Karnataka High Court
WP/16242/2000 of M/S SHEVIRE CASHEWS Vs AGRICULTURAL PRODUCE MARKET COMMITTEE on 9 November 2000
N ‘-4 ft y’ t N r ci ci 3) (4 ‘4 .— f ci ci: H ” <C Di H ” H ” 4D H ” Di ‘c i Di ci ft ) cc i ft H ” (f t 4> : Di ci ci 4> ci D i- H ” < “ N 1ff •lf ) ci , D ci I D i f t -(4 r ’ ci ci <C (4. 4ff
C) ft - ci ftN<CD
fttNrcia14.,ciC-C) ft - ci ftN<CD[1]DiH”‘-4y’<3DiO4)ci”ciH”H”’(1lciDiH”ciH”(4.U)‘4)(4,)>7cia4ff:4. cicici(4)H”ci(14[ft]Di:ci ft4))QDici•ciDi’ci Dicift—4ciH”cia01of ft . (4)‘(:0afta(O.‘:ci—ç ft“4.ci‘1)Dici“4 a (3(ci‘cici’cio(‘3H”—4“K.CE:3:H”1ff)(‘3)‘<(ci’,ftH”ft1.)34’H’”(143ci’ H” ciO’r’.ft<‘444>ft14-C<Cft C( ftH”<C’>”.4>.ft4>1>40) 3 ft17(“)<tft3’17’(4)<C H” ft. H”<CciH”(7<CaCO.:‘N”1ff)“4
C)’cn :4>4>.
‘1ff.
(<7 ft
Cr<Ccici
(‘N
>‘, 4(4 ft 4’>
H”
C)
ft’
((4.,
‘
,
H” <C
4< 3)
ci ft
<CH”ft-f)>,,
Di’
(‘4)
“'4
ft
7’
Di’
<C’
—(H” ft
Di
H” ci ft ci
H”
(C ft
<C
H” Cci
<C:
...fl)
.ci
H” ci
oft•
:rr 4>3
(C: ft
(3“
ft
cici3)CL
cift
CciC)
ci, Di
Di’
ci
ci
Page 1 of 14
4Dci:‘4.—fH”DiDi(4H” <C‘ciH”H”ciftcici<tft3H”ftH” Di ci (ff,”(Dii><C. :xt-’ciçt:(ft,ci,.ft170 ci ftaft•ft(ci.414 (‘7(3:H”<3<o4 ft (31)[‘i:]ci.ci“f’cici.[ft]‘(‘14(14—(ci*ci.7’a114ci((4.(4)‘<Cft((4‘i:(4:7’:<C(C>‘ff‘N’,:<Cft’)j_..ff:33C)a4,’,.,ci44)‘-44))ftDicif—, 3.<CH”H” ci 3H”fffDi<Dici ft<—‘4040Diacciftci<Ccici’3Di33ci>fjft0ciDift)4C),:4>:aC).(ft4>:H”ciH” C: ft•ci(ff( ft C),43:H”Di ciC)a‘C(ft4>:H”ciH” C: ft•ci(ff( ft C),43:H”Di ciC)a‘CDi3< ciDi(4Di4,)(0< ft4>ciciciH”cift Dici, a ciDi Dici, ftH’Q’)ci ,QN. (3 DiH”ciç’t4>(‘1)ft‘7’H”14:ft ft4.ci‘<CftcliDi-H”Di<Cci(0)Di’ci<Dci<4) DiDiH”C:7(“4H”14:ft ft4.ci‘<CftcliDi-H”Di<Cci(0)Di’ci<Dci<4) DiDiH”C:7(“4<“N1ff•lf)cia(4) ft ciH”<1fH”ft ci 3,((4(‘4)13H”‘-0‘cicici.<,,, ci—‘4>CDci,ci(‘4H”ft(fl<0 cici aciC):“4:>(‘14’31IDift0.ci4>Cr H” ftciIDift0.ci4>Cr H” ftciH” H”QLL, C0)’’<DiH”ft-(4<CciH”(ci ci.:iDiftH”1-’ci, cicir’ ci<C‘<CH” (Dft’< ‘C) DiCC’ff>.<),,Di” “(4):(4)ft-(4<CciH”(ci ci.:iDiftH”1-’ci, cicir’ ci<C‘<CH” (Dft’< ‘C) DiCC’ff>.<),,Di” “(4):(4)
ci:ci
<3(4<
(ci (3)
<C
<C
ci
<C
ft ft’
NO (3
:3’
‘
DirDi 744>’,
ci
‘K
ci
Page 2 of 14
‘
<C
C)
ci.
H”
‘0710:ci
(3.
ft)
<3
cift
07ci
ci
Di
H”:31-4Ccii3:-‘4.:07.-ICC):143xCH”-IC.4H”:o:H”31<3*r(1)—014.:CH”.-40H”.-4:4.ICxcIn.70ci4-43.4,,)0C.-0)030<3ft“3o—0:rn.rH”-ci214H”C00a0(3:‘070pcicoo:<a:j:33Na0:-4.N,:44(3.a“4.442010ozoa<a-4<3*I->140731a4)0(3)‘0-4cooa..3,H”7031Or07—:07Naa0ci’IC00H”03
f
4’
o
‘..
Sc,
a
a
t..
a
-bE
a-1r
a
‘
-i
oC
a
o3
c-I
•ft
ftC•‘-D1in03fta0Cu
a
a-i003ft•3•I—o3aoCt0atC04<-ifts0a—ft0Q•.d0a030•10ft03tI...(1)E•ft•ft-hoa-1ra7aftafto3•03aa.0ft—0ac-I•a03ft—•ft00300C-%3x•Sfrã‘0-‘‘-‘0ftC•‘-D1in03fta0Cu4<7u•ftac0aao‘-‘0aSta•ft5-‘0C•11•ft‘-a.z.‘-a-ft-1
a
C
DC
ft
a
ftO
.0
C
ft
a
a
N
‘-a.
ft
a
t
ft
-i aft03
(a
•
C
Page 3 of 14
•
70aa3
aft70•0-baa070aa3-47••100ar4<O••aa30‘-a.0at0•aaft03-4E-IaCftSE•—(t(to•aI—•a-i3••-4St-I3•r•aa700‘-a•03sftftfr.ft0’-.0aft700atft-%•ir30‘-a.a030-,tb•aft0aftft7ft5a0•1ftS-%oa•00C33•aI—•a-1St‘--a•0-13a0Era50ft0000S0taftft00-‘ft‘-a.30ft‘-a.ft7Sar0ft0I-IftS00aft•3070aftCCftSr0E—fta3aft‘-0a—‘--a-i‘-aft70ft1000ma3ao••a•aaaara3‘34<‘-‘0NNiIa0ft.03•0ft7-ia00’aCaaait0a3ait0zftzaaIftC“-0azo3a300aOft5ftsat0Caa0sa•‘-a.ft3fts0i I
4<
,a
0-b
ft
I
S
a
—
“
‘30
a
‘03
at
z i
a
ft
a ft ft
Q
X
C
-c
a ft
a
a
—
•
L’
C
—ft
•o
—
a ft
U
ft
ft
S
a
itO
•
a
-b0-II-.ftSInIat‘-a-Ift.NftStOasO5ft•a.-1fta—30—30-IS•aa-t30•0aC30a00C-a3a•ada a
.0
C
ft
a
a
N
‘-a.
ft
a
t
ft
-i aft03
(a
•
C
Page 4 of 14
•
70aa3
aft70•0-baa070aa3-47••100ar4<O••aa30‘-a.0at0•aaft03-4E-IaCftSE•—(t(to•aI—•a-i3••-4St-I3•r•aa700‘-a•03sftftfr.ft0’-.0aft700atft-%•ir30‘-a.a030-,tb•aft0aftft7ft5a0•1ftS-%oa•00C33•aI—•a-1St‘--a•0-13a0Era50ft0000S0taftft00-‘ft‘-a.30ft‘-a.ft7Sar0ft0I-IftS00aft•3070aftCCftSr0E—fta3aft‘-0a—‘--a-i‘-aft70ft1000ma3ao••a•aaaara3‘34<‘-‘0NNiIa0ft.03•0ft7-ia00’aCaaait0a3ait0zftzaaIftC“-0azo3a300aOft5ftsat0Caa0sa•‘-a.ft3fts0i I
4<
,a
0-b
ft
I
S
a
—
“
‘30
a
‘03
at
z i
a
ft
a ft ft
Q
X
C
-c
a ft
a
a
—
•
L’
C
—ft
•o
—
a ft
U
ft
ft
S
Page 5 of 14
a
itO
•
a
-b0-II-.ftSInIat‘-a-Ift.NftStOasO5ft•a.-1fta—30—30-IS•aa-t30•0aC30a00C-a3a•ada a Ct7‘tax“‘a7ooono.s‘Cap.m0-Io70.-Iaa30(Pt-ICt300.-Iaa30(Pt-ICt30C37Ct0”’0Cta-I•(Pt3rCI—aCt03aaCtar.ao.ow’I-’I-’-l0£r•3a-’•asCt21ar03•0-I•‘-.•.00Ct•ato‘Ca“Oaaa0i3a0a-’0p.’0a30•-b0CL’‘CI’.CtI.’Ct50-Ia0050aasCt31Ct7aa,-1CtCt30070Ct0-hO-ICt“-CC03“.73aC-l•SaCoa•C(Pt30a55CtCt7Ct0Ct0aa-100a703a-103a0ja0s•t•I.’0%0’.‘0.4ai-COCt0-10.4.4•00Ct03•SCt70C00•-lbrCtCt7aCta-%-1.‘-lbtoaaCt07300•Ctaao•I•I 0a-I•(Pt3rCI—aCt03aaCtar.ao.ow’I-’I-’-l0£r•3a-’•asCt21ar03•0-I•‘-.•.00Ct•ato‘Ca“Oaaa0i3a0a-’0p.’0a30•-b0CL’‘CI’.CtI.’Ct50-Ia0050aasCt31Ct7aa,-1CtCt30070Ct0-hO-ICt“-CC03“.73aC-l•SaCoa•C(Pt30a55CtCt7Ct0Ct0aa-100a703a-103a0ja0s•t•I.’0%0’.‘0.4ai-COCt0-10.4.4•00Ct03•SCt70C00•-lbrCtCt7aCta-%-1.‘-lbtoaaCt07300•Ctaao•I•I 0C-Ia7t-cI...o0-II...000sCt0Ct07•00a03a3-1a.a3C—7a0‘.‘.-c‘<Ct.4Ctq._oaa00C00•3a-I•WOo.3Id.0tO07070-1030Pb.ca70•a00a3Ct“•aaaJ43a•ozCt0CtCta00I—t—7a0‘.‘.-c‘<Ct.4Ctq._oaa00C00•3a-I•WOo.3Id.0tO07070-1030Pb.ca70•a00a3Ct“•aaaJ43a•ozCt0CtCta00I—t0247-IC000S2c£7-ca-0.4a000za030-b3•-lbCt“S2c£7-ca-0.4a000za030-b3•-lbCt“oOr00“‘a.Ct-10Ct-b-h0-lasCta-1b%0aCtCt773aamo707a007a•••S•3-ca0at-cCt-b-h0-lasCta-1b%0aCtCt773aamo707a007a•••S•3-ca0at-c -‘
Page 6 of 14
0t0t0a-lbC0-l4b0.400oz0acc7asCaaa•aoaaa‘-‘a07a7asCaaa•aoaaa‘-‘a07a7•00-1-I-ItE0Ct0000h3%lbrrCt•CtoSI0-1-I-ItE0Ct0000h3%lbrrCt•CtoSI.4az0oCtaaaa07070aai-’S0as7.£•t£•a3CtCtwzC7‘a.aCtarr-ICtSIaCt0•7”.a3CtCtwzC7‘a.aCtarr-ICtSIaCt0•7”.CtI-100aCt33037•0aCt33037•0-1a•‘-p.’t-100lbId.taCtI’.00lbId.taCtI’.0a03 0-1CtaCt0Id.—30Id.—3CtCt-I7007—7•CtCt0007‘-1aaa-1•0.4•00-1I—3-10I’.5Coo0-1I—3-10I’.5Coop..aaaCtaCoCt3CtCt0aCoCt3CtCt0z•70770•i•a00-1•i•a00-1
‘
Id.
O
a
a
to.
O 0‘
‘
Ct
I’.
Ct
‘C
Ct a
a
so
.
.‘
0033.
Ct
a
a a
St
a
U
‘<
Ct
-lb
77s
o•I•I 0
-lb
a r r•.
a
a
Ct
Ct
St
-*0
rO
Ct0
-
p..
z
t
a
I’.
Ct
z
*-
Page 7 of 14
•
I)“a,H-HaC)C)H’C))—‘CC‘-C-H’CD,—-C)‘‘C:C)cH-.C)“C—iDCD‘—CraH-rCD))C)CL-C)1)C)C),,)CC•0-”CLDO.3C)C).3CDCC•C)C):
°—‘
Co
CL
C)
CD
CD
CL
C)
<C
—h
Ct.
-C
CL
C)
:C)
DC
C)
C)
C)
-C:
‘C
CL
I)
CD
CL
CD
C)
CD
H-
C)
CD
CC:
C)
C)’
C.D
C)C)’ClC.DH-C):‘CLCrDC,:-C.C)CDCLCTC)C:+C)‘-a-Cla-CD,C)3CL.C))3CCCoC)CDC)‘C)-aCLCrC))C)C))DoC)C)‘-Ci)C)C)CDC)tC)ClCDC)CDCTCC:C2CCCC:C)CD:C)H-CDC)CL,D‘H’’-C.C’)’CCC..’CLC)CDCD“C.C)CLC)-tC)’33CDCCC)’C)CLH-‘K0”CDCDCC)’CLC)’CC-”C)CLCCCLCC)HH”C)C)))“CC)CL’H-C)”C)C)H’-C)DoCLH-)C.DC))CLCC’C)H-C)C))Cl.)C)C)oCLCLDoCDCDCDCDCDDoDC)C)C)C)CLCDCDCC-t3CDCC)
CC-CL””
3’
CD
‘—“C)::
CL CC
Cr
—C.
C)
C)
CC)
CC’
CL
CT
CD
CD:
CD
CD’
DC
C
C)
C”
C)
CD
CL
)‘a3:
Cl
Page 8 of 14
‘CCI:-‘
CC.C))
“C’—
CC”CC’C’’H-3C’CC):CCLCCDCLH-C)-
-Co
6—6I-C.—CC:).):CH-’-):3’:CCC’CC.C))‘3’C.):ClCC:oC—’CL:o,a-a“C’—-aCooC)3’DC—C’aH’C):“)C’:’C)CC:C)CC”CC’C’’H-3C’CC):CCLCCDCLH-C)-C)‘CLH-’C--,CLC):C)C)CLC-’C)C:)C)CC)CCDCDCD3C)’3C)CCD’C)CD:HCLDoC’rCCCL3CiH-CDC)CC)CTc)).CL3’C)ClCDC)’CC)DC‘C.CL:.C)LDCOICCL2—CDCDCL°-“-Co“C)t363CLC)CDCD‘CIDDCCDDCçt-r-1CC)23C)C)’C)C)3”C:DC)CLC))It.-‘.C”CCC)’‘a,,’C)otC-”C)o°rCDC’tCDCLjDC)C)“CCL3C—’DCC--C)’C)H-)CtC)’CDC-”•0CD-CCDCD-CCD:CL-çCD
CCC
p
Cl
r
-C.
CD
CD
l
H”
‘C
‘C)
CL
a
3’
-C
CO
CL
C)’
CD
‘C)
.-C
C)
CC’
CD
CCC
CD
—C
CD
CL
:r
CD
3:
CD
-C
CD
it
•fl
C)
C)
H-
CL
CL
CD::.
CD
CC-CL””
3’
CD
‘—“C)::
CL CC
Cr
—C.
C)
C)
CC)
CC’
CL
CT
CD
CD:
CD
CD’
DC
C
C)
C”
C)
CD
CL
)‘a3:
Cl
Page 9 of 14
‘CCI:-‘
CC.C))
“C’—
CC”CC’C’’H-3C’CC):CCLCCDCLH-C)-
-Co
6—6I-C.—CC:).):CH-’-):3’:CCC’CC.C))‘3’C.):ClCC:oC—’CL:o,a-a“C’—-aCooC)3’DC—C’aH’C):“)C’:’C)CC:C)CC”CC’C’’H-3C’CC):CCLCCDCLH-C)-C)‘CLH-’C--,CLC):C)C)CLC-’C)C:)C)CC)CCDCDCD3C)’3C)CCD’C)CD:HCLDoC’rCCCL3CiH-CDC)CC)CTc)).CL3’C)ClCDC)’CC)DC‘C.CL:.C)LDCOICCL2—CDCDCL°-“-Co“C)t363CLC)CDCD‘CIDDCCDDCçt-r-1CC)23C)C)’C)C)3”C:DC)CLC))It.-‘.C”CCC)’‘a,,’C)otC-”C)o°rCDC’tCDCLjDC)C)“CCL3C—’DCC--C)’C)H-)CtC)’CDC-”•0CD-CCDCD-CCD:CL-çCD
CCC
p
Cl
r
-C.
CD
CD
l
H”
‘C
‘C)
CL
a
3’
-C
CO
CL
C)’
CD
‘C)
.-C
C)
CC’
CD
CCC
CD
—C
CD
CL
:r
CD
3:
CD
-C
CD
it
•fl
C)
C)
H-
CL
CL
CD::.
CD
C)
Do
C)
CD
Do
C_
)D:
CD
CL
—r
CD
Page 10 of 14
Do
‘1
rr
CD
CL
t-.C)
CDt-.C)C.)C)D-aC)3CL‘CCtC)—C‘3H-CLCrC):CrCDCL.C):CLCLCDorDCCCCC—’CDC)CD3’Cl.CD.CLCL‘1CDC))00CC)ClC)flCD:U).CD33-C)CrCC):CCCrC)16C:CLCD-CH’CL“CC”C)CLCC3:CLZr3.DCCD:3:CDCDC)CDHH‘-CTCDoC)CDCC)C)CLCC:CD:C)H-CrCD-)CL.:t-“a-C)%3C)CLC)C)CCrt’22’ClCDCDCD’-CCD-CCl—oCD:))CDCDC—CLC)CLCTC)HCDCDC)3CLCLC)DCHClCD‘-CC°.DCCDCD3’C)CDC)C)
Cl
DC
C)
C:.
CCF
ç
CC
.
C)
CD
C—”
Ct
CCC’
CD
.93:
DCC
-C
CCC’
CD
Ct
-CC
:C)C
Zr
C:C:
CD
6:
CC)CCC
Page 11 of 14
CCCCDCF7tZrCDVCDCV::C)CDCZCCDzrCDCFC)CCCVC—%CFCC.((CFZrCDCFZrCCCf.CD“C,VCCCDCCCCLVC.‘CCCDC)CDCCCCF-oF”F”CDDCC)CCC)CCZrCC)F”CICDCDF”CFDC—CC)D)—h,CC)(CCC•CtZrCDF”rFZrDCF”CDC)CDCt—14CDCDF”DC-C,rCDDCCCC-CCFZrCDCFCCC)CDC)CDCf:ZrCDCDDF”CDZrC)5CFCDCDDCC—’F”CD-CC)CCCCDCDtC—C‘CCCFZrC4CODCF”CFC-CC)CDC-CV-CCL)CCC’CCCCFF”C)C.CFCDCCC’CDCF.:—CC‘CC33DCCDCF“C’‘<CCDDC.:CD:C””C):,C)CFCC)CDVCCC‘CCDCZrCDCDCDCC)—C•ZrClCD‘CCCCCCCCD‘CCCC;.CD<3CDCDCC)CCCCCDC)—,CF‘<C;trCDVDC—C33CDCtZrCCCC)CFF”CDF”DC:‘CDF”ZrDCVF”D:.CCCDCZrCC)CCCCCC-iDCCF:ZrCDCFØCDCDDC•C)DrCCCV:DCCDD-CD:.CCD:C)ZrC-‘CCCCCDrDCCCL‘CC .41CC)F”CFCC‘CCCCCCCC”‘CCC.DDCCFZTV—Ci)CDC)ZrCCCCC)-CDCD.C”CC)C)DCCDF”5;CFCD;9F”CFCD93C):CFZrCD‘<VV•DC‘.F”CFC).<CDC)CDCD•F”F”CLCZCDCDCiCF”F”CDCDF”F”CDZrV.:C)C):“C-C’C)ftC)C)“CC)CFC)F”9C)CCCLCD‘CCCDCDCt“CCCF’Zr:33C)—CiCCCCthCDDCC33‘CD<CCCZrCCCVF”F”-CCD:ZrDCCCCCD::CDCC):—CCCCCDCFZrCF”CDF”CCC,CD‘CCCFDCCDC);tZrVDCC):CFC)CDCDC)CC.C—CC:F”F”CD:CD:CDC”CD””“CCF‘CCDCCCC:F”-CCtCFZrCC.CD:CDF”CD,C)<C.-CF”C)“CF”F”CCC)CDF”DCF”C)F”CDCF”F”9$CCCCDF”CLF”DCCZrZrCDCClDCF”CDCDDCF”‘CCCDCCF”F—’CFCD:ZrCDZr“C339ZrCD—CiCDClF”Ct:9333C)C)ZrCDCD:CD:CDC)ZrDC
CD
CT
CCC
CCCVJCCt—CCDCCDCCCCCCZrDCCCDCDCCCCCCZrDCCCDC—’CC)F”‘C)CD:C)F”DCC).CCC.“—C-C’.CCC‘CC‘CCFCtCF:F”C)tCFZr—CC3•C’Zr‘CC‘CCFCtCF:F”C)tCFZr—CC3•C’ZrCDC)-C-C‘CD3.CDCtCDDCCC)DC:-rCD.3.CDCtCDDCCC)DC:-rCD.:C)CDCDC)DC).CC,C)DC.:-CCDCCC3CCDCCCCCD‘CCC)93CD“:—CC<CDC)CF:;.,C.t’DCD:CZrC)CCCC)(CC.C”DCCDCC)DCC)CCC:F”CCCIDC ¶) CCDC)3CFC)CC,C)DC.:-CCDCCC3CCDCCCCCD‘CCC)93CD“:—CC<CDC)CF:;.,C.t’DCD:CZrC)CCCC)(CC.C”DCCDCC)DCC)CCC:F”CCCIDC ¶) CCDC)3CFC)CDCDC’t’DCCC—”C:DZrDCF”CC—”C:DZrDCF”—CCCCDCF”C)CDZrCD)C)CDZrCD)DCDC)C:CC,CCDDCZrZrCDCDCDCD;CCCCDDCCCF”çtCDDCCCF”çt-CF”CCC’CC)C—”33CD..:.ZrCC)VCCFC:CCDCFZrCC)33p.F”F”:‘tCCCCD;CDC:.:CtC’)CD’F”-CCDCDC)’CDC-”33CD..:.ZrCC)VCCFC:CCDCFZrCC)33p.F”F”:‘tCCCCD;CDC:.:CtC’)CD’F”-CCDCDC)’CDC-”CFC).3CCCDF’CDCCCCD-C3.F”DCCCCCCCCDCCCCD-C3.F”DCCCCCCCC):CrF”DC:CF“CCtCD•-CF”CDZr2:tC).CD:.:F”CD::Zr:)DCCD’1C’CDCF“CCtCD•-CF”CDZr2:tC).CD:.:F”CD::Zr:)DCCD’1C’CD
CD•
CCCI
C—’flF”-C
CC)
F”
CD:
.30
‘CC
,
C”
Ct
=C
V
C)
C).
CC)
‘CC
CD
CC.
CD
CCC
DC
F”
C)
F”
CD?—
CC)
CD
C)
Zr
F”
CF
F”
Zr
CCC
CD
CCC
CF
C)
‘CC
DC
“C
—C
C)
CCC’
CD
CF
CF
‘<C
CF
C)
CD
C
CD
Ct
CF
j
DC
C)
CD
CF
DC
C-”3’C”,
CD:
Cl
CD•
CCCI
C—’flF”-C
CC)
F”
CD:
.30
‘CC
,
C”
Ct
=C
V
C)
C).
CC)
‘CC
CD
CC.
CD
CCC
DC
F”
C)
F”
CD?—
CC)
CD
C)
Zr
F”
CF
F”
Zr
CCC
CD
CCC
CF
C)
‘CC
DC
“C
—C
C)
CCC’
CD
CF
CF
‘<C
CF
C)
CD
C
CD
Ct
CF
j
DC
C)
Page 12 of 14
CD
CF
DC
C-”3’C”,
CD:
Cl
a0ZI-.ft‘a.ftNNN‘4aa•-,‘a.aa(‘1oaaaft-10a‘a.ar-iaa•i-b‘a.ftaa5ftS-çft‘a.0‘a.ft54<aft3o-*t‘-‘3a0ft‘a.aia3a-.Os0Sftaaaott‘toa-IasCo-çrzaaa0044a-Sft•00aftftft-(ft-Iaa3zaa‘0oft•aCa‘a.S0C‘1c-‘a.a5-I00ft‘a.a(ft-I,aaa0aa-çSa0Sa-4‘0aaa-IS0Cft0aftI-.aft‘a.fta57zataoa‘<ftaft‘a.aaaKa-t•5•ftazaI-’z0‘a.0ftz‘a.0seta’a’aa-iaa-(•0-1a70VxH0Hozosa1-çKz‘a.azaa‘.—‘-.‘a.NOa03aa‘a’0aca.zft0azft‘a’aaa‘a’aftaraa-baftraI‘a.a0•I-,‘a.ftO—•-ha0-çbtrKaft•aotftft‘a.a‘a0za‘-.ao0o0z0imfts‘a•‘a.K•ftsaK‘a.a03‘1%ftraa350a1aaft‘a.ft033a-.0ft‘a.•1aaa‘<0‘a.ft‘-SCz•‘a.a•Sata-çC00-Ift‘atz0‘a.0ftaz’safta-I7aftSaa-S‘a.a‘Cft0ft50aaft 0’
a’
N
L’
a
a
ft
S
a
t
a
aft
‘a.
‘a.
o
z
z70
-ç
‘a.
ft
S
-
a
0-I-I
a
-i,
o
oa
aa
•
‘a
a
o
o
C
•
-I
•
a
q
‘<
o
‘-
a
c
a
•
‘a.
‘a.
o a
oft
‘a
o
z
-
-0sai‘a.-aa•<oWbsI’(%__‘o‘a.0ofta0ftzsa-$5ftaaa•-I’zft,.ft35‘a’00‘a•a‘1aft‘a.azr0aft‘a.(S0ftSZ-iaz-$0ft-Stafta.saCaaa-it00’oa011‘Oft70C•5a0(Sftafta-tC%‘.. aftaftstsaa-.aa0aiciizzsazaaS—‘a’oIi0a3r‘a’‘a.a‘a.ft!afta’ftaS1i’aaa5oft0‘a,15aCa‘0‘iaaftaaa‘a.a’aaaoaftaa’0‘.saaftaa‘aa-1K5•oz—0
ft
a
fta
a
agOCtoo0asCt0CtCtaawe.‘.e‘.‘.is.0•CtaU0a‘-.eaCtais’.
is’.
aao
aaoUzoais’.0itaa,-.•o0‘-.30CzzCt•a-b‘-.—a0a0Ct0‘Ca70•c0aaa-i3anaCt ‘‘.0
<
C-1itza30-<•
i—.
‘-.
a is’.
is..
<
z
C
w
is’.
z a
E
‘—‘3
n
a
Ct
o
a a
s
C
Page 13 of 14
-
(t
-c
az
-b
U0Ct0az•‘C-cais-••‘‘.07a•t70Ct53Ct0aI’30-c0aI.’.Cat4a00•a-Iis’.z100a•£0it£UCtIs’.Ct070CIs’.is’.at0es’.aCt.aCa70a0a•%%3‘s’saa oit1Ct3is’.-1z000aUtCa0b.0,..ais’.ais’.a0‘‘.0•3030a0a 7•W-l0aCtiaa3•aaasoa s.z•saa-0
Ct
s
a
,a
a(tflIS70I-.cCa-cOc..—CU•.a<ic3,-.a0CtcaCt70C...weaC‘-.za£at300UzaaCtc.b-’05% aaOis’.eC0Cta0az-c.I•za0is0az1‘05CtI-.a•Cta00-*-*Zis’.0-c1%•3a0’a oaCt-cis.a.
OOsoezt
aoocaao
CtOaa-c
a-co-cs
•a
ao.ac’-cc
ao.ac’-cc
a’s’.
ca
‘-‘t
Ct—Iz
anal..
ae’—oit
b1O37
awe
Is’.
)CCCt
a a
.‘z
asz
a.o asa’-.
Ozoa
Is’.
£
Is’.CtCt
,s’.a
Ct1I-.w.7
sea
Page 14 of 14
Loading citations and judicial treatment…