Karnataka High Court
RFA/91/2002 of SARASAWWA @ SARASWATI W/O GUNDAPPA UPADHYA Vs SUNDARABAI W/O NEMINATH UPADHYA on 16 December 2010
I IN THE WOE COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT DEARWAD DATED THIS TEE 16’ DAY OF DECEMBER, 2010 BEFORE TUE HON’BLE MR JUSTICE V 0 SABUAHIT R F A No.91/2002 BETWEEN MT S R A A 3 i SARAS A N APIA P)HY ?C IA C Jo SFH Z )(TSN(6I MATICA FI(AU F A DY SRI A HOK I I YAN’\ F 11\ AD
CD
Cj3(123CD13CCC—CDICDI3Ct3CCDCDIC1I3)a
Cl
Cl4—4--
j
/
C
C
4-I
I
r
Q
I
CD
3)I
C
-CD
-CD
-
[I]-
C
CD
I
I
I
CD
I
CD
CD
CD
C’
I
C
Cl
C
j
=4—
CDIçjqICD333(1CDçjqICD333(1CDC)I33C333)CDC333)CD441—CD—CD4—.ClCD(1cc—(144CD(1cc—(144oeJo444)0ClC)CDClC)CDC—Cl3)ClCDQ--4:CIDCDCDL(:1ICC)CDCDCl4444ClClCD-/444-I34CDQ--4:CIDCDCDL(:1ICC)CDCDCl4444ClClCD-/444-I34
CDCD2)I92H0502*i0005-CD<‘I050)CDCD262—-2)5<0CDCD10<026)
LI10or(102)CO1**IorCDCDI
2)5
i
<0
<
.
2)5
<0
—
-
—
Q—
C)
CD
CD
))
b
CL
<0
JO
CD
CD
*
I
Ic
CD
‘
CD
or
CD
CD
I
C
CD
CO
CD
CD
CD
<0
LI
CD
1CCDoro—CDCDCD(1O-or102)C)+jorCDorCDCDSC)02CD005-CDL)(CD(1)CD2)00orCDp0502Hor02CD<02)CDCorCDCD02)0)05or40)p*<0262)10CDpIIorC—/<0C)ILICDL)
cc1ccC)-CDC)ciIdclCD•CD1IC3C)ciC)CDCIiciCDciciCDccC)cc;C)C)C)CD-IC)ciciCDCciHP1cciccciCDIci3CD11dclC)*cifciICDIC)CDItci cccCD
ci
C)
ci
C
C)
ci
-CD
-CD
cia
C
I
cci
CD
*1
Dii
-I
C)
I
ci
C)I
C)
-ci
ci
I
I
1I
Di)
C)
I!
)
ci
—
Cl
C
C)
CD
C
:1
C)
C)
ci
ci
f
CD
CD
:5
ci
C)
ci
-
CD
C)
cci
CD
ci
CDI
cc4’P&:ci:tciIC):rC)r‘DCDCDciIDC)Iccci:tciIC):rC)r‘DCDCDciIDC)IccciDC)CD‘DiJcici)ciccC)‘DiCD‘DiJcici)ciccC)‘DiaIciIci1C)C)ciC)CDciciIci1C)C)ciC)CDci-4’C)(1cCC)ciC)C)CDCC)ciC)C)CDC)ciaI—CD4’CDccICDcc(ccCD-jcc(I/aI—CD4’CDccICDcc(ccCD-jcc(I/CDCci:iZ‘C2cDci:iZ‘C2cD
CfCf2222—2()ciLJ20?0Cf(C))20I,1)(0(IC1)(22-9:.ci(0+Cf(0CfII-12c.ci21(021‘(2D(2(CaC212IC(2(2
I
fr
Cl
- ci ci
-
(i
-
C))
C))
a
(L
ci
(C)
ci
(Cf
Cf
Cf ci
Ci
ci
IC
ci
C
H
C
r+
(CC
ci
—
JO
C
H
(C)
ci
Cf2ci02ci(C)0ici0(Cf9)2czC)ci2(2r0)(1—-)202—CI(2C)C)-C(2ci(2—30(0—Cfci((I(2(2—Cf11ciçt,-(09(Cf-+0ci0(IC)-(CCTj-ciC(227cip2CCtJ2222
(C)
*ci43Li-icici:3oci,-ci-rriI(39-a43cci3)31pcifr-I10ci,103)Ci-(/24--9‘ci-‘ciIfr—_Ici3)IcJcciUQci,f0a3)1cci(ci9—ci,cc-,ci’(ICDcciI—‘-34-(39--cci-9(:3:3(-ci-24-3,13’cici :30
ci
ci
ci
0I
I
p)
fr
ci
ci
_3
ci
3)3
ci
-I
ti
.4
)
cci
-f
I
J
cci
cci
—
-J
(ci
o
-4,
:3
-ci
-
(ci
I
ci
I
cci
cc
4Th
cci
I
cc
cif
ci
Ic
Ici15’:3-ci0aI—‘-ci-4-’Cl-4Icir-cc-ciC(ci_fr)acc(cicciciCccci-4439-1-2‘-I-Dj-313-4(I‘-19-444-I-’4-I:310-4-cciC,-4cc-’-cci-4cc00j-‘4—t‘ciciIcc)-4-(/2II(ci-ci3’-fcc—tccij-Ja‘TI—II109-I—‘4ci,-4(ci3)1-4/II:3cicicjcia, a 0‘-3a8WID’0IaI-.)-‘
I
rtp
tCD
CD
WI
WI
CD
CD
w
5’
CD
9.
CD
a0t
‘‘0
S
pa
CD
0Cl)
g
CD0
•gWI
—.
CDapa
c-fl
pa
papat
CD
s
I-a
I-’
pa
‘0a’a
iCD0
a.
CD‘a
S
Uhfk)WI4*CDCD)CD‘•CDWICDCDpaiaPaQQI’)4*fta..,to2.a.
>1‘0
-0(tCD:3cr(-)H-o:3ci):i:3j01iDzCj:3
ci)
-
C
ci)
(
C
z
-
a
f—,—
f—,—
C
Page 1 of 5
t
:31
:3
:3
Cr
p:
:3)
J
C
CD3—1):3—:30--ci)1)2:313ci)i)))c:33rCii)—-2:2cccci-2-CC3:313CI13-3CC--Cr-LII)——313-2C2313,jH13-ir-1313i)CDCD—cc)‘-C13Cci)CcC)—1-+z -0ca0C)0aCD0Wa.C)
0Go
WI010artbWa.WICDB’8ommpaaCDzCD0‘0aCD-CDIpn—a B’8ommpaa Wg CD
trat
q
:“
1CD
am
-.-%(.4)——
t1
CDCD—aaaCD—aaa—C’)p‘0
a
-,3C)C)ITiC)?ITiC)C)ITiC)?ITiCTi—CIICLiTi—C)CC3CCICC-—3C)(ITiCTiCCTicCCTiIjLiTi—CIICLiTi—C)CC3CCICC-—3C)(ITiCTiCCTicCCTiIjLiTi r Ti
C)
C
Ti*
*
I
Ti
-
Ti
C)
C)
C
—
I2
Page 2 of 5
Ti
I
C
C
C
Ti
I
r
+
C)
Ti
Li2-3IC—33IC—33)2TiC)ITiLI3C—CC)ITiLI3C—CçìLiC)IIC)II—Ti1jIICQCCLiC)CI1jIICQCCLiC)CILIIfIIICCfIIICC—LICTiC)2TiTiC)2TiTiCC)-HILSII-TiII-TiCCoCCCTi-jC)—C—C)ITiCCTiC)CC-C)CCITiCCTiC)CC-C)CC
Ti
C
I
LI
I
“2
-
Ti
Ti
C-C)
:53):5a):5a)‘3:5‘33—÷r’33D:5333‘3CD-5I:5C3’:53)‘33,(5‘33(3)C)3I‘3):3iJ3‘3,:5C1Z’(3):33“*(I,“3:5“53)3)‘-—(1CCD::i‘33rt:5:5C3)‘3CD—t1ID+‘3’:5_5(5(I:5‘3:5‘3CDCDCCD
CDa_5
CD
:5
_5
Ct)
I
:5
3D
:3
-
:5—
—
T
)
(it)
I
:5
:
1) )
:5
‘3
CC
Q
‘-
5:5:5
‘33
Ct)
:5
S
‘)
-
:3’
C
:5
‘3
‘3:3
S
iS
:5-
Ct
C
CC-
r
Ti
C)
C
Ti*
*
I
Ti
-
Ti
C)
C)
C
—
I2
Page 3 of 5
Ti
I
C
C
C
Ti
I
r
+
C)
Ti
Li2-3IC—33IC—33)2TiC)ITiLI3C—CC)ITiLI3C—CçìLiC)IIC)II—Ti1jIICQCCLiC)CI1jIICQCCLiC)CILIIfIIICCfIIICC—LICTiC)2TiTiC)2TiTiCC)-HILSII-TiII-TiCCoCCCTi-jC)—C—C)ITiCCTiC)CC-C)CCITiCCTiC)CC-C)CC
Ti
C
I
LI
I
“2
-
Ti
Ti
C-C)
:53):5a):5a)‘3:5‘33—÷r’33D:5333‘3CD-5I:5C3’:53)‘33,(5‘33(3)C)3I‘3):3iJ3‘3,:5C1Z’(3):33“*(I,“3:5“53)3)‘-—(1CCD::i‘33rt:5:5C3)‘3CD—t1ID+‘3’:5_5(5(I:5‘3:5‘3CDCDCCD
CDa_5
CD
:5
_5
Ct)
I
:5
3D
:3
-
:5—
—
T
)
(it) I
:5
:
1) )
:5
‘3
CC
Q
‘-
5:5:5
‘33
Ct)
:5
S
‘)
-
:3’
C
:5
‘3
‘3:3
S
iS
:5-
Ct
C
CC-
:5E?’-1:5C:5-“15f:55’:5CD:5‘5‘_‘t-5C-Ct):5-:5(2C::5(3-3(3)I5‘3-HCD:5‘3:5—t‘I3)—(3:55Cl35:5:33:5CDCC)‘5:3—C)-‘t(21‘:53)ICDC2:5‘3:5)Cl9:5-:5(I:53))SCD9‘3CD—-t,:5‘_tC,3(3)—3))1’C-530
a20—ci,CciCr<ci0g9 iaCD—CL:Z-cioci)3a9—flTNCjc9CD_—“Nt—T-—CD—c-CNSNJrCDCTN,ci0CtCD—CD-Zci—•.TNT——.ccTNtciC—CDCD0ciC2—TN-ccCD——-C;CCTNTHH•CHCrECct225cCID-t-iC2C)
H
ID
—
2_,
_,
cc;
CD
S.
Z2TNtrt—-0—*oCT—JrTciH.t-:4TCDt91.TNt$j)CD0rtcicCCC)ciHCCci -3_)-IcL(tc)+—j(0(1-I4(0C3.34?IIj—CDC3+CD.-C(0C;.13.4C131334rr, I
I
L
Ci
4’
C
-
CD
+
C;
-
-
.4
::r
J
I
4’
I
C)
iD
4?
C
C
0.4.443,CD
IQI0
(0:;1
3,CI—.333I$3’C-3.(3-4IDC(013$33$33)(3(0(0$$3)1313(03C)-43$(3CC)J2$3)(03./(04-Cf -‘K“t0.1“t0.11S1-;Sw41’.1’3I?..411’.CD1-;Sw41’.1’3I?..411’.CDlSOi•1.4“I‘I—.41,,Oi•1.4“I‘I—.41,,0)4,;a.44a‘I•a‘..,—a.44a‘I•a‘..,—C,i0*CD10aEJ*CD10aEJ
:
“‘-‘.44•°‘‘a0—Ot0)ItP.a——0..‘2•.4131T.4.1a‘0StC10)“1W1CD2co- ‘- n
)
C’.
-%
—
.?
0)53
‘JO
!
;
..
CL
)
3.4as’.1as’.1
Page 4 of 5
a.
.
a
a
..
ttio
PDCDci(i‘ciCtC>CtciaC1ci.tcittiooctciiCDciCCt•C:rCtrtCD-1CCDdCrCDC2R?UQciCDciCD)-ci—€ci0CD$nn(/2:ciencici/2cicicicicici=g--———/2:9)0(4/2Crt2*ci.enCDenen44/2a4D7aci:—en(4-”*ci1.1-jen”.Cren—C..—sen-(/2enn-ici.CrCD—0“CD.—NC.eCDci-“/2-4cicici/2ci—grmen-iciunci..Cci-“CDenCDciCDenC.‘cienci9%ti0ciciencici-“CDci49ci:oitciCDen-CDCDciit-.C-.0en0ciCcici440ciSa05ciciCDaenaCciciCtcicicici ..
—
ci en/2
en/2
CD
ci
<
en
—
CD
Cci0cicicici.CDCDC.rtCrt—3rCciCDD.CDCDCCDCDciCD-en——ci.—ci0enciciZC—rt.CDCDcien1*sen“.—çen—ciCt2C9ci$.en/2en÷—0cienCD(4-i—CDp5ci.—cien2ci09/2:._rt.ciciCCCD—ci.0aci.enCrC<0CDC”cici—C<PS”=en-aencicicici2CC
ci
t
Ct
ç
-i
ci
“
C
i
CD
—CD
ci
en
0..
-en
CD
it
ci
C
Ct
ci
Page 5 of 5
Loading citations and judicial treatment…