Karnataka High Court

RFA/91/2002 of SARASAWWA @ SARASWATI W/O GUNDAPPA UPADHYA Vs SUNDARABAI W/O NEMINATH UPADHYA on 16 December 2010

I IN THE WOE COURT OF KARNATAKA CIRCUIT BENCH AT DEARWAD DATED THIS TEE 16’ DAY OF DECEMBER, 2010 BEFORE TUE HON’BLE MR JUSTICE V 0 SABUAHIT R F A No.91/2002 BETWEEN MT S R A A 3 i SARAS A N APIA P)HY ?C IA C Jo SFH Z )(TSN(6I MATICA FI(AU F A DY SRI A HOK I I YAN’\ F 11\ AD

CD

Cj3(123CD13CCC—CDICDI3Ct3CCDCDIC1I3)a

Cl

Cl4—4--

j

/

C

C

4-I

I

r

Q

I

CD

3)I

C

-CD

-CD

-

[I]-

C

CD

I

I

I

CD

I

CD

CD

CD

C’

I

C

Cl

C

j

=4—

CDIçjqICD333(1CDçjqICD333(1CDC)I33C333)CDC333)CD441—CD—CD4—.ClCD(1cc—(144CD(1cc—(144oeJo444)0ClC)CDClC)CDC—Cl3)ClCDQ--4:CIDCDCDL(:1ICC)CDCDCl4444ClClCD-/444-I34CDQ--4:CIDCDCDL(:1ICC)CDCDCl4444ClClCD-/444-I34

CDCD2)I92H0502*i0005-CD<‘I050)CDCD262—-2)5<0CDCD10<026)

LI10or(102)CO1**IorCDCDI

2)5

i

<0

<

.

2)5

<0

—

-

—

Q—

C)

CD

CD

))

b

CL

<0

JO

CD

CD

*

I

Ic

CD

‘

CD

or

CD

CD

I

C

CD

CO

CD

CD

CD

<0

LI

CD

1CCDoro—CDCDCD(1O-or102)C)+jorCDorCDCDSC)02CD005-CDL)(CD(1)CD2)00orCDp0502Hor02CD<02)CDCorCDCD02)0)05or40)p*<0262)10CDpIIorC—/<0C)ILICDL)

cc1ccC)-CDC)ciIdclCD•CD1IC3C)ciC)CDCIiciCDciciCDccC)cc;C)C)C)CD-IC)ciciCDCciHP1cciccciCDIci3CD11dclC)*cifciICDIC)CDItci cccCD

ci

C)

ci

C

C)

ci

-CD

-CD

cia

C

I

cci

CD

*1

Dii

-I

C)

I

ci

C)I

C)

-ci

ci

I

I

1I

Di)

C)

I!

)

ci

—

Cl

C

C)

CD

C

:1

C)

C)

ci

ci

f

CD

CD

:5

ci

C)

ci

-

CD

C)

cci

CD

ci

CDI

cc4’P&:ci:tciIC):rC)r‘DCDCDciIDC)Iccci:tciIC):rC)r‘DCDCDciIDC)IccciDC)CD‘DiJcici)ciccC)‘DiCD‘DiJcici)ciccC)‘DiaIciIci1C)C)ciC)CDciciIci1C)C)ciC)CDci-4’C)(1cCC)ciC)C)CDCC)ciC)C)CDC)ciaI—CD4’CDccICDcc(ccCD-jcc(I/aI—CD4’CDccICDcc(ccCD-jcc(I/CDCci:iZ‘C2cDci:iZ‘C2cD

CfCf2222—2()ciLJ20?0Cf(C))20I,1)(0(IC1)(22-9:.ci(0+Cf(0CfII-12c.ci21(021‘(2D(2(CaC212IC(2(2

I

fr

Cl

- ci ci

-

(i

-

C))

C))

a

(L

ci

(C)

ci

(Cf

Cf

Cf ci

Ci

ci

IC

ci

C

H

C

r+

(CC

ci

—

JO

C

H

(C)

ci

Cf2ci02ci(C)0ici0(Cf9)2czC)ci2(2r0)(1—-)202—CI(2C)C)-C(2ci(2—30(0—Cfci((I(2(2—Cf11ciçt,-(09(Cf-+0ci0(IC)-(CCTj-ciC(227cip2CCtJ2222

(C)

*ci43Li-icici:3oci,-ci-rriI(39-a43cci3)31pcifr-I10ci,103)Ci-(/24--9‘ci-‘ciIfr—_Ici3)IcJcciUQci,f0a3)1cci(ci9—ci,cc-,ci’(ICDcciI—‘-34-(39--cci-9(:3:3(-ci-24-3,13’cici :30

ci

ci

ci

0I

I

p)

fr

ci

ci

_3

ci

3)3

ci

-I

ti

.4

)

cci

-f

I

J

cci

cci

—

-J

(ci

o

-4,

:3

-ci

-

(ci

I

ci

I

cci

cc

4Th

cci

I

cc

cif

ci

Ic

Ici15’:3-ci0aI—‘-ci-4-’Cl-4Icir-cc-ciC(ci_fr)acc(cicciciCccci-4439-1-2‘-I-Dj-313-4(I‘-19-444-I-’4-I:310-4-cciC,-4cc-’-cci-4cc00j-‘4—t‘ciciIcc)-4-(/2II(ci-ci3’-fcc—tccij-Ja‘TI—II109-I—‘4ci,-4(ci3)1-4/II:3cicicjcia, a 0‘-3a8WID’0IaI-.)-‘

I

rtp

tCD

CD

WI

WI

CD

CD

w

5’

CD

9.

CD

a0t

‘‘0

S

pa

CD

0Cl)

g

CD0

•gWI

—.

CDapa

c-fl

pa

papat

CD

s

I-a

I-’

pa

‘0a’a

iCD0

a.

CD‘a

S

Uhfk)WI4*CDCD)CD‘•CDWICDCDpaiaPaQQI’)4*fta..,to2.a.

>1‘0

-0(tCD:3cr(-)H-o:3ci):i:3j01iDzCj:3

ci)

-

C

ci)

(

C

z

-

a

f—,—

f—,—

C

Page 1 of 5

t

:31

:3

:3

Cr

p:

:3)

J

C

CD3—1):3—:30--ci)1)2:313ci)i)))c:33rCii)—-2:2cccci-2-CC3:313CI13-3CC--Cr-LII)——313-2C2313,jH13-ir-1313i)CDCD—cc)‘-C13Cci)CcC)—1-+z -0ca0C)0aCD0Wa.C)

0Go

WI010artbWa.WICDB’8ommpaaCDzCD0‘0aCD-CDIpn—a B’8ommpaa Wg CD

trat

q

:“

1CD

am

-.-%(.4)——

t1

CDCD—aaaCD—aaa—C’)p‘0

a

-,3C)C)ITiC)?ITiC)C)ITiC)?ITiCTi—CIICLiTi—C)CC3CCICC-—3C)(ITiCTiCCTicCCTiIjLiTi—CIICLiTi—C)CC3CCICC-—3C)(ITiCTiCCTicCCTiIjLiTi r Ti

C)

C

Ti*

*

I

Ti

-

Ti

C)

C)

C

—

I2

Page 2 of 5

Ti

I

C

C

C

Ti

I

r

+

C)

Ti

Li2-3IC—33IC—33)2TiC)ITiLI3C—CC)ITiLI3C—CçìLiC)IIC)II—Ti1jIICQCCLiC)CI1jIICQCCLiC)CILIIfIIICCfIIICC—LICTiC)2TiTiC)2TiTiCC)-HILSII-TiII-TiCCoCCCTi-jC)—C—C)ITiCCTiC)CC-C)CCITiCCTiC)CC-C)CC

Ti

C

I

LI

I

“2

-

Ti

Ti

C-C)

:53):5a):5a)‘3:5‘33—÷r’33D:5333‘3CD-5I:5C3’:53)‘33,(5‘33(3)C)3I‘3):3iJ3‘3,:5C1Z’(3):33“*(I,“3:5“53)3)‘-—(1CCD::i‘33rt:5:5C3)‘3CD—t1ID+‘3’:5_5(5(I:5‘3:5‘3CDCDCCD

CDa_5

CD

:5

_5

Ct)

I

:5

3D

:3

-

:5—

—

T

)

(it)

I

:5

:

1) )

:5

‘3

CC

Q

‘-

5:5:5

‘33

Ct)

:5

S

‘)

-

:3’

C

:5

‘3

‘3:3

S

iS

:5-

Ct

C

CC-

r

Ti

C)

C

Ti*

*

I

Ti

-

Ti

C)

C)

C

—

I2

Page 3 of 5

Ti

I

C

C

C

Ti

I

r

+

C)

Ti

Li2-3IC—33IC—33)2TiC)ITiLI3C—CC)ITiLI3C—CçìLiC)IIC)II—Ti1jIICQCCLiC)CI1jIICQCCLiC)CILIIfIIICCfIIICC—LICTiC)2TiTiC)2TiTiCC)-HILSII-TiII-TiCCoCCCTi-jC)—C—C)ITiCCTiC)CC-C)CCITiCCTiC)CC-C)CC

Ti

C

I

LI

I

“2

-

Ti

Ti

C-C)

:53):5a):5a)‘3:5‘33—÷r’33D:5333‘3CD-5I:5C3’:53)‘33,(5‘33(3)C)3I‘3):3iJ3‘3,:5C1Z’(3):33“*(I,“3:5“53)3)‘-—(1CCD::i‘33rt:5:5C3)‘3CD—t1ID+‘3’:5_5(5(I:5‘3:5‘3CDCDCCD

CDa_5

CD

:5

_5

Ct)

I

:5

3D

:3

-

:5—

—

T

)

(it) I

:5

:

1) )

:5

‘3

CC

Q

‘-

5:5:5

‘33

Ct)

:5

S

‘)

-

:3’

C

:5

‘3

‘3:3

S

iS

:5-

Ct

C

CC-

:5E?’-1:5C:5-“15f:55’:5CD:5‘5‘_‘t-5C-Ct):5-:5(2C::5(3-3(3)I5‘3-HCD:5‘3:5—t‘I3)—(3:55Cl35:5:33:5CDCC)‘5:3—C)-‘t(21‘:53)ICDC2:5‘3:5)Cl9:5-:5(I:53))SCD9‘3CD—-t,:5‘_tC,3(3)—3))1’C-530

a20—ci,CciCr<ci0g9 iaCD—CL:Z-cioci)3a9—flTNCjc9CD_—“Nt—T-—CD—c-CNSNJrCDCTN,ci0CtCD—CD-Zci—•.TNT——.ccTNtciC—CDCD0ciC2—TN-ccCD——-C;CCTNTHH•CHCrECct225cCID-t-iC2C)

H

ID

—

2_,

_,

cc;

CD

S.

Z2TNtrt—-0—*oCT—JrTciH.t-:4TCDt91.TNt$j)CD0rtcicCCC)ciHCCci -3_)-IcL(tc)+—j(0(1-I4(0C3.34?IIj—CDC3+CD.-C(0C;.13.4C131334rr, I

I

L

Ci

4’

C

-

CD

+

C;

-

-

.4

::r

J

I

4’

I

C)

iD

4?

C

C

0.4.443,CD

IQI0

(0:;1

3,CI—.333I$3’C-3.(3-4IDC(013$33$33)(3(0(0$$3)1313(03C)-43$(3CC)J2$3)(03./(04-Cf -‘K“t0.1“t0.11S1-;Sw41’.1’3I?..411’.CD1-;Sw41’.1’3I?..411’.CDlSOi•1.4“I‘I—.41,,Oi•1.4“I‘I—.41,,0)4,;a.44a‘I•a‘..,—a.44a‘I•a‘..,—C,i0*CD10aEJ*CD10aEJ

:

“‘-‘.44•°‘‘a0—Ot0)ItP.a——0..‘2•.4131T.4.1a‘0StC10)“1W1CD2co- ‘- n

)

C’.

-%

—

.?

0)53

‘JO

!

;

..

CL

)

3.4as’.1as’.1

Page 4 of 5

a.

.

a

a

..

ttio

PDCDci(i‘ciCtC>CtciaC1ci.tcittiooctciiCDciCCt•C:rCtrtCD-1CCDdCrCDC2R?UQciCDciCD)-ci—€ci0CD$nn(/2:ciencici/2cicicicicici=g--———/2:9)0(4/2Crt2*ci.enCDenen44/2a4D7aci:—en(4-”*ci1.1-jen”.Cren—C..—sen-(/2enn-ici.CrCD—0“CD.—NC.eCDci-“/2-4cicici/2ci—grmen-iciunci..Cci-“CDenCDciCDenC.‘cienci9%ti0ciciencici-“CDci49ci:oitciCDen-CDCDciit-.C-.0en0ciCcici440ciSa05ciciCDaenaCciciCtcicicici ..

—

ci en/2

en/2

CD

ci

<

en

—

CD

Cci0cicicici.CDCDC.rtCrt—3rCciCDD.CDCDCCDCDciCD-en——ci.—ci0enciciZC—rt.CDCDcien1*sen“.—çen—ciCt2C9ci$.en/2en÷—0cienCD(4-i—CDp5ci.—cien2ci09/2:._rt.ciciCCCD—ci.0aci.enCrC<0CDC”cici—C<PS”=en-aencicicici2CC

ci

t

Ct

ç

-i

ci

“

C

i

CD

—CD

ci

en

0..

-en

CD

it

ci

C

Ct

ci

Page 5 of 5

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead