Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
AMIT KUMAR SINGH vs SMT ZEENAT FARISHTA on 12 November 2024
srftf, q. - os/201a
uq e-i{ft 3Tkm.-i"T E-d-dg{
(t u.vf futrq)
(ffiq 3Tffi - qrflfrq aft vrq ftqm q.-d)
sTftd =i. - os/zo1a
1. uF--o qun Rfe sneqq sft eo.ru ftte ss F-t-q 46 s{, ftqrqft g-1, t-d-q rrx iTqgi Edsrtr, gm srcT-ff +ft ffi< ru frra urmo {qft qtrdTrr %;#i fr-{-€ ffi d-flf, wR-{flr cH fr cfuff q)-6q-q wft{flr, cfu-fi ct-6q< wR-{flr s{rf,rq Ts.ffq ffi qt6qq wfr{flr ffi<ilff ncdqr @rdtft, t{irqrE fu-dr t-flqrc (vO),
3. E{rE m-R{nT orilru *fq ffi wfu{flr Frfl$+rff dES?TY t-flrqq fu-dT t(irsK (vt), dEq-q tnr-dt.ft, q {grd rqg{ d,tq (ft) fufr}s ffi E-sfrIq-d wrc +{i rft-ooz, s-df {€frrq-d fre uug<, {Fqc *6 ms skqT s-of qre.fr*q,a tRu vug<,
o sffi t'rEq( ordtft, 492001, slrftiil ;i. - os / zota cNmD er+ cfu {s-{ffq ffi q-fu{flr, ftncft<il-ft4-df{i t-{ilqrE fu-dT tflTqrE (uq)-
{rrwrom gl-grqrdT oTrflq *ft gTnr-{rdT, df< Tq-{ F-qrift-\'c.3il-{.fr. , ft.w. ftrO offi fudr {l-qg{,
Page 1 of 19
vqg{ /frq qfun olart8, qogv g-xr Nq oilhtsr, {€lt=r Bftq rrm qror o-qf qqrrrfuo cfu*ri aA ir-S< Tq-{ {rqgs (u.rr.)-+szooo . vmrqrft.rur t oTft-flreff ca d ft\ fr Grtrf, ririfr \'s +ft fiq-gcT ff-c arE{ffir t vf,wrfr a-qrq t d ftq fr +ffirmr qs +ft +{q trs oTB{ffir r vf,rqrfr oqro s {Fq-{ +-o. d.w gtrsqT d fu ,fi 3rft'd-6 orstrFr erBq-mr I 3ntqr (fqq;- 'tz.'t't.zozc d 6)
1. qft-dTQff oTfr-f, ecri fti-6 d gxt q6 srfta qm 30 (1) qn$fi.grd rgss d or-d-.fei eilft ers.fr. S-rz, iTqgq, zv e-qfr 3rlqor,q qq-dg( d orTtcT
Page 2 of 19
slfid i. - os/zofi R-rTo 2e,05.2018 o) fr nrgf, of .T{ t, fu-fl erTtrT d nqr eildr erffi t dfu-d cqft now d effi-affirzerqM d gm u-rgo wvfu 3trleq fu{i6 0s.05.2018 o) F-{tr fu-qr rrqr t r
2. e-fi-{q o-r r{&q {s u-6l-{ t of vf,{qrfr @-qr6 5 {Bsq t-fr ds Efr€qT vugv d ET{T gq{ 3TEfi-{q d qrqa or\'ftq-r-d q#cTE rglzooo M srqgs di-q srf+s ftfr|s ys oFq d fr'-{-€ s--qo fu-qT, tr) srtft-wrd gffi'{rc o.A.E.x. tzt / zooo d w t c"ffin alor gc a{fufi{'r d $ ffi{ 3rEq-[ft gm Frofq fu+o zz fuoqs 2ees fr qtqq i\ frFfd ftrqr rrqr I d-{-gr{R Gr}Eo t.o d e-a 48e3766.43 qirT (or-.s-dTfi=s ars ffi Eqr{ llrcl {n fu-qm-d Fc-n furft-q q-€T) G qs vrRr w k+o 04.01.2000 t rrRr e-rp ei-i d6 i7.34 sfrfl-a ilffifi w t qrq cftrerfiT'T ri gero-gero eruo rrgm: e-ga vri or erffi furfRd fu-qr rrqr t dqrS$r( srlqo-ilT d qidr sTf*f,rft o) er1fr wr"r qa i&o frtfl TqT t p e-qfr Fil-sT q-{ f,q-dfi erlffi d u-6-{or t ija.c tt eq-fr o-rffi d evn oTfr.draff d am ffi n+ru d gtr orBrq of srvfu u-rgf, 01 r$ o1 fu6u tg c-c<ifto irqfu or f+oq ergeu p 3il-iqc d cfuqrft o-qro r t s i erqMzz orq-dTeff i\ fuqr \rs rrqof fuo-q qftw-d 638350/-(d aro ersftn rox ftc ri q-qnr) ocrd qlw 6{ ortr-dTeff o} s-m rrqfu or ftm qTD!-fl fr rfl-{ or frq t qqD o{fi-drfr t t sm irqfu
Page 3 of 19
ft"ft mur rrrarmf{ d ffT eerfi' *i ot ot{ grc r$f ar t
4. rnel fr qA rfr oqm fo-q .rqr t ot ft-rm i1.os.2oo2 ol q-6-S eR oTfi-f,rfr o) qa oea gio gsn 01 Bf,r qe{ t vffi rl*Tfu o) s$ rgg+ t {fr?rt d-fr ofrv. gtrsqT d erefl-q erfr $-{ x-ur qrw fu-qr arT I {fls 6 31fuow fo-qr rrqt of ffif,r qa ffo-q oqe-eT q{ 1ee3 q ffi( o-{-i d s{qkr vrqgq yrfl Ets-fiT ?ETT rr-qr erT, fu$frr qdr 3rie6 qa o) dfr"q'e of qfr qS zooz d mw di cv Erfl EsTr, Tq qa ifro or f+oq qz gftqq oqri or qgr)q fu-qr t qqB et-geu-ooi ca of Gi-{ t of$ E-Errq c-fr fuf,r, ilq erftf,r?ff t fu-f,r =qr-qrEft{r vugv d qErrEFr i qenfr FrtqrST i-g qcF{ul c-{gf, fu-q1| qqfr gs orfu6-{q d 1fc&T s-f,wrft t-o am n*go frrd .ri aa onilEc w <ierf, wqk d Aqq i orTe?r k{i6 1i.os.zoo2 crfrd $n t
5. orft-dTeff qeT tnr q6 fi .F-f,{r {Er t d} e-*1ft e-fi-{q if orft-dTaff t sil-cfu or}fi ftqr-6 r+. os2oo2 nqo fuur, qi \rfti!-c tcr c *i d orsq f{rm 28.08.2003 o) frwd o-{ ffi oTffi qr$+I o-{ fr T{, ftRrd fot-q gr: oilqfu srT-nc{ y-{gf, fr-qr rrqr, d erTtpT fu{ifi 06.01.2004 d orgrl-i ft{if, of T{, fu-fi-d fr-s-€ 3rBft-i"T d nqa orftd trfi-{q e/zoo+ wgo fuu, d siltsT fr-+o 13,01.2004 d ergux F-wf, 01 .d ffi fr-s-€ qmfi-q s.c. v@ qrqrhrq d rrqei slfumT o-qifr zoor /zoo+ e-{gd fu-qr q\ orffiq eTfffr-{ur Grfta;f. - os/zon oTfi-d q. - os / 2o1a E c'll6ls lq d vrqa slw tqfuo. sq.ln d q-firYr d ft{if, of .r{ gs r-rgd frrd Ti fufud vB d fr-rr< d-i d fr-r-q uqo o1 T{ carq oTftm d frwn di d fr=s-€ qmftq sqils qrrilcrrr q TqYTd ifts &-&Yr< nrgo fu'ur .rqr, u) ako t I
6. srcfu'finf o-r {6 rft oen ra o1 ei1fr oiffi gmr ftcil-ft df,I o) fi-dt-q o1 .r$ eErfi rtqfu o.r o6rr ffi qri or oiltrT crRf, fuqT .rqr, ftmd fftq encroc aTBftqq of Bfi=q or-gq* o1 qrqr oo G oz d qrsumrg$r{ srqfu nrgo ord gs zrfr .r$ rrar+or or ergtu fu-qr rrqr en t T. Brrq ser oi U-"i d qrqkT f,q-fr orffi gxr wRa en$fro silA"r krT6 2s.os2o1a d qrrrq t emfrro-of am q-{sd 3ilcfu Grrn{q fti-ifl fu-qT .rqr, ftrqrci qer +fi-i qs sr0q-qq d r{Erer q6 erfts rrqq €rT d <t'e< rqn o1 .r{ t t
8. r-tgo elfi-a oT grq enerri t o1 E-n orko-{ur HTr qtRf, 3iltsT ft-flo. i3.04.2018 Emfi=q EdE 16 v@ qtqtdq gr-{I celrl orfi-f, o-qro' 142/201r { qrfuo snter os.o+.zora d ftq-q fr oeC o-r rcrfl vigfr-fiwl ori gV E'q-e SE clw fu-ql .Tqr t, u-+fu- qa6q EdT-r-E iia qrqraq gm 3Tfi-a.rrff \q fudf,r qeT rq{ftq ffi dEqq d qw frqlfud ft-6s or-Jqq oi Hfr cl-il Trr gs {fl orko.-{q 6r<i, Td or}s-q t crR-d sntqr frrr6 rsoz. 2004 gm'qeftq sq t qrR-d fu'qr rrqr t q-g.ft sfu-a vq r\ qE M frqr .rfl t o1 cfrqfr oqro s p wrfr d qq ftrEI w snt cai or ro rsor t r TqE rrrrfu aroie-sq orftftqq d or-drffl qrqr z'
Page 4 of 19
oTftd i. - os/zorc nqo tozr, frr fi qi$ orlfor.ft 3{iiqT fuqlo 3ilBq-(q d E-o w fuqR T€t fu-fl r-qr I E", o-'*ul sTrrr 53-g rrqfu E{TiacoI sTfuft-{q d Hsilq} d s-orcr t eiffi o-rffir effion rt qt 1'q eTAq t t e. 3rfi-f,raff sET o-r Grfuoarc B of ss sTfuf,-{'r sm qrfto ertq *nm qrq ft-qin\ d ffif, t, q-qfu orftf,rsff o\ {s oTfh6-{ur d oTffir o-r EFI TS QTI, qfu q-6-ft qR etro sqfu d e-"1 or frEn qrqr *i q{ EFr go{r I srq fr oTfuosm t o1 +i\ fr qfl oTko-{'r o) qn-ftq E<ftrrrg s?E qrqlas d FPfu S qo gn Een o1 dem rrqfu d frq-q fr eqeuo-at gm o-sd frrqr rrqr t, A-S fr frqlfi oTffi oi vg< forfRer ftrql qrqr qrRq en, q-qfu srftf,reff Tq l+rartrgT{ ol setcrx TS t, efu p oil-nfi d cffi o.qro. r t s i o-qe E4-o' tros erye-4r dt Eqft o1 eero. frrqr, ffi frq-q t qfr-dT?ff vrqrq q-q[d-ql t 3iq-fr vrqfu q-qri tg ETffi o-iiTr {Er, frr{ gs fi-q er1-fr oTfffi ait eft-q< otq-o w Eqfu fuoq o-q fr .r$ t
10. orfi-f,rrff o-r q6 .fr orBfrwr t q,1 Grfi-f,r?ff fud gs m-rrur qrq qTt t sfuf, c-fr E) irocn fu vwd ss ffi oTffi o) gqYft r-S fr T{, qfu s@T{ at ffis or qrr q<rq o-G ot v-fl!-fl-ft s{tso-i"T \rq q-qrf,-q of t't rner fr 3rk6Qm ftrqr .rqr t of ei$ srffi FRr qrftd 3ilt-cT f{qlo. BI4.2}1B d frs-q t oil-}E-fi qeT t G{rqchr GrEF-qq rgor sfr Bfiq 3rgi$ $ ft-qq 11 qq oo d eq-on orT-ifi eqd oTffi d nqel
Page 5 of 19
sTftd =i. - os / 2o1B 2e.05.18 orfrdrQff o\ dem rlqfu d oil-Brfl fr g+o tnrt d frYq i q'Rd o-t kqr rrut, u-qfu qll-fiq udwg vq qrot?rrr 6Rr cafi sifi-d uz / zott I q-Rf, 3rTtpT d fr-'{q gqrlmoq orlE-{ rqo fu-ur .rqr t, d gc-qr{ fu afuo t r vneT fr qm 151 isEqBa rsz vft.ft.rfi oT err-i{q !fr ntgo fu-+r .rfl t I {*rd oTfrR-ffi o-dE fr=ArTq ,fr g.{qr$ & dkd t'qs {fl oTBo-i"T d vrqs qT{T re (zs) ern.0.fr.vqd 1ee3 d si-a.fd qrlen u-tgo fuur t't gqrd vnq fr gIfuE Qrc fu-qr rrqr t ol ql-r-ftq Edrr-,rq vtq qrqt?rq t erqa e.{.w Mz / zor or Frufq ttr gv orft-dTrff \'q fud-ilr ,*, fr 4a fiurRn 3i-ge-,q R-+o 21.12.1ss3 vs or-ge-q d 3{rtrT{ q{ u-ET{ frrt .rd onfuq-il d frs-q i stfi-dTrff d cel t Fefq kqT t t g€ *mf w nqo ufi-a d qrrsq t qilfi orffi gmr crfud orTtyr ft-iTo 2e.05.2018 o) erqrra frtd qd, vnsT fr qrquf qq m uri or er-gtq frrqr rrqr t
11. (l(lq:qt( sYilffidqracqsft-ow fu-qr rrqr of +flq 01 .ri qrqfu ituy fr-org srfufi-{q arr c .e}ili o\ q-d-e w fr .r{ irqfu t, ftrq=ft1 yTd d ei-Ev+ri s-w vqfu w ot$ fi 3Tyr cqeT<tdr irugv fuors rrBo-{"r et vrEqft d fr-{l fuoq esro., o{elqr ordrsTr ETrrqr qfr frrq qr rrod, fu-g n"ft qkrut i tift oti .t-gq6 clw TS frrqr, d\ q\ sqfu {-qgq fuorfi urBfirr d gtfr-s o1 t, vneT fr s-fl-d frsq fr Efuo .iu-o vg< t yq rs srBf,Yq grr Tf, sriqq t qko vo qeftq entu i gc oaat w f*qR €t E"n t qs W z'
Page 6 of 19
orfrf, t. - os/zorc qriEc d 3rFr{{r) rl qqe B !fr ft-{ qasf,"f oaa ffitr q), ilc \'o. cqfrq M frqr qrq qn-fi=q safl.s qlrrTFrrr d frrTr ft-{yT d ffia t r gn oTrEr-{ q{ eerfi rrqfu w srfi-areff ot eilftc-.q g{ vqfos frri ufi of rrarqor qY-er T-g t t
12. orfi-f,rrfr qer i fr+ro rc.11.2022 o) u-tgo frrd Tn ffiq orT-+fi oir{.q. zzoz /zozz d qrqq i\ ffi ddT o) fuoq o-q dft6 3ilqq-.q c-Erc ot .ri er+a vrqfu or enftc.q oTfi-dreff o\ srcfl ffi qri o-r 3r-Jttr {s ffiq oil-}q-q q sFfd opal d oTTETT{ q{ fu-qr r-qT t r qnq fr err$.q zzoa/zozz Hm rci1.2022 d llqq t e-{flft-d 3rTqrti o) 3Tfi-d srq-c d eirw d w fr ft-qri d ftd qfi ot ergtu fu-q wr t, oTqlo rlfrq d 3{ft-f,T?ff qeT qE oE=Tr qrecTT t o1 qi$t 3rlff,rfr er*r fuo-q 01 r$ rrqfu "qd t, d-tfi arc-o fi t", q,l yrd qr fr-o-q o1 .T{ t, n) o-s dem rrqfu or GilBq-.q t-*' d qmr rS sr, m[ qmftq BEr .qlql('lq --s, ch rfiqoffi{q qtP{q Eqcqo-c eTarf0 frs-€ {T{rar uwr (zorz) e vfl.fr. fr.rgz d q-fi'Rr d t'fi srsrq +drft ddT o) Grq-f,r?ff t rrqfu or efifuq-s fuctT-n wi or ot-{ Em' e-q-fr orffi 6\ TS an I qrar fr Grrchq srDf{qq ol Efrs or-gi$ d frqq 11 vs s7, HTsT fr qm zs orR.$.fi vf,c d qmillt d y-orw t qilfr 3rffi d 3ricT o) effidT t qt q.rc ord gr frarft vrRr wrq iftqr d or-{i c-rs-$q hts d qrreT qErT r-S *i d e{TEn-{ s{ q_q-fr oa o1 orffi sxr ffffiilr i) qt
I 3Tfi-f, =i. - os / 2o1B T(E d-{-{ Eqfu oT oTrfuTil orfi-dreff t d-o--i ffi ddT o\ kflqT urcr frfu fu-q sfo-q1 66 .ri * I sneT fr ffi ordqTfi of dq-f,r gq fuo-q qfrq-.{ qqr o-Ei of qfuqr o) qFf, q-mt gq ffi oTffi cR"T t rp mRn-o$-< ili or oeq srftd flc{ i ut3 uli or eqtu fu-qr rqr tr
13. gs etko-qq d gm crRd oiltYT kilo' 2s.11.2022 d ugcx oil-Acfr qeT o-r oil-il{q orr{q. zzoa/zotz k{i-ff 1011.2022 slfrc ailArT d qrq ft{-mvr tg dkd rsT r-qr t, snelid Ec uriq{ 6 trtuq t s-fiTfud fr'fu-6 fr-Soil or fr ftqrorq fu-qr qrcr t t 14, B-f,qqrfr e.qro t 6ryr fuir6 20.0s.2022 oi v-rgo frri Td wfl-s d qrtuq t GrrBril o1 grterTrrT t wifB-d srrnr< o-t qanq nrgo orfr gs cfrsrq fu-qr rrqr t 01 erTEq'-fl o-r f,eq qmftq Edsre wI Rlr{ntrrt ErtI ge.rq oTfrd o.qfo. 142/2011 it dfr-f, trq d qnryq ii frFff, fu-qr qT Tor t gs qi$ oIffi d Er-{t oII-q-cFr Gf$ft'qq, 3Tarfl oil-{.S.fi.\'f,e d frxft srqqlq q-T Bc,ciq{ TS fu-qT .rqr B t r+rer fr ild d qnqq r\ en{.q. zzoe,/ 2022.q1 fi vfuqrq frrfl r-qr g ,
15. vf,{qrfr oqio s {Fqq t-fi. Gfrs. StrssT gm ft-qr6 06.12.2018 o) olftd fl'cq tFT qflq ntgo o-rd gq ffi oTffi Hn of T$ oTffi or wqef,q ort gv r*go effi-a or ffiq fu-qr rrqT t, fu-fl-fiT ii$q vn nox t of ffi oIffi t ffi sqfu o) o'ft,fi i f,fo.-q cngq-er ,to 3rfi-d "i. - 05/2018 d ernm w q{ rsgs t zooz d qtq sTci qet tl fr-o_q q-a frElR( y'q qfi-{q rS o{tfl, mI Tf, Gil-iEc d qrtqq t t-f, d qel fr nql-q faqr rrqr ilq-fr TErq qr d ftqre{ q qqo sqfu ot ffi o.rffi ftB srqo t, fu-{ oTfi-f,rrff i p 3il-tqc d slR-a Fpf-q or fl-q ffi6. tt.os.zooz o) Ei qri d vrog< tn'rft fi frdq o) g-fr-ft r-e Rqr,
s) o{frq e\ g6T t qq 3rft-dT?ff iliT eiIfr alfl*ortr d rrqs c-tTa oilcfu ftts wqo ofu * GrTtqT fuflo re.rz.zoos d vnq fr GilAYr frflo oo u.zoo4d@E !l@ gr{r orftd q'qTq- p/2oo+ rfr erdcr mo rs.oz. zoo+ d GrTsrq fr{tf, of r{, ftrird ft$--q q-.dd gq.ft.;f. sost /oc .ft qmfrq va rqrqrmq ETtl fi-rw or fr .d \'q q{6n qnr-f,q 6Rr orftdrQff 6T ErE ft{K frqr rrfi, ftil$ ft-o-< n*g( of .ri orq-d qtl-fi=q sa qTqTFEr Hr-{r frwfl of -r{, ftil$ ft--o-< u-rgf, ffis er-gqft qrtdf,r fi rnr-+q v@ qTqTFrq i\ frwfl e) g+t t t '16. {s vorqrfr 01 Gilcfu t fu orfr--dlaff t r.q.nd ffi +dqq wfr{flr \'s qffi oqr-fi 1 q . d e-M t-fi d va i Efuo nrrq tiem o) o"t g+ft i-fr RsT G qm 6-9 rrqfu ilf,rawr orfufuqq d Gr d frw t qtc-ft-q Buq qlqrdir d gm fr-dri fuqr qtcn-{ q.Fr{t-flo M frqr ET Tor t t HrQr fr fr--il.l -qrqtdq snr stfr-d ffiq ot o-FsmT +-q d M s) ,ft srcrl-q1l fo-qr vl gm1 t t qq orTqTq) w erfi-eneff grr c-{g( orfi-f, frq-if, frd qri or ergtu fu-fl qqr g vnq fr 3ilqfu fr
Page 7 of 19
oIftf, =i. - oi/2oi} fu-q r .T-$ t a orfi-f,rrff i qi$ sTffi d qrqel erqB ilffa orufu n3o fu-ot err, fu$or fu{ro.-{ur q,{i gq qr1fr orffi i franfr ddT o\ orTEq@ ffi tnr sBo qTtvr crRf, fuqr t'r
17. s-f,{qrft q.qtq t d am R-{I6 rg.rr.zora o) yQrD qqlq r-{gd 6{d Eq qqfr oiffi grql qlfrd 3r-tqr oT rrqelc fu-qr ?TqT t t rnq fr nrger orft-d d fr!-q tt qRFffi 3il.cfu d qrqq t eilqfu m T$ t ft1 orft-d kFq-Sd-cT d ftErd t ilfhd $, 6-1-w o1 $ d E-s erko-qq gM {ift c-qfr at erfta or ft-{r6-{ur fo-qr w gor t t vflar fr oilqfu fr .T{ t of orftdTeff sTlqo-i"T d qrqer sq gut arei t sqRerf, q-fr Eun, oui o\ gqrqr .rqr t, q-{fu r:+fiT{ frrd .T-d r{yNic ail-t({ d ergw vugq fuo.'R{ flfuo-{q 6M Eift o{Tyrq oT ntgo ffin orrtfi qrf,ftq E-drrqE sa qfql-dq grq frrr< fu-qr w gol tr vrrqrfr o-rro z ffi dor rrsq-6-Rr gi-gr-qTaT d gm sf,r-qrft ilo d qqrq d ergw orft-mT?ff gm s-{gf, erfta or cfusTs o.-{d gg erufu B-dlft T{ t o1 3rfi-dTaff d cqr oT fuo-q 3r1s-rrr 1'fr qu vfu-o qgalur t, fu-q't srft-dTeff grE o-r E{flrer{ Tfr t q fr ffiil Em sqft oTffi-a o-qt or wE meFT $ \'s orficil?ff o\ au ffi s-fr-{ui t ffiT irqfu w o'fr oi$ ss sm qfr g3Tr q's Er+ sTkfi-{q d gm p wi-er q sm-d ffq or Hrc Eli d or+qE srfi-drrff i ftufq or Errt +i d oro-qq olfrf,r?ff t F"fu o) er$fuo -rfr
3Tfi-f, ;i. - 05 / 2018
Page 8 of 19
s-f,rqrft d sm 1q-i@r or</T/1) I (\+mi oTR/7/ rz) d wflrM tn) qqrq d wq rrqffid ord gv u-t5o effi-a Hr{fr-{ 1's eiltr-{$-{ urfr gv Grfi-f, ft-rrfl frrn qfi ot ergdu erfta smq i sFff, oeqf d c-{Tcr t fuqr .Trn t r 1e. sf,rqTfr o-qro e <rogv from mfffi-{tl d arsr Hro. 0e.07.20're o\ srq{r yaro. qq[s trEf, o€ gv qfuow fo-qr rrqr t of qs vf,{qrft sn S.erx.t. ve-dgt oT qa fu{io 06.0e.2018 q} g.+g-r-sldT nq-d ?i-ar d qer fr qre ;ieq tj ct-{9 ctr I ? I q-ort+q rrx Tqg{ d nlqfd(ul oTffi d ilq[fa en, ffi fi.0.s.2018 yrkr 83il, futr w rql sf,{qrfr i ffi ddT o) qa o-qro 1635s ffi6. 2s.11.20j8 iRd ftrfl r-rrT I T{reT S efi-oqrq fu-qr .rqr t of s-m qre o1 BnQ-drd d-o fis irugq fuoriT mffo-qq ffiE eqrq qrrd)dT d qtq Ma g{ ,ft, frRTd sfir wrc ffi qf-6qq, er**rn qrfr, g{rE w-ft{flr, qfufr +6q-q i q-drq-d tffi +s R-qT6 16.r2.1ee3 d qrqq t vrogv fuf,rfl fi*firT ot q6qh r\ o-q fu-qr vq r)s 3r-qB 01 fiq fis RqrF 22.01:ss4 ffid o-{rcn, ffi orqn q{ wrc ol r+o go cflftc-fl R=r-o 22.01.1ss4 i\ ffi +flq-E, om{s' wd, gvr< Efu{nT vs q-fuo +6q-( o-r {6r t t {s oel-c d rrqqiq t gq.oil-{.ftfl-q Grfrkffi UEq ordcTdc aTffi vr6 ,TE-q( erffi 6r-{ yrrrel q* ,ft q-fl.q fu-qr qqr t t zo. orfif,reff qeT am dfu-o. ild d vnq fr ft=ro rc.0s:024 C fufu-a ild fu-qr rrqt t I
Page 9 of 19
3rfi-f, =i. - 05/2018 rflar fr B-f,rqrfr vqw t d am fi Hrfi 11.0e. zozq d frfuf, nd v-rgo ftrw rrqT g '
21. srrr seT d olft'qr{, dfu-f, \'s frfuo ild d c-fitvr t ftq qr{ frqnuftq t :- (r)'- cqr q{$ 3rffi 6RI eflSfufl sntfl ze.os.zora frB frqq *sa sTqrKI frtd qd +rqt? 3rTfu[s fr.qB?
(z) :- ew ft-+.q o1 rd Eqfu or q)fro orfi-cnQff d seT n grterTfr-.r frtn ufi &q:- ffi ffiq cr{t fl ffitfu-d frns-{ oq 6qq frqr w rar tr
Page 10 of 19
eq"S orffi i oltrdrfr etko ftie gRI ntgo urvfu sil-iEq krm o3.os.2o1a o\ gw qq t wr o{rtrr( q{ F-wfl frtqr t 01 fu-fl-kf, sqfu or f+oq q$ zoo+ t fu-qT qr go-r t vq qrqftro-of o1 qQrq onck o-1 ftqrfi-{ur furm oo.ot.zoo+ o) frrqr w gol t \q fu6u oTffi t r+ q$ Y{srfl oilcM .r\ mq r{Etelrt6ft tFI g&tcrt{ T& t, B-S 3rq-f,{ oTEfr{q 01 Bfiq sr-g{$ d F-qq 60 m-l apl qrt o-i Efi Tfr t, fu-s flT ftqq d omrfd 3ilcfu ffi frfU t 30 kdr+ d sr-{i nrgf, E}-rT qGq, fu-fl-mT orq'rs t I ffieI fr ftE!ft 01 .T{ ot erlqM gr{t rNgf, GTrcM or qfrerq qlqrf,-q) Em fu-qr uro< ftrrqo ft-qr w gmr t G sr-a-o: erft-f,rrff/oilcM gRr c-{gf, of .r$ orrqfu ffi oTffi d ra q$ d sr-fl{-fl d w-drd B-{r
Page 11 of 19
3Tftd i. - 05/2018 ftrifr sfua 3rqr d v-*gd *i t Ei \ilt utrq q +oa qlrr$-{ ftqiRo oG gv ft-wn of q-{ t t
23. onft-f,IQff grsl {fl 3TEo-{ur d T{q&T R-im r.os.2oz4 r-*go ftrd Ti fuMa ild d qrurq ri fr-6q tnr-ffi o) vp q-orfr gq qmftq g@ifg qTrIIoFI gs ql"Ifi-q BEEI -.|q tdq I _t ch oi rfiffid o{ trqf, erq-d {fr-fl{ m rnri or 3rgtq fo-qr rrqr t t niq fr ua fi orcfu cd qriTfi .T-$ t A ei$r oTffi d vrqs ffi ddT i fr-6q sfu ffio 12.01.2004 d eiffi wn fu6q sftq-d vq wrsotq kt-s q rol-(w{) vq} oq e), d vlRT ffi ddT t qqr c-fr fu-qr, sfu R-ilo fi.022004 ol d-fr d am v-ql fu-qr .rqr, d frB fr-{-€ t r ss asq ffi ddT d qa il ta ETEfrrfd frqr urqr 1t--o t r
24. Grft-f,rrff srlff,ffir gm ffo--q qlRr \'s qr-s.Sq qts vrryq ifrqr d eres wfl Tfr +i o1 orTcfu d H-<li t qrrftq rrrs sa qrrrarq d arq-q$ arl! O fr.d.fr.szz fr.vq. wffRrqq f+W inc rrf,o .arw q c-mn frGlf, o\ v-qqo fi+-qrrqr tt eTel fr Aqq fr qmfiq sE qtqtdq orRr€-c tfu& omrqs yE erq (zoo+) s \Fr.fi{fr rsz o) rg-Etrd fu-qr rTqT t vu n-+* re.os.zoze C r-rger frri Ti fufu-d ild d qrtqq c) 'rfr qrf,fi=q s@crrr qErrf,q G va qrqrd-ql m q-ro-gerd o) ir<ffin ord gv srft-dlrff o-r seT rqr .rq t t d qqqgiil ticn {sts srqA gs srq fus-€
Page 12 of 19
sT'ftc{ =f. - os / 2o1B 25, {fi 3Tkfi-{q o)uema' q6 ts-fl t fu "qqr w{ orD'o-wT d ei$r oTffi am rrqq qfr T$ fi-dTft fro-q tnTffi t yqrfuf, qrqfu wre o-ilfi g-01 wre rftqr 53oo rrfrrtd ftero tliq TrR {rqg{ w effi-sreff or .nt$ frB-fr rqd ftBa t', fu"q-d 3ilErr{ q{ silfi-drrff ffi old-qr$r ot g.d-ft ti or frfuo Eo {Ekrr t, erqw erileo am gql elM"r d qrqeT vdrd Td derrfi-.r \d frts--o' Gnqfu rrrr$-{ t, furr w Xu <)u qs qd sfr siltm{fi-flr qfr w urft t
26. {fl s<.f { srft-dTeff iltT ilIfr orffi d vrqa ntgn of .r$ cqq orufu furm rc.os.zoo2 d 3rgr{ri orfi-draff o-r q-E oel=r {fl fu sfir orrqnftu sqfu q6-q !!-{ q-r yt-+q crri {Tqg{ o\ erftdTeff i sqfu d {qfr d xq rrq-qq-rrs d xfr qk t, d arosoo/- (erc 6;s qq1 EmT{ cTq ri) slt vftw-fl g?rdl-q oq Ht-o 21.12.1ss3
o) o-q fu-qr t gs oilEr-{ q{ orfi-flr?ff or tq sd vq oilBq-s t, q-qfu xofr qs i aaqrsrd s-m wqfu ero fu-qr, d qR srrlq-o qeT 6-r q6 oel=r rferrr fr{fud otC a{el-qr qrq-fiq E-ffi'q.rq va qrqroq d ilr {ftfil{ ft-qr .rqr for \'s orft-dTeff d qa t M rErc of T$ *ft, n-q q-qrq oTftf,rfr o-r we ft-ou gcr irqfu w rfion frri Eri of cRRaft ftffin +ft, fuS gi{ ir-<d q qs vffiq e'ot efimpffrzerqM i fiq-f,T qrqrgfryr iTsg{ d qtqtdq j1 6q-46: q{ 2oo2 d d$neo. 1T6f{rdT fu sl< u-rgf, fuqT, fu-fl-sT F"fq s-gat orw fudr qr+rfiYT {-qg{ Hm trq ft-rTo 21 q4 2011 d
Page 13 of 19
oTfi-f, ;i. - os / 2o1s Grg{Tn ftrqr qrqx oTfi-f,rrff/srft or qrq ara a-o zot qa t ffo-q qa Mco ovr qri d oTfuori t irqB-f, arr I i-s-Rrcrqr w i) ftFi-o fu-qr rrfl \'q srE q-{ ftrr< ov frqr .rqr. ftm+t cfr B-f,.arfr oqifr z d krm fii1.2018 t (vi-@r ort /t) d fr iid'{ B E-GII-'I sg oilt@Zqft-dTrff sTfra gqx ,ffi ftr-6 i fr-s-q qmfiq oqro o.-ffirr.ra ga -rllqldq d rrqeT cer-q 3rftd uz/zot1 Tigd fu-fl, fu-fl-f,r fuq q-Hftq B@ -qlq Ici q d gm Hm 05.04.2018 o) fu-qr sroq orfr-dr?ff gr-{r c11( qTq Fruiq ol otrs-o-I-s+ d G{Tflr( orqB flfu-f, forfRf, fo-qr rrqr I rflar S ffq o1 oFso'r-28 vs zo d ergvrx qrq lMq q +{r rfr q-4y r-qr I sioo: fr-4-{q qt-qrf,q i orfi-dr?fi erfr-d fti6 u1q ft{w frrd uri d M o) Rers ivd gr .nriT 3ilq-S€r< srR[fi w t rfiom .rqr t
27. en$fro GrTtsT H6 2s.os.zo1l t q6 ftE!fr .fi d t of qr;ffi-q s@im qr-qff,q d rrqe{ nrgo of ,Ti rnpTd d-s ft-&cn @-flo. 104ee /2018 3iltyT kirn fi.os.2oi8 d uS*rx ft-.{fl 01 w go1 B, orarfa fu-fl ff6-q t{rIcqq6R /fua-q orgeq d 3rTEr-R q{ erfi-drrff oTF-a fu-6 xw er1ft orfsrfr q fr--os o1 T{ srr-qrifls sqkr w erci Ef, vs we' o-T ErtrT cn-{ {6r t, scl {{rqs-dR t 3rft-dTaff d ao gq {qc o} rserq fr{fuf, o}d qq olffiq o.Iffi qr q-{ftq EdErtr s@ qrrrr"fq d gm {$-f,ri TS ftqT rr-il, cq effi-opffZ3ilqM or &nB-o {{trI, 3lat-c[I srTE!-dC O-t Et-qI fta-q 01 .T{ rlqfu
Page 14 of 19
orfi-d =i. - os / 2o1B qr qlrftq Edrtrrq s@ qrqtEs gM q}fr-f, ffq trflo. 05.04.2018 d qrqro e)s qfr T6 ur-flr I
28. grrd v+rq fr erq wffi'q oeq q6 .fi t 01 {d fr 3rfi-dTeff orft-d fri-6 d srrr Eiffr Grffi d srTtsT Hro. 06.01.2004 i\ qfYa +or qn eikosq d rrqa orfi-d o-qi-r tz/zoo+ utga of .T{ eft, fus w {s o{Bo-iq d $ ffi{ orffi d gm q'Rf, orTtyT k{ro" rs.oz.zoo+ d Grgilrt oTfi-d F-fin 01 .rg, ftilTd ft-d-€ orft-f,Ieff orfr--d frr6 i qTTft'q s.q.BEr ;qrq[f,q u-+agr d T{s&T qrh=mT Eqro' 3osi / 2oo2 q-{gf, frtqr, u) siltrT fuo 2o.ol.2oo4 d ergrm ftwf, o1 .r$ gq srftdTrff o) qrq-fi=q zu ffi arffiq slkfr-{q d wqeT ffio. sq.Tn clq +t *1 qmolfr fr .d, frrg srfrdTqff i qTTft-q oTffiq 3Tfu6-{'r d $ca 116{0l nrgn frr+ E}, tqT 6l{ ufuow c-fr t r zs. eq-dt 3rffi d rrqa B-f,wrft t-o arr wgf, frrq .T-i 3il4-fi ft-rm p qd zozt /zoot \q sf,{fl-fr t-fi d ilo-r$-{ Erq l-e-€ro. S.w.qrq griT nsgf, frri .rt wal qa d qrtqq t eq-dr sTMr
o) qa otqrkr o-{Err rt-rrT 6J 11trffid t-cq qe] dxr ftrd Td mq d crf,rffl q[g rfl g-5 53oo q1ffi-s e)dE TrR qsgv tiuo Hqfu i G sqf, Hq-fu o) ffi f,+o-q o-s xuT w{c{ fo,i qri or orgirT fu-qr rTqT t eqsfu i d-{ srm-t e rfr r-tgo frri, fu-{$ o{TErT{ q( qr{-fr orffi gxr ftflfr fr-o-q offi {flr=r o1 T$ | qilft crffi i eT$fu-a olT+cr t w{ der o-r quh fu-qT t of s-m qrq-fu oT fuo-q q$ zooa ti fu-fl w gor t G
Page 15 of 19
srfta c. - os/201a eiftq w t fc+- t7.o2.zoo4 o) ttr6-q gw fu-w w gor t t srerld oilqFd-fi-df of oilqfu Xd q n=no 06.0'r.2004 o) ftwfl of ut g+t efr qs ffi oTffi Eff gfu ffio 17.02.2004 o) of w go1 pfr, ae cqr grftareff o) Gi r+ q{ d ei-fl{rd d ccqrfl R-flo 03.0s.2018 o) ei$ 3Tffi d rrqer frr{fr ldkf, mcrqr-{ d otrd 3ilcfu rrgo o-d or 6O QII 30.. frtfi .fr qfu o\ d frrfi ftf*6 orqsldl o\ en$fro o-{=rT srEiil t, vc} Heilr -.]tq Id {..t, G{emr srBm-{q d wqei frD d srf,.fd furffud rrqq lfrqT d oiw GtTqfu r-{gf, s{i o-r Efi t, fu-g srfrP-.ra o.rcr nch tnr ro c d frfua Tiar q fr fufrfr qrq ffi d ergw rfiom ul {rm-aT I {fl EffiT t rl-6r qs sffiq B o1 ilIfr orffi of 3tTtpT qEoT krm os.oz.zooa gs 17.02.2004 d 3i-s-di-6-{ r\ rqw t of qqro. 'lr.'l zoo+ o) c-{flifr-d o1 T$ ffi oTffi frdt-Ifr df,r Er-{r-{rdT gw erfra d sc-rfl-fr qqrq t (a\ Urt]9<hIll d qer d r+m-a r& rq ffi ddT d sm rtq{ +drft rtfrr sozoooo/- (fi-s ars u-d-s rwx) vqd rrrrq ifrcr d eres qfl foq t qqB crB-$q hts d 3o2to./-(ft-fl awx d ri rror) vq-t qqr o-FrT QrT, uo-q fi zozao/- (fi-s ron d ri nro) rqi rrsrq $qT d erqq qq-r fu-qr qqT I 10,/-(cs) Fq-d of v) tFfr afr, qqdr sIffi d siltsrr-qn ftqT.'s grwe Hq- rc.02.2004 d qrrqq rl q=n oq frqT rrqr I qqB erlqM qa sff oil-cfu B q,1 Grrq-6-{ oTfufr-qq reor 01 Bftq 3qqfr d frqq sz I
Page 16 of 19
oTfi-f, ;i. - os / 2o't} Hstri) o-t scdErq fu-qr rrqr t r gs olilT {rryf fr-6-'q orffi fid t Vq srqn< frr} qri *,q t r
31. Gil-q-cFq orfuftqq rgor of ergvpfr z d ftqq sz d e6on +f,r-Ifr fdl o) qcn-a ffi dor slB--d +i w ffi qlfrr or zs qfrcra cEn'kr G'qr ryrqr e)'or t G rs ft-qrl d 3l-qr rtq'f qfrs-d w'il orcT +f,r t, erqqn frqq sa d ergrm wcr o1 .T{ slRr YrT{fi d Ff, fr qw of qr}.ft Ts or=rrr rrqfu gn: ftarn of qrt ft, d w EM,I i\ t€T urq d ffi ddT i qqd ffi slRi {{Tq {ftqT d sr-{i qqr fu-qr t, cn. rc / - (EH) sqd cTs"}q qftfl t o-c sr, d ffi vrRr or qrq c-St t'r
32. dtun orfi-dreff qeT t qr+fiq wFFI .qlqldq fr. T{iTff{ srqT{q qrqr G (zors) g \ry.fr.fr. +oo o) rr(ffiir qx Gr-q-cF'{ etBftqq sz crsqrd 01 orgfu q$ o-*nn t, B-fi-{T am orfi-aifr o} Tfr ft-d-flr, o-;sq of BW ffi a;Rr ffi ddT i rrqq ltqr d oiw qqr fu-qr t, fuT of qi1fr orkilft 01 qTtqT qEoT t rqw t, n-o ro7- (rn) w-q cTs-$q etrr of ofr ftqq s7 d vds-{ Tfr qrlT VT E-{-at l
33. erq w$ HTar q6.fr s-ffiq t o1 qR 3{fifl?ff wEfrrde $i{ G{qTfd qqcF irqfu 6l vqffi rra x-fi zqfu Et-dT, di sr) ffi oTffi
o) gq orTqTR) w g<tft ti or Efi ilf,r, fuE orq-dTrff dqo irqfufl or iqglBox o.*fr c-& {6I ordl ,t<
Page 17 of 19
oTfi-d =t. - os / 2o1a \iq o-fua fu-ao ergeu d ernnr w eIfi-f,reff cF-t sr( q 'l-1o iq/zot1 fuq fuilo 21.06.201r d ergvm z-gef 3rw fufl vrorcftw vugv d i\ -{.ltqtdq frrw gert qQrrr 3Tfi-d @-ql-o. 142/2011 rrrTftq Edrr-TE sEE ;qrqlEq d aqr R-rlo os.o+.zora C ft-wd a1 .d, ffi fr--d-q c-{gf, ffiE 3r-gcfr rlth--qtr .nqro' ro+gs/zols qri-ft"q r{@ilq Rrt rfdq d anr srTtyT R-rTo M.os.2o1s d erScx ft{rn ot .r{, o{Qrfd qft-dTpff or eErf, r:qfu w oH frkfi 6o gs vqs qfi Tfr t I sfl ol-{ur qil$r oTffi ilqt gq{ 3rlfo.-{'r d n-oqt wEfrrd-e o-r frqreq o-{i tg F{n T} ftftT d ffT ot ,ri ffi mTffi epmr ffi olffi d q-Rq-q o) enelfto o-rt or ot{ uo qfi-f,r?ff or qfr e=mT I
34. orft-flr?ff or d T6 Td t o1 ca tiuo rl-Eqk d sarftfl oilEq-iq tt er t {c] oiqq st ro sno t t {fl frss d fid o-f qfl B ol 3rfi-dTrff oH eftorro =rfr err, B-q-d Gilfuq-fl or q\ rft ww en T6 v$d rqo: d qqs d oT$-{ Tfr en, 61v o1 Brfi-dr?ff d qq t rqs Ewra{q or oN ftB wqo ilflra-q, frd ffi-q( fuo-q qe sT EFr q={, srrr q-r -rfr ffin =rS geri, o+vlo 3rfrdl?ff or erl0qeq erf}qn qifrRH no-ft or en, d srrflB-o rsrfr qtT ca orTfuq-il' rFT wtrri G we sT{f,fu"o wrft gs uq iJqc4cl6l( d u'fr qfu e), ftTr-d fr-s-€ flT sTfuo.-{'rixqffino-*qtffi {rrERdc ftrrqtd dBi{ t-6 d qet ti q-EE fu-qr, ftil$ Fqler{ c]?l'..lql6l C qT{f,fuo rqqfWt x"ft (n qhilq\ tt q< Etoa ot{ orTqfu rrgf, Tfr fu-qT sq
Page 18 of 19
sTfi-d i. - os / 2o1B fuoo ge t)-i e+o fi.oz.zoo4 fr 6rFrrl r+ qS d Gr-dq-d d qrqro erfi-f,rrff i ei$ srffi d rrqer 3rTcfu 3il-Ac{ fu{ifr 03.05.2018 nqo fu-+r, wefu frr{ft fr fr86 cFrETrq d qrn fr,rtfr fi qk o) fr-oq orffi o) er$D-o o-{t tg r+ q{ 01 or-qE d qrqro ertcfu ntgo ori o-I 66 rfr ftq .rqr t r enqqx orEftqq o1 Be'q Efr d ftqq oo, or 3{ertrT 62 d ei-f,.fd ftrs qfuf, s) ei$r oTtrqrfr d ft--s-€ Gilqfu v-rgo ort o-r 6s' frqi .rqr B, Bqr-d fuq so t{ss of sqq rfin f+ffud f, \'s o{fi-drfr qeT o-r qe od fi {ffi q},s rfr d fu qrflftq uffig.ra wr q[qr-f,q Ertr ceFI srfta o-r M dkd *i ft-{rfr 0s.04.2018 t ifi-q {tqr oilcfu nrg.r o-{i dl vrrq qftqr rrurqr st.q t, orqq ot qR orfi-dreff d qe{ t qmfi-q Edrr-rT6 tszzl -q lq lc{ q i qrqrloTfi-d {Sffi fuqr rqr for, c-c olqrq erftareff t-nr oq-c qx tlcnoT en, fo-g 're qmfi=q E-d-ir.rE s@ qnn-f,q i Grft-dTeff d qrqq'-,
6) fr clr"hq c-fr qrql G vnq fr crqB qlfu-d fl+fR-d os f+qr, e-e oTftdrQff d ca t ffi( irqfu d rqs GTamr 3nfuqs d tq-q q oH rft cRRerfr TS B I W{ o.xur g*r fi-s or q-d t ot qq-fi oTffi i sffi-dTeff gM q-{gd oil-qfu orT-}c{ ft-im os,os.zora o) r+ qS d oiil{rd d w-qro nrg.r Eti d o-rqq sfuo w i\ frwd fu-qr t t 3s. d qq orft-mT?ff o) fuoq of .r$ qqo irqfu d rqs o-r Erqr o-ri or ot$ ro qrrftq EfdHre BEEI qTtI]Eq trrgr eelq orfi-f, q fiBa trq Hr6 05.04.2018 d c.qrd elq c-& arT, d-q oTftfl;i. - os/2018 orfi-f,r?ff o) qilft arffi d rrqa frffi rft eilqr tr{ ftdrft oTffi "1 g+t ti or t-o qS cc-f,r \'q frk6 e-o d erTrs i orfrdTeff se{ ol qs n-d TSqT-{i qtq l-fr t o1 qiffi oTffi sm of G fr-6s offi Ts ltd wrtrfrfre rc/- ((s) sqt qB,iq htir d enTrs d fqB of ge q c[q t r
36. d qq orfi-f,rrff qer o1 ft-o-q o1 .r$ .i.ro sqfu w ot$ fr'E-fi vscr slw rfr t ss ffi orffi ") g-+O ti or ofi eE-o ro c-& t, oq orfr-dT?ff qei gM nrgo effi-a o) orq frr€ GEetI q{ Xq ds w qrterT o-{i of omm{fi*flr tq rS ra rnlfr t 3t Bqt-ffiq{rri fr-A-{rT t q-fl sr[forq or M t of qi1fr 3Tts-.rTft gRr ilq-fr s-{-{ur O.A.E.X. B1/2ooo i crRd q-|qr Rlt-fi zsos. zore d qrqq rt ergftroaf/oTfi-dreff oTfr"f, Rr6 d rmr q-{go oilcfu srT-}fi fuqro' 03.05.2018 o) ftwfl o-{i t mt$ near-flo 3{Qrqr &drftf, ZE rS o1 .d t., s{elh orfr-dTaff HRr wgd erfid silErrr$-{ Et"fi{ ft{ifl frrn qri ql"q i'r
38. a\ qq orft-flrrff gxr c-{gd otft-d olqrr8-{ t, e-q otrnEo qeT o} cr-srd-{ff HyirTc GrrlE-{ zzoe/zozz fu{ro fi:1.2022 d qBqq ii erilfua daqfech' orarqr frff6 fr-Eerl o) srfi=d d qrqq rl sori oi ro rf-on =rS fuqt qt r{o-flI I
3e. tr?rtrrcrT rrgo efnfu 3rrifi zzoa/zozz ffio 10.11.2022 ft-wfl fu-qr qror t t oTftd =i. - os / 2o1B
40. qRqrqf,: orfi-f,raff gRr q-{gd Hrrfr-{ furiftd orfr gv ftwn of qrfr t r
41. orTtYr of cfr d nv vgfr erDmrft or oTmq il.rir d t orrerr g-d qFlr6r-q t en:q krro. pltzozq d qtfua fu-qT t t2- \\' orfi-d A s{dY{ ffi6:-12.11.2024 q--d) ffiqqffi,
9. em.0 q.c.G ud-qrra
Page 19 of 19
Loading citations and judicial treatment…