Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals

M/S RANA GREENS vs UCO BANK on 20 December 2023

gc. q. ;i{t - 7/2023

f,ur rqft 3Tfufiq sf,cr5t

(q s GudsrE{rq)

(fior*c arffi - qr+fiq * vm ftqrs q}a)

1. rr.rT ft{ gnT mqrr$ei +ft qftfltrd Ri6, ffi e1q . svtIFs srffiS qrq {qr+o il6€rd uqft <ro u-<r tilvra {dtr tig tcna (vq.ft.)t

z. cftkd file sTrtrq 4t fi<{ RtE sq s-frs so s{, Ner eflu 1s6 *, fi{ ffi q:rq ?Dqdnl @S qrq rtqr+d ilrtrd vqft <rro qq frqra Edq t<i ,tqra (\'c.fi.)t

3. q-aqr ffi cfu fr qftfuo ss o-fte +s uq ffi gil+S qrq {qrqo n-#rf, Eq{ qrfi s<I fiqrf, {+t t-c frcrd (wft) t f{rq {61 d'n Rrq-ge 3ffifg qrqr sd'Erd offifi otdR ts, "tlqrf,

(wft) 3nrt{6 t enicorrur of gtt{ t ff rrisr f'fuf,r qfutrfiTrl strrsrfi +6 01 frt t fr oTffi{r qtt srfuf,ffir t

Page 1 of 11

W. q. ;iw - 7 /2023 3TT t qT (ftHio 2o:t2.202s ot dIF-d)

1. oTril{oq-q d am frfuI oTrnfi vm zz (z) ffi) eil-r.S.fr. g€ 1ee3 d YrqurcrS{R gs sTBfi-{ur gM {d rorq etf.q. qqir, rcn/zott t dtfrd ffs ftFirr 01.06.2022 oi ercl-ffi frti qri of stf,q-f,r tS t<=* 0s.01:023 o\ u-qo fu-qr rrrn tt vrq fr nor-r u-Eo ort tt gv fudq oi sqr frri Eni tg YQro, sTra-({ 3r$'q' 172/2023 ftdro 0s.01.2023 trEd fu-qrrqr t't

2. u-qf, frtt .ri ao qrtfi or €dq gs s-fii-r B of oTlil{o s'iw z cftr&-f, Rid s-d M trcr.ft{ or Ngt t, ffi gnr s{ zoto if sf,{srfi {oi d-o t ffiq flE:r{FII fr T$ fr I frffit or grrdrq r€t E\ cri w vf,t-qrfr t-+, gRr yfl 3Ttrf,rul d qqa aa ud-e< fi7s/2017 rqo ftur .rqr, fufld vs eTB{wr grt v6 q$q Fruiq ft{;6' ot.oo.zozz qRo ftrqrrqr B t

3. sTrilq-o qeT oT slfuoQr{ t fu sd qs srB-f,-rur d qqa u-qo frd 'rn p ud-6q ot qn-orfi Tfi A .r$ r qrft qn sTlilffi' cm a} q{fi oTffi sM ifrfl o1 T$ m-'r qanr d ,trTsrc d qrtqq t g{'orXq Frulq o-r gn ilt rrt IrrDwI ot sttryq o1 qFII trqr of 3Tlnffirlsr ol ftqq rr t.m ffi Flg-tr ffiq{ ft{c rsge d croqrtrgsn 3il-tRro.r qrfr T€l of Tg gs GTrn{o oqi6' r or rlekT qoT ftEo-r 3r-ffi rqo ftr+r rrqt ett, ffi gun o.-{i d qwtrd 6t$ qm qrfi T€t o1 T$, srq fr 3Tfu6el-t t fu oTl'f{o ce{ o\ tfro qrwx fiqrd frirtr 24. os.2o18 tt q+tt rorQrf, 01 .d, mS q-.ei ot

Page 2 of 11

\TI. \. ;i{{ - 7 /2023 srNR sTIn{6 qeT of Tfi frort sfl ?DRut sTr-ilq-f, qqr ol-ffl-& d .il-rr r€t d sort qrer fr GTftrer{ t of dt fr sTrtcr iD'T sFr gur, vrR-o \o. cffq ftoiq omrsm frd qri fu era-ct u-qo fu-qr .rfl t t

4. fuaq erqr snnqr d qrtqq t orfu{erq foqr .rqr B fu vqfr oTffi gr*r ifuo fr-q q+rr d erFRl=T d qruqq t sTrt{o cer o\ g6 qffq ffq t5r El=T EcTr I {S eTrET[r w frdq erfl frri qri or sr-dirr fu-qr .rfl t t

s. sr-{rn{f, to anr qerq d qrtqq t frfrq sil-ilqq G fuf,q eTqr oTii<'{ or futtq ori gv cfusr fuqr rrqr t of YfdwR Enr ifrf, +k w cffiqq sqfurd r€t gq, rq tc( etDpr=r Hr6 24.0s.2018 et otrql rrqr, fu( .fr yffi.rq sqRerd r-€t gV, Tq \16 cfu Eq-qr$ or eil-tcr frqr qrry gf, cetq ffq q}frf, fuqr ,rqr, fuE sTril{o ceil gRT ei-sfl sTrETrit q{ stm frfrq oTrtfi rgo fuur.rqr t dI ffi dFq c-€t t r

6. fuoq erqr srrilfi or ,fr g{ uurit w cfufl-( frqr rrql t of sTrtffi qs oi Xo urilc< tt r1a+ tw rorq-q ft{;o z+.os.zoze d qraq fi o-{rfr T$, fut ft cfuqrft,rq scRrd r€t gq \q ffi cfrk{ + ft-f,q or or$ on'r fi T€f fiInn rrfi t l f€ entmt qt f+oq erqr sTrn({ ftfifl frti qri or st-dtE F;qrrqr B t

7. sq-q celi ei gn 'rw t r na 3Tlilfi 1073/20113Tl-gd 61 3i-{drs-{ ffiqr rrqr B t

8. ffiq fr€ t fu *4n Td sTli{q 3fr.q 1073/2017 t crfu \'o. rItrq gofq fr{m ot'oo' 2022 slttrtkt fuq qfi dr'q t't

Page 3 of 11

\q. q. ;fTr - 7 /2023

e. Td sTrn({ d Gi-{dro-{ t qrqr qror t ot friro go.tt.zotz ol aa uril<t oTfuo-rur d wqer rqd fu-qr rrrrl, ftil-slf fuim 21.12.2017 d qreflgsrl cffitur o'r so ftTs ot o,RTI {drci 01 qu-+ ve fufuf, oem e-qf, o.-{i tg ftt';5 rz.oz.zote o\ sTBo-rur of Yftil-S d sqeT sqfurd *i tg +trfl nfud frtqr rrrnr eTrtcr cfu6, fu{ifi 31.03.2018 d ergvx ftiro ot.os. zore ol nfuf, ttrfl irFNI sTw d trqr, rq tc{ ToTqFI or eTrtcr fuI rTqT, fus w tfto qrwx frqrd fti'ro z+ r$ zota tt sffiqq or itEs norRrf, ?D-rrirT rrqT t, ffi qruqq t ffi d sqer sqfuTfr Eli at ftE tz.oz.zora of frrE frrf, of .r$ tn r qqfr sTrtvr cFf,rr ft{15 tz.oz. zora d crgwR qtro srTI d o-rqur c-6{ur fr"irf, 22.07.20'tB o.) TarFrf, Es[I, fu{ friro zz.oz.zota a\ yiro q,Tr d o-nq kqro 31.01.201a d ftq wrFrd $TI \'s ft{vq st.oz.zots a\ {fsqR d Er{r tw cffi'{H d oTrEl-{ qr il-Tft sfr ort gs ft6 d wqet grqr{ fu now gqEINUII q-fi-rd fuqr rrqr, fus qq ftiFn rz.og.zors a) ftrd.ri sil-t{r ctdo.r d ergwn rdr} Tn qi w sd dE Ei T+t afr qs yffiqq d fusq \o cefi.q U{-qri o.r sntu fl+qr rqr, wrer fr cffi 6qfq r oT rrf,T rrfr frri qri or ft ft{Yr frqr .rqr, fus w eil-t{r cFdo.r ffi'r6 $.os.zozz d GrgsR cffi +-,qrq z or vS tror Stc- r d rern qr frc- I I sfr fuqr .rqr t I zrsfr trfl dlfus sfr smrrrttr-f,r rfr crfr.r$ Br

10. ffi sFD EM iftd +fu qrv-s oTrqx sTffiq qr Bqdfcr tr erq-d}o.-{ oa q-qr qror t fr1 fus cfr w qifufl ifrd $rr, ss cfr w

Page 4 of 11

\,TI. q. ;iTt - 7 /2023 crw-{-df Bqf,er r€l ilt $ 61w frEs qrcfl gur, uula qe ftffi{o t 01 rfuqd sFD HrtT iftd ilk qffi rrur rro c-€f c-gil w yffi,rur t ntrs ei t S6R r€t fu-ql

11. qe ftffi{o t of W y6'w fr cffiqq o} nR-d ffi sro trEs dIftf, T€t $TI, ilq cfur€nfud f,rffi .F-{-ff G t t cfu{Qrfua ilfi-ft d frTq d sTrt{r s ftqc zo fr.fi.S.d ersqFir$Tn q-q qFrEr-q of qe frc-ql-fl d qror t o1 cffi w,is a1 dIftff t qq ra t, elQrsr erq oxqt t qfuqa drfi-fr scrq =rfr t rq iidq of cfr rQTrfuf, fl-{rfr of qr},ft, fusd sio.l( tf+o sqrqn qa. d s{I TeIFT w ffio +i{T d, wdt sffi d sifrq qrq fuqrsEo elarqr @lq$tq((l qri-o,fi dr gg q;RuI y?DTUI n u-qd frrt Ti M-st d qreT sTlilq-r qftfd-f, Ri-d i 3rqfl vifl q1q ouIFINI ilf$-d gqr ftrot dvra sFfd t, ftmS sntrn q{ sTlt(o qcT oT a-d t of 3rr'f<-6 sH qTq oraelrcI fr rrar B t gs ox"t v$ ffi sFF cTq rfr g{ | {S o.nur qd if+o qrwt HrilEIl-{ qa of qu-+ r€t w s-6-r t Tqfr Grir+Eo to am qE ild wr T qr t at oTi{flo cen t dq sqtw t d erc{r qf,r fusfl frqr sS qi w ffi sro iBo ot Ti \q tq{ ffiT{H tr{rfl rrfll Es frsq fr fid oT *ra B o1 gs Kn rl-t 46 ile,q qE-s1,i l.fr B o1 ff{ srqt"e t f,"fr qk i sTT{r qot \'Ffl fusr, qfu q-6-d['t T6 t at "eq1 qffiwr 6ra dlfrs iiBd *t mtro w slsl-st tw rorqn d sqq ffiuft cs d{ srqfu t e-drt 'rt qfr w ftsr-fl{d eTr, d ffi{ vs qt ao cEil \is ss qi * qIwoci fqrwd qdl qrqr rnn I FI

Page 5 of 11

gc. q. ;f{r - 7 /2023 cRfuTfut q w u* o\ ca ft-d-f,r B fu qrwq tt +trfl ift-d *i qqq elefid qrd zote fr u't qer orerfd Aa eril6 d cffiqq l-t /'ng oTtn aHft dmrf, d qt w frflsw c-S ,) 3il{ w ErT o\ .ft ca frf,dr t of +sr enleo cen iF-6 {6r B fu qrq ourcIrfl q q5 ftors tnrat B, {fl o'rwr dfrH dIftfl =r€t E n gs tw t e-orRrf, qq-fl {t oTrt<o ce{ d EH t E-S Gil-fr, qe ot$ qq.Fiil tnarfi c-€l t t

12. unr zz (z) (s) d trd sTBo{u o'I \.o' cefu sil-tu dl oTtIrKT Ed of qrRilfr rEI-{ a1 .r$ t t erx.S.fr. w 1ee3 o1 ensr z+ d ci-gqn rqfqT sTEftqq ie63 et qrtr 24 + oi-gqry qqfEr olEft{q tsos d s[qEIFT sqT s*ltl or1 frri Ti t, d crR-d qfi qtrq Gr-tvr o\ srqrkT frri qrt tg sTrnqq rqd od o1 srq frqr qe ttr ffi (ng-i-d ffiw r'oo) rgge it crqtnfrd c-€f t, aq rqlEr s1frftqq 1e63 d srgd-( rzs d norvr t t€-rT *q-r, ffi oi-gnn go qftq M erqrw ftil wi or sTri-fi vs cRfuTfr t so flC{fl d rfet rEo 61qr "TEq t qe cffi qqr rN sfua sq t ririq il-fi-f, $Tr t, fuE s6i frqH BfrT $q t orfi-f, T€t $Tr t, aq crfrf, sTrtcr oT en dri foim t so fr{fl + oicr srTil{r u-Ea ehr sGq, rnq effi ser rN sfuo w t €+fl offi-a gen t, fu-g qEi ririq sfua w t drfif, c-€t E Tr t, a-e crfud ffq o.r sn *i fu{i6 d so fr{fl d oiil sTri-fi u-*ga fo-+r qr so'cr B, {sd Hrer fr srffiq t qfr sl-g-dq rzs t qFtd w$fiwr d ffi,fu q-6 arrpr fr .ri t of qs sr-g-dE + frsq d oTrtsT s ftqq zo d

Page 6 of 11

W. q. ;iTt - 7 /2023 tr( ertfr .T{ cfu{erfud f,rffi sFdd drffi TS crfi qr$rft t

13. cirr *D'wr fr "rs T6 ftffi t o1 W sil-a-<q d cffir'r w fu sro t itro ${s cls{-dt ca {fl-} Tt ct qr sqileT;r *i d on"r drffi T€f g$ r entcr s ftqq zo fr.fi. fr. d rr€r<rEHR HrnqR qa d qrqq t e-orRrf, iItrfl of cfuerF-d f,rffi ergd-< rze qqfEr sTfuft{q d Avq fu sidd il-ffi Tfr qrfr T-$ t ilq eTriq-fi ceT e\ {fr oTfufi-{q gxr qtRo gfi' ceftq frof-q ?D'r Er=r dri kcio d so fu{fl d stcr vo ceflq ftolq ol erqrw frrt qd tg sr-trfi u-ga ori oT 66 fqfr d ffr ffi d.q tt

14. 3Tril{f, t-+' d gr-tt ild d qrqq t A-oq eilqr oTrtfi gs Td oTrt(q or f+tttT o.-{t gg qmftq sqf,q -{l lq ls{r{ d an{rEeif, Efo.I ffiqqa Gva emq rtsr rrq 0orr) o w.fr. vd.d. res, rfi +{ t{rs fr6 ftsa qRftrra olftvtq 2012 4 .d. ts r Egq ornilffi srmr f{t'q * dq, rrEFilET 2012 .fr. Ttrd +{ffi rni q-q fur€

Page 7 of 11

qfuT{ fu SITTD' zooe (e) w.fi.v6T.d. es u-qo fui .rt t t 1s. sffiIil{o s{ft{ffir gM rqd frti T} ild d s<{ fr sMq t of qr+fiq sqrq qrqrrq d ilrr {fid drEfl{ r,ti qq fudq t6 ds EFsqr d q-fiqur q tgl cffi d eTrflor d qqtf fr q+wr A tr$ t d ern.6. fi. g€ tsgs d Y,il-E *i d Xd qqm .qlqlclq d scfr oFq-o no-<q d scRrd e\ qa en Yq qc{qra *rwl TEur e-q.fr 3ltro--wr ($.ein'A')

I gc. q. "i{t - 7/2023 o.) fiqwt $il, fufld yffi d ftq gt: r{dv e-f,rprd oq-i of Gil-qqq?firT Tfi efrt {fl s-s-wr of cRRIfr Etrd, ft"{ t qfi gs q-6ror fr cffi ceT ol ifrrqg qle anr iR-o {qs il-ftd fr c-fr g.Tr qq Hcrqn qa d qrtqq * rolR,f, rilifl srgdq rzs rqkr qfuftqq A siil.ff, t'6 ce+q M o.) srrrgtT fron qfi & spq-f, drfi-ft T€t crfr.r{ trEE ?Frwr Gr-fl-n{o t-o at qm+q sqf,q qrqTcrrr d stm q?r{ei( ?Ft EIrq q-€l frqr qr wrFrrT I

16. Gt-{-n{f, to em qm+q \tqilq 'qlqlCl{l d d erq qrq-{Er( €rnT s rqf<T G{fuFqq d s-qr+ fi e-{gd H rt t, fuT{ Eio,r to,}rr{f, ftt-€ silqrtcr trer, q{t +{ tflq RiE fft-€ EHfurd olftqlq gq{ d qu urer_r'rz o-rfr gq {fl fid ?Dr rkT t et {fl rfi'{q a1 cRfufut tt cffiH, enrtil w frfrtT oTrilfi d sil-il{fi rrur tnr qErwr Btt-{fl jpf rfr t r qqfu B=I w qfurro n-ftfr Te g{ t r gs rrnq sr-{rf{6 t'fi o'} s?m qq-{srd t drlTrfuf, o61 fu-w qr E-+Tr I ssd sre{ fr qmftq vqilq qrqrcrq ErtI ff tfr Errer fur'a qli+{ GfirF gFsqr q" 3[q (zozl\ s \ry.fr.fr. azr fr "trqtq or<rr d apa ol v<rror $-o errsrT o-rt or fu€id cffi{d fu-qr rrqr t, orfu wrqrq E[rq rffT fo-fl ur sd t

17. trtr{qrfr d-o' of sn( fr rEa frd rrt erq qnrEEr(t Atrc t{

* to' ofrq,, sst€M ft&H cdic ftfr& ft-t,€ gnfu ffger (s srq d aea E-s yqw t T6RIEI

Page 8 of 11

gq. q. =f{r - 7 /2023 ftq *i fr gq qrq-ggrd t s-mrsrfi t-o' dI ot{ rcE c-€t ffit

18. gs frlm G{rilfi tt 3Tileo qeT i Rim zs. 11.2o2s d srqc S qrq d sTFrds rqd frtt t, s{-d ci-gsx tqr w vo-or t ot wrfrfrtde t-c{ o.} ritr qq-{r ffi oTffi d sTricl ft{ro ze.r t.zozz d s-ml$ t qrft at 'r{ t, fta-rd gTIETR w eTrilffi ca a) ss sTkd-tq gRT crRd vo ctrq ff-q o-l glq Hq Biz.zozz oi T{ft sR 6ti oT fuqr rr{r tFsFI fqrqrfl fttn qd dr.q t gq qrn<o cen gM qE eiltec ft{1o os.ot.zozs o'l u-Eo fu-urrqr t, olqff, EH Elt Riro te.tz.zozz t eo fu+s d siqr sTrtfi e-qf, fl kqr rqrr v< qRRlfut fr fi-o tnr rrrT t o1 eTlt{f, qql Elql u-qo mil+c err<t 22 (2) (fr) eTx.O.ft. v€ 1se3 3t-g-dE P3 qqkT oTEft{q rgog d Yrqtrrcl t fuBrf, drdr B G go ,*Xq fuq o.I gFI iIi fuirn t 30 fudfl + oie< rqa gur t, nq f{erq erqr oTlifi ffifiN fl rqd 3Trilfi Xw dv qq ftqro{q dr.q t r 1e. {c cRfuTfu{it d 3TIil@ ceil o\ gor ds w Eilqri irl Gltt-{l-t tt + s+w t rqa fuoe effir sTItfi 2s,oool-(qffifl rox) vci cR-qq sTrtfrd or Sfin fo-qr qror t r sTrtB-d cRqq {rfu q t rs,oool-(q<e rqx) vri 61'oo.6t. En qrmg( o1f n gq fu 1o,oool-((fl 6qR) vqt 'qrf, d drr df n go nkrrg d siqs qrTr frrt qri of rrd qs fuf,q emr fu-qr qror t t

20. erq ffiq aes t' of "Eqr qrRd 96 ,*Xq ffu sTrrr-KI frtt qri qY.q t" d qa

Page 9 of 11

\q. q. "f{r - 7 /2023 frffio aps t o1 p o1-5fi d qfufl-firg w iftH il-fi-d r€f E n vi wqrqx qa d qrtqq t rorRrd nfus efi<-orr"r d qfqn ftqrs qH ovlrrrcT fr ffia Si rsrR-d E)-dr d, Ss ttps rrr ot$ yrrTur q-€f B, srerf-d Ta srrilfr t vffiqur dt E-i-qr$ tnr Gttl-{N T€t ft-f,r t, erqtd qffiqq dt Ei ft-{r 1o' qe{tq ftutq crRd EsTr t t

21. frE \q aeqt oT cfrwr o-{t d cgqr-d srfuo{q zn-r qd t .ht {fu cffiqq srertd $fl frfrEr sil-nfr d erfeoqq w {et sr-ilfi 1ot3/2017 i *qq o1 dIffi gf, cftq trq d srqrkT H qri fu rq( frrt .rt qTA-fr d frsq t or-g-d-( 123 qqffl 3lfifrqq rsos d wfiotot d ergwn sqo arffi c-€f t r vs onq qrqFo t ao utn6q d cffiqq of gq ds w Eilqr$ ir-t sltr*n to{ trq qrRd fuqr .,tFrT lqB rmcT t t sTqtf, xoft qmlentrolq o-) g-{qr$ tnr srtr-{N fr} ft-{r crfud 96' cftq ff-q futo or.oo.zozz si ss Aofu d oi-g{RTr t nkd ffi wrw qa sqrtm sFfT cRfuTmf q sFdd cfuqq eillifuf, or orqrw frrt qri qtrq t I

22. rrtrrrcrT enn{o qfl ilrt e-Ed frlqfr sil-ilqc qrfeoqq cr so,ooo,/-(rurm rwn) vri qR'qq sTnIfuf, ord gv ffion fo-qr q-dr t r e[ntfrf, ctrqq qrRT or sW ,Tr.r s-mi-srfr {+i t-o' d \rsrsre t qqr e-{, vrril v$-< \'fi EqT;E d si<r rqd 6{i of yrd T{ Td urf6q Gil.*. 1ot3/zo'n qR'o vo q$q frulq frcio or.oo. zozz gq \o. cftq ftofq d srEcrwr q nfrf,

Page 10 of 11

\TI. q. ;fTt - 7 /2023 ffi wru rr.r eltrrftI fu-qr qrcr B \q oir.q. 1o7s/2o17 g"r ds w gror$ to g-c, {anfud fuqr qror B t

23. ffi o\ fttRrf, ft-qr qrcr t o1 qm zo

(r) (3) d ur+nn-5wn e-{fr oTffi ef Etrfr rFrrot tr, eTtIrkT ffi q[i o1 qs-{r }fud ot qHt

24. ffi *1 Pr{frn fu-qr qrcn t o1 W oTrn{q sft.g. rozs,/zotz sTrtfl fufo tz.os.zotg d T{ ot tufr t sil-t Xu dv w g+or$ fu sdl fft-r ct gq: tenfuf, ftq qrq t 2s. srrq sH ftiirq- zz.tz.zoze o-\ ffi d sqe{ scRrf, di, qr.T fr we foqr qrar t fu cffiqq o\ ao oTIilfi t el-+ffi u-qd o{i of wrq ffqr so fu{s fuirf, 22-12.2023 t cR"{ dfrt

26. strq qH ortl=Ir orrqT qq {6q ott t slrtyr gd ail-rllerq g qrq ft-qio zo.tz.zozs d dfro frqt \2- 0)) s{dg( fuiT,i-2l.12.2023 23' $6r€H 3TPmrfr) S.eil{.8. q. c., \'di uffistra

Page 11 of 11

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead