Karnataka High Court

CRL.A/598/1998 of CHIKKAHOTTAPPA @ VARADEGOWDA & ORS. Vs STATE BY HULIYURDURGA P.S. TUMKUR on 9 September 1999

COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BAN3N ORE DATED THIS THE 9TH DAy OP PiEMBER 1999 PPSENT THE HONBLE MR. JUSTICE M.F. SALDAa4A THE H’E. MR. JUSTIcE NS. V•ERABHRAI eel No, 598 98 Between: 1. Chikkahottappa Vareegowda, S/o Vare Gowda, Aged 55 years, Resident of Bandihalli, Kunigal Taluk. 2.

\W

CD 5[(tHH]CtCo CtI18(0000Z ThH.(UxH:y84

8OlDCCD

CoCt

U) i C a(0CDCD51i•C(U1CD 0151(0CD‘J) iQH.CDCD$Z OCrP51CDCDCDCS) ri-CCtCDU)CDCDH. C—CD(UCtw0)Ct(UH. Si CCt Cl i-i. 0 0t’);ç•’b.-C)’ClCDi-hCDCD51i•C(U1CD 0151(0CD‘J) iQH.CDCD$Z OCrP51CDCDCDCS) ri-CCtCDU)CDCDH. C—CD(UCtw0)Ct(UH. Si CCt Cl i-i. 0 0t’);ç•’b.-C)’ClCDi-h(UC)4Cii:rainC)U)(U•i-hC,)(UDiCtH. 0 0ID (1 Z 0)CDi-hCtCtCDHoW51CDCU•CD rt4(U•(0OClC.C.irtN0CDWbDHirtH1\).fl5CDC.(U5-*C.H.ZtZrtZC)0H.cx00 ri.w(D0C)tDnHa(O45t0CDNu(P.51C,i-rt1Cfli1H3rNClCtCOQJLflCD111C051oNCD.-h1tJ)d )0Q3 -rt H.ZU)cOticD3Q0)WflC )-3.i-t(DNT.CNMçrtw rt(13o:CD(D0CC)WOCWCDCH.Ot-hWO•rDipO00C000 (DHHCCHHrtri-C.CDJcn((DQH.’-. CHH C)OlD:iii•H**wS—C71Dw*E5-h(051kH.C0:ifrCC ri-CCii:rainC)U)(U•i-hC,)(UDiCtH. 0 0ID (1 Z 0)CDi-hCtCtCDHoW51CDCU•CD rt4(U•(0OClC.C.irtN0CDWbDHirtH1\).fl5CDC.(U5-*C.H.ZtZrtZC)0H.cx00 ri.w(D0C)tDnHa(O45t0CDNu(P.51C,i-rt1Cfli1H3rNClCtCOQJLflCD111C051oNCD.-h1tJ)d )0Q3 -rt H.ZU)cOticD3Q0)WflC )-3.i-t(DNT.CNMçrtw rt(13o:CD(D0CC)WOCWCDCH.Ot-hWO•rDipO00C000 (DHHCCHHrtri-C.CDJcn((DQH.’-. CHH C)OlD:iii•H**wS—C71Dw*E5-h(051kH.C0:ifrCC ri-C

ci

CD

51ipO

zri-C.71D

i-h

OC

NCcjNflrr—

SDCtif)CD iCO(1eH. H.eH. H.U)Coi-h‘8 C5t, Z”rtHC4CDH. i-h H(‘IH.8i-h‘8 C5t, Z”rtHC4CDH. i-h H(‘IH.8CtLQC)CDCCt(Dh0H.HCDH..Q)rtU)51DoH..COC(DCDC)0 Z0 (D0UIOHOrto N a.<CCCCClC)CDCCt(Dh0H.HCDH..Q)rtU)51DoH..COC(DCDC)0 Z0 (D0UIOHOrto N a.<CCCCCl

U) COCD51CD H.jCl) (DOWCDtY••4CD[[H.Q]]HOs8CtDiC.Hi-.CCuH.CD•44H.Si Si%C.Ui%CDHH-CD444CDi-f)51CDClCl051tlCoowIhQrP0CClN sirtHH-H-Cl(00)wCD.CC(1 H-C

>

d51h

H. H. H.j

‘t

CD

i--•

CD Li)OW[[H.Q]]

•

C

ct

CoZ1co•

C’i51

(Drv

CuCuCu

W

0,

W

CC

s

OC

“p

•o

WE

‘1

ft i:

E

to

Pd•

•

C

to to

to

-%

3a

-(

0toso

Cs

C

to

-‘

Pd.

to

too

ft

C

ft

Pd’

as

Pd’

I-’

C

-ç

)-

(B

U

a ft to

to

‘4i

-C

•

E

‘C

I—’

to to

7•

00am

—‘

‘C

Pd’

Pd’

•1

ft

-b

ft

Pd’

to

to

Pd’

-ç

t

•

C•

to

Pd’

•

Pd’

•0

Page 1 of 19

0z

0av

70a00avz0toft0ftft0Cstoo-ç0ft7a30•£bC3030am-i70Pd’0ato00ft0300•000r0aaz3P’-ito-btoto0Pd’ft0Ift-ç0ft3toUozftt•7Zft0Pd’30C.0£0o0770ftPd’S3iCa-’C0C7C3C.0ft030ato•-ç3Pd’0ft•03ft7-i7C0Pd.3-çftPd’0aft•Nft300to033C<5toato70•3•3003-ç30Pd’03U0to0ft-ç0•-1•EPd3007am0ft0ft•0Cto£0703•0Pd’Cto3CE-1-4ft03tlb-430toftft-f0070a07•7C-t00•0to0Pd.0a3000ft030z30U3ft%(•Ø0ftto0to-403ftC00a-$000-c,a57saSft0w-0towC...0(pm5(00rto03030-iftft50ft70ftPd’o30oC<U0a0to0aoNI100to£I—to30Eto-bI-’3Pd•a50-1•<ftft0ft000aPd•70tiØtiØ03-h0s00a00U0ft570-1ftC71Pd.0Pd’I—0a33aC.0003•7-%-ç0•1-ft0toCC0ft3ft09300-ç753CaoC0-100ttoto000030a0Uam-hOft)—fttoto00toE0C£C7ftamzz0ft0Pd’fttoftftPd.50Pd’(0Pd’-ftft37ft3ft705700Pd’0ftC•00asoa007fti—a0sPd’0a.

aa

a

‘1

ft

Pd’

U

ft

Pd’

Pd’

Pd’

to

Pd.

Pd’

Pd’

.3

to ft

(.4

C

Ca

ft ft

a ft

tiØ

C

NO

r

r

C

-ç

ft

Pd8

ft

ft

0-IPd’CPd’30-4Pd’500000Pd’CCto70ftaPd.03D.4(ho0Pd’atoPd’to0UPd.30ft0(“33totoC)U00to-ft00Z-ç0‘a0%%(0tictiØ£W0-çU00-ft0ft-,500

aa

a

‘1

ft

Pd’

U

ft

Pd’

Pd’

Pd’

to

Pd.

Pd’

Pd’

.3

to ft

(.4

C

Ca

ft ft

a ft

tiØ

C

NO

r

r

C

-ç

ft

Page 2 of 19

Pd8

ft

ft

0-IPd’CPd’30-4Pd’500000Pd’CCto70ftaPd.03D.4(ho0Pd’atoPd’to0UPd.30ft0(“33totoC)U00to-ft00Z-ç0‘a0%%(0tictiØ£W0-çU00-ft0ft-,500

Ca‘aCztotoçt‘atoCt‘a0Z(P0toCt‘a0z‘aa“0C)-1‘a3to0z•.oN‘aCt“0“0‘..•000toZ-1zato7to-ftto-çtotocC7to0‘0tototo0Ct0Ctz-to0Uto0toCtoto£toto7‘0003‘anto‘aCt•to-Q0‘a‘atoz-toCto-bCt7Wto00Ctoto0-ft‘aN‘a‘0rtozasCtoIItotototoC‘acCtoa7‘aZLa.am•C)•tototoatoto‘0C)03‘aSto‘azCt£‘aCtt70totOtototoCtoz‘aZUtotoa3‘aCtCtto‘01-4N0totoi‘a7toZ7Ca‘0CCCtCto‘a7Ctto00Ctotoas-ft0‘OC)‘0toiatoCt-ftto00‘ato‘aCt1Czato-çto(0)0Ct‘a0Z00N‘a‘O00C‘Otto0‘a‘aC)to-çto‘atoCtto‘1toatoZ-ftC3‘a‘<to‘asszCt‘a0atoaUSZ‘atoz‘0‘aC)7‘ato0-ftto0to‘a30‘a‘ato<to00to0to‘a0ZCt0atotototo-ft-cp.tc..affaC£7‘a‘atotoztoCt‘a‘W‘0‘atoato‘0to0-iCt‘atoto•0Ct7toCt‘aSZ‘aatoCt•‘aCCt‘a3toCtsstotoatoCtoCtto‘aztoaCt7toto-t‘atos0CtototoCttoU0CCt(IT•Ztoto‘UaCt£00Ctto7Ctsto‘000‘a‘ato0Ct0Ct7tototo‘0CttoUCCtN•00•3•aI‘UCt0Ct7to70to‘aCtto‘atoCtxC‘a‘aCt‘1‘a‘ato•030—fttotoato30toUCto33toCtto30to•‘a£‘aCt7Ct7to-itto0Ct0-%atoCtto‘aCLa.‘a3C-c‘a3to‘000••toto0zto-b-ftto0Ct7toto‘a0“CC-çaC-c—£toCttoCttoCtato—I7toCt7to‘aCt7C‘a3‘a0)Lto70‘atoCtto7‘atoCt7to‘az0377toatoCtCtoa0z Ct-b0£sto-fttotototo0tototoCtCtCta07SCtotoCtto‘a0Ct0aCt070‘aCtototos3toCtto‘a‘atotototo3Cta‘a0toCt£to‘az73Ct4<07‘ato•to0ZNtoato7Ct•toI‘a0rto‘a00Ct03tozrtotoCtto0Ct•0toC%737toto•CtatoCt70to7%3CtCtU’to-1to77C..a030to(to30totoCtZZ‘aSto‘atototototoxC)0.0Ct3C0atotoZtoazto37CC‘aD0Cto0to0-çCttoCtZ‘ato‘a37‘aC‘atotoztoto3C‘atoCto•aa‘a‘atoa‘Cto£to‘U7Ct3Ctto‘a£070t00totoCtto7

Ct7

‘a

Ct

sto

to

La.

‘a

Ct

C

C7

‘a

to

to

to

a

-i‘a

-%

C7

‘a

z

to

toC

‘a

‘aa

-ç

to

to

to

to

U

‘0

to0

‘a

to

‘a

to

C

to

to‘a

‘a

4<

C

toza

to

to

to

Ct7

to

to

Ct to

‘a

to

‘a

to

to

-ft

Ct

Page 3 of 19

to

ra—ci(0‘0a—cia-.a—aaa•-ft‘-afl-4cicpa4*ci-ç•0a-•05o05C-ft05cizaaoaciia*30o-ç0a0Ca-.çtsNa-ci3a—’a-a-’aci-(ssa3aciCciaaaa-’ci00aSa£-fta-ftSa-’ci04*4*3Csazitci‘-‘ciS3ci4*-10a-aa•0aaaa.o-ft00Q..4*ciCta-I-ftC‘-‘3‘0%S0a0aa535C00Stcia4*a05ci3aaa-ca-’ci‘0CitCC03-ft35aftcia-.a-’-ftacici0Cci-433-cciCr4*;00-3-ft.0a—’aa-’a-*saci-çS•C0aa-’C005C-fttacia-f00aaa-ft-4aa -ft 0aaS0SCa-.0aa0-ftit3a0-ft-ftaSaCa-ca00S

Cci050_a•3-ftci,-‘-ftLio-74*0ciC•ooCci•ab-icitI-.Cr3-çaci-çaC00çt3aI-’ciz-43,-‘.•-ç4*aoSaS4*‘-.0S4*30ci4*tcici-çci‘-‘ciaacia-ho0-ça‘0-(acia0tI-,Ca,-‘aci-15aa0C5ciaI—0•4*30S-bci04*ciciciI—cia-.sat•-’0a£-i•o0C-44*30oci-4a-ftCa-’a-’ciza3ciCaa3ci-ca3aCtaa-ça0-,-0a•taciCacit..ca—ci0a-çCciaa4*3acasaz4*0-ft•0-çaci-ç‘-.sa0ci4*0z-ft4*7aaCa-.taa5oa(‘Ct3ci0-c-ft3cici-cit0-.4<3aciCcia.£asciCaaoSaciit0ci‘-‘ci-taca-.azci5açtz-a(0cita—i3a-ça00-a0-c*3I-.ci<0ciaa-•ci-çaa-’ciita-’.a-’0C•3aci-ac*3a‘-aaci-cSaaaaa-.a-.0Scia-’•0C0a-’a-.0-10•0cia0C0-ç-ft-,‘0Ct3.aaj—ta—ciS(‘3cia-’amci-1zaa00CSciaa-’ciza£a3ciCacia.-’ci0NC’3a‘0acia.’.‘0S-1S0-ftc’aciacia-’£arci<a3aci-cacia4*SaSoaci•cicicicia-’a—ci4*3a00-c-ça0Sacici0-ftCr3aciao0Sa-.0ta-.0Scici5a0Caa-c0(p•‘-a•0-ft-ç4*35-çaa‘030ft30ci•‘0—-a•0-caciaSftCciacia—0cia30ciCa0-flaaS-fta-.aaci•(p00OSoa-’.5aa-ftcia—’4*4*I0aaS0SCa-.0aa0-ftit3a0-ft-ftaSaCa-ca00S

-ç

ci

‘0

a

-ç

‘-‘0

0a

-ft z

a

4<

a

ci

-c a

ci

a

C

(pci

a

a

‘-‘

ci

S

C

a

a ci

a-’

‘-.

•O

ci

•Ocino

‘C

Fç——LI..:CC-CCC-CCCCCC-F:1CCC>CLC.CClElIC—

H

—

S.C

CCFIC—F——Ic5)C)c‘C5)‘F5)((5‘:_‘‘—(‘C15),—C‘ES(5)CC(5)ID’i(5)F’CS.,7S‘(55))5(5):•.‘1‘-H.‘.‘.0C1CC.-‘C’’C..--C.7...--CCCCCCCCCCUIICCCCC:sQUH’UC)C7CCC•)‘(I:,‘7+CTCLElElCCC:CEC...C)ICCLC)C)11C)C)C)C)‘C(CFI(C’CCC)C)C)C)F—Fc.cCICC’,“.IC(5)

H

I))

I

C

t

F—

‘C)

C’F.”

CL

.,‘‘7

—

LL

F

J”

CF

H

-+

H

,)

((5

C

C

C)

“CF

I——CFcCC(5))F’IF(5)(5)(1)CD(5)C’’icI’-CH0CCCCC‘‘--CC_rC(i1”C.U-())CCCCCCCCCCCCCUHHCCC’CCCCCCC’CC-I:5CC‘7C)C..ElI—CCCCC.CLCiICCEC:’—CL(CC)CI(CIC)CC.C.CLC(CIC(CC’

U

U

-ç

ci

‘0

a

-ç

‘-‘0

0a

-ft z

a

4<

a

ci

-c a

ci

a

C

(pci

a

a

‘-‘

ci

S

C

a

a ci

a-’

‘-.

•O

ci

•Ocino

‘C

Fç——LI..:CC-CCC-CCCCCC-F:1CCC>CLC.CClElIC—

H

—

S.C

CCFIC—F——Ic5)C)c‘C5)‘F5)((5‘:_‘‘—(‘C15),—C‘ES(5)CC(5)ID’i(5)F’CS.,7S‘(55))5(5):•.‘1‘-H.‘.‘.0C1CC.-‘C’’C..--C.7...--CCCCCCCCCCUIICCCCC:sQUH’UC)C7CCC•)‘(I:,‘7+CTCLElElCCC:CEC...C)ICCLC)C)11C)C)C)C)‘C(CFI(C’CCC)C)C)C)F—Fc.cCICC’,“.IC(5)

H

I))

I

C

t

F—

‘C)

C’F.”

CL

.,‘‘7

—

LL

Page 4 of 19

F

J”

CF

H

-+

H

,)

((5

C

C

C)

“CF

I——CFcCC(5))F’IF(5)(5)(1)CD(5)C’’icI’-CH0CCCCC‘‘--CC_rC(i1”C.U-())CCCCCCCCCCCCCUHHCCC’CCCCCCC’CC-I:5CC‘7C)C..ElI—CCCCC.CLCiICCEC:’—CL(CC)CI(CIC)CC.C.CLC(CIC(CC’

U

U

a-ato£to0)-•0C05CCStoC‘<ccsto-ça-aa-•totoa-.cc0toC0£770tocca-zccCCcc50totoccto07Ccc£toa-.cc-ç7Z00totoU0tocctoa-toto atcc0a-•to-cto70to505tocc0a-ccc0tototo-ft0toz-iacca-•a7tocc00toasa-sccza-toto00cca-.ccsscc-ctotototoStocccto-htoccto-ctocca-.0toto.-(7a-to-fttotosC05toUto3-c0a-C0toto£totocc-toa-.tototo05atoscc‘<ztotostoCSccto£a--(77a-toa-tototocccco-ct0to7£Cto0to7-ccccc-ftto0cc0

cc

ccztod-..cca-.3a-’1toama-.zccso-c-htosaocctoStotocc07•ccto0toto-1aa-scctotocccc1%zto£Ctoto£a-.-c07tocctoa-.z-cto0toto00to-c-fta-.to-icc0tototo-t0-hz0-ftto7toa-0•toa-•-(a-.a-.0tototo-coa-0z0a-•ttoScc-to0tot30zcccccc70t00-ft•to-ftto0-(0cc0cc0to0-(a-.Ctoa-.-ctoccccs0cccco0to0toc’OcczUScctos7cc5075toatotoccto0toto70to0toSto17570to-s0£cc antotocc’--ftnto-1C0a-to-ba-’Sto0toto0cc7z7zcc00Ca-<7tocc-’0-cCa-.0zC0ccC-a-.a-.0cato*1tototoacc-ctoz-ccC-a--tocc0007ccUcca-Uc7£-t.C-ba-a-.to7cca-a-.trto030toa-tos‘<cca-CsccCto0a-.tototosa-•cctoa-cccccc3stototocctoUa7to00Xtt0<tototoSUcc0Ccc00-I-ft•a-.0C0za--totoC.0£0ztoatocctoatototoccC0-ccctoUa-.3a-.a-•a-.toC£-lto-IiS£toatoUUSa-a-to7a-toto7toCa-a-’a-.a-.a-.a-(a-.toz3toto-ito<a-a-toccatocccc0tocc‘<a-.5a-.a-’to.‘<to0toa-tostocccca70a-.t-c7<‘<0totoa-.cc££toa-U-ICzccscctoa-icca-C0-<toUtoo7cca-sO-ftcctooccrcctosto“c-accssz7tocctototostoUto•totocca-toccto-stotoa-7a-.totototo53toto-fttoto-hotoCraa-soCs0Cctoa-toto-$0a-.0-fttoaa-’a-.•acctooa-ftSa-.a-.cccctocccctoCto0a-.0Cto57 srto-cs0ccccsa-.7cca-.totoc-tto0toa-.totocctozsaScc0to0-cstostoC•to

1. 5ato

C

a-.

an

o

to

to

tocc

<

a-.

a- a-•

z

C

7cc ft

C

-í

cc

to to

cc a-

to

ccto

to

C

7to

a-cc

ss

to

-i

-ft

to

a-a-Ia-.

a-.

to

C

s

scc

z to

t..S

to

at

to cc

a-.

t

7-Iito

a-.

to

a-cc

Page 5 of 19

cc

Ft

$•CDCDC•‘CDLO-lftftftftftftftftftftZftv£30303000£00o000o‘•ftftftftftftftftftftft00oo03£3£070£n200o00r-C<a.ftftftrt‘-o00o01ô0£ftftftftC-.xZ0£fta-a-Ca-rrrr<0ür-r-b-ta-Za--i,Cr-flflz--iSZZZaaara•Ccçr-ittaaaa-sZZ--(ZCereraaaaaaa‘tflita—sCc’(‘CC-‘“aaa-fti-•er.1CCCI-’7Q.77I-’37Ct0..attc.totoNCCCc.to:3-)-3Da-.3777777337t-ç•)57tototototototoOtototototototo:3tototototototoc.:3tototototototototototototo33737C337a-’a-’a-’I-”totototo.tototototo:3ntotoo.:37Ototo:3totototototoCrtotototo7totototototo7tototo1to3Crtototototototototo—-r‘i-i.CCa-’a-’a-’(0CrCr(0tos:31-’toto:3:3tototoa-’toto-ctoa-’:3-ctototototoSSS1’•trrrt-1*-£‘.‘<Q.‘1n(5a---10)C0)Sa-”-ctototozaac-.a-”(0a-”•‘TSii’-cii’RCzzezzacaaICu.-tF-’SC..(1)1-ftz0zaftI—0ftzzaaftaC,ftftrI-’•C)(isC)a-’.••It’(‘:C)—•I—‘——1U:(UC•-wa-’U)—Lbt‘1’-%-%LuOsfCtC:.LbL.

‘..

to

<

to

%

tto

r

ft to

eto

ft to

F-

:3

a-’

aa-’

to

ft to

C

‘-

:3

C

r-

t

,c-

to

toz

t

F-’

to

C)

to

to

r

•

to

ft

Lb

C

-

to

sto a

to

—

a—

ft to

-

to

%

-

to

.

to

a-

a-

r to

ft

£

CD

to

z

-‘

to

C)

C

a

c“%CDftftftftftfto000£00033‘--fto0000033fta.03000£0ft0££2Sçto00.r-bSa-.‘-heZcacr‘ia%aaa-‘C-CV.-CCaa-‘t7ae7arCCCI-’777a3toCto‘Cr7733ttob’.totctototo:3totototototoC3C3I-”‘-•ir-••--tototo:3£tototototoa-’C‘<-$csCr(0n7srtotoa--a-C:a-’tov-.rC..‘<‘‘-i.totoa-”tototozc—-l0’‘-“CCt.•‘tcazza3oftftcCf-it’‘zC..CTI——.C.F-‘C(I)C)‘C)•at’-%I—LuCtLbZ,)c,.3

o

-b

sr

to

-‘

to

C..

ft to

C

C)

t

Z,)

;LtjNO

r

‘..

to

<

to

%

tto

r

ft to

eto

ft to

F-

:3

a-’

aa-’

to

ft to

C

‘-

:3

C

r-

t

,c-

to

toz

t

F-’

to

C)

to

to

r

•

to

ft

Lb

C

-

to

sto a

to

—

a—

ft to

-

to

%

-

to

.

to

a-

a-

r to

ft

£

CD

to

z

-‘

to

C)

C

a

c“%CDftftftftftfto000£00033‘--fto0000033fta.03000£0ft0££2Sçto00.r-bSa-.‘-heZcacr‘ia%aaa-‘C-CV.-CCaa-‘t7ae7arCCCI-’777a3toCto‘Cr7733ttob’.totctototo:3totototototoC3C3I-”‘-•ir-••--tototo:3£tototototoa-’C‘<-$csCr(0n7srtotoa--a-C:a-’tov-.rC..‘<‘‘-i.totoa-”tototozc—-l0’‘-“CCt.•‘tcazza3oftftcCf-it’‘zC..CTI——.C.F-‘C(I)C)‘C)•at’-%I—LuCtLbZ,)c,.3

o

-b

sr

to

-‘

to

C..

ft to

C

C)

Page 6 of 19

t

Z,)

;LtjNO

r

ICDCl)CflCl)CDCOCOCOCDCDCDCl)CDLI)COC1•41’‘CDCD‘TICCVxstaa-xxv-,ititacaazaazaaaaaaaazaczzaaacaaaaazaaititititititit-taazzaaazaaaaaaaaaaaa?azaazaaaaaazaitititaait3acaaititaDiCtarr-‘‘--l‘-z000c£3eoa£000za00£000a-cC-•--j:rrta.3000x0o090000U3000o0U300o-‘-cCrt•U-•UUrU.o0£00009£oo00000x0a.Ut‘-.r.002atV00iCeDi7CanCctato0o£..CtrrC.::tCCit-,Z-iZr--70D-a.zits-70:t(tm-•-iiZZcaaaraat.a-ifl(.aaCC-(Z-ZZCci.Zz•CCaaaaaa-ftak”ft0-CCCaaa)-.1’•t--C.-fti.ts-.r’!.L‘-.t:‘-‘-,citt(r137CCCC.737a3Ct777a7rc.CCCg,‘-•‘-•CC-77777777737CtCt-cCt-cCtCtCtCtCttototoQt?tototo-‘rUtotoI-toto-Cfr’•U37333Ct7Ct‘<‘<‘<3-cow3-c-cn.-c5.1•CI-”I-”-4(A0)-1to-c•<2.---10)04)4)(00)(0C0).Z0’0’•‘0(0I-’.C2::1kX1‘—ii:..;•(2W•2s.-’i-’•—-<0?i-’.‘<Ci(fl(I)Di(I)tO———402:C:(.t0?•-‘.Di40C)DiDi)CC)DiDiDiDiC)—•S.DiccDiWI——iS’.tODiDiDiDi—CsCa.it)-%.—L)Di•Di••U.4’Ca ••J’•Ct•CC.wit0.)—CC.%..73-aazaaaaaititxitzaazaaazaaaxi--t-.-zatitazccitI-ittza3000arx,9tt03£oU00033000r00z-rr£oaxrrrC.i-..ri-.Vri-ra:-aaaCZZ-r-‘Vc.a‘CCCaeDi-ft-4V-ft-‘tCC•C‘-•77ci-sCC‘-‘-‘-Xs-DR3•37x373C337C‘<Tici-ç35.a.-1‘tQCCVt(0a)toU)Z0)(tjqt‘it1.C”‘ftp.’ClDiDiC;DiDiQIDi0..Dis—a—

r

5. Z

Cli

z

Ct

it it

Ct

Z

Cc

DI

a

1*

a

•t

‘•

0’

•-

“

r•t

.

•t.

it

U)

a

Ct

a

z

D

‘(

I-

‘.

:0

Di

ci.

Di

C,

z

a

z

a a

z

a-.

a.

a

it z

a

CD

a

Page 7 of 19

‘C’

a

a..

axa..

4’

to1t1”0CtC)to‘S•7ato-i0Ca-ctoto.•3Ctcnawto—aa-‘-.nstoaatoCtsa0astoatsC0stoto0tI-”Ct£I”arto7•sato-cantoDatosa—ansatoa5toaa—a-caCaa0•a-a-caasCt000tosnaanarsosaato-caaa-hnasaa-’0sato0a-”a0to•0aCtoa-toto•c-.Ct-ctoa—.toaaatoISatoaou’s-Ctstotoa-nC£Ct-trtototo5tonotoaCtc.a0stoatoaazS-ftsCt£a-totossa--cotoaatoCtzCtCtC£totoCtCtaazssaoaaaaz-ft to Ct3££U005totoI-’.to%0StotoI-”1”1aa‘•505000aC-.0CtCt0E3ao00-i0to55ZCt••Ct-CI)C•0Scasa’totoCCOito‘—ztotoaIi-aaatoatoto-cCo-cqi—a‘-.as0•toa•sas0asacto0-t<0-stoCtotoCt-’ton-cxtotoCttoatoCt50aa0Ctto70ato stonoI-.£1o•I—’Cno0aUaato•nsaa35toca—-iacCt-c••Ctotosa-to0-iasCta-aes•-ctosaeaC0toaasanoca-a-la—etsL70sOasasa-atoCO3a-ia-.aa-3anna-”totoon0osCt3Ctso-cnsctoatoasza-.zatosaatonoatoc.£a-aa-nCsna-sto‘cocsnssszozntoanstossanoaaatoatosa-saa•tooa—s-ca-na—satoatocCTaCa-n0ra77<£aI-”n7toatonsCt0a-.sO0a-.xtoaatossza-oCaaa-atoa-i—Ctotoa£aasa-toa-a-a•3a-c0tonazo-%atoaa5<a<ac.tototoaa-ato0CttosSsatoz-a-to-c30-fta-to0aastoto-cSn-eCtsaatoa-sa<atoa-0s•acatooatoto-c,atotoUsCCa-cC£.Sa-a-a-0a--sa-zacCt0Cto0tIson•‘<aoaasasa-csa-a-c-a-.ac.a<an to C

to

to

c

-

to

toc

o

C

as

a

a

aa

to s

I-’

•

a-’

to-z

aas

a-.

to

o

£

a-

c..

n

s

sa

to

to

to

Ct

to

t

a

to

no

s

nto

Ct a

n

Page 8 of 19

a

-c

-4a

a-’.

a-

-c

t

s

to

san

n

a

I-’“0VtVt£to•777totoId’I-’-tto03Id’7to3£()Id’toId’Vt0a30C)Id’totoC33to1-CaVttoa31-’to00tototo-i1-’to•777totoId’I-’-tto03Id’7to3£()Id’toId’Vt0a30C)Id’totoC33to1-CaVttoa31-’to00tototo-i1-’i-aVtCt•to07azto7toUVtC‘<30tototoCtoto-IiVt0to0to0toztoVtNVt-ia0to1-Vt03Id’3Catoto-1toVtUVta-30to3VtVt77Vttoto33Vttotototo‘0tot-s0£to•to07azto7toUVtC‘<30tototoCtoto-IiVt0to0to0toztoVtNVt-ia0to1-Vt03Id’3Catoto-1toVtUVta-30to3VtVt77Vttoto33Vttotototo‘0tot-s0£toId’toId’toId’Vttoa-33Vttoto033tototoVttotototo0to•a-Id’Vttoa-33Vttoto033tototoVttotototo0to•a- atoI-’1-’Uto-ctoVttoto n3toVttoto3z £

tototoact3Id’VtVtto

to

to

c

-

to

toc

o

C

as

a

a

aa

to s

I-’

•

a-’

to-z

aas

a-.

to

o

£

a-

c..

n

s

sa

to

to

to

Ct

to

t

a

to

no

s

nto

Ct a

n

Page 9 of 19

a

-c

-4a

a-’.

a-

-c

t

s

to

san

n

a

I-’“0VtVt£to•777totoId’I-’-tto03Id’7to3£()Id’toId’Vt0a30C)Id’totoC33to1-CaVttoa31-’to00tototo-i1-’to•777totoId’I-’-tto03Id’7to3£()Id’toId’Vt0a30C)Id’totoC33to1-CaVttoa31-’to00tototo-i1-’i-aVtCt•to07azto7toUVtC‘<30tototoCtoto-IiVt0to0to0toztoVtNVt-ia0to1-Vt03Id’3Catoto-1toVtUVta-30to3VtVt77Vttoto33Vttotototo‘0tot-s0£to•to07azto7toUVtC‘<30tototoCtoto-IiVt0to0to0toztoVtNVt-ia0to1-Vt03Id’3Catoto-1toVtUVta-30to3VtVt77Vttoto33Vttotototo‘0tot-s0£toId’toId’toId’Vttoa-33Vttoto033tototoVttotototo0to•a-Id’Vttoa-33Vttoto033tototoVttotototo0to•a- atoI-’1-’Uto-ctoVttoto n3toVttoto3z £

tototoact3Id’VtVtto

Cto£totoVt7toVt00Vt-b7Id•toto-çCtId’I—3Id’0toVttoVt7•£IdVtztotototototo3aVt7toVttoId’3Li.n3toVttoto3z3to0.0Id•0toi-atoCId’ato-iC3toVtVt5•0to-cto03toto3aatoI-’1-’Uto-ctoVttoto0to3Ctotototoa0zUtotoId’to0b0tVt£0-(oCtotoVt3toVtto03to‘<0.700toVtId’1-Id’Ctbtototoact3Id’VtVtto0Id’VtI-’Id’toId’03Id’s-ftct7to•to3çPtoId’-çI.-Vt07toVttoVt3Ctoto3toto30to£toCt£to£toto3DtoVtVtto3VtUto7to1-’71-VttoVtto3toId’301-’attoUtoVttoatVt7totow.3a3‘<ttoto3toztoi£73toVt£tototo000toVtto3a,-3‘<Vt7to3toCtototototo1-’I—to3VttoVt3toCtoUtotoD7totoC03Vt1toCVt-c0-ft0-cztob—1-’tototo3n1-0‘<Vt0toto-fttoa—-ft0-hrVt3toto0o•Uto0-c0C3ato-cI-”Id’to-c0a-303Vtto7tototoCVtto3Vt3•-f-4)0to0ctVt7.toVtVtUtoVt£totozId’s-ftct7to•to3çPtoId’-çI.-Vt07toVttoVt3Ctoto3toto30to£toCt£to£toto3DtoVtVtto3VtUto7to1-’71-VttoVtto3toId’301-’attoUtoVttoatVt7totow.3a3‘<ttoto3toztoi£73toVt£tototo000toVtto3a,-3‘<Vt7to3toCtototototo1-’I—to3VttoVt3toCtoUtotoD7totoC03Vt1toCVt-c0-ft0-cztob—1-’tototo3n1-0‘<Vt0toto-fttoa—-ft0-hrVt3toto0o•Uto0-c0C3ato-cI-”Id’to-c0a-303Vtto7tototoCVtto3Vt3•-f-4)0to0ctVt7.toVtVtUtoVt£totozto03to0C7Vt0to3.ato0to£3toto7’(toa0‘<astoId.0C0totoVt3Vt0-torto3<77toto-ctoVttotoI-’totoa3to—atoSto-cto0tototo3%DVt0Uto0Id’3VtId’3toto•I-3toatoaVt0-.30Vtr30£3toCI-’Vttoatoto-hOVtto-h3to0to0zVt35totoUtoId’toI-’Id’Vt.to3Vt3toId’to0VtVt33totoVt3toVtVtId’totoCCT3Id’totoId’oVtId’3to•o1-to0toUto0Vt£totototoi-’Cto0toa0£tototoId’37tto-VttototozVttoatCtoId’Vt01Vtto0-4)to1—00Id’33to3sId’I-’£i’Otoaz1-’CtoVtto7r”4’oto30Vt-cVt“<tob-’7VttoCtoratoaVt3toId’toatotoato£totoVt73toVttoVttoaCtoa—toCtotoI-’totoa3to—atoSto-cto0tototo3%DVt0Uto0Id’3VtId’3toto•I-3toatoaVt0-.30Vtr30£3toCI-’Vttoatoto-hOVtto-h3to0to0zVt35totoUtoId’toI-’Id’Vt.to3Vt3toId’to0VtVt33totoVt3toVtVtId’totoCCT3Id’totoId’oVtId’3to•o1-to0toUto0Vt£totototoi-’Cto0toa0£tototoId’37tto-VttototozVttoatCtoId’Vt01Vtto0-4)to1—00Id’33to3sId’I-’£i’Otoaz1-’CtoVtto7r”4’oto30Vt-cVt“<tob-’7VttoCtoratoaVt3toId’toatotoato£totoVt73toVttoVttoaCtoa—toCto I-’

to

Id’

to

Vt

-t to to

to

tototo a

to

to toCto

to

toa

Id’

Vt

Vt

to

a

Vt

Vt to

7-ft

to

Vt

Vt to

Vt

Id.

Vt

31-’

to

tozz

-c

to

a

Page 10 of 19

£

to

to

to

(1(1)(1H”(3/30H”(3)3314-”F”0)1t(1)—30H:0(1&—‘(3/““:3(1ci)cm(033),(03))3):4”33tm(4)1)30’0i’’:1(3)itci:3’F’(I)CI(3)‘3(330)43(130’(33‘<31)31(3)(33’030a0)it134çt303)1I))(/)(1:)C(3):3(3)1,3)1)an’’<F”(.1)H”9)it(1)‘3033(0301)(1)34)cm(00)0)F”34)9)(3’(3)CL01t(3:“9(‘0(3(033)(3):(4)030’(0(4)034((43033’:F”it‘‘3)i’t’3033It(1)(Ita—3(4)H’0)it3’(1’“9cm(F(4)H”(3(F(4)4,00’)‘134:”0)(U:30.“33:cm’H”3::):11)>1(3)(3)(3)3:Ciit0)33)(13F”3/F”a:1)3:’F”(3)33it0itF”(443’(330330.3’3:33’(3)-t1”:3(1.(4)F”:)cm,1))(1F”33I))cmF(‘FEl”(3)It’0)F”a13)1-”(),)(},“I):3)((33(:1’Cj;H’(3:33))E0:(3“F(3)(4)33’H’(1)(4)0F’”4F”(3)(“F0’:3I)H,,ft0,0)(‘3CF”’(1it—,:3F”(F’4%),‘4’)<1::3)(09(04-”(0<3(1“cm”9(01))(1cm(3)1<Ii.1))cm(3(3)H’(‘3:r331<3)(4it’):“II(3:cm0)(J\0)%)(3)13’i3)0)H’“3(0(331))(4)3’)(1)3(3H’1’)3’(4)1)(4)ocm’“33ft3H”(3)33-4/)—.F”:30)it‘<3it—cm(3(3)ci9)30(3)o(3::(3“It(1’30‘30(3)3)1)F”1)302’F”(3)(333))(3)1)cm33)9)‘9)4,0:3ri9)“33:H’(1)F”(33I“33)-331))9333)t3))U)H’03(1)3:C)’(0’cm’(3/(3)3:C)F”0,013.H’ItI,:1tç1’F”30::(4)It’<:t”:F’(3):1tcm:3”(3(3)(4)’“3:1)(1)3)3)3””t”F”(3:1’(13(4)(3)i(01’)(“3’(3)(4)0)F”I—,“00

)

t

:

H”

C

(1’

)

t

:

H”

C

(1’

:30

3:

(I)

‘3

H’

‘F”

“C

C,

C’’

‘3)

F”’

t

(0’

CL

1t

(3:

F’

“4’:

(D

‘H”

H”’

C

())

H”

0).

H”

El

C:

H

*

(3) ’

(/4

It

3”

3:

)

4’”-’

<:

r’

(U

‘H

Page 11 of 19

-

0(1):1:F”10(U30(U,“3“30(3)30H-’(3(3C-”14)()C’,ElcmH’3300H.”(3)(33F”3ElH’”“30‘30(34(F’(U33:)(3)’(1):4’(13”F”(33’)(3)(3)<:430(3)(U(030’I’(333(3(3,H’j’Itcm(U33))F”(0((30,H’9)(‘30)CL0(0‘(301,4330,H”‘13’.(‘ft3)(3333’3044/)(13,(3t:3’1CL‘F’0)oIt(3)(3:’:33)(U13)(U33H’‘3’0:3F”(3(4)(%4(UF”iF”CLo333’(Uit1:(U(1)H”33334t(3)3)a(U’E9’66it9’H’3’(Uti-I’cm(3)::3”1))“4/031’C(3(3)(F’(‘I”(4)F”0)0301)H’<t0“1’(F’Cl:1’030”F”(3)H”(F(3)cm‘,(7‘<

a cm

H”

3’

34. cm

‘

(

cm’

F”

‘t:

4”t’

(U

3:

:3’

“t

F”

CL

(U’

Page 12 of 19

1) )

CC•-CDC—CC-CC-33CD33CCrt1)IDCCCC)CC33tC33—33C-CD(333C.3C(3CD(3:3)CCCCCCC-33)CCC—CCC0C—‘CCCCI33C33C)Cr(CCCC33CCCC—C—C‘CCCC.33CCCNCU——CtCC<JCC—CCCCCC-‘C’CCC33“33C-”—b—CCCUC-”CCC-’-33CCCC-CCCCCCCC33CCCCC-CC33CC-’CCCC‘C‘CC)cC’CCC.C.C33CUCiCCCCCUC—”CCCCCIC33CCCC)C)—C—cC-‘CCCC33CCCC—:(CCt‘CtC-U—C-CC-C)(C-‘C-‘CCç‘CCCC(333CC-’“CC’CCC-—U’CCCCC-—33UCCzCCCCCCC)—C-CD33CDCCCUCDCC‘CC”CC-CCCCCCCCCCCCC:CCtcCC)CCC33,C(CCC‘C—CCCCl—CCC-”CDC-—CCCC(C—nCCC’C—’‘C)C(C—C,CC,(UUCCCCCCC-CC—)ClC-33C-ICCC’C,,,C2CC——CCU,CCCCCC-CCC33,C’))C”“UUC“CCC-CC—CC)cC-UCCCCCC),UC)CCCCCCCCCCl‘C—“CC’CCCl’—C’CCC‘CCCC-—C(3CCC-CC-CC-CCCCC,33CC-C’CCl‘CCCC-CCC):CCCD—C“CCCCCC’C-CU—CCC,C’CCC)CCCC.CCC

(U

CC

C

—h

C

—

C

C

C

C

Cl

CCC

CC

n

‘C

‘

CC

,,C

C

CC,

CI

Page 13 of 19

CC

CCC

CD

C—

—.

CC

IC

CC

CC

C

C-’,

CC

C

,

C-

C—

C—

C))

Cl

VC

C

C

CD

33’

CC

C)

CCC

C))CCCCCC3333C233-C-C))332CUCUCCCCDCCCC33Cl(C—33’CC—CCC——C-C—C-C.C-rClClCC)C—’C--’CCCCCCcCC‘CCC—C’CCC’C—33‘CCCCC—CCCCC(333Ct((C(3(C)CCC)-”(CCCDCUcCCCC33CCCCCCCC—33+CCC‘CC-’C)C)C(‘CC—CCCCCC—C—CCCC33C“CCU(4ClC))CCCl’C4)—JC-CCCCCCC()C‘—CC-‘CC-CCC-CCICCCCC‘CC-C33—U“CCCUC—C”U,CCC33—CCC-CCCCCD-C•CC

CCC

C

Page 14 of 19

CC

CC-

LUCLUit0i’.3LUa0it03a’itCit.<0-%it70LU00LULUzLU9LUp...it7LUCLULU-(‘•CLU070P-’‘—LU3LU£I”it70’)•LLU“<rn-a’3arn-•00LUita‘<—‘<LU03it7LU-cLU00CLU-LUC(tLUitoLUitLU0-%it73LU‘1LULULUzitLUiCitit0‘00‘-‘•it0it70it0LULULUCaLU3C)LU0-ftit7LU‘U0b”fri0LU‘<LU..d03fr’it-ftitfr%“<-cLUC)0CLU‘1LUC•aLU30LUit7LUC‘<LU‘03P”3LUitLU30LUi”-*it7LUCLUCiPLU3it7LU0C7fr’itI-’LUW‘0it0ULU--‘P”LUaLUC03•ELUit7LULUaLULU‘ftLU30itt70itit7rn-a.LU‘<-%C)0C-(£LUC701-’ait7LU£0LULU-ft00itCLULU‘11CLUb-•aLUzC)a00-ca0itO0ft-ft-ftb-a.LULULUitOrn-’Oit37LUS£LUi—B“<90LUC‘•a‘0-LU0£0LULU-ft00itCLULU‘11CLUb-•aLUzC)a00-ca0itO0ft-ft-ftb-a.LULULUitOrn-’Oit37LUS£LUi—B“<90LUC‘•a‘0-LU0-ca-’C0LUit7LUitaitLU00LU-ça-’i-•LU£a0it71LUa-’‘.C)LULUUitLUUI-’‘-•LUa-.LULUita-’LUa0a-’LULUitoitLU3itOa-•3LU3LU‘-a’0LUzLUCa’”3LULUC7i-3a-’LULU,3C‘aLUoa-130it£a’it£LUa‘oa-’0itLUaa-’3z0LULUa‘1a-’-cCitLUC)LUitLU‘1LUi-0‘0LUit0LULU•a-Iitr0rLULU70‘00a-’LUi-’LU7LU-%LU£LU‘Ut-100LULULUCLULU03a030it3C73-0C7a-’LULUa-’ULUa-’‘0‘0C0iti£it73LUita-’CLULUa-’itC00aLU303ULU7LUa-’-ft77LULU0LULU0itLU0it0it7LULULUait7LUit0it7LU3LU7LUitCC70-fta’”3LULUC7i-3a-’LULU,3C‘aLUoa-130it£a’it£LUa‘oa-’0itLUaa-’3z0LULUa‘1a-’-cCitLUC)LUitLU‘1LUi-0‘0LUit0LULU•a-Iitr0rLULU70‘00a-’LUi-’LU7LU-%LU£LU‘Ut-100LULULUCLULU03a030it3C73-0C7a-’LULUa-’ULUa-’‘0‘0C0iti£it73LUita-’CLULUa-’itC00aLU303ULU7LUa-’-ft77LULU0LULU0itLU0it0it7LULULUait7LUit0it7LU3LU7LUitCC70-ft it£‘0cLUit‘1(it7LULULUC)00‘0LU0tit‘00LUCLU-i33LU9uLULUC)1LULULULU“3ILU£LUitit3LU0LUa-ft0LUitC007rn-’0itI-’-*00LU73it-‘ILULUa-ILUittLU‘-‘•LU‘07C0LULULULU-$0-%3LUC0itaCLU0LULU£LULU3-$3LU3a0itOitLULU‘ULU0itt3fr‘030LU‘4)LUNLULU-cQb.aLU3itLUaC)707£LU3I-’LULUtLULU-ccLULU03£a-’LU70LUCaLU3zLU3LUCita-ftitLUa-’-ftLULU-1LUCitO“<07itLULULULUCCLUitaitOitLUI-’a-’-fta-’itCzLUit3LU3a-,’l79itLU0itLULULULULU73‘IaLULULUit“C

it

it

‘-4

77LU

LU

C

LU

‘0

LU

it-I

LU

fr’

C)

C

i

it

iti3LUfr’ ait-

C

-ft

a

-ft

fr’

o

LU

C

LU

‘1

LU

LU

it

LU

7i

a

C

LU

C

7’

LU

LU

LUa

£

LU

it

-ft

it

a-a’

a

LU

-%

it’I

LU

LU

it

it

C

it

Page 15 of 19

it£‘0cLUit‘1(it7LULULUC)00‘0LU0tit‘00LUCLU-i33LU9uLULUC)1LULULULU“3ILU£LUitit3LU0LUa-ft0LUitC007rn-’0itI-’-*00LU73it-‘ILULUa-ILUittLU‘-‘•LU‘07C0LULULULU-$0-%3LUC0itaCLU0LULU£LULU3-$3LU3a0itOitLULU‘ULU0itt3fr‘030LU‘4)LUNLULU-cQb.aLU3itLUaC)707£LU3I-’LULUtLULU-ccLULU03£a-’LU70LUCaLU3zLU3LUCita-ftitLUa-’-ftLULU-1LUCitO“<07itLULULULUCCLUitaitOitLUI-’a-’-fta-’itCzLUit3LU3a-,’l79itLU0itLULULULULU73‘IaLULULUit“C

it

it

‘-4

77LU

LU

C

LU

‘0

LU

it-I

LU

fr’

C)

C

i

it

iti3LUfr’ ait-

C

-ft

a

-ft

fr’

o

LU

C

LU

‘1

LU

LU

it

LU

7i

a

C

LU

C

7’

LU

LU

LUa

£

LU

it

-ft

it

a-a’

a

LU

-%

it’I

LU

LU

it

it

C

it

Page 16 of 19

LUa

LU

-I’.

k

3tCt00055.30m0to0Ct•-(CPaC(Ct1-0’0‘—soa50%0C07U)-tNOn.js5Ct00553x(0a-.0CNE550005a®x0300a-S0C0x00‘10CitO00-ç0050a-’a-•00zSIrtat00NsaxN5000a-03‘ISN)“a-.azC30I5x0CtCt00aa00ra-.S50C00x0000-Ii0NC....5:a-.Ct0azsa.-.0C.-.0itS0C0a-.-1a•sa“<0c-..•0C0)-4-i‘0000<- •t0•Ct00Z0050t00501550•07%50505C(0Ctam‘—to•-iaxnaCti0CtCt%•-(00Ct4tfr.N%5I)-SSS50CtII,.-•5a.-.0a.-•i’•z0’0am0•tCacr0U)Sks0Pa53Ct3Ct-ftSa-.0•-ftCC00C‘—0t,.ro‘<a00N0-ça-’00e3.0-ca—a‘-•o0Wit3CtCt-ft000Ct0C‘CCt405fri5-1-‘c0t0Cssamçt000Caa-.010000Ct0Ct00C050-%a-’cm0an0-%00a—03Cta00a.-30‘<at050ti55%0a-•rna00sa-.0000Ct0000-1Z00ca—BBCt0a.-’CtCt0itOam0oam• ss‘-•itOa-.005a•C000s50000oa%a—‘1Ct4*503O’fiI-.0ita-’00‘C‘00500CtSCt0a0(0‘oa-’s0C-$tc.-.00050Cts00a-’.ansC0z0-ts0a.’a—a-’•<50-iCtz0c-froa.-.szma-.-ft€t00Cta-’‘.00000Ctaa--0c’050a®5NOzitS005-çU)a-.Ct0£0Ct00Ctz1’0a-£50fit0-ç£0sa-30Co0aasa-’C...a-C0‘<I-’50a-’oC•05005•at0a—0z01500‘•CS03350005I-‘Ct000ta.-.00a—a—aa.-’53a-•-ç0-100500-IaS(P00000“t500C0a-.t£‘00n-Caa.’.fia-.as50Ct0‘0CCta-’055000050Ct®soat05itO£a-’m005a®it5SCtCt‘-.C00•0-ft5055UC0‘11000‘00sOC3a.-a000-ft0-ft‘0050000a—a0oast0a-.a-Ct00a—s505CCtCt—IDCtCtCta-’Cta-’00a-’00U05a-’0I50500-10saao-aossa0a—00a t ow

Ut

fr.0

a

Ct a-

I.”

Ct

Ct

Ct®

a

‘0

C

cr0

a

‘-.

Nfl

a-

•

s

s

t a--

•

•

D

Ia

as

00£

C

a

a—o a-’

a-.

itS

s

Ct

a-.

t

•

a

Ct

-ft

Page 17 of 19

a

C”’SFftCfft((1(555-”ftft((5F”:rCsFt(53(1o33(3(:35””-CfCfCf55It5I:ftcItr33ft(3(35(ft5,,,,(3(1>ItItft((5F”—:F”Ct53’(3ft:3(3)—ftC5)13,5)ftItIIt:3Csf(((53FtFt-U)ft3333ItItH’itCfftItIt(55C—’It:3ftItftIt0(ItftftItoIt((1ft5—’3(3(ft(ftCsItCsIt5-”(CIt(3ItIt’CCC(ft(3ft>‘>IC’ss-’(.3HCfC>-7433(35((555,3‘3’)ItItC)ItCfftFtFtIt,,((C0It(t(3C-”33:ft5-”CC,ItCItft(If—(C’:)ItCl13(3)((3(55ftft(35Cs‘“““74,s3)5,-”((3(35(3.F’C:._s5>F”Itft5)It’ItSC.F”0C,CCs)((1ft:3ItItH’It—HC-5—(HtIt.It(ftF?Csft(3It“((5ft(ft((C(3:5,sv(5((35((3It(3)(5CIt(CfIt>ftrC’;5()It(ftCf33It((3Itft((3:.ItH”C_5)CfftCf.“:3C..;’.ft33(Q535ft-It33(3(53—5”H”CsCftCfftItft(35ft>.C”CC(53It(3)ItItCC.(:35—’((5ItftC’ItftItft135—5ft“5’((5(It33Cft(55Cs)(7.F”(33(33-ft(1((35)(55‘>C>33(5It5”((55)—5>—:(35It>Cs(ifC)C(3Cf.CCf(ftft(3)It(3)““533(CC(‘(1-(Cf‘5”(‘55’(‘55It.CC’5-ft(3ftCCCf(CfCLftft(C((C(I)IC(3It((5

ft ft

ft

It

It ft

ft

H’

‘ft

Cf

(Cf

ft

It

Cf

3,,

C

It

5(

“5.

F”

C13

C(

((1

ft

-

It

ft

((3

ft

It>

It

It

Cf

(C

(U

Cf

Cf

ft ft

C

C>

Page 18 of 19

It

(C

C((

CS

ItftCs’tC.(3CC(ftft(55.(3It033(554s-Csft(C,ItFt::H’It(‘S(_It53)ItCI.F?F?>F?ftF”’00((5ft((3(5(3Cs(3)t(Cf(CsftH’Cs(C’C)Cfft55553(33CC(5(35(3.ft135>CsC)H’CL(3C(C33(5)((5.rCCf53335,CfCs(“C(-5.ft’:13ft(It.33(5It5.-”—5>It(C:F”3)C”ItftFt33(5)(3C,(Cf?F?ft(.)3:3(3ftC)Ct-ts5”ftCF”F?ItC;ICCt(35(3ft(ftftt(3((5ft53)It0CftIt’ft(3F?0ftftCf((5CfC-”ftsCCC>(55CfItr’C(3(:sCItIt5(3F”IC(3ft5CSCF?F(3;f>.C(It’s““sFtF?

Cf

-

.iLC——C11-22.222-22-II---11C12.2221212.2.2.I2.2212-2.2.2.-2.-2.02.2.2.2—-.2.—122.cI(CI2.CD——1

—

C

CD

2.

2. :

$

C

CD

2. C

2. -

—

2. -

-

2. 1:.

:..

1CDCCD111CD2---BC.CC21—22.22.2.2.ID12(CIICDCDCCCD

S

N

)t.

Lz.J

fl”jb

Li

)

Page 19 of 19

Loading citations and judicial treatment…

You have used today's free searches. Sign in, for free, to keep searching without a limit.

Compass reads the judgments for you and finds the paragraphs for and against your question. Sign in to use it.

My Vault follows judgments for you and records every later decision that cites them. Sign in to keep one.

Sign in to download the court's PDF. The full text stays free to read here.

Search and read Indian judgments without limits, save them to My Vault and find the relevant paragraphs with Compass.

Open the sign-in page instead