Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
VIKAS GOUR vs CENTRAL BANK OF INDIA on 19 May 2023
CONTD. ORDER-SHEET
DATE
19.05.2
PAGE No
REMARK
DESCRIPTION OF THE ORDER
23 1.
oH qrst ET{r s-o-rq s-qd 6-r eql-{
srroffid fu-qr .rqr fu 3Trt$ qBor fuiro rs.
05.2023 Vs crkd 3fftT friro ta.os.zoze ii sf,(-qrfr @-qrfi 3 d srk{ffir +fr srn.gc. {rq 6-r {H (d n dr6-r ffiq Tfi{cr sm-rqrfr o-qr6 3 or fr crq d dI ,rqr t t
2.
fr T{ qrrorft d q-sreT t onicr
qhor vq sntsr ft-{rfi ft.os.zo23 of oT"q eTf-d o-r ci-{dtm-{ o-q srqr qror B ot vf,rqrfr e-qio o d eTE{ffir aft erR.gc.{rq o-r qlrr ontcr qhol G or-tcr t qd q-€l t I
a-{gsri d frrt qri or or-tfl ft=qr qror t r
3.
sTr-icr of oiq eri-d i sf,rqrfr
oqio g o-r qlrr ZE {of ed B, ffi gux
fu-qr qror t t we fu-qr qror t of ao ertvr q sd fi e-orqrfr oqio g o1 sn( t fr frTf,r ftsn Grfusffir d t, +fr erx.gc.rr-q orB{frr q6r qrq gq vorqrfr oqro s oT
qm frqm-r ftril gfr 8fr frk frm c6r sr-q t
4.
s-m r{cilBfl 3r-t{ ot gr: efi-r e(-+
oTq-ifs fo-qr qrq t
ffi{3Tffi
S.eirq.O q.q. gs r-d-s.ra
CASE No.
qld)
srfid qql- 7 /2017
urr qqft 3lBfi--{ur q-{dg(
(qwrtu gi uffislg vq)
(ffi{ qffi - qnfrq *fr qrq ft-qrs q}a)
3lfi-f, =rw -t / 2oi7
Citations and Judicial Treatment
Cited by
0
Decisions in the index citing it
Cites
0
Decisions referred to
In this index
0
Of the decisions it cites
Overruled / Questioned
0
No negative treatment found
Loading the citing and cited decisions…
This judgment in the centre: on the left the decisions it cites, on the right the decisions citing it. Colour is the treatment; choose a decision to open it.
1. ffors .ts er-flq fr d.d. tht sq o-te zs q{ rorq dqq z+e t{ fr6n o.ra}fr, 3nfift sffi+rsr qa .ilr trrrET fre ern.qs.ern'fr q-{dg{
2. q-fi qkr ?ir 3Tt-irq sft fr d.ft.'ilq gq ?Eftq sg q{, t z-fi-afr uga 'il{ oTrfrru fr qtcr 'ilr ss tnte zg qS t z-fi-+ffi dFqr .ils Tfr fr q.tqT 'its sq otq so q{ ffi 232,tffi ze d ofto-{-< (ERqrq-D- erftarefrrrur t fud-q
1. ee--d t-6 SF strsqT, tEa eft.fl "-qgd qrftT{ q'{e, 5w$ +ooozr qra ql-td fr-q qq.fr.qqfrETQffdrd cqf,W I
z. M fr% flTE fr-q e)qrtgq {rra q-srE qro-B qrq €qtEft mqT qTd-qr€T q-q-dgi fuqtq sTftf, ;irt- t /2017 q-s-dgi F-qrw 1760 St fr erss d ftd q-ftqrd frRt'r +ftdrd qqf,g{ I
3. AqoT frm S-S sft fttq fr+n sq o-ftq zs q{, zr srdiqrsT ts qo-sdr t-s,d qNI oTr$ qrff-qIsT tida qq qY-E A gw eilTt ,qqf,g( -----gorqrftrrur t (qqft. vffiqrft o-qio r to frt stri fr aft eroq qTot etkq-m t ffi daT vf,{qrfr oqrfi s of oft t ,fr 3Tr-r.\'q.{-q otBrmr t 3nt{r (eno ft-tio 18.0s.2023 6f qTRd)
1. 3{ft-flpff <ru q6 erfta qm 30 (1) ern.S fr. fr.qq..cn$\q.. 1ee3 d ersqrrEelr q{S GTffi o"qi6 1 gM 1M{d [fi{q oqto d.q. $.q-tr.2r /zoos ti qTRd 3Tl-tcr fu-o' ot.tz.zol: d fao-c u-qo tht q-{ t, fus Grrtqr 6 gs e-qfr GTffi i oTfi-fletr qH gNI u-qo umfu Gil-ifi id"iro 1s.11.2.12 o) ft{w oq frqt q-qr t
2. €etq t rfi{q {fl qtDTq t o1 M fr% cqre dq d Mz{ qrrf, ffirq q-o-g d oTfi-dieff sqT of 3tti t fr qlfu( tq{ qBrm t v oTfrd fr<- t /zo,tt anr smwrfr E-qio r te,a t-o. dw gtrsut t x"r ffi q{ fu{io 17.i2.2002 d ergwx z.ry qrw fu-qr eil, fus x"r +t $eil tg {.ra srsrq qrg i ffiil erqa qqfu of d-o d ottft{ Eiero. frqr w, fu-g Xq t5't Urffl-{ q 6-{i d Oftur T.rf, qT"-g 6I Xq qrf,r V{.ft.{. ffi d q,tr-qd Een gq B-drqrfr t.fi d grrr xur rq-fr tg fu{io o6.s.2ooe of gs oTBo-r'r d *rrGI ei.q. .i+t 31 / 2oos q-qd fuqr, fuq-6r ftrroa"r fuil-o 14.07.200s o) gs 3TBo-ruT d gM qrRd ffq d norvr fr qrqr M frqr .rfl"\'q M trq qi qr1-fi tg eqo qqfu qr) f{o--q 6-{ mur eqdd of eqqfr t?r gq cgff rm.r q+ t-qx fu-qr .rqr Tq 3rBo-iq d s{fr orenrft of qq-fr orffi tg ifud tuqr r
3. erfi e1q5* t qfr qqdr oTffi A FM srrT o1 .r$ q{fr offin$ d u,1qreff7umM gm serq sitrcR q{ rqd 3Trqfu 3Trfqq ft{Fn zg.or. zors ol ft-{w fuqr rrqr 1d vqff 3Tffi grur {6 fufRd fu-qr rrqr o1 qrqfuffif d sm q-Ffd q-gv frqr d EMoT t qrffi Trilq qz d qpfd qqfu ft-q tr
4. oTfi-dTeff qa o1 3n{ * erlt sft-fiem fu-qr rrqr of qq B-trq-qrfr i-fi d Hrtr gq: ffir otffi qRr+I o1 .r$ G ffi q-{iT ffiio 17.10.2011 s-oTRrf, of .r$, ils sffi{qrfr Eqio. z d we gi orTfurs dt qqfu A fryq d otffi s-trrBd Eti oTfi-d ;i+t- 7,/zo1t fr eifi-metrq"r d gm r{fr oTffi d wra gr, oTMfu orqrnfi ,rqd fuqr rrrT, ffi orffiu oTDlolfr gm gq qtq w fuqri frri R--fl fr {s orrtTn w ftEw o-s fuqr .rqr of $ d enqM am e-qd srsq qTqfu ortqril<ll fu{ff fr-qr qT T+l t, fus oxq qrg arir d fu€if, t GilqM o-r oTrilfi erfud B r
5. oTrt olfrf,ptr qfl o-r sTkoerq t of derfi IHqfu d q)ur qrfiqrsr u.a.i. +a7u furo qrqr fut ttz / 1 Tttt iq{ so,/e gd +*q.d 18zs qrfrlte t I {df,: EqTq ffi \q i\ftqT qd qutnEr at qqfu efr, ffi Euft qfu ri.ra uqrE q'g d gr{r fu{io 11.0e.1ee7 d fro-q qe d rTrr4-q g qq fu-w rrrlT err I ild,.qc-qra q.ra q-srE qT"-t t gm qrqfu or Tfr ,Tt-[ q-d et{w-d 1612.6 q.ftfi-c ft-{i6 11.12.1s08
o) orft.f,retff ffi orfi-dT .ilq @t ft-oq fu-qr vq tq ,il-.t f{flo 28.03.2002 d gd dzqo clclq{q Icl 22s q{rhtc fr--6q ?D-r RqT t, ct6[ v.Fr qqfu srq-mffi 6qio z d enBq-s fr {S t. A-g * q-rd[rf ae;q o] q-{tq.r o{i gq e-qfr GTeFrff ET*T orfi-dptr qeT rnl Gilqfu orqrlrq fr{w fu-fl .rqT, q-{fu G)r qqfu Td fr fr fr6-q of w gafi ,fr, s€-d frq-q fr yfwd dE [f t fo sorqrfr d'o
o) vm qqfu o) ffi fu6q 6,ri or otg 3TEo-n Tfr *, Gt sqfu B-ffiqrfr t-qr d onEqs fr .ft T€f t, fo-{ B-f,rqrft tio x"fr qfu t sszie tnq, o'fr fr etrfi Eqfu oT qtfu6 rs-emFr q€f fuqT, q-qfu aTftd i;eJ.- t /zott fi"ft qfrf, of erq qqfu $d-dgq tt furf, t, ffi xq q{d frrqr qr q-.ncil t q-q q{ff orffi srrcT o-{i t T{ d-6 sm q-ffiqr dfufi-d trfiqur fr qmfi-q B.EkrrI ail-qt?rtr EnT frEItR-d frvrr frffi or ,ft qrf,{ Tfr fu-qT rqr t srftareff qer o) E-flr$ oT dol fi TS kqT .r,qr Tq ffi tg q-fi-rfud qqfu w ot$ qan ,fr qtqr q-St ot T$ | {ff ors"r 3Tftf,pff qm Bftd qrq w erq-fr GTrqfu d T€t zn{r sot I
srrcr qH or efftq ad gql ,rqr t t
6. ont rm rfr ormo"rrq t at qdi oqe gq qwa o-r ril-rrdT d qEt ts-qffdeT d fuqiil 3ilotrd q€f d-fr, Eq-d qrq fr {fu vf,rqrfr to am trwrfro ot .r-$ d-fl oTtrrur=r ffiB.T A frqq fr ma*f qer t utqfu q$ ow+r t, rq twqfid-cT o-r ot{ l..Trq fi q€t t, E-{rd qTsT fr qmfiq BzEkrrI qpficrq d erqgErd d {iEtr-d orfr gq otre $o qr< frt .r{ M d qffi q qfi-drpff qeT gm q-gd'orqrilfi g"T dq w gi qri q}.q rarfr gv cqfr etffi sm qrRf, qrt€r d dq n f u.re o-ri gv effi-a srq{ d vdri .rt orqTRt q{ Irqd oTft-d {ft6I{ ov egfr oTErorfr d oTr*T fd;il6 01.12.201T o) erq,m frd qri or orjtq fo-qr rrqr t gs uffi q-qfu o\ ffi olffi t 5m frtt qTi o-r HTgT fr qft-f,Ieff qei d oTrBq-6q o\ {iTi vst or q-SitT fo-qI Tqr t t eTftd iqt- t /zolt srr.r rTeT o1 frr t ftfud ild fi rqo fui .rt dr
e. srrr se{ o) E=Ti d qrard {q 0-d d sqer Tfi'qra ffiq qw t o1 "eqr "rgfr otffi x"r eqd sTH-o--{q q-q-dg{ gr-{ wR-d 3il-Acr ftqro or.rz. zorz (ga6q \/v) Aq Wf eloq orqrw frrn qri qtq t "?
10. 3Trnffi qs of 3tr{ t erfi-a srq-q d srq u-qo frri Tt ffiTrNl o-r Gi-f,elm-{ o-{ qFrr qror t at Grft-flQff va i cqfr qffi d wqer ftqq 11 (i) ffiq q-gq-fr 3il-q-cn{ orfuF-qq rsor saqfua fuqq ra S.erx.0. (ffiw) (ftw rsse) vo \dvn zr S. ern.fr. tglcrq l eea d srqqr+ A Grf,.f-d 3ilqfu enlqrle{ gsgd fu-qr rrcn srT, d gs sTB6-irr ot sqrrd: B-f,{qTfr qs o1 Gft t sdrfr .r$ gs qriFro qTqfu w fr-qn o-rfl t of eqr orq-dletr qa o\ q{dr oTffi grr qrfud oTrtqT ftiTo ot.tz:ott d i{s€ Efr oTBfiwr d wqa qfr-d rtrg oqt 6-r E6 r+or t, 3Terqr orar tofu-fr sqqr-q vqffir t t
11. B-f,{qTfr qer o1 fr{ t d-d d *qn arrrrq z16 qcq silq foqr rrqr t at qq oTfi-drTeff qa d ErqT q{fr Grffi d sqa Gil-rrcn{ sTEf{qq rsor ot trftq q:qfr fr qT.qETrfud ftqq r1 d u-tDRI q q.+T G ffi otffi d fr-s-{ ailqfu enqtr<t qqei fu-qr rrqr err, d fttw fo-ql rrqr t, oq qq-f,pff o] oE-f, Fqq 11 G) d qrcqmrjsn HHq q!-6ft -rltqtdq t qrq rqd o-r+r qr, u} =rS foqr .rqr,
8. sTftd fsr.- z /zott fug $s orBo.-{ur d sqm erfi-a q-qd o1 T$, d (frott
12. GTfi-fletr qa of frt t u-qo frrt .T-t frfu-d n-d d qrtqq t rdTt Ti R-g"n d e-orqr ti q{dl orffi grtr vtRd oil-t$ ft-{m 01.12.2017 d g+ft A .r$ t. fti-sd strf, 116 dP{ fi t a1 q{ft qffi t gs dsq rR fd-dri r€f frqT t of Td d qTqfu orqinfi fu6q orffi d erswa E) qri d ors"r ft{w gcdr en rry qrqrilq-ff GrIqfu or}qrilqq on-rrfir orBfrqq rsor q,t trfrq 3rjqfr d ftqq r d srqETrdt d oif,.fd T{fr oTffi d sqs qr-qrf,{tr ertqfu orrqrilf,{ q-qd fu-qT rrfi eTI, ffi qqm oTffi gm enetfro orTerT d ffaq t ft-rttT fuqT .rqr t. oq qgr frfuo qgq U@ w t ffiq t fu "cqr en&fro 3TrteT A f{sq qff .r$ oTfi-m BP{d *o.t X"r dv w gt qri fr"q t"? {sfr qa frffiq-d t of qm so oTR.S.fr" g€ tgsa d qrqqmrgqn f,u q{dr 3Tfuf,-{"T d q{ft oTffi gM qrfuf, 3il-Aqr d rft-q frBn qfu o\ sTrtsr of qfr ffi{ frd \ilri fr so fr{s d oiil *-r egfr orkfr-{uT d HqeT sTfi-d u-go ori tri Eo s-ff{ fuqr .rqr t, fu-g ue oqfr qffi sxr qq-fr o-Fffi d dRT{ frffi ffiq GTEfuqq d siil.f-d rqo frrt Tt oTMfu erq-il({ qtr ftrr6-r"r fuqr E\. nq v{T fiB-ii qk ffi sTrilqq o-1 ftgr6p1 fuqr d, ss frqlq sFlqrq d 3trd qi sqrTn qFfd t, tswDI fr ?IIIT sdr;IT *rn t {g EMruT t tsr qrq d oil-qfl ffiftqq 1e61 o1 Bfr'q olflfr d ftqq rr d ur+mrjqri u-q ot$
oTftd fqg.- t /zott qfu EWfr oTBtrt-ft d qqeT EE ftqq A trd E-+T \d fuoq orffi d fr-sq 3ilqfu qqra-frq q-qd qror t qtl e-qft qffi srgr fiBd qfu d fr.t-€ eTr*T crRd o-{ frqr "TIET B) a-c ftqq 1r (o) Ffi-q fiSq-fr oTrq-cr-r oTBfr'qq 1e61 A qrqqrtr5vx ss fifuf,' qfu o) Herq ql-6n qrrnf,q fr ffi{d qqfu rR Grrl-;rT E6 si Ed 6) Terrfr-f, 6Ti d frr qr6r-t srE q-qd ovi or oict-{N qEH frrql.rqr t vq qr-6n qrE d qRuTrq d 3rqrtfi-{ cqff uffi or M eiftq qrfl .rqr t t
13. qe frffio t qt fu{rfi 01.12.2017 o\ q![fi qffi HM stFT qTeifud orTtqT wRa or ti d q$4kr qE Rrfr wE t qfi fuq 3ilqT{ rN eilqMr/3Tfianptr qer i dqo Hq-fu w eiqt Em. .Fr Ercr q{[-fr 3Tffi d qqer u-*ga fuur, vS eqd oTffi t fro.n T€t fuqr, .rd fr q{dr oTffi A srgr futrR T{-6 d-q offi q of T$ d, fuq fr e-q-fr oTfuFrft d sm oTqi ftqd d w fusr .rqr t of ffi{d Eqfu fus wqq t-fi fr qtro vs-oq mq mW fuqr rfrtT, g-q1 W +irfA U-tf6 qlo-g 61 qer.flI pnfl-q,tq (ffffii fr ed sTT I sff oTrEr-{ q{ sftr qqfu w iio HM fiq frqr rtqT sTT, dstT uri vEff oTffi + figr$r oTffi gnr BFr qqftr ot Fruiq fiirfi M.o7.2oos q,t M fr ciro. ril"Tr eflt fuoT-s .ilq t sm wqfu o\ 6* z+.oa.zora t frqr ffililq of un frr frr} qftE fu'qr, "W fuTfr t fro trq o1 q$fr tg ffi t t-+l q-fr qr sotTl", aterfd orMfufi-af qei d EGr or qr{ frRra Eq t sf,rq d goT er, Tq d 3r..ft-fletr qei o) ftqq 11 (o) en+or o{ftft'qq of ffftq Gr-jqfr d fr T$ qcrcsn d ergen erqi Ef, o-r EltrT {sflfua o--{i tg qeffi aFr6R qrqlerir d qrq lrEd o-{;Ir qIEq QTr, .to16 qqM 7eifiareff ca o) ffio sqqr{ sqaer eT, fu,g oTmdTQff qa t frft fr qrqerftf, aofuo sq=TR ED'r ci-gqriq T€t fuqr, fu*rd er,Trq t q-q-fr oTffi Ertr qrR-d 3Trtvr oihq d Tor t r
14. qR qrqrq frB-f, qRfuifr w lcqrs fo-qr qrq d q-{ff orffi G-qdg{ d sm of qr rS g-+T ss ffi ffi xur e-qfi 3Tkfi{"r se-dg{ gRr Tf, qdc{ d.q.=ist tt / zoos d qTfud 3ifrq qTtvr ft-rm 14.07.200s d q-fi-ryr fr x"r qiffir 3Tffi of ifrf, frtt Tt ffi qTrufid-c d qltqq t qorqr xq d qq-fr tg ffid Tfr. ril ifer-o Tfr re t, o\ ffi fto-q tnv *ur q{d o-Et or f{{lT \q ro ftqr q'qr, vfr 6-6 d ed.fd qq-fr oTffi gRr o[q.[t6] swrfud of -d, c-q qFr ?T6 fi srr of gs erko-rur d otfuq oTrtvr \q cqff e-+rm u;{ o} erqrw frr} qd o1 $6tqdl qrw ffi fu{r q-{fr oTBor( d sqa e-qd rh1 .ri 3TMfu of {qm orffi, q} qEr ftqrfi o-r Eo rqrr t. ss qxiefr srq o-r Eda w t f{rrfrTq o{i tg Eo-ER fi TSt qmr qT rtrFcrr, d qt qrRd M * qt qrt tnr frfuo' w t E6 q-€f T{kTr I {s frsq if B-f,t-qrft qH grfl u-qo frrn r}
otC +Aq sza Mq orcfiEo 6q}i< sr$fu frfr& fut.q ft.orn. (zoog) z qftq otC d+q zs+ frqr oTftd i;x- t /zolt tffiq qErrIq=T, sTftf, ;iq{- z /zo1t qFfq \d sn-q ffsq qlqr qFfq \Ei srq qti (zooa) z \ry.$.fi. 2Bo Gilftda f6 ofiq, o.rr$ ffw E<{dTrd +{ 1rti srq fr effi{d orftq1 ei-q-dE-ft-q dr15. TE ftffiff t fu o{fi-drptr sH i E-s orBfi-{q gm ei.q. et /zoos t dR-f, Gfhq 3il-tcr foir6 14.07.200s A ft-s-€ o-li GTfi-d n*go r& fuur w qrfud qTipr oifrq d T+r t. ftrw-d ftqq t eqd oTffi d nR'd qq-ff u-+ilq qd fr ft-} ..,t frtvrr3qTx qqfl ffi q-ffirfun gf t, a-e e-qfl oTffi 6m gs 3TBfr-{ur d otfrq qTtsr d norcr fr qqo Eqfu d ffi fr-6q d furq fr rtrrfud ot G orffi eIffr oTffi d ffien t qi ot qr rS orffi fr Tdt qi$ qr so-ft r
16. orffdietr qs of qt{ t eTq-i 3Tft-m srq-c d rilEqq fr qqft'q s@dq qTrrrrq d qq-{qtn (zoos) a Vs.ff.fr. erg nqdq RiE HrFrfr tfr\,ti gLq,
.fr.fr. 1
fi.t.rd q-{qr (tggz\t \ry.fr.fr. 1s7 qririd Rr6 Yq 3rq frv-d +drd Ri6 G erq riEffi-d frrt Tt t fu{ T{ T{r cnfl }rrrc ort gv {s fi-d oI TcT t o1 qq oTftflrptr qer t ftE d oia-.fo qtw fuEo sqzrn o-r 3TtErR[ Tfr fr'qT, m[ {s orftf, ot gil{r$ d +qrq oTfi-mretr qer o} Bq{)-ffi qfrwRa MdT t ot$ aH q-€f vg+or I d ff{sd f+oq qrrqrer W srq ,
11. oTftd =fw- t / 2017
17. Brr-q qfl 01 fri t u-*gn fui Tt frfu-n si ftfud a-d gq Glft-dretr qe{ d sxr erfi-a grq{ d qrtqq t s-drn .r} dr4T \d frfuo' ft-S.rt w fr-qn o-{i A swro {fl erfuo-tur o-l M B qfr oTfi-f,tptr qei gRI nqo o1 .r{ qe effio ffi*.qq-€f tr
18. qR'uTlq sw srftareff q&T gnr u-qo effi-a F-{ff a1 wft t t edrT of \'fi sFr qrf,fr qffi oi iftd o1 qrq t
19. g'+rrl rTeT oIq-qT{Trt=TT qr( arq qgq ffi strirT gd -qtqtdq i ens frciora.os.zoze a} q'R-d fu-qr t v, €' ")-" (rTqF{sTq ffi-{3Tffi S.ern.f q.q. \rq u-ffi-sqa