Karnataka High Court
WP/12081/1998 of MGMT.,MAHARAJA RESIDENTIAL MUSEUM,MYSORE Vs SWAMY & ANR on 19 October 1998
11 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BANGALORE DATED THIS THE 19TH DAY OF OCTOBER 1998 BEFORE : THE HON’BLE MR.JUSTICE YGOPALA GOWDA WRIT PETITION No.12081 & 12082 OF 1998 CONNECTED WITH WRIT PETITION NOS.25762 & 25763 OF 1998 Btwnn I. IF i t 1 a V I •4r : ‘1 • ./
I
a
a
A,
-—C
C
-9-C—d((phII.pA-C4
4.dS
V
A$a
S
(
$
I
I
(3noftzi-’C-sx13xa-f(3(3(1(UF”CC)C0Cx(tZr“CCl1ift3))(s(0(5(0F”C)(1(U053-51330)(3(3)3)(3(3ftCC(3((3CCF”iaC:0)F”,-“sft(530)oQftaF”333)(3)4)(3aaosaaaa ((3
UtZr1313o
F
1t
—:
((3
F”
D
rtz
ft
a
osaa ft(UF”1)(0(\)0(3C::53(“1C)(3aft0)..F”ft(3)ft(5.(3C:00ft00)0)ft‘(0(303CC0)ftftHø.ftC)(OCU0(3F”(5:rF”CZr(1(3(3)5)ftfta0)0(3)ft3(UaC33ZrZraC0•a(0F”0)C)3(05)(3aftCCCift(33)334.(5.ftft®(0-4)—(500)ftft(C(I)a(0Zr0•C:-‘(3—(3—F”aC)0)(3ft0((0ft0(0zftaio0“CF”(0ZrC(3)ft0(5’0Cft0)ftC)1Cftft(00)33ftCZr:UaF”(5:Zrft(0C)ftC)a:o(U(U0Zraift(5C)(3ftF”C)Zra13rt(3-(5(5ZrC)CaaaZr0)ft0)Zr(U33(5ft(5):3—5F”—(5ftF”a(3F”•C’4”Caft(-40ft(5o.(33C’aaZr(3)C):3ft33)ft0)-(13‘3((33)4>oaF”-(50C3-CCC:3)0ftftfta3-5F”(5)(4))a:3<(34)-4)3CF”053(U43)a-ca-“(3(4)•ftF”33):3ft.‘3)C1)3(30)(5F”353(UF”CF”ft0ft(U3:F”ftF”0Zr0CF”ftaaZr0F”F”—:130)0(U(3.0)(U(3C)CC)C)3C:ft0)‘ft:3(04”ft(3C)(0ft3))F”(U(3(3).(5)C(3)4)ft(3F”ftt,C)a55:3)o(5ftZrC)“:rC(3—hftF”9.(5((3F”‘(0-1CC)o3(5).1353CC>-5_,ftC(95at(1)(3)F”F”(5ftft:3CC)(UF”zZrZrft:3C)C))0aoftac,ftC)(U‘CC)C)—bC)(0(33:3ftSC(33>ftF”ft•C)(4))(3ftF.”ftftft0003C-50:Zr510ZrftZrZrZrF”ftft(0ft‘(0aCft3irCC)(4)53
H
:r
—(0
—(0
ftZra
C)
o
C
a- a
(3.
ftC):roCF”a
(U
C
a
z
ft
(U
ft
Zr
(U
(U
—
(a a
a
‘(0
ft
Zr
a
.))
a
C:
:3
a
3))
ft
F”
C
((3
F”
F”
Zr
((3
-i
(4))
(
C:
ft
Zr
C)
1) )
ft
F”
Ut
F”
-)
C)
F”
ft
Zr
C)
F”
ft
F.”
ft
(U
(4) )
—ft
—ft
(U
:3
a
ft
Zr
C
>>
(U
3)0)0)(54(Iz a13 013CC(5)Zr‘<o Cl Clft.(5) C) ((1Zr(3•IC30 (C(5(31 C) N)F”C53((3aC’ 33 (3)(U(3PC F” F”-5(C(-1)C’ 2()C)(53aia0C(0-C0(UC(3F”—.C(‘C‘0U(33.(5)Caft)CCwF”00)ft.1313(:(a(U0)0)F”F”‘53(U((3F”C:0(3.ft.C)(Y((3ftZrF”(4))0:F”-“53.(U(9
CDDo“C3.CD
CD
it
CTCDC))H’
Page 1 of 6
CCCDCoCLH’C)CDH’CCDHoCDCDH’0)CDCI)H’CO-C,CDCDH
CCDH”C)CDCD’CC)3CCC)‘C)çtCTCDCoitH”H’C:’C’çtCTCDC)“toH’CCDC)CDH”CDCL)3CTCD‘43CC)DLH’C’CD3CD,,CDCDCLft.CCCDH’CDH’CDitCDDox:DoC’)CD.:“CCTCitC)C’)CLH’CDH’0)CLCC)CDit5CD:Co.CTDoItDoDLCTDLC)C,,“tDO:CDC)CTC)C)CDDOD)H’DLCTC))C)H’Do:.-CitCDçtCTC)).C—bCDC):CLCDCDC)H”DLC’CCDCDCD—toC)HHCDH”DLC.DC‘H:DO’SCLCDDLCCDDoCLCD”H’DC•CD:0)0C)CCH’CDCCTCDC—bDLCHCDCiCDCLCLCDC.CHCDCCDCCDH’CL.CDCDCDcCH’DoCDHCooDL3itCDCDCLH’CLCDH,CCCCCDDoC)CD’CH’DL“CCDCDCDCD3CDCDCCDLCTCDCT•H”CDCL-4H’CDH’C’CDH’DLCDDLitH’CDDCHDLCD’HoC)CDCD.43’CDCDDoDLCLCD4)’DOHCt43’CD.CHoCCD“CDoCooCDHCoDLHC0)CCi)DLH’ESCDH’CDDo3CDCDii’CDCoCDDoCDCDHCLCTH’.CH’DLCDCCDLCTCDCH’CDOH’CLCT3CDCDoH•H’DCDLCTCDC•—hC)C—CD<:-rCL\H’CDCH’0)CCH’H’C)CDDo:H”CLCDCLC’-THC)CDCC43CD0CDCCLCLDoCCDCDCLC)C)C:)C0)Q)CD’Do‘))H’DLCD:C)DoC)HH’CDC)DLCTC—hCDH’D.).CTDODLCTCDC)CDr°C)CCHCTDoCTCo:H,tCD’)CD’CDCLCOO3CDCC0)C)H’—bCDCO)CH’CD:CDCOH”ty—oH’C)CLHDoCLçtCTCDtC•CD0)HH’CDCDCDCoDCcDLCDCCCH’C)DLCDHoCH’CDCDDLCTCCDC)CtCLCTC)CD-CDC)C. CDCDCH’CoCD0)cCCDH’.CDDLCDHCD‘°‘tCTC-toH’D)CTCLWCTCD1))CDL4)CLDO-CDOCDDLtH3C)itCoCDC>4),CTCDC)H30)H’CCDC)H’CCD—cCDitCTCDitCTH•CTDo:)CL43C)çtCTCDCOt43C00H’C)CD“C<H’C))HCDLC)HCTCDCLCDC.43CCCçO’HCLOHCD1))DoCDitH’CD3C):).CDCuCCDO‘C)CDHçtc’C)CDçtH’CDCD“CDDLCTCCCICCTCDDLDoCitCDHCLHoDCT4))H’DLCCCDH”C)
t
CT
CT
CD
CD
CT
-C
-C
Co
D)
CT
CD
C
CD
C
)
H
DL
H”
C)
<
CD
C
—
CD
it
DO
H
DL
C
CD
H’
CD
CD
DL
CT
H’CD
DL
CT
Co
CT
DO
D)
D)
H’
CD
-h
H
C
Do
Page 2 of 6
CD
DL
CL
CD”
CD
CD
CD
H’
fti
CD
DO
CL
CL
CL.
H’
H’
DL
CD
CC)
H
C
CD
CD
C
C)
-h
H’
CL
CLCDCTCDHCDDOCLH’CDcCC)CCDctCDCC)DCT—o3•0:43043;Cl)CDCD42.CCCL)2CZ•3:CC)C)0:C) C).,)C’)C’) C))CDzCCDC,-4.,C)CLHC’CTH’C):)-CCLCCDCo)HCDCD“0C)CDC—bCDrD’o3H-C)CD0.b)H0H’CLH”CHCDHCDCT:C.Cr)DCH”CD0:.C))C’)C)CHCLCDCDC)orH’CL“C•‘CD3CDC,CDCDCçtH’H”CDCCLC)oC)43.H’çtCD.H’C)[‘CDCC)Q.CD:CDCDItCTitCTCDLC)H’CD:CTDLC)C)DCCDC0)CDCDCo.CDCC)H”Ct-bSD)CDCTCLCDDLCTC))CDCDCDaIit0)çtH’C)itH’CH’CDCCDCLH’:43.C))CD5it‘HCLit’
n
t
CT
CT
CD
CD
CT
-C
-C
Co
D)
CT
CD
C
CD
C
)
H
DL
H”
C)
<
CD
C
—
CD
it
DO
H
DL
C
CD
H’
CD
CD
DL
CT
H’CD
DL
CT
Co
CT
DO
D)
D)
H’
CD
-h
H
C
Do
Page 3 of 6
CD
DL
CL
CD”
CD
CD
CD
H’
fti
CD
DO
CL
CL
CL.
H’
H’
DL
CD
CC)
H
C
CD
CD
C
C)
-h
H’
CL
CLCDCTCDHCDDOCLH’CDcCC)CCDctCDCC)DCT—o3•0:43043;Cl)CDCD42.CCCL)2CZ•3:CC)C)0:C) C).,)C’)C’) C))CDzCCDC,-4.,C)CLHC’CTH’C):)-CCLCCDCo)HCDCD“0C)CDC—bCDrD’o3H-C)CD0.b)H0H’CLH”CHCDHCDCT:C.Cr)DCH”CD0:.C))C’)C)CHCLCDCDC)orH’CL“C•‘CD3CDC,CDCDCçtH’H”CDCCLC)oC)43.H’çtCD.H’C)[‘CDCC)Q.CD:CDCDItCTitCTCDLC)H’CD:CTDLC)C)DCCDC0)CDCDCo.CDCC)H”Ct-bSD)CDCTCLCDDLCTC))CDCDCDaIit0)çtH’C)itH’CH’CDCCDCLH’:43.C))CD5it‘HCLit’
n
toto-ii ato0s-“. no-*zz0n07toVto0toZs-fttoC0-ftSctoan‘o-bnctotototo1toto3toto0s’wZtoto0ntotortoto0-,3flto•I-’toit70CtoitCitittoas-.to‘-tototoz3-ç7to3stoctono-toFtotoa•to•atoaa.3a,.0to00-ftn\torto•s-’.aX-cPd•Pd•t.a.z-c-c-i-ca.totos-.totaft3to“CIPd.SOI-’0toS-I333IPd’Pdto3toto*ttoCtoanit3CPd. noto(1)Pd.1Pd.70s-’<Ca‘•07%3•toaCto3toPd’to3toto<toi0C3toI-’-c3E•-ItoaotototoaaPd’orustouseocas-.ato(00-fttoto3SCtotcC3to0-fta.0toto3Dtzna.0itnC7ino•3toto0•“C3to7(0to0toI-’SCNitnzs-’ls-to5-.toto-ito0toto-i—‘-cni-.znz“CC-c0tc..a‘<o“sns-•3sn-1‘-‘00toC-ato73to’aatootontoa.cto-1ezztotototoctosaa-’a3‘—0totooan-i-cotoctoetoc-itoto‘-‘3it-ftnto30toCntoI-.a.totoznato-e,-cs7toto‘c-catoonoozto3noitto-cititstonittontoto5tostoan%‘>s asr-ceto50to5sOtototos-•n“toa.Cto-fttoto%D-cztoCtoz-cto0a.o-cnneatoorto-co‘-‘it‘c-s,e,.itoto‘--a-.zntoitto0ita-.to,sztoto00‘-“5-’a.sz0atotoPd.to5-’to3toC0tototoa-.ititCa-.aato“CCa-C0znstoeaPd.a-.to3,-‘Pd’-c0caa-.a-.tottoztooatto-tonto‘to-ice3wtoto0toZ%7to0tXtoon.oztooxza-.a-•a-.-taa0to-ft•0ozzz0to*4-ftntoo-c0ita-ftto0<-fta0-titoPd.-iitjoa-.itCtoznnzscto0nn no sno-ca.zesstoa-.‘.-iztosssctos3to•tototoatona-ctototonnto n
totototo3totototoaC‘rtot30toIDODa3IZ-cPd•Pd•ttoaiomozzzta<rt000IPd’toI•-I••lNfl<CtoUiCOlONto•%(NO-c5-’1tO’tCDaPd’0INIo’to(0%,tIl-It0%toIO”Xø70-*0Nto01-ito0100-cns1,1‘isntoPdIto’I-’It-’p.1.to“.aiooz•to-beeweI-.toto-IIitsI5toeeto0-ci“CtoiCtoztooaa-.IzntoI5-’0toC30ICa-toIPd’nit31aPd’Sto1tototoa-’Izto0tottoo03-ttoatit3to0Iitosa—zto’nto•toii to
a.
to
to
s-.
to
o
-b to
it
toe i’.
to
5-’
to
C
a
to o
‘c
to
too nan to o-c
a
•
oxc
to
z to
a
to
a.
to
to
s-.
to
o
-b to
it
toe i’.
to
5-’
to
C
a
to o
‘c
to
too nan to o-c
a
•
oxc
to
z to
a
Page 4 of 6
oaCt(I3413to3to7413Ctn70ton‘<04141Cd•a413to•1CtC3413a00Do0atoEto-%aCz41‘—3Do0atoEto-%aCz41‘—3o0atoEto-%aCz41‘—30atoEto-%aCz41‘—3)hCl’mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çCl’mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çt0amo030•aI-’to110amo030•aI-’to11amo030•aI-’to11o030•aI-’to11030•aI-’to1130•aI-’to110•aI-’to11•aI-’to11aI-’to11I-’to11to11111700341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-10341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1t-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftto030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft30CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftCDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0n0-t034130041n-ftn0-t034130041n-ft0-t034130041n-ft-t034130041n-ft034130041n-ftt-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftto030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft30CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftCDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0n0-t034130041n-ftn0-t034130041n-ft0-t034130041n-ft-t034130041n-ft034130041n-ftzUtor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zUtor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zto•C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30•C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo303noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30a-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30Cn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30n50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo3050totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30toon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30on-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30n-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30C-1C0•l-7tototo30-1C0•l-7tototo30a-çztototo-C41nCtn70to-çztototo-C41nCtn70toansn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0It0-toa.toCton00-toa.toCton0-toa.toCton0toa.toCton0a-çztototo-C41nCtn70to-çztototo-C41nCtn70toansn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0It0-toa.toCton00-toa.toCton0-toa.toCton0toa.toCton0ansn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0It0-toa.toCton00-toa.toCton0-toa.toCton0toa.toCton0t0-toa.toCton00-toa.toCton0-toa.toCton0toa.toCton0-(3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iId..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i.3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i003410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘03410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0t0to-(a-çton7-4Id.0to-(a-çton7-4Id.to-(a-çton7-4Id.-(a-çton7-4Id.a-çton7-4Id.0no0CI-’a3ttoto03lCtOzI-.an0•1Id.3.totoUId.7to0to0Z‘d070-çton.0303tz•QnCtSt410z3totoCtI-.341t‘<‘.•41Ct7t0a-ito0•3Eto•n7041nto-C7baCtotol--fttotol.a.nton-an041-çto(a‘0N‘0I-’‘0 as3a‘00no0n-5Ctoto‘-n0-i41ftI.’.341n•00-ta1nId.to41030-%Id.nI-.033413n413o7•41no-(no7-1toId.0z00CtS413ntol-’03ton0-$to•as730tonsn1.ztonatoCt•E.7410toCnan00-1a0za41CId.fl17to3•CrtoUoCt70StC-t7(<•-çc3atoUId.0tototo00znnto033toz03IONOl’‘0‘03a0’ljd.oto3030%0O.aI-.3to-ft.to<tn541-çntozad03031-•3atoId.to-h0a0o-1an00413-ç0-ftto-4zI...5n700toES0a-cto3-ino7totoO.3.rzaE00-ç30O3atoto30r30-i30aE-441t‘C03Sn3I-’03341-ft
‘—33z-i0S-ione0C-10C-1C-1-1-ftn70to70toto0Ct.41e-ç41-b-çe-ç41-b-ç-ç41-b-ç41-b-ç-b-ç-ç41n-ftn-ft0ton•zton•zn•z•ztoto30to30300ton0n0-4Id.Id.aCz41‘—3Cz41‘—3z41‘—341‘—3n41)Cone0C-141)Cone0C-1)Cone0C-1nCtn70toCtn70to(ft0I0III-’aCl)l-’O‘0aCl)l-’O‘0Cl)l-’O‘0l-’O‘0‘0to304141e-ç41-b-ç04141e-ç41-b-ç4141e-ç41-b-ç0041n-ft041n-ft•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0IN(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I‘10‘1-ft(ft0I‘1-ft(ft0I0n0304141e-ç41-b-ç0304141e-ç41-b-çto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-13l.’.n41)Cone0C-1l.’.n41)Cone0C-134130041n-ft4130041n-ft30041n-fttoto-ç0ton•zto-ç0ton•z-ç0ton•zl-7tototo30tototo30to-C41nCtn70to-C41nCtn70to41nCtn70to0-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0Ito3totoId’0-ftS-i3totoId’0-ftS-itotoId’0-ftS-itoId’0-ftS-iId’0-ftS-i0-ftS-i-ftS-i0‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0nI-’aCl)l-’O‘0I-bCton7-4Id.n7-4Id.7-4Id.-(41ntoto-ç0ton•zntoto-ç0ton•zatoEto-%aCz41‘—3toEto-%aCz41‘—3Eto-%aCz41‘—3to-%aCz41‘—3-%aCz41‘—3341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-141amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1Ctto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1C0•l-7tototo300•l-7tototo30•l-7tototo30a.toCton0.toCton0toCton0Cton0-çton7-4Id.o0mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çx•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-ç•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çt•n0304141e-ç41-b-ç•n0304141e-ç41-b-çt0amo030•aI-’to110amo030•aI-’to11amo030•aI-’to11o030•aI-’to11030•aI-’to1130•aI-’to110•aI-’to11•aI-’to11aI-’to11I-’to11to11111tor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zr4141ntoto-ç0ton•z4141ntoto-ç0ton•zztototo-C41nCtn70totototo-C41nCtn70tototo-C41nCtn70tonsn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0Isn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0II..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i03to3totoId’0-ftS-i3to3totoId’0-ftS-i003410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘03410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0C-(n0Do0atoEto-%aCz41‘—3Do0atoEto-%aCz41‘—3o0atoEto-%aCz41‘—30atoEto-%aCz41‘—3)hCl’mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çCl’mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-ç700341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-10341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1t-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftto030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft30CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftCDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0n0-t034130041n-ftn0-t034130041n-ft0-t034130041n-ft-t034130041n-ft034130041n-ftzUtor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zUtor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zto•C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30•C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo303noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30a-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30Cn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30n50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo3050totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30toon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30on-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30n-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30C-1C0•l-7tototo30-1C0•l-7tototo30a-çztototo-C41nCtn70to-çztototo-C41nCtn70toansn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0It0-toa.toCton00-toa.toCton0-toa.toCton0toa.toCton0-(3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iId..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i.3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-it0to-(a-çton7-4Id.0to-(a-çton7-4Id.to-(a-çton7-4Id.-(a-çton7-4Id.a-çton7-4Id.0S-ione0C-10C-1C-1-1-ftn70to70toto0Ct.41e-ç41-b-çe-ç41-b-ç-ç41-b-ç41-b-ç-b-ç-ç41n-ftn-ft0ton•zton•zn•z•ztoto30to30300ton0n0-4Id.Id.aCz41‘—3Cz41‘—3z41‘—341‘—3n41)Cone0C-141)Cone0C-1)Cone0C-1nCtn70toCtn70to(ft0I0III-’aCl)l-’O‘0aCl)l-’O‘0Cl)l-’O‘0l-’O‘0‘0to304141e-ç41-b-ç04141e-ç41-b-ç4141e-ç41-b-ç0041n-ft041n-ft•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0IN(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I‘10‘1-ft(ft
’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iId..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i.3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-it0to-(a-çton7-4Id.0to-(a-çton7-4Id.to-(a-çton7-4Id.-(a-çton7-4Id.a-çton7-4Id.0S-ione0C-10C-1C-1-1-ftn70to70toto0Ct.41e-ç41-b-çe-ç41-b-ç-ç41-b-ç41-b-ç-b-ç-ç41n-ftn-ft0ton•zton•zn•z•ztoto30to30300ton0n0-4Id.Id.aCz41‘—3Cz41‘—3z41‘—341‘—3n41)Cone0C-141)Cone0C-1)Cone0C-1nCtn70toCtn70to(ft0I0III-’aCl)l-’O‘0aCl)l-’O‘0Cl)l-’O‘0l-’O‘0‘0to304141e-ç41-b-ç04141e-ç41-b-ç4141e-ç41-b-ç0041n-ft041n-ft•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0IN(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I‘10‘1-ft(ft0I‘1-ft(ft0I0n0304141e-ç41-b-ç0304141e-ç41-b-çto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-13l.’.n41)Cone0C-1l.’.n41)Cone0C-134130041n-ft4130041n-ft30041n-fttoto-ç0ton•zto-ç0ton•z-ç0ton•zl-7tototo30tototo30to-C41nCtn70to-C41nCtn70to41nCtn70to0-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0Ito3totoId’0-ftS-i3totoId’0-ftS-itotoId’0-ftS-itoId’0-ftS-iId’0-ftS-i0-ftS-i-ftS-i0‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0nI-’aCl)l-’O‘0I-bCton7-4Id.n7-4Id.7-4Id.-(41ntoto-ç0ton•zntoto-ç0ton•zatoEto-%aCz41‘—3toEto-%aCz41‘—3Eto-%aCz41‘—3to-%aCz41‘—3-%aCz41‘—3341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-141amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1Ctto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1C0•l-7tototo300•l-7tototo30•l-7tototo30a.toCton0.toCton0toCton0Cton0-çton7-4Id.o0mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çx•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-ç•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çt•n0304141e-ç41-b-ç•n0304141e-ç41-b-çt0amo030•aI-’to110amo030•aI-’to11amo030•aI-’to11o030•aI-’to11030•aI-’to1130•aI-’to110•aI-’to11•aI-’to11aI-’to11I-’to11to11111tor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zr4141ntoto-ç0ton•z4141ntoto-ç0ton•zztototo-C41nCtn70totototo-C41nCtn70tototo-C41nCtn70tonsn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0Isn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0I410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0II..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i03to3totoId’0-ftS-i3to3totoId’0-ftS-i003410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘03410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0410‘0NEnI-’aCl)l-’O‘0C-(n0Do0atoEto-%aCz41‘—3Do0atoEto-%aCz41‘—3o0atoEto-%aCz41‘—30atoEto-%aCz41‘—3)hCl’mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-çCl’mex•t•n0304141e-ç41-b-ç700341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-10341amCtto3l.’.n41)Cone0C-1t-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-.to030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftto030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft030CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft30CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0CDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftCDl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.a.l.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ftl.41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft41-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft-%5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft5-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft‘<0n0-t034130041n-ft0n0-t034130041n-ftn0-t034130041n-ft0-t034130041n-ft-t034130041n-ft034130041n-ftzUtor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zUtor4141ntoto-ç0ton•zto•C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30•C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30C3noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo303noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30noa-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30a-cCn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30Cn50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30n50totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo3050totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30totoon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30toon-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30on-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30n-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30-bE‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30‘1C-1C0•l-7tototo30C-1C0•l-7tototo30-1C0•l-7tototo30a-çztototo-C41nCtn70to-çztototo-C41nCtn70toansn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0It0-toa.toCton00-toa.toCton0-toa.toCton0toa.toCton0-(3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iId..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i.3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-it0to-(a-çton
•l-7tototo30-1C0•l-7tototo30a-çztototo-C41nCtn70to-çztototo-C41nCtn70toansn410-s•N(1’‘10‘1-ft(ft0It0-toa.toCton00-toa.toCton0-toa.toCton0toa.toCton0-(3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i3•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0n-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ft-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i-ftn-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-in-ftSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iSCE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iE.Id..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-iId..3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i.3•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i•00I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-i0I..’03to3totoId’0-ftS-it0to-(a-çton7-4Id.0to-(a-çton7-4Id.to-(a-çton7-4Id.-(a-çton7-4Id.a-çton7-4Id.
n r
Cl’
to
U
-(
‘-43
to0
-ft
-(nn
to-i to
to
to
to
0n7
S-i
to
Id.
Id.a
Id.
41-4
to
toC0
to
toa
to
n to-ç0
to
00300-13
to
-ft
3n
a
Page 5 of 6
a
V
onnO77C00-ç-(ntoa-ft0DOD03-$n410omoa3woønId.Nfll-’no(JTQN73“1000%t01-.3I-.’’to030ton0N35•to00n‘1‘1o-iiajhto0‘0‘030‘0‘03to00o-tnaIdUtoSCto3ono003ttonU0IdasUId.<3n7toId.E0’ttoa o1)93CL93ftft93???ft•))ftC):C)C:C)C).C)C)?ftC)C)CC33rrftF”C)C)rt&33F”9333C).C)?—C)rC)C)C)C)C)C)F”C):C)()ftC):\C)C)C)T)C)C).C)1.7C)(3)C)C):CC)C)?CC)cuCrtC)C)C)C)CC)CUNC)F”C)ftCC0ftC)çtfC)C)ftC).C)C)F”C)tC)C)?.C)CF”C)C)C):C)C)ft1)C)•CC).C)C)C)C)C)?C)F”C)93C)C)I)C)CC)C)ftC).ftNIC)•C)C)C)ftC)?F”ftC)CCC)CC)?ftC)ftC)7ftC)•NIC)F”C)ftCUC)C)‘CftftF”C)C)F”ftft F”F”
U)
C)
C)
ft
ft
C)
C)
C)
C::
C)C)F”ICC)?C)C)C)C::ftC)C)C)33C)C)ftC)C)C)33C)C)C)33F”C)ftF”3333C)ftC)C)C)Cft‘ftC)ftftC)F”C)C)F”C).C)C):)C)C)F”2rtC).C)7CC)ftC)C)1)CC)ftC)ft.C)t??C1)C)C)33ftftC)C)C)33ftC)C)33)?.C)CC).ftC)?C)3)ftC)ftCftF:?C).ftftC)C)C)Cft‘ftC)ftftC)F”C)C)F”C).C)C):)C)C)F”2rtC).C)7CC)ftC)C)1)CC)ftC)ft.C)t??C1)C)C)33ftftC)C)C)33ftC)C)33)?.C)CC).ftC)?C)3)ftC)ftCftF:?C).ftC)?CF”F”‘CCtftC)C)ftF”C)C)C)F”C)ftC).C)ftC)C)33)C)C)C)Cl?33.:)C)3C)CCF”C)CUC)C)C)‘CC)C)F”03)C)C)CCCCC)3)F”ftCC)C)C)79.F”ftftF”C)C)flC)C)ftF”C)C)C)F”C)ftC).C)ftC)C)33)C)C)C)Cl?33.:)C)3C)CCF”C)CUC)C)C)‘CC)C)F”03)C)C)CCCCC)3)F”ftCC)C)C)79.F”ftftF”C)C)flC)F”3)ftF”931)C)‘7F”3)C).C)ftC)C)C)2F”C)C)C)C)CC)CC)C)•CF”ftC)?.C)C)3)C)C)F”CCC)CCCC)C)C)ItNC.C)NCCC).C)ftC)C)C)2F”C)C)C)C)CC)CC)C)•CF”ftC)?.C)C)3)C)C)F”CCC)CCCC)C)C)ItNC.C)NCC93C.93ftft.C)ftC)ftrftC)ftftC)ftC)ftftftftftC)C)C)?C)C)C)C)C)C)ftft.C)ftC)ftrftC)ftftC)ftC)ftftftftftC)C)C)?C)C)C)C)C)C)
ft
ft
CL
ft
ft
ft
C).93C)F”ft
.ftCC¶EC)C)C)C).C?ftC)?C)C)ftF”C):C2CF”C)C)C1310[C)]ILl:1)çC)C)C)—l:z z IL’C)C)C)IC) CC 0-ftCC C) CCC).ftC):C)(CI F”‘7CC)ICU IC) C)I“4C)C)IC)’ .3: C)33CfftC) F[F?]ftft3)C‘7ftC)(?3NI C)(9)C)C)ftft3I?N:F”rC):C)ftC)I)C)C?)NftC)C)C)ftftF’F”ftC)C)I.?:4)4)I4)f)C)??C)C)CI)C):C)ftC)???Cf93CftC)F”F”C)_C)CCC)C)C)C)•C))::3)(UC)C).38C)C)?C)ftftC::‘CC)ft.ftftF”ftC)f?C)F”C).C)C)
.ft
C)
ft
C)
C
C)
.
.s
Page 6 of 6
Loading citations and judicial treatment…