Central Administrative Tribunal

Savitri Devi vs 56 APO on 12 November 2026

Cites 0, Cited by 0

(Reserved on 05.11.2026)

Central Administrative Tribunal, Allahabad Original Application No.782 of 2026

Pronounced on this the 12

th Day of November, 2026.

Hon’ble Mr. Justice Om Prakash VII, Member (J)

Savitri Devi a/a 84 years, W/o Late Lala Ram, R/o- Village- Nibi Kalan, Post- Nibi Kalan, Jhunsi, District- Prayagraj (Allahabad) U.P.- 211019.

​ ​

………..Applicant

By Advocate: Shri Satish Sahu

​

​ Versus

1. ​

Union of India through Secretary, Ministry of Defence, South Block, New Delhi.

2.​

The Secretary, Department of Personnel and Training, Ministry of Personnel, Public Grievances and Pensions, Government of India, New Delhi.

3.​

Principal Controller of Defence Accounts, Draupadi Ghat Allahabad.

4.​

Commandant, (OD) Fort, Prayagraj (Allahabad), Pin-908778, ℅

56 APO

5.​

OOC (A), Personnel Officer, Ordnance Depot (OD) Fort, Prayagraj, UP.

…Respondents

By Advocate: Shri Suraj Singh

​

Citations and Judicial Treatment

No citing decisions in the index yet

Cited by

0

Decisions in the index citing it

Cites

0

Decisions referred to

In this index

0

Of the decisions it cites

Overruled / Questioned

0

No negative treatment found

Loading the citing and cited decisions…

ORDER

Present Original Application has been filed under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985, seeking the following reliefs:- “(I)​ to quash the impugned order dated 10.07.2026 passed by the authority concerned whereby the applicant has been directed to make amendment in her correct name and date of birth for family pension. (II)​ to issue an order or direction in the suitable nature directing to the concerned competent authority/respondents to release family pension with appropriate rate of interest in favour of the applicant. (III)​ to issue an order or direction in the suitable nature directing the concerned competent authority/respondents to provide arrears with interest of the late payment of the family pension from the date it accrued/due till the date of its actually paid. (IV)​ to issue any other suitable order or direction in the facts and circumstances of the case which this Hon’ble Tribunal may deem fit and proper.”

2. ​ Brief facts of this case are that the husband (Late Lala Ram/Lalaram) of the applicant was working as Labourer/Mazdoor (Loader/Unloader) in the Central Ordnance Depot Chheoki and retired on 30.06.1999 after superannuation. After retirement on 30.06.1999 from the Ordnance Depot Chheoki he was getting a pension. The husband of the applicant died on 06.01.2026. After the death of the pensioner Late Lala Ram, the son of the applicant made a representation dated 27.04.2026 wherein he requested for the family pension for the applicant with some correction in the PPO. A letter dated 15.06.2026 was also made to Comdt, Ordnance Depot Fort, Allahabad regarding correction in the name of the applicant and issuance of the family pension. In response of the representation dated 27.04.2026 the competent authority/ respondent no.5 made an order dated 10.07.2026 whereby he rejected the claim for family pension on the ground that there is error in the name and date of birth of the applicant. It was also directed to provide corrected document after correction in the document as per service record so that the next step of the proceeding may be initiated. Aggrieved, the applicant filed the present O.A.

3. ​ I have heard learned counsel for the parties.

4. ​ Submission of learned counsel for the applicant is that as per impugned order dated 10.07.2026 earlier the name of the applicant in the documents dated 28.07.1976, 22.12.1978, 25.11.1981, 22.01.1986, 11.04.1990 and 26.08.1993 has been stated correctly as Savitri Devi but from 04.09.1998 onwards it is stated as Sabitri Devi which is all due to clerical mistake of the concerned office as the ex employee Late Lala Ram was a fourth class employee and not literate enough to get it corrected. There are several documents such as Adhaar Card, Pan Card, Voter ID and Bank Account which shows that the applicant's name is Savitri Devi and name of her husband is Lala Ram. It is also mentioned that there was a joint account in State Bank of India of Lala Ram and Savitri Devi which also shows the applicant's name as Savitri Devi and also shows a status that they were husband and wife. The applicant alleges that the concerned office is in habit of making such mistake/error which is also apparent from the PPO wherein in address of the village & Post of the deceased employee is shown as Nibi Kalan but state has been shown as Maharashtra and date of birth of the applicant has been shown as 01-JAN-3001 which shows the carelessness of the concerned office and the same is ultimately a harassment for the employee/dependent of the employee. It is averred that the applicant is ready to give an affidavit that "Savitri Devi" and Sabitri Devi" both are one person and her date of birth is 01.01.1942. Learned counsel for the applicant also placed reliance on the order of this Tribunal in O.A./1404/2024 (Smt. Rekha Singh vs Union of India and ors) decided on 09.10.2025.

5. ​ Submission of learned counsel for the respondents is that upon scrutiny of the service book of the deceased employee, several discrepancies were found in the petitioner's name and date of birth. The same was communicated to her, and she was requested to correct her name and date of birth as per the service record so that further action can be taken. He contends that the respondents have not committed any illegality or infirmity in the case of applicant and rightly taken action in accordance with existing rules which is just, proper and legal in the eye of law. It is further stated that it is the employee's full responsibility to submit family details in the service record. Furthermore, this office has not rejected the family pension claim of the applicant. However, due to discrepancies in the petitioner's name and date of birth, it was requested to amend these details in accordance with the service book of the deceased employee and submit the requisite documents, so that further action can be taken. The employee is fully responsible for the family details endorsed in the service records. At the time of retirement, the deceased employee submitted his wife's name as 'SABITRI DEVI' and age as "50 years" over his signature, and the PPO was issued accordingly based on the information provided by him. The age of the petitioner is clearly recorded as '50 years' in original PPO No. C/AOC/16566/2012 issued at the time of retirement, placing her birth year around 1949. However, the petitioner is intentionally submitting identity cards reflecting a date of birth of 01/01/1942 to claim an additional 20% pension intended for individuals over 80 years of age. Thus, it is argued that the applicant must update her date of birth to align with the deceased employee’s service records.

6. ​ I have considered the rival submissions of learned counsel for the parties and perused the entire documents on record.

7. ​ The claim of the applicant herein is for family pension after the death of her husband who was a pensioner of the respondents’ department. The respondents have not denied family pension to the applicant but have asked for supportive documents in order to correct the anomalies in name and date of birth of the applicant so that the process for payment of family pension may be initiated. The respondents argue that the name and date of birth of the applicant have been mentioned as ‘Savitri’ Devi till 1993 after which it is mentioned as ‘Sabitri’ Devi and there is also anomaly in the age of the applicant in the service records of the deceased employee which is mentioned as 30 years in 1976, 28 years in 1977, 36 years in 1980, 35 years in 1981 and 1986, then 40 years in 1990 and 1993 and 50 years in 1998 and 1999. In such a situation, the respondents have argued that since the details furnished by the deceased employee is anomalous, the family pension of the applicant cannot be processed until it is aligned with the records with supportive documents.

8. ​ So far as the argument of the respondents regarding the responsibility of the deceased employee to get the correct details entered in the service records is concerned, it will not be out of place to observe that the discrepancies in the details mentioned in the service records might have occurred due to clerical error and not entirely due to the wrong information furnished by the employee. An instance of this can also be seen in the pension payment order issued to the deceased employee. A photographic image of the said Pension Payment order with the errors encircled is as under:- It can be clearly seen in the above inserted image of Annexure A-8 of the O.A., that the date of birth of the spouse of the deceased employee has been mentioned as 01-Jan-3001. It cannot be believed that such an entry has been made due to wrong information furnished by the employee concerned without accusing the person responsible for making such an entry of blindly filling in the impossible details. Similarly, even the state of residence has been mentioned as “Maharashtra”.

9. ​ If the above fact is taken into consideration, as the relationship of the applicant as the wife of the deceased employee is not disputed and the difference in name can be attributable to a phonetic/typographical error, it would be more judicious and appropriate that instead of demanding from the applicant the documents to align her details with that mentioned in the service records of her deceased husband, the respondents should take into account the documents submitted by her in support of her claim to verify her name and age.

10. ​ Thus, the O.A. stands allowed. The impugned order dated 10.07.2026 is hereby quashed. The competent authority amongst the respondents is hereby directed to make the necessary correction in the service record of the deceased employee on its own treating the name of the applicant ‘Savitri’ and ‘Sabitri’ as one and the same, if necessary, and release the family pension to the applicant along with the arrears on the basis of the documents supplied by her in support of her name, relationship and age within a period of three months failing which an interest at the GPF rate shall also be payable to the applicant on the arrears of the family pension. It is clarified that if the documents except the documents required vide the impugned order have not been supplied, the applicant is hereby directed to supply the same within a period of one month from the date of this order to the competent authority after which the competent authority will take a decision as directed hereinabove within a period of three months.

11. ​ All associated M.A.s also stand disposed of. No order as to costs.

( Justice Om Prakash VII) ​ ​ ​ Member (J) Madhu​​ ​

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Sign in, for free, to download the court copy. Reading the full text here stays open to everyone.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead