Karnataka High Court

MFA/21022/2009 of THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER Vs SMT YALLAWWA W/O LAKKAPPA NINGANNAVAR on 16 December 2011

COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT PHARWAD DATED THIS THE tdm DAY OF DECEMBER 2011 f3EFORE THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE K.GOVINDARAJULU M.F.A. No.2 1022 OF 2009 jMV) BETWEEN: THE DiVISiONAL MANAGER, ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD.. DIVISIONAL OFFICE: I(IRLOSKAR ROAD BELGAUM NOW REPRESENTED BY

...)

HciC)C)irnaC)—-C)—aaacici.ciaciciaC)C—rnai.C)9HC)1—--icicc-9aHaaCC)H-HC)Ucici——aC)

ci—

—

—a

—

—a

(

—

lci

Ci—

H-zHaaC)C,HciaC)HHHç‘‘rn?EiacC—HC)—C)—HHaHciHC)aciHC)cC)C)ci0H)ciHaC)PCCC)C)H—aHHciCC)ci.C)HHC)HHaHcici:-)El)C):C)C)-‘UC)aC)U‘Elrm——r—o1aC)C)H—HHCCCCHUC)HU-‘CC)aH—C)HC)•aHHH.C)C)CCUCHH-C)ci—C)CcCC)

HC)—C)—

—

H—

—

ciHH.HcrC)HC)H.HUC)C)Ei.—a,.)o

a..

CDa.

—

ci.

-i

Page 1 of 7

—

C))

2. HciC)1HH—H-C)a.U-aH.1C)C)C)Ur)9)C.C)UC))C)

C))

C)C)/C)C)CDCL-)C)-)C)CLC)C)C)C)C)cC)C)ELC)C)C)-C)C)C)CLC)CLc*C)C)—C)CC)C)—1.C)*C)cC)C)ELC)C)C)-C)C)C)CLC)CLc*C)C)—C)CC)C)—1.C)*C).(C5C)*C)C)C)/..ELEC)ELC)C)ELC)C)_C)C)’9C)C)C)C)C)C)L$2C)ciC)—C)C)_C)C)’9C)C)C)C)C)C)L$2C)ciC)—C).C)_C)C)C),—C)C)CLC)jC)C)-C)—C)(C)C)CL*C)—C)—C—C)C)CLC)-cCLCLC)CC)CL*C)C)—:C)C)aCLC)C)C)CLC)CC)C)C)C)C-rC)aaCC)CLC)C)—C)C),C)C)C)5C)C)C)-C)—C)C)C)(C*a-C—LiC)—NC)—C)-C)C)C)-C)C)C).,,C)C)C)CLc.(C—-C)c_cC)———CLCC—,_—CL—c._C)-**C)CL-CD-—C)C)CLC)jC)C)-C)—C)(C)C)CL*C)—C)—C—C)C)CLC)-cCLCLC)CC)CL*C)C)—:C)C)aCLC)C)C)CLC)CC)C)C)C)C-rC)aaCC)CLC)C)—C)C),C)C)C)5C)C)C)-C)—C)C)C)(C*a-C—LiC)—NC)—C)-C)C)C)-C)C)C).,,C)C)C)CLc.(C—-C)c_cC)———CLCC—,_—CL—c._C)-**C)CL-CD-5*C)c—--aCLCLC)DC)C)C)C)CLC)DCCD..C)CLC)—C)DC)C)C)C)CLC)DCCD..C)CLC)—C)CL...C).-C)C)

—

-CL

—,**

Page 2 of 7

c-S

—,

._ç)

c-c

C)cC)

C)C)C)C)—C)C)C)C)C)C)C)C)C)EL—CL..-C)CL2—C)——C)—C)C)C)—CLC)-CLoC)C)C)CL—CLC)CL-CLoC)C)C)CL—CLC)CLC)C)CLcm..)—C).C)cmC)-cmC)C)..)—C).C)cmC)-cmC)C)C)ELC)C):-C)-C)-C)C):-C)-C)-C)CCCLCLC)(C-CLCLC)aC)C)Cc—C)—-C)C)-CLCL—5*,—-CLCL—5*,—C)DCC).cC)C)C)DC-C)——-C),C)C)—C)C)DC-C)——-C),C)C)—C)C)C)C)

Page 3 of 7

—

,,.—

C)-

C)C)

—>

9).C)9

C)a

.C)

C)aC).C)—C)aC).—9’C))C)9).C)9C)C):cC)9:C)9)C)9’C)cC9C)C)—9•C)9a9C)aC):9C)C).C)C)-i—C)C):9C)C)C)-C)9)‘9C)<N9C)C)9aC).—9’C))C)9).C)9C)C):cC)9:C)9)C)9’C)cC9C)C)—9•C)9a9C)aC):9C)C).C)C)-i—C)C):9C)C)C)-C)9)‘9C)<N9C)C)9C)9)a—9C9cC99)C)C)C)C)C)’aC).aa—C)C)C)C)C)9)9C)C)9)aaaC)C)C):9oaC)•.C)<C)a—C)aC)C)C)C)9)aaaC)C)C):9oaC)•.C)<C)a—C)aC)C)C)C)

<C)

C)a

:9o

CC)

9CC)aC)‘1aaC))999)9--9C):aaC)’N(Cc.C).LC)aC)r’taC)’—C)C).C)aC)aC)9)C)—C)9’9C)‘C)C)C)C)99)aC)9*rNC)aaC)C)C)9.9)9C)C)C)C)9C)999)99)(9-NC)NC)C),C)a999)C)—9)C)—9,(Ca9C)a9C)C)C)C)C)C)C).‘C)CCC)C)‘C)N.C)’‘-C)C)C)’aCC-‘C)—C):9C)C)—C)C)C)—C).Ni))C)(C)‘C)C)C)C)“C)C)(9C).9’C)99)99cmC)C)COC)C)C)9)9,a9’C)c-NC)--C).C)

9’

—

C).

C))

9’

9’—

—

(C)

C:,

0’

C),

9).9:C)—C)C)C)C)C)C)C)C),9’(9C)C)CoC)C)C)N-C)aC)C)o—C)C)C)99C)C:C)—C)C)9’aC)C)C)C)<NaC)C)C)NC)C)C)C)C).—..C)C).<NC),C)C)C)NNaC)C)9a-N9C)Pc-’C)C).co(mC)6.6C)-9,9’

—

r±

—

0S8

8(N

—C)

C)SSPto(N(NS;ta(Na

t(8

3.-

oDt(8)C-3.-p3C)ft(N(Na-00):3-C’j31rj31r(8C)-CL-—C)(N$C)(NtCA)‘55C)9CCC)cC3A’..3(NtCA)‘55C)9CCC)cC3A’..3/8C83Y—3(8<.‘8—CL—(8C5->C’3Y—3(8<.‘8—CL—(8C5->C’C-P-rC’CC’9-p0CC/8p.8P-rC’CC’9-p0CC/8p.8(8(8.-8-1)C’CLA’CL—Cat——CL—Cat——P_‘-C’-‘C’‘—‘——3—‘38CC’

C(83.(NH53-ft-)ThCC$‘-A)—-‘aC)-j3(8S.fCC’CftCC3:3:3(8—$83C’9—((38CA3$3CC——CrCCA”CO

3. t

3. (N

CCCL

(NCt

(NfCt

A-

-L a

CfCo.-

3..

C’

(0%

‘Ci

‘

A’

‘

‘C

(8‘a p

CC<C)

CCD

CDLCD

—

r±

—

0S8

8(N

—C)

C)SSPto(N(NS;ta(Na

t(8

3.-

C(83.(NH53-ft-)ThCC$‘-A)—-‘aC)-j3(8S.fCC’CftCC3:3:3(8—$83C’9—((38CA3$3CC——CrCCA”CO

3. t

3. (N

CCCL

(NCt

(NfCt

A-

-L a

CfCo.-

3..

C’

(0%

‘Ci

‘

A’

‘

‘C

(8‘a p

CC<C)

CCD

Page 4 of 7

CDLCD

CDLCDCD”co3)CL3)CLCDCDCCDCC<C)CDHi’DCCD‘C.‘H-”CD5,CD’ccCD•CDHiDC9(C)CDemLHeDH--‘C)CDH>cC)CD(CHHic-emCD’HeDCCD‘C.‘H-”CD5,CD’ccCD•CDHiDC9(C)CDemLHeDH--‘C)CDH>cC)CD(CHHic-emCD’HeH-iHHeDCHeDCCLCDCDH-cc’CD’-EL9ELHi”CDCDCDCD9CDCC2CD—DCHHi’crm9<CD‘CD”CDCDHi9CD‘ELCD(He<HHi’Her>Hi’——tHecr5CD<—CCH>CC—DC(H)tHic)’CDDC“—CDCDemCDCL’HHH-3)CDH-”CDCD-EL9ELHi”CDCDCDCD9CDCC2CD—DCHHi’crm9<CD‘CD”CDCDHi9CD‘ELCD(He<HHi’Her>Hi’——tHecr5CD<—CCH>CC—DC(H)tHic)’CDDC“—CDCDemCDCL’HHH-3)CDH-”CDCDH-H)CL<33CDC)CD—CDH9m“CC)CDCDCDH-’H-(CDCDH-)DCCD9’(Hecr<<(4HiH-Cc,CDCL3HH-CD)DCCDemCD(CDCDCCem)CDCDCL(((3CD‘CDCD.CD—Hi’r<(C5)tELCD)<HiSHeCDCDH‘CC“HH’CDCDCLCDem<CCDH’‘H5ELL5HZDC-iHHeH”HiHeem(HCDem—H’)CDCD>CLH-,.CC‘H-HiCDCDH)CCem‘“<‘H—(HCDHe‘ELemF,“CD)—‘CDFcCiiH<F‘‘CD’<‘H—emHi.ccemHeCD’CD’CD’—CDH—‘CD(C‘He)H-’H-CDH-‘CCc’em‘(4HiH-Cc,CDCL3HH-CD)DCCDemCD(CDCDCCem)CDCDCL(((3CD‘CDCD.CD—Hi’r<(C5)tELCD)<HiSHeCDCDH‘CC“HH’CDCDCLCDem<CCDH’‘H5ELL5HZDC-iHHeH”HiHeem(HCDem—H’)CDCD>CLH-,.CC‘H-HiCDCDH)CCem‘“<‘H—(HCDHe‘ELemF,“CD)—‘CDFcCiiH<F‘‘CD’<‘H—emHi.ccemHeCD’CD’CD’—CDH—‘CD(C‘He)H-’H-CDH-‘CCc’em‘

‘CD

(CD

C)’

r>CC

(CD

em—

5H-

H-

rrn

—

(‘Hi

He’

CD’

—He

<C’

(CD

H-

‘H)

CD”.

—CD’

-i

H-’

CC’

5DC

Hi’

CD’

,,)

H-’

—‘

Hi’

DC’

(Hi

—

<3)—

‘<

CD)

(‘H

“

‘

<EL

H-’

Page 5 of 7

CD*

<“H

CD”

(CD

(

H-

—‘

H-

“<C

CDH

cccCD’ELtHe’CD—(CDH-CDem5)()9HHCDDCHi’5CDELCL‘CDCD5’<H<H-cccFCi<9CDHiH))CDH-—‘CD’C:CDCDHe)JiH-—H’‘H-HeciHi’(5(9H-CD5)‘,CD’49CDemCD—7CDHe5)’CD)H-CDHi’DC’CDC”Cr:’CD9CD”CLHe’He<H-7He.CDCD.em—“CmHe<3”‘H-CDC>ePtHe’(CDICCCDCDemCDtHeCCDemH-’“He-.CDHi’—‘C’,Heemem(5<(CDCDCDH—‘CDHeE.FDC—H”emCC’CDCD’—DCCDHiH-”(5ememCDCD’CLCL

3?)

3/?

(3?

:3—-

3’)o:3—-—i1133/2”3?)(331311)3(333:3—31,(3em331)311)1:3em3).1/)3)31([(3emEemem,i,-N3/)(3/-‘E0E—/23?)331.:3(3(3313/):31‘1:3:31n1))3—(3?o‘emmmemf1)33em:3:33)0)$3)1:3mm:3:):3remE—c:3-ememem:3Hr3131:311(3—emem33)mm(3?ema:3:3mm32;(33)3m(3)/2)31)3)..31(3em—LIrememem313331emem’()3)LI0)LI’emL,:3:3em3/20’31:3.mm(I)(:3$3):3(1)LI(33:

rem.

$-em

“-

“

1)2;

3?)

—.

/2)

$1)

1)2;.

(

(3?-

em’

em—,

‘3?

:3:,,

‘

-‘

‘

rem

‘33

31mmem“a

(333,em rem

3/)

,,,,‘

$33333,rem.

3) :3

(

$3)

313/

33’

e-em

emem

31:3:31)33:3:3em

3’)

,‘335

1)2;:

:3:3

“r

Page 6 of 7

LI-I(Th31“:31:3mem,—(3mm(3)mm—J:3:33(3mm:3(3LI:333111(33)(3)

“3

333/

em1)3’

emrem.emmmem0:3331)::3:3:31)33(3:33?:).:33’)em333(3)3?):3333)(3031r3?:$1)(1)mm(3)(3—(/)3:r-%.em(3)11):33:1):3mm:33.3)em:3)$1)1)33(3).(-,:3,0)/2)mmememLILI:3emrem;,[em]:3(/2/2-,332’em(/:3—(3’‘I(‘31:3emLI‘mm3)-LI:3.,ememem3333“1)2;1)1)(:3)3)r’m.0:).mm3:3(3)3))eN-3)1-’mm:3(‘/2‘(3,/2:3emmmmm3:3/c)emLI.(3)(1)

—4.

12i

—

9292cf—04—4cxQ1)—(9C)-C)C)—0.=C)C)j.92(C(CE0jC)C)-(9(Cj.(C(IC(I(IC(C)(9.C),C)(C

—

Page 7 of 7

Loading citations and judicial treatment…