OSA/185/2023 of MOHAN (DECEASED) 1. N.MUNIANATHAN Vs V. JEEVA (DECEASED) A.DANIEL (DECEASED) 1. JAMES S on 15 October 2026

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED: 15-10-2026

CORAM

THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE N. SATHISH KUMAR

AND

THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE GK.MUTHUKUMAAR

OSA No. 185 of 2023 and CMP.No.21868 of 2023

CNR: {HCMA011518722023}

1. Mohan (deceased) 1. N.Munianathan

S/o.Nagappa Naicker, No.52, Pillayar Kovil street, Puliyambedu, Chennai-600077

2. Narasimman

S/o.Jeganathan, No.171, V.V.Kovil street, Ramakrishna Nagar, Alwarthirunagar, Chennai-600088

3. P.Srinivasan

s/o.Parthasarathy, No.113, 3rd Avenue Anna Nagar, Chennai-600040

4. Devika M

W/o.B.Mohan, Res at No.126, Poonamallee

High Road, Velappanchavadi, Chennai-600077

5. Abinash M

D/o.B.Mohan, Res at No.126, Poonamallee

High Road, Velappanchavadi, Chennai-600077

6. Lavanya M

D/o.B.Mohan, Res at No.126, Poonamallee

High Road, Velappanchavadi, Chennai-600077

..Appellant(s)

Vs

1. V. Jeeva (deceased) A.Daniel (deceased) 1.

James Stephen

S/o.Late Arul Doss, res at No.8/8, Anna Street, Gandhi Nagar, Saligramam, Chennai-600093

2. A.Christina

D/o.Late Mr.Arul Doss and W/o.Edward, res at

( Uploaded on: 26/10/2026 12:55:15 pm )

No.8/8, Anna Street, Gandhi Nagar,

Saligramam, Chennai-600093

3. A.Regina

D/o.Late Arul Doss and W/o.Gunasekaran, res at No.8/8, Anna Street, Gandhi Nagar, Saligramam, Chennai-600093

4. A.Alphonsa

D/o.Late Arul Doss res at No.8/8, Anna Street, Gandhi Nagar, Saligramam, Chennai-600093

5. M.Balakrishnan

s/o.Munusamy, Old No.5/165, Kamaraj Street, Palanjur, Chembarambakkam, chennai-600123

6. B.Vincent

S/lo.M.Balakrishnan, 1496, School Street, Palanjur, Chembarambakkam, chennai-600123

7. K.Reeta

W/o.P.Kumar, 52/51, Perumal Koil Street, Numbel, Chennai-600077

8. S.Allis

W/o.A.Sivalingam, 1751/Annai Sathya Street, Palanjur, Chembarambakkam, chennai-600123

9. Paul Essaikial

S/o.Balakrishnan, 1664, Kamarajar Street, Palanjur, Chembarambakkam, chennai-600123

10.B.Sathrock

s/o.Balakrishnan, NO.1525 Ellimuis Nagar, Paapachathiram, Chembarambakkam, chennai-600123

11.E.Yesumani

W/o.Yesupadham, 9/25, Kalaingar Street, Priya Colony, Nandhambakkam, Chennai-600069

12.B.Rajkumar

s/o.Balakrishnan, 5/165, Kamarajar Street,

( Uploaded on: 26/10/2026 12:55:15 pm )

Palanjur, Chembarambakkam, chennai-600123

13.D.Vasantha

W/o.Late Daniel, res at NO.8, Anna Street, Gandhi Street, Saligramam, Vadapalani, Chennai-600093

14.Minor Thoshann Harrish

S/o.Late Daniel, rep by mother and Natural guardian the 13th respondent, res at NO.8, Anna Street, Gandhi Street, Saligramam, Vadapalani, Chennai-600093

15.Minor Karunya

D/o.Late Daniel, rep by mother and Natural guardian the 13th respondent, res at NO.8, Anna Street, Gandhi Street, Saligramam, Vadapalani, Chennai-600093

16.R.Devi

W/o.Late V.Rajagopal, res at No.2, Anna

Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

17.R.Padmanaban

S/o.Late V.Rajagopal, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

18.R.Gopi

S/o.Late V.Rajagopal, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

19.R.Krishnaraj

S/o.Late V.Rajagopal, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

20.R.Shanthamoorthy

S/o.Late V.Rajagopal, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

21.R.Subbulakshmi

D/o.Late V.Rajagopal, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

( Uploaded on: 26/10/2026 12:55:15 pm )

22.R.Muthulakshmi

D/o.Late V.Rajagopal, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

23.R.Komala

D/o.Late V.Rajagopal, No.5/165, Kamarajar Street, Chembarambakkam, Poonamallee

24.V.Devi

W/o.Late V.Veera Raghavan, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

25.V.Ramesh

s/o.Late V.Veera Raghavan, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

26.V.Ramachandran

S/o.Velu, res at No.2, Anna Street,

Thirumangalam, Chennai-40

27.S.L.Sudharshan

s/o.S.N.Lakshmi Narayanan, NO.23, 2nd Main Road, Srinivasapuram, Korattur, Chennai-76

28.N.Karthikeyan

s/o.Nagappa Naicker, No.52, Pillayar Koil Street, Puliyambedu Village, Chennai-77

29.Palani

s/o.Nagappa Naicker, No.51, Pillayar Koil Street, Puliyambedu Village, Chennai-77

30.Kumar

s/o.Singavel, No.1, Venus Colony, 2nd Street, Alwarpet, Chennai-600018

31.Ravi

s/o.Chetty Babu, No.18, Sanjaji Gandhi Nagar, Perumal Agaram, Thiruverkadu, Chennai-77

32.Nagarajan

S/o.Muthukrishnan Naidu, No.2/20, Kanna

Street, Nerkundram, Chennai-600107

( Uploaded on: 26/10/2026 12:55:15 pm )

33.Selvi

w/o.Late Palani, res at No.63/59, Pillaiyar Koil Street, Puliamedu Village, Numbal, chennai-600007

34.Minor Praveen

S/o.Late Palani, rep. by their mother and next friend Selvi, the 33rd respondent, res at No.63/59, Pillaiyar Koil Street, Puliamedu Village, Numbal, chennai-600007

35.Minor Prasanth

S/o.Late Palani, rep. by their mother and next friend Selvi, the 33rd respondent, res at No.63/59, Pillaiyar Koil Street, Puliamedu Village, Numbal, chennai-600007

36.Bharathi Devi

W/o.late Nagarajan, res No.26, Karnam @

Karuneegar Street, Nerkundram,

Chennai-600107

37.Mahalakshmi

D/o.late Nagarajan, res No.26, Karnam @

Karuneegar Street, Nerkundram,

Chennai-600107

38.Minor Yuvaraj

S/o.late Nagarajan, Minor rep. by his mother and natural Guardian, Bharathi Devi, res No.26, Karnam @ Karuneegar Street, Nerkundram, Chennai-600107

39.Sampath

s/o.Parthasarathy, Nehru Street, Perumbakkam, Chennai-600100

40.B.Rangabashyam

S/o.Balarama Naidu, NO.126, Poonamallee

High Road, Vellappan Chavadi,

Madras-600077

( Uploaded on: 26/10/2026 12:55:15 pm )

41.Manivannan

S/o.V.Ramachandran, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-600040

42.Mugundan

S/o.V.Ramachandran, res at No.2, Anna Street, Thirumangalam, Chennai-600040

43.Prema Bai

S/o.Ashok Kumar Jain, NO.3, Second Floor, Narasimadasorry Lane, NSC Bose Road, Chennai-600079

..Respondent(s)

Original Side Appeal filed under Order XXXVI Rule 1 of OS Rules read with Clause 15 of Letters Patent to set aside the order and decreetal order dt.

19.06.2023 made in A.No.3007 of 2023 in A.D.Nos.37674/2023 in CS

No.114/2009 passed by this Court.

For Appellant(s):

Mr.R.Loganathan (No appearance)

For Respondent(s):

Mr,V.Vargees Amalraja

for Mr.S.William for R1