Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals

AMIT KUMAR SINGH vs SMT ZEENAT FARISHTA on 12 November 2024

srftf, q. - os/201a

uq e-i{ft 3Tkm.-i"T E-d-dg{

(t u.vf futrq)

(ffiq 3Tffi - qrflfrq aft vrq ftqm q.-d)

sTftd =i. - os/zo1a

1. uF--o qun Rfe sneqq sft eo.ru ftte ss F-t-q 46 s{, ftqrqft g-1, t-d-q rrx iTqgi Edsrtr, gm srcT-ff +ft ffi< ru frra urmo {qft qtrdTrr %;#i fr-{-€ ffi d-flf, wR-{flr cH fr cfuff q)-6q-q wft{flr, cfu-fi ct-6q< wR-{flr s{rf,rq Ts.ffq ffi qt6qq wfr{flr ffi<ilff ncdqr @rdtft, t{irqrE fu-dr t-flqrc (vO),

3. E{rE m-R{nT orilru *fq ffi wfu{flr Frfl$+rff dES?TY t-flrqq fu-dT t(irsK (vt), dEq-q tnr-dt.ft, q {grd rqg{ d,tq (ft) fufr}s ffi E-sfrIq-d wrc +{i rft-ooz, s-df {€frrq-d fre uug<, {Fqc *6 ms skqT s-of qre.fr*q,a tRu vug<,

o sffi t'rEq( ordtft, 492001, slrftiil ;i. - os / zota cNmD er+ cfu {s-{ffq ffi q-fu{flr, ftncft<il-ft4-df{i t-{ilqrE fu-dT tflTqrE (uq)-

{rrwrom gl-grqrdT oTrflq *ft gTnr-{rdT, df< Tq-{ F-qrift-\'c.3il-{.fr. , ft.w. ftrO offi fudr {l-qg{,

Page 1 of 19

vqg{ /frq qfun olart8, qogv g-xr Nq oilhtsr, {€lt=r Bftq rrm qror o-qf qqrrrfuo cfu*ri aA ir-S< Tq-{ {rqgs (u.rr.)-+szooo . vmrqrft.rur t oTft-flreff ca d ft\ fr Grtrf, ririfr \'s +ft fiq-gcT ff-c arE{ffir t vf,wrfr a-qrq t d ftq fr +ffirmr qs +ft +{q trs oTB{ffir r vf,rqrfr oqro s {Fq-{ +-o. d.w gtrsqT d fu ,fi 3rft'd-6 orstrFr erBq-mr I 3ntqr (fqq;- 'tz.'t't.zozc d 6)

1. qft-dTQff oTfr-f, ecri fti-6 d gxt q6 srfta qm 30 (1) qn$fi.grd rgss d or-d-.fei eilft ers.fr. S-rz, iTqgq, zv e-qfr 3rlqor,q qq-dg( d orTtcT

Page 2 of 19

slfid i. - os/zofi R-rTo 2e,05.2018 o) fr nrgf, of .T{ t, fu-fl erTtrT d nqr eildr erffi t dfu-d cqft now d effi-affirzerqM d gm u-rgo wvfu 3trleq fu{i6 0s.05.2018 o) F-{tr fu-qr rrqr t r

2. e-fi-{q o-r r{&q {s u-6l-{ t of vf,{qrfr @-qr6 5 {Bsq t-fr ds Efr€qT vugv d ET{T gq{ 3TEfi-{q d qrqa or\'ftq-r-d q#cTE rglzooo M srqgs di-q srf+s ftfr|s ys oFq d fr'-{-€ s--qo fu-qT, tr) srtft-wrd gffi'{rc o.A.E.x. tzt / zooo d w t c"ffin alor gc a{fufi{'r d $ ffi{ 3rEq-[ft gm Frofq fu+o zz fuoqs 2ees fr qtqq i\ frFfd ftrqr rrqr I d-{-gr{R Gr}Eo t.o d e-a 48e3766.43 qirT (or-.s-dTfi=s ars ffi Eqr{ llrcl {n fu-qm-d Fc-n furft-q q-€T) G qs vrRr w k+o 04.01.2000 t rrRr e-rp ei-i d6 i7.34 sfrfl-a ilffifi w t qrq cftrerfiT'T ri gero-gero eruo rrgm: e-ga vri or erffi furfRd fu-qr rrqr t dqrS$r( srlqo-ilT d qidr sTf*f,rft o) er1fr wr"r qa i&o frtfl TqT t p e-qfr Fil-sT q-{ f,q-dfi erlffi d u-6-{or t ija.c tt eq-fr o-rffi d evn oTfr.draff d am ffi n+ru d gtr orBrq of srvfu u-rgf, 01 r$ o1 fu6u tg c-c<ifto irqfu or f+oq ergeu p 3il-iqc d cfuqrft o-qro r t s i erqMzz orq-dTeff i\ fuqr \rs rrqof fuo-q qftw-d 638350/-(d aro ersftn rox ftc ri q-qnr) ocrd qlw 6{ ortr-dTeff o} s-m rrqfu or ftm qTD!-fl fr rfl-{ or frq t qqD o{fi-drfr t t sm irqfu

Page 3 of 19

ft"ft mur rrrarmf{ d ffT eerfi' *i ot ot{ grc r$f ar t

4. rnel fr qA rfr oqm fo-q .rqr t ot ft-rm i1.os.2oo2 ol q-6-S eR oTfi-f,rfr o) qa oea gio gsn 01 Bf,r qe{ t vffi rl*Tfu o) s$ rgg+ t {fr?rt d-fr ofrv. gtrsqT d erefl-q erfr $-{ x-ur qrw fu-qr arT I {fls 6 31fuow fo-qr rrqt of ffif,r qa ffo-q oqe-eT q{ 1ee3 q ffi( o-{-i d s{qkr vrqgq yrfl Ets-fiT ?ETT rr-qr erT, fu$frr qdr 3rie6 qa o) dfr"q'e of qfr qS zooz d mw di cv Erfl EsTr, Tq qa ifro or f+oq qz gftqq oqri or qgr)q fu-qr t qqB et-geu-ooi ca of Gi-{ t of$ E-Errq c-fr fuf,r, ilq erftf,r?ff t fu-f,r =qr-qrEft{r vugv d qErrEFr i qenfr FrtqrST i-g qcF{ul c-{gf, fu-q1| qqfr gs orfu6-{q d 1fc&T s-f,wrft t-o am n*go frrd .ri aa onilEc w <ierf, wqk d Aqq i orTe?r k{i6 1i.os.zoo2 crfrd $n t

5. orft-dTeff qeT tnr q6 fi .F-f,{r {Er t d} e-*1ft e-fi-{q if orft-dTaff t sil-cfu or}fi ftqr-6 r+. os2oo2 nqo fuur, qi \rfti!-c tcr c *i d orsq f{rm 28.08.2003 o) frwd o-{ ffi oTffi qr$+I o-{ fr T{, ftRrd fot-q gr: oilqfu srT-nc{ y-{gf, fr-qr rrqr, d erTtpT fu{ifi 06.01.2004 d orgrl-i ft{if, of T{, fu-fi-d fr-s-€ 3rBft-i"T d nqa orftd trfi-{q e/zoo+ wgo fuu, d siltsT fr-+o 13,01.2004 d ergux F-wf, 01 .d ffi fr-s-€ qmfi-q s.c. v@ qrqrhrq d rrqei slfumT o-qifr zoor /zoo+ e-{gd fu-qr q\ orffiq eTfffr-{ur Grfta;f. - os/zon oTfi-d q. - os / 2o1a E c'll6ls lq d vrqa slw tqfuo. sq.ln d q-firYr d ft{if, of .r{ gs r-rgd frrd Ti fufud vB d fr-rr< d-i d fr-r-q uqo o1 T{ carq oTftm d frwn di d fr=s-€ qmftq sqils qrrilcrrr q TqYTd ifts &-&Yr< nrgo fu'ur .rqr, u) ako t I

6. srcfu'finf o-r {6 rft oen ra o1 ei1fr oiffi gmr ftcil-ft df,I o) fi-dt-q o1 .r$ eErfi rtqfu o.r o6rr ffi qri or oiltrT crRf, fuqT .rqr, ftmd fftq encroc aTBftqq of Bfi=q or-gq* o1 qrqr oo G oz d qrsumrg$r{ srqfu nrgo ord gs zrfr .r$ rrar+or or ergtu fu-qr rrqr en t T. Brrq ser oi U-"i d qrqkT f,q-fr orffi gxr wRa en$fro silA"r krT6 2s.os2o1a d qrrrq t emfrro-of am q-{sd 3ilcfu Grrn{q fti-ifl fu-qT .rqr, ftrqrci qer +fi-i qs sr0q-qq d r{Erer q6 erfts rrqq €rT d <t'e< rqn o1 .r{ t t

8. r-tgo elfi-a oT grq enerri t o1 E-n orko-{ur HTr qtRf, 3iltsT ft-flo. i3.04.2018 Emfi=q EdE 16 v@ qtqtdq gr-{I celrl orfi-f, o-qro' 142/201r { qrfuo snter os.o+.zora d ftq-q fr oeC o-r rcrfl vigfr-fiwl ori gV E'q-e SE clw fu-ql .Tqr t, u-+fu- qa6q EdT-r-E iia qrqraq gm 3Tfi-a.rrff \q fudf,r qeT rq{ftq ffi dEqq d qw frqlfud ft-6s or-Jqq oi Hfr cl-il Trr gs {fl orko.-{q 6r<i, Td or}s-q t crR-d sntqr frrr6 rsoz. 2004 gm'qeftq sq t qrR-d fu'qr rrqr t q-g.ft sfu-a vq r\ qE M frqr .rfl t o1 cfrqfr oqro s p wrfr d qq ftrEI w snt cai or ro rsor t r TqE rrrrfu aroie-sq orftftqq d or-drffl qrqr z'

Page 4 of 19

oTftd i. - os/zorc nqo tozr, frr fi qi$ orlfor.ft 3{iiqT fuqlo 3ilBq-(q d E-o w fuqR T€t fu-fl r-qr I E", o-'*ul sTrrr 53-g rrqfu E{TiacoI sTfuft-{q d Hsilq} d s-orcr t eiffi o-rffir effion rt qt 1'q eTAq t t e. 3rfi-f,raff sET o-r Grfuoarc B of ss sTfuf,-{'r sm qrfto ertq *nm qrq ft-qin\ d ffif, t, q-qfu orftf,rsff o\ {s oTfh6-{ur d oTffir o-r EFI TS QTI, qfu q-6-ft qR etro sqfu d e-"1 or frEn qrqr *i q{ EFr go{r I srq fr oTfuosm t o1 +i\ fr qfl oTko-{'r o) qn-ftq E<ftrrrg s?E qrqlas d FPfu S qo gn Een o1 dem rrqfu d frq-q fr eqeuo-at gm o-sd frrqr rrqr t, A-S fr frqlfi oTffi oi vg< forfRer ftrql qrqr qrRq en, q-qfu srftf,reff Tq l+rartrgT{ ol setcrx TS t, efu p oil-nfi d cffi o.qro. r t s i o-qe E4-o' tros erye-4r dt Eqft o1 eero. frrqr, ffi frq-q t qfr-dT?ff vrqrq q-q[d-ql t 3iq-fr vrqfu q-qri tg ETffi o-iiTr {Er, frr{ gs fi-q er1-fr oTfffi ait eft-q< otq-o w Eqfu fuoq o-q fr .r$ t

10. orfi-f,rrff o-r q6 .fr orBfrwr t q,1 Grfi-f,r?ff fud gs m-rrur qrq qTt t sfuf, c-fr E) irocn fu vwd ss ffi oTffi o) gqYft r-S fr T{, qfu s@T{ at ffis or qrr q<rq o-G ot v-fl!-fl-ft s{tso-i"T \rq q-qrf,-q of t't rner fr 3rk6Qm ftrqr .rqr t of ei$ srffi FRr qrftd 3ilt-cT f{qlo. BI4.2}1B d frs-q t oil-}E-fi qeT t G{rqchr GrEF-qq rgor sfr Bfiq 3rgi$ $ ft-qq 11 qq oo d eq-on orT-ifi eqd oTffi d nqel

Page 5 of 19

sTftd =i. - os / 2o1B 2e.05.18 orfrdrQff o\ dem rlqfu d oil-Brfl fr g+o tnrt d frYq i q'Rd o-t kqr rrut, u-qfu qll-fiq udwg vq qrot?rrr 6Rr cafi sifi-d uz / zott I q-Rf, 3rTtpT d fr-'{q gqrlmoq orlE-{ rqo fu-ur .rqr t, d gc-qr{ fu afuo t r vneT fr qm 151 isEqBa rsz vft.ft.rfi oT err-i{q !fr ntgo fu-+r .rfl t I {*rd oTfrR-ffi o-dE fr=ArTq ,fr g.{qr$ & dkd t'qs {fl oTBo-i"T d vrqs qT{T re (zs) ern.0.fr.vqd 1ee3 d si-a.fd qrlen u-tgo fuur t't gqrd vnq fr gIfuE Qrc fu-qr rrqr t ol ql-r-ftq Edrr-,rq vtq qrqt?rq t erqa e.{.w Mz / zor or Frufq ttr gv orft-dTrff \'q fud-ilr ,*, fr 4a fiurRn 3i-ge-,q R-+o 21.12.1ss3 vs or-ge-q d 3{rtrT{ q{ u-ET{ frrt .rd onfuq-il d frs-q i stfi-dTrff d cel t Fefq kqT t t g€ *mf w nqo ufi-a d qrrsq t qilfi orffi gmr crfud orTtyr ft-iTo 2e.05.2018 o) erqrra frtd qd, vnsT fr qrquf qq m uri or er-gtq frrqr rrqr t

11. (l(lq:qt( sYilffidqracqsft-ow fu-qr rrqr of +flq 01 .ri qrqfu ituy fr-org srfufi-{q arr c .e}ili o\ q-d-e w fr .r{ irqfu t, ftrq=ft1 yTd d ei-Ev+ri s-w vqfu w ot$ fi 3Tyr cqeT<tdr irugv fuors rrBo-{"r et vrEqft d fr-{l fuoq esro., o{elqr ordrsTr ETrrqr qfr frrq qr rrod, fu-g n"ft qkrut i tift oti .t-gq6 clw TS frrqr, d\ q\ sqfu {-qgq fuorfi urBfirr d gtfr-s o1 t, vneT fr s-fl-d frsq fr Efuo .iu-o vg< t yq rs srBf,Yq grr Tf, sriqq t qko vo qeftq entu i gc oaat w f*qR €t E"n t qs W z'

Page 6 of 19

orfrf, t. - os/zorc qriEc d 3rFr{{r) rl qqe B !fr ft-{ qasf,"f oaa ffitr q), ilc \'o. cqfrq M frqr qrq qn-fi=q safl.s qlrrTFrrr d frrTr ft-{yT d ffia t r gn oTrEr-{ q{ eerfi rrqfu w srfi-areff ot eilftc-.q g{ vqfos frri ufi of rrarqor qY-er T-g t t

12. orfi-f,rrfr qer i fr+ro rc.11.2022 o) u-tgo frrd Tn ffiq orT-+fi oir{.q. zzoz /zozz d qrqq i\ ffi ddT o) fuoq o-q dft6 3ilqq-.q c-Erc ot .ri er+a vrqfu or enftc.q oTfi-dreff o\ srcfl ffi qri o-r 3r-Jttr {s ffiq oil-}q-q q sFfd opal d oTTETT{ q{ fu-qr r-qT t r qnq fr err$.q zzoa/zozz Hm rci1.2022 d llqq t e-{flft-d 3rTqrti o) 3Tfi-d srq-c d eirw d w fr ft-qri d ftd qfi ot ergtu fu-q wr t, oTqlo rlfrq d 3{ft-f,T?ff qeT qE oE=Tr qrecTT t o1 qi$t 3rlff,rfr er*r fuo-q 01 r$ rrqfu "qd t, d-tfi arc-o fi t", q,l yrd qr fr-o-q o1 .T{ t, n) o-s dem rrqfu or GilBq-.q t-*' d qmr rS sr, m[ qmftq BEr .qlql('lq --s, ch rfiqoffi{q qtP{q Eqcqo-c eTarf0 frs-€ {T{rar uwr (zorz) e vfl.fr. fr.rgz d q-fi'Rr d t'fi srsrq +drft ddT o) Grq-f,r?ff t rrqfu or efifuq-s fuctT-n wi or ot-{ Em' e-q-fr orffi 6\ TS an I qrar fr Grrchq srDf{qq ol Efrs or-gi$ d frqq 11 vs s7, HTsT fr qm zs orR.$.fi vf,c d qmillt d y-orw t qilfr 3rffi d 3ricT o) effidT t qt q.rc ord gr frarft vrRr wrq iftqr d or-{i c-rs-$q hts d qrreT qErT r-S *i d e{TEn-{ s{ q_q-fr oa o1 orffi sxr ffffiilr i) qt

I 3Tfi-f, =i. - os / 2o1B T(E d-{-{ Eqfu oT oTrfuTil orfi-dreff t d-o--i ffi ddT o\ kflqT urcr frfu fu-q sfo-q1 66 .ri * I sneT fr ffi ordqTfi of dq-f,r gq fuo-q qfrq-.{ qqr o-Ei of qfuqr o) qFf, q-mt gq ffi oTffi cR"T t rp mRn-o$-< ili or oeq srftd flc{ i ut3 uli or eqtu fu-qr rqr tr

13. gs etko-qq d gm crRd oiltYT kilo' 2s.11.2022 d ugcx oil-Acfr qeT o-r oil-il{q orr{q. zzoa/zotz k{i-ff 1011.2022 slfrc ailArT d qrq ft{-mvr tg dkd rsT r-qr t, snelid Ec uriq{ 6 trtuq t s-fiTfud fr'fu-6 fr-Soil or fr ftqrorq fu-qr qrcr t t 14, B-f,qqrfr e.qro t 6ryr fuir6 20.0s.2022 oi v-rgo frri Td wfl-s d qrtuq t GrrBril o1 grterTrrT t wifB-d srrnr< o-t qanq nrgo orfr gs cfrsrq fu-qr rrqr t 01 erTEq'-fl o-r f,eq qmftq Edsre wI Rlr{ntrrt ErtI ge.rq oTfrd o.qfo. 142/2011 it dfr-f, trq d qnryq ii frFff, fu-qr qT Tor t gs qi$ oIffi d Er-{t oII-q-cFr Gf$ft'qq, 3Tarfl oil-{.S.fi.\'f,e d frxft srqqlq q-T Bc,ciq{ TS fu-qT .rqr B t r+rer fr ild d qnqq r\ en{.q. zzoe,/ 2022.q1 fi vfuqrq frrfl r-qr g ,

15. vf,{qrfr oqio s {Fqq t-fi. Gfrs. StrssT gm ft-qr6 06.12.2018 o) olftd fl'cq tFT qflq ntgo o-rd gq ffi oTffi Hn of T$ oTffi or wqef,q ort gv r*go effi-a or ffiq fu-qr rrqT t, fu-fl-fiT ii$q vn nox t of ffi oIffi t ffi sqfu o) o'ft,fi i f,fo.-q cngq-er ,to 3rfi-d "i. - 05/2018 d ernm w q{ rsgs t zooz d qtq sTci qet tl fr-o_q q-a frElR( y'q qfi-{q rS o{tfl, mI Tf, Gil-iEc d qrtqq t t-f, d qel fr nql-q faqr rrqr ilq-fr TErq qr d ftqre{ q qqo sqfu ot ffi o.rffi ftB srqo t, fu-{ oTfi-f,rrff i p 3il-tqc d slR-a Fpf-q or fl-q ffi6. tt.os.zooz o) Ei qri d vrog< tn'rft fi frdq o) g-fr-ft r-e Rqr,

s) o{frq e\ g6T t qq 3rft-dT?ff iliT eiIfr alfl*ortr d rrqs c-tTa oilcfu ftts wqo ofu * GrTtqT fuflo re.rz.zoos d vnq fr GilAYr frflo oo u.zoo4d@E !l@ gr{r orftd q'qTq- p/2oo+ rfr erdcr mo rs.oz. zoo+ d GrTsrq fr{tf, of r{, ftrird ft$--q q-.dd gq.ft.;f. sost /oc .ft qmfrq va rqrqrmq ETtl fi-rw or fr .d \'q q{6n qnr-f,q 6Rr orftdrQff 6T ErE ft{K frqr rrfi, ftil$ ft-o-< n*g( of .ri orq-d qtl-fi=q sa qTqTFEr Hr-{r frwfl of -r{, ftil$ ft--o-< u-rgf, ffis er-gqft qrtdf,r fi rnr-+q v@ qTqTFrq i\ frwfl e) g+t t t '16. {s vorqrfr 01 Gilcfu t fu orfr--dlaff t r.q.nd ffi +dqq wfr{flr \'s qffi oqr-fi 1 q . d e-M t-fi d va i Efuo nrrq tiem o) o"t g+ft i-fr RsT G qm 6-9 rrqfu ilf,rawr orfufuqq d Gr d frw t qtc-ft-q Buq qlqrdir d gm fr-dri fuqr qtcn-{ q.Fr{t-flo M frqr ET Tor t t HrQr fr fr--il.l -qrqtdq snr stfr-d ffiq ot o-FsmT +-q d M s) ,ft srcrl-q1l fo-qr vl gm1 t t qq orTqTq) w erfi-eneff grr c-{g( orfi-f, frq-if, frd qri or ergtu fu-fl qqr g vnq fr 3ilqfu fr

Page 7 of 19

oIftf, =i. - oi/2oi} fu-q r .T-$ t a orfi-f,rrff i qi$ sTffi d qrqel erqB ilffa orufu n3o fu-ot err, fu$or fu{ro.-{ur q,{i gq qr1fr orffi i franfr ddT o\ orTEq@ ffi tnr sBo qTtvr crRf, fuqr t'r

17. s-f,{qrft q.qtq t d am R-{I6 rg.rr.zora o) yQrD qqlq r-{gd 6{d Eq qqfr oiffi grql qlfrd 3r-tqr oT rrqelc fu-qr ?TqT t t rnq fr nrger orft-d d fr!-q tt qRFffi 3il.cfu d qrqq t eilqfu m T$ t ft1 orft-d kFq-Sd-cT d ftErd t ilfhd $, 6-1-w o1 $ d E-s erko-qq gM {ift c-qfr at erfta or ft-{r6-{ur fo-qr w gor t t vflar fr oilqfu fr .T{ t of orftdTeff sTlqo-i"T d qrqer sq gut arei t sqRerf, q-fr Eun, oui o\ gqrqr .rqr t, q-{fu r:+fiT{ frrd .T-d r{yNic ail-t({ d ergw vugq fuo.'R{ flfuo-{q 6M Eift o{Tyrq oT ntgo ffin orrtfi qrf,ftq E-drrqE sa qfql-dq grq frrr< fu-qr w gol tr vrrqrfr o-rro z ffi dor rrsq-6-Rr gi-gr-qTaT d gm sf,r-qrft ilo d qqrq d ergw orft-mT?ff gm s-{gf, erfta or cfusTs o.-{d gg erufu B-dlft T{ t o1 3rfi-dTaff d cqr oT fuo-q 3r1s-rrr 1'fr qu vfu-o qgalur t, fu-q't srft-dTeff grE o-r E{flrer{ Tfr t q fr ffiil Em sqft oTffi-a o-qt or wE meFT $ \'s orficil?ff o\ au ffi s-fr-{ui t ffiT irqfu w o'fr oi$ ss sm qfr g3Tr q's Er+ sTkfi-{q d gm p wi-er q sm-d ffq or Hrc Eli d or+qE srfi-drrff i ftufq or Errt +i d oro-qq olfrf,r?ff t F"fu o) er$fuo -rfr

3Tfi-f, ;i. - 05 / 2018

Page 8 of 19

s-f,rqrft d sm 1q-i@r or</T/1) I (\+mi oTR/7/ rz) d wflrM tn) qqrq d wq rrqffid ord gv u-t5o effi-a Hr{fr-{ 1's eiltr-{$-{ urfr gv Grfi-f, ft-rrfl frrn qfi ot ergdu erfta smq i sFff, oeqf d c-{Tcr t fuqr .Trn t r 1e. sf,rqTfr o-qro e <rogv from mfffi-{tl d arsr Hro. 0e.07.20're o\ srq{r yaro. qq[s trEf, o€ gv qfuow fo-qr rrqr t of qs vf,{qrft sn S.erx.t. ve-dgt oT qa fu{io 06.0e.2018 q} g.+g-r-sldT nq-d ?i-ar d qer fr qre ;ieq tj ct-{9 ctr I ? I q-ort+q rrx Tqg{ d nlqfd(ul oTffi d ilq[fa en, ffi fi.0.s.2018 yrkr 83il, futr w rql sf,{qrfr i ffi ddT o) qa o-qro 1635s ffi6. 2s.11.20j8 iRd ftrfl r-rrT I T{reT S efi-oqrq fu-qr .rqr t of s-m qre o1 BnQ-drd d-o fis irugq fuoriT mffo-qq ffiE eqrq qrrd)dT d qtq Ma g{ ,ft, frRTd sfir wrc ffi qf-6qq, er**rn qrfr, g{rE w-ft{flr, qfufr +6q-q i q-drq-d tffi +s R-qT6 16.r2.1ee3 d qrqq t vrogv fuf,rfl fi*firT ot q6qh r\ o-q fu-qr vq r)s 3r-qB 01 fiq fis RqrF 22.01:ss4 ffid o-{rcn, ffi orqn q{ wrc ol r+o go cflftc-fl R=r-o 22.01.1ss4 i\ ffi +flq-E, om{s' wd, gvr< Efu{nT vs q-fuo +6q-( o-r {6r t t {s oel-c d rrqqiq t gq.oil-{.ftfl-q Grfrkffi UEq ordcTdc aTffi vr6 ,TE-q( erffi 6r-{ yrrrel q* ,ft q-fl.q fu-qr qqr t t zo. orfif,reff qeT am dfu-o. ild d vnq fr ft=ro rc.0s:024 C fufu-a ild fu-qr rrqt t I

Page 9 of 19

3rfi-f, =i. - 05/2018 rflar fr B-f,rqrfr vqw t d am fi Hrfi 11.0e. zozq d frfuf, nd v-rgo ftrw rrqT g '

21. srrr seT d olft'qr{, dfu-f, \'s frfuo ild d c-fitvr t ftq qr{ frqnuftq t :- (r)'- cqr q{$ 3rffi 6RI eflSfufl sntfl ze.os.zora frB frqq *sa sTqrKI frtd qd +rqt? 3rTfu[s fr.qB?

(z) :- ew ft-+.q o1 rd Eqfu or q)fro orfi-cnQff d seT n grterTfr-.r frtn ufi &q:- ffi ffiq cr{t fl ffitfu-d frns-{ oq 6qq frqr w rar tr

Page 10 of 19

eq"S orffi i oltrdrfr etko ftie gRI ntgo urvfu sil-iEq krm o3.os.2o1a o\ gw qq t wr o{rtrr( q{ F-wfl frtqr t 01 fu-fl-kf, sqfu or f+oq q$ zoo+ t fu-qT qr go-r t vq qrqftro-of o1 qQrq onck o-1 ftqrfi-{ur furm oo.ot.zoo+ o) frrqr w gol t \q fu6u oTffi t r+ q$ Y{srfl oilcM .r\ mq r{Etelrt6ft tFI g&tcrt{ T& t, B-S 3rq-f,{ oTEfr{q 01 Bfiq sr-g{$ d F-qq 60 m-l apl qrt o-i Efi Tfr t, fu-s flT ftqq d omrfd 3ilcfu ffi frfU t 30 kdr+ d sr-{i nrgf, E}-rT qGq, fu-fl-mT orq'rs t I ffieI fr ftE!ft 01 .T{ ot erlqM gr{t rNgf, GTrcM or qfrerq qlqrf,-q) Em fu-qr uro< ftrrqo ft-qr w gmr t G sr-a-o: erft-f,rrff/oilcM gRr c-{gf, of .r$ orrqfu ffi oTffi d ra q$ d sr-fl{-fl d w-drd B-{r

Page 11 of 19

3Tftd i. - 05/2018 ftrifr sfua 3rqr d v-*gd *i t Ei \ilt utrq q +oa qlrr$-{ ftqiRo oG gv ft-wn of q-{ t t

23. onft-f,IQff grsl {fl 3TEo-{ur d T{q&T R-im r.os.2oz4 r-*go ftrd Ti fuMa ild d qrurq ri fr-6q tnr-ffi o) vp q-orfr gq qmftq g@ifg qTrIIoFI gs ql"Ifi-q BEEI -.|q tdq I _t ch oi rfiffid o{ trqf, erq-d {fr-fl{ m rnri or 3rgtq fo-qr rrqr t t niq fr ua fi orcfu cd qriTfi .T-$ t A ei$r oTffi d vrqs ffi ddT i fr-6q sfu ffio 12.01.2004 d eiffi wn fu6q sftq-d vq wrsotq kt-s q rol-(w{) vq} oq e), d vlRT ffi ddT t qqr c-fr fu-qr, sfu R-ilo fi.022004 ol d-fr d am v-ql fu-qr .rqr, d frB fr-{-€ t r ss asq ffi ddT d qa il ta ETEfrrfd frqr urqr 1t--o t r

24. Grft-f,rrff srlff,ffir gm ffo--q qlRr \'s qr-s.Sq qts vrryq ifrqr d eres wfl Tfr +i o1 orTcfu d H-<li t qrrftq rrrs sa qrrrarq d arq-q$ arl! O fr.d.fr.szz fr.vq. wffRrqq f+W inc rrf,o .arw q c-mn frGlf, o\ v-qqo fi+-qrrqr tt eTel fr Aqq fr qmfiq sE qtqtdq orRr€-c tfu& omrqs yE erq (zoo+) s \Fr.fi{fr rsz o) rg-Etrd fu-qr rTqT t vu n-+* re.os.zoze C r-rger frri Ti fufu-d ild d qrtqq c) 'rfr qrf,fi=q s@crrr qErrf,q G va qrqrd-ql m q-ro-gerd o) ir<ffin ord gv srft-dlrff o-r seT rqr .rq t t d qqqgiil ticn {sts srqA gs srq fus-€

Page 12 of 19

sT'ftc{ =f. - os / 2o1B 25, {fi 3Tkfi-{q o)uema' q6 ts-fl t fu "qqr w{ orD'o-wT d ei$r oTffi am rrqq qfr T$ fi-dTft fro-q tnTffi t yqrfuf, qrqfu wre o-ilfi g-01 wre rftqr 53oo rrfrrtd ftero tliq TrR {rqg{ w effi-sreff or .nt$ frB-fr rqd ftBa t', fu"q-d 3ilErr{ q{ silfi-drrff ffi old-qr$r ot g.d-ft ti or frfuo Eo {Ekrr t, erqw erileo am gql elM"r d qrqeT vdrd Td derrfi-.r \d frts--o' Gnqfu rrrr$-{ t, furr w Xu <)u qs qd sfr siltm{fi-flr qfr w urft t

26. {fl s<.f { srft-dTeff iltT ilIfr orffi d vrqa ntgn of .r$ cqq orufu furm rc.os.zoo2 d 3rgr{ri orfi-draff o-r q-E oel=r {fl fu sfir orrqnftu sqfu q6-q !!-{ q-r yt-+q crri {Tqg{ o\ erftdTeff i sqfu d {qfr d xq rrq-qq-rrs d xfr qk t, d arosoo/- (erc 6;s qq1 EmT{ cTq ri) slt vftw-fl g?rdl-q oq Ht-o 21.12.1ss3

o) o-q fu-qr t gs oilEr-{ q{ orfi-flr?ff or tq sd vq oilBq-s t, q-qfu xofr qs i aaqrsrd s-m wqfu ero fu-qr, d qR srrlq-o qeT 6-r q6 oel=r rferrr fr{fud otC a{el-qr qrq-fiq E-ffi'q.rq va qrqroq d ilr {ftfil{ ft-qr .rqr for \'s orft-dTeff d qa t M rErc of T$ *ft, n-q q-qrq oTftf,rfr o-r we ft-ou gcr irqfu w rfion frri Eri of cRRaft ftffin +ft, fuS gi{ ir-<d q qs vffiq e'ot efimpffrzerqM i fiq-f,T qrqrgfryr iTsg{ d qtqtdq j1 6q-46: q{ 2oo2 d d$neo. 1T6f{rdT fu sl< u-rgf, fuqT, fu-fl-sT F"fq s-gat orw fudr qr+rfiYT {-qg{ Hm trq ft-rTo 21 q4 2011 d

Page 13 of 19

oTfi-f, ;i. - os / 2o1s Grg{Tn ftrqr qrqx oTfi-f,rrff/srft or qrq ara a-o zot qa t ffo-q qa Mco ovr qri d oTfuori t irqB-f, arr I i-s-Rrcrqr w i) ftFi-o fu-qr rrfl \'q srE q-{ ftrr< ov frqr .rqr. ftm+t cfr B-f,.arfr oqifr z d krm fii1.2018 t (vi-@r ort /t) d fr iid'{ B E-GII-'I sg oilt@Zqft-dTrff sTfra gqx ,ffi ftr-6 i fr-s-q qmfiq oqro o.-ffirr.ra ga -rllqldq d rrqeT cer-q 3rftd uz/zot1 Tigd fu-fl, fu-fl-f,r fuq q-Hftq B@ -qlq Ici q d gm Hm 05.04.2018 o) fu-qr sroq orfr-dr?ff gr-{r c11( qTq Fruiq ol otrs-o-I-s+ d G{Tflr( orqB flfu-f, forfRf, fo-qr rrqr I rflar S ffq o1 oFso'r-28 vs zo d ergvrx qrq lMq q +{r rfr q-4y r-qr I sioo: fr-4-{q qt-qrf,q i orfi-dr?fi erfr-d fti6 u1q ft{w frrd uri d M o) Rers ivd gr .nriT 3ilq-S€r< srR[fi w t rfiom .rqr t

27. en$fro GrTtsT H6 2s.os.zo1l t q6 ftE!fr .fi d t of qr;ffi-q s@im qr-qff,q d rrqe{ nrgo of ,Ti rnpTd d-s ft-&cn @-flo. 104ee /2018 3iltyT kirn fi.os.2oi8 d uS*rx ft-.{fl 01 w go1 B, orarfa fu-fl ff6-q t{rIcqq6R /fua-q orgeq d 3rTEr-R q{ erfi-drrff oTF-a fu-6 xw er1ft orfsrfr q fr--os o1 T{ srr-qrifls sqkr w erci Ef, vs we' o-T ErtrT cn-{ {6r t, scl {{rqs-dR t 3rft-dTaff d ao gq {qc o} rserq fr{fuf, o}d qq olffiq o.Iffi qr q-{ftq EdErtr s@ qrrrr"fq d gm {$-f,ri TS ftqT rr-il, cq effi-opffZ3ilqM or &nB-o {{trI, 3lat-c[I srTE!-dC O-t Et-qI fta-q 01 .T{ rlqfu

Page 14 of 19

orfi-d =i. - os / 2o1B qr qlrftq Edrtrrq s@ qrqtEs gM q}fr-f, ffq trflo. 05.04.2018 d qrqro e)s qfr T6 ur-flr I

28. grrd v+rq fr erq wffi'q oeq q6 .fi t 01 {d fr 3rfi-dTeff orft-d fri-6 d srrr Eiffr Grffi d srTtsT Hro. 06.01.2004 i\ qfYa +or qn eikosq d rrqa orfi-d o-qi-r tz/zoo+ utga of .T{ eft, fus w {s o{Bo-iq d $ ffi{ orffi d gm q'Rf, orTtyT k{ro" rs.oz.zoo+ d Grgilrt oTfi-d F-fin 01 .rg, ftilTd ft-d-€ orft-f,Ieff orfr--d frr6 i qTTft'q s.q.BEr ;qrq[f,q u-+agr d T{s&T qrh=mT Eqro' 3osi / 2oo2 q-{gf, frtqr, u) siltrT fuo 2o.ol.2oo4 d ergrm ftwf, o1 .r$ gq srftdTrff o) qrq-fi=q zu ffi arffiq slkfr-{q d wqeT ffio. sq.Tn clq +t *1 qmolfr fr .d, frrg srfrdTqff i qTTft-q oTffiq 3Tfu6-{'r d $ca 116{0l nrgn frr+ E}, tqT 6l{ ufuow c-fr t r zs. eq-dt 3rffi d rrqa B-f,wrft t-o arr wgf, frrq .T-i 3il4-fi ft-rm p qd zozt /zoot \q sf,{fl-fr t-fi d ilo-r$-{ Erq l-e-€ro. S.w.qrq griT nsgf, frri .rt wal qa d qrtqq t eq-dr sTMr

o) qa otqrkr o-{Err rt-rrT 6J 11trffid t-cq qe] dxr ftrd Td mq d crf,rffl q[g rfl g-5 53oo q1ffi-s e)dE TrR qsgv tiuo Hqfu i G sqf, Hq-fu o) ffi f,+o-q o-s xuT w{c{ fo,i qri or orgirT fu-qr rTqT t eqsfu i d-{ srm-t e rfr r-tgo frri, fu-{$ o{TErT{ q( qr{-fr orffi gxr ftflfr fr-o-q offi {flr=r o1 T$ | qilft crffi i eT$fu-a olT+cr t w{ der o-r quh fu-qT t of s-m qrq-fu oT fuo-q q$ zooa ti fu-fl w gor t G

Page 15 of 19

srfta c. - os/201a eiftq w t fc+- t7.o2.zoo4 o) ttr6-q gw fu-w w gor t t srerld oilqFd-fi-df of oilqfu Xd q n=no 06.0'r.2004 o) ftwfl of ut g+t efr qs ffi oTffi Eff gfu ffio 17.02.2004 o) of w go1 pfr, ae cqr grftareff o) Gi r+ q{ d ei-fl{rd d ccqrfl R-flo 03.0s.2018 o) ei$ 3Tffi d rrqer frr{fr ldkf, mcrqr-{ d otrd 3ilcfu rrgo o-d or 6O QII 30.. frtfi .fr qfu o\ d frrfi ftf*6 orqsldl o\ en$fro o-{=rT srEiil t, vc} Heilr -.]tq Id {..t, G{emr srBm-{q d wqei frD d srf,.fd furffud rrqq lfrqT d oiw GtTqfu r-{gf, s{i o-r Efi t, fu-g srfrP-.ra o.rcr nch tnr ro c d frfua Tiar q fr fufrfr qrq ffi d ergw rfiom ul {rm-aT I {fl EffiT t rl-6r qs sffiq B o1 ilIfr orffi of 3tTtpT qEoT krm os.oz.zooa gs 17.02.2004 d 3i-s-di-6-{ r\ rqw t of qqro. 'lr.'l zoo+ o) c-{flifr-d o1 T$ ffi oTffi frdt-Ifr df,r Er-{r-{rdT gw erfra d sc-rfl-fr qqrq t (a\ Urt]9<hIll d qer d r+m-a r& rq ffi ddT d sm rtq{ +drft rtfrr sozoooo/- (fi-s ars u-d-s rwx) vqd rrrrq ifrcr d eres qfl foq t qqB crB-$q hts d 3o2to./-(ft-fl awx d ri rror) vq-t qqr o-FrT QrT, uo-q fi zozao/- (fi-s ron d ri nro) rqi rrsrq $qT d erqq qq-r fu-qr qqT I 10,/-(cs) Fq-d of v) tFfr afr, qqdr sIffi d siltsrr-qn ftqT.'s grwe Hq- rc.02.2004 d qrrqq rl q=n oq frqT rrqr I qqB erlqM qa sff oil-cfu B q,1 Grrq-6-{ oTfufr-qq reor 01 Bftq 3qqfr d frqq sz I

Page 16 of 19

oTfi-f, ;i. - os / 2o't} Hstri) o-t scdErq fu-qr rrqr t r gs olilT {rryf fr-6-'q orffi fid t Vq srqn< frr} qri *,q t r

31. Gil-q-cFq orfuftqq rgor of ergvpfr z d ftqq sz d e6on +f,r-Ifr fdl o) qcn-a ffi dor slB--d +i w ffi qlfrr or zs qfrcra cEn'kr G'qr ryrqr e)'or t G rs ft-qrl d 3l-qr rtq'f qfrs-d w'il orcT +f,r t, erqqn frqq sa d ergrm wcr o1 .T{ slRr YrT{fi d Ff, fr qw of qr}.ft Ts or=rrr rrqfu gn: ftarn of qrt ft, d w EM,I i\ t€T urq d ffi ddT i qqd ffi slRi {{Tq {ftqT d sr-{i qqr fu-qr t, cn. rc / - (EH) sqd cTs"}q qftfl t o-c sr, d ffi vrRr or qrq c-St t'r

32. dtun orfi-dreff qeT t qr+fiq wFFI .qlqldq fr. T{iTff{ srqT{q qrqr G (zors) g \ry.fr.fr. +oo o) rr(ffiir qx Gr-q-cF'{ etBftqq sz crsqrd 01 orgfu q$ o-*nn t, B-fi-{T am orfi-aifr o} Tfr ft-d-flr, o-;sq of BW ffi a;Rr ffi ddT i rrqq ltqr d oiw qqr fu-qr t, fuT of qi1fr orkilft 01 qTtqT qEoT t rqw t, n-o ro7- (rn) w-q cTs-$q etrr of ofr ftqq s7 d vds-{ Tfr qrlT VT E-{-at l

33. erq w$ HTar q6.fr s-ffiq t o1 qR 3{fifl?ff wEfrrde $i{ G{qTfd qqcF irqfu 6l vqffi rra x-fi zqfu Et-dT, di sr) ffi oTffi

o) gq orTqTR) w g<tft ti or Efi ilf,r, fuE orq-dTrff dqo irqfufl or iqglBox o.*fr c-& {6I ordl ,t<

Page 17 of 19

oTfi-d =t. - os / 2o1a \iq o-fua fu-ao ergeu d ernnr w eIfi-f,reff cF-t sr( q 'l-1o iq/zot1 fuq fuilo 21.06.201r d ergvm z-gef 3rw fufl vrorcftw vugv d i\ -{.ltqtdq frrw gert qQrrr 3Tfi-d @-ql-o. 142/2011 rrrTftq Edrr-TE sEE ;qrqlEq d aqr R-rlo os.o+.zora C ft-wd a1 .d, ffi fr--d-q c-{gf, ffiE 3r-gcfr rlth--qtr .nqro' ro+gs/zols qri-ft"q r{@ilq Rrt rfdq d anr srTtyT R-rTo M.os.2o1s d erScx ft{rn ot .r{, o{Qrfd qft-dTpff or eErf, r:qfu w oH frkfi 6o gs vqs qfi Tfr t I sfl ol-{ur qil$r oTffi ilqt gq{ 3rlfo.-{'r d n-oqt wEfrrd-e o-r frqreq o-{i tg F{n T} ftftT d ffT ot ,ri ffi mTffi epmr ffi olffi d q-Rq-q o) enelfto o-rt or ot{ uo qfi-f,r?ff or qfr e=mT I

34. orft-flr?ff or d T6 Td t o1 ca tiuo rl-Eqk d sarftfl oilEq-iq tt er t {c] oiqq st ro sno t t {fl frss d fid o-f qfl B ol 3rfi-dTrff oH eftorro =rfr err, B-q-d Gilfuq-fl or q\ rft ww en T6 v$d rqo: d qqs d oT$-{ Tfr en, 61v o1 Brfi-dr?ff d qq t rqs Ewra{q or oN ftB wqo ilflra-q, frd ffi-q( fuo-q qe sT EFr q={, srrr q-r -rfr ffin =rS geri, o+vlo 3rfrdl?ff or erl0qeq erf}qn qifrRH no-ft or en, d srrflB-o rsrfr qtT ca orTfuq-il' rFT wtrri G we sT{f,fu"o wrft gs uq iJqc4cl6l( d u'fr qfu e), ftTr-d fr-s-€ flT sTfuo.-{'rixqffino-*qtffi {rrERdc ftrrqtd dBi{ t-6 d qet ti q-EE fu-qr, ftil$ Fqler{ c]?l'..lql6l C qT{f,fuo rqqfWt x"ft (n qhilq\ tt q< Etoa ot{ orTqfu rrgf, Tfr fu-qT sq

Page 18 of 19

sTfi-d i. - os / 2o1B fuoo ge t)-i e+o fi.oz.zoo4 fr 6rFrrl r+ qS d Gr-dq-d d qrqro erfi-f,rrff i ei$ srffi d rrqer 3rTcfu 3il-Ac{ fu{ifr 03.05.2018 nqo fu-+r, wefu frr{ft fr fr86 cFrETrq d qrn fr,rtfr fi qk o) fr-oq orffi o) er$D-o o-{t tg r+ q{ 01 or-qE d qrqro ertcfu ntgo ori o-I 66 rfr ftq .rqr t r enqqx orEftqq o1 Be'q Efr d ftqq oo, or 3{ertrT 62 d ei-f,.fd ftrs qfuf, s) ei$r oTtrqrfr d ft--s-€ Gilqfu v-rgo ort o-r 6s' frqi .rqr B, Bqr-d fuq so t{ss of sqq rfin f+ffud f, \'s o{fi-drfr qeT o-r qe od fi {ffi q},s rfr d fu qrflftq uffig.ra wr q[qr-f,q Ertr ceFI srfta o-r M dkd *i ft-{rfr 0s.04.2018 t ifi-q {tqr oilcfu nrg.r o-{i dl vrrq qftqr rrurqr st.q t, orqq ot qR orfi-dreff d qe{ t qmfi-q Edrr-rT6 tszzl -q lq lc{ q i qrqrloTfi-d {Sffi fuqr rqr for, c-c olqrq erftareff t-nr oq-c qx tlcnoT en, fo-g 're qmfi=q E-d-ir.rE s@ qnn-f,q i Grft-dTeff d qrqq'-,

6) fr clr"hq c-fr qrql G vnq fr crqB qlfu-d fl+fR-d os f+qr, e-e oTftdrQff d ca t ffi( irqfu d rqs GTamr 3nfuqs d tq-q q oH rft cRRerfr TS B I W{ o.xur g*r fi-s or q-d t ot qq-fi oTffi i sffi-dTeff gM q-{gd oil-qfu orT-}c{ ft-im os,os.zora o) r+ qS d oiil{rd d w-qro nrg.r Eti d o-rqq sfuo w i\ frwd fu-qr t t 3s. d qq orft-mT?ff o) fuoq of .r$ qqo irqfu d rqs o-r Erqr o-ri or ot$ ro qrrftq EfdHre BEEI qTtI]Eq trrgr eelq orfi-f, q fiBa trq Hr6 05.04.2018 d c.qrd elq c-& arT, d-q oTftfl;i. - os/2018 orfi-f,r?ff o) qilft arffi d rrqa frffi rft eilqr tr{ ftdrft oTffi "1 g+t ti or t-o qS cc-f,r \'q frk6 e-o d erTrs i orfrdTeff se{ ol qs n-d TSqT-{i qtq l-fr t o1 qiffi oTffi sm of G fr-6s offi Ts ltd wrtrfrfre rc/- ((s) sqt qB,iq htir d enTrs d fqB of ge q c[q t r

36. d qq orfi-f,rrff qer o1 ft-o-q o1 .r$ .i.ro sqfu w ot$ fr'E-fi vscr slw rfr t ss ffi orffi ") g-+O ti or ofi eE-o ro c-& t, oq orfr-dT?ff qei gM nrgo effi-a o) orq frr€ GEetI q{ Xq ds w qrterT o-{i of omm{fi*flr tq rS ra rnlfr t 3t Bqt-ffiq{rri fr-A-{rT t q-fl sr[forq or M t of qi1fr 3Tts-.rTft gRr ilq-fr s-{-{ur O.A.E.X. B1/2ooo i crRd q-|qr Rlt-fi zsos. zore d qrqq rt ergftroaf/oTfi-dreff oTfr"f, Rr6 d rmr q-{go oilcfu srT-}fi fuqro' 03.05.2018 o) ftwfl o-{i t mt$ near-flo 3{Qrqr &drftf, ZE rS o1 .d t., s{elh orfr-dTaff HRr wgd erfid silErrr$-{ Et"fi{ ft{ifl frrn qri ql"q i'r

38. a\ qq orft-flrrff gxr c-{gd otft-d olqrr8-{ t, e-q otrnEo qeT o} cr-srd-{ff HyirTc GrrlE-{ zzoe/zozz fu{ro fi:1.2022 d qBqq ii erilfua daqfech' orarqr frff6 fr-Eerl o) srfi=d d qrqq rl sori oi ro rf-on =rS fuqt qt r{o-flI I

3e. tr?rtrrcrT rrgo efnfu 3rrifi zzoa/zozz ffio 10.11.2022 ft-wfl fu-qr qror t t oTftd =i. - os / 2o1B

40. qRqrqf,: orfi-f,raff gRr q-{gd Hrrfr-{ furiftd orfr gv ftwn of qrfr t r

41. orTtYr of cfr d nv vgfr erDmrft or oTmq il.rir d t orrerr g-d qFlr6r-q t en:q krro. pltzozq d qtfua fu-qT t t2- \\' orfi-d A s{dY{ ffi6:-12.11.2024 q--d) ffiqqffi,

9. em.0 q.c.G ud-qrra

Page 19 of 19

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead