Madras High Court

WP/28403/2026 of S.SHIVSHANKAR Vs THE COMMISSIONER OF CUSTOMS on 11 November 2026

Cites 1, Cited by 0

Citations and Judicial Treatment

No citing decisions in the index yet

Cited by

0

Decisions in the index citing it

Cites

1

Decisions referred to

In this index

0

Of the decisions it cites

Overruled / Questioned

0

No negative treatment found

Loading the citing and cited decisions…

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS Reserved on 06.10.2026 Pronounced on 11.11.2026

CORAM

THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE N.SENTHILKUMAR WP No. 28403 of 2026 CNR:{HCMA011383752026} and WMP No.31122 of 2026, WMP No.31123 of 2026 S.Shivshankar Manager and F-card Holder M/s.Saro International Freight System No.16, Jeyalakshmi Nagar Main Road Nerkundram, Chennai-600 107 ..Petitioner(s) Vs The Commissioner of Customs, Office of the Principal Commissioner of Customs (Air Cargo) New Custom House,Chennai VII Commissionerate Air Cargo Complex, Meenambakkam Chennai-600 016 ..Respondent(s) Prayer: Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for issuance of Writ of Certorrari to call for the records of the impugned Order-in-Original No.1375/2026, F.No.CUS/APR/INV/216/2025-GR(1-4), DIN 20260473M0000111701, dated 18.4.2026 on the file of the respondent and quash the same in so far as the petitioner is concern. For Petitioner(s): Mr.A.K.Jayaraj For Respondent(s): Mr.B.Arvind Srevatsa

O RDER

This Petition has been filed seeking to call for the records relating to the impugned Order-in-original No.1375/2026, F.No.CUS/APR/INV/216/2025- GR(1-4), DIN 20260473M0000111701, dated 18.4.2026, passed by the respondent and to quash the same insofar as the petitioner is concerned.

2. The petitioner is the Manager of M/s.Saro International Freight System, which is a partnership concern, holding a Customs House Broker Licence under the CBLR. The petitioner is conducting his business in accordance with the regulations prescribed by the customs authorities. The Petitioner has been in service as customs house broker for the past 30 years.

3. The petitioner while working as a customs broker had filed the Bills of Entries on behalf of the importer M/s.Precious Metal Refiners (PMR), who have imported “Gold Dore Bars” from republic of Guinea, [Least Developed Country (LDC)] which has purity of less than 95% and categorically falls under CTH 7108 1200 of the First Schedule to the Customs Tariff Act 1975. According to the petitioner, the importer has availed the benefit of Duty Free Tariff Preference (DFTP) scheme extended by India for Least Developed Countries notified vide Customs Notification No.96/2008-Cus., dated 13.08.2008.

4. According to the petitioner, the “Gold Dore Bars” falling under ITC (HS) 7108 12 00 are partially refined gold bars, which are used in the manufacture of standard refined gold bars having a purity of 99.5% and above.

5. According to the petitioner, being a licensed Customs Broker, he acted on the basis of the information, documents and declarations furnished by the importer. The petitioner as a Customs Broker had facilitated the import, including the filing of Bills of Entry and the subsequent clearance of the imported goods. According to the petitioner, based on the Notification No.096/2008-Cus, dated 13.08.2008, the benefit of a nil rate of Basic Customs Duty (BCD) and Agriculture Infrastructure and Development Cess (AIDC) was claimed. The petitioner who had acted as an agent of the importer had also claimed clearance of the goods under CTH 7108 1200.

6. Pursuant to the searches conducted at the importer’s premises, statements were recorded from the importer as well as from the petitioner. The allegation levelled against the petitioner/importer is that he had wrongly availed the concessional rate of duty under the Notification dated 13.08.2008 by relying on third party suppliers based in Dubai to procure Certificate of Origin (COOs) and other required documents for the import of Gold Dore Bars from Guinea. The petitioner was issued with a show cause notice seeking an explanation as to why a penalty should not be imposed under Section 114AA of the Customs Act, to which he submitted a reply dated 18.03.2026, explaining that all the documents received from the importer had been submitted to the department at the time of import and the said documents were uploaded to the e-sanchit facility of the ICEGATE Customs Portal. The petitioner had no reason to doubt the veracity of the said Miner Assay Certificates.

7. According to the petitioner the Mining Assay certificate issued by M/s.Siramamba Mining SARLs Company was uploaded along with all the Bills of Entries in the Customs Portal and was also referred to in the Common Description of the Bills of Entry as “Mining P/L” and “Assay Certificate uploaded”.

8. According to the petitioner, samples were drawn and sent for testing on 01.09.2023. It is a specific case of the petitioner that he had obtained authorisation from the importer and exercised due diligence to ascertain the correctness of the information, verified the antecedent and correctness of the exporter code and furnished all the information to the department without withholding any particulars.

9. According to the petitioner, he had not furnished any false information warranting the imposition of a penalty under Section 114AA of the Customs

Act. It is the case of the petitioner that the respondent did not take into consideration the reply given by him to the showcause notice issued by the department and passed the impugned Order-in-Original dated 18.04.2026.

10. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the impugned order is not an appealable order, in support of his contention, relied upon the judgment of the Calcutta High Court in Shri Bikash Bose Vs. Union of India & Anr. [WPO.662 of 2025] wherein in an identical situation the Calcutta High Court has held that the order-in-Original can be challenged by way of a writ petition under certain circumstances viz., (a) breach of principles of natural justice; (b) infringement of fundamental right;

(c) challenge thrown to the vires of any Act or provision; (d) an action wholly without jurisdiction; (e) where the statutory authority has not acted in accordance with the provisions of the enactment which regulates it.

11. The learned counsel further submitted that the petitioner is at liberty to approach this Court if he is able to demonstrate a violation of any one of the five conditions.

12. According to the petitioner, he was denied a fair opportunity to participate in the proceedings and no opportunity was given to him thereby infringing his fundamental rights. Apart from that the action which was taken by the authority is without jurisdiction as the impugned order did not reflect consideration of the reply given by the petitioner.

13. The learned counsel for the petitioner in support of his claim, relied upon the following the judgments and regulations:

1. Commissioner of Cus (Imports0, Chennai Vs. Sainul Abideen Neelam, 2014

(300) ELT 342 (MAD) [Division Bench of this Court]

2. Kunal Travesl (Cargo) Vs. CC (I & G), IGI Airport, New Delhi, 2017 (354) ELT 447 (DEL) [Division Bench of Delhi High Court]

3. Commissioner of Customs (Import) Vs. Trinetra Impex Pvt. Ltd., 2020 (372) ELT 332 (DEL) [Division Bench of Delhi High Court]

4. CMA (MD) No.944 of 2016 dated 20.02.2024, wherein division Bench of this Court held as follows: “29. The facts, such as the alleged payment of Rs.60,000/- through ICICI Bank as remuneration for the illegal export and the alleged transit of Cargo from Chennai to Tirunelveli by the appellant, were never verified, though they are verifiable. The admission that the appellant is a licensed dealer in red sander and he know the exporter John Alexander as Alex of Tutucorin is neither a fact to corroborate the incriminating statement of co-noticee, indicting the appellant. The principle of preponderance of probability been wrongly invoked by CESTAT without any fact either circumstantial or by way of corroboration relate the appellant to the Cargo seized by D.R.I. Not even a remote material available to believe the statement of a tainted person.”

5. CBLR Regulations 2018

14. Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent submitted that the impugned order passed by the respondent does not suffer from any illegality or irregularity. The impugned order is a detailed order. An opportunity was given to the petitioner by way of show cause notice No.394 of 2025 dated 27.05.2025, to which the petitioner submitted a detailed reply.

15. The impugned order in paragraph 35, discussed the authenticity of the Certificates of Origin, the challenge to the CFSL report and the detailed objections raised by the noticeee to the department’s reliance on the CFSL forensic report dated 03.06.2024, which found that certain signatures and stamps on the COOs, had been reproduced. He further pointed out that under Rule 6 of CAROTAR and Rule 20 of the rules of Origin, the impugned order has categorically stated that the mandatory procedure was bypassed by the petitioner herein. Further the impugned order stated that the statement of the petitioner was recorded on 27.09.2023, in which the petitioner had confirmed that the original documents including COOs were received from the airline along with the goods. The impugned order was passed after discussing all the contention raised by the petitioner and by the department, the show cause notice and the reply given by the petitioner and the evidence that has been gathered during the investigation conducted by the DRI.

16. The learned counsel referred to the issue that was considered by the department which reflects in paragraph 52.3 of the impugned order wherein it has been held that the investigation had established that PMR had submitted COOs before Customs authorities bearing reproduced signatures and stamps as found by the CFSL, that all origin related documents had been obtained entirely through a Dubai based intermediary without any independent verification, that PMR's own directors admitted that they did not know whether the gold had actually been mined in Guinea, that no direct communication of any kind was established with the Guinea based supplier or miner, and that PMR had admitted that it had not carried out due diligence under Section 28DA of the Customs Act.

17. Apart from that, issue No.iv viz., “Whether the importer exercised reasonable care under Section 28DA of the Customs Act, 1962” was discussed in paragraph 53 of the impugned order.

18. Based on the violations committed by the petitioner, as stated supra, the authority held that the claim for the FTA exemption benefit, based on the submission of non-genuine/non-authentic origin documentation, was not sustainable. A sum of Rs. 25,64,48,030/- (Rupees Twenty Five Crores Sixty

Four Lakhs Forty Eight Thousand and Thirty only), along with applicable interest, was demanded from M/s. Precious Metal Refiners Pvt. Ltd. The department had valued the goods at Rs. 173,51,01,693/- (Rupees One Hundred Seventy Three Crores Fifty One Lakhs One Thousand Six Hundred and Ninety Three only), which were held liable for confiscation under Sections 111(m) and 111(q) of the Customs Act, 1962.

19. Further, paragraph 52 of the impugned order discussed the role of the petitioner and the relevant portion is extracted hereunder: “52. Issue (ii): Whether the demand of differential duty of Rs.25,64,48,030/- is to be confirmed or dropped. Having held on that PMR is not eligible for the duty exemption under Notification No. 096/2008-Cus dated 13.08.2008, the consequential question is whether the differential duty demand of Rs. 25,64,48,030/- as quantified in Annexure-A to the SCN is to be confirmed, and whether the extended period of limitation under Section 28(4) of the Customs Act, 1962 has been correctly invoked. 52.1 I first address the quantification of the demand. The differential duty of Rs. 25,64,48,030/- represents the Basic Customs Duty and AIDC that would have been payable on the five Bills of Entry had the exemption under Notification No. 96/2008- Cus not been claimed. The noticees have not specifically disputed the arithmetical computation of the differential duty in Annexure-A. I have examined the computation and find it to be in order. The total assessable value of the five consignments as declared before Customs is Rs. 1,73,51,01,693/-, and the differential duty computed thereon at the applicable rate is Rs. 25,64,48,030/-. 52.2 I now address the invocation of the extended period of limitation under Section 28(4) of the Customs Act, 1962. The noticees have relied on the Supreme Court decision in Northern Plastic Ltd. v. Collector of Customs (1998 (101) ELT 549 (SC)) and related decisions to contend that a bona fide incorrect claim of exemption, based on genuine belief and without any misdeclaration of goods, does not attract the extended period or penal provisions. I have carefully considered these submissions. I find that the ratio of these decisions is not directly applicable on the facts of this case. Those decisions dealt with situations where the description classification, and value of goods were correctly declared and the only issue was a incorrect exemption claim. The present case is materially different. 52.3 Here, the investigation has established that PMR submitted COOs before Customs that bore reproduced signatures and stamps as found by the CFSL; that all origin-related documents were obtained entirely through a Dubai-based intermediary without any independent verification; that PMR’s own directors admitted they did not know whether the gold was actually mined in Guinea; that no direct communication of any kind was established with the Guinea-based supplier or miner; and that PMR admitted that due diligence under Section 28DA was not carried out by it. These circumstances go beyond a mere incorrect belief about notification eligibility. They reveal that origin-related declarations were made before Customs without any factual basis to support them, in reliance on a supply chain that has failed to substantiate the origin claim at every level of inquiry. 52.4 The admission by Shri Prashant Tibrewala in his statement dated 26/27.09.2023 that PMR did not carry out the due diligence required under Section 28DA of the Customs Act, 1962, is a significant concession. Section 28DA is a non-delegable statutory obligation cast directly on the importer. It cannot be outsourced to a third-party intermediary. By claiming the exemption while knowing that it had not independently verified the origin condition, PMR furnished information before Customs without reasonable care for its truthfulness, which constitutes suppression of material facts within the meaning of Section 28(4). As held in Eastern Silk Indus. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs (Airport/Admn.), Kolkata, “Fraud in common parlance means dishonest dealing, deceit or cheating. It makes no difference whether fraud is committed by outright forging of documents or by wilful mis-declaration/misrepresentation. Fraud is fraud.” I find that the importer has wilfully suppressed material facts and accordingly the extended period of limitation of five years under Section 28(4) of the Customs Act, 1962 is rightly invoked. 52.5 I accordingly confirm the demand of differential Customs duty of Rs. 25,64,48,030/- (Rupees Twenty-Five Crores Sixty-Four Lakhs Forty-Eight Thousand and Thirty only) against M/s Precious Metal Refiners Pvt. Ltd. under Section 28(4) of the Customs Act, 1962, along with applicable interest thereon under Section 28AA of the Customs Act, 1962. The sum of Rs.10,98,00,000/- deposited by PMR pursuant to the order of the Hon’ble Madras High Court is appropriated and adjusted against this confirmed demand.”

20. Heard both the parties at length and perused the impugned order and the judgment relied upon by the parties.

20. It is not in dispute that the petitioner, who is an agent, was performing his duties in accordance with law. The judgments relied upon by the petitioner include Commissioner of Customs (Exports) v. I. Sahaya Edin Prabhu, reported in 2015 SCC OnLine Mad 847, wherein the Division Bench of this Court held that a Customs House Agent could not be penalised under the provisions of the Customs Act for failure to discharge functions as a Custom House Agent, as penalties for such violations are provided for under the Customs House Agents Licensing Regulations.

21. This view was taken by the CESTAT, New Delhi in M/s. AV Global Corporation (P) Limited v. Commissioner of Customs (Preventive). It was contended therein that action under Section 114AA could be taken only against fraudulent exporters and that such action should not be taken against a Customs House Agent merely for acting in that capacity. The same view was also taken by the CESTAT, South Zonal Bench, Bangalore in Access World Wide Cargo v. Commissioner of Customs, Bangalore, reported in 2022 (379) ELT 120 (Tri. Bang.), wherein it was held as follows: “6. After considering the submissions of both the parties and perusal of the material on record, I find that the appellant who is the Customs Broker has only filed the shipping bills pertaining to the exports made by the ADPL Customs Intelligence Unit conducted the investigation and prima facie found that the mobile phones exported were not manufactured in India and have been manufactured in China and the exporter ADPL was not entitled to drawback under Section 75 of the Act. A SCN was issued demanding drawback of Rs.1,20,02,815/- along with interest but after following the due process, the Additional Commissioner only confirmed the demand of drawback to the tune of Rs.50,48,749/- as per Rule 16 of Customs, Central Excise & Service Tax Drawback Rules, 1995. Further, the rejection of this amount is under challenge before the Revisionary Authority. This, itself, shows that the exporter ADPL is contesting the denial of drawback which is subjudice. Further, I find that in the present case, penalty has only been imposed on the CHA under Section 114AA of the Act and no penalty has Customs Appeal No. 20444 of 2021 been imposed on the exporter. Further, I find that the ingredients of Section 114AA of the Act is not applicable to the CHA and is meant against the fraudulent exporter as is made out from 27th Report of the Standing Committee on Finance (cited Supra). I also find that in the present case, the Department has failed to prove that there was a mala fide and wilful mis- representation by the Customs Broker. It seems that the Commissioner (Appeals) has totally misunderstood the facts and has wrongly observed that the appellant (Customs Broker) and the exporter have been operating from the same premises and have an identical ICE Code which leads one to suspect the bona fides of the appellant. This finding of the Commissioner is factually incorrect and without any basis. Further, the Commissioner on the basis of these facts has wrongly come to the conclusion that the appellant is involved in the illegal export whereas the appellant is only a Customs Broker who has filed the shipping bills on the basis of the documents furnished by the exporter.

7. Therefore, in view of these facts, the imposition of penalty itself is not sustainable in law and therefore I set aside the imposition of penalty on the appellant by allowing the appeal of the appellant.”

22. In the present case, the petitioner acting as an agent and the PMR’s Directors had admitted before the respondent that the genuineness of the certificates had not been verified. In such circumstances, petitioner cannot argue hot and cold to establish that he has been protected as an agent who has only furnished the documents provided by the importer and discharged his responsibilities in facilitating the clearance of the goods.

23. When the respondent had established its case based on the statement given by the petitioner which was subsequently retracted, regarding the admission that the genuineness of the certificates had not been verified and the benefit of the exemption had been availed on that basis, the petitioner and the importer, M/s.Precious Metal Refiners had given statements before the department indicating that the mandatory procedure contemplated under Rule 6 of CAROTAR and Rule 20 of the Rules of Origin had not been followed. Based on the statements given by the petitioner before the DRI, the petitioner has not established any ground to interfere with the impugned order in this writ petition.

24. In view of the same, the present writ petition is dismissed as devoid of merits, however liberty is granted to the petitioner to challenge the impugned order by way of an appeal. No costs. Consequently connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.

25. After pronouncement of the order, the learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that, in view of the dismissal of the writ petition, the petitioner has been granted liberty to file an appeal, however, the dismissal should not take away the petitioner's right to have the appeal heard on the question of limitation.

26. In view of the above submission made by the learned counsel for the petitioner, the period of limitation shall be computed by taking into account the time spent in pursuing the writ petition. 11.11.2026 Index: Yes Speaking order Neutral Citation: Yes sai

N.SENTHILKUMAR J. sai To The Commissioner of Customs, Office of the Principal Commissioner of Customs (Air Cargo) New Custom House, Chennai VII Commissionerate Air Cargo Complex, Meenambakkam Chennai-600 016 Pre-delviery order made in WP No. 28403 of 2026 and WMP Nos.31122 of 2026 & 31123 of 2026 Dated: 11.11.2026

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Sign in, for free, to download the court copy. Reading the full text here stays open to everyone.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead