CIVIL APPEAL None on 16 June 1973

C^,;'o-^__

INTHEHIGHCOyR'I'OFJODIGATUREOFCHHATTISGARHAT BILASPUR

W P fS ) NO^Q^ /2010

PETITIONER

ishok Kum.ar CKandraS/oLateShri Nawagautiya Ghahdra, Agedabout38years;OccupatkinUpperDivisipnTeacher,Govf.Middle ,School,Sakarali,BlockDabhara, Distl; : Janjgir-Champaabout38years;OccupatkinUpperDivisipnTeacher,Govf.Middle ,School,Sakarali,BlockDabhara, Distl; : Janjgir-Champa:{c.G^' ' 'r::..^^^^^^^^^^•..

^liii^b^.^^.^

fe-:^;^"

RESPQNDENTS

a,

State of Chha&tisgarh Through :The Secretary.SchoDl EducatonalDejpartmentj D.K.S.Bhawah,The Secretary.SchoDl EducatonalDejpartmentj D.K.S.Bhawah,;Rai^E;T)isfrict;-Rarpur^(Gi(j;):Disfnefc;EdH:eation QfGcer', •.:Disfnefc;EdH:eation QfGcer', •.

;::<3'a^gir,J®tsiriGt;';Ja.n}gir-Cit£Ern@a •;11WS;i:'::;':':ll^i'::^]:\::::^^

! 1^';.:01@el!;i@HucatiQnl|Qfficer',,,'^BlQieie:i®aIaliaFa,,VDistrict ..Janjgir^BlQieie:i®aIaliaFa,,VDistrict ..Janjgir '.CIiamp^<©;:G.)::,v^:1, ;l'v^ •.••.!''-.^

WR!1;;^PETH3Q ^BNE®n^^ARTieLE1 226 .• QF ^! THE€QNS^TUTi©N/QB^I^lF©R'lSSIJMGE.(3EWMa?;!INNATUREOrMAND^MUS y. CEK'I'KaRAK^ 1 OR^ ANYGTHER Wm^O^I.JKE.^Aa^I^.E^C.;. -'..r ": ;YThepetitioner, nainedabove'rilos^humbly |'and^4-^^11^

•Svi -^w\v\^, ^Wl't.hww'y.

3'n^T^rxraraf?'WT,_.....U:£,^...^,36Q2/C"200'

W*«?(TShliqi

"%./y^

W.:'"S!S3\'1; S-HC-22••^^^sl §'^i.tf'''.^^,~^^_ ':^""" ^^

-s^-^fptRra, ^Tflwiii. (»iinitiy3Tr^?r['iRra?]>d-^..^-1s^"WI.*<IWfT9iHr«(i200'fa^ST'SII^I'^1<=hi^i<n<f1'rt TfFl^f'? ft^ <Fi|<^t<R-li'* S^V311^1 TOIIW ^rf^I^TaiPwan^rsh+li^ ^?ft3Goveraiaent vide notification datdd 16.6.1973 aiaended M.P.Non-Gazette Class-II Educational S^avices (Non-coflege Serviccs)Recruitment aad Promotion Rules1993 added qualification ofB.T.I. or B.Ed degree for appoiatni|ent on the post ofAssistantTeacher.Thepetitionerwoiddbeentitledforadvaaceiacrements onlv ia the conditioiilfhat he had obtamed hisB.T.I/B.Ed./B.T.I. degree at his o(vn cost during semce afterobteiiung pemussion fonn fhe dcp|fertment between 23.10.1964to 1.3.99. To clarify the above po^jition, circulare have alreadybeen issued on 6.2.2007 and on 3QU.09.Facts, as detailed above, are|not[in][ dispute.][ This][ Court][ ia]the inatter of Yashwaat ^uiaar BJiaradwaj (supra) elaboratelydiscussing the circulars dated '2^.12.98,1.3.99 and relyingupon fhe judginent of fhe Hon'bteApex Court in the matter ofBadrinarayan Acharya's case (su^ra) has he]d fhat teachers,not assistant teachers alone, woul|l be entitled to two advaneeincreraents on obtairung B.Ed ^xaiaiuation certificate after22.10.1964,astiiecircuJard^ted22.10.1964doesnotprescribe aay outer limit of the period ofobtamiug B.Ed, M.Ed-^"& B.T.I. certificate. It has been fudther held fhat circular datcd1.3.99 is appUcablc to only Assista|nt Teachers (LDT) aad not toofher teachers (UDT).Shri. Das fairty subinits fhatprincyle of law laid down inYashwant Kum.ar Bliaradwaj'scas^fsupra} bas attauied finalityand case of the petitioner in fhjis petition is atso squaaelycoveredbyfheabove judgxueijitasalsocirculardated24.12.19987~^VWI