Debts Recovery Tribunals and Appellate Tribunals
M/S RANA GREENS vs UCO BANK on 20 December 2023
gc. q. ;i{t - 7/2023
f,ur rqft 3Tfufiq sf,cr5t
(q s GudsrE{rq)
(fior*c arffi - qr+fiq * vm ftqrs q}a)
1. rr.rT ft{ gnT mqrr$ei +ft qftfltrd Ri6, ffi e1q . svtIFs srffiS qrq {qr+o il6€rd uqft <ro u-<r tilvra {dtr tig tcna (vq.ft.)t
z. cftkd file sTrtrq 4t fi<{ RtE sq s-frs so s{, Ner eflu 1s6 *, fi{ ffi q:rq ?Dqdnl @S qrq rtqr+d ilrtrd vqft <rro qq frqra Edq t<i ,tqra (\'c.fi.)t
3. q-aqr ffi cfu fr qftfuo ss o-fte +s uq ffi gil+S qrq {qrqo n-#rf, Eq{ qrfi s<I fiqrf, {+t t-c frcrd (wft) t f{rq {61 d'n Rrq-ge 3ffifg qrqr sd'Erd offifi otdR ts, "tlqrf,
(wft) 3nrt{6 t enicorrur of gtt{ t ff rrisr f'fuf,r qfutrfiTrl strrsrfi +6 01 frt t fr oTffi{r qtt srfuf,ffir t
Page 1 of 11
W. q. ;iw - 7 /2023 3TT t qT (ftHio 2o:t2.202s ot dIF-d)
1. oTril{oq-q d am frfuI oTrnfi vm zz (z) ffi) eil-r.S.fr. g€ 1ee3 d YrqurcrS{R gs sTBfi-{ur gM {d rorq etf.q. qqir, rcn/zott t dtfrd ffs ftFirr 01.06.2022 oi ercl-ffi frti qri of stf,q-f,r tS t<=* 0s.01:023 o\ u-qo fu-qr rrrn tt vrq fr nor-r u-Eo ort tt gv fudq oi sqr frri Eni tg YQro, sTra-({ 3r$'q' 172/2023 ftdro 0s.01.2023 trEd fu-qrrqr t't
2. u-qf, frtt .ri ao qrtfi or €dq gs s-fii-r B of oTlil{o s'iw z cftr&-f, Rid s-d M trcr.ft{ or Ngt t, ffi gnr s{ zoto if sf,{srfi {oi d-o t ffiq flE:r{FII fr T$ fr I frffit or grrdrq r€t E\ cri w vf,t-qrfr t-+, gRr yfl 3Ttrf,rul d qqa aa ud-e< fi7s/2017 rqo ftur .rqr, fufld vs eTB{wr grt v6 q$q Fruiq ft{;6' ot.oo.zozz qRo ftrqrrqr B t
3. sTrilq-o qeT oT slfuoQr{ t fu sd qs srB-f,-rur d qqa u-qo frd 'rn p ud-6q ot qn-orfi Tfi A .r$ r qrft qn sTlilffi' cm a} q{fi oTffi sM ifrfl o1 T$ m-'r qanr d ,trTsrc d qrtqq t g{'orXq Frulq o-r gn ilt rrt IrrDwI ot sttryq o1 qFII trqr of 3Tlnffirlsr ol ftqq rr t.m ffi Flg-tr ffiq{ ft{c rsge d croqrtrgsn 3il-tRro.r qrfr T€l of Tg gs GTrn{o oqi6' r or rlekT qoT ftEo-r 3r-ffi rqo ftr+r rrqt ett, ffi gun o.-{i d qwtrd 6t$ qm qrfi T€t o1 T$, srq fr 3Tfu6el-t t fu oTl'f{o ce{ o\ tfro qrwx fiqrd frirtr 24. os.2o18 tt q+tt rorQrf, 01 .d, mS q-.ei ot
Page 2 of 11
\TI. \. ;i{{ - 7 /2023 srNR sTIn{6 qeT of Tfi frort sfl ?DRut sTr-ilq-f, qqr ol-ffl-& d .il-rr r€t d sort qrer fr GTftrer{ t of dt fr sTrtcr iD'T sFr gur, vrR-o \o. cffq ftoiq omrsm frd qri fu era-ct u-qo fu-qr .rfl t t
4. fuaq erqr snnqr d qrtqq t orfu{erq foqr .rqr B fu vqfr oTffi gr*r ifuo fr-q q+rr d erFRl=T d qruqq t sTrt{o cer o\ g6 qffq ffq t5r El=T EcTr I {S eTrET[r w frdq erfl frri qri or sr-dirr fu-qr .rfl t t
s. sr-{rn{f, to anr qerq d qrtqq t frfrq sil-ilqq G fuf,q eTqr oTii<'{ or futtq ori gv cfusr fuqr rrqr t of YfdwR Enr ifrf, +k w cffiqq sqfurd r€t gq, rq tc( etDpr=r Hr6 24.0s.2018 et otrql rrqr, fu( .fr yffi.rq sqRerd r-€t gV, Tq \16 cfu Eq-qr$ or eil-tcr frqr qrry gf, cetq ffq q}frf, fuqr ,rqr, fuE sTril{o ceil gRT ei-sfl sTrETrit q{ stm frfrq oTrtfi rgo fuur.rqr t dI ffi dFq c-€t t r
6. fuoq erqr srrilfi or ,fr g{ uurit w cfufl-( frqr rrql t of sTrtffi qs oi Xo urilc< tt r1a+ tw rorq-q ft{;o z+.os.zoze d qraq fi o-{rfr T$, fut ft cfuqrft,rq scRrd r€t gq \q ffi cfrk{ + ft-f,q or or$ on'r fi T€f fiInn rrfi t l f€ entmt qt f+oq erqr sTrn({ ftfifl frti qri or st-dtE F;qrrqr B t
7. sq-q celi ei gn 'rw t r na 3Tlilfi 1073/20113Tl-gd 61 3i-{drs-{ ffiqr rrqr B t
8. ffiq fr€ t fu *4n Td sTli{q 3fr.q 1073/2017 t crfu \'o. rItrq gofq fr{m ot'oo' 2022 slttrtkt fuq qfi dr'q t't
Page 3 of 11
\q. q. ;fTr - 7 /2023
e. Td sTrn({ d Gi-{dro-{ t qrqr qror t ot friro go.tt.zotz ol aa uril<t oTfuo-rur d wqer rqd fu-qr rrrrl, ftil-slf fuim 21.12.2017 d qreflgsrl cffitur o'r so ftTs ot o,RTI {drci 01 qu-+ ve fufuf, oem e-qf, o.-{i tg ftt';5 rz.oz.zote o\ sTBo-rur of Yftil-S d sqeT sqfurd *i tg +trfl nfud frtqr rrrnr eTrtcr cfu6, fu{ifi 31.03.2018 d ergvx ftiro ot.os. zore ol nfuf, ttrfl irFNI sTw d trqr, rq tc{ ToTqFI or eTrtcr fuI rTqT, fus w tfto qrwx frqrd fti'ro z+ r$ zota tt sffiqq or itEs norRrf, ?D-rrirT rrqT t, ffi qruqq t ffi d sqer sqfuTfr Eli at ftE tz.oz.zora of frrE frrf, of .r$ tn r qqfr sTrtvr cFf,rr ft{15 tz.oz. zora d crgwR qtro srTI d o-rqur c-6{ur fr"irf, 22.07.20'tB o.) TarFrf, Es[I, fu{ friro zz.oz.zota a\ yiro q,Tr d o-nq kqro 31.01.201a d ftq wrFrd $TI \'s ft{vq st.oz.zots a\ {fsqR d Er{r tw cffi'{H d oTrEl-{ qr il-Tft sfr ort gs ft6 d wqet grqr{ fu now gqEINUII q-fi-rd fuqr rrqr, fus qq ftiFn rz.og.zors a) ftrd.ri sil-t{r ctdo.r d ergwn rdr} Tn qi w sd dE Ei T+t afr qs yffiqq d fusq \o cefi.q U{-qri o.r sntu fl+qr rqr, wrer fr cffi 6qfq r oT rrf,T rrfr frri qri or ft ft{Yr frqr .rqr, fus w eil-t{r cFdo.r ffi'r6 $.os.zozz d GrgsR cffi +-,qrq z or vS tror Stc- r d rern qr frc- I I sfr fuqr .rqr t I zrsfr trfl dlfus sfr smrrrttr-f,r rfr crfr.r$ Br
10. ffi sFD EM iftd +fu qrv-s oTrqx sTffiq qr Bqdfcr tr erq-d}o.-{ oa q-qr qror t fr1 fus cfr w qifufl ifrd $rr, ss cfr w
Page 4 of 11
\,TI. q. ;iTt - 7 /2023 crw-{-df Bqf,er r€l ilt $ 61w frEs qrcfl gur, uula qe ftffi{o t 01 rfuqd sFD HrtT iftd ilk qffi rrur rro c-€f c-gil w yffi,rur t ntrs ei t S6R r€t fu-ql
11. qe ftffi{o t of W y6'w fr cffiqq o} nR-d ffi sro trEs dIftf, T€t $TI, ilq cfur€nfud f,rffi .F-{-ff G t t cfu{Qrfua ilfi-ft d frTq d sTrt{r s ftqc zo fr.fi.S.d ersqFir$Tn q-q qFrEr-q of qe frc-ql-fl d qror t o1 cffi w,is a1 dIftff t qq ra t, elQrsr erq oxqt t qfuqa drfi-fr scrq =rfr t rq iidq of cfr rQTrfuf, fl-{rfr of qr},ft, fusd sio.l( tf+o sqrqn qa. d s{I TeIFT w ffio +i{T d, wdt sffi d sifrq qrq fuqrsEo elarqr @lq$tq((l qri-o,fi dr gg q;RuI y?DTUI n u-qd frrt Ti M-st d qreT sTlilq-r qftfd-f, Ri-d i 3rqfl vifl q1q ouIFINI ilf$-d gqr ftrot dvra sFfd t, ftmS sntrn q{ sTlt(o qcT oT a-d t of 3rr'f<-6 sH qTq oraelrcI fr rrar B t gs ox"t v$ ffi sFF cTq rfr g{ | {S o.nur qd if+o qrwt HrilEIl-{ qa of qu-+ r€t w s-6-r t Tqfr Grir+Eo to am qE ild wr T qr t at oTi{flo cen t dq sqtw t d erc{r qf,r fusfl frqr sS qi w ffi sro iBo ot Ti \q tq{ ffiT{H tr{rfl rrfll Es frsq fr fid oT *ra B o1 gs Kn rl-t 46 ile,q qE-s1,i l.fr B o1 ff{ srqt"e t f,"fr qk i sTT{r qot \'Ffl fusr, qfu q-6-d['t T6 t at "eq1 qffiwr 6ra dlfrs iiBd *t mtro w slsl-st tw rorqn d sqq ffiuft cs d{ srqfu t e-drt 'rt qfr w ftsr-fl{d eTr, d ffi{ vs qt ao cEil \is ss qi * qIwoci fqrwd qdl qrqr rnn I FI
Page 5 of 11
gc. q. ;f{r - 7 /2023 cRfuTfut q w u* o\ ca ft-d-f,r B fu qrwq tt +trfl ift-d *i qqq elefid qrd zote fr u't qer orerfd Aa eril6 d cffiqq l-t /'ng oTtn aHft dmrf, d qt w frflsw c-S ,) 3il{ w ErT o\ .ft ca frf,dr t of +sr enleo cen iF-6 {6r B fu qrq ourcIrfl q q5 ftors tnrat B, {fl o'rwr dfrH dIftfl =r€t E n gs tw t e-orRrf, qq-fl {t oTrt<o ce{ d EH t E-S Gil-fr, qe ot$ qq.Fiil tnarfi c-€l t t
12. unr zz (z) (s) d trd sTBo{u o'I \.o' cefu sil-tu dl oTtIrKT Ed of qrRilfr rEI-{ a1 .r$ t t erx.S.fr. w 1ee3 o1 ensr z+ d ci-gqn rqfqT sTEftqq ie63 et qrtr 24 + oi-gqry qqfEr olEft{q tsos d s[qEIFT sqT s*ltl or1 frri Ti t, d crR-d qfi qtrq Gr-tvr o\ srqrkT frri qrt tg sTrnqq rqd od o1 srq frqr qe ttr ffi (ng-i-d ffiw r'oo) rgge it crqtnfrd c-€f t, aq rqlEr s1frftqq 1e63 d srgd-( rzs d norvr t t€-rT *q-r, ffi oi-gnn go qftq M erqrw ftil wi or sTri-fi vs cRfuTfr t so flC{fl d rfet rEo 61qr "TEq t qe cffi qqr rN sfua sq t ririq il-fi-f, $Tr t, fuE s6i frqH BfrT $q t orfi-f, T€t $Tr t, aq crfrf, sTrtcr oT en dri foim t so fr{fl + oicr srTil{r u-Ea ehr sGq, rnq effi ser rN sfuo w t €+fl offi-a gen t, fu-g qEi ririq sfua w t drfif, c-€t E Tr t, a-e crfud ffq o.r sn *i fu{i6 d so fr{fl d oiil sTri-fi u-*ga fo-+r qr so'cr B, {sd Hrer fr srffiq t qfr sl-g-dq rzs t qFtd w$fiwr d ffi,fu q-6 arrpr fr .ri t of qs sr-g-dE + frsq d oTrtsT s ftqq zo d
Page 6 of 11
W. q. ;iTt - 7 /2023 tr( ertfr .T{ cfu{erfud f,rffi sFdd drffi TS crfi qr$rft t
13. cirr *D'wr fr "rs T6 ftffi t o1 W sil-a-<q d cffir'r w fu sro t itro ${s cls{-dt ca {fl-} Tt ct qr sqileT;r *i d on"r drffi T€f g$ r entcr s ftqq zo fr.fi. fr. d rr€r<rEHR HrnqR qa d qrqq t e-orRrf, iItrfl of cfuerF-d f,rffi ergd-< rze qqfEr sTfuft{q d Avq fu sidd il-ffi Tfr qrfr T-$ t ilq eTriq-fi ceT e\ {fr oTfufi-{q gxr qtRo gfi' ceftq frof-q ?D'r Er=r dri kcio d so fu{fl d stcr vo ceflq ftolq ol erqrw frrt qd tg sr-trfi u-ga ori oT 66 fqfr d ffr ffi d.q tt
14. 3Tril{f, t-+' d gr-tt ild d qrqq t A-oq eilqr oTrtfi gs Td oTrt(q or f+tttT o.-{t gg qmftq sqf,q -{l lq ls{r{ d an{rEeif, Efo.I ffiqqa Gva emq rtsr rrq 0orr) o w.fr. vd.d. res, rfi +{ t{rs fr6 ftsa qRftrra olftvtq 2012 4 .d. ts r Egq ornilffi srmr f{t'q * dq, rrEFilET 2012 .fr. Ttrd +{ffi rni q-q fur€
Page 7 of 11
qfuT{ fu SITTD' zooe (e) w.fi.v6T.d. es u-qo fui .rt t t 1s. sffiIil{o s{ft{ffir gM rqd frti T} ild d s<{ fr sMq t of qr+fiq sqrq qrqrrq d ilrr {fid drEfl{ r,ti qq fudq t6 ds EFsqr d q-fiqur q tgl cffi d eTrflor d qqtf fr q+wr A tr$ t d ern.6. fi. g€ tsgs d Y,il-E *i d Xd qqm .qlqlclq d scfr oFq-o no-<q d scRrd e\ qa en Yq qc{qra *rwl TEur e-q.fr 3ltro--wr ($.ein'A')
I gc. q. "i{t - 7/2023 o.) fiqwt $il, fufld yffi d ftq gt: r{dv e-f,rprd oq-i of Gil-qqq?firT Tfi efrt {fl s-s-wr of cRRIfr Etrd, ft"{ t qfi gs q-6ror fr cffi ceT ol ifrrqg qle anr iR-o {qs il-ftd fr c-fr g.Tr qq Hcrqn qa d qrtqq * rolR,f, rilifl srgdq rzs rqkr qfuftqq A siil.ff, t'6 ce+q M o.) srrrgtT fron qfi & spq-f, drfi-ft T€t crfr.r{ trEE ?Frwr Gr-fl-n{o t-o at qm+q sqf,q qrqTcrrr d stm q?r{ei( ?Ft EIrq q-€l frqr qr wrFrrT I
16. Gt-{-n{f, to em qm+q \tqilq 'qlqlCl{l d d erq qrq-{Er( €rnT s rqf<T G{fuFqq d s-qr+ fi e-{gd H rt t, fuT{ Eio,r to,}rr{f, ftt-€ silqrtcr trer, q{t +{ tflq RiE fft-€ EHfurd olftqlq gq{ d qu urer_r'rz o-rfr gq {fl fid ?Dr rkT t et {fl rfi'{q a1 cRfufut tt cffiH, enrtil w frfrtT oTrilfi d sil-il{fi rrur tnr qErwr Btt-{fl jpf rfr t r qqfu B=I w qfurro n-ftfr Te g{ t r gs rrnq sr-{rf{6 t'fi o'} s?m qq-{srd t drlTrfuf, o61 fu-w qr E-+Tr I ssd sre{ fr qmftq vqilq qrqrcrq ErtI ff tfr Errer fur'a qli+{ GfirF gFsqr q" 3[q (zozl\ s \ry.fr.fr. azr fr "trqtq or<rr d apa ol v<rror $-o errsrT o-rt or fu€id cffi{d fu-qr rrqr t, orfu wrqrq E[rq rffT fo-fl ur sd t
17. trtr{qrfr d-o' of sn( fr rEa frd rrt erq qnrEEr(t Atrc t{
* to' ofrq,, sst€M ft&H cdic ftfr& ft-t,€ gnfu ffger (s srq d aea E-s yqw t T6RIEI
Page 8 of 11
gq. q. =f{r - 7 /2023 ftq *i fr gq qrq-ggrd t s-mrsrfi t-o' dI ot{ rcE c-€t ffit
18. gs frlm G{rilfi tt 3Tileo qeT i Rim zs. 11.2o2s d srqc S qrq d sTFrds rqd frtt t, s{-d ci-gsx tqr w vo-or t ot wrfrfrtde t-c{ o.} ritr qq-{r ffi oTffi d sTricl ft{ro ze.r t.zozz d s-ml$ t qrft at 'r{ t, fta-rd gTIETR w eTrilffi ca a) ss sTkd-tq gRT crRd vo ctrq ff-q o-l glq Hq Biz.zozz oi T{ft sR 6ti oT fuqr rr{r tFsFI fqrqrfl fttn qd dr.q t gq qrn<o cen gM qE eiltec ft{1o os.ot.zozs o'l u-Eo fu-urrqr t, olqff, EH Elt Riro te.tz.zozz t eo fu+s d siqr sTrtfi e-qf, fl kqr rqrr v< qRRlfut fr fi-o tnr rrrT t o1 eTlt{f, qql Elql u-qo mil+c err<t 22 (2) (fr) eTx.O.ft. v€ 1se3 3t-g-dE P3 qqkT oTEft{q rgog d Yrqtrrcl t fuBrf, drdr B G go ,*Xq fuq o.I gFI iIi fuirn t 30 fudfl + oie< rqa gur t, nq f{erq erqr oTlifi ffifiN fl rqd 3Trilfi Xw dv qq ftqro{q dr.q t r 1e. {c cRfuTfu{it d 3TIil@ ceil o\ gor ds w Eilqri irl Gltt-{l-t tt + s+w t rqa fuoe effir sTItfi 2s,oool-(qffifl rox) vci cR-qq sTrtfrd or Sfin fo-qr qror t r sTrtB-d cRqq {rfu q t rs,oool-(q<e rqx) vri 61'oo.6t. En qrmg( o1f n gq fu 1o,oool-((fl 6qR) vqt 'qrf, d drr df n go nkrrg d siqs qrTr frrt qri of rrd qs fuf,q emr fu-qr qror t t
20. erq ffiq aes t' of "Eqr qrRd 96 ,*Xq ffu sTrrr-KI frtt qri qY.q t" d qa
Page 9 of 11
\q. q. "f{r - 7 /2023 frffio aps t o1 p o1-5fi d qfufl-firg w iftH il-fi-d r€f E n vi wqrqx qa d qrtqq t rorRrd nfus efi<-orr"r d qfqn ftqrs qH ovlrrrcT fr ffia Si rsrR-d E)-dr d, Ss ttps rrr ot$ yrrTur q-€f B, srerf-d Ta srrilfr t vffiqur dt E-i-qr$ tnr Gttl-{N T€t ft-f,r t, erqtd qffiqq dt Ei ft-{r 1o' qe{tq ftutq crRd EsTr t t
21. frE \q aeqt oT cfrwr o-{t d cgqr-d srfuo{q zn-r qd t .ht {fu cffiqq srertd $fl frfrEr sil-nfr d erfeoqq w {et sr-ilfi 1ot3/2017 i *qq o1 dIffi gf, cftq trq d srqrkT H qri fu rq( frrt .rt qTA-fr d frsq t or-g-d-( 123 qqffl 3lfifrqq rsos d wfiotot d ergwn sqo arffi c-€f t r vs onq qrqFo t ao utn6q d cffiqq of gq ds w Eilqr$ ir-t sltr*n to{ trq qrRd fuqr .,tFrT lqB rmcT t t sTqtf, xoft qmlentrolq o-) g-{qr$ tnr srtr-{N fr} ft-{r crfud 96' cftq ff-q futo or.oo.zozz si ss Aofu d oi-g{RTr t nkd ffi wrw qa sqrtm sFfT cRfuTmf q sFdd cfuqq eillifuf, or orqrw frrt qri qtrq t I
22. rrtrrrcrT enn{o qfl ilrt e-Ed frlqfr sil-ilqc qrfeoqq cr so,ooo,/-(rurm rwn) vri qR'qq sTnIfuf, ord gv ffion fo-qr q-dr t r e[ntfrf, ctrqq qrRT or sW ,Tr.r s-mi-srfr {+i t-o' d \rsrsre t qqr e-{, vrril v$-< \'fi EqT;E d si<r rqd 6{i of yrd T{ Td urf6q Gil.*. 1ot3/zo'n qR'o vo q$q frulq frcio or.oo. zozz gq \o. cftq ftofq d srEcrwr q nfrf,
Page 10 of 11
\TI. q. ;fTt - 7 /2023 ffi wru rr.r eltrrftI fu-qr qrcr B \q oir.q. 1o7s/2o17 g"r ds w gror$ to g-c, {anfud fuqr qror B t
23. ffi o\ fttRrf, ft-qr qrcr t o1 qm zo
(r) (3) d ur+nn-5wn e-{fr oTffi ef Etrfr rFrrot tr, eTtIrkT ffi q[i o1 qs-{r }fud ot qHt
24. ffi *1 Pr{frn fu-qr qrcn t o1 W oTrn{q sft.g. rozs,/zotz sTrtfl fufo tz.os.zotg d T{ ot tufr t sil-t Xu dv w g+or$ fu sdl fft-r ct gq: tenfuf, ftq qrq t 2s. srrq sH ftiirq- zz.tz.zoze o-\ ffi d sqe{ scRrf, di, qr.T fr we foqr qrar t fu cffiqq o\ ao oTIilfi t el-+ffi u-qd o{i of wrq ffqr so fu{s fuirf, 22-12.2023 t cR"{ dfrt
26. strq qH ortl=Ir orrqT qq {6q ott t slrtyr gd ail-rllerq g qrq ft-qio zo.tz.zozs d dfro frqt \2- 0)) s{dg( fuiT,i-2l.12.2023 23' $6r€H 3TPmrfr) S.eil{.8. q. c., \'di uffistra
Page 11 of 11
Loading citations and judicial treatment…