. ,iqq g-q-qiir{6 EIFITEITC. 6rqid-q sq-q-$-qo, qrcnqrd, qqr&T 481oo1
8. efrqn emr $il-fr 6ffi, qnr qTFTTE[e, qta-rrtYT 481001
e. fr.l-{ gfr."tl orefters', q+q-q fuor eratq[e, qqr]cr 481001 . . sorqr*qq onn{o o-qi6 r vs 2 s-d q-}d tqs o-qft o1 riifl sfrs VdT-ff d--"GT qrro qla rro: t Grcriffi ilf, d fuq sfr ft-fo grcr erfu+wr I si-fl-n{6 o-qio + ffi ddT rrqrd ftTd {r-wsn d ft\ dt crftd-o orqcnd erfuq-mr t oiftq eir&r Cfii6 14.10.2024 d qlB-d)
3il4-{o. E-rTr furm 30.03.2024 6) q6 trmrur qr{r 22 (z-fr) erx.S.ftV{d 1ee3 vracBd F-qq 11 \q 2 w$-{fr $Rl 2002 d !-rqqnJ d 3rd.f-d g-{gd o-{d Eq sfl 3rrf6-i.U.r dRr vsq. 324/2020 q qiR-d 3TrarT fuj6 24.1j.2o22 zF) tr-{sd tg ftd sri or eTStq fu-qr .rqr t r
Page 2 of 10
\rq. g. ;tw-fi/zozc
2. rrgo eirilr< or crdq gs n+x t fu ffi{ oiDif,rft gm entcr o1 znkfir +a d z16 {$-o-ri fu-qT rrqT t fu il6 i fuo.'q sTffi fr Zfu qr1 t fur fi 3il-ie6 qa o) za,u,ooo/- (ol.idrfir ars ffir+ rwx rqt) o1 t_{rA q-gi or en*er frqi.rq B q\ qrq r+rrf, r-& t u-qfu qtft-6 sr-qrq Wf 3il-ipT d qc-dn 4o,oo,ooo / - (qrft'fl aru vq|; o1 otlfr of Gil-s it 3nn{fi d qfudr-i ;61 56tnts (uw .nt-s srd) of .fi q T-qrFqT i q-qrq zh-qr 61 fu"ql t gq Xftd 3rfrq 3ir+n d oiqq fuqr {T-s{q r€il d ilo zp6q,B6 d em of .r$ .iuo, rrqfu o1 ffi M, {fuRfl flqTil{uT 3nR eidu orffi d dsT dfro or ftqr g '
3. Gil-iffi sel ol zrd fi eiftoem t fu n-6 odqtfr gs gfi'qra ffi ddT s-tr{qrft oqio + i fta os R'Tm fi.04.2024 o\ ffi frtrtfuo or z o-i_.s (d o-its sq-d) ut eqfu o) qn 6.2i Erq d ffi w rS B yq t'o offi i {frq ft-d t qa qrqfu o\ aer o-s +ft +-{ fu{i i' vq r+rilco oqro + t 3rq-i srrs Eld d o q[qffil { s-f,r frqr B t gfu-tT eisfter-o t Rrnq-a fr G, fu-d 6llcilUlc of$ 6Tffir qfr 01 qr rS t r orsoT fu qF-d sntpT d or<q gfffJ g-d t-f, o1 rtETfril rrq-g r-S t q_qfu ilf, d e--d t+Efrrd'e q .fi rg-rm fqs Tq rful$ q {d rfi urm ;rw ft-q t, q-gwffqT ftq t, as {Ertf TS o1 qr rro-ft r wq fr Grqfu d .r$ t fu s-+f,er rrr{s dd-{ e Bqfu or Xor+r fu-qr qrfl "TR\, ffi w-v-fr-o-o d am ffi
Page 3 of 10
\rq. q ffi7-18//2D24 dor rrq-r-d fti-e vrworq o) .rnr q-ilqri d s-Etrq t 3rdq Yfrrr* of .T{ t gs q.sTft d ari wr*fl o{ Tdfl r{PtT ftvq$ ts c-{ B16 sft-q fui ol XF o) frvq$ t-s ii ao 4es $-cr rerfi tr-d fuo zns rcra cfuifi frqT I
4. snneo qei t qa d) 3tfr6an fuqT t fu TE zh1 "-gwiqr yq driqrq. ol w-r-f,rfi o) fulT m-s vfur* o1 .T{ q} orilEr ++r qtqEre B, fu-g orfBq,-i"T ar{t .f,it frrd .d qF-d qTerT t crli{fi qel d qMi 6T Cfu-o 3{BoT{ firT t qqfu ffi
o) frwfl frrd qri an q-qiw ernnq B wqfu fr-fl rrq{q rsaTr d "-gqfiTr {+Tq r-& t \'q "-giifiqr d orn-q fr T@16-{ €.rq rfr t, fuE t-6 d crD-Ed 3rffi d sm dsy$ ilffi ri Ee-{frd flEITfr o-ffi of Grffi g@ d rfi o-ft or cn-${ 6) eTfr fikd o1 Ti 1 g< enurtr tr{ slfufl q-dTq-dT or et-gtq fr-qr rqr t r u-rgo ftd .ri qil-q d qrtqq 1) fr-frq 3rd<l 6T cfrqrc o-{d gq 3rrqfu Fft T{ t fr gs 3rlqil"T rr<T gug 324/2020 q 3iT+pT em.S.fr. vf,c 1ee3 d H-qtrrd d fff, qrkd c d-i d oRU.r rTrrr zz(r)(fr) em.$fr gqd 1ee3 d qr-drr-{ o{rotrd q-S *d t vnsT fr 3ilqfu A .Tg B fu Vq.q. c-qd o-{, ysq. o) g+wffuo H qrq or ot{ frqT-{ TSr i u-qfu 3nt{r f{rTo 24.11.2022 d e-5rm vsq grT ds w frirm5 ol ,r-$ t r
Page 4 of 10
gc. g. ?-q<18/2024
6. sf,{qrfr q;Tb' 1 t z d gNT ofl-qfu d G t fu rr{o Vqq qM"q r& t qfr6 ?TR Gil-iEE qeT ot-t'lpT ffi6 24.11.2022 t fti .Bd t a'r vr\ sft=f, q)-{q d rrqa Grfid rigf, o-$rT en qsfu 3{rt{r vFdo-r ft-{m 24.0s.2024 d er-grm 3Trd-c-6 i ot{ 3Tfid nrgo r& fu-fl t I
7. s-f,rqrft +-6 d il-{r oB+reTq trcnar u-gn o-ri g\ e-{gd frhq 3iln-<-q qM'q c-€l Et-i d entns w frrr< frd qd or er5tv fu-qr rrqr t r
8. sm-<_fl-fr qirq q i eiq+r 3{ErI GcttEr u-rgd 6-{i gq 3ilqfu d .r{ t fu qr}c6 cei o) emT 18 rlqffi \-€ zooz d ur+mryn erfr-a c-rgd 6-r+r en, fu-d gqmrm-{ srd6 r-t1o mri ot ot{ f+nq l-fr t I nrgo oil-}qo frtr G ooil o-lrrdcr 3rk{q-{ ovd g-s ffir fr"{ft qrE 6l-{"r d nrgd fuqT .rqr t u+fu nflq ft'-f,q or-ffi d q'Rur:mrgsq furm fi.02.2020 o) ft-6s q-{ d Fqlcq Vq ffio 1e.03.2020 C ffiqq d cTq fi fr--6q 6l-ffi Ti E) qrfr B r nrer fr 3ilqfu A r{ t f,+- 3il-d<-6 qel rrlq'gvt erzr) t 3TBo-i!T d rrqa q-fi-{o-i qrT T& frrql t n-q g-d g-{qd zrr 66 TS B E-s ild d rrqe.tc t qrf,fiq sqf,q anrnErq ERI N nRe-q dr{:c-s fdft--s fr-s-€ rtc f6 Ss Sqrzoqz r-edgn. w.fr.sqjqso t cffid fu€ro o) rr-<ffid o-{fr gq csw n sftdfud opd d 3ilrTn s{ Gtr}Ec fuflT m qd or 3r5tq fuqT 31
\rq. \. nqr18/2024 e. 3il-is-m. ceT i ts_f,r-drftTur +1 3rli i} e-{go ftrd Td u-sr+ s-{ ft-il6 22.08.2024 qr} Rwr{si u-go o-rd gq c-rgd ccn-{q Ta 3ilifi t qFf-o oed d eirqrv q{ Xq ds w friroarT *i or erffian fuqT t r r+rQr fr R-flo. ot.ol.2o24 6) ncgo fu-d Td MGr d qnqq t *A *r* 1 vq z trM c-rEd fud Tn qqrq ol cFilqrE o.-{d gq Td 3trie{ q qFh oui d 3r-Jsc s-orqrfi d-o ErT of n-g offi G ls 3rBo-i!T gt-iT qftd oil-isr 6i q$d q-ild gq 3Tv.tr sel {sT ,rqn t t
10. seFkT: zra vdqftq t fu gs 3rBft-irr d avr {rr q-m-{ur q wkd oiltpT Hro 24.0s.2024 d mqq r\ qg qtr q-m-e fu-qT TqT t fu-carq-d, ur-6 fr-E ffiq t fu gs. oiBh-inT arur qR-d eil.tyT Hm 24.i1.2022 d frw furro 30.03.2024 o) qqd q6"ffiq q-m-{"r rqT Xur ds w gi qri +s t, v+rq fr qftd 3iltpT fuflo 23.01.2024 of Grfrq o.kmT t fr cqw fu-qr rqT t fo. frEq end-6q 61 qMqnT G rrqq '{filrt d fu-g w erni.ur grr or}qr r 1i. sifrq ild d dRrc fuflo. zs.og.oz+ o) sTri<o qeT gmr lqfl: q-qd fu-A r-d dfu"o ild d qqq t 3rftoarc fr-qr rrql t fu 3r]-]@ cel gpr c-{gd \rs.y 416 / 2014, W.q. 142 / 2o1s 3rerqT 324/2ozo q qFr Wdfl yq orDq-rq qn+r o1 dtl-m o-r rri frqrm5 r& geri B r
Page 5 of 10
\rc. q. nE7-18 / 2024
12. rnq fr e-d vqr .Tqr t fu gs srko-{"r trr<r gug 324/2020 t qrfud .n-qpr ms z+.rr. zozz I s-<rEqrfr t-o' o1 ffi orffi of frts fuw qrm .rqr fu-{ fi oil-ilq-fi q-d w 2,84,so,ooo / (d ois ffi drcr q.rlql e-wr w-i) d g.rdlc 01 yrd 3ni\fr-a o'v fr .r{ r g{ o-n'rt .1 q5 ffiu 3il-a-{q r*go fu-+r .rq * q\ rrqq {tqr d or-fl t't 'r3. sm-{dTfr qel of 3n{ i} ngo frd nd dfu6 d-d d 3r-J$R 3rrqfu d Ti t fu u-qn frfuT sna-fi rffi d.q rS t r erilro ca o) g-+qr$ 6-I Em' ttq rfr t r
14. 3rri@ ca t fr{r6 30.0s.2024 6} ffrfud ad nrgo fuuT t ffi qrtqq r\ sc-r+fr tm asr rh1 .r$ oTffir oi qFd elfl rm-d ovd gq c-{g( frfrq 3nffi rfifl{ frd qri or orgtq ft-q-r rrql trrnq fr
l. ;iTi i2lo/2o1s gq-+q psR ft-s-d afi-d-flq cko. HFfs o-fr{H q crR-d srTerT ffi6 10.04.2019 of qfr !-{gd o-{ 3rqi'T qeT rel B t
15. grr erffm-{ur d rrqer qQrq 1ffiq qr{ .:\ A,- E lcp - aqr entElo. EM c-qd ftfrq sTrtfi srq frc d sr-fl *o.v gq ds ri fi$ufrq t?
16. q-6 frffif, oeq i fu 3na-{fi ceT i q..6 frfrtr q-fi-{q {s 3rtso-wT E-M g'{T.g. oqT6 324 / 2ozo M q-|d ftqs Ts 3i-q fffi-q rlc il*- dtr gET Ts erq S qR-d 3ifrq orTtqT f,firo
\rq. q nE7-18/2O24 24.11.2022 o) srqr-ro or orftq rq r\ friTef, Tfi-{sr gs.g. 324lzozo d ga: vrfr 1E +{i tr{ {arft-f, ftrd qri oi ergtu fu-qr t r
11. 3il-i<-o. qa i qrtT 22 (r-O sw.g.ff. gqe 1ee3 d crrar ftqq 11 vq 2 ErSrft vdr 2002 d ql-qqrn o-r s-de .nrd gv 3rrle{ u-*gn fu-or .rq.I Bt
Page 6 of 10
qEt frkfr fterfr w sti fr-qn Tfr t fu qq GrftsrfllT d 3ic-i dpr crft-d en-tv7B"1q 6 f+trfu-A-o-c of pTM qtvr 22 (r-fr) erx.S.fi\.f,e rggs d or-f,.fd c-fl-{ o1 ,rE trq-erDft'qq 1i gq z w${fr $Rr 2oo2 d crsqc qrr frhq enil6q 6 ft\ $TrTd =rS d r 1e. {s' 3rtsilq 6} 3rqi fr 3rrerT 6-r gcyTfu-d-oq o-{i of of-{ q-{ftF-ir yrfu crw r$t d qfu entcl +z ft{rq r fifr.{ft d cTsilr} d trT fu{fr fi qrqrErr C arc-i fi stTerT o-T grmznc o-G of u\ {ftB-a pTfril-qT c-fl-{ $t G d, sift qqfqT q {d-d gy ill orBo-irT o) .fi grtr-d-mq qfr pTkrqi Hq. t ersTfd qrR-d oil-lyr ffipT qfr 3rftq-dT o) qqqrfuo .nEi or Em-, {fl. erD6r"r o) q-& t ld fr qrR-d 3rTerT ZE Trf E) q6r ech fu qrfud 3rTerT q q-ilfl{yff Ztr qM$-f, c elr
Page 7 of 10
qmfrq B@dq -q lq lci {.1 il-{t S€i wffi ft-'s-d rfc frF 3i-al (zor+) s g{r.S.fr. zs t q'6Eq-cRqfrGtfu
gq. q. Tqt-18 / 2024 c-cset-Ecff ZB d 3rrlq q qIR-d trq oTerdr enirT fr Scv.frdo.q 61 3Ttrlr{ TS E\ rr-+TT qs qrkd o{dyr of oifrTdr 61 M rfr fuqT uil qthfl | cFq -qlqtwlcl orsT{h1 tfr fr€ ec mF 1ff. (zors) 8 wr.fr.fr. 8! q qm+q sqilq ;qrflaru or *ro t fu SilTA-ci-{-{ erffior A 3trT aa entu t efifufua M o] Td fut t qfrerq q-fr fu-qr GT stndl I ld fr tqT M eifta znr e+rqn e) vro-or elr
21. d qq gr+ srkE{q 6[<r grg 324/2020 q 3ifrc afltrT ft-{r-6 24.11.2022 q'Rd s-{d gq ft-rorgTfo ir'.fr oeid 6t qrqq.T 6{i gg 3ifrq ftq.$ qrfufr fuio or e-*JT o{ 3iftq Frq-S fusr qzn t ss ftr-d Td ffiq ftq-{ it Ecft st c-.qer<rff Ztr Grr+eo seT fiFu q-tr w rnor ffi 3Trrrn qy qrR-f, GTftq crrepT yr-{Ifu-doq of cRB n oilTr E) nq q-d fr c{r}ffi qeT {s 3rfufi-{'T d st-frq 3TIATT t ftfu-d t fu-{ fi w eik+r"r d eqeT frfrEr sfl-iel q-rgd o-r crfud 3nepT ot oTq-rd frrd qti or ergtu Sciimfi-{ rrhf,qi d ffd o-$ or Em-il{ TS t qqfu w 3rfuo-{q d rm rtiffi \rrd 2oo2 zl1 qm rz(r) vlffi \rf,c 2oo2 d fff, agfr no-wr q crkd 3{frq oilepT d frw orDfr.qq of qm ra d ffn frB-d qkr o\ erfi-a u-qo o-r| qX qffier rfl-a qi ,r{ t r
22. EE-d 3rfrftfi q6 FqBo Reft fi s-ffiq t fu qm zz (z-fr) o{T{.S.fr.vflc rggs I
sTar 1rrd-fi q-{gd q-& *i w q-qd Gna-fi fiqq Ter fuql sr qriqr I wqfu sq frfrq end-6q 6 3il-iE-fi qa i erko-rq d 3n+pT ft-fl6 zqit.zozz d fus-€ fufffi 30.03.2024 C eiqfe d..!.rTrr 16 qrd
Page 8 of 10
Vq. Y tq-ta,/ zoz+ d srir{T gwffiot GTrnfi u-igd o.ri fu ftqq 5 y(2) S.enrd (fiqfi-q-i) re+ rgss d H-qqT-fl1TiT{ ordeT qftd +i t 30 frqr{ d 3r{i wel q-, d cqsrd q6 Afrq 3rr-ne{ nqd fu-qT .rqT B of:_d fr rrgf, G{id-<-{ q 3il-iEq q fu-s o-{ frfrq 3il4-({ fuel r-qT fu-g qrv zz (z-fi) enqg -a- qTyf,c rgss d qt-qqTq) mi sds ord gv 3il-iefi qeT i eq-inT !-{gd fuqT B q) grirh-d)sq 3rT-ne{ fr qrrr qCqT nq F-oq 5 q(2) SBrRA Fhft-qr) ae{j 1993 zF msilri d norsr t e{r-ililo seT il-{r q--{gd 3rTA-q-{ 3r-qfu ErB-d e}-ov yr AE w q}E!ftq fr c-S tl ZJ qTq+q sqilq ;qiqrdq E-M shmr otffiftq Ersffiq tuft-ls ftr-q nmr g M gs.fr.S.+rzdnorvrqfiG
qflslT d 3r5flr{ or-qD ilB-d oil-ile{ frwfl fuqT qrcT qrRI rd fr f,+tEr qa i vrqq cftqr 6T q-frsrE c fu-qT d r q-qfu Err q-m-wT d smrqTdqeT i rrq-q qftql ol cfrqTE fu-q1 g
24. C mr Grrd<o qeT il-il c-{gd 3Tr}c{ sIqD eTtsd B, X"r <)s w gi "Tri q),q r-& e"r rrer S eilf,qT a7 ftqq 1 {fi.fi.rfi. d crct]]r} d c-fiTpT d qrRd 3rhq entqr g-flTfu-doT zn1 aTmi
Page 9 of 10
Vq. q. tq<-'ta,/zoz+ o1 qRD t qfr B n-q Gr-ieo qeT FRr c-rgd gfl 3ra-<-{ q sffid oeqi oi X"r dv q{ qr{Brr r-Er ot qr rro-ft r zs. rrEfwsq 3il-ilil6 qe{ trm q-{gd fr'Aq 3IdEq Gr-qB orBa Eti d Xu <)u w gt iil.i d,q Mq c di i\ Gflf, frrqr qrnr t r
26. srq qe{ 3rrFil otqql a-q q5-q 6-l't t 3rrePT gd 'q lq lc4 q t 3Trq fu6 14.10.2024
o) erm'erRo, fuim us e}fr-d fu-qr TTqT I qqdgi, ffio 14.10.2024 2h \o (qTq q--d) ffiq 3rETmrfr S.erx.0.q.qyq u-ffiq.rd
Page 10 of 10
Loading citations and judicial treatment…