MUKESH KUMAR vs EAST CENTRAL RAILWAY on 10 November 2026

1. Mukesh P.O. Ala present p

- By Advoca

1. The Un Railway

By Ad

Pe

1. Learne

2. The re “A. Pro Level-6 contain to its Se

B. Estt. the Ass Annexu No.- 7 promoti

C. The Seniorit CPC P represe the acti (Passen

D. Any deem fit

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATI PATNA BENCH, P

O.A./050/00431/2

CORAM

MR. JUSTICE NARENDRA KU ’BLE MR. KUMAR RAJESH CH Kumar, S/o Sri Rameshwar Ro mpur Gonpura, P.S.-Phulwari Sh posted as Loco Pilot Goods at Ra

ate(s): - Shri J.K. Karn. -Versus- nion of India, through the G y, Hajipur. 844101 & 28 ors.

dvocate(s) :- Shri M.D. Dwived

Shri M.P. Dixit, l/c O R D E R (OR

er: KUMAR RAJESH CHAND ed counsels for both the parties a elief that has been prayed for in th ovisional Seniority List of Loco Pilot 6 of VIIth CPC Pay Matrix of Electric ed in Annexure A/1, may be quashed erial No.- 3 to 26 who have been place Office Order No. 8/'A'/2026 dated 03 istant Personnel Officer, East Centra ure A/2, may be quashed and set aside to 28, who are juniors of applic ions from the posts of Loco Pilot (Goo respondent authorities may be dire ty List of Loco Pilot Goods / Loco R Pay Matrix of Electrical Department entations /submitted by applicants and ion for Promotion from the posts of ngers) may be directed to be initiated a other relief / reliefs as the applicants t and proper in the ends of justice.” OA No. 431/2026 IVE TRIBUNAL PATNA

Order dated:- 10.11.2026. UMAR JOHARI, MEMBER (J) HANDRA, MEMBER (A) y, resident of -Village Hinduni, harif, District-Patna, 801505. At ajendra Nagar (Patna) & 15 ors. ……. Applicants. General Manager, East Central ……Respondents. i, ld. ASC. c for Pvt. Respondents. RAL) DRA, MEMBER (A) are present and heard. his O.A. is as follows:- t Goods/Loco Running- Electrical in cal Department as on 14/05/2025, as and set aside, so far the same relates ed above the applicants erroneously. 3/05/26, issued under the signature of al Railway, Danapur, as contained in e, so far the same relates to its Serial cants but have been ordered their ods) to Loco Pilot (Passengers). ected to publish and circulate Final Running-Electrical in Level 6 of VIIth t as on 14/05/2025, considering the d on the basis of Final Seniority List, of Loco Pilot (Goods) to Loco Pilot and completed. s are entitled and Your Lordship may . , t l n s s f n l r l h e , t y Digitally signed by BINAY PRASAD BINAY PRASAD

Patna Bench

3. Learne that has granted.

4. Learne similar v

5. In view Stateme evident there is as relief

6. In vie infructu rendered

7. Learne objectio will har agitate t taken by

8. If priv responden

9. No ord

(Kumar Raj Member

BP.

ed counsel for the applicants ha s been sought by the applicants

ed counsel for the official resp view. w of the above submissions and ent of the respondents, (especia that grievances of the applica nothing that remains in the O.A f of the applicants is concerned. ew of this Written Statement, ous and accordingly, the O.A. d infructuous. ed counsel for the private respon on to the stand taken by the offi rm their interest, therefore, he the issue in a separate O.A. op y the official respondents. vate respondents are aggrieved b nts, they can approach to the app der as to costs. jesh Chandra) (Just r (A) OA No. 431/2026 s fairly submitted that the relief s in this O.A. has already been ondents has also expressed the looking at para-2 of the Written ally sub-para- f, g & h), it is ants have been redressed. Now A to be adjudicated upon, so far the matter has been rendered is disposed of as having been ndents, Shri M.P. Dixit has taken ficial respondents, stating that it may be granted the liberty to pposing the stand that has been y the stand taken by the official propriate forum as per law. tice Narendra Kumar Johari) Member (J) f n e n s w r d n n t o n l Digitally signed by BINAY PRASAD BINAY PRASAD