Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals

SBM BANK MAURITIUS LIMITED vs SHRI ISHAR ALLOY STEELS LIMITED on 22 September 2023

L

$L q. qN-12,/2023

xrr {qfr sTfuF{ur \ffirsrgt

(e u To ud..mq qrq)

(ffi{ qffi - qrrfiq ff vq frqrs qed)

w. q. =i{t - lz/zozg

1. ys.fr.vq. d-6 fufr|s, gr-oruItls qc ffi€-6 efiF qrRsfl furT ftfu|s drqfrftl-fr) olqTte 3ilfu-s \'fl.fr.\'q.ff 1, ffi{ gdqder, rr, erffi dtgq ffid-f, sfiv. +ftcm g.s Rwi$o-cs7 gp-sq-{ enqtc' srq Ts.fr.Gr-$.d-o 306-g,E d-fufr, fr qro, et-<T Edf ordffi,qrqr €) gE-$ (\'css) 400 051 urilq5; fdrd

1. fr grr-r vdrq *d fufr|s o'Eqfi Eq-{TmttG Ritrsqr o-qfr \re lruu. 5rvtD'I ffi sTrfu-fl ros st fq 6rsfl qw.fr.d. t-s qrftq-{ qri< gE-$ 4oo 021 ffi q, {skq-f, tfuI t-{-r -dl, s{.R t€ Edt (rntl \ru-s gsnffiAq oTrfu-fl 314, qrrfteryr E-d-{ 452 oo3 a[tt eilfffu{d ftr-qeet, 6rS-J GfrF gq$ |

2. fr Etr-{d frE 3nflq s'ffq 6tka RiE cqq ffi {-r qrd-o qq{ E+t (sqfr.) t

3. sft fttq frE cilHq s'flq fr EiRd fi{E qq{, Frqr$ {-r srfu{q-r Edr (\'q.fr.)l

4. ffi XdEdq qH aft Tffilri RiE ffi q-fr o.rdrft sqlq-f,rtrf,{ .iqra (f'q.ft.) t x-

Page 1 of 24

gq. g. dTr-12l2023

s. aflqft Erfu-rc d-s cH gft q-drq fti-6 d-fl ffi Erq{FrT ote, gtr-{r qf,rfuqT {dI (qrft.) t

o. €c to dis {€}t E-*SRq-o fte dq Eid{ (vq.ft.) r

7. dc t-o mw sfuqr E-g€Rqo .DT-fi{ dis, sTffi d-+r, vq.fr. trs, sdq gq.fr)t

8. orqttqTq qo E-*dRq-d Er-ft{ dts, o-ta eFr qffit

e. rtc t-o. dq. d-{E GTn.\'4.4. qrrf, 5dt t

10. t-6 sfiu, q-SEr (Td fr tn d-6) dd rls gds gq.fr t

11. E-c{ tcmd TA-c ftd-eeTq oq-fr srfilc fufrIs ffi Grrfu-fl +oo, O.ga.gq'. Hrcrer orC qrdf, q ffi roo17 gu-c orqlte oTrfu-s g-601, g6 q-o)r, zrs gff+q o-{fuqT drs ur+r gdf tE, 3r+}fr €E) gE-$ 4oooe3,

12. s{r-$.fi.Gil-$.ftfr} eil{.fi.GTr$. ff armr e-df oldffi gq$ aoo osr ,

13. E-gdqd sfrqile +-o' mq' sfuqr, sil-$. g.fr.on$. ff or cts gq-$ 4oo oo5,

14. rg$R'q-o urftfuq-o o-rcit{rc ds, qtr€qr cqfsrfl qq"r, +d t-s, ,iqro,\'c.fr. 462 011,

15. dT$F F<qlt{ olmkn ds gtrsqr +gd Grrfu-fl +'re}fl, fi-fi fiqT n,f, gE-$ 400 020

Page 2 of 24

vL \. nsv12/2o2s

16. eTSw. E-{dt{ o-nitqc mw. gFgql +Eq GTrfu-fl ffiqT drfi fiqr qrf gE-$ 4oo o2o,

16. qfuc il< mm. gFsqr, rf< tqq, sq ft--df, qrs dro.t$ m,f q ,r{H f,rg-{ gE-{ 400 020,

17. E-gdq-d 5dr<frue t-o 3fou qtr€qr qlexq fr{ silfu-fl 2s, d.m.q-.f q ftd 110 001,

18. sr-$.m.0il-{.ftfr}s fttqi F€q Frq 14 cfr{rf, Q-ryr-d qn o-qdqo B'dqq, err$.+ er-$.<iiq-d erqr e-df oldffi gtq$ +oo osr, 1e. GrTi.m.on{ ftfr}s fuilqi F€q Er{ 15 yftcro t-ryr-g nrl o-qd{f, fuilqi, sr{.* err$.++C qrqr E-df tnTu+ffi, gq$ aoo osr. ...omril{f,rrq I srffq-o-rrq ht oiR t fr {rGq n-fi-{f,l srBq-ffir sqfui-o t Gr{ril{o@qi6zdfu frsfr{r slrr'.IIEI elkq-ffir t srrTils-o o-qitF rr sd ro d fuq fr oTN \rq.{EI sTBs-ffir I sr{ril{f, s-,qr{. e d ft\ qRts eTR{ffiI chTr n-fi sTfu{ffir sft fr.Yio-fi qrq{ d qrpr sqRerf, t ei-ar srfiE-orruT drtrff cc-4-f, ci-gqRerf, t x

Page 3 of 24

Vq. \. iEt-12,/2o2s 3II t VT (f{-{io. 22.os.2ois d dftsy

1. vq-q seT o-i srrn{o cer a1 eir t u-Ea frri.r$ frhq gfiQrfqrT oil-ffi q{ ETr r-flI

2. efi--Sqrqx t #r ftI].-qf, c-6-ror dq. 12/2oos Vq dq. B/2..0 s-q-dt-m-flpf G[rgd oy Sq frfrET oTdEH) d qreT sd.{ fu-ql.rflt

3. s-flril or erq-oloc fu-qr .rqr t

4. 3[ilq-o ceT ERr ftiro o+.oz.zozz oi qa g-{eTrq-fl Gil-+{q ss sThfii"T gm qtRil sTrtcT frrra' 25.67.200s o) ornkr or {il uffet oL*. 13/2002 an X"r sls w E-{sr$ fu g-flarffud frrt qri d Gr-Stq d vnpl rqo ft-+r .rqr t I {ekr: F[d" Zfr-{eT W B{rtfi 13 / 2oo2 ol Tc, rer.fud frri qd of warcor qr& 'r{ pfi, fu-g ngo frd rrt €yilr{r eil-a-fi ftiro re.os.ozg d *W" *+" ftcio' rs.og.zoze d c-mTcr t g-{Rriq-rT uiltEq qy ftrn.rS {iyiq-{ d qtsq d W eniqq rc7zooe d 5{-{arffrd m qd of sarqor q?ilhf, oq fr.S ,rg t, w*T fr gs d?a o-r rft q"1o fuqr .rqr t ot slrts-o d-6 d dM 96' crq td 3il'iEq p/zoo3 yfuqffi q-qio r of ftfi?-i o-qfi i$d ff tcTn gq) qm= d fus-€ u-qo fu-+r rqr Qr, rq #t W sTrle{ F-dyr d epne fr entvl pr* zs.oz.zoos d ffrr ft-{ffi or frqr rrqr gx Xo urtu dq. q. 12/2003 t crRd fuqr rqT t \.s efrg.o.qio tt/zooz q M of G of ei.g. tz,/zooze t cIRf, or-tcl {q e-m'{ur d ftq rff c6r qrq t oil.g. 1s/2003 t sfr T$ Eqoft t sqfuf, mfuw ont{T

Page 4 of 24

gc. \. iq<az/zozs a1 cqrFrd cfr (vt@r \/2) d w t rqo o1 q-$ Br5. Torur oT fielc Sfl norq q-Krfud t ot de t-o ofiw dfficm d am zo,ts,ot,zzs/-(frs 6t-s s+fl dr€I gfi Eqr{ HkI {t s-fis) roc}, eplfa +t,oz,gzz,za tfr ({o-d-rd=fl dl-EI ENrd aqrq d m qr$s r-cS +trn tfr) *ss.S. Tq qru frt T{dl ig {s GTfuf,rut d sqer q-{-rur {d 3rltfi eqd fu'qr rqr, ftil-stt 3Ti{q-6 do' d {o eilnfr + cffi oqio a Yq s o-r tq{ FDRrq d ntqq fr €qH q-filR[f, o-{-t oT ,tto nrf* zs.to.zooa ol qrR-d fu'qr rqr afl, frtd slril@ t-6 d a-o-rfi{ crkqd srffi d gnr fi-o d 3rfu{ffir gsr ertot eR kt .rt ft{Yr d er+q< qffi o.qio a G s or r{+is srlzll-t qr\ i e-orRTf, o-srt or q-q[s r€l fuqr q-qr c fr sil-ileo f+. d Sc<roq o\ gs fqvq tf qErd fo-q rrw t

6. o.l1 qft-ow t of rl-q notq fis d vra g'ro( tg iq=tT-o 2s.o7.2oos o\ rgo $il, oq sil-A-q-o. d-o d G{R{ffir ERr t-f, of a-qw t oti fttvr c dri or oerc fid d sqm ftrqrrqt, fus oTrrr-{ ct Tf, 3rtifi ftrw o-t fuqT qqT, qqfu 3[q fut gs ffiq €*QTrcii grr qffirur d fr-{-€ e-qd na sTlilfi oltrfi-{ur gnr ffisri frr} t t

7. oni-q-6 seT o-r ul1 ffiow t fu qq d-o mw. q.dEr d anr otg.ro /2004 t frqrq{ orffi of q+tr d ctr( fr-os B-{dsqT e-oIRTfl o-{fi T$, n-q sIfiffi t-6 o\ M fr f,sR gf,rq ' 6f, fufris t sdFd vrqd o.r 5l=I Ecn I ai.f,c{-qrd oTIil{r t.-6 d gM e-qd ftd 'r} W sid-fi d frrq t qrl-orfr ger$ q$ \s d-r mF

Page 5 of 24

gc. \. iq742/2o23 {SEr fl-n e-qf, fu-n Tn frqrq{ s-fi-rur fr gncfril u-qd o.ri tg qTfu-qf, 3lffi a1 pqho of 'r$ t

8. ,,1 ffiow t of ct{rc t frg-fi fu.t Ti sTB-q-d qffi d grqr sTla-{o. t-o at 6qw d u-qo ftd .rn W sTrnqc d s-f,{ur oT Ftsq o-{i ct q-E flo EGTI ot ft{Yr d ertns t ftir6 25'07' zoos o\ s-fi-rur ft{R ot ftqr trqt B I ilEc{srfl frqr{ wwr rc / zoz+ iT enqfu u-go ovi d etu Td GTBaffir oi Xa olrilfi d 5r-{afqqT tg orffi o-Ei or frtcr fuqr rqr t e. sil-a-{f, sqT o-r 5cq eilqn B of W sTfffi of ts tq vs cfrfrtrd fu F5ff cTBqd sTffi d am gc"qrd-q ol slffo-{q d 3TI-t$ ft-4r6 2s.10.2004 or sIeFI r-€l frtn qri d frs-q fi dr$ qTToiff T€t fr,.r$ gs w-qlf,-q-ff qlkqa 3TFrf,rft d Xo sTrilfi of qRfufui tnr slq c-€f en, qfu t-o. strw, c*o eM u-orRro A-o-q s-{q\sry A cc-qrd ger$ T$ qn-orft d qrtqq t aa 3nnfi srFqlq-{ d errnq tt ft-{tr d qfi or 5l"T ESII, q-Efu sTiilq-o do dI qffi qen t o-rfr {S {rRT {qf,{r t'r W orqq qrqFo ti ao ern<-t ts/zoos a gr{-tiqq fu-ql qrcr sFdd t, srer fr erft-oerc t at q-{ildl ao d oxu Ta 3liilfi erFrdrfuo q€t fuqT qI sor vo 3TBtr-i"r d slrtcr ft{16 2s'to'zoo+ 6-r srEt"r T€t fuqr qT wD1, d rp qfl *'q t t

10. 5-flertcqr e?rwr urgfl o-rt fr gs l+o< of flrrr frrn qri tg Yero' t ffiq sTIn({ 464/2023 u-qo frr+r'rqr tl trq( fttn ..ri sTr+<-{ ti aa enileq t qFfd e'rdi or 6 qft-aa-+ ori gv gr,wn-+r sTlilf,{ u-qo ori ti gq fuflq o\ mqt / frri qrt or ergtu ftqr rqr t

Page 6 of 24

\q. g. d{t-12,/2023

11. sTnrf{fi @-qi6 P E-c{ tcl-Tf, g$e W€rc tFqfr qdie frfr-s qrd-d r$ ft-d d em 3ril<o qer of *r t u-qo frd Ti fuf,q flqI eTlifi tnl 'lcllq s-rEd fu-qr .rqr B r u-qo frd .ri qfl-s d qrtqq t ortqfril dr .d t of GTids-o t'o go tfu;rr €{QrT t, fu{-d g[q 2o.1e,ol,72s/- (fi-s o-trcr E+fl EIrEI $r EsTR qr<l q\ B-fis) sqt slqln{o qqio r o-qfr d xq ti o1 erd o-e T{ B, a-e tfu-.r €{eTr a\ fft fr erfuo swr {f,qr w G sq.ror Wo qt{-fr nosq o\ qMfut o-Ecr ar, qrer fr sTfuo-rq d sr-N[ o-l qEFI tDl"TT er, fuS olfu{ffir srcr ftt Tt ft{sr d ero-g< sTrnf,f, *6 d gr*r erD-oqur d ft{cr or qroc r€t ftqr rrqr ar, dt 3Tl-nc-o +-o o1 dl[{qrfr o\ Edf,l Br12. qrer ft cfuqrE fuqr t of qq ffi ZE d onq ot$ noqq ftrw or ftqI qrf,r t aq qFrq rs t sTri trdf of E{flr ig clGFl?T grrerfc{ of orffi of sr-qr+m-dr *ft t t qs q-fi-{"r d qril{f, +-o + 3Tfu{ffir i eTfuf,-rq d do of e-<w t at$ fttgr crw c *{r oem fu-qrrqr t t Es Elt,t sTko-ruT s-orur ft{K o-{i fg id-qsl en, GrQrfd ro-rur fi-{w *i o-t El=I slrilq-{ d-o ol cR"{ t er Ts nos F-sw E\i ftcio fr fr qqq Sql vrs"r d T+t eft, fu-g rz q{ ccqrd c-qf, fu-qr rrql g-+*efc-iT sfl-a-r{ frffi !fi EffiI t c d E-flTfr t qfrffioY.qtr

13. 3i-fl-n{o qqtr. e d ar*r gsd srQr fr cfufl-( ftqr rrqr t of sFdk{ d f+oq or ot$ wffowr rfr t I sm-i<n qer d aRI q-qrq d srq qFrfiq wktq atrrlTerq att Td

Page 7 of 24

gc. \. ns7-12,/2o23 HrfrqT frs-{ f-€0 fftfi zozr Rs.fr.fr. #{ drgc itffc siH 1260 ftufu fuio to.tz.2o21 d riEtrd ori gv u-qo ft-o< ercr Grilfi ft{w frt} qfi or sr-g-tq fu-qr rrqr t t

14. Gi-dr fi{ril{m.g at fri t ot$ frfuf, wers rEf, T€l fu-fl .rqr t I rrd tg erqrteo oqto 2, 11, 16 d sTB{ffir sqRem Eg B, fuE erfi<o ca fr1 Giri t u-qo fu-qr rrqr g-{ertl-lT vq fuf,q ercr sTiil({ or l+tET qd T€f o-srqr rrqr t t

15. srFr sq{ oi E-i-i d qrqro gf, ct-7 ffi R-S q6 t sfr "Eqr ert{o ilo gm e-Ed {m sTrilfi Gi.q. 1312002 gol dtq qt Ei qri t-g go' renfud frti qd +q t" I

16. slrga Tf, q-s-rq dq. 'tz/zoos qs et}q. 1s / 2003 of p sniql cfu+-retJ 61 s-ffiaq ot srqr atrflr t A n-+o 03.02.2005 6 qt_qrd IF{ GrT'{cH iz/zooe fr fr-E( entql qk6T T€i frrd .T{ t, qfu el.y. tz/zoos t ftrd q-$ 3r-tcT qndfiT ti

o) d qri 01 ftrquft ot T$ t si fun sifrq sil-tsr ftEi6 2s.o7.2oos d q-filyr tt et.q. p/2oos Frtr fu-qr rrrr q6 frRFi srTecr et.g. rz,/zoos tf crfud fuqr wr t gq {S errtsr a qd qfi at ftqufr ei.q. rslzoos e1 GTrAcr qBot frcio zs.oz. zoos tt qd t t

17. sl.\.tz/zoo3 A oTMt t qrqr qrot t' 01 €c fu mE +ftYrfl d sm eitq. e/zoo3 M * gffi vfr *f, fufr|s o-qft \d oral 14 d fr-d-€ srqr {rRr fi,63,s1,363/-G-{6 o-rre iso arq E-+qrqt rox ftc q) f-s-d) sqi of q{fr tg friro zo.rz.zooz oi oTfufi-iq d sqa nqo fuqr ,rqr, ftrsfi frTd G siltrT qko. kqio' zs.to.zooa

Page 8 of 24

\rIL g. i{t-12,/2023 d ergsn Bs e-{-{q d qffi qqto q q s o1 f,rffi tw q-{-rcrq t o{d qri t 1]kiD-d tTi ot ufr u-qo ovi or *rio n-oi-" 08.07.2004 a\ aliftq sffisr d qpr frfl r-ql ett, fu-g nonn a1 cfr u-go r€t di w s-f,r"r ftd d sqq Eqsr$ tg ft{d frqr .rqr t ffo ERr gi: entcr fl qro-q tn-{i tg Gil-trT qFdol fuirf, 03.02.2005, 31.07.2005, 2e.04. 2oos, 18.05.200s o\ q-{-{q k{if, 05.07.2005 d fuq ft+o gen, a-o GTfi{o d-f, of 3iR t oTE{ffir fr qdI"T "-gfrfr t BqRaft qd qnqro< 3Tril<+ t-o. t fttvr qt< o-{i tg qafl-{ fuqrrqr G s-m'{q ot sTFJq E.r-sr$ ft{;q za.oz.zoos d ft\ ft=s-d of 'r$ t qqfr rfi-{ur ft{1o zs.oz.zoos o\ Eil{-{ ri fuqr rrrrr, Tq sr-a-<-6 +-f, +1 3fu i\ 3lfu{ffil fr rrdcr t0-{f,r of scRa{h d o1 T{, ftn-d ar*r sTfu+{ur d sqa sr-nEo. fu q,t eir t d{ ftftT clqt =I il{r oTFo-sq dl qfr-d fo-q rrqr t

18. oTBfi-rq d am qa ftqoft af T{ t e1 sTrds-6 tt-6 dr sTrtcr ft-{i-r 2sl0.2004 + erratrrgqT( cffi ca oi tw cffiqn d qtqq t qtrcl va nfud o-G qrT fttcr ftqrrqr sTI, fuS 3rd-<-o, f+' ilT o-fua entcr oT qldq ci-Ht erqfl{ frq qfi A qr+W T€t frtqr .rqr r gsd srq fr ft,wut of T{ t fu cem d or-il{o to gxr oTfuo.rq d gr-t$ fuim 2s.io.2oo4 o-t rITFt=I o61 fu-+r rl-il, rsleI fr sTidq-6 fu A oTB{ffir dr 3Trn<-r do of aqr t dld ft{€I T€t frfl 'rqr B gs ftqfr d srq 3fr.q.@-qi6 tz/zooz e\ ft{ff fu-qr rrqr Ts vfr entqr d q-firqr t ei.q. fi/2003 fi fu{K srr$Ir rlufl I 1e. .,1q qkf,r frirm 25.o7.zoos t we t qfi sqvq or frrro-<q Xu dv w c-€t geTI t, qfu

Page 9 of 24

gq. g. {Tr-12,/2023 eE vfusrfudt of tw qkdcm d qrtqq t rfriq of flrffi o-{rn qfi or qricr ftqr rqr er, fusol crr{ T€t fo-qr rrfl Qrr, $ft ao d qr*q etfi-tul ftTw fuqr rrqt t, \i-{fu qffi q.qfr. 1,2, 3 G 6 of scRTfr ft-i-il{ oTB{ffir fr E-fryr erq-qrd d qrtqq t el.\. tz/zoos fr qd +ft {fr t, gu fuoio. 2s.o7.2oos o] fi cffi s.qw t, z, e gs o at scfuft qd * t

20. qfu srTilq-o to am rs gffefq-fl orilfi d qrurq t Ta uliqq B/2003 *1 gc' raTrfuf, frti qri or or-g-irr fu-qr .rqr t r grr oxu na sTrilEc is/2003 o1 cR{eTMf o-r vds fu'qr uil=Il enqq{o tt er-gd tf, q-firor dlq. B/2003 d srft-fl{ t wE t fo s-w q-6-{ur de tf, efr.w. +ftvm d grrr gc< uffi offi 4 ggIR Vf,rq *f, fufr|s uFo ga zo. qffiq-ur d frs-q u-qa frur .rqr, fusd cffi 6r;r . 2 g{r-tt-d frr-6, oqio s ffi-< ftr-6, Eqr6 4 ffi Td Ecf-{ Ri6, oqi3; o 8ffi Eftfrxq dw, gw cffi t Vs st-q qffi q'qr+, t drrrtrfl zo or r4gw 65 frw d ses to tr

21. eitg. rglzoog et sil-tyr qBrfi-r fuir6 og. 1o.2oo3 d sr-q-dfiq t qrqr qror t of vffi qqlo t, 2, 4, s, o or sfrfrfuc gqrfr ffoqld oft srF+m gnr fu-qr .rqr t t cffi oqizn te ot cfrfrfuf, eTtr{ffir aft qsm fuH @qiq' 18 oT qftfrfuf, fr g.gfl rrd[d d em fu-qr rqr t t erq or ot$ cftftfun d T€l EoTI, fr.5 ffi sro gM ifud {q+ qa so fr{ of ot-qB {ft d frc qr GrBfi-rq o) qrcfl cMf, T€l Eli at fttquft d srpr cfusrfr qqrq t, B, 9, 10, 1L 12, 14, 1s, ro, rs qti LL vq. g. d*-12l2023 20 at drfifr of sqqnqr of rn Tsf B, erqto g{r Xo urte< B/zoos fr ro qn cffi ocio s a1 fl-ffi ts 16 r$ tl, ftrfl+1 f,rffi A frw q fr'q orffi tn-st or ftt{r oTlil{o do. e} ftqr ?Tql I etq. rglzoo. 6 31fuow d ergsx sffi oqio r aft gcnr varq 6f, fufris o-qft ilT ftd trn uq o1 aHFId erq qffi qqtr. z t o d arr M{d o1 r-$ efr, sTql( s-o-{or t ot-gqRuo cfuqrfi @-fl-o 3 61q Rie cqq o-$ qqn-d-<Tt i t gfi ul+lliClql( eIIl sQTTf,: frfuo crqqrii or erqefoq fu-qr

22. qrq d ew.S.fi.\'{d rggg o1 tTt{I 22 (2) (fr) q scfuTfr d qqs fr roqq ftrw frri qrt t qftifuf, oTrtcr a\ 3TttrkI frtt qfi o1 arq-{aill H-qqrF-d o1 .r{ t, fu-g S.sw.fi. (ffiw) ves rsse d trf, ftqq 5 v d ur+n<rgnn g-{ffiroc Grilfi r-Eo ovi tg cfuqr qd flTq *fl vrqETlfua t, fr-{ frnft ZE d orqq ft-{w frt$ rr} q-fi'rur d g-flertcfl fu qfuqT GIQrqr srq 6qr oFio l-fr t, e 6r qq6r{ cfu-qr €trd G q-qtil 3Tfuft{q d yTq'eTHt d e-6-Ifl t s-u gwvfv-+ 3nd-fi qr fusn o-rcr sfud *q-r t

23. sr-tcT s ftqq z fr.ft.fr. d <fafo tt{q e1 fl-ffi fu oo qdri ri srwnd vri qq qrE c-I F-{ff frrt qri or qr-qEr=I sFtd B \ki sr-tgr e fr{q + S.ff.fi. d tr( {s f{6 t ft{tr frt} ..r} nos of frrafc-fl .nI qtqEIFI t, srq ft qrfr 01 d-s qe u-Eo ovi or rfr e-o e<Iq frtqrrqr t t

24. er-etr g ftqq 5 fr.fr.fr. d er-5sx o-$ cffi d q-f,{ur t qq qE qffif or qq-s

Page 10 of 24

t2 $L \. d{r-rz,/zozs ci-fiI drftd d qror t gs srfr vq sffit oi Tc' ririq ori t-E srrilfi rqo ovi d qgsd rror t, (q qrqrdq ot qa qfuo-R frqr .rqr B fu tfr cffi d fr-sq s-m-{or grRq o-t frqr qd re tS cffi d fr$-q fi srfr a dwW u-qn E{i at erffif,r rErq of .r$ t t 2s. ff qo{"if or erq-froq a-{ srqT qror t fu Xa eTrilqc e.qTo e/2oos ti gc< cffi o'qio 1, z, 3 gq o d frq 3Tftsffir * sftcl srq-qTcr scRrf, E\ {B ai gs 3i.q. B / 2oos d gw cffi E,,I.;w 1, z tiq + t o d fug .Tffis-ffir eqTfr fi-dqTd oti a1 scfufr d d g-o1 * vq qq ft{1q zs.oz. zoos oi al.\. tz/zoo3 ss q-o-ror d qffi o-qif, 4 vs 5 d {idq sfr ilffi d 3il-+cr or qroq c-fr Eti d GilEil-r q-{ FrK fufl rr-{rr, ils ..fr vs ys'rur d erq gq cffi o'qio r, z, s \is o d lag oTk{ffir fr sfril 3rqtil-d et BcReft d sff T{ B G eil.q.rs,/zoos t ftqm 25.07.2005 oT ft-qf, gtrtvr qkfiT T€l fti-6 rr{ t, aq siltqT Rirfi oe.1o. zooe \d ilEcsrqrfl of ft-{ili or-tcr chf,r ftiro rr. o3.2oo4 d rmTqr d rra ergqm fo-qr qr s-6-f,r t at {s }rD{q d 5w cffi qqro t, 2, 4, s gs o d ffiq Efl-fr fi-dqrd otr or cfrftD-f, h;ar qcr esTr eIT, ril-, cffi oqio g frfE RiE qqq of scR'eft d frqq tt sil-il{o {-o a) GTr-q{qo oTffi q-rcr er, fuflor q-f,{ T€l it H-oT ar, fufl tg sTril{o t-6 o-} yfl eo{q fr srtvr ft{;o' rs.oz.zooq d ergrn oiftr qq{R fuqr rqr er I cld q ?rl lcl fi-d d gnr fi orfrfttr srq fufl r-qr er, fu-S cfrsrfr oqio g ot ilrffi TS E\ s+t efr, Grqfd qq dg. rslzooa ftiro zs.oz.zoos oi fi-o dpa qrd t-g ftq-n , \ ' \ .

Page 11 of 24

$I. g. d{t-12,/2023 erT, dq e-ff-{ur d qffi oqio g of ergqRetft oT src gs sTl'ffo d-o am sfl qffi or r{dlr orfia o-rt qri d frsq fr frfu6 sqqn c-fi frtn qd d qR'ur1q t5I gsq ffiq eTr, Glatff, gs u-o-tof d cffi qqrq t gs s qtt sqRpft or ot$ fu{rq c-S arT I {fl de{ qfi SE Efl ql-f, t .fr +fr t a1 qffi oqto r, 2, 4 \is o of *q t q-{ sidRq eTrilfi eil-{.q.=i. S-r ft-qio 1o.oe.2oo3 of u-qa fu-qr rrqr eTr, w u-{sd fu oka w t

26. sril<-o wT gM gwefv-+ urn<l rtgo zn-{i t gV fuo< q-r ol-rur ao urile< G fudq erqr 3Trilfi tt tqr16 fo-qr rrqr t, fu{ w ErcT ti gv qr+ftq Bailq Rlr{nrrq ENI #cn-d gwdrC f+t-a w.va. srafuqr G o.qfr ftfits d.O. zooz drt 'nz qq.d.rrTrE fr.ersqq-q r)e \ry.fr.fr. ,76, qu fr qtrfiq rfqrrd ErffrC ff{r +f,r \'{ Erqsl fusa qfrfi dF strsfl d crfu sTrtcr fuiro zs sTfd zoos qmfiq vq-{eIFT errotC gRr d{rd ortrd Re) =iqq sat/2..s Brdro, qE +fr frqq qrq t q]fu sil-tcr ftt'ro. zt ,rl zooe o1 ffiir o-G gq trd rsr.rqr t' q,t 3rril{f, t-6 q,t o-rht {S {rFr Ets w t vq sTrn{o fu ot et$ {6 Tfr t, eftqt frg-fi qrfu-q( 3Tffi d am of T$ ZE d o-r<q eniem d-o o\ eTfr T€f cffi qrBg r ffi unrx w fuoq effir frt$ qri or 3t-{tET fu-qr rrqr t t

27. smfi{f, o-qi6 rz d ars fusq erqt qrtfi or ffiiq ord gv silcfu dl T$ t of rz q{ d fuf,q or or$ onq c-€t t, n-q fuf,q efiT frrqr qril frB sq-a c-€l dqr, srpr fr c-d rqt L4 gq. q. qN-12,/2023 rrqr t at GTIi<-6 d-o g< erqrqra so B r trd d sqeh t qffftq wkH anqrrq fl17 stts' tutu& ft-s-€ \+c eTrstRr{rf, ftr+qlcx du qdFfq wnt dCtoffi fus-{ fufrd sTftd d{t 16e63 zorz fr crR-d oTI-tcI frqi6 24 qf,{ft 2otz, N qrd{ fo. ffs-d \rII. w.d.fr. ftTfre fuftn oTtrd 501/ zozo d qfu sTrt{r ffiio, zr qq+fi zozo, ftn .r.derqrd m fu{-€ fifri.r o-i-A mF ccr{ ffi Oots) 'tz qfiq drC d-Sq 64s ffi vrqqT fuq w ffffi 1,ti 3P<1 2oo1 \rfl.fr.fr. 1260, olErq swr f+w qt{H ris erq 2023 Vfl.fr.fr. sfiq dr{c qftc otd sz, erstrrq \iq 3l-q f{f,€ S{rd aus Vq$qq sTrstst (zotg) r+ Tfl.fr.fr.gt g. etx.6. cerq EfeTtoi fftr $r.q. 104 z.rz,w.fr.sTd. ftra rlfE-{rfl 6d ftfr|s t crRf, sTrtsr ftcio st. 03.2018 a\ ffi( ort gq Grffq-o cH il{r tr$f, g-fiarlwT sTIilfi gs fudq erqr sldEq F-iR frti qri or qeil {sI ,rqr t t

28. srrq qH of 3i{ t rqd frtt T} 'qqgEroi ti qRrqrfud Rr€Tdt o-I sTret nd-o eqw fuqr rrrn I cf,s ss sltro-rq o\ qa ts-{r B fu "cqt Efl IFFwI of qRRiffii A e-mrcr i fuflq erqr sTrnfi ffio.ri or gwvtvn 3Tffq-{ ffio.r{ frt} qd dr.q t" t 2s. eaFKr: T6 B-dsfrq t fu w erli6q 31r. \.13/2003 d gqlTd qffi{T d anr 3il-n{6 f6 rht *r t u-qf, frti .ri gs g-irafq{r gTlilfi o-r qqTq trqd o{ slQrqr dfuo ild d qrtqq t .rqr t, ftd Grqln<-o o-qi6 qfrsrc/futtq r€t fu-qr g{icrrf, offiq

Page 12 of 24

$I. g. iirt-12,/2023 12 d gs q-wq t crRd 3ni{r frir6' 30.06.2023 d qrtqq t Tfl qffi qd.m.sTr$.m3Tr$. t-o' d tern qr sdfuo fo-qr rrqr t, d axr 3r-a-{f, qa o1 fr< t u-qo frt$ Tn 5-irertqqT 3Tfifi qd fuf,q ercl Gn'ffc o-r futq fr,-qr .rq B t

30. srfl-i{f, o-qio P ed.q.3r-r.fr flfiz frfr-s d mq oT gq eTrEIn q-6 t fu W cffi sTr$.m.0il-$.frGTrg. d-fi fuft's Euft o-qfr fr dflI er-orq €f, frft's Et sfuF Ar{n tro eil, ffi H[n o-qfi d u"r dl 3i-flrf,So-c Se ta.oz.zooo d qrtqq t N qrCr t-o of st-sd-{ fu-qr rrtlr w 'f,,..ffi-qo qsT{+"z Vftto-c fuil-6 15.11.2011 d q-mr{r fr qr& tf, t qfqrc 3r-fl-n{6 qiw e en$.ent.fr. qdtc fufr's d qq +t ao cffi o-qft srTrr e[f,[q 6f, dfr]s or e}c \r6l\I'-e sTfl-f,{ ot frqrrqr, ftrsd sIIqR q-{ erc frffio qqrq p ftrfltg dBfl a1 tk{f, rscn t t

31. qdqn sdms-o s-,cirq- P eff$.q.3rRfr. cdAe fufuts d sm 3rrilq-r +o' at cilr t u-qd frtt Tt g{rarc-{T qrilqq or fut)q qrtt 5 qqffl 3rfrftffi d tr( u-qo ftrn .ri t+oq sqr errilfi tDT E-ql-q rqd oG Es fu-qr .rqr t t

32. gs effiffq-f, of fri t qmfiq @filq d q-q EEid d riqffid o-sd Sq dl .illqlclq sTrqfril A .r$ t ssd 3tr( fufuf, glfi-d 1 6s62 / 2017 err{.q.0ffi.fr.ft-t-€ 3Tlstfu{d ftrq}fr 6 gulq o1 oFw.r z, 9, 11, 12 r+ of €EFta fu-qr rqr, q\ trrr 30 (1) erx.S.fr. vEe tgeg d strd qqfr sTPmrft sM qrRd om 6 ft-tu u-go of T$ oTfi-d t irn;itrd B, fr;.S 3Tidq-6 d-6 -< / \ ----

Page 13 of 24

\nI. y. i+<-tz,/zozg iltr Irqd qE srltdl-q w elBm-{w ar*r eniro d-o d aa oil-nqc o\ eilg.rzlzoog d eftrorfr o-qio + G s or r+qq e-rrRrf, TS o.-*r} qrt et ZE + sTrETr-{ ct ft{K frti qfi d fuo-c rqo fo-qr rql tr

33. vorqrfr qqt+. p d anr trE( cnq qTqtoclcl ft{i{f, slfi-f, sot / zozo N qr& t-o f+r-q gq.gs.A. fr. fufuis ot o.Fsor 2, 5, 6,7, 12 1's ro oi ffid fuur .rqr t t qr+ftq sqoq .t{lqt('l<.1 or qe Esfa sTkf,ruT d sqffi rtrr ftti Tt oTr'ffi + sqfkf, t fusfr ftqq 5 q

0. ern.6. (dr$-f,{) vffi 1ee3 n frtrd sq-q erqE so fu{s o-i frKrRn rfi frtn qfi at qrsr ot G t, sTQri-d sc-trfi qIrgETa fufl qqfr rti qRfuffit d rorq w vffifa EYi t s{I IrFwI ti 3l-q-ffirftq c-€t B t s4. uf,t-qrfr qqTr. e qfr fri tt rrgo qzrEqiil Qo13 rz uffq atJ +-Q-q o+g of o-trsrr 8, e, 10, rz, zr G 22 qI {<fld o-t enqfu d 'r$ t ot GTriq-{ t-6 of 3irr t u-qo frd 'r$ Xa 3Tr+fi siQrqr fuf,q enqr Gil-ilfi tt w{qr+fl tnl 3lril-q t, epl 6 wt< tnrq rfr TS <{ttqr trqr t, 2oi1 gs.fr.fr. ofrq dr{-{ qfiq otd tzos d o-trsf,r 1, 4, 15, 17, rg gq zo d qtqq t 3lrcftil m 'T{ B fu 3rififi to am rz s{ d ft6q or ofi Hgfud onq c-€l ikrrrir rl-qr t r gs orq'r rEd sil-nfi ffi +'q c-S[ t, zozs \'{.fr.fr. d-{ or-{-{ qfiq otC gz ot oF-srl 3, 5, 123, rs \ti t+ d qrtqq t 3Trqfu fr .T-$ t A sil-ilq-o to ARr fuflq eTrlr frot Eri t-g ikrrrrr q-ql orsq qqiq r€t t t (zors) r+ qffc (/ o'rC

L7 yq. y. d{t-rz,/zozs dfrq 81 srq}grq \q srq f{s-d SvrdT e-s rqfrsn sTrfrw of oPgoT 11. 12. r+. rs o) rffi( oG gq silcfu dr T$ t qrt sr-il{fr to sm fuflq t 5-{terlu-rT Grr]fi rrgo ori ot o'r$ qqito srerqr Hgfud ?Dl-{q }Fre r€l fuqt rrqr t, efu Gr-a-q-{ gfl .nr Gnznut FlFritxr6 r-6r B, sgrr+{r oT erqrq B t vS entm qr c-qd GIrilfi ft{K frtn qfi oi ergtq fu-qr .rqr B t 3s. or-{ril{6 o-qio e d gRI 0.sTIt6. rifird ENr gq.g.1o4 /zo'n d cIfud e[rtcr fuiro. sr. o3.2ole d qrtqq t oTrqfu ift T$ B o1 aq vqfr oTD-o-r"r o) qm s rqtfl GTEftqq + vrstr-r\ d oif,.f-d fuflq erqr o-{i or erBox rSI t t

36. qai n-o sr-{in<o e'c[T. P +t GT}t t q} qa enqk m .r$ t fu zq eq.dl 3Tkf,-i"T ol qnr s qrqlcr erDF-qq d e-{T{r ti fuf,q sqr fui qri ol eTfuo[r l-& t, gs e-d t qa eTfum-rq wrqo =rfr t, o-nq at 3rD6{q d qqer fufl vqfr oT oTrdfi dfud d, sS d s-m-rcr t qm 5 fl-qffl eiEft-qq ot crfrGmn M qrft B, qa sTrnfi ETt{t 22 em.0.fr.v{e rsgs S ersETnI d sin-.[( rqa foqr .rqr J, fu-n tg enr.S.ff.vre d ff( ot$ frts sqq frfl qrqtTrF-d r€t t't q-qfu srgd-( pz qqlEI srBftqq rgog d sEqrfl-Tsri tsr qrq d fiqq e-6rRrd a-{-i tg sTrifrra qir qqr o-{i q S$ T6 d eTrErR w ftrw frrn TS y-oqq d g-+tertwr tg sTtil{q rqo ori sFkT 30 k{fl 01 vq-q fifl qFff, tr

37. u-a genfuo Afu t qfr olrt<c \,ti oTfi-d u-Eo ort tg frE d Gtrn frFo qrq €qT dt (

Page 14 of 24

w. q. {{r-12,/2023 ffi-d frti qrt d g+ t qm s rqtfl gTEfuqq d srqETF cr+rq d-fr B t qqfr qrq q-I d srq d u-osq fr wrq frqr ffifl frrn qd tg *TRr s qqfEr oTEfrqq d qrqqn dr[ Tfr a]i r gsd ss fr qrqr z+ eTn.S.fr. g{e 1es3 tt qE qrqETrF-f, t'o1 +fl dI q-6f,r t qqkT oTDftqq teoe d ql?lEn=I ertro-rur d qqer u-qo frrn qri srd oridfi tl umq dH r qq-d HTqI fr qm 2s (z) Tqtfl srBfuqq rsos d s-oRI fr tqr qrq o\ em.S.ft.g€ regs t s-fi'{ur of g-{-{qiq-iT GIfffi s-qd o.{i tE sqq ffqr crsETrfud l-€t t, aq rqiqr ogF-{q d srqqFr sTroffid dtt qs qrqr + t z+ d srqtrn qftfu Tfr Ett, arQtfd oTroffid Elt,

38. erc qgr a-o enqBo fu6q or cfi t, {s fl<d q qnfrq BEKTTI amflEt-q Eirn Ecr iqr+f, \qT qH frs-d qq.[a.vraftm qu-g o-qfr ftfr& { dlftT trq fu{io, 28 uri{fr zooz d oFwT s i ft Ti qq-wt d ergvx e-owr t 3iilr frFd dfuq ol eqn t {sd Eg qernR oi g"r s}s w gr+r$ ot erqs{ ti t EtnR T€t frtqr srqr qGq t (zoot) o gs.fr.fr. tzo qq.d. u-sl-( frs-d fr. orss.rc d tfr q-q-d t, fusi qq-on d fu Fg-fi 3lk{ffir d y-o d qd d q;pqq qffirrt o\ ftqr{ o-ffi d Td ot$ q+tr r€t ffi ss ssa fu+s d ftnq t sr-nfi tr€d EG[r, qr+ftq sqtrq qrqroq o-r eTftTf, B e1 ftdq erqr sr-ifi w fuqx .q lq l(4q dr vs s-m'{q fr sr-dffitrd qqfu d drfuq o1 qn fr vsfl "TEq vs Hrqq qEI <lq d cel t Ti-d{r qrBq Ts {fl Frdq ot o.trsor e q ft:qufr of G t q1 qstq zh'Rq q{ fuqn 6-{d g*ril seq qrs oNqrql qrfl zlrBq \ri qffi wfioqq of ffior

Page 15 of 24

gq. Y. i{r-12l2023 Trf,[tt +fr t, i{f,q fu-d-{r o-q sTerfl oTRo t, sTtr6 E.{irrf, T€f drdl HreT fr ftrquft of ,r{ t ot qE sqlTr-ffir tF.r srrqFr sTeFxr qFl{rm-r fuf,q frrt qri ry dert q dt, oq Hlqrq Fq t fuf,q *'qr fu-ql qFn sTEq I tS fr frquft oFs+'r ro fr of ,r$ t t qr+fiq rrcmrT EffiC d em d-ar .il-{ g.s Er{sr TFD d s-d-rq if q)fud ftufu ftdro za.o+.2002 sfi o.Fso.r + fr ftqoft et T$ B of sr.fl-qfl: fuS fi seFD'N @t ftflq t s-o-{ur u-qo ori t et{ onr c-€t cgqf,T gs Gr6i qifuq srB6 oi Er6i ft-d-q ercr o-{i t go-R fu-qr qrqr gqT-fl-6 q-Te o\ gi fr-rT fr +6 fr$ qd d g@ frn vq qrq qtrffifl dr'n t tS qFrd d q-s{or o\ X"r dv qr Eqt qrct qrfrq t qr+ftq srqtunq $al d enr dvrd Re erfta sozlzooe t dfra -qlqlctq ftutq fuqro zz zoog tl o1 o-fuor 4 t frquft ot .r$ t o1 qqfqr sTDftqq rgos d oiffi qqq frqr or furftor qerfl-rt d orfufl-r t io-R o.-{i tg T€t foqr .rfl t yq q-inf,q o-r qq-q 6-d-dq B qfr qm-ortt d qq fuq{rc fufl-E o-r Hr(tilq a[q rlEl=T o-{i d EMtuT t qrfufi ft-{ro.vur fu-qr qrq gS o.trsor i qe ftqoft fr of G B of qrsr s ,rqtcr ofiFqq d trE fuoq erqr fu-fl qrcT otd or qrfufi fra-+' +dT t yq fuoq fu-rfl o-q eTQrqr eTDo B, ot$ qre q$t rtgf,r, qt@ ftqr rqT w+wur qss Wt dror B r

39. qr+fiq \tqilq qrqroq d fr. zao d HqA fr oftTd ftqr rqr t of qm s rrqiEr olEftqq d ena-cc w fuqn znG wrq erft ilfrftfi EM"T fr qq+ zrBg 1,ti ve-ox znr '? qfuqtTr f+ta vqr.n ftta w smd (zoro) o gs.fr.

Page 16 of 24

vI. g. qilt-12,/2023 slFrtur ffiq +dT t n fu vs-d eTfuq-ffir oT, vrsT fr fuqfr o1 Ti t o1 frgffi sTtr{ffir d gM fi-{a frfu qq sqR'eTft d T€l o-trfr T$ \'s cerfii-r of q+qr fr TS fr T$, n-q qR gqts-fl o.r rruq q fuoq mfl fu-qr qrqr qfrq, srq fr ft;qufr sft T{ t et Eisn ft-qrq ot gq dq w firro-{q 6-{i d ceT t y-qrs *cr qTEq q a1 ilf,ffi Grrqr q{ s-s-rq o1 S-o- t{r sTEq r *e sfr'q, ilrnars fusq ffiq q.d go-c orei-d (zoos) e qs.fr.fr. zsz d qrq-d tt cTTftq sqf,{ Rlr{ne[q o'I oIftTf, t of ulEr Errrrrq qrq fo ilfi.-ffi Effir Hl+ll-ll.(|t fr-4[rur +l d, trq EqRtrrq qrq o]r rf,G ftqr qrcr qfrg, qrpl fr Equft o1 Tg t 01 f{6rq erqr ftti qrt ig qdrirr rrirr oxq rret'f *ar t c ft1 ft-f,q qff Gi-sE, rte sfr,s. oqfuoT ftw srq

Page 17 of 24

.fr.fr. rsz d r6qor osoo ftqfl d ft-f,q o) rqr ovd Eq qr+tq \tE-ilq d am frqoft of T$ B' of notq t .qlqtclq siilffitrd Tfr qfr qrN vq eto' trn oi M gv fusrq erqr fu-qr qrql ilEq vs rwr fr Eryft ot G t qt qm s qfqtfl srftfu{q fi sFtd qqtw onq rN sf,qifl T4-{ fr-trri o-cfl znBq orfu qrn-qn qrq srq d sd r fi-fl ")Erfr f{t'q ofrr+{ ofrq, ffi qfufr q-c erES (zors) z gs.ft.rfr. ras d s-m{q fr fust sK qa sqRerft d or,il-s fr tflT{ o-r fuqr .rfl, d g-flafqfl d qqA q qm+q s@Tq qrrrerq d am ft-q-{rr arTrnrrir a) fuf,q erff Ea n+-sq o) 5-{-{arffid or gq dtq w ft-im-r'r ori or fttcr frfl q-fl, arfu qeffir-ti d cts fuqqTq ffinrfr-c fuqrq oT oi( d vrd r fftA sror fuuq qfrfi mm' strsfl r,ti erq (zozt) s qs.fr.S. ozr d *nqor d .4

2L $L g. c{t-12,/2023 qr+ftq vqrq qrqrcq trM ftqoft o1 T$ t sfr Tqfw orsur of srwor T4-6 fr-qTq o-rqr zrBq, ilrfu Hrrsrc qrrlslc d E-d qq o-olr rrFr(o-s eTc-fl-S qfi t oS en dio qrq qr=r of EreTr q{rfuf, Et6{ crq-{fl ol qo fraor B r qFrfrq \rqilq qrqraq d gm fr.\'fl. clsFrfr ffi gi er;q fft-q r+c ds oqlao.r \q sral (zorc) z \'fl.fr.fr. rzs d q-qA fr GrftTd cM{a fo-qr rrqr t fu qq =qrq Eiq w d W q-q o-r El=r gon d, ncr o[c qa-oxt o) qrq sl{ ori Hqq qrr-f,dt am a-o-ffi ererqr vffi Efuot'T c-€t crrfl-qr qrfl "rBq t

40. erq sfl s-f,{"r d E=+f +t qRfuifut w sTio-f,{ fu-qr qrq d Grfufi-{q q-6 rrrdr t of mtro 2s.o7.2oos qi qq q-s-{"r S.q.p/2023 G dq. B/zooe E-{sd tg frq-d .}, aq efi.q. rzlzooa d Tq cffi qer uot o.q-fr sffi oqio r fi s vo o q+cr f,ffi-f, +fl BqR€rd q 1 qffi qqfT. q G s d frqq fr tw norq-a or entil frqr rrqr en \'s dg.relzoos +l qra qffi o-qio s +1 g.qRTfr clE efr fu{ft1 orffi d frqq ii rsFd( o-ffi fu-qr qET erTt frrgm-r qrcc r€i *t d o-nq eil-tyr e frqq s S.ft.qft. A vtsqrfl-gsn GTBo-iH al.\.tz / zooe d qffi qqtq t gs s d fu{-q gs 3i.9.13l2ooe d qffi oqio s d fu{-q srrtffi d'o or Iff, GTrilfi ftIw fuqr qr q-o-f,r qr, q-{fu Gil-iqo il-n d GrB{ffir q}E orffi tg g.qfurd t erqfd q6 d rqe B sft sTrn{o il-o' dr entcr s ft-qq 5 lfr.fr.Tft. d qrqtTn) d onr t dFdf, d+ q.sr B r

Page 18 of 24

VC. g. riry-12,/2023

41. qei ilm fudq t on+qq wgd 6-{i d rF]-{ur oT frsq t d r*ga qIilfi \d q-cQr qe t T6 derr e-rrd fu-qr rrqr t of T{ { Grr-nq-{ t-6 d lttDwr at tq ts tg fun fo sTffi *1 6gm fuur rrqr er, vsd EnT oTra-{6 d-f, d GTk{ffir d fr{ilr ftfut or crf,{ TSI fo-qr rrqr B gs Gr-ico' tr6 d gq-f,q of fr qfud rfr fufl r-fl si qr+{r d-o oi ao sTrifi B/2003 d ft-{K d q[i irr EFr dcr $il sq tro mw. e--$-fl d gRr e-qf, fu-qr .rqr frqlr{ yer\ar fi/2oo+ t vqdvw e-+.rRrd gS, re gil-neo. to gm u-qo ffi .ri p sTrnqc d ftyq q dq qqora o1.r$ yq qa gio gsTr of c-fir"r fuirfi 2s.o7.2oos et ft{w or frqr .rqr t t

42. f{reriqqT oTitr<-{ Ts fumq ercr sTrilfi t 9o. fr onq scrffl uqr t, fund sqet{ it sil-il{o f6 d M tiqt rnia r+tq d anr vrqeT T{ d qrurq t ifd orrnfi i sFfd oeaf oT Eqatt fu'qr .rqr t t

43. sr-{rn{o @-qi6 e "il Tf, s-owT t cffi c-€f aTI, efu Ss srBo.-{q d 3Tr-tsr fti.r6 30.06.2023 d norer tt cflmrr qq-qI rr-qr t, ffi qa t N qr& d-o d gm 15 !tl-rl-r zorr oi ftqrF{d Gi-sTfrue fic d oilEil-{ rN zq g-rfr or ro oiofuo $il t, vt\ gs q-m-{or d ft-{w *i o1 qRRerh-'qt vq eniro do d a-w y*vfv-rr srrfqc fr fut .ri oerit t r{dBd dQ4I oT en dtqr ,fr or-JqTfrn rfr mqr qT lrrrflr qqfr frfi-6 srqETrit d enEr-{ qr Gnfl-teo qqrq p d gr*r no-gor d g-{erfc{r mr fttET fu-qr rqr t t gq. g. ivt-rz,/zozs

Page 19 of 24

gsd srsr fr vffiq cRRTfr T6 fi t fu oTrf<-o t-fi d Er{ tf, sffi ufr oqfr gilT gdrq €d of dt+q-{ t ft} T} f,ur yrRT 20,1s,01,72s/-(ft-s o-t-s v+s drcr vm' Eurr( Hkr d s-+'fl) Fc$ u} s{ zooz of Raft r{ q-or+r w, sft q-{fr tg Td 3r-d-dr-{ qqlq B/2oos rqo fu-w rrrrT ert, Grari-d frf,Er{ qft o-rqt <rfr qr*r sis w t d-.n oTifq-r d-o d a-ffi-r*, sqr-fr Grffi gRr sTr+qfi t eremr qr;r{flfi{ of .r$ 1tr d enw qr la-0ft qer a\ Ed-ft qS {rRT o1 qtIdr t gefr u-<rt or t-+ \q qfu'trt A-fiR +fi oi Et6 src of {d-fr erfuo qrx 01 qqd + dfof, or tcr eilo Fo t gs qrqtrn fr c-S *ql r 4s. Sfl-q fi s) q-q i-€l B of 3rtr{o t-6 d gM s{ zoos il ft-rw gs rovq d g-+*erlqfl tg crsBfr ft-f,q t ftiro rg.oz.zoze d T6 e-crrur u-qo frrot .rfl B, fu-S qTTfiq irqilq q-q[f,q Ertr sc-t-ff sFfd eru-gwmt t cffi{a fuqidt d s-{'tcl t tqr qrq d fuf,q of Grqfu srEf, qE-dTUi Tfr +fr t, qfu fuoe ertr frr$ qfi fu voror rr+r o-rur qEf,[ot Etor t, vwr fr noqq fr sis w dfr qqfu fr qar/ noq gs qFr o-r uw Scq pq fr frqrguftq for t r

46. 5 qRRaTfut +t sr-+q-{o qiw p fr oi{ t trqd frrn T} vs cffi{d ft-dlol qr Ett qqFI u-.rc ort gs gs fi-o or rro t of smlt{f, qqTr. e d sffi{f, Rrdio\ t gs s-o{q t drqifua olqT qrqBf, q T& dq-r, qfu sFfd 6n"it d q-otgr +t ft-f,q erril or sTrn{dE do -f -.'

Page 20 of 24

$L g. riq{-i2l2023 oi z-r vqft u-orur tt g"T dE w Er-qr$ oT slr1-qR frqr vrqr qrqtrf, t vfuo i.r 4t. d +sr fu o1 .r$ qrqr tl qC apa qrqr rl-w +t qs erD-o-q"r grql oil-i{f, d-o or vqrl rorq etq.o-qio. e/2oo3 d cffi o-qio + gq s Ss eilq.@q-fi B/2003 d qffi oqro s o-r qrqr c:r Fr tw s-otcrq r-S qr{rn qri d ernm w ftEw or fti Ti t, u-{fu Gntu e ftqq s fi.fi.ffi. d csqrrT-Srly qra or).g.rz,/2003 d gffi q-,qrq. + gs s d fut-q Ts ei.\. rslzoo2 d sFdil-ff ffio g d fr$q fr nosq ft{w frrt qrt tFq w, orror ot al.\. tz/zoog d orq TGq sft-flfi qqto t, z, e Vq o Vq ei.g.relzoo3 Grar Tq cFffi 1, z, 4, s, o of orfiff E) Z-+t ,fr gs orkq-ffir BqRrd Ei Ti ei, T6 gfi ts frft-6 aE t, d qrqro-q/sTfuo-rq RM of .r{ q-iqer ZE t r

48. qqfu q6 grffio.q o-r utn-rq rfi t, tuE qmftq \E[ilq .qtqtdq dsm +go fu sfr vFwr furq fr.,zw8 tdt{r (zota)t 3 \r{I.tft.fr.rss vq w.o.w.fr. +o. ftftls TtI 3rq ffs-q qfrq-{ +o ofru' gfrgqr $i erq (zoz.) u *.*.*. uz d qrqA t qr sTftqr u-q-e fuq .rqr t +t qq crR-d ofl-tyr sTQmr trq q ot$ trqeT aE A-on-{ t n) tS ZE ot q-qrq fi gw< fuur qril qrBq t 4s. qsd qrq S eq4 ot.T{ t 01 ffi ff qfu of arflErq a1 Ztr d onq eTFr TEr Ehr sTEg t qmfiq i;@crq .tmrrarr d gR[ (zozg)s w. rfr.rfr. azt d Hqd q q-e laquft fi ot .r$ t o1 qq qrfu+. fi+io r*r ftEo w vge e) fu qrqrf,q sM ?

Page 21 of 24

\rq. g. t'{t-12,/2023 at T$ ZE s-.qa t, aq c ftrd qa Bfua t, qfu qrirTcrr or o-fq t of vs ZE oi Eqrrl qrq I

50. g*rd wrv fr 1o sTr'd<-{ 13/2oos d frrq q s-Mq oes qd fr t of vs ro-wr ot qRfuffit *i y.* t cfrn"r fr-i fun fr aa sr-a-c{ 12/2oos i qrR-d ftrn Tt sTresr o} GTrqT{ qfl-s-r etg. rglzooe fi ft{w fu-qr.rqr t q-qfu er).q. rs,/zooa d gw cffi 6qitr 1, z, +, s G o erEq-mr d qrtqq t scRerd gV ei \'s qH cffi orno g d ririq ht f,rfi-ff {6 T$ eft, a-q qn qffi Eqio 3 d fuEq fr no{ur q-tyr g ftqq 5 fi.ft.fi. d rur+rgwn ft{w frr} qd qlrq ert fu-d srftoi,r gni 3i-{qri tf S$ {6 d orsor ori.q. B/2oor fr eiq. p/2003 A cffi e-qrq t vq s of crgqRarft d orq ft-{w fuqr .rqr t, qa ttft s--qer ZE t, ffi q-q qqffi6 geg B qu ZE gux fun uri q1.q g, s1. g.fl qtFwr o1 qRfurfut d HEf d tqr qrq dt z16 vo ffl q-6-rur B, m-s-tt ft-f,q at dffi q-qfu a1 ge-+ t zo,oo,oo,ooo /-(frs @-0-s) FTt t fi sTBfi do erc (ck-fi l-fr) Eis w t, r+sT fr Gil-iqr e ftqq 5 Tft.fr.fi. d srqErr} d Gr-{A-qr E) qfi d orq arq wrfuf, $Tr t gq enilEo cer ot 3ir t fuflq t g_ffadqil orlrt rqo ort or qfl-qr rrsr omq frsqnr s-{i dr.q gs r{qrtTt-{ {rf t, orq at qR onn{fi t-f, o) T@-rd oTQrsr ffr GTfuo qrd w Erfr fi sfl qra oT El=r d .rqr +dr qft strteo t-o' gxr ngd fuqr rrirT Tfl srnqq e/zooa sffi aqw 4 Vs 5 GrQrqr dg. rslzoog d yffi Eqio 3 or €dq s-d'rFrfl TS E-rl-i qd

Page 22 of 24

W' g. {Tt-12,/2023 d znr*q ererqr ord{fi erfu{ffir ilT ft{sT crq c-€f alt or oerc ftri qd d orsor ft{tr o-q frqr rrqr t, Tq orrgq fr s-d-ft srD-f, {rfu oTarl-d 2o,oo,oo,ooo / -(d-fl s-rls) srn fr sTfuf, rr-fu t sR{fuf, e-qft u-owr o) s-{{erfE( fut qri or gTl-ilfi dcflIFT rrgo ftrw rlqr dtf,r q$ifu ctiqfuf, fudq t Ffq-{T otri<t rqa ori ot Gtq sitg or<or r€t ft-gdr, orq"r o1 fuf,q t 9,0{uI q-qd ori t srril{o qeT o) ot-{ sftR-fi orq qEar-i at ot$ senq{r r€l r6-fr r gc cRfuTfut fr gs fio or EM+fq g +t ord<o qer gmr qm{srfiq fuflq t sTrilfi n*go r€l fu-qr rrqr t, qfu rqa ftd .ri gqrQfqrT sn'ilfi G fudq e{qr Gntfi fr qorqr rrqr onq fuorq sr GrrETt-{ t, Grerlf, qfl s-o-{q ri fuf,q of st-qfu oi qrs ti d e\,il-q ctDrur fr tr|trf, dlo r{ of ci-cqfuf, qr*r, fuoq o-r wfifi-ruT vs EriT g{ leqeT ZE dr q-f,f, til qFNTII-f, -.{lqlclq qd sfud tr s2. s-m qRRerfui t gs fio oi qo t ot .rld fr ert-{6 qa d gnr entcr ft-{rfi zs.oz.zoos oi sTtrrfir frrn qd tg dd siem-i{ oTsrtfl rz qS c{-ara orTtfi u-qo frur rrqr, fu-S qrq ol q{-fuf, Eti t e-qrt d s(ttq t \-s 2o,oo,oo,ooo /-(fr's o-{ts) Fci t GTRo dtmvl qiq w +i d q-mtsr fr e-qd g-fielfwl 3r-ils-{ g.Fdf, qR-qq sTrtft-d o-r gs otrtqo' t-f, of {fl qqut 3l-qE d qro t dFdd E-{t gg tf, sTd-fi Gi.g. 13l2oog oI fuiro 2s.o7.2oos o1 fufr fi g,T dq w ET{r$ tg ffi qfi ilrtkT s-{-{Qrffud fuqr qr'+r dro trd w q-qtrf, it sfuotr s3. .nErc-mq GilicqF to gr*r rgo lcow erqr srdE-{ z,oo,ooo,z-(d oru) t-Eri ctrqq srltfufl

Page 23 of 24

TrL y. dry-rZ,/zOzg qr{ ffimn fu-qr qror B r entB-o cRqq {rRr fr t so,oool-(qqs1 6qr{) t-qi rfi.eN.a.sR sf,dw' ii vq r,so,ooo,z-(vo drel qql-fi EqN) t-qi '+ilrc A ffi fr Gltfl-ft 15 fr{s d siqr qrlT o-{, qrIT rfrq trm-{ur t rqo 6{t at [ffi qd d qPT u-qo gwe.rkn 3rff({ {$-o-ri fo-qr qror t t fler fr se frrqr qror t of enilq-o t-6 kir6 25.07-2005 d crar-d t 5+wtv-+ sTriqr crRf, dt mtro d qtq a1 or-qB ol qt'i qd 6r E-6-En c-€f frTr t s4. sm' sqt-ffi GTntfud YrdT d e]tal$-{ frfrq yoqq e/2e23 1fi6R fuqr qror t Ys Td 3nilfi ei.q. n/zoos + rr-flf t cltrd 3r-tcr ft{ifi zs.o7.zoos srqrfl fu-qT uior t 1 qRql-{fl; 3ridq-6 d-6 ar{ e-{gf, {f, 3nilq-{ 3il.g.rs,/zoo3 ft{m 2s.o7.2oos of Re{fr t g"r s}s w Ecqt-$ tg 5c, Tenfuf, fu-qr qror t t GTrAvr g_d qrqrf,q d eno fr{io 22.o9.zozs o1 dfuo frq t

,/' (trqffin) ffi{oTffi $.em.fr.(r.u. Ti E-ffisrrd.) lp , a TeI|{:-qrrd5{ ftqtq:-z2.oe 2023

Page 24 of 24

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead