Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
MR GANGARAM SINGORIYA vs PUNJAB NATIONAL BANK on 18 November 2024
olrq y. tx -oz/zozq
m"r cEfr sTtro.-{rr s{dgr
fitariv q.i r-ffitr.rd g1@)
(ffi{ oTDrorft - qrftq fr vrq ft-qTq c-}d)
olx. \. iq< -oz/zozq
J
rrrn-{rq fu61 gqp.1
sz qS qrPff fi-qr$
nr.ilRqr, qrg
Agkft tqqT
@
qrilrq tqTTf, t-o gxr rrsT resrfi,
orqfilq zo *ta nrx trq{r firftflr
tr{ ts,
irmf, EE6@r fr€ anr ttfuT
srqt+i-i 18 gr+qgcl=rd qRqT,
tq-r as WTrq Pzois (ERut"Tr)
qrq fr \-,n
sr-qt-fl.d qfi-f,d
c
gq.rgm< griT
tnrqfmq -1 qg{q
ch IC,ll( q I
slwmtc
{JlqTt{E, 11-{sI{ r-tr{Sq
wd-d, gq.gq.18 d qNT
gqqTf,)........ .......vcrerftp11
orfi-f,rpff qsT A fr\ fr vq.eil-r.
tgr{ eftq-mr
trtrqrft E-flrr 1 d fu fr erEq
qmqfr
.effi-opff I
Page 1 of 14
or{ g. iqt -oz/zozq
{q-r-frq erfu+mr t
dtufr
B-f,rqrfr oqio s of *i t ot
sqRro r€t r
3TI t
ET
2.
nqo frri .ri gr-iTfr-dtm-{ 3na-fi or r{dq'
{fl etFT{ t sff Grdso t {a g*{.q. t rtgo rr{il'rm Gl-ilfi s672/2023 fuqro ze.rt.zoze d vtpl (vi@-i zs) t (\'+ffii za) d etrrilw u-tgo ftd r Xa uriler fr Fiffi r) ti (vier zz) o<r d (ffitfq rtgo frri, ffi qrtqq t m-.r v{fir \'q silEq-iq r1a-n o) orqrftr frrd qri o1 {r-fl-rrd-r m.ft vs rffir{ d qrtqq t e-{flfuf, oeat e\ {f, ysq. t q}-.s-fi ftrr+--{q ftt}
vrt or 3r-gtq fusr, fuE Giltffi ceT o\ orfu-d s6r{raT rl(ri rdl o1 Tg I fr gv,ro crors-dt oT
3{Td)o-q fu-qr rrqr, fun orrq qrql 13 (3) d or-f,,f-d frrr rlan d fr=f,€ ts-dTfr .T{ 3ilqft ot B-srf,iT r-fr frrd qB d oea w rfr fr-qn * ;1 vlor I
K
(fuq* $.tt.zozq d dft--f,)
1. sricr gM ?rd griTffiteq srd-dn qrqT 14 w orTtyI +z rfr.fr.rfr. HEcRir irrfiift gqa zooz d yrqqri\ d stro {fl oTD-m{q d grr rfl.q. 4oB/2021 n qR-d enA{r ft-{io- 23.01.2024 o-r griTffion frrn u.ri & n-r* 17.02.2024 o) gti GIBfi-{q d wqer rrgo fu"+r .rqr t, u) rrq-q ftqT d eiqs tl {
Page 2 of 14
snr g. iqt -oz/zozc
3. snn{r seT o-r ent erft-fien t fu .iqrq tcrd t-6 t ftqi6 sr.os.zorz oi ymrso-c eiqq 6r u-Ctoer +g +t Tr-{s dr$-{ d ffid o-rd fu-qr B, ul d-r or erri-e gir o{i d s(fw t Graq ord fuqr rrqr t frrs qrq fr offi ; fr tn d nrq qlqr ers fuqT te qnol-tr ftfl, fu{$ fr-{-q @tg oTffi T& at .T{, wqfu qcfu q-.q +ft orq6 u* s-rEf, \'f,.Gtsil-$. q'tr ?dr, ftflrd frqq n wqBr oqio 37i / zo23 frtq ;qmfiyr q-ssrft d qrqro-q t cd B t v+rp.r 6 ffiow t fu vmwrfr il-fi A am qrq fr o-qfr t gift r{& or eil.0.gfl. d GrqR w q-m-{or o\ sqq ryd o-r trrrmr fuqr, q-qb c-{9f, ftri Tt R'cilqn orr'ff{ d erlE]ic c{ qIE oxq fuo< frfro rror t, E-qfu vtrwrfr +-fi i onA-q-fi d GIIqfu G[a-qq qNI 13 6-q1 r1t$,fi \r+d 2oo2 ol qqltr q crqqdi fl -wqq fuqT B, fun onq Equt odqf F-{w frtd qTi dFq t I
4. ent erft-oel-c t o1 W slk6qur d wqer t-fi grr q-qd frd Td q-qrq ftqro ps1.2024 d q'qerm-d +dyr dyfi-f,rf, i ,roo oeiT tsr fu-i t yq enilqo or R-Wr$"si ft{p6 tz.ot.zozq t\ fr-4ri fr =r& ft-qr .rqr t gq erurtt qy rkrfl grqTmoc ail'ff{ lffon or s-.q?ff d ft-s-d qgr 3e 11qffiq{e d oidrff, (I€IGIfi oTffi o-{i gs srfr t vq'a o1 .r$ a"r rfrr z+ooooo/-(*ft*r ars) q| r5o aq reooooo,/-
Page 3 of 14
3rR q. iw -02/2024 (erq6rr6 oru) tqn qrsr Htr( qFNI frsti w eTffi ffi znr sr-jirT fo-qr t t
5. smrqTfr qer t griTfucilcn-{ Gli-fi or ot{ ftfu-d qqrs e-{gf, Tfr fuqr .rqr t t
6. 3nil{o- qm i {s grrtmmq qfrtui ot E-{Trg d +irc friro zs.oz.zozq d u-go ffi ,t-d' sloRq q-ifi 4tlo / 2024 ftqr6 zs.oz.zoz+ d cnqq t qftftfr oeql fl orBfiQfi fu-qr rrqr t I qe+r o-q o-r euf{ fu-qr .rqr B qs qrricr d 3rfl.ff, snieT fu{rfi 23.01.2024 o\ erqr< frri qd et rrarcror qrfr .r$ t t T6 erq oTdRq Grla-fi en$.q. azsr / 2oz4 d qrtqq r] frfu-d n-d d w t eTftR-n 3rftn?rc fu-qr wr t t o-€frq fi kirfi 2l.oa.zo24 d qrtqq t ,fr od rtgn fu-qr rrqr B r frfuf, e-d u-qo fu-qr wi, fusor Tcq erMR B al eq erk+rrr grt qm 17 rrl$€ gd d q-fl.fd ftirqr gfl.q. t qrRf, Gnicl d griTfudtf,{ or ot$ srkf,ri r-e t, qfu frR( qk d qnl 18 Ea+ffi g-f,d d qrsqTcTgqx erfi-d q-qd o-ri or ao fl-w t t
8. sf,.qrfr cm of *i t qmfiq q.s. s@ qtqtdq d Em qrts ftfrq dqdft fr--{-€ rtcq tr{itro 3Tr{.fr.orr{.fr3n{. iln fufr}s zoro (e) vq.ft.
Page 4 of 14
srn g. iqt -oz/zozq ga.d. ooo d cffi{d fu-€Tf, o\ sdfud ort gv erqM o-*r$ .r{ t't e. sffisrfr seT o-r qe,fr ird t ol gfl oTBst{rr i ftt<R Ttro. oeqf a1 fril+tr o-q ertfl q'R'f, fuqr t, d qR 3rrtffi qrkd oTr-i{r i\ frBd t d\ vt\ S. srrr.q.A. d rrqer elfi-s c-{gf, orcr anftq pfr, Brpr fr e-d rsr .rqr t fo q< onild-o i sf,rqrfr d-fr d o.rqtdq er-qx Hq-d-flr o-rt or et-jtq fu-fl \'q e-trts rrgo fuqr, fus w fr-qrv o-q qtolfuf, ft{16 oo.rr. 2021 ffioR ft-qr rrqr \d 3Trtrq-r t qr$itar qrRr qqr fu'qr, oq d-r vo^t"g 3Tri@ qa ot qrqtl fu-d Ti t {fl oTiErr q{ Tq( grirmloc ail-nc{ Fwfl frd qri or q-gtq fu-qr t r
10. vq-q sel d nd d e-{l-il t gs effi-o-*q d T{qeT v6 qra ffiq cq{ t fu "qqr gfl eikocvr 6m gqTg 4oB/2021 t cIR-d 3r-t{r furf, 23.01.2024 dr.q t"?
11. serrrfl: q6 s-dq+q t at Grdffi am fuqio 2s:o:oz1 ei G{Bo-tq d wqeT qr{t 17 wffi vre zooz d qrqqriJ A trd r*6 urd-et d qrqq t w{ 3nq-q o-r q-oqq trqo fuq fu irmd ardfoaqy il€ sc qRilqt pl qEq o-roi B, ii\ E-stT ffidqa oT drs-€r-{ vq fftRtT o-{t t yq vd-gqrft oriro g qrq8fr vfr rqr E*@i i srffq-r t r+qd os
Page 5 of 14
3rR q. tq{ -02/2024 tcmd Erdfm-mw +g of drs{r vs ergsn A frqq t qrn-mT-ft to-t 3nA-q-n o\ zq ti tE ffid fuqT, fus fryq tt vo er-grrrr 3r'fir W s-m-t-qrfr e'qio 3 d qq ftqi6 ro.or.ro17 ffio E3rr, fus ffif,d d Gtrr.ff, q1d ogi t-g erTiqfi I soooo,z-(v-um rurr) sqi ,rfr qIE frtt .ri --vnpr fr erq.rd o-slqr rr{r.q,1 tzooooo/- (crmq arv) vq$ sf,rqrfr *fi dlr tTT, ftrnrl soooo0o,/-(E-ffin' e.ls) sc-i of ergcn vRr qIH a).ft t il{grl-i sf,t-{rfr d-fi i 4oooooo/-(qrtr$f,r-q) sqn fiSflc qrw, uaaoo/- (qrorors rie-a rqx d c) $qn d frrq rfrqn fuqr, ftrfl-+t rawr ter+a cdfm-d-si e)_d smrqrfr qfiq z o'r qe ftffi zz.oe.zora d ffaq t fr T$, F6-d r$r{d srfu tnr futrrq oir}eo 6) ftqr6 rz.o+. 2021 q1 fo-+r rrar, frrg qe funo ze.os.zota d ffaq t s-misrft e'qto z t erq.ro otrqr of q-fr ei-ss'q\-wfl or eil-ilcrq ftwd fu-q-r w go-r tterr fi-q nq fril frfu fuim 01.04.2017 qrrrfr fu-i .R {qfu erra-q-r t cqn q* rrrrfl T{t-6r{ o1 qa fu€-w G[]qo d yroruT o-r T{: qfteTrr frrn q.fi or ergtu fulr W vf,t-qrfr qqw z o\ fi orsit-fi u-rgo fuur ,fuE ol-tfl fuio 2i.11.201s + ci-gtrx silqrnfi ftrr< or frqr rTqT, aq Gia-q-fi cer t vtrw[fr @-qlqt s d fr'{-q gfu-fl RcY-i (d qt{rqr r Hefi qrqrf,-q i q,
Page 6 of 14
sTn g. iq< -oz/zozq qkqrc rqa fuvr frfuo galr ift-d frtqr, fu-i .fr ffif, sq * ffit oT UTfl-r s-idr {6r I
12. oil-tEo seT o-r 6pr"r r6t t o1 s{S clq Tfr *i d onq vierrqrfr d-r i Grd-<-fi d dli vmrsu-e ol yc.fr.q. sfted or frqr, oq entro t dc qeT qrt of ersqeidr q.re o-ri qT qqmd-ilii d frt-q ot$ 6rffi c o-{i or ergtu fuqT, fu-{ vffisrft i-fi t {rqr$ qr< e-{i a1 @ti ilsdi T& ftsrfr t rrq-q rftql d Gicr 3rra-qq fi u-go =r& fu-qT, qfu Ft-{ r+Eo dri d $ A enqt orq d fus yq ees $ tg GrrA-{r o-r \-{'rsu-e EIET qrfl 3il'qttrq fu-qT rqr, qqfu GTd-{r or ffiqe 3ra-q-{ ftwn dr gfrI er I sfl frq-q i Gr-a-{o cq i +fi $rFI st qz ifufl fuq r
13. sirt qftEQrc frtqr rql t fu flft fi-q strwrfr t-f, d gRr fr-rr q++ funo 13.04.2021 vq eilEEriq Wcr fuirfr 18.0s.2021 (\-i@r q,/zz) ift-f, o1 .r$ eft t u€ oeat ol e-r1d ys.q. o-T e{TEIrq e-Tr6-{ frl q+lt \ti sIIETs ta+qr o1 3FIrkI frtd UIri ot gs 1T6r{f,r d nreT er< ergwiFro sartctr or ergtu frrqrrqr t r
14. 3r-i'Eo seT i \s\dfufl €t S drirl ftqrm' za.r.zoze o\ u-*go frri Td {yirn urnqq 6 nrtac t {frrt ewrfuf, or Tf, qfl.q. t oEgoi-s. ze t s.sz gq rrso-s oidq, Gr-g-d)q a1-dilq t trErqcn <--
Page 7 of 14
srn g. tx -oz/zozq qH or oTgtq fuqr, fti-sd qrtqq r\ q6 des d-.€-iT qrsr fu fr'.r qqqr d ergrr< w.ft.g. of ftO Aqro 3i.o3.zoz1 qyffi T{, q-qfu d}oqr-f, d rrra u-qo q-qrq t ftqi6' sr.os.zozo d y,ns t dq vmls!-e g{ fr.q.s.ft{-d fu-n qri oT oaFr fu-qr .t-qr r s{rar fr qt.siT qra o1 3rtffi qa i fr-q qaqr Rirfi rs.oa. 2021 d frvq fuqf, otqrnfi qlgd fuqT, fu=g sf,rqTfr ilo i erqd-ec q-{ fuqR frr} fr'-rT fr qnr 13 G-q) d GlEnfr?F x-qqni trr scdqi ord gv sirE.rrrq Eq-cr iBfl fu-qT r trrq fr er.q osal oT GIftoafi ord gs elrd-{6 o) &Tffi qri or srr qle frrn sd d frsq t o?z\ or rfr cisiq{ e-{flhd fuqr rlzlTt 1s. otrlef, ceT a1 siri t e-{gd \rfl.q.or frfu-d qqrq gmEqrfr t-fi d drtl fr=irf, e.o1.2oz4 o\ u-qo Q-{d Eq fr-'r gtrtr G ofl-fuTiq ta+tr ifuo fun qrt +t o-rffi o\ dq wre ord gq qfuqrE fu-qr qqr r tyma er$-o-c-qr qld d am fufio 14.12.2023 yEf, frri d fuqo u-+ro d qrqq t{ qrn{fi qel 6Rr vf,{sTfr e.qTq- 2 d fr-s-€ T{'.q. t frr} T} 3rft-firrrl or yfr-qrE fu-qr .rfl, fu-{ orTnqo qeT grr wgd {jcNfi 3il-ne{ a-r q.iltr sm-{qrfr qa o1 3]t< t nqo TS fu-qr rqr, qfr$ sfltcr qkfl ftqlo rz.or.zozq d qrfln ilT orrAq{ oT +fuo 6qq frrqT rzn slT I
Page 8 of 14
qR \. f.q< -oz/zozq
16. eiao: gw 3rfuo-tq dnr qrfud sntyr furfi 23.01.2024 d ergrn eTrnq-6 ilt nqd vfr.q. g"r sls qr fuqR frri fu{r fr w oilErR qr ft-fl( a1 .r$ a 3rrBrs q.r-rr ft=iro ft.0s.2021 d ssq qK ol{q' fu u-otut vo' Ttr srrlEtt=I d nom fr r1q,i mq crrt1 or ti d orsq \-{l-su-c r*q d qri t 3iT,} Ei qri trq r€t t r gtdfr \'€rc oTrRilf,&i d gor B r
11. orEfi{q d e{rtcr ft{16 za.or.zoz+ t q-er 6Ymr sniqo sfl i q6 grqTmmq 3rd({ sFfd orurit w fuiro fi.02.2024 a) u-qo fu-+r t, dr nrq *ryq1 $ erci t t
18. vf,.qrfr cs of u\ qa sil-cfu B of gs sTEfi-iq ot trm 17 s{+ffi vf,e d efffi ue-go s-fi-{or fr q'fud frrS qH srd snMi ot g+*tffio-t o-{t q,t clfrerm cfr B't qa fto sf,wrfr qer d g{{ ild t waro .rS $ I orror of qriT rz (z) trt$nfr gqd zooz d irEstr ttrRI 17 (1) $-ffi grd d oid,fu u-qo ftrn ud srd errH fl ftqm-rq erx.S.S.fr. \9.. V{e tsss d crflril \'q Mt or ergrw o-rd Eq 6*lT EY-oI t vq qM 37 {Jl$r{fr g{e d org{aq {ir s{Dfu{q d vreqrq em.S.S.fr.\,s'.gerc qs er.q q'iilfr frfucJ d orfrR-ff t t erc rs-S {ilpi fr qni zz (z) (l) em.S.S.ff. v{d 1ee3 t rra srqqrh-f, B'ot mq e-r1ft Grkm-{q o't sTct trq A grsl.mE-r of vlffiq nw t Ys E t-c ffi Fqrd gfft-qr) $E{ '1ee3
Page 9 of 14
sTN g. iq -oz/zozq d Fqq Vs.q. d 3inrff, 3lfuf,-{q gM crR-d 3lricT d fi .Bd qfu ol so ft{s + Gi<t grrrffi-or onf(r u-rgo o.ri of eftrorR-or fr .d t r w srqqdi t tqg t of xq et{-dr 3rE-m-wT o) trm rg em.S.fr. gfd 1ee3 d trn urg-a ifiT 3rra-qi Grerqr qM rz (1) q{Sffi vqd 2oo2 d otrE u-qa frrd .r} eird-cq t qrRf, frrS qri srd eiftq or-tcl i cidRq snM d Aflq gqiThdrmn of qffi rrw t r 1e. qq oi{ -fr fi.Bir qfu {s slfuo-{q d wqei giirmoc arr'dfi u-qo o-ror B, dt vS E te ffi EEg-ff d ymrmrTflri ewr gqql q6 Edt=il +aT B of crfud ontcr d eexr Eqql u-ea <ff 2ft ft-qfln t gs qr$ Rerfr Gr-Ayr az ftqq r rft.ft.rfr. d etrE qrqwF-a t t zo. ua grerfuo frE t o1 fttS qlqrdq, slattiT 3{kfi{'r ol ere gqirmoq *1 6fo6 qrffi yrw drfr B, eTQ{fd qR crR-d GTr+cr fr tS o-}$ r.qa nft cfudlFf, c d, ftrfit crgqn fi-f,rirr w rr$ of qrq o-I Er=I $n t, eq e cF cfr{d olri{r q,t G{frq-f,r y+Trfuf, T& of BT rrfi-fr q-d fr frkf, qfu ot qrw srqn 3rfif, ql'q d, wr frfu'fi Rrdld o\ tqr{ t rvd gq erq qrrg. 4oB/2021 it qRf, Gn+$ frnrfi 23.01.2024 d S-r-iTfu-d)oq qq ft-qn fu-qr w ra t t
21. garrfl: ltE scclqfi-q t of q-g 3iD--ff-ivr d Sru gfl.g oT gET ds q{ F{roTq T€i fu-qr .rqr t c
Page 10 of 14
oln g. tx -oz/zoza fr frilft frfrrfud dea, orQtrn frfu qrt qrsr of .r{ t r 3rd-<-r ceT grt q-q( T{i.y. yfl orEtr{ qr ftrr< fu-qr .rqr t of vo gK sqrtTl-{ d trfiTcr d q.qoi, srRr qqT oq ti d o.rqq dh s-orgo-c s-drq d qd t $a$qft s-{cr{ srR,ilf,&{ d .rqr B ri u-qo r+clnrr onilfi .rfi {rfr srrrx s{ Uq dq w fr-qrs frri fu{r ft-{qr fr;qr .rqr t r
22. gg.q.4ogl2021 ongf, a-{ c[q-dtm-i fu-qr riqr B, fufl w clfrd sntcr fuirfi fi.10.2023 fl erq-eto-q ffy srqr qror t of f,4 fi fi sf,rqrfr t-r d sxr flfi emrq of ortqfr d orffi .rg aft at {fiirrFr tr{f,ttr Rim' 27.11.202t d q-+-Rr t qW iTRI wu d uri rt-{ d-{ gorsu-e ti< o-r frfl .rqr t W s-s'{ur srffiq-{ zh'q c-€t B, fu-d sil-nff ce{ i ilT 3rgtq or sfuqrE fuqr Ts olBfi-{q d am ent s-m-iur goT sts w F{ro.wr tg frqT qro-s 3ifrq ild a1 frf} Rqro os.rz.zozs ftqtfrf, o1 T$ t qS fiq errtEo qa d[{ q-qf, Tiyilu{ sfl-trdr-{ q{ ETr qrqx q-{-ror sntqT tg Fq-ir fu-qr rrqr vq ficilw{ Grra-fi 6r frqrqxur a-{i d nrq fr s-w qFf-o oriqr{ q{ on-d-{m q&T E-rq e-{gd \ryr.g. d srTt qffiGrt q}rq r fi{r foiiRd o-ti gs Tfi.Y. o-r ft-{rfi-i"r o-q ftqr rrfl t
23. qe srBmrq Grntfud qTtcT ti u-.ua q:ff nE itdrl t, dt crdr t of mfo p.01.2024 o-) srq qsT o\ oridf,o qsT FM u-*go ftri Tn trnfi eiltfi srd
Page 11 of 14
sln q. tx -oz/zozt \. s672/2023 tffis 24.11.202s w t:c-qr$ tE ftqT rrqr QtT I rFqd gs! gq qls qr E-i qri tr.q t qr rfr, qs G-g w vrq ot c-S g-{r .rqr edr, slediT GTril{o qq o\ {s frE q{ srrr-{T ca {qi oT GrtNN ft{io 12.01 .zozq d T€t ft-dr, fu "Eqr q-q{f, w.q. snt GrFrqts{ qt'q c-& t'r
24. gtd oTFrR-fir ere nft ca rfr t fu w Xd at or-tcr qFdor fuim fi:'o.2ozs t wq t at orra-{+. rIH q6 }rrre .E{ Tor en of cg q-{-{ur o-t guT ds qq ftqm-{q qrrcn B, vs-+t [rft gor d q-6-ru t 'sf,l-qrfr qer o\ q-o.{or d wqrs e-{g( "ri or ft{qr td gq c-o-{or d g"r dq qq ftgro-rur frr} qd ol Aq (d or q-cnqq Gifrq ird fu elFro fu-qr rrq'r, ilq orri<o qa o\ {s qro o-r GrrNR ftn fu{r fu qqT een-q,r ers ert 3rFrqt-w{ dr.1q q-€f v6 Trrr t t wf<"ir t srBf,-iq grr q6 qn fuqr qnr fu sil-i{fi griT elgd qfl.(. srli srfttrcq fr.q =rS t, q-a tttT onirr t E\ 3rrn@ ca a\ S-{qrg o'r GrtNN fr} fu{r crRd fu-qr rrqr t, d ffif-r qrq ftreio d uft-o^a t r 2s. 016l Sfl frFo Reifr w fr-qrr fu-qi qrq fr "cqr sniqm qeT Errr rrliEnq c-Krq d qtqq t fuItRf, vrRr or 5rrf,;t o< ti qn t unr ra (+) ti Bqq qrq o.nq gilftilsfr{ d qror t", o\ qq GTd-ffi seT srsT t qa o-a 16l B o1 sm-{qrfr t-fi d HRr ds nli orffi a1 T$ t'r gs orrq q6 {iT
Page 12 of 14
3rN g. tx -oz/zozt q-frqur er g"r drv qq ftrrwq qrror t, e-c alrt{fi frr .Bo csT o\ gw dts w g.{qr{ o-r erqrrr ftm{r sIEq, drfu vs+t eqeTr oT {ur drs w ft-trowr fuqT rnsdt
26. gc cRfurfut fr gn fio o-r qd t of gn.q. qoa/zozt fr crtrd 3IrfE fu{rfi 23.01.2024 tl u-.qa Eyf ZE fuqqn t, GrQrfd srrleo qeT oi gtr fug w fu "eqr u-qo W.V.urt g,T ds w e1ftq}f,i q\''q r-fr t', qr 3rrrqr csT rsi el 3rtr-{N frn ft-fl fr 3il-taT qR-d fu-fl .rqr B, irq q'Rf, 3iltsr k{rfi 23.01.2024 a1 cRfu tt t, orsrfd orrdq-6 qeT grr u-rgd griTmroc aTra-fi ftqq s q E ffi rql-d (effiql) vd{ 1ee3 vq snisr +z ftqq r rfr.ft.rfr. d qrqqrc\ d tro griTffimq tg sFtf, gq 3iluri fuqqrc t t wr o-nq fts ol rfl t aff urieo 6rT u-rg( sil-n({ {+f,R o-s y$.q. 4oB/2021 fr qlR-d entcr fuir6 2so1.2024 ot eur{ o-r eniro qeT gxr e-{9f, vfl.t. 4oB/2021 [d at Ra{fr t Uqdq w gi q-i tg grierTe( fu-qr qnr arqkd t sfuf, t r sTq fr u-rgo frrc 3Tl-]ei en{.s. gezz,/2023 qI .ft X"t sls w F-{rf,-i'r fu-qr qmr sfuo t t
22. qRqH q$v oTitr<-r seT gm e-ttrr srra-<q ffiori fu-fl q[f,r B t e-<r5rm 9fi. GIRo-rq ETsI gs.g. 4oB/2021 { q"Rf, Glrtyr kflo
Page 13 of 14
oTR q. iqt -oz/zozq 23.01.2024 oTrIrkI fu-qr qror t t qRurmd: ys.(. W sls qr E-{qd tg gl-ierTfrn o1 qrft B t
28. rfrr$ 6 ffiiro fo-qr qror t of Wq +oa/zozt ol Xa iqr w g"r dE w r5i qd tg qfr-q-€ fu-qr qrq vq vorqrfr .rq o) f*r fr,go +trfl ifud ot gro( tg .rrgf, fu-qr urq r 2s. q-d d wra r3ror$ tg vo.q. furffi oa.oz. zozs ol u-qa d r
30. eni{r o1 sfr gfl.s. 4oa/2021 q $6rq ot qrq I orrtYr gd qrrlld-rl fr etrs ftqio ra.r t.zoza d sift-a fusT r b'\\' 2\ wqdgi ftqis:-16.r 1.2024 fitl{flq 3rffi, O.em.fr q.c.gq E-ffi$rrd
Page 14 of 14
Loading citations and judicial treatment…