Karnataka High Court

RFA/235/1994 of SMT.VENKATALAKSHMAMMA Vs O.N.V.RAMAN & ORS., on 20 November 1998

a -e 4 I— 1 a V r •ta 1’if ‘p 4 * ‘ ; — h 4’ f l 9 a • 0 . O tc O < 0 t 0 . I o . a a . Pa P C H a p .’ . C d I” S W I 1 j1 4 • S • P4 0 Z ?0t0 I a - m e t . DI • 0 0 0 u o 0 a ’ < a a (0

‘;—ah•0.4’ fl9OtcO<0t0.Io.aa.PaPICHap.’.1j14•CdSI”•P4SW0Z ?t0 Ia-met.DI•000ua •co0a’<• aaa•(0)ftQfl&0Paaaa11ZCdaOil0044%.3CDIDIa00CPtftaSDIt.aa5.0Cd143,ft01(0)•1ftftDICp...t‘4ft‘4ft0‘CaaaVI

a’

IPI

.3• a Parti—a 0i-’.‘1 COoaCZ••‘40• DSaOaa pa‘3wa5’.IIIa0Cd •Ik0aaPt •I C. a• DI Part DI Part Part

• DI Part DI Part Part

I•aa

P30.0

‘.10’

()(“A1)1AL Al(AlALCAl ( (AL(9A 1 1CA(ACn:(I:‘(3 (9 (9(9(4’t ‘....

(9 (3

5’

l—C fl

“A

()(j’CAl ( (11(12(9A 1 1(Al(9.‘ACn:,‘(3 (9 (9(‘1(9(4’3:a):t(‘41

( :Al

LAl “

..5‘CIa)

LAs.

((U‘AA“I9(9U(3:(‘A(9’

Page 1 of 15

U,03CC 03.30)CO3)03CU02CotoE 030’Co it 03—%CUC’0oCC(1H C3i33ototO[H]33 5‘3u33 H’ wOL02j:3) 2-’.CC ‘pC)CD[Opt]‘020301 H’ \JCICD ptpit030C)) H’ 02H.Ht0’0’C)—2 02 HUHCC 0 02))2)3) 02HHOC..’ 0‘D20 C7\ 3 101 to‘1Ci) 02‘102COCC)CC 003022)32 0 i2)32 0 i 0 i i30(3)(Oft)))C)ittD’<31HitHH3)—_C.ttjH20303P200303CL0CC:itChCM,i02çt02c’PiCDit000ICr+CU%JWCC3’ ‘3113”HititoCDCOCCCDCCo0’3: 30’ 021000)’ .“ 02itH0’‘103C IC-aCCC) rt-33D‘030‘)DCCC)2)41“mCI:.“7w02‘30<03)03))tOOP02s‘-341‘‘lj’oHH01p2CC1102‘14,:0130o(0010)m0230030’:•02:—3 C))CC)[it3j]C-’5CC)•CC 0’0”•PHD01’33mbo3)>’C3303CCIitp0P.-Cp2p2.:)0)3B’1J12.)j3Cs)C0’”0IC0202CCSW•CCD‘2IC)‘PS-‘CC—2.02CC’it0’ to[30:]‘3•4,,‘0‘I’ll*$)4%*),flCC)CC’[CC]CC>0’ 0Cr’3C):H Q,‘0310’*CCC0CD‘-C‘2))

CUC’0o

Ht0’0’C)3ttjH

022)32 0 i2)32 0 i 0 i i—_C.

C-”

3>’

Page 2 of 15

it:

0CDo ctoCDC)Cxl:32)01 toCC’Cr03))0’p203’1))C-’- (3 N 2))’p20313 0CC0[H]•0 0’5-)0)0:02C)CCHCC3:p,.:.3’C)p20.02H33)3:;HH5H 00’C SoC)CC0H C-’CC)CC çt‘1‘1 0‘3C)‘CC’CDCCHC-’-C-’3:5)tiCCDCD-“CDCC303CCCt5)’ C>’2))’“C31CU’03itO,HCC3QU’-CD•—3CC’(0)i>tCCDCC)CC)CCtO(3:H‘CC)12’0COC’32 or.tornI.0’CDHC)o I-’‘103-___ %, %*CD ‘3‘C’CI1) O:NCD-t(C)[H’]0-CD0.C’(‘CCDCC’pt 0’“1.I’-,) 3“.1 02-CitU’CD‘0CD’S

—

torn

I‘0

I-fl

z a.’. “.4

‘Q blO.

‘1

‘

a”.4(I

‘1a

I-,

I-’0.

I-,

r,:!nr.I’n’..Can‘QrozftopqI-’0’4aw0a•CflPC)Zn..t1&??g%I4..•OB‘.J,mat 1a”.0.•‘Waa,.I•P$a(Ma4

•

Ib0OPt5tie’SW

p..

U’%.0

‘°8”°”

OiQPtPtt

P”0

OiQPt0P”0tttl’OrP&itI.,.’4‘°2[,r:]tI.,.’4‘°2[,r:]MI1,..CIt3t tI.,.’

t3t

MI1,..CI

••

s’.

o aOO

•

I-’

SrP

rP’l a”

I.’

‘bJ.OcDa4CI.’. g gHPttr‘i

a.•

(flrPO’-’.Q.

øm’-’.

1coIia-’Woac

‘-‘0

•

‘-‘0•Da)gatC4CpgpaI.’. g g

)gat

Htr•1a’

‘A

I-..aH

CwO

0104’lI—

t1oo

‘0‘aps

-.Jen

.0,1

‘-S

‘-S0S

a.Cl)WP1‘41•••COMOZ(salaD)RIO’OPIPIJi•Cl)0S..,1S...x,oIC 4aIaC4oZ0‘40.5.z•zs0W0’mI.a.a’’ftzz’un0’P.P$P“I9a44,4a0’:&“I4ta&•Pith0’tflPi0$‘1f-’t..S$tV0)I4‘0lfl40’V4a‘-A0—0

I-1OPtPitt

0‘00

‘liz0rC0’00pft‘C4

.4a.Sfl’4Cm’0•.Sfl’4Cm’0•

W*ZEOBOI

I—.. 4t... 4t...

tt O’—’.I. O’—’.I.

—I—I.tt O’—’.I. O’—’.I.I—.. 4t... 4t...QW-’O. 0.C0W0O‘ 10):’>ob-RID’0 zg-’:’0tt o tt‘-I4ftWft‘0RImOPiI-’4004,0I

b-RID’

PiOoie

tOH

•a’1b

W •

40.4t1

b’

‘

IaI

-tnt

ozxa,it0Ca,zS33‘(a-i

i-’

it70S‘3Sza--, as0a-Ct55‘<a0aa--I•.a-3-ft-hCtCt®75-5555aza,ana)CCtaa,7S5S-ta,amSIaza,a—aa.—-5a•a,a—S0CCtCtCIa,7a-a,a,0a-a,-1a-35Ct-hoa,a-•0-c00a,•SCta-za,C0a-a,a-•a,•0a-a.-’•0aSNa,a,a-a-0‘..5a,00C0a.aa,Ct05-i3zS

-‘

i’•

a, a,

—

‘<

-s

‘-.

-c

•

aa-a-a,3

ê’

•

•a

5-1,0-1

5n3

S-ç

,-‘a—1)3

t’-.a,a-z

,-‘a—1)3a—1)3

I-1OPtPitt

0‘00

‘liz0rC0’00pft‘C4

.4a.Sfl’4Cm’0•.Sfl’4Cm’0•

W*ZEOBOI

I—.. 4t... 4t...

tt O’—’.I. O’—’.I.

—I—I.tt O’—’.I. O’—’.I.I—.. 4t... 4t...QW-’O. 0.C0W0O‘ 10):’>ob-RID’0 zg-’:’0tt o tt‘-I4ftWft‘0RImOPiI-’4004,0I

b-RID’

PiOoie

tOH

•a’1b

W •

40.4t1

b’

‘

IaI

-tnt

ozxa,it0Ca,zS33‘(a-i

i-’

-‘

i’•

a, a,

—

‘<

-s

‘-.

-c

•

aa-a-a,3

ê’

•

•a

5-1,0-1

Page 3 of 15

5n3

S-ç

,-‘a—1)3

t’-.a,a-z

,-‘a—1)3a—1)3

o-I5-1,0-1sCt5-0ca-a-0-cCz5n3Ca-zzSaS-ça-ina,a-t’-.a,a-za-a,o-%fla.-i-a5aI.”zaa,n,-‘a—1)3it‘-‘a-a,sitaa-a-a,3aa-Ca,a-a,zU35Ct0a,a,•a,-5a-CZn®7a-fta-3S0C.“Cz‘<a-Cta-a,za,i00s%-ç••(I)0a,0a,5a,5-%0C.a-a,C-3(0a--ft-,,‘<•a,5S3aa,za-3I•‘in‘—ca30a-5a,Ca-•cn0-s,mmwz0•a-0-noaaS3a.-.a-ita•a,wz‘0—‘s-cn•N.w‘Ja,3ftzit37sN‘J3oa.a•0zCa-a,a,a’-(5•raa3a,a,Ct0nCtN-%-ftaCt-50a,0a,••a,a-.a-a,na-a--%7S‘(eaa,05‘0Ct7s0•m•Ca-Ct osNwa0z5-15aa,a,a’•CCta,a-a-a-<Ct‘‘0a,0a.aØ%iISDZza-a—noa,‘<a-••a’3ora,-t,‘0‘%a5zaa,-ft‘<0a,Ct‘-4050C1-5a,3a-Cza,a,CtZCD(Pa,St3a,Ct0a-fta,SU0a-a-aa-Ca,a-a,zU35Ct0a,a,•a,-5a-CZn®7a-fta-3S0C.“Cz‘<a-Cta-a,za,i00s%-ç••(I)0a,0a,5a,5-%0C.a-a,C-3(0a--ft-,,‘<•a,5S3aa,za-3I•‘in‘—ca30a-5a,Ca-•cn0-s,mmwz0•a-0-noaaS3a.-.a-ita•a,wz‘0—‘s-cn•N.w‘Ja,3ftzit37sN‘J3oa.a•0zCa-a,a,a’-(5•raa3a,a,Ct0nCtN-%-ftaCt-50a,0a,••a,a-.a-a,na-a--%7S‘(eaa,05‘0Ct7s0•m•Ca-Ct osNwa0z5-15aa,a,a’•CCta,a-a-a-<Ct‘‘0a,0a.aØ%iISDZza-a—noa,‘<a-••a’3ora,-t,‘0‘%a5zaa,-ft‘<0a,Ct‘-4050C1-5a,3a-Cza,a,CtZCD(Pa,St3a,Ct0a-fta,SU0a-a-Cta,a-•S3Ct3a3a3Ca-t5a,5-c asCt5a,na,a-a,•Ct0,Ct•n5-a,-I’.3a,a,a-Ct£•Ct00C-c-ft0aSCtC-çz-c-0a,Ca,507aCts50-i-q,Ca-a,a-na-a-z<(s7a,3a,N0

a—

a.-’

a, n

1’•

-ç

-,i

ito

•

a-a-,

‘0

‘0a

•

-s,

0a-Ct

•

Ct‘ca-C

•

a a3S a.

-ft

‘0

a- a, a

a, a-

a,z

‘

-c

•

SCt0aLU(tØCt0170001b-00-ab-’010‘-•N01Ct3z-‘—‘-•Ct‘•‘•0Ctb-0137-ft®LUaLULU•0a00010LUCtE3LU(V7a0101LU03LU-ftCti-LU0a33bLUiaLUCtLU•0b-LU30Ct3aLUCaLUCtb-b01N3aaC.b-CCt333Ct001CtCt013b-LU(00CLU3LU(VCt‘-LU01ZCt0LU•o0LU013.ALUC0‘-‘VLU02-4LUb--ft1Ct00013-C

LU0

01U

U-‘

NCDCt70CtCD7‘-‘00

(I)0)

00LU001UZ050ttU-‘NCDCt7‘-‘00Ctb-ULUb-10N0’(I)0)C001LU701•010I010)CtIi01Ib-1(LULU.C01aC0-•NLUCt70101Ct7CDib-b--izCtLUCCtLU•3b-,01o001s•‘<CtLU.03b-Ct•0I‘<•b-Ct‘-CC‘-.CtLU7LULU01CN‘4UDCLU3a-ia‘-“LU%-%‘<010)301CC.-IttLU-4,CtI—01‘00’‘a®P1X01t aLUCtz0LU0LU-‘01301-IiLUb-b-b-•70-ft®•030LU01z0aCt£LUCt01C-%0ZLU3Ct(0LU0I01-ft b-s b-

b-LU

-C

-ft

Ct01-%s-ft®

-ft

-cCt a

•

-‘

Ct ft

fr.

Page 4 of 15

3fr.1Ctb-i-sCt70b-3C01‘-4013b-0701wLUCaCt7Ct(0aLULULUb-LUb-301LUCt1773CtaCtCt-ç.Ca)s.I‘-.i-’oICtsCtLUa3CUS3Ctt01-1Ct0Ct3,—CtLU010101a0101‘c).-.CtLUi-’b-103LUb-b-Ct(V%•aC0LUCti-nb-b-01Ct3-ftLU0(0C-ftC33‘<3z az‘—zLUzI-sma®Cti-sCt(0Ct70CtZ0ab-LU01LUCt7LUnflLUCtLU%LUt.0C-It-ItOa ae001Ct3•LUi-N‘i-I3Ct-ftLU0-ftLU•LULUrrLU030•b-33i-’‘0(0i-s(fttLUzb-LU3n01-Ito3aN%toLU-çCt50LLU3C0.-(CtNa0zan,015CaCt®0 a33•Ct7CULU(VCti3a013LU®CNCIaS.ILU3CtCt70b-nOb-b--ab-C0C011(0-C00001-ftaC301-0(VCt010-ft®11b-LUCt3z2%CtLUCb-73LU01Z0Sb-CtLUb-Cto03-ftCLUC3CtLUaLUI—b-LU31LU-ftLU-ftLUCtSLU(V01Q301(VaaCtzC01b-01b-Ct0z3flap9CtzCzb-b-n‘-•oi—QI-’LU®3s•<(0-CCtzLULU(V0%çtLUCt3(00-i0.b-b-01anI(VCLU01-C0111SC01i--nb-LUa-ft1i%0(03a1a(0C®3053077001(V301a

qØ

‘—

Ct z

‘<

-C

-I

b-s

•

7CC

‘-LU

•

Ct z

•

b-LU

b- b-SE

-a

qØ

‘—

Ct z

‘<

-C

-I

b-s

•

7CC

‘-LU

•

Ct z

•

b-LU

b- b-SE

Page 5 of 15

-a

—‘•.-..•-•si.

—‘CD—L’1C).••——C..D—aa733-tzca-05oitazaza-.oititittitit-cazacaaaatit7•.•azit-tzatz.titit0,o0o3.-*-tirtitt3oo0-j-r’0anr3SNuaxrCzo£V.73ii.®La:..CaI-.fl-r’ai-.:L(IaaCC•-—WCDfr•I’•-s‘-.z-c-cCC,-rtotoc-..C’-.-117‘CCr-?£1cccc-%cccccccc£‘•-•cccccccccccc£——-43cc:—si.(4‘•-•-43—tIRci,1-’.‘—.

C:—IU?—1CS%C:‘.1—i—a..-———“C-a—:L-.’CL.‘,7777a-t37300a••.rxititititititazaaaaiteazzzaacaaaza7ititititita‘it3arz0003o‘rta>ttto0003*033000000U-‘rr3ro3ZtI.ni-CtCCC7ccNsi.i&+.7at2-hD:.O7370t‘it’-is+o--hO;a-4itoaIE---2.*-at•aafl-.-r•w. ass,--.--r’-‘‘.,i.--jC‘-.C1-.-c‘3-.-rCcvicrci-c‘-•cv.Rt,-14’-?:2-“cccccccc12-.cccc--0’cvcccccccccccc—.a-s-4’(Scccc-i—(ftCt:.‘<ft(t•——cc),•—.•VCi—C)Ci-—.-*•T

-n

—n

-—

-4’

a z

•:

.cc

-i a

-r

1-t z

•.:

-s

-..

‘.

a-.

7. çt a

4?•—.47a3,-c.ititit-toaaz-Iazitit:tt---a0-‘-t33oq030-:7-33033r.Jt70z.-taaaI-.aarC---rI-.aCitCC-h-tC-ç.40QE—CtQ‘...-•0ccccccii.0’cc•-‘1--Cit—‘-‘

-i.e

o to

k•

u0l.-’to

i-’

to0

‘a.

•

SOW

‘a.

‘a

-ç

(‘to

z(‘to-ç‘attortatoftasto00•Ct0‘a.CttoOtoCi-atoc-t--ça.7-%z<-iCstocato50-I)tonnoftaCtoototto<I.’.I-.I-”£to£totoI-’‘a.,ft•70-ç•ztoaazto-s,-tOsnSazatotoaSartotoftto01)totorto0C-1S7toft‘<-1to-1totoaztofttonotot-ç‘(atoa...xtocto30£tofttortoI0ztton‘a.03• aCttoto30Cz03ztoI-.z<torr•ft1-4,‘a.•C)atotzato-iztoN<0

çt

toto‘a.a

ft as

0.0

‘a.

‘a•

I—

‘a.

Page 6 of 15

•C)atotzato-iztoN<0z(0.0Ia.CCtototrto‘..totoCfttoCtC31075totoa‘a•0-çi...75Qft‘a.toft30to‘a’•-çto<(4I-.toft•tot-cnwtoftstto<to1a13to03‘a.o•a+0toft(fltotto0%a377to-çt0-ttototo3toctototo£S0£C•zIa.‘cfta-(ritoI’totoSto‘-aI-”Ia’,_.C-*33‘a.a sok”C)tSrtototCto‘a’zt5C1sosa—to‘a.‘a.zC)-o3Cttoto-iT-Iaftto0CcI—ftototpa.S•0)toftosCztoai.ztotoS‘a.wztoz3toftto0ctotnztiNot-‘a.z-<atosQQtIQ•to-ç‘a.-ftto3ato•ft0a-toafto•0’00C.,’I0(1)to‘a.0to acto-fttoz1)-csto-‘toa.3I-atsofttna‘-o0•Ia.I...a-Sto1)ft£NctNtoto00toftto30‘a’zztoz-ç-to-ftatacto•—1ft‘a.—II-”‘0•0—0toasO0ftto3‘<U)toCC0to•1I—to33fttototoftft‘a’£ztofta-—4II’ft57toto03to0030aI. 111totostor’totozto z ‘a.

‘a.

-b

‘a.

ftC)

•

‘a.

rn x

•

‘a.

•

•W

to c

ft s

at to

“C

•

-t

-a,

..o•‘-4ft)a.toa&l.a.2ç.totw-C ‘fttoa

tw- a

‘a.

z ft

ai.

Page 7 of 15

tozI-çI-a‘a,‘at0‘—C03I-a50C•a.£a.C‘a’tootoI-a‘a,‘at0‘—C03I-a50C•a.£a.C‘a’tootoftoa30C30C-i00ZftzfttoS-10ZftzfttoS-1toaoto-(too0-(too0-1o03toC-ç3toC-çtoa3aCttoto‘a.ztoto‘a.zto-13Ctz‘a’toatoftI-’7fttoto‘-a7toI-aQC).t<0’30ftI-’7fttoto‘-a7toI-aQC).t<0’30ftC0-c•i7totoC.flto0toC0toto-c•i7totoC.flto0toC0toto-oza-aa.fttoa.fttoçt3.70za.toto3ato70za.toto3atot•.0-tC0raCtoaCtoC3a3totozzcttofttoto3totozzcttofttoto .r..

-‘

I—

-‘

-‘it

—•

‘(

fø

P-’

I-.

Page 8 of 15

r..(3,,%.1..‘1£—4’..(_4’CD.•—CDCDCO—tit7ito>cceaitit.ititzz<¶0o0039303030a3s.)r’ita.333000000*003000033o03zzctr)0303030..0a.a.%0rCCr.30£03-rF--cr•.zçtçt-•1000.rr%tc•-rr-703...-.,:-..-fl:t70crtaa-.0.0x3.‘a.•I-.aaflFaaflaCCZC-(--rUaa-4-4a•ta‘0act-t-..-:-.fl.;((-I__3-‘-‘ZCC-‘C:7aaI-.I-.(0:‘.-tis.-.E-‘Q.,c‘-r‘ra-aCC.S1.S-4-io,7a37Ci.$..‘0A-:a.‘e.-‘wCQZ...a,-:‘)-‘Cti:(a,C-7L,r•0’m‘<mtor--7•<0C--1,0)‘<::;C-3,m0.m,.t70-çto--a>Cr0-%0.:0J.dci-7.-(0,-(0‘CC’u0)(0,.(a’(0--itit‘?‘.4eezz.4.-,i1----1t,C4;bd.ft)-‘.C’C)n‘Cr.i—LI‘u‘—1-•a-T-€.Ci.-$“--I—ft0303..03•030303.‘0303•“0303030303030303—t030303p-s.‘——e-41‘.-03-..030303C’C’.1.—•“$1‘fti...03—CUp-a.—.‘——(1)•“)—‘-C—..fl)—-—c

-‘

I—

-‘

-‘it

—•

‘(

fø

P-’

I-.

Page 9 of 15

—-%CCCDCDCDOPititzititititit‘.itit3aa,a0z330£033--3£3003o3302z.,--D--rC-b3,:?‘i70‘a-J‘:aaaCC,aa,‘t-.0<ZC-‘-‘‘0-IIt‘)3’-7a7‘0.-I.za.‘-‘144I-”“.(0Cr(0C-.0.p.t:t(11.0-(0(4it1.;I..•0303p-i.0303¶4b.o0303(C0303(C0303(I)C)5>5>.....CI‘—-s,0>—-%-.,-,‘>I—

fr-’

4t’-’

•r

it a z

a•

—

-b

$._

i—

I-”

•t-.

c-;

—

0) —

(a.

.:,.,

3--

-b

.‘h

-h

,‘>

-—

---

“.

..a

a a

t o

Page 10 of 15

t3o3-anCt-tano-c0t0-oo••a00nCt-i000cz‘aC3700-mCtc’‘aza00-‘•0•-c‘amcCo7io3Ct70zam0-tocz0—0amC)C‘a0‘aCt‘a700nO0ai<zma00a0C)C-i‘a0Cz0Z0Z‘aCtc030-0CtzaCt0C.)‘a300C0t0ir0CIt•000•o at00CtçCt-i•z-çct0z<00-b-i0Z07‘aOa‘a000i‘aG0-i700-i‘a-%Ct‘a00Ct‘a70013‘aCt7Z0z0z3aznz0CC0000C700Zan‘at‘a-t-a‘amnOn••k--ft7Ctt0t-40‘a-hCt00070Cl)00‘aanoo7•l0t-ia‘a-c‘a-c-iz00zu00‘a0C00-%CtC00Cl)0•7CtxamCcC070t000007Ct•03-i‘a0300Cta•am‘azma‘an0‘aCt-cz‘<ct<0ctzCtCt7000-a‘a0‘a•<0CtzrtC‘a0C00004°’a00000-i‘a0-‘0t%‘az0z0Ct0z3Ct‘a0PEzCt3nocaa‘aa-i070Ct‘a‘aCt‘aa0‘aCto0‘a-e.-%0a00zCt70‘a-iCCt-0-1Ct090‘a00a0-ft-ftCt0a(0‘aC000zCt-hzzCt‘a0)C0.0070Ct0-70%?Ct0‘CCC03-hO07Ct70‘Ca0za0zazCt7-7<-10Cl)o0CtCt3CtC)004<0n•‘an0z—zICt‘a0CttCt0.0z0C-%‘a-hO‘a70Ct‘aCt3a4<0107‘a0‘CCt0Ct-ç-10-i000t0CtCtCt10-ft07Ct77Ctz‘ar-i‘azCt0000Ct0-c7•0a‘ao0-i0nCt00-cCt0nCDa z

30Ct00C)70-%as03C0Ct‘a‘a70.00-hO4<h’•00Ct1-çCt‘az0070000za3‘amn00hIt0(0-l(C‘a‘aW0ZC)0C)00z0m‘aa‘a®‘a‘a0za•‘a‘a‘a-itzz00fl0cnct‘a70N000z000ZCtCt303‘C0-ç0(0C0CC-s0Ct37C7000CtCt0Ct770-b005‘aCz0000a0z‘aa00Ct‘a-i03CtCD0‘C03a0000e‘a0%act0‘a0Z‘aCtaz70-0.0C0‘C0

-i

‘-•O

‘a

-l

-i ct

‘aC)

‘-•

-tO

‘a-i

‘a

0. ‘a

•

‘a-h

‘a

-i

-ft

‘a z

-i

‘a

‘C

‘a

-c

‘a

-ft

-i

‘C

‘aO

‘a

0‘aa0Ct-10-i000t0CtCtCt10-ft07Ct77Ctz‘ar-i‘azCt000Ct0-c7•0a‘ao0-i0nCt00-c‘CCt0nCDa70‘a-s0r t

Ct z

‘a

Page 11 of 15

-c

oCt00CttCtO-ftCtCtI-’C’•00fr-30-çi.7-413303C-Ii-•0.0‘-‘•0Ct00o0000-0C0.i-C3-1-43o03‘0i-a•-100a®to3-4o-aam(tO0000Ct•‘00a-‘I-.0C0-%afr.s-ft00I-.aC000000333000a-Cws-4z(0•a00CtCtOcta0Ca0‘C313C’Ct00333U30w473Ct(tO0‘<“C0•0t0003flU30-41-4I-’‘a-4070•0CtVtZ.00Ct®0C-4CU03ozz-C070a0SC0•00-%30-4ft3I—0‘-‘•00i-’300abas-‘ftC30C00Ct®Ct00•04033i-’03aCt-C00•)a..<Ctmat003-Ci-i00-S0C•3Ct30U“ft30I-’-1-ft)•“C01-’003030CI...ECt3030-fta-iC-C)‘ ossa®0Ct3-ftVt0%33•0a3a403oo03Ct•<I-.000Ct-II-Ct030Ct.0z00oCto0.ad0oCt®3Ct‘30Ct.00at333000as®I-CSC.00•70C0Ct30-40-‘Cçt0C0oC‘C0w-4030•<00CtU.00CtCtI...‘00“<000-‘-‘aCt33Ct3I-a3Ct000)••00Sue0Ct53oC‘—C;:‘a0I-..03i-a-4000CtI-’303•(0zaCt.03C033CtaSCa0-40o0i-•00‘p-ftI-.3.0-fta0I—0o’sacaC00ft‘0“-£00030l.a.C)i-.0003003çt-40.0CtU3-CVt®C0“C00i-aC0“Cao0-‘C0UCtfr0Ct0o‘-‘030I-.-43Ct3300‘-•O003000Ct03Ct®-t-ta3Ct-fta-ftzaoCt®00

‘ana00i-’0-1Ct-50-tI-’0I’•0an333•Cta3“ft0000033‘03I-.•<Ct‘0az003CtCt£Ct3I-’.330Ct00I-a-4003i-0•0I-a33003•00aC0W1Ct0C0I-.oaCtsCt>t•01-dti-00Is.)Cfl3003Ca•\-ftUCt0000C0CtCt0.03CtSCC0S0-00“C30Ct‘0‘0a-sI-•“4-i•“C00“ftCt•‘0‘0030030r-C-Ca‘-.zCtCto-i0“C‘<3£CtCi-’0030033(00aaz£0CtzCt3“430S0-0Ct0-4--.

‘0

-Ia

‘0

•

-ç

‘0

-4o

i-.

Ct t3

Ct®

I-C-lw

‘4.

‘thE

•

-ft

-CD

0’0

3a-iC

-ft

“4

1-43

-‘4

•

i-a l.ô

aCt®

a ft

‘0

‘0o

3ao a

i-.

Ct a

to to

Vt%toct77I-ai-aatoa3I-’CCDtoto4)r-zcrto‘-a0CaCDzVt04)z0a‘C3Vt3totoi-.C‘<3Lananto0Vta3ato-c0toaCoa-cz‘-.3a‘-aatotoaVt3‘-•ai-aVtca3i-’VtrtoaVt0oa•3zato3L0a-ltoo.0-h3totoVtC-taVta‘-•aNto0-i-ai-Vt-c0a-.Vt‘-‘to-b3I-.0tor’aa0-tI-’3zai-atoc..r’toa‘00Crzto-caaaVt10CC30i-CD03aatototoaatoaaVt31)C)i-a‘-ai-a30toU0CC3a7i-.to%to_a30i30“1i-a(4CaVtCDaC33aaVtVtCCa3to3aa-actaa

t to

t i-a

to to

i-a

-c

Page 12 of 15

-c0aVtz-%zto0to4)3330Vt‘-a‘-aa0aa-‘-atoVtaU raVtt0aQC)03toi-aCC’nxn-.€t‘-azaa-cnzVti-.a-ctoVtVtamVtØi-0VtVtaUaai-a“<7to3‘C‘CtoU‘C3•0zaarzaa70VtVtattoI-’0Cmtoto3aa0U(3to-%-c0-rnxn-.€t‘-azaa-cnzVti-.a-ctoVtVtamVtØi-0VtVtaUaai-a“<7to3‘C‘CtoU‘C3•0zaarzaa70VtVtattoI-’0Cmtoto3aa0U(3to-%-c0-rCcaa-bt‘C0a0Vta0toato‘-aaUC-b3a0to(ftCLa‘CVt3UtaU•tona‘-.-cooraaaa37-c7zi-aa.otaztoaVt0aVtaVtaac-c0.0ao0ato‘-aaUC-b3a0to(ftCLa‘CVt3UtaU•tona‘-.-cooraaaa37-c7zi-aa.otaztoaVt0aVtaVtaac-c0.0ao0zrC3toiaL‘-.0zca.o.0azi-a-Ii3UtoatoacCtoVt3-*to-<i-C0toUI-’aUt‘—I-’to0Vtto0•to3VtVti-aVt0i-•.0c£3i-aVt‘Cto‘—aI-’toatott.a3303i-0toçtVtazi-a-Ii3UtoatoacCtoVt3-*to-<i-C0toUI-’aUt‘—I-’to0Vtto0•to3VtVti-aVt0i-•.0c£3i-aVt‘Cto‘—aI-’toatott.a3303i-0toçtVti-atoacazCto033i-a‘-Vt3i-aVti-aVt‘-ara‘C000Vtatoi-•to3Z‘0LtoVtazz<Vti-.ato—0zi-.o-bUiaVt‘1toVt‘C0toU0La0-h‘C0I-atoa3C)Vt‘00-cto30C)‘C3a-l3.1Vt-cVttotoI-ftoVta3’00a0•a03‘<-iz‘-azzato-c-co‘0to-‘ai-•-%•-tO-ft0Vt3-cVtmaa03Vt3‘0‘-a0C‘-aat-ci-a)-totoCi-htoto‘Cto3toCi-.aa3aatoVtaoza0i-a‘CVt33i-ai-a0toto30to03C£i-a-czVt0‘CUaa‘0i-•-c3Vt3toVt1to3C)00-c•toVt0Vtatoi-•to3Z‘0LtoVtazz<Vti-.ato—0zi-.o-bUiaVt‘1toVt‘C0toU0La0-h‘C0I-atoa3C)Vt‘00-cto30C)‘C3a-l3.1Vt-cVttotoI-ftoVta3’00a0•a03‘<-iz‘-azzato-c-co‘0to-‘ai-•-%•-tO-ft0Vt3-cVtmaa03Vt3‘0‘-a0C‘-aat-ci-a)-totoCi-htoto‘Cto3toCi-.aa3aatoVtaoza0i-a‘CVt33i-ai-a0toto30to03C£i-a-czVt0‘CUaa‘0i-•-c3Vt3toVt1to3C)00-c•toVtVt0i-a3aVta0i-ai-ai-’33c-fttoVti-aaai-Vt0CcVtC)a-c 3to‘-‘33toVt‘CVt-%3c-fttoVti-aaai-Vt0CcVtC)a-c 3to‘-‘33toVt‘CVt-%VtatoCaC-%Vtto•3m3aaCDto00Vti-a‘C0aaoto-ft0-c0Ci-aa£CCto3i-ototozaVttoVtrtototoCtoaVttoi-aaVt3to“1to3aaCDto00Vti-a‘C0aaoto-ft0-c0Ci-aa£CCto3i-ototozaVttoVtrtototoCtoaVttoi-aaVt3to“1to-40Vt3-ctorato0arto£33to-c•atotoCDi-’to30CDVtaaatoto-c•atotoCDi-’to30CDVtaaato to a a

to a

i-.

•

<.0

Lax

-c

a to

-c

a to

Vt r

a a

aaa

i-a

i-’

Page 13 of 15

,-az

to-ç

tCt3‘-30a

03to‘-•

flCttCt33,-msa

totCt303flCttCt0•-ça‘-30aaoto‘-•33,-msaaaa-sCD•-ça‘-30aaoto‘-•33,-msaaaa-sCD‘rn.Q-ci.’.CtO3•3CtI•3ft•‘.a0U,.zCDi—.CD.0a3Ct‘oaI-’I—•%-b-‘-%.0aotoC‘-i-aa-t‘..s-.c.-i‘-ze.aato•to33toCtft•Ct-b-‘-%.0aotoC‘-i-aa-t‘..s-.c.-i‘-ze.aato•to33toCtft•CttoC0‘-•7)•aa3asa-100‘-•0aDCt‘-a-i-%atoa‘-z0-c0to-itoab-I0b-a3133toza3zzna<‘-toao a’0s-ca0aC-%Uatoa‘-z0-c0to-itoab-I0b-a3133toza3zzna<‘-toao a’0s-ca0aC-%UtoU-•CtCa•0CDatoCD0Cza--ftoCt‘-‘z‘-aCt3aaanzt3i-.o-ft.aaaaCtaaa-.,-to3tob-•toaoa3—Ct3C3ct 3a‘-‘0-(toctocOasaaa’-a-.-fta•‘a0sa0aa30‘--ftC)30aU30‘--ftC)30aUa-tato.o-caa‘-03-4-1aCt-NC‘0Ia30—0-i•COC‘-3to‘00aCtU<0zCDza‘-Ctto3o3aa3‘-03-4-1aCt-NC‘0Ia30—0-i•COC‘-3to‘00aCtU<0zCDza‘-Ctto3o3aa3

P1I-.Q()(a<a030zaaozzaztoazCoaC0CD330çt-5000“•toaccza‘-.aC3C‘-03033fttoI.’.3aa30‘303a‘<a-c‘-3Ctz3C‘<0aaa’--aama-.‘-.<xaCa3aI<000‘01Cftncta03aCem-iCDCtN“103aUi003a--ta-4Ct-1waSCao‘-aaa7b-’to0a‘.o•C3Ct0z3-‘0a0Ctto-Ct3‘05-(30aawa-c‘-0ft3-%-cca7aCaCto-ft-ç£fraaw.3aC30Ct£U0Ct3aC0-t-0C-ft0•—Cttoli - a

Ct a

•

‘-

-ft

m x

•

a’-’-.

•

0’-

3-bto a

-s

-Ct

‘C

‘-

‘-‘C

-Ct

‘-

oC-10

‘-

aatooC-10‘0aQaCt3-fta0-1a0CtU0c033atozCtsaato-çtoaa•CoCioa‘-a-aa‘-0-taa•aaz—cC)Ctza‘-aC‘-a0a-1Ct0-ftC3o-‘-aatoCD-a’-’3zatoa‘-Cta-caU3£CtCti-a‘-a0Cti-’.‘-5333033C30z0aaC-cCaoa -ft

-to’-

aC0c—•

-o

a a

a to

‘<

‘- to

‘-a

3to

Page 14 of 15

-a

.*a

(t) Ct57a.UiU00(toi.1.3(aa-a3‘Cb-.CI—.(4-‘ICtem:r-cC-pI-..(6:19;0;Cz(C’C.E(3‘T(ii‘a-I“xi

C) 1. eCrrZ:, 3it.S(’:.t.C-.ncrflaxocl-wa.7-f:‘.WØj.a£cei‘ttnjg3Crrc e •Lzflo e‘‘<cqt•0;pa.1.—mce ace Cez ctfl:...

Cr z

—,

‘3Q

‘

rt:•..

®z., ma

-%(h-c,

re O:r

••

•)C‘S’. C)..;‘lbO••i-I 0 0‘-‘!’-’(fl*-‘ei__ntk’(*3itCM,-.-!D.’-m•J&::-ts-.cija’.•)az iV.cCeoo.OOaee,oJItea‘< nb..—..to.t.C•4*C ‘t C•z-z-,0.Set‘‘?--In-c (p..:3i‘h 7•t)ocr(,-Ct4*3r-fr”)’.b-Cflrz-n—• -t(toE%03cao(4Ort‘“,cze(*0<3rI-IC-c.Z<3zZ0(tfl•a.•r1 Ot;Cbzz’rr1-.Q-i0z<‘O-‘døctz(4—40foci,itZRcC(t-I’.:.Cfr 3D-‘D.f4 ‘-a) ),ç -t W0b-a‘rC

flcm.r3

V•-t-.

C,—

—

ØØ

•r1 Ot;

Z.-.- >

tt6j

‘a

‘4C.Ct(ftCtC)VI(SC-,a,(a0Ct:-100-ç1)I,n0•1:1-‘

‘: ‘:

‘•fl (4 0’ e.

flcc..

‘D

s...

ç’

‘—ecep.,

.TrrØ

‘-et’n

flCPrSw

O-

coe,-.

1zC--zC--

‘ri_i-a

fl•a.oC-

S.Cøt)‘oa..-t

Zrj,

:nu r -• ‘ ‘

‘•

‘Si

Page 15 of 15

Loading citations and judicial treatment…