Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
SHRI ASHISH TIWARI vs PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK on 22 October 2024
crr g. frt -lo/zozt
arr qEfr 3Tk{.{"r sfdw
FwtrA{r gq Edwlo {rq)
orn. g. tr< -lo/zozs
r. fr oncfts ffi oroq afi olR.gs.
ffi sq o-ftq +e q{, Ne{ M
q-s-Srn ffiq, ffi
l-z/sto
olt-{r o.r*fi frcrd (\'q.fr.) aozoto,
2. fr ornYsffi q-sq srftq fr1-6
ftrqrfi vq o.0-q 71 s{ Frqr$
l-z/sso oIt{I o.r#ft ,nqra (vq.ft.)
(fao),
z (q). sffi {rffi ffi
qfu rFdrffq
Grx.vs. ftrqrfr FF}rqH ffi) sa
znftc zo uq, ffi
$-zlsso oli-n
ordtfr .iqro (\'q.fr.) +ozoro,
z(fr) affi ffi ffi g* Effs afr ern.
vs. ftrsrfr cfr aft eTq ffi
sq
o-ftc +o uq ffi
z/sz,qd-e ict
zos frilm'slqreirz -s oll-n 6rd-ft
,tqra (vq.ft.) 462016,
z (fr) afr ,{ft emf S* *X, * ens.1'fl.
ftrqrfr cfr sft orft-d vrqf vq ot-q
36 s{, ffi
B /sz,wrdn Erti
frs-r otf,n {Ys ftqrf, (wO)
462042,................ 3[rtrffi,rurrrot I
fft-q
qqrs irmd t-6 qFdfi qrd-c qis
fiqra (w.ft),am 3rsrrf,w 3rrhtsr,
qqrq ivnd t'6 qis qfu6 qrd-c
,tqrd (vq.fr.),
(ffi{ qffi - flrftq fr trq frqrs q}a)
Page 1 of 5
sn-r g. frt -lo/zoze
orftR-ff fudr q@
o-if,cr
orqfaq dci.nqr (w.t.), 461001
o-e$-c-sn, 6d-4rt orqfdq fr{irrrqrc
kqfr), 461001,
fudr q@ dlcrd o-@c frcrd
kt*.1 462001,
n-r$-e-w A. A. qrn fiqra (vq.fr.
),aozoos.
slrtq-fi ceil d ftq fr *dvr ftan
efi-q-mr t
Bffiwrft tr6 d
slqtff srftq-mr r
fr\ aft ci-(q
3rr t
qr
(k{m 22.i0.2024 o) u}fud)
1. oni{fi qeT i k{i6 03.10.2023 o) qa 3Trd-fi tlr-q 22 (z) ($ em$.fi. \'rd rsge s6cBd ftqq 5-q S. em.O. (ffiqr) Ftr iee3 d oin-.fd rqo oG gq yq slk.rtur Er*r ge.g. 13s/2016 q crR-d siftq oTricr ffi-r 06.0e.2023 1q-tffi oTR-q,/1) o-r gr{rfufrfi-{ o-r qrR-o ontw d orqrkr o-r q-+-{ur gn: g"r ds w gr-or{ fu ftd qri or ergtu fo-qr rrqr t t
2. snn<-o. qar of frr t u-qd ftri.rn SflTffi-oq ennfi o.r s{rErx rie}c i {s err{ t fu Bffis-srfr t6 d am qrsWf il{qt d gqrqr rrqr B gq q-d-f,['f (wrilq u-qd r€l frd Ti t t eri{fi cql Enr u-rgo ewfu orqrile{ * q ftrpn*ur r-€t fuqr .rqr t gs vrtrrqrft d6 d ,TE-qd orffi i erkowr d qru qler foqr t
2.
3.
4.
Page 2 of 5
srn g. frt -'to/zozs qti u-qo frri .rn wErq t fr npqt 6r wE qfi-q-fi Tfr fu'qr rrqr t, q-{fu qn-fi=q sq'trq qrrlTorq d gm fr.ff. &ra erqr furq wFrTeT 1994-1 \'s.fr.ff. d U-4-{or t cfrrkd erftqf, d u-gwr 6'qe $ qrrqq t clw Glrtyr e{erqr M cR"T t clq t r srer fr olftfiel{ fuqI .rqr B qfr qr*r rs sr,m t'fd q sFh frfufr crqqrii dl olTisr o-q vmwrfr d-+. frrfr *ft c-fi'R 01 o-rd-drfr o-rt or w c-€t rqf,r, -qfu oiln{fi seT 6t 3fl"Nut giert u$Trfr efi t
s. 3ntEo ce{ Ergr qrer fr oTk6"?rq fo-qr rrqr B of fr,t ss sT sr?qrif,{ d qqrq of drffi or ot{ c-qrrT T& t, fu-i fi oTkfi{q arir drffi d ogq o) .ra-o il0d t Tfffi'R fu-qr rrqr t't sr*r fr orBfr-{q i gs erd w fi tqn r€t ft'qr o1 s-trt-qrft do i slEo.-iur d trer oqe fuqr t vs 3iftq ontsT of oEs-or-zo vq zr jT frn Tn ftq{ qF-d d t gfr T{6 t B-drn Tn fqD-6 er{i d entm qr entfl A f+tifu-dro-c or erStu ft-qr .rqr t t
4. vcrqrfr ceT d aM u-go ftd Ti ftfuf, ild d qrtqq t srrcfu d .r$ t of qR sriffo qe{ {s' orfuo'iur ERr crkd .,+mq sntcr ffio oo.os.zozs t ft .Gfl t, d B-t srRT 18 si+ffi vf,c 2oo2 d cTsqr+rgwR srfi-d u-go ori 6-r E6'kqr.rqr t, frrd gcirmroq oriffi frqutq c-S t t HrpT fr qmftq q.q. wr qroroq d d E:RT rrre-q Frfur ffi f{r-€ frq, +isi on$.fr.sTr{.fr sn$. {-o. fuk}s zoro (s) \'q.ft.va.d. ooo -1 sqtr-o oG gv v-s qfuoqq dr griTfr-dr-6-{ of $ffi slkr n drt q n-d ror .rqr t t
Page 3 of 5
5. srrrr qeT d ild + e-6'M t ffi frB-o q{{ ffiq i of 'cqr sTrtr<-fr rr$ Etqr rqc s-+nfrrilot olrnfi ffi fr.q B' ?
6. er&R-a oTrtyr (\'+ffi q-1) ffiff oo.og.zozs qff eqrFrd cfr ricr.{ d, fuf-d s-s-*6-{ t se B ot oTrn<-6 ceT Enr qtvt 17 (r) st+* v{e 2oo2 d ffd frqio oz.os.zozo o1 rgo o1 'r$ yq.q. n. fis/2016 ldI dq w ETr qrfi'{ eifuq w t ontcr ftqi6 oo.og.zoze d qnqq * ftn-qf, o1 'r$ t'r
7. crRd ontcr q,t o-Fso-r ss d ergrx oTrfuq-fl q*+ fuiro 02.04.2016 o) Rfr-d d6rm rrqr B t qqfr m-.r qqcr ftqio oz.or.z016 sTsr fr fudr qmz mqrd am crR-d 3ntcl ft-{io. 01.01.2018 qi 14fu sqo et+ furtRd fuqr.rqr tr
8. frtft ,ft qrqrfrq 3renr orE-m{q 6\ sTkT griTFtrdffi +t sfrTdi'6'r quf{ v@dt qtrndq d rrqq srr-q cr cffi{d qTqrE€nil d qnaq t fu-qr .rqr i, ftil-sd ffT srer qqrqqqq wrft f{s-€ ec afrq. dIfunTE 1,tf er< (zot+) s Wfr.fr.25 fr s6-tur t qmftq vqrq qlqldg o.r ro t of rymm= fu entcr +z ftqq r fr.ft.fr. q sFfd ernm f+ e{rqT{m. t, Grslfd oflAR-a snicr cerq EEqT ZE t Tfud e), erqsrT Zfu Wf snt$ ft grqTm-6c ?Fr orlqm T& E\ q'm-dr vE gilTffiffi d qBqq t 3ntyr of oifrTdr o'r fus,+ Tfr fu-qr w sqor I oi-ar q?FwT qr{fi tft t+t-q s.c. rrwr (zorg) s ss.fr.fr. 86 t qr+ftq sqilq qFIIEt-q or q-o B srr{ g. i;rt -lo / zozs
Page 4 of 5
srn g. frt -lo/zozs of e-d6 dejqrerfi eprqr ftfufi zfr y+nfuolor or enqx c-€l 6) so.-fr, rrd fr W Zfr erfl-a or oilETR d sfi-fr d I q-aftq vqtrq RnrrErq ilI flfu or+ffT{ crfte fdft|s f{s-c ensrq €e rffiRrA t's srq (zozo) z \ry.fr.fr. ozz d qrrd q qmftq 3 qqXtrui ft1 fi-d i qfiqn A t fu grilmffiq at Yrffi frft-f, +ft B gq g-{irffinn of s{rs t qrfM o'\ Tn RTt fr w G-geif w nd u-qo ori 6-1 3Er*R rfr ftqr qr qfidr, ftffiol ftrrowr Td q fuqT w gor t t e. Tfl.q.13el2oro d crfud oiftq sntcr frqio. oo os.zo23 o'r srq-fr6-{ 01 qrql qrar t of gs' elfuo-iq grr srir cri of strt t rqo frti .rn erftqzr+, (fftnst w fuwn gfo qrcqr ord g< eiftq ontYr qti ffi fuqr .rqr t, srqif, qrfu6 frio or c-fr.r o-r frfu gs il?di o1 fra-t1qr at .r{ t I n-(rTffR 3Tfuq M efiftfuo fu'qr rrqr t, orarid qr-Rd eifrq sni{r n tS ot$ rea <vff ZE r€l B, d entcr az frqq r m.ft.fr. d qrqqni d ffd Eq orE6{q o-} crftd oTrtsr k{ro. 06.0e.2023 d gr-{Th-dm-{ of crfu r<n o-rft t t 'ro. {s cRft'eTfr n rd fr enil{o. qer gs orEm-i"r FRr crR-f, eiftq sTrtcr t so, o\ fi.Bd rrqw ov ra t, fu-S qTtffi qe{ 6'} qs eikowr d sqer yr-*rffiot or 6ti frfuo 3ilEr{ clw rfr t, ilq e-Ed gq{rfu-droq ona-fi Tfffrri l-fr fu?Tr qr so-f,rl
11. s"tstrrr oTffqo eET aM u-qo griTffioq cna-fi onqr$-{ fiqi'R-d orfr gv ft{fi fu-qr war t r I
GrR q. iE< -to/zozs entvr of cfr d HPr ongd yfl.\. qrcs d t grEI geT oIq"II olrlrt qq qrq ott t ?
12.
13. q-d-f,gv ffi:-2z.to.zozt orrarT gd qrqTerir i eTru ffi zzlo:oza dt drfuo fu-qr r ( >Ll a\ (vrqfr-qTv c-}d) ffi{qffi, $.ein.fr q.c. Ts Eiffs.r-6 o ?>
Page 5 of 5
Loading citations and judicial treatment…