N.L. ABHYANKAR AND OTHERS ETC. versus UNION OF INDIA on 24 April 1984

r

..

S5~L

N.L. ABHYANKAR AND OTI~ERS ETC ..

- -~ ...

• v • . •. UNION OF.INDIA··

-.

. · ·

. · · . April l4, 1984 • · . . [O~ CHINNAPPA: RmoY, A.P. SEN AND E.S. vrNKATARAMIAu,· 1n · -:t. • .High Court iud~e~ (Co.1ditidns. ~! .se.rvice) Ac/ 19.54. ·s. 1.5 ~ First -Schedule_ Pari] para -10 & The High. Co;~t JuiJt!S (Conlitl.Jns of SeTvic~) Amendment Act ~ . . . 1976.: --· '. · · · · -. · · '· · : . : . · . Sup:i'eme Court Ji.idge3 -(Condition's of Ser~lie) Act i9S8, S. · 14 & '(he · Supreme Conrt Jndges (Condltlons r . . of ;service) . Amend1neizt Act 1976. Retired Judie:_;.High Court & Supr~me Court enhancedPen~ionary ben-efits entitlemeni fo.....;.lrrt[spective OJ date ofretirem_ent, :; .. -· < ; -"i -' -·. , . . ._ . . ' , ~ -. . - " .

, ._ -• The Judges of the' High C0ur.t and of the Supreme. Court will be entitled to 1he'pension1ry· be:iCfitS u11der·- the amended Act of 1976 irres.=. . pective or the dateS of their -~re_tiremcnt. ·They will be sci ·ea'titled with e_tf ect ·• ·from t.to.1974. Arrears of pensio·n calculat·ed under th~ .Pro\'jsions of th~ new Act "wiU be paid to those to Whom it is -due ·within four. months. In~ tbO. · c·ase of Judges' who have died after' t.10.19'74 the·amout1ts. due wiTI b~ p1id ···to the legal heirs of the Judges withiO four months. The family"pension due to·the Widows _will be calculated under the' proVi.sioos of the 1976 Amending· Act and paid.to them. Ad-boC p.iym;:nts rOadeJ if any, V:.in be {ldjllsfed while _!Daking sue~ payments. [S52 D:-F] . '

·D

CIVIL. ORIGINAl. . JURISDICTION:· Writ Peiition '(Civil) ·Nos. 3S31 to 3534' of 1983;.

(Under Article 32 of th~ Cotlstitution) • With . . . . . . . . ( " Writ Petition (Civil) Nos. 4831 to 4833 of.1'}83. ' · (Under Article 32 of the Con~titution) And Writ Petition°cCivil)_:rfo. 13243_ of 1983 of 1983 1983

F·

•

G.

Petition°cCivil)_:rfo. 13243_ of 1983 of 1983 1983 (l,Jnd•:" Article 3.2 of the. Constitution) -Bobde; A. K. A. K. K. Sanghi,' Ms .. .. Amaljit .

V. A. Bobde; A. K. A. K. K. Sanghi,' Ms .. .. Amaljit . Chauhan -and Smt. :. R. B. Bobde for . . the petitioners: . , . . .. ..

. .. ..

·H

.

r

l

,.

)I

SS3

,N. L. ABHl'AN!(l\R '· lJNlON (Chinnappa-Rerjdy, J.)

·1

D. K. Garg for the Petitloner in Writ Petition No. 13243 of 1983. - A

K. Parasaran, Attorney General, R. D. Agarwal a~d R. N. Poddar for the Re~pondent ·

The Order <?f the Court was delivered by ~ CaiNNAPPA RiiooY, J. In view or'our decision in D.S. Nakara v. Vnion of India,l'i'[I983] I SCC 305 and for the reasons mentioned . by the Allahabad High Court in Writ Petition No. 3281of1979· ·dated 2.3.1983 in the case of Bidhubhushan Malik and otlters-v. Union of India, wh-ich we have accepted as correct in Special Leave Petition No. 9616 of 1983 just now dismissed by us we allow the writ petitions. The Judges of the High Court anl! of the Supreme · Court will be ei<titled to the·pensionary benefits 'under the amended Act of 1976 irrespective of the dates of their retirement. They will "'1 be so entitled with effect from 1.10.1974, Arrears of pension calculated- under_ the provlsio"n,s of the new Act will be paid to those to whom it is due within four months from today. In the case of Judges who have died after 1.10.1974 the amounts due will be paid to the legal heirs of the Judges within four months from today. The family pension due to the_ widows will b,e calculated unper the provisions_ of the 1976 Amending Act and paid to them. Ad· hoc ·paymenis made, ifany, will be adjusted while making such pay·· _; ments. The writ petitions are disppsed of accordingly. What we_ · have· said a!iout pensionary benefits does not llPPIY to payn:tent of . gratuity. ., c , D

E

F

N.V.K.

Petition allowed.

0